There Was No First Human

PBS Member Stations rely on viewers like you. To support your local station, go to: to.pbs.org/DonateOKAY
↓ More info and sources below ↓
If you traced your family tree back 185 million generations through evolution, you wouldn't be looking at a human, a primate, or even a mammal. You'd be looking at a fish. So where along that line does the first human show up? The answer may surprise you!
Inspired by Richard Dawkins' "The Magic of Reality" amzn.to/1eFPE0v
Also check out Richard Dawkins' "The Ancestor's Tale" amzn.to/1fbf17e
Images of prehistoric species used in this episode:
Tiktaalik, Procunsul, Plesiadapsis, Juramaia, Hylonomus - by Nobu Tamura (spinops.blogspot.com/)
Homo erectus (by Tim Evanson) bit.ly/1uwI5zu
Joe Hanson - Host and writer
Joe Nicolosi - Director
Amanda Fox - Producer, Spotzen IncKate Eads - Associate Producer
Katie Graham - Director of Photography
Andrew Matthews - Editor and motion graphics
John Knudsen - Gaffer
Music:
"Ouroboros" by Kevin MacLeod
Produced for PBS Digital Studios
-----------
Join us on Patreon!
/ itsokaytobesmart
Twitter
/ drjoehanson
/ okaytobesmart
Instagram
/ drjoehanson
/ okaytobesmart
Merch
store.dftba.com/collections/i...
Facebook
/ itsokaytobesmartpbs

[@jrlopez1027.]

I'm just glad the first human didnt write "First" in the chat

[@exploited5172]

Jrlopez1027 creative

[@vaishalirandheer3048]

Ikr and this is an ORIGINAL comment. YAYAYAYAYAYAYAYAYAY

[@chewchew3991]

First

[@falcon5178]

first

[@ThePinkstarfashion]

Second: )

[@mamamia8733]

Imagine watching a movie with your cousin but he's a Salamander.

[@sarmadqureshi521]

i did

[@MasterGaming-el7jx]

@@sarmadqureshi521 nice

[@michealfoux]

what are you doing cousin salamander

[@mamamia8733]

@@michealfoux Netflix: "are you still watching?" *someone's salamander*: insert thrusting here

[@Sinzreal]

Sounds like a pokemon or pokemon fusion

[@justthinking4670]

The analogy of, you were once a baby and now your an adult, but there was no one single day in which you went from baby to adult. Brilliantly said.

[@jimmym3352]

Pretty sure when I joined the military I went from baby to adult. :-)

[@jingyitou838]

@Red Kane , so, you are saying you are a baby before the day you hit puberty and became an adult on the day you hit puberty?

[@jingyitou838]

@Red Kane that means you are no longer a teenager after hitting puberty?

[@jingyitou838]

@Red Kane so, which day onwards did you lose KID characteristics and biologically became adult right on that day ever since?

[@jingyitou838]

@Red Kane did you actually read the comments carefully before replying? The highest comment here is mentioning that such a day did not exist, which leads to my comment. So what is your point exactly? Are you agreeing that there is such a day or disagreeing or agreeing and disagreeing on the same time? You made me felt very confused with your stand.

[@opaquerat8692]

Him “There is no single day when you went to bed young and woke up old” Me: Comas exist.

[@abelhapedras]

Not a 24-hour coma, though.

[@opaquerat8692]

@@abelhapedras wdym?

[@waffles9771]

@@abelhapedras what

[@lauriedurk]

That would need to be over a very long span of time for it to work. It’s a “single day” not a period of sleep. Although a problem with that phrasing is that most people’s sleeping tends to happen over two days, with most of it in the second.

[@opaquerat8692]

@@lauriedurk ok :)

[@diobrando1754]

“Congratulations, it’s a boy!” “Oh, it’s a human”

[@aa-girlslin4309]

DIO Brando hah!

[@Raccon_Detective.]

Hehe

[@Lumberjack_king]

Were they expecting a wolf girl

[@Ayd1th]

wow the bs atheists believe

[@parlaybot]

Shut up

[@dittygoops]

Teacher: *Shows a picture of a fish on the board* Now class... Can anyone tell me what this is? Student: MY GRAND DADDY!!!!!!!

[@SALVADORANFIRE]

LoL!!!!!

[@janaex2433]

💀💀💀😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😱

[@michaelwalenter7017]

+Verify Destroyer no, religion isn't allowed in this comment section

[@nerdgirlmc9407]

The Bloxxer. At least there right

[@cynthiafrage]

😭😭😭

[@TheMightyMosch]

I would give my right arm to see a time lapse of that entire stack! Much like those time lapses of people taking a picture of themselves everyday for several years except of the entire evolutionary history!

[@gaymermoment]

That would take long

[@wildec2]

Ever heard the saying: 'the cake is a lie' ?

[@mewhzy1501]

@@wildec2 ura clown

[@wildec2]

@@mewhzy1501 "ura clown" Amazing to read such wisdom, well done.

[@danifurka6790]

I don't think they made photos of themselves

[@experience741]

We have organs and cells just like animals. Humans neither special nor created by invisible being

[@myamdane6895]

We are special because we are the greatest and most intelligent form of life on earth. But we evolved the same way

[@vex3091]

@@myamdane6895 Sometimes when i look at our society, i tend to question if we really are the most intelligent.

[@stephaniesmith3544]

Someone saying "I refuse to believe we came from a chimpanzee" is just as annoying and ignorant as someone saying "I refuse to believe that I came from my cousin". It makes no sense. At all. At least educate yourself before making some ridiculous comment and sounding like a bigot. And if you still refuse to put some research into what you say, don't expect your comment to have any credibility in it. Also, I love how people who do not support evolution still continue watching videos like this. If you hate it so much, why click on it?

[@PowerofRock24]

They click on this video because deep down they have some doubt in their own beliefs. Why else would a good, testament-abiding, Christian come here? To insult people? Nahh, their Bible tells them specifically not to do that :-) I think it's just the first step for them to open their mind though.

[@stephaniesmith3544]

I actually haven't considered that. They could be in denial, so by finalising their opinion in comment form could make them feel like they're not losing faith, but deep down they are. Or maybe some do it because they're just trolls.

