Voice Teacher Reacts to BIG MAMA - Break Away, 하루만 더, Never Mind

[@zeusdad5484]

Ahhhh it’s killing me that you didn’t do the whole killing voice set. I understand it’s a long bit especially with your reactions, but all of the songs are just soooo good, and all of the voices so unique but so well blended, and the sheer joy and support for one another they exude singing together as the set progresses, is just so enjoyable and charming. Would really love to hear your assessment of their different voices and parts and how they blend and play off each other throughout. Please consider a take2 of the whole set! Thanks for what you do.

[@warrenpoultney8215]

I agree with you. As they go through the set, the textures are unique in each song. Their interaction with each other together as they go through, makes you just fall in love with them.

[@thehobojarpen]

I agree. As awesome as "Break Away" is, I was really looking forward to her reaction to "Woman" (the 3rd song in the Killing Voice medley) - which I think is a true highlight.

[@yuklimka7251]

With subtitles to understand the lyrics and the spoken interactions because they touch on their careers past retirement.

[@Smin414]

age From L - R Shin Yeon-ah (49) Lee Ji-young (43) Lee Young-hyun (41) Park Min-hye (40) In 2012, the group Big Mama was disbanded and each member is serving as a practical music professor at several universities. And fans of Big Mama, who made a comeback in 2021, liken Big Mama to idols and call them professors dols.🤓

[@jamesrawlins735]

Lee Younghyun doesn't teach anymore. She's active on various singing shows, and she gave birth not that long ago.

[@민차장-u8o]

그냥 표정만으로도 충분한 분석이 가능하십니다 ^^ 빅마마 많이사랑해주세요 ^^

[@elencaetano5158]

I need to see you reacting the whole video🙏🙏🙏🙏 they’re awesome

[@pengiepengie]

Their voices all matured a bit but I think they sound better now. The one on the left is the leader and she does the arrangements for their songs. All four of them are now professors at University teaching their experiences and are highly regarded for their high level technique. The song '여자' showcases their harmonies, the song at 16:24 '이별, 그 후' will let you hear what the one on the left can do.

[@Aesqie]

여자 is my absolute favourite Big Mama song, it's so perfectly arranged!

[@루루-u2h]

대단하네요~~넘 고맙고~💜 진짜 한국 에선 훌륭한 가수중에 최오들💙💙💙

[@ErgoDog]

I adore the one on the left. She is singing so effortlessly and pure.

[@jamesrawlins735]

That's Shin Yeonah, the oldest member (she was 49 when this was done). She actually created a Kpop girl group at her university, Azer, which debuted last year.

[@Megl_guhr2ou9v.l]

Wow Thanks for sharing the video. . I'm happy to finally be able to see Big Mama killing voice I've been wanting to hear~♡Big Mama made a comeback after 9 years. .😆

[@happyguy61]

What a fun reaction Beth! Really enjoyed their voices and harmonies and also loved the look of enjoyment on their faces. No need to apologise for being light on the technical aspects - the look of enjoyment on YOUR face said it all lol

[@vitorfreitasdecastro4921]

Great video! I was overwhelmed as well when i saw this for the first time, they are outstanding. If you could you really should react to the entire video they are soooo good and this performance its amazing. Wish you well

[@franciscojavierp.7162]

A thousand thanks for bringing these great artists to your channel, and another thousand for your comments and joy. It's a pity that this fantastic group is not as well known as other artists in the Korean scene, when, as far as I know, they were true pioneers in their country, who served as a base for all the great artists who are now in the spotlight. I said, thank you very much for your knowledge and smile that make us have a good time, which in the end is what we all seek on the internet, to have some fun, and if we also learn, it's a win win. Greetings from Spain

[@yuklimka7251]

The entire Killing Voice series is dope. Mamamoo, Ailee, Sohyang are just a few female groups/singers that are worth your attention.

[@gentlemen4070]

What an amazing vocal group! What an amazing vocal techniques! What an amazing vocal harmony! It is just so amazing and sensational. Always thank you so much for great reaction and analysis. Absolutely I agree with you. Have a nice day. 😊

[@naufalirfandi912]

I need full react, OMG!!

