What If Anakin Skywalker And Darth Vader Were BROTHERS

[@theerinmarie]

"No Luke, I'm your uncle"

[@ryplay08]

“That’s not true, that’s impossible”

[@Shiki199]

Luke: uncle Owen?

[@catsithx]

​@-kazu5167 I told you I didn't want you to join them. Now get back to the farm. 😊

[@MinktheStorykeeper]

*takes off helmet revealing he is Owen*

[@tgb0079]

"Search your feelings, you know it's true young Skywalker, I didn't die on the farm'

[@Fatherofheroesandheroines]

Luke..i am your fathers brother's nephew's former roommate.

[@shinigamimiroku3723]

"... So... what does that make us?"

[@kaijukoopa1248]

​@@shinigamimiroku3723nothing..which is what you're about to become

[@andrewwinslow9315]

I See your Schwartz is as big as mine!

[@Totallysteveharvey]

So your friend of my cousin? I see the Schwartz’s is strong with you.

[@Novus53994]

And now I feel obligated to rewatch the og version 😂

[@MinktheStorykeeper]

Takes "you were my brother Anakin" to a whole new meaning

[@RonDiani]

Or the “please brother help me …”

[@Riftrender]

Dooku was the Grandfather of the High Ground.

[@RegentOfGreece]

A true diad in the Force. One brother meant for Kindness and compassion in the Light Side, the other meant for hate and destruction in the Dark Side.

[@disneyknightspadilla1406]

I wish you could’ve done one where Palpatine decided to clone Anakin rather than manipulating him.

[@kaijukoopa1248]

Oh that's a good one

[@leolopesotis7806]

yeah that's a good idea

[@MeJustMe101]

He did

[@magnawaves]

Luckily for you, a bunch of other SW what-if story tellers have done this exact story. Lots of good ones too

[@loviehawkins4861]

He did

[@Ravenfanatic5]

When I saw the title for this video: "A surprise to be sure. But a welcomed one." After I saw the video: "We shall watch your career with great interest."

[@Thebeastofthelantern]

Hèhè true brother

[@owenyang8361]

WHAT IF ANAKIN WAS JUST A JEDI BUT SECRETLY THE CHOSEN ONE AND NO ONE KNEW EXCEPT HIM

[@Acendshadow]

So what if he was obi wan but powerfull

[@owenyang8361]

I don’t know how to respond so ya like obi wan

[@Acendshadow]

@@owenyang8361 i meant like what if Anakin was like a normal Jedi like obi wan

[@owenyang8361]

@@Acendshadow what do you think a meant

[@Acendshadow]

@@owenyang8361 he’s a normal hedi

[@alexander.tahtadjian]

This was amazing. I’ve been a fan of your videos for a while and it’s always fun to see your interesting SW what if’s. It was also fun to see Anakin and Darth Vader being different people getting shown some love. This is definitely an interesting scenario and it should definitely get shown some more love. Plus I think we could all agree that this is one of the best what if’s that us SW fans asked for…plus I think we could agree that a duel between Anakin and Vader would be epic. Great job as always and I can’t wait to see what you do next. I do have a few ideas for some possible what if’s: 1) What if Rey was a Mandalorian…essentially what if Din Djarin found Rey and took her in as a Foundling. 2) What if Ezra was a Mandalorian…something like how both his parents were Mandalorians who left Mandalore and went to start their own lives (you could still keep most of Ezra’s backstory) and potentially make Ezra and Sabine a couple (since Disney won’t, we have too…#ezrabine4ever. 3) What if Jango Fett and/or Boba Fett Joined the Republic…I think something interesting could happen with this. 4) What if Rey, Finn and Poe went back in time to the Clone Wars…this would make the World Between Worlds even more of an important focal point and I could also see them get along well with Anakin, Ashoka, Rex and the rest of the 501st (it would be fun to see Rey, Finn and Poe join the 501st) I hope these are some amazing ideas for some potential What if’s

[@catsithx]

What if anikin had a gambling addict and no one could stop his luck.

