What If Ahsoka Turned DARTH VADER Back To The Light Side On Malachor

[@unclebozo9845]

Great story, the only major criticism I have is that Obi-Wan would not have been killed by Vader if Ahsoka redeemed him, meaning he would have been alive during and after the battle of Yavin, and likely would have actually been on Yavin when the Death Star was destroyed.

[@demonkingnetsu4045]

I thought about this too, but honestly, you could just say that Sidious or an Inquisitor killed him while he stalled to allow Luke to escape.

[@unclebozo9845]

@@demonkingnetsu4045 no way Obi would've let a lowly inquisitor, and Sidious wasn't on the Death Star at the same time as him.

[@piratavorak]

It was starkiller

[@demonkingnetsu4045]

@@unclebozo9845 If Sidious sensed Kenobi, I think he would have searched for him the same as Vader did in the original. As for the inquisitor, which would be more likely, I disagree. Kenobi could easily beat the inquisitor, but his sacrifice was not to win. He could have fought Vader with the same ferocity as he did in his show, but he chose not to. He chose to let go, and by doing so he allowed for an escape. Had he gone all out, had he fought Vader/The Inquisitor to win, it would just have led to Luke being captured as reinforcements were called.

[@mikecotto1167]

@@unclebozo9845remember: this is an alternate timeline or story. Perhaps Palpatine was at the Death Star since Vader was no longer around to carry out his order and killed Kenobi.

[@RyanTheDark]

I would love seeing a image of what Anakin's suit would look like. Love how this played out with including Padmé in his redemption!

[@Fan0303]

There's an unreleased game designs of what uf Anakin survived after Sidiusus's death, and 2 of the designs are him having new suits

[@99thJediWarrior]

I love how Anakin was saving his son during the Death Star trench run!

[@primal1233]

I actually wish Ahsoka really was able to turn Vader back into Anakin

[@mr.ghostking5743]

Same

[@99thJediWarrior]

She was close to doing so, too.

[@eugenelau3927]

@@99thJediWarrior She was a sisterly Ex-Padawan nearly Jedi Knight, but in OT, it was blood and flesh that could redeem Vader to the Light Side!!

[@wargamesmaster]

At that point of his life, nothing short of Padme coming back to life to slap some sense into Vader would make him come back.

[@brenersilva7361]

What if obiwan asked bokatan for help to hide luke

[@darthhauler9947]

A Mandalorian Luke. It'd be awesome considering his piloting skills.

[@brenersilva7361]

@@darthhauler9947 all i could think was mandalorian luke with the dark saber

[@darthhauler9947]

@@brenersilva7361 it'd be awesome 😎

[@gundamleviathan5760]

Bo Katan had too much on her plate to protect Luke.

[@trainion9626]

Mandalorian Luke The Second in Command of the Nite Owls

[@dianesinger9729]

I loved Anakin the white and blue suit like the 501st. Nice tribute, I am glad he went back to the light and helped Luke

[@RuzzyID]

I wonder if Ahsoka would've tried to reach out to Master Yoda though, to inform him of Anakin's redemption

[@DrownedInExile]

"Revenge is not the Jedi Way." "It is today!"

[@thestarwarsgalaxy]

How does Obi-Wan die, everyone is asking. Obi-Wan dies from boredom in this. That’s how!

[@colethelin9203]

What an amazing Star Wars Fan Fiction of What if Ahsoka Turned Darth Vader back to the Light Side on Malachor. Can you Please Create a Part 2?

[@staroceans8677]

Wow, you REALLY have a TALENT for writing cool story twists. I am ALWAYS captivated, if not spellbound, by the storylines. They are refreshing, unique and often have a very positive and pleasant ending. THANK you for your efforts and keeping the original iconic characters alive, and forever in our memories and hearts ❤😊

[@thestarwarsgalaxy]

Thank you!!!! Comments like this make my day

[@nealsmall9316]

​@@thestarwarsgalaxyWhat do you think it would've been like if Darth Vader never got burned

[@VrVHS]

@@nealsmall9316 He would not have the suit and would've probably over-thrown Sidious. (Also, yes, I know this comment was made a year ago.

[@mattyjames704]

This surly needs a part 2 of luke meeting his father after all this and then how the next adventure would go between father and son

[@craigmcdonald3846]

Seconded

[@BlackKing.2000]

IMO Ashoka most definitely could have turned Vader back to the light. Just with enough time to get to him.

[@ichiban308]

On Mustafar, I don't think she could overpower Vader, but he didn't hate Ahsoka like he did Kenobi, and I believe she could have gotten through to him together with Padme.

