The Walking Dead Quarry Camp: Shane's Warning!

[@harryince4233]

Shane beat up Ed because Ed has what Shane wanted, a family. But Ed abused his family which Shane didn’t understand because Shane would’ve given anything to have Lori and Carl.

[@potatopeeler2919]

Well said. I just wish Twd show explained things a little more like they do in the comics.

[@Nacho_Boi420]

Ig twd figures that we would put the clues together . But not everyone can decode what they put down .

[@RachaelLynn4711]

That could possibly be it, however though I’ve also been with hotheaded men like Shane. To me I took that scene as Shane channeling all his anger and frustration (especially with Lori telling Shane they were off limits to him) out on Ed. Sure Ed was a shitbag and had it coming to him, but Shane just went to town on Ed because he was beyond mad, frustrated and hurt and Ed got the receiving end of it.

[@zv623]

@@RachaelLynn4711 Ed deserved it the whole reason Carol kept her hair very short at first was so that Ed couldn't grab her by the hair and beat her

[@SamanthaBoooooooo]

@@zv623 Season 9 (I think) Henry tells Daryl how Carol's first husband used to grab her hair and slam her into the wall. He goes on to say it took her many years to feel safe enough to grow it back. I take it as a sign of inner strength Carol kept her long hair after Henry's death and splitting from Ezekiel.

[@mystify7478]

Totally agree that Shane was right for kicking Ed's ass!!

[@randybarnett2308]

@kieron spiteri I agree too, but what if instead of Shane, Abraham was the one who beat up Ed!!!(if Abe was in the camp that is) 👍💪😃😃

[@JennyKenobi09]

The group were wrong to view Shane as bad for that. I cheered when he beat that piece of crap of a character .

[@nickjoseph9991]

@@randybarnett2308 lmao Abraham would wreck ed

[@randybarnett2308]

@@nickjoseph9991 poor ed😂😂😂

[@ryanthereaper5032]

@@JennyKenobi09 not everyone hated it just a few nutjobs

[@Reinnemann2]

Remember too that part of the reason for Rick and Daryl's brotherhood is the fact that Rick was the first one to jump in and try to save Merle. I really don't think a lot of people would have been saved if not for Rick and Daryl's bond and this was the start of Daryl seeing the kind of man/leader Rick truly was.

[@TWDExplained]

agree - good point

[@littlejezzey2515]

It was pretty clear y rick went back was for the guns I mean hell every one except Darryl was 100% sure Merrill was already served on a all u could eat special hillbily buffet

[@lanabrown2541]

So true

[@Nurse_Shelly44]

I do think Shane did the right thing handling Ed. Not only did he stick up for Carol, and let it be known that abuse wouldn't be tolerated, but having that sort of dysfunction is bad for the group and had to be addressed.

[@MomoTheDisciple]

Is it even in question that Shane was wrong for doing that? That beating was deserved. In season 5 when a guy hit his wife Rick insisted the guy needed to be executed… what Shane did was tame.

[@NinjaNuggets21]

Leadership wise, Shane ran on instinct and Rick relied on his intuition. Two styles that could work separately but to coexist requires so much communication and commitment.

[@edwinbetancourt3958]

And Shane was NOT going to be on pure communication with Rick...he was desperate for his wife and kid.

[@zeezmusic7245]

Isn’t instinct and intuition almost the same thing ?

[@codieomeallain6635]

@@zeezmusic7245 kind of but not really. Instinct is more primal, it’s the first thing you think of and you just do it. Intuition is more what you think is best. It’s a subtle distinction.

[@Raelyski]

I liked Shane i hated him dying honestly. He was a realistic leader to me. I know some may not agree but majority of the group didn’t like him because he was “harsh” but harsh people like him are needed as well as people like rick . It needs to be an even balance.

[@nenelindsey9725]

Shane was misunderstood ! When he beat the shit out of Ed I knew he had a good heart he was just unstable mentally and that lead to his Demise .

[@treygibbs2476]

I don’t get how Shane was an asshole and harsh but merl and darryl weren’t . Like that shit just blows me 🤦🏿‍♂️

[@jojohoney4981]

Nene Lindsey anyone would be unstable in a damn apocalypse tbh 😭 he was so confused in life he thought his best friend died then developed a relationship with his friend’s wife just for his friend to pop up like “hey I’m not dead “

[@chicagochicana8092]

Shane would’ve really had the governor and regan shook. He wasn’t no punk or coward💯he was exactly what the group needed but they refused to have a realist like him . They wanted someone who could give them hope even if it was false instead of someone who would keep it 💯 with them ...

[@conceptice4607]

Shane and Rick couldn’t have coexisted - I agree that Shane was a good solider and a good gun but it doesn’t matter. Bottom line is that they couldn’t have both led, and Rick was better for the job in my opinion. Shane was too hot heated and would’ve gotten them screwed down the line probably. Rick has the perfect mix to be a good leader - he