[@Totallysteveharvey]

I want this

[@IanHarrison-n9m]

So what if Anakin was just like hakari fr

[@theonlychickensama8353]

At least Anakin would never lose his hand

[@catsithx]

@@theonlychickensama8353 because he would always have a winning hand.

[@jclozanoc]

What if R2 saved anakin from the dark side What if Obi-wan reincarnated in his own young self (dies at deathstar, awakens just after seeing qui gon die)

[@HolyknightVader999]

Hell, it would even be cooler if Vader was an evil clone of Anakin.

[@jeremywatters2295]

nah

[@ziephel-6780]

A better version of the Acolyte lol

[@MrCadeRay]

"YOU ARE MY BROTHER VADER,I LOVE YOU"😢

[@havesomeculture]

Nenad, his birth name must be Nenad, at least of my rethinking - he would be raised by their mother alongside Anakin unto being found and then trained as a Jedi just as well, but once he turned to the dark side, there’d be no redemption for him as Darth Vaeder.

[@The-Gaming-Shark-i7k]

“A weakness you’ll soon regret, Skywalker.”

[@Python085]

So really taking the idea that LUKE'S FATHER Anakin Skywalker and Darth Vader were TWO SEPERATE STUDENTS of Obi-Wan Kenobi LITERALLY? Neat!

[@Gilgamesksiklls]

Not literally but more figuratively as in this scenario vader was never a student of Obi-Wan but was captured as an infant and trained in the dark side by Sidious

[@The1stInterviewer]

Here's a what if scenario: you know how towards the end of the Clone Wars some council members thought Yoda was going senile and have some form of dementia? Well what if he was going senile and had some form of dementia? In his forgetfulness he uses his force powers recklessly and had to be stopped.

[@thedigitalbash1506]

My goodness man this is one of the best SW What Ifs. I have said it many times, you are the most gifted SW What if creator I've ever met. 😉🎉

[@BlueSkyBirdies]

It sounds like Anakin's brother was literally not given a name before "Vader". Maybe Shmi didn't know she was expecting twins and only thought up one name (Anakin) prior to the birth, so when there were two babies she named one immediately and decided to wait for inspiration to meaningfully name the other. Only she never got the chance, because Plagueis stole him. And I feel like it would definitely be in the nature of the Sith to deny a child growing up under their influence a name until they had "earned" one. So the second Skywalker twin was probably just called "boy" all his life up to when he tried to take on a former Jedi Master/unspeakably talented and experienced duelist by himself. Yes, he failed, but his eagerness to try and his usage of the Dark Side to cling to life beyond what should have been physiologically possible likely proved his worth in Palpatine's eyes, enough to reward him with the name "Vader". Was I close? Did I get it right? 😊

[@hanhnguyenluu75]

Idea: What if Palpatine gave the wrong person nightmares of Padme dying? (He doesn't know)

[@ShaunAbraham-o7z]

I enjoy your content much more than the Disney+ output.

[@davidcatabui2018]

It's mainly better because he respects legends and the fans and usually it's intelligently written, and because it's free to listen to

[@samszczepanski2281]

Poor shaak ti, not even in fanfiction can she survive

[@thebananaspeedruns9275]

It is a series staple to kill Shaak Ti whenever possible

[@beccamaroney3782]

​@@thebananaspeedruns9275 it's so mean. If I did this story, I would have it so she survives. I would have had Ahsoka mentioned more

[@gaming-verseandadditionalv2500]

Welcome home .” Vader and anakin 2.”

[@Tuskin38]

Someone has been watching the acolyte

[@LikeABoss1211]

To me, this one had a lot of potential to be a long series.

[@mauricetoyer1844]

These stories need to be animated asap! This was a nice one here.

[@Armor_of_Torrent]

Another amazing story. Thank you

[@cryowax2986]

Awesome story! Now I wanna see "What if Sheev Palpatine and Darth Sidious were BROTHERS?" With Sheev being the kind and charismatic politician who is strengthwise powerless, while Sidious is the evil force wielding Sith Lord who manipulates his brother from the shadows and aims to use Sheev as a tool to set up the throne of the Sith Empire. Sheev trying to inform Anakin of the monster that shares his face. The surprise twist to the Jedi who go to arrest the chancellor only to be attacked from behind by a seeming copy of the man wielding a red lightsaber and terrible darkside powers

[@moneygrabber6720]

I’d be interested to see how this plays out if they were both twins that grew up in the Jedi order together. Palpatine just picked the darker of the two to corrupt and then the two brothers have to fight on Mustafar. I can see a fun movie moment of Obi Wan coming in to save HIS brother Anikan

[@Hypercube2017]

Finally, one where the winners still take heavy casualties. Now, a brighter future can be made from the ashes.