[@npittswarof2]

Love how the title is the polar opposite of pente patrols recent video. Lets us have 2 different but very similar stories, from 2 amazing narrators

[@Triforce00]

This is such a well written story, unlike many fanfiction what ifs here on KZbin, very very special, every part of it, thank you ❤

[@jacksonpless5243]

I love this story but the only thing is obi wan wouldn’t be dead if Vader was turned on malacore, it would’ve been cool to see them reunite here too

[@dillonroberts9945]

I like that you and PPSW went opposite routes, this one was more of a "feel good" which I can always dig. Also Im really glad you guys collaborate a lot because both of you are my favorite "what if". I hope you guys keep doing the Ahsoka streams, always nice to hear y'all's opinions

[@reeceemms1643]

Before I show my submission for what if ideas, I have an idea for a video, could you do a choose your own adventure type what if where we end at a choice and the view chooses what happens next. Any way onto my what if suggestions. 1) what if Padme was forced to marry for the Republic during the clone wars? 2) what if Padme was enslaved by the Hutts or Zygerianns during the clone wars? 3) what if Padme was made a prisoner of war during the clone wars? 4) what if Cal and Merrin had a daughter (aka. Jedi/Nightsister hybrid)? 5) what if Cal trained Luke Skywalker? 6) what if Ahsoka trained Luke Skywalker (and probably told him who darth vader was)? 7) what if Jyn Erso survived combined with what if Jyn Erso met and fell in love with Luke Skywalker? 8) what if Ezra and Sabin had a child

[@y.n.tryone4683]

8:03 but bail can’t arrest him on behalf of the republic since there is no republic he can keep him as a war prisoner but the republic turned into the empire remember

[@notapplicable1296]

I love this story, some stories I just have to visit from tome to time. This is definitely one I revisit

[@Themaidbawb]

Bro was crying at the end of the video

[@hostergaard]

What if Darth Vader became a famous underwater basket weaver instead of a sith lord?

[@zeno6554]

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 YES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@dryferr5557]

These are killing me Great job 👏

[@zeno6554]

how do you mean by _______ you?

[@aidanlightfoot8601]

why cant Disney make an animated what if series dave would make it masterful

[@soulju3192]

This is Going to have to be my Fav What if Star wars

[@nathanj7520]

I wish this got more love I listen to them every morning on my 25 minute ride to work 😁😁once more the sith shall rule the morning 😁😁🤜🤛🤘🤘

[@AllieZelda]

HOLY CRAP the 501st suit idea! I must have caused a ripple in the Force because I tweeted an idea about that thing earlier today!

[@oliversherman2414]

You always come up with the most impressive scenarios

[@danielharman572]

There's four potential what if's here maybe more. 1) What if leia skywalker was raised on tattooine and ahsoka tano took a part time job at the lars moisture farm so she could secretly help obi-wan kanobi to protect leia skywalker and also secretly begin training leia skywalker. 2) As this is going on obi-wan kanobi was taking luke skywalker to mandalore to meet with bo katan kryze who would give luke skywalker to house wren to raise until the time was right. 3) Also obi-wan kanobi would find the path and thru them master vos and ask him to go to mandalore to house wren to help protect luke skywalker and begin very basic jedi training. 4) They would all be told that master yoda is alive and in self imposed exhile awaiting for the will of the force to tell them that the time is right to fully train the skywalker twins unto full knighthood in the jedi order. Thank you very much for your time and creativity. Kind regards from Daniel Harman.

[@Darth_Vader_Explains]

Hooray! An outcome where I get a happy ending. Very well done! Let's collab some day. Next make "What If I had lost to Obi wan on the 1st death star."

[@BasiliskenWrestlingFan]

Probably an unpopular opinion: Darth Vader needs a hug, because He has such a sad life 😢

[@zeno6554]

yeah................... :( or an happy life AND a hug@@BasiliskenWrestlingFan

[@fishandjam5383]

11:54 "Search your feelings, you know it be true."

[@timothyfrasier8218]

You forgot about his daughter and this time he didn't blow up the world she grew up on so she wouldn't hate him that much

[@yourlocalghastyt285]

here's a problem with this story: Ahsoka and vader could've escaped the temple before it exploded to go with ezra, kanan, and chopper, ahsoka would've def died in the explosion, and obi wan would still be alive due to vader not killing him on the death star

[@CosmicSmoke758]

I had the same thoughts watching the video

[@thestarwarsgalaxy]

Vader didn’t truly turn until Ezra, Kanan, and chopper got out. And I don’t think Kanan and Ezra would just let vader hop on board. They don’t know him like Ahsoka. And yeah she probably would’ve died in the explosion, but then I don’t have a story. Not everything is going to be perfect in these I suppose

[@john98765333]

Oooh, very nice story!