[@PowerofRock24]

It could be that the Bible has been disproved once again and they just feel the need so assert their anger on those who accept Evolution over Adam an Eve. Or yes, it's possible they are trolls :)

[@andybechdoldt6583]

I totally agree with you Stephanie I was in a student Christian refuge group and they were saying that evolution isn't real. And I asked why and the leader said "because my uncle isn't an ape"

[@PowerofRock24]

andy bechdoldt Well, if that's what they want to believe then... I suppose it's no use trying to show them either. Christians can be very fanatical about their beliefs which is understandable.

[@ilikescake4928]

Sees someone try to kill a rat Hay that’s my 1000000000000th cousin 784 times removed

[@poplar6658]

LMAO

[@tharieqaziz3806]

The guy that kills the rat:Sry

[@PlentyOfTrickShots]

1:42 He called his relative cute 😳

[@bigmoniesponge]

Lol

[@user-mc6tq7xb2q]

@@bigmoniesponge roblox kid

[@mothman1717]

Sweet home~~

[@darshanik8426]

2:38 i feel like a kid for laughing at that.

[@onebeets]

i want to unhear this so bad

[@Romandy13]

Man, you're lucky to have photos of your grandparents and their parents. My parents won't even tell me anything of their past (had to do research myself).

[@cesarvalle5301]

Romandy Doe what did you find? Was your family a part of a monarchy or were they peasants of some far away land ?

[@melmelodies8730]

100th like!

[@SchokoAprikose]

German?

[@craigbrown1760]

You're not the only one. I have one living grandparent. The others died either in my teens or early 20s, when I cared about....other things. And he says he doesn't know anything about his grandparents, aunts, uncles, etc. And he isn't senile or anything like that.

[@wildec2]

Sometimes its better to just move on.

[@akshara487]

He literally looks like his own grandpa.

[@Irreverent_Radiation]

Maybe he is a time traveler... he traveled into the past, got stuck there, met his own young grandmother and he is his own grandpa

[@sandbrick]

@@Irreverent_Radiation D A R K

[@jaystyla629]

@@Irreverent_Radiation back to the future in an alternate timeline

[@slack_cactus_jack7953]

Nobody probably cares but I have realized, well me and my brother realized that our grandfather looks a lot like us, and my father’s grandfather and my father have many similar features

[@lioniscoold9420]

Which one?

[@jonathanjohn1075]

“see the resemblance?” me: actually yes

[@Chiater]

After seeing the insane comments in the national geographic video on human evolution I'm glad to see the comments here are positive and not dismissive of evolution and science.

[@brandonng2883]

I sorted by Newest. I'm seeing a ton of bollocks claiming either evolution is false or Adam and Eve were the first human

[@KingKevin108]

I genuinely cannot tell if the religious people in the comments are trolling or not

[@bazonga9085]

Benjamin Steffen AhahahAhahahaha. Can I ask you something? How do you believe in your god when throughout history their have been different gods entirely that we have let go? I just don’t understand. You’d have to be pretty stupid to believe in your new god when you don’t believe in a sun god or a water god or a weather god.

[@azestical6566]

FiggerNaggot bro I’m pretty sure he’s saying “why would people troll about evolution if it was proved already?” Or it could be ur statement idk

[@boshlovely2002]

lommm mmb Ok but how do u know that sure we call them myths now but back then plenty of people believed in them so what about now What makes the religions nowadays different(surprise they aren’t and eventually people will stop believing in them too)

[@HoodedSpidey]

I can’t tell if you’re religious or not.

[@axeonvonshadow539]

Kingkevin108 this video is 1 giant troll. Life didn't spawn from nothing and become all these different animals. A group of creatures were created, innerbreeded new species until they couldn't innerbreed to form new offsprings.

[@EvolutionMachinetoMan]

WTF all the animals, insects in my home are my family ? I don't need to be scared of lizards,cool.

[@kinglyzard]

You are undoubtedly more closely related to lizards (As Chordates, Tetrapods) than to the bugs (Arthropods)

[@dom4947]

Lizards are cute af

[@tennesseeexposed9325]

Evolution : Machine to Man Are we all related to Neanderthals? Do we share a common ancestor with neanderthals?

[@infinitytraveller7772]

Nope. they are not even slightly related to not even your ancestors from million years ago, exclude these hippy socialists from the scene.

[@bobbysantiago5659]

I like lizards too! They're very social, and I know they're a great pet.

[@wipylow5639]

Me:eating fish Also me: cannibalism

[@illosovic]

Also you: Neanderthal

[@autumn-marissamcclounie7868]

I love the analogy at the end with the stepping stones being species 👍

[@marthaajohnston2112]

I just realisd taht when i ate sushi...i was eating my 1000000000000000000000th cousin

[@agent3djparty955]

Wait u are ur carnnivererse you ate HU,ANS Police:911 what's ur emergency This guy's canaball FBI OPEN UP

[@francissquire9910]

You're not just related to every creature, plants are your distant cousins too!

[@maysaiiart6214]

DAYUUMMMM

[@maysaiiart6214]

dj party canniball lmao it’s Cannibal it’s like your saying can-E-ball

[@jesuriv1]

It was accidental. Not to worry, I know a good lawyer.

[@merrickmcfarling1795]

Bro, so like what if you when back in time to 375 million years ago and you got hungry so you went fishing and you caught a fish and ate it but that was actually your tikaalik grandfather

[@isaacvu3708]

No, at that time we were a reptile-like fish, and we didnt feed on the same species of our own, we hunt another fish species that was totally different from our own. And yes, we and the fish we hunted at 375 million years ago came from a same ancestor about 550 million years ago

[@colinp2238]

The paradox of time travel! Tuna is OFF the menu now.

[@colinp2238]

Lingo vi What isn't a fish?

[@shawn.spencer]

Isaac Vũ no the op is saying that what if your today form you time travelled back and tou got hungry so you caught a fish and you ate it but that fish was actually your ancestor

[@V1xtory]

Isaac Vũ he was saying about time travelling 375M years ago and still human.

[@Domziiee]

It’s a fundamental issue of language. Because everything we live with has some sort of spectrum. We resolved this by breaking it down using categories which in turn makes labels. Which works by directing us to a part of a spectrum, but gives us the wrong thinking by causing us to, in certainty, identify that ‘thing’ as ‘it’. Its causes a lot of issues especially socially. Instead of defining and categorising someone by a definite term, we just need to see them for who they are to know how they fit. Categories are just a guide, but what you’re looking at, is it’s own thing.