[@philliplahm6264]

Luke, I am your uncle

[@marcusisgod2592]

As we know darth vader was a natural engineer and could use mechaguru or whatever so what if he used skill to create nanobots to repair his lungs and burns while also making limbs that could conduct the force to make lightning. This could relate to inquisitor baris as she used nanobots in the bomb and he may remember nanobots and their uses. He could could also conduct experiments diguised as torture to fool sidious, learning to heal wounds, make force sensitive droids/limbs and using nano bots to manipulate mididclorians to strip or enhance the force in individuals. What I was thinking was that he used nanobots to remove scar tissue especially around the lungs and he would be dipped in bacta or bacta would be applied this would allow him breath which means he can meditate more deeply. And for the limbs, it is possible to make material force sensitive and I was thinking he make limbs skeletal looking like in attack of the clones but would then cover the we either grafed flesh from his body or flesh made from his blood and other ingredients like perhaps kyber crystal this would make the force flow from him easier and perhaps with the sith alchemy in the limbs making his force lightning more powerful. Basically an uber vader who is perhaps stronger than full potential anakin.

[@TonyAncom]

What if Revan wasn't found in stasis until the first year of the clone wars? That would mean that Revan in his prime would be alive and well, and Darth Vitiate's spirit would still be dormant since Revan didn't awake his spirit at Yavin.

[@Frosted_cheese]

Such a cool concept!

[@MultiGamer2016-k8l]

please do "what is shmi was the chosen one"

[@notapplicable1296]

There is a A03 (archive of our own) story with Anakin's twin sister, they both are generals to the 501 & Ahsoka's dual master __THEY ARE AMAZING LUKE AND LEIA RAISED BY THEIR AUNT AMELIA__

[@mphoramathe1801]

Twins, now? After what the acolyte did? bold choice

[@CameramanYTChaosAndAnimation]

I would tolerate seeing this but it goes on into the original trilogy, just Padme and Anakin are still alive and part of the rebellion

[@TheStinkyGhost69]

I'd love to see an alternate version where vader won, then a part 2 for the OT

[@AdamWingard_Official]

A surprise to be sure, but a welcome one

[@blackknight6202]

What if Plagueis had a secret apprentice to help him fight Sidious ? What if Obi-Wan went with Ahsoka on Mandalore while Anakin went to Utapau ? What if Vader noticed R2-D2 was with Luke during the Battle of Yavin and understood he was manipulated by Sidious ? What if Ventress killed Dooku to take his place ?

[@Walid-mk4jo]

The skywalker bloodline is just an endless cycle of confusion.... 😮‍💨

[@SWGuyHere]

What if Sidious and Palpatine were two different people?

[@C0nstrucyt]

cool concept

[@notapplicable1296]

Jedi kinda deserve to lose, they don't gather allies or inquire info they really are blinded by the DARKSIDE & are too arrogant and fearful to ask for help

[@annawilhelm9697]

Bravo! Loved it.

[@Whynot31136]

What if Palpatine put an inhibitor chip into Padawan Anakin

[@derangedlunaticakad.l.7030]

That’s a good storyline.

[@Hawkeye-ve8bl]

What if the Republic had a Droid Army and the CIS had a Clone Army?

[@jackmarlon9102]

What if Palpatine told Luke Skywalker the tragedy of Darth Plagueis the Wise?

[@warpstarrogue3554]

Vader would just kill Palps instantly for bringing up the story for the umpteenth time, in front of his son no less.