[@00martoneniris86]

What if Ezra killed Thrawn above Lothal What if eno gordova traind Luke and Leia What if Cal kestis died in order 66 What if Obi wan Kenobi killed Darth Vader on mustafar

[@00martoneniris86]

What if Palpatine didn't return in the sequels What if kannen jarus survived What if Thrawn joined the rebellion What if Rogue One survived What if Yoda died in the High republic Era What if Darth plagueis yused ecence transfer on Darth sidous

[@zeno6554]

Palpatine returning in the sequels was bullshi

[@Randorr]

While it’s a sweet thought, I don’t think it ever could’ve happened. He was far too gone at that point, Vader truly had killed Anakin. The only one who was ever able to- and would ever be able to save Anakin is Luke. In this moment, Ahsoka just represented everything Vader wanted to destroy. Just another piece of Anakin’s past which he is trying to erase. That’s why he didn’t really hesitate. He was trying to get rid of Anakin for good, and killing Ahsoka would help him accomplish this.

[@vampricyoda]

....How does someone who knows so much about Star Wars not know Yavin is a Gas Giant with no land to live on? And how did Obi-Wan die without Vader's duel?!?! I doubt Troopers were able to take him out.

[@mastrblckhwk]

I had that exact thought

[@Dragoninja26]

Yeah I even went to wookieepedia to check if I was misremembering about Yavin, and afterwards came to the comments with the same two problems. I could accept Obi-Wan's death being due to some inquisitors being sent to be on the Death Star due to Vader's absence or something, but then someone pointed out that without Vader, Leia being captured and droids meeting Luke and getting him off Tatooine doesn't even really happen, right?

[@TenkoBerry]

This be pretty Interesting 👌

[@khalelrussell2271]

Love this

[@sweetpeali6313]

I love this

[@inzyniertv9305]

What if Republic hardliners rebelled against the Empire soon after it was formed?

[@IsengardMordor]

Oh that is a good one❤

[@inzyniertv9305]

@@IsengardMordor Republics true believers would take up arms against the Empire to bring back freedom ajd democracy

[@wedgeantillies66]

Sidious hubris in believing he knows and can control everything, comes back to bite him in the ass as Ashoka and Anakin, no longer being jedi throw all of the establish playbook out the window and kill him in a way he could never anticipate.

[@TheAviation360]

I think ahsoka would've called rex for help

[@HolyknightVader999]

Then I suppose Fulcrum is going to have one hell of an asset to take down the Empire.......

[@colethelin9203]

hi the Star Wars Galaxy can you please please create a part2 of What If Ahsoka Turned Darth Vader Back to the Light Side on Malachor? Thanks

[@Felix24148]

I wish you could partner up with an artist to make a page by page storyboard anamatic to go with this audio

[@runeuchihawhatifsandgaming3783]

incredible story galaxy

[@beccamaroney3782]

He also should have recognised Leia as his own as well.

[@Jimmy-ch8cy]

What if Vader betrayed Palpatine before the events of A New Hope

[@scottparker6399]

"Vader's white blade...."....Sublime

[@OverHeed]

What if Palpatine WAS A GENUINELY NICE POLITICALLY MOTIVATED NON CORRUPT Man?

[@fortale7167]

Have you ever heard the tragedy of darth plagues the nice/polite and wise?

[@nicholaslin1630]

Mara Jade Skywalker needs to be included in this alternate path. And this time Mara lived her whole life by her husband's side. And none of the Skywalker family turn evil. The fall and redemption were already enough. As well as the destruction of Anakin and Padme's lives.

[@Hitoshishinsoscvmsock]

What is maul and vader teamed up to fight Palpatine???

[@fdfgaming9076]

I almost cried

[@Ladybug-m4j]

What if the daleks were in star wars

[@notapplicable1296]

Anakin has two/2 kids, isn't it just the Jedi way to hide one of them from their parents. I Love The We Are Not Jedi, my only caveat would be Ani-Vader force choked Sidious while Ahsoka drives the death blow Go Teamwork

[@gerardocovarrubias-b5x]

hey tell me when you make what if anakin stayed on mortis make sure he comes back to save the jedi and padme after training with the mortis gods and reaching his full potential

[@tonystank3091]

I did find a slight plot hole. If Vader had turned to the light, who killed Obi-Wan? Certainly Sidious wasn't on the Death Star at that time.

[@MartinCorrigan-t9l]

To be fair for all his crimes rather anakin came back or not he needed to answer for them

[@benscott2743]

If you are looking for "what if" new ideas, how about something like "What if Leia was forced to remain naked during her captivity with Jabba the Hut"?