[@Far2hip]

Hey there Bethany!! I just saw a few of your reactions to Floor Jansen and want to encourage you to remember how much you enjoyed Ghost Love Score in the video that you reacted to, and then listen to her performance in the official version performed at the Wacken Festival in 2013 in Germany. In all seriousness, it is one of the most perfect vocal performances matched up the the instrumental aspects of the collective performance I have ever heard. I had to go through it dozens of times to try and pick something I would change to make it more perfect, I really tried to be as critical as possible, but there was nothing. Absolutely nothing could be improved to further perfect the performance of both Floors vocal, or the bands performance of each instrument. It is truly spectacular. Definitely worth a listen. 👍🏻😎👍🏻

[@younggichoi2760]

Your smile make me happy. Thank you!

[@mikuish3406]

One Day More was their most recent song at the time of the Killing Voice recording, but they actually released an album earlier this year called Born! I’d really recommend Like Nothing Happened (the title track of that album) and Starry Night. Each of the members have their own solo song on it as well :)

[@hesperides6292]

미소가 너무 아름답네요. 무슨 아나운서나 항공사 광고모델의 웃음같아요 . 치아 자체가 .. 보컬 선생님이 아닌 모델이나 배우같네요 . 웃음을 보이실때 그 치아와 함께 너무 아름답습니다.

[@warrenpoultney8215]

Asking us to choose which song from this? How could we? Each song is a master class in of itself lol

[@직관적이해]

Oh, you should check 'woman' and 'after the breakup' in the medley.

[@xenato]

ALL THE SET, PLEASE!

[@cks0909]

She's so beautiful, especially when she smiles

[@dynamicduo.studio]

The first woman, Yona Shin, is a jazz singer. ♥

[@카라멜보이]

우연히 알게된 채널... 당신의 미소가 너무 아름답네요. 제가 제일 좋아하는 엄청난 가수 빅마마입니다.

[@sebastianhernandez4176]

The side by side reaction sounds like a great idea!!

[@hongandy3683]

I love your reaction ^^

[@정군자-p2z]

감사합니다 새해복많이 받으세요

[@ErgoDog]

We need part 2!

[@g55dg55d]

요즘 핫한 크로스오버 남성그룹 포레스텔라도 있지만,원조는 역시 빅마마!!!

[@mediapropagandaxx]

Big Mama was a four-member vocal gg that debuted in 2003 under YG entertainment(2ne1 & Blackpink).

[@elencaetano5158]

Just to respond you… i prefer their mature voices, but they’re work with this for years, so, i think that they got more consistent

[@AJ-xb2pk]

빅마마❤️

[@rayanenoberto6879]

Pleaaaaase react more to Bigmama (빅마마) and to Lee Young Hyun (이영현) - the vocal monster with the writing on her pants. She is my favorite singer everrrr!! ♡♡♡

[@maygo9019]

Great reaction Bethany, Big Mama is amazing❤👐

[@vidthreenorth4007]

About vocal changes over time, it's a hard question because recording techniques and styles have also changed over time. Within KZbin, I checked back through their careers and I don't think their sound has changed that much. Their voices and singing styles have evolved a bit, but again, listening to it, sometimes I think I hear changes that come from microphones, or the taste of an individual producer or engineer, or the room. Overall, I think they seem to be generally a bit fuller voiced, but surprisingly little changed.

[@Scsibut]

Great reaction as always. Love big momma. I still hope you can do a reaction to David Phelps singing Whitney's I have nothing. I would love to see your reaction

[@또땅-j4b]

‘여자’[It’s unique](2006)은 꼭 들었어야 해요

[@meccakyo]

GOOOOOOOOD Reaction!!! 👍❤🧡💚

[@yullinsh]

와~! 정확하게 예측하시네요! 👍 😊

[@bettylmt196]

I'm with everyone else. Please react to the full killing voice! Love long reactions!