[@Fatherbench]

When I was litter. I thought they were different people and then I found out they are the same person sometime later

[@SteveCowlishaw]

Seems like a much better idea but I really don't like how all these stories end with episode 3 This story itself, I would've had Anakin's episode 3 journey end with him recovering on Polis Massa with him able to continue the fight another day, and then took the story to the original trilogy but without Luke and Leia. The story wouldn't really play out like this though since Palpatine did everything he can to manipulate the entire life of Anakin, he set him up with Padmé, placed ideas into his head etc. Chances are Anakin would've never seen Padmé again after Episode 1, and Qui-Gon likely wouldn't have been feared by him as much, so Qui-Gon may have survived, and perhaps Dooku would've never fallen. I've had ideas for this story for a while tbh :P

[@kaarthikeyan8227]

I was hoping that Anakin would find out who vader actually was

[@zackcross7190]

What if there was a Basilisk in the Jedi Temple?

[@N3O1999]

It’d probably hunt the younglings with a low M count when someone opens its chamber

[@JJBInc-yd2ym]

I thought it would be cool if both skywalkers grew up in the jedi order and led different garrisons in the clone wars, and were more close. then one of them gets seduced by the dark side and they end up at odds

[@simpsonsquire1997]

Geez, just goes to show how the Galaxy REALLY was better off without the Sith. You know what you should do? Do another version of Anakin and Vader as brothers, but this time, create a what-if where Anakin and Vader are kinda like the dysfunctional twins from the Old Republic and actually have him betray and murder Anakin. AKA, Luke Skywalker’s father.

[@sakomanlee]

What if the Jedi Council had a Sorting Hat to help place prospective students?

[@ZeKermet]

A vader in the clone wars is scary

[@GalacticFlash]

LOVED IT

[@bigwsly]

Can you do what if Luke was born instead of anakin in the phantom menace Or what if palpatine and sidious were different people

[@Zay3xxxx]

Man so dooku fucked up the entire sith plan

[@Achuidian179]

Interesting story. Personally if you ask me this What if makes more sense than the Canon. Day 124 of my list. What if; Anakin never gave into his feelings for Padme (Pentre Patrol did his version), Aayla Secura was the chosen one and became Darth Talon, Shme Skywalker was adopted by the Tusken Raiders, Boba Fett saved his Tusken family, Count Dooku was a regular count for the CIS, Jabba the Hutt supported the Jedi at the Start of the Clone Wars, and finally, what if Sabine and Ezra fell in love?

[@lastlink1684]

Day 2 of asking what if the 212 was stationed on courostant instead of the 501 during fives chase?

[@edisonlaw934]

Vader: Your mother never told you what happened to your brother? Anakin: She told me enough... he died during childbirth. Vader: No, I am your brother. Anakin: No... that's not true, that's impossible!

[@xana3771]

What if Ahsoka and the nightowls joined Anakin and Obi-Wan to save Palpatine in exchange for help for take down Maul ?

[@spencermillard1]

What if a 44 year old accountant named gary was the chosen one

[@Somethingfs-sx1ft]

What if revan was the chosen one

[@marcusisgod2592]

What if darth vader went to darthomir to learn. New suit or perhaps more unique powers. Resurrect talzin maybe. what if Vokara Che became a mentor to anakin as anakin was being treated for bullying and trauma from being a slave. What if anakin fell in love with luminara unduli, serra keto or bultar swan. What if anakin was taught by agen kolar or sasee tin or adi gallia.

[@dimax5146]

Yeeeees, finally! I've only one thing to say, I thought that the brother was good but nevermind, I love this story❤

[@Riftrender]

What if Dooku and Tyrannus were separate people?

[@ZoranDraskovec]

What if anakin had a sister

[@howtogoogle8031]

anakin woudlnt conlfiited because he doesnt have darth vader onside him so no conflict palptince cant corrupt anakin hmmmm

[@marcusisgod2592]