[@Pinkielover]

She used to take on the 501st all the time great gangbangs No one handled a meat saber better... Man that video about Obi-Wan talking about Ahsoka Tano to Luke funny as hell if you haven't seen it

[@00martoneniris86]

What if Ezra bridger didn't pull Ahsoka into the world between worlds

[@Exaris79]

What happened yo ObiWan since Vader didn't kill him in the Deathstar. What if Vader got stranded on Myrkr. With the Ysalamiri negating the Force, will that reset Vader from the dark side. The Sith are addicted and corrupted by the dark side. With the disconnection, if Anakin's not pruned enough, his cybernetics might heal him as without the dark side, his body would be given the chance to recover as the dark side was never used to heal him.

[@MattJames2211]

how did they travel through hyperspace if they were only inside a tie fighter which doesn't have a hyperdrive?

[@Ayoits_jayden]

What abt anakin finding out and meeting leia I feel like that would be a good part 2

[@y.n.tryone4683]

11:45 how would kenobi he dead in this story if Vader wasn’t there to strike him down ?????

[@oodakiifrost8755]

Plz part 2

[@Leethalpersonal]

What if Ahsoka trusted Maul

[@jaytod2058]

It appears that Palpatine is the one who defeated Kenobi in the Death Star instead of Vader in this alternate timeline.

[@hojuzinney163]

👏👏👏

[@AhsokaTano-p5u]

How did obi wan die in this what if, because Darth Vader killed him originally, but without Darth Vader he should still be alive. Also why was the emperor on the star destroyer? He wasn’t on the first star destroyer. Also the emperor would have gotten a new apprentice till then. Still I enjoy ur videos and I think they r very interesting.😅

[@shadowfast541]

What if ahsoka becomes the emperor's apprentice and anakin joins the rebel alliance.

[@donovancapozzola2076]

What if savages death turned maul to the light?

[@the-orenge-head]

Embrace ahsoka Too bad they only did that once after ahsoka died But like what anakin said this is where the fun begins

[@darthjarjar2742]

Baked beans

[@CommanderAlien18]

What's good

[@oliverclarke6948]

but who killed ben kenobi?

[@Charbar1954heiseigoji]

Sidious mabe

[@zaney2172]

How did obiwan die in this time line

[@nandiplays3875]

This is what I call a FANTASTIC fanfiction 🙌🙌😀😀!

[@neanderthalknight9417]

isn't Yavin a gas giant?

[@mday979]

With this new time wouldn't Obi-Wan still be alive though??

[@Lodada]

Legally speaking Vader did nothing illegal since order 66 and all that

[@JessicaWilliams21880]

What if Revan trained Anakin Skywalker just before Qui Gon gives Obi Wan the task of doing it, because we all know that Obi Wan pushed Anakin towards the dark side more but with Revan Anakin would be in balance just like Qui Gon said he’s is the chosen one meant to bring balance to the force.

[@kierangilchrist5645]

Part 2

[@adamfleming2186]

How did the Empire find the Yavin base in this story?

[@jettucker3347]

how did obi wan die in this story if vader was reformed into anakin before episode 4?

[@GoldAronZKing]

Grey jedi Darth Vader is op

[@alex141516]

What if Anakin lost the podrace and wasn't freed?

[@Tharus12]

Isn't Yavin a gas giant and how did Obi Wan die without Vader on the death star? Otherwise, an enjoyable story.

[@matrixmaster9616]

I wished for that.

[@fox-milessavioroffoxes3782]

Wait isn’t the Planet Yavin a gas giant? How could they stay there and survive?

[@ssjgotenks2009]

ther emroe then pelant yaian there yaian v that not gas planet

[@fox-milessavioroffoxes3782]

@@ssjgotenks2009 What

[@jongrotsky-tj6br]

Wait if anakin skywalker turns good doesn’t luke skywalker not exist yet

[@wendyandcarla2176]

I’ll do you one better what if Ashoka turned Vader back to the light but Ashoka was consumed by the dark side

[@teraplays33]

what if sidious trained grogu

[@gamedaddy8839]

Someone Plz animate this!!

[@notstupid1933]

Why was Obi-Wan a force ghost since Vader couldn't kill him on the Death Star since he wasn't there

[@RipCityBassWorks]

Wait, how did Kenobi die without Vader on the death star?

[@guillermofernandez1047]

How did Obi Wan die in this timeline if Vader turned to the light earlier that means that he wasn't in the death star when Obi Wan, Luke, Han and Chewie arrived maybe some inquisitor killed him or he died of old age.

[@omega1845]

Wouldn’t abi-wan still be alive because Vader didn’t kill him on the death star?