[@arahman7659]

Loved your reaction to Big mama!!! Their talents are off the charts! Please take this chance to do another killing voice reaction. It’s mamamoo killing voice medley. Mamamoo is a 4 member kpop girl band. Their vocals are renowned through the industry. Would love to see your reaction to their distinct vocals. I just know you’ll love them. Please please please react to them 😊

[@kdbang413]

I would love to see you watch The Staves - Winter Trees or Mexico. Amazing harmonies from these sisters. Their voices are beautiful🔥

[@elencaetano5158]

Please 🙏 try MAMAMOO killing voice medley, they so uniq too

[@elencaetano5158]

The whole video 🙏🎶😊

[@SY-by8yn]

Thanks for the reaction! ☺️ and Please react melomance killing voice! he is a good singer 🙏🏻🙏🏻

[@suhangundamtv1797]

Everyone want part2.😆

[@유스케스]

smile beautiful

[@marysantana2240]

You Must Watch MeloMance, Dingo Killeng Voice Is Simply Amazing

[@도키오키-f6e]

웃는 모습이 정말 아름다우세요 치약 광고 하셔도 될듯함

[@user-husuabi]

정말 미소가 아름다운 분이시네요.Your smile is the most beautiful smile I've ever seen.

[@erinmiddleton9522]

you need to react to the whole thing! :)

[@elencaetano5158]

You can do a long video, we like good explanations and dingo’s perfomance is always like a good medley apresetation from the artist… has to be done completely We are used to watching long videos

[@임베르토세비지]

Here is South Korea 🇰🇷 Good day 🎉❤

[@otk-company4695]

They are real university music professors. Today's class is this song practical test!!

[@misssagagemini]

Please react to the rest of the songs ! Especially woman and the solo!

[@Obbey]

Please, react to their Love Alone sing as well. It is a great music and harmony.

[@5concepts_]

bigmama❤

[@thehobojarpen]

Please react to "여자" / "Woman" which is the 3rd song in the medley, I believe. Thanks!

[@atomic2808]

Hello, i love your reaction

[@glauciacamargo5437]

aff I wanted to see the whole reaction! I won't leave my like just because of that

[@richardizzi758]

master vocal class is now in session.

[@kamai58]

미소가 예뻐서 영어듣기 평가하듯 계속 바라보고 듣기만(유튜버)하네요. 아! 물론 빅마마는 너무 많이 듣고있어서 유튜버만 봤어요. ^^

[@sushisin377]

Part 2 Big Mama

[@psstarpac]

Here’s a MV link for the first song right when it came out so it will answer your question. kzbin.info/www/bejne/r2HLdYSCepmeodE

[@johneyon5257]

if you want to do a side-by-side comparison - here is a video posted 15 years ago (and probably around the time it was actually filmed) - of their song "Nevermind" (the 4th song) - performed live in a radio studio - kzbin.info/www/bejne/j4vahXpun9qGnbs IMO - some 20 years later - there's a minor loss of power & breath control - but not enuf to affect the performance it's hard to hear a maturing of the musicality of korean singers - they don't improvise much - if the korean audience likes a melody line - they want to hear it done that way again - - as R&B type singers - these members were able to put more personal touches in their singing - but it was all there 20 years ago - as you'll notice if you check out the video i linked to the group's history is interesting - the head of their agency disliked the trend in kpop to manufacture boy & girl groups based first on looks & and lastly on talent (a good singer would be thrown in the mix as if an afterthought) - so he gathered these R&B soloists - older than average in the kpop industry - told them to never get plastic surgery - and produced a clever debut music video ("Breakaway" the first song in this video) - in it slender girls are seen performing - then towards the end - the camera moves into the back room - where the actual members sans makeup - are shown to be the actual singers Big Mama struggled for a few years - but acquired a reputation - and girl groups today will perform "breakaway" to show off their singing (no group has matched Big Mama however)

[@johneyon5257]

in 2011 - a promising R&B group called Bella debuted (kzbin.info/www/bejne/eaCln3SnbrWngrs) - but disbanded after putting out their second song - a very conventional kpop song - one of the members of that group debuted in Kiss and Cry (kzbin.info/www/bejne/Y3ebZoFqm5p1obM) but that lasted a few months - a 5 member group Spica (kzbin.info/www/bejne/rKTbgaKYnLCUeZo) managed to last about 5 years altho the members didn't seem to make any money (that happens a lot - only the extremely successful groups make the members rich - eg BTS and BlackPink)

[@Turmadasgemeas]

Can you react to Mamamoo killing voice too? They are amazing, you're going to love them!!! Please, please!

[@maeotis1]

you should see mamamoo too!!!