What if anakin spirit in the world between worlds saved padme by making her a force ghost or new mother if the ones. She could make him help ben solo and others saying you got to help people who are suffering from your past actions. What if anakin was piloting before attack of the clones and sensed ventress fall to the darkside as her master died and took his ship to the planet to investigate. Perhaps starting a romance as they are very similar in their stories. Also what if ahsoka taught ben skywalker as she saw him as history repeating itself. What if anakin was a jedi watchmen or wayfinder. What if anakin went with kenobi to face maul and savage instead of adi gallia. What if anakin fell in love with luminara or your own version of aayla secura romance. What if oppo rancis trained anakin. What if anakin met and fell in love with ventress just before the clone wars just after her masters death. What if anakin became a jedi sentinel like a watchmen or one of those who find younglings. What if evan piel became a mentor or second master to anakin. Or anakin became a healer either before or after his mother death could be related to his friendship with offee or alternatively what if he was trained by tra sa who taught windu and actually did not forbid attachment as shown by her relationship with tholme , they could become like a pseudo parents to anakin and train him away from the temple in azati martial arts and from trasa the living force as she is a plant lady so imagine anakin controlling plant life.

[@אפיקבןזקי]

What if obi wan kenobi got a padawan along side anakin?

[@superfish6794]

They were different people ..."Anakin Skywalker was weak ... I destroyed him" - Vader to Ahsoka ...

[@memeboyr6177]

What if Anakin and Obi Wan captured Dooku on Oba Diah?

[@Yellowriverco]

Soooo early. Stoked for this one though.

[@Acoolnamme]

I think more could have been done with this concept, especially after they finally reunited as enemies. But it was a nice story, regardless

[@somathegamer4933]

No, Luke, I'm your brother from another mother from another brother, mother

[@theervinalliance6339]

Loved it

[@thenomadsclan6238]

This one would have been cool if vader did kill anakin. We’d get the og movies with a less broken obi and a good force ghost anakin

[@lorossilvers3490]

What if Palpatine used Essence Transfer on Padmé Amidala during the Clone Wars to get closer to Anakin? And What if Padmé Amidala was Darth Sidious instead of Palpatine? Also What if Chopper was Anakin's astromech?

[@KRIT_101]

What if Anakim was the perfect Jedi. (Following the code, being a true Jedi, etc)

[@irystocrattakodachithatmooms]

What if the Jedi built a redesigned Star Forge?

[@howtogoogle8031]

anakin the light darth vader the dark evil hmmmm

[@MCZombieDude]

Can you do a video on what if Anakin accidentally killed commander fox after fives death

[@georgepapatheofilou6118]

What about the droid attack on the cookies

[@justinetherton5777]

I like this story it’s cool❤

[@faheemashaik1120]

Lol I got here 37minutes after publish

[@phillipbarr]

Youre fan fictions are testing the waters now lol.

[@scareditymays6yearsago477]

What if Anakin’s force ghost help train Anakin during the clone wars?

[@wintermoon5442]

What if Padme was horrified at Anakin for slaughtering Tusken Raiders?

[@louisdellalucca8969]

Seems odd that Plagueis wouldn’t know there were twins

[@wyattbuck8765]

what if the gungans killed grievous on naboo and maul saved savage on mandalore

[@y.n.tryone4683]

Ok here I have some problems with this story 1. If anakin had captured dooku the Jedi would be heavily guarding and monitoring to uncover who the Sith Lord is as you have mentioned in previous what ifs 2.)after Vader was burned on mustafar , sidious would want to turn anakin to the dark side as he now was the only one who could be the most powerful being in the universe 3. If the Jedi thought the sith was responsible behind dooku’s death why would some of the most strongest Jedi leave courscant 4. Also why would windu go without any confirmation from anakin . Yes in the original timeline he was preparing to confront palpatine but he waited for anakin word . 5. I’m sorry but Vader and palpatine ain’t overwhelming windu . Windu could literally crush Vader life support and sidious is pretty weak with the saber compared to windu

[@santicollectionprime7128]

What if Anakin skywalker was kidnaped by oni to be part of The spartan 2 program from halo??

[@mikecuozzo9709]

3:08 how could a mom let a 2nd child go after loaing one?

[@kevinallerston5969]

"LOL. No. I'm your father, silly."

[@landonshields96]

What if Palpatine gave up his emergency powers then killed all the jedi

[@skeletonlover3214]

cool story

[@ladavasek5906]

What Uncle Owen was secrete Mandalorian and taught Luke their style of fight

[@marcus2665]

How long does it take you to write one of these?