[@juanausensi499]

Well said. For the record, that 'wrong thinking' is called Platonism.

[@backbeatben]

But then who is to say the category and language used is correctly defined?

[@corvus_da]

If a species is defined as a group of all animals that can mate with each other, could you say that some of our ancestors belonged to two species at the same time? Because they could theoretically reproduce with modern humans (if they weren't dead), but also with the species of their parents🤔

[@aaryajain6396]

Theoretically speaking, every child is a slightly different species than parent A. So even though this child can mate with his parent as well as his own descendants, there will come a time when his great great....... Grandson Bwon't be able to mate with the parent A. So A and B will be called different species, and then there will be C , D..... P P and A will be greatly different in all forms. So species B, C.....O become transitional species. Eg A is theropods, and P is modern birds. So Archaeopteryx, a transition species, will be D or E (eg) But remember that when evolution occurs, only a part of the animal group evolves . So its possible that D evolves into E' as a separate branch on family tree.

[@LimeyLassen]

There's something called a "ring species" that's just like this. Animals at the far ends of their range can't mate with each other, but ones in the middle can. And sometimes the far ends overlap each other in space. For example, on the east coast of the US wolves and coyotes can hybridize but on the west coast they never do, and the size difference between them is larger.

[@blacklyfe5543]

No

[@FinBoyXD]

2:10 I actually see some resemblance there. Especially when you look to your left. Same jawline and all.

[@caitiemaycaitiemay6884]

Thats why people at my school act like snakes Thanks for information

[@ViratKohli-jj3wj]

F

[@Sanjoy1969]

@@ViratKohli-jj3wj Oh hi I am a fan of you.

[@sshireen1083]

HAHAA!!

[@ViratKohli-jj3wj]

@@Sanjoy1969 that's so nice of you man

[@paulawolanski3237]

That's why so many kids are rats

[@eldonmacwood]

At some point, in that stack of photos, there was a homosapien-sapien. At some point, you get to the first photo that makes the cut. Just like when we become a new species, there will be a first, singular, or plural. I mean, if a family has several babies, like twins, it could be more than one first. Maybe you can't pinpoint the exact the first point, but there would come a point if we could look through the photos of time without losing a single second, that we'd get to the first homosapien, as we could with any other species. With age, we still have stages we can mark when which begins. From toddler-puberty. We have stages so we can see where a person is at in their childhood. We also have ages where we can track a person throughout their lifespan. We have beginnings, middles, and ends for so many things. And yet, we don't for a species? Well, that's not completely true as we can dictate when a species is extinct. At some point, we become another species. If we didn't, well, I wouldn't be here commenting, and there wouldn't be a YT designed by Humans. There's always a beginning of some kind, even if that beginning is simple or complicated. You can't have a stack of photos all about how people evolved without having a first pic of said species. To do so would be highly illogical.

[@a-l-c7605]

I like how he put all the language in the caption to everyone to understand this vid🤩

[@calvinwilkerson1305]

root

[@cocomelodramatic4252]

recommended- “there was no first human” | it okay to be smart also recommended-“the first human” (evolution documentary) | timeline

[@mid5503]

@Cora C Yeah, there is no first because micro organisms can multiply. So that mean something coming from space or one chemical reaction created some kind of organic matter that made 1 micro-organism or a bit more.

[@tenchi1357]

The First Humans was ADAM and EVE, God Asked Them to Come to Earth and Get Man Kind Kicked Started Because There is No Evolution of Man Kind, Just One Day God Put us On The Earth and Good Luck . 😇

[@ReincarnationofiForgor]

​@@tenchi1357okay, proof? I have proof of evolution. Do you have any proof of god though?

[@tenchi1357]

@@ReincarnationofiForgor YES I DO ! Your Standing On It !!! It's All Around You, You Breath It All The Time !!! YOU ARE ALIVE !!! What More PROVE DO YOU WANT ??? God Said Let There Be Light ! The SUN Our Star in The Heavens and Beyond ! Forever and Ever , AMEN ! 😇

[@ReincarnationofiForgor]

@@tenchi1357 that is.. not proof in any possible way. You just said "my proof is that the world exists" and okay, cool. But you proved that the world is real, not that god made it. Also, there's scientific evidence that the world was NOT created by any god.

[@vnzandroid]

i lost my faith in humanity after reading the comment section.

[@Sednas]

Just do a search of the biggest scientific discoveries last year and you'll think otherwise. The earth with always have its retards, it's just a fact. But natural selection will take its course. The smarter people will stay.

[@tomlutes3373]

@@Sednas I hope you're right. At moments I despair, tempted to believe that idiocracy looms on the horizon.

[@50subsfornezukovids4]

@@Sednas nah natural selection picks who can reproduce more. That's why I think our spicies will split from them, I hope so.

[@JastwatchingYT]

@@Sednas Natural selection has stopped trust me, you and me live in a world where resources have become abundant and can be mass distributed.

[@jingyitou838]

@@Sednas unfortunately not quite, smarter humans are more likely to plan better on reproduction and raising offspring, and is often limited to raising very few offspring and making sure they get the best education and attention from parents, however those that are less educated or smarter is more likely to end up with significantly more children that they might not bother to ensure they are well educated. So unfortunately smart people are expected to have less and less percentage share in the overall human population in the long run.

[@annetteholman2999]

Excellent, both clarity and humor.

[@winkleberrygang]

You teach me about the things i have always wondered about but i never wanted to ask about because i didn't want to look stupid to anyone. Thank you so much, i'm a new fan

[@Invexity2406]

u wouldnt seem stupid ita a question that many people dont know the awnser to besides if they call you stupid just remember that they learned things before you and thats ok

[@besmart]

How can you tell where one color of the rainbow becomes another? It's like that.

[@wikikanselmovedaccount5689]

It's Okay To Be Smart nope!

[@vincentmadgin8370]

It's Okay To Be Smart if you think about it we are related

[@VidPersonal]

God was created by some humans on earth!