[@mrchang9651]

4분다 교수들입니다 대단하신 교수님들

[@yuyukwonha2109]

The first kpop that bring rnb genre

[@v3go366]

솔리드:🤔

[@tomsawyer2768]

Great reaction:-) of all the girl groups this has to be my favourite- So Much Soul -Yes sir eee! They all know there stuff! During their Hiatus from the group All 4 of them took Jobs as Music Professors in Korean University To Join another Korean Singer ,I know you Enjoy, and my Favourite all-time SoHyang:-) Can you imagine the crop of Musician’s and singers Korea is developing! Another good Koran group is Mamamoo, and you can bet they use to listen to some Big Mamma Here is their first hit m.youtube.com/watch? Mr. Ambiguous v=QwjWP2Tnsjk&vidve=5727&autoplay=1 Also SoHyang has been busy , check out her and Petra Written and Composed by SoHyang and Petra Back up vocals done by SoHyang and Petra. Freedom kzbin.info/www/bejne/a166gX5jedGNabs

[@tp-ej5gu]

2번 디지니 목소리 뽑혀갈듯

[@achmadfaisal772]

Please next do reaction ( MAMAMOO ) live performance killing voice version

[@Neniiyo]

처음 볼 땐 몰랐는 데 이 분 썬글래스 자국 많이 나셨네 ㅎㅎ

[@나무-l7q]

R~ Im KOREAN Thank you !!!

[@munhanglee3461]

당신이 더이❤뻐요😂

[@purple.bts_2013]

They all are professor in colleage^^

[@HK_K]

😍😍😍😍😍😍💕💕

[@glaubercandidopita]

React Just the Way You Are - Gabriel Henrique (Bruno Mars) Especial Dia dos Namorados [Valentine's Day]...

[@annwashington471]

They have been in the industry for years. They are incredible singers and should be more famous than they are. Unfortunately, in Korea because of their size they were bigger they weren't pushed. They didn't fit the beauty standard to be singers.

[@feralgrandad4429]

Nice, bit of a shame you wanted to hear Shin Yeon-ah more then you skipped past her best song (massive float ups etc) still I understand the time constraints. 😁

[@yoelmaspiola]

❤️🔥✌️

[@thiago_fiuza]

Thanks for the reaction, check out this video ( kzbin.info/www/bejne/n2KpfqKdir6Kn8k ), BIG MAMA - One more day. Whole song and 15 year old students listening to the dark. Hug!

[@jameskim1505]

I'd risk everything for Ji Young Lee

[@MrTBake95]

They are all music professors at universities

[@니선-b5n]

어두운 술집에서 위스키 한잔과 어울리는 첫곡

[@baekku5784]

Pls react to Taeyeon Killing Voice

[@굥사탕]

3명은 교수고 한명은 현역 가수...오랜만에 만 나 합을 마춘게....현역 가수가 누군지 마춰보셔요..

[@starcraft_official]

Bright song, and teeth

[@권준수-q1x]

습관적 ..방문자가 되내요.. ㅋ 같은영상도 여러번 보내요 리액션 미소가 그리워서...2-3일이면 그리울 시간도 아닌데....

[@soojin9408]

OMG. .

[@tp-ej5gu]

허스키 오랜만에 듣네 ~ 여자음악 교수라~ 끝네준다 허스키~

[@777maruhan7]

귀엽다 ㅋㅋ

[@elaijahpascual8731]

Can you react to MAMAMOO KILLING VOICE too? They are like the babies of Big Mama 😂 I know you will like them. Its a small request from a newbie subscriber. I will appreciate it if you do react to them. Thank you. 😊💕

[@미일정벌]

아침 첫 스케줄, 원테이크로 한번에 찍은 영상..

[@김영원-w3q]

They are all professors.

[@rkurniawan4432]

next please check out Vanny Vabiola from indonesia, she just released a new cover of adele's easy on me.. also covers of whitney & celine.. 🙏

[@diamondneill6043]

Please react to cimorelli they are 5 sisters that all sing and harmonize and they have been on KZbin for 10 years

[@edinag3239]

lol why didnt you react to the full video

[@확그냥-t5y]

박찬호 다..고막을 포기한다

[@kimtony5202]

recommand another female Kpop vocal group ... "Mamamoo".

[@ghgrrghj]

Please react to highlight killingvoice too 🙏

[@pamungkazkyukyu5686]

Pleace reac again from lndonesia, Denden Gonzales "She's Gone" cover Thank's.......