[@holeesiyet5561]

It's Okay To Be Smart you are not smart if u are smart answer my question when is the end of the world

[@Alabastro69]

well, if you know a little about light you would know that when one single ray pass thru a cristal prism it disperses in seven colours, where does it disperse an one colour becomes another? in the precise moment when comes out the prism, the same with genetic modifications, if human races would passed separated some milleniums more, the same modifications that changed size, colour of skin, eyes, hair, or eyes shape in asian people may changed enought the genoma to don't allow procreaton between races, giving diferent species, an then the colours of the rainbow will be too diferents one from another. to be smart, must observe details.

[@snakejanders]

does this also mean there was no first chicken?

[@MrMancus1]

Jake Sandstorm Exactly, says this theory. There was no first chicken, so there are no chicken today. But, because there are chicken, the theory is wrong. It is just an intricate way trying to prove the Bible is wrong (no fist man, no Adam. No Adam, no sin. No sin, no need for salvation). True scientists don't lie.

[@snakejanders]

Religious views aside, many things in the bible have been scientifically disproven. There was no "first" human or chicken because the changes in the genome of the species that humans or chickens evolved from were so gradual over hundreds of thousands of years that it's impossible to identify those miniscule changes between a single generation that would denote a new species. It's like the Ship of Theseus. If you replace a ship one piece at a time, it's impossible to determine at what point it's a new ship. So if you replaced every piece of a ship with different types of wood and metal one piece at a time over a long span of time, there's no single instance where you can say definitively that it's a different ship. But after every piece has been replaced, it will look entirely different from the original ship and will have no piece from the original ship. If you looked at a photo of the original and a photo of the "new" ship side by side, you would likely say that they are two completely different ships- and they are, but it's impossible to pinpoint the exact moment that one became the other.

[@MrMancus1]

Jake Sandstorm The Bible is not a scientific book, so there is no need to scientifically prove or disprove it. Unfortunately the "science" of evolution is saturated with the dogmas of atheism - like it or not - though it should not be necessarily this way, and - believe it or not - atheism is a religion. The whole concept shown above is based on the erroneous presumption of continuous and linear change of species, although this has not been observed nor proven. The phenomenon called fluctuating variation e.g. in case of Darwin's Finches give an interesting insight into how evolution works. For more on fluctuating variation, see: www.truthinscience.org.uk/content.cfm?id=3160.

[@snakejanders]

the "science" of evolution is saturated with libraries full of research and fossil records. but no, you're right, we were all magically zapped into existence by a sky wizard. makes much more sense. Atheism is, by definition, not a religion. And for the record, I'm not atheist. Did you even read that article? because it still supports the theory of evolution. I don't even know what you're trying to argue anymore. You're all over the place.

[@MrMancus1]

What do you know about evolution?

[@sriarvind7312]

I know I'm nine months late, but using a colour gradient from say blue to green, you can demonstrate that there is no exact point where there's the first green spot. It just goes from blue to more and more green just like we became more and more humanoid

[@Heisenberger_69]

Exactamundo. Not that hard to grasp

[@somebodyhastosaysomething.7009]

Awesome video. Very easy to listen and watch.

[@misspiggy6667]

“Adam and eve were the first.” Me:

[@ejlinsadikovic4847]

Jessica DeNittis I mean you clicked on a scientific video that leaves religion out of it and fiction what did you expect your fairy tale religion in here

[@lemonlimeoof3238]

Their comment is actually saying that those people who believe in Adam and Eve being first ( which they are) is wrong because of this video.

[@victorcreed5987]

Yup thats right

[@normalperson659]

@@ejlinsadikovic4847 Dude. Christianity is no fairy tale. You didn't have to say that. We didn't do anything to you.

[@D1str1ct]

According to Sumerian history they were the first modern humans or humans in the form we are today.

[@migueldoliveiracomposer]

If you pause this video at any point, you can hear a creationist nearby having an apoplexy.

[@innerslothamonggus9070]

I want to HAHA your comment, but this is not FB.

[@elijah_godslayer9904]

Not really, i mean without evidence this is a claim, which it is and the theory of fish people is an interesting one, macro evolution is unprovable but very much attention grabbing.

[@onebeets]

@@elijah_godslayer9904 i mean proving particles hit each other is impossible too, you can only look at a time frame and the results. Its kinda like calculating derivatives

[@grantdillon3420]

@@elijah_godslayer9904 Like any proper scientific theory, such as the theory of gravity, the theory general relativity, electromagnetic theory etc, it certainly is not provable, but it is falsifiable.

[@postnutclarity3055]

Lol, good.

[@shourovesharma8794]

Religious people will unhappy after watching this Truth

[@unwantedshogun5071]

Yep, they simply can't handle the truth

[@unbreakableunion2350]

Evolution and science: *Exist* Religions: *Allow us to introduce ourselves*

[@kacperxt371]

evolution and science don't overthrow religions

[@doc6188]

@@kacperxt371 yes it does

[@kacperxt371]

scientist who discovered DNA was priest

[@Amit_Pirate]

@@kacperxt371 so it doesn't mean that dna and genes were his creations and now God has the right to DNA. Religion is no match for science. Science is beyond religions.

[@Amit_Pirate]

@@kacperxt371 it doesn't mean that God said him to discover that DNA.

[@gabrielvale1186]

we will evolve in after 2000 years! we will become anime

[@froztbytesyoutubealt3201]

Genos

[@katharinerobertson238]

Gabriel Vale I was thinking bratz dolls, tiny body, giant head and giant eyes.

[@winters504]

Gabriel Vale I LOVE anime! Ready for the afterlife? We'll look like we're anime characters!

[@coie9240]

yeeeeeeeeeeeesssssssss :>

[@joyharb4495]

ROASTED PEANUTZ I want to become kira :p

[@deer_hunter_1234]

I get it everyone evolves slowly with little changes you don’t notice

[@RinkieGeintie]

🤦‍♂️ 🤦‍♂️🤦‍♀️ 🤦‍♂️🤦‍♀️🙈

[@ejlinsadikovic4847]

Rinkie Geintie Why you facepalming i mean he is correct

[@RinkieGeintie]

Ejlin Sadikovic yea but Why didn’t he knew that? 🤨

[@RinkieGeintie]

Ejlin Sadikovic PS: I don’t want to hate that he’s stupid or something

[@scoopscoop598]

@@RinkieGeintie there is a turtle on his profile pic

[@lohan5901]

When I first saw this I laughed so hard after he said “ Well, he was a fish”.

[@shalomnoah7309]

*"Life is what happens in between the Snapchats‽"* Nice. 3:30

[@lopfi4366]

The question is what are we gonna become a million years from now ?

[@EdwinLuciano]

Extinct.

[@miguelpadeiro762]

lopfi lottfi 100 years* extinct

[@hbkjnhbjk1598]

lopfi lottfi extinct ;)

[@hbkjnhbjk1598]

pricila hahahahah lol definetely yes

[@RustyWalker]

_"I wouldn't be surprised if we ended up bald, hairless"_ I'm nearly there already :( _"and our jaws would most likely be quite small and weak because we no longer hunt with them."_ We're descended from a vegan primate ancestor. We can tell that from the shape of our guts, and relative sizes of small to large intestines. We evolved into being omnivores gradually. _"We'll end up shorter due to lower oxygen supplies"_ Wait, what? Do you know something I don't? _"and weaker because of our comfortable lifestyle. (I think our cultural choices will dictate what we look like)."_ We don't all have lives so comfortable that we don't go to the gym, or swimming, or walking, etc, and we give rewards to those with outstanding athletic prowess because we find it entertaining to see them compete.

[@sran438]

*looks at comment section* Not going to even bother..

[@jarrygarry5316]

Open the comment of newest first.There is religious war in that comment section

[@whatever63644]

Did he mislead us or something?

[@bigmoniesponge]

@@whatever63644 no, religious people are just mad.

[@ElijahHoodz]

Doctor: it's a boy/girl 3015 doctors be like: *Doctor: it's a human!*

[@littleking5546]

Are what are the doctors ?? Apes or God ??😂

[@kingzolew4967]

It sounds like we need to question what the word “human” truly means then…..

[@johnchambers9836]

It's just a label given to primates in this stage of evolution

[@omarabuaita3858]

1.5 Million years ago I think I saw Donald Trump.

[@rakibkronos]

+Omar Abuaita Naw man, he is an offshoot from orangutan.

[@rorycampbell7360]

+spaveevo Or, a side show. ' Donald and his preforming Wig.' Captured from the wilds of Borneo. Evolved from a Mop head !

[@littlesis4313]

good one

[@nonono9406]

+Rory Campbell as well as his small loan of a million dollarz make it rraaaaiin

[@Synovia]

lol

[@loganmclennan2617]

I find it crazy how people can believe in a book written by people 2000 years ago. People were so dumb then, they thought the world was flat! Are those the type of people whose book you want to follow? Crazy man, crazy.

[@jamesgarrett7844]

Certain people are also fucking crazy stupid today. You're cherry picking the population, just understand that. To a molecular biochemist, a high schooler studying chemistry is near mentally challenged.

[@AydenHub]

Actually along time ago people from well educated civilizations knew the world was round, but yes, your kinda of right because people believed in blood letting and that was pretty stupid

[@alcoholandfun243]

+AydenHubbell Productions (GamingPro752) This is not about evolution, but some people still believe in blood letting today. Crazy stupid people at all times ☺

[@hanktoni]

They didn't think the world was flat, the bible clearly states that it's a sphere.

[@pizzaface117]

Its funny that philosophers in western europe had already began to accept that the world was a sphere while desert-centric goat herders spawned religions whose tomes dictated the opposite

[@teawnagrove8541]

Is it just me or are KZbin comments are starting to become Twitter comments

[@cyberlemon9840]

Sadly, yes.

[@marcelloberry6829]

yes :(

[@witheryt1617]

Who else when you heard “my grandfather from 185 million years ago wasn’t human he was a fish” you though “WAIT IM PART FISH!!!!!!!”

[@kakashihatake..1700]

No you are the part of hazrat Adam A.s blood line.

[@witheryt1617]

@@kakashihatake..1700 👍 I was joking around but 👌🏻

[@subline_funtime]

1:15 even earth thought we looked gay

[@visittanzania7166]

Funny

[@speshalkmf9273]

@@visittanzania7166 loool

[@speshalkmf9273]

It looks like KRS

[@ausrichter5180]

If a God exists why does he go through such great lengths to hide from us?

[@InvokingPeace]

+Ausrichter people don't want to hear the truth, it feels better to believe in a comforting lie

[@ausrichter5180]

Antonio Tunjic A guarantee you that 99.44% of the world would believe in God if he showed himself. The .56% that might not believe are the blind.

[@InvokingPeace]

Ausrichter if he showed himself, yea... but he never did, there are no gods, it's just a character made up by humans, that's why this debate will never reach a conclusion, it's simple to believe in anything you want, even if it doesn't exist, you just have to pretend

[@ausrichter5180]

Antonio Tunjic Oh, I didn't realize you were agreeing with me. My bad.

[@InvokingPeace]

Ausrichter sorry for not making that clear ;)

[@gumabllhasbobux8590]

So your telling me whenever i eat fish I'm basically eating my 1,00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000th cousin???

[@bigmoniesponge]

Yes.

[@gumabllhasbobux8590]

@@bigmoniesponge W o a h d u d e

[@gaymermoment]

A bit too many 0s

[@jer4516]

teacher ok kids your project is make a family tree the smart kid:2:00

[@mauricethegecko9700]

Joe: "there was no first human" Christians: :l really

[@penguinmaster2361]

@@50subsfornezukovids4 They didn't say they were religious though

[@monkehballs8996]

dont forget the muslims yes the story of adam and eve exists there too, expect its different.

[@Banditxam4]

@@monkehballs8996 no it's not different I'm a muslim 😅😅 It's exactly like Christianity. I don't know about Judaism though

[@Banditxam4]

@@monkehballs8996 and in Hinduism as well but story is different in hindusim

[@monsterv61]

He does not know adam

[@derekmartin5340]

so wait,does this mean everyone in the entire world are cousins?

[@plexmars0000]

GamerLee10K basicly yes and every religion says that

[@adrianadelvalle1540]

He actually had a video on it

[@user-ts2ny8jg9d]

If you go back far enough, every living organism is related

[@DonAmnesia]

Idrah So, the important question is, everyone who ever had Sex committed Incest?

[@oogabooga8405]

I'm sure that incest means to have sex with a grandparent, parent, sibling, or child.

[@michealfoux]

that's a good ice breaker. "so my great great great great great...grandpa is a fish".

[@k.sheehan]

im looking for the mad christans

[@Fil_the_spil]

It doesn't contradict Genesis

[@michaelliu2973]

I just don't understand why so many people are against the theory of evolution.

[@SuperBryan180]

***** you do know that gravity is also just a theory right??

[@SuperBryan180]

that was completely irreverent and that actual definition of theory is a group of ideas meant to explain a certain topic of science, such as a single or collection of fact event or phenomenon

[@Chineseguy001]

Because its illogical.

[@halbarbour7805]

Vlach Please tell us, what is illogical about the theory of evolution?

[@SuperBryan180]

coming from a 14 year old i wouldn't trust my self to explain the theory of evolution but you can easily educate yourself by reading a book

[@ryanlowe1781]

To deny evolution is to deny reality. Creationists are not to be taken seriously in anyway and laughter should accompany their every step!

[@COolpuP-co1mk]

+Ryan Lowe >I think i'm right so ill laugh at everyone who thinks differently!11!!1 that's basically your thoughts ;)

[@ryanlowe1781]

COolpuP12345 No I'll accept any credible source of evidence and that's the end of creationism! Let's not pretend it's some how equal, creationists are on the same level as people who believed that the moon is made from cheese! Those are my thought's

[@COolpuP-co1mk]

believe what you want, but there will still be people, like me, who will have faith in topics like these

[@ryanlowe1781]

COolpuP12345​ No I believe only in thing's with sufficient evidence to do so! The privileged position that religion found itself in, where by people's religious idea's were never called into question are thankfully over! I agree that there always be people who hold ridiculous ideas, I don't agree that they will be your's. Reality exists regardless of what you believe, how many believe or how strong that belief is. Humanity has reached a pivotal point and the biggest questions are still to be answered, your denial of reality will leave you marginalised and unheard in these wonderful times to come. You can not graft new ideas onto a closed mind!

[@COolpuP-co1mk]

well one comment from some extreme atheist will not change everyone's mind even though im religious I have my thoughts and beliefs, it will not be over by one person comment on a online place with cat videos religion also explains some unsolved things about the big bang Plus if one closed his mind about a thing that doesn't matter, it can find new things to do and learn other than debating on a place with cat videos (which i am here for)

[@estonianman632]

maybe if my fish ancestor hadn't reproduced how many living things wouldn't exist on earth, who knows

[@Quarequieus]

Fish doesn't exist actually. Neither Estonia. Neither you. You are completely delusional and non-existent.

[@corpse2.028]

Imagine someone in your family being a fish and a lizard and you have something to prove it

[@katyungodly]

I mean technically yes!

[@azeemmann]

All the creationists out there, PLEASE pick up a biology textbook. You DO NOT yet understand a fairly simple topic like evolution. Tbh, I dont understand quantum physics and honestly some of the things physicists say today arouses my suspicion; does that mean I go out and have a debate with them? I simply can't, because I do not have the knowledge to have a rational debate with them.

[@tomlutes3373]

Thankfully, people like you exist: the antidote to Dunning-Kruger arrogance. Well said.

[@jingyitou838]

Exactly, that sounds pretty much like a student in class doubting the teacher but claims that he/she didn't really know much about the topic, but he/she just thinks perhaps the teacher is wrong......

[@erzan]

The comments on here are worrying. Not only are people demonstrating a basic lack of basic science. But critical thinking skills too.

[@erzan]

LordVader1094 If you bothered to read basic scientific entries, perhaps you might learn something. Why should people over the internet act as your teacher? Go search how Viruses adapt and evolve for example. The theory has been tested to death. It's not even a debate, it's like someone asking for evidence about how Earth rotates around the sun. No one who understands the science is going to bother explain it to someone who can't be bothered to learn it!

[@jamesscott3995]

There's this wonderful building that houses a vast array of knowledge from all parts of science, life, ect. It's called a library. They have a whole section just for books on evolution.

[@entropy2k263]

John Maton Is there evidence that a virus "becomes" something else? No, not in the way you describe it. But the evidence of speciation and evolution abounds in a variety of fields from geology to archeology to cell biology to genetics. Like the video explains evolution is a gradual, ongoing process. there is no way to point at one specific split, you notice it over many generations.

[@jamesscott3995]

+John Maton Maybe you don't understand scientific method. These things get peer reviewed and ran over by scientists around the world. The assumption itself is without merit.

[@jamesscott3995]

John Maton That word appears not once in the article. You also show you didn't check the references and read the ACTUAL study. Pdf files. Anything other than the vauge summary.

[@abdulrouf8307]

It was a little funy to me because he said my great great grandfather was a fish

[@averycuriousclumpofatom2159]

It a fact

[@pinkajou656]

Father no longer sounds like a word

[@laxlag16]

Religion cant compare to the magnitude of knowledge science has taught us

[@IHeArTrOcK20]

you can't compare it because there are two separate things, but you definitely can acknowledge how they intertwine

[@sonicpsycho13]

Abigail April I watched that debate and Ham just made a fool of himself. I'm guessing by your statement that you don't actually know what the scientific method is nor how it applies.

[@BlackBeard23456]

Abigail April Even if Nye "lost" the debate it would not matter. Bill Nye does not speak for the entire scientific community. Just like Hamm does not speak for every Christian. Basically Hamm's thesis was the scientific method does not work, but the fact that I am using a computer right now kinda disproves that.

[@Sk3ptik0n]

Abigail April Even according to many Christians Nye mopped the floor with Ham. When Pat Robertson tells you to stop being an imbecile, you know you are way out of the mainstream.

[@sonicpsycho13]

Tax V. You clearly don't understand the big bang theory or abiogenesis. Nowhere in the big bang theory does it say the universe came from nothing. It's an explanation, based on observation, that all of the matter and energy in the known universe was, at the dawn of spacetime, a singularity. Sorry, but this isn't nothing, it's literally everything, including spacetime. You're asking to observe all of the matter, energy, and spacetime to be compressed into a singularity and then expand. Which is inherently impossible, since you, the observer, would be part of the universe and would have to be in the singularity; it's a paradox. Abiogenesis, on the other hand, starts with materials that already exist and uses natural processes to thus far create protolife.

[@pkgfx]

This video made me think how in the hell I exist

[@pixar2714]

Actually saying god did is better because it gives you meaning and hope. And plus when christians say god did it it doesn't mean it should end there because god did it. You can still explore how god did it.

[@pkgfx]

^

[@colinp2238]

pkgfx: He exists in that realm that we know as the Twilight Zone. (blows amoke into the foggy atmosphere)

[@manictiger]

Just thinking about the conditions required to make Earth habitable makes me wonder that. If the planet that collided with us to create the moon didn't hit us with exactly the right velocity at exactly the right angle, we wouldn't exist. The amount of steps to go from a ball of lava to a planet with 2/3rds of its surface being water, (a requirement for the ozone layer), is nothing short of amazing. So many things had to line up nearly perfectly for us to exist. I hope we get smarter about how we treat this planet. It's nothing short of a miracle.

[@irrelevant_noob]

Theomega Gamer actually, there's NO f'ing means to "explore how god did it." He works in mysterious ways, remember? -.-

[@crewrangergaming9582]

I am thankful to be from a culture (Hindu) which in its ancient text have mentions of human's ancestor being a fish. Our vast knowledge from our ancestors got forgotten or became myth, but when you look at those with an open mind you find many things that later came true, from other people in the Scientific age, from other people across the World..

[@gaymermoment]

Hinduism and buddhism seem based compared to christianity and other religions

[@rayaanishfaqgaming]

I seem to like these types of religions (sanatan dharm) like buddism jainism and hinduism, i still like to be a atheist

[@misusisi1]

Then why u guys eat fish alot dumbrick

[@jimmiburton3246]

My guy Dawko getting a big mention. The leader of the evolutionary biology world

[@PidgyEdits]

For the Thiests who do not know, A scientific theory is an explanation or model based on observation, experimentation, and reasoning, especially one that has been tested and confirmed as a general principle helping to explain and predict natural phenomena.

[@matthewericowens]

I am a Thiest, and I do know... But I hope you let me comment. This presentation is based on a THEORY that came from Charles Darwin. It claims to be based on Fossil records, but that is still lacking evidence since the "Missing Link" is still undiscovered. Science deserves its credit, science teaches us much. All true scientific discoveries come through Inspiration from God. Scientists are sometimes inspired. Long before god sent Charles Darwin to an earthly family, he had told his prophets about the creation of the world. One of his prophets was The First Man. Adam. I'm happy knowing that I don't have primate, or fish ancestry.

[@iGotMySniperSticky]

Matthew Owens Every time you find a new fossil of a previously unknown species, that doesn't fill in a gap--it creates two new gaps. Thus, using the phrase "missing link" is a theist's lack of understanding of evolution. You all-capped "theory," leading me to believe that you still do not understand the difference between a common theory and a scientific theory. A scientific theory has no evidence against it--none. Theists claim that evolution cannot be, yet they give no evidence against it. They provide no scientific publications that contradict it. Why? Because there are no scientific publications against it. Without evolution, biology does not make sense.

[@OufTarek]

Tyler Meister I'm not going to do the research for you, but I'm just going to let you know right now that there are many things that contradict the theory of human evolution. If you care enough then you'll find out :)

[@iGotMySniperSticky]

brownkid72 I have a bachelor's in biology and have found no such contradiction. Please enlighten me.

[@OufTarek]

Tyler Meister 404 Bachelor not found. Keep dreaming.

[@lena5669]

This comment section is just disturbing

[@2-dsynctium773]

Justin kleeberger throw away your bible and go to school for once.

[@stiofanofirghil1916]

Purgatorius is my favourite, especially in the novel called Evolution, by Stephen Baxter.. Fantastic book!!

[@chaunceyfeatherstone6209]

Capo is my favourite. The first primate to define "peon". What a glorious prick. good thing he went south.

[@averagecroat196]

ayo grandpa lookin mighty fine on 0:20

[@wickedninja8599]

Yeah, evolution is a slow process that takes numerous generations to have noticed changes, so therefore you wouldn't see one species give birth to another. Now, if only we could get creationists to understand this.

[@KubusSc7]

but...but...Crocoduck! XD

[@robzrob]

They don't want to.

[@wickedninja8599]

robzrob I know, I was being facetious. LOL

[@juliofelipeangelini2820]

Actually, there's nothing inherent to evolution saying it has to be slow. It's only when applied to life, and more specifically, the lives of beings that take a long time to reproduce and/or die that it looks slow. Short-lived, fast-reproducing organisms such as bacteria or even insects, change faster through evolution because of that. In fact, mosquitoes evolve fast enough that we can see the difference every month -- they become resistant to "old" pesticides.

[@wickedninja8599]

Julio Felipe Angelini The video was a reference to humans. I was talking human evolution. Yes, lab studies have shown fruit flies that have evolved new traits in a fast rate that can be witness. As I said though; I was commenting on human evolution.

[@Youngboybetta]

so, that means... humans are still evolving. 0.o

[@schuylerpablico8300]

evolution does not stop

[@banialy4852]

maybe next time u look outside u will se poepol like bird and u know how pervert low poepol life having sex with a bired

[@nidavelliir]

Evolution stops when we stop reproducing

[@banialy4852]

hahahahahah ik wat u mean gays right HAHAHAHAH

[@sulffojus1227]

+bani aly yeah if everyone turns gay then we cant reproduce and no evolution

[@Ali-sc7pi]

So how did the first species occur?

[@johnchambers9836]

A biogenesis is being worked on. It seems that in the right conditions non organic elements can be brought together to form amino acids

[@edwincortes8423]

Just a few hundred thousand years and will become Saiyans.

[@delsi26]

Good luck to you then

[@patri9880]

"He was a fish." I subscribed.

[@SuperJuneM]

Lmao everyone needs to calm down with this religion stuff you will believe what you want to believe. Can people freely have opinions without getting criticized nowadays?

[@ireneyimmongkol]

AngelTheNeko Preach!

[@nouda6567]

Ngan Khong then open yout eyes

[@yaziri7]

Nowadays?it's been like this all history

[@netmeister999]

I believe that Adam and Eve weren’t the first humans, but just the first ones with souls like us.

[@ZenithPictures]

Golly, you have no idea how much peace "there was no first human" brings me 🥰 Thank you for this great video!!

[@Quarequieus]

Humans don't actually exist.

[@jimmypk1353]

One of the reasons I admire him (besides being incredibly smart) is because he always reminds me of River Tam's elder brother, Dr. Simon Tam from Firefly!

[@SimranWasu]

This was amazing! I loved the way the video flowed. Really gave me a new meaning to a species and showed evolution is just a continuum and we only see a small slice at every point.

[@GingerSpiritSmurf]

"Life is what happens in between the snapshots" That was so inspiring lol

[@dom4947]

Gianyce Gesualdo woah i was reading comments and while i was reading this he litteraly said it 3:33 that was scary

[@alexdunn5695]

Dom ME too, as soon as I read it, he said that

[@subline_funtime]

*in between snapshots be like* Barbra move to the left no omg Barbra my left ok smile

[@HoodedSpidey]

Also known as, “we have no proof but we will assume this is what happened.”

[@louisinese]

same

[@maemilev]

*Glad that I am constantly evolving!*

[@Readitboi]

This cat will become a big cat

[@darrenmalthouse7526]

10 years ago and still brilliant, interesting and relevant. Best youtube channel. End of.

[@robertdewar3788]

Our mitochondrial DNA is passed down only from our maternal ancestors, by looking at humans that have the same maternal ancestor (ie a first cousin), and seeing the number of mutations that have occurred over that single generation, you can establish when the generational lines of every human on earth meet. AND THERE IS A SINGLE INDIVIDUAL FROM WHICH WE ARE ALL DERIVED, a kind of evolutionary 'Eve', a human. As this is our common ancestor, you could argue that she is the first of our lineage - the first human.

[@besmart]

Robert Dewar Mitochondrial Eve is not necessarily (and likely wasn't) the first human. She's just the one who is our most recent ancestor. There were other Homo sapiens alive at the same time as her whose lineages died off.

[@robertdewar3788]

that makes sense, thanks

[@Ranger1812]

Denis Belyasov And your comment is relevant, why?

[@wlmkn]

So what were her parents?

[@philipalmqvist2131]

Robert Dewar There hasn't really been anyone like that. At least not a human one since the humans that emegrated from Africa first later interbred with neanderthals and created a new kind of humans--the Indo-Europeans, and they later interbred with some other variation of people in Asia. To say it in plain English--you would have to go back to a time before modern humans to reach this point and it is likely that it never occured. If there would have only been two people alive they most certainly would have gotten a pretty load of genetic diseases. If they managed to still survive it would still have had happened a long time ago. If they succeeded it was likely because of other people whose lineages died off.

[@ubiq6348]

Brilliant, I love your videos. They are so well produced; and presented with humor and great articulation I could imagine you being an outstanding talk show host:)

[@nmoney6655]

This What if and Crash Course

[@moonhaeeun5012]

When u said Father father father it sounded like u said Potter potter potter potter potter potter lmao 😂

[@tedkrasicki3857]

Never were any humans totally identical to any other humans. It may be minute, but genetic drift happens with each life-form.

[@goldentaco9124]

we're fish 🐟

[@StradaleF430]

Blake Hunt Fairy tales with no true poof

[@Kamal_AL-Hinai]

YAY!

[@marcusminingplushbros3121]

Emmy Zhang WERE A CANNIBAL!!!!

[@ArufisuIsRuru]

Naif Mohammad Sharif No evidence human was from monkey, if it was, then where's the monkey come from? of course fish, and where's the fish made of? clay

[@mayur4699]

WolFrost Arfis yes 1000year old quaran explain everything, 1billion year old fossils are fake..

[@frogstamper]

I truly feel sorry for literally half the kids in America who are brought up with this ridiculous creationism myth, no other democracy suffers with this level of absolute ignorance.

[@erickimlebs3053]

The magical evolutionism myth has way too many holes in it. The fossil record itself contradicts this video. There is no evolutionary tree but rather a record of what God created & cataclysmic extinctions over time.

[@frogstamper]

Eric Lebs You may call evolution a myth thats your choice, but 99% of the the worlds biologists would disagree with you, as would the majority of educated people. By making ridiculous statements like the above you're just showing how un-educated and dogmatic you are, I mean what makes you better informed then the most skilled men and women in their fields?

[@johnhays2647]

Eric Lebs If it was untrue and not valid, then why is it that without it, the entire field of biology falls apart?

[@colinthomas6439]

Eric Lebs How does the fossil record contradict this? Please give examples.

[@zeus5793]

Eric Lebs You sure are lost in the fog. You need an uninstall!

[@protohale]

Imagine you could take a picture of every ancestor down the line and put them in a big stack, with me at the top and my fishy forefather all the way down at the bottom. This is me, I'm a human. These are my parents, they're clearly humans too. He was 185 million generations removed from me and he was a fish. But where along the line did the first human come from? There was no single point where one became the other. Instead, evolution is a journey on stepping stones, and we give each one their own names.

[@vesuvandoppelganger]

You really think that you came from a fish?

[@spatrk6634]

@@vesuvandoppelganger you think you come from dust?

[@vesuvandoppelganger]

No.

[@joshuakerger2897]

I've often thought about this. So how do we determine that something is now a new species?

[@AndrewWilsonStooshie]

If the group can mate with each other but no other groups.

[@jingyitou838]

It's gonna be hard to see a new species in our lifetime, there are some extreme cases where that might had happened, but we humans have a very short recorded history of some short 5000 years, even shorter when we starts to learn about species around us, so likelihood that there is a new species evolving during our lifetime of human history is quite unlikely

[@bigmoniesponge]

@@AndrewWilsonStooshie thank you.

[@ruthjavierramirez428]

I'm a 14yr old girl and I love to learn I really like science but seeing how much hate people get from studying it really scares me.

[@uknownada]

Now you're 22. How do ya feel now?

[@kiilee5963]

@@uknownada she became albert einstein

[@AbduIIl]

​@@kiilee5963 🤣😂😂🤣

[@Golems_wrath]

​@@kiilee5963what Albert Einstein was trans? Now that's the real question....XD

[@kuiku5101]

Shes probably soing onlyfans now

[@niclassjrslev4458]

this video is a little bit fishy. lol.

[@niclassjrslev4458]

lol

[@vintraxs-4855]

👍

[@arjunator2688]

These vids educate me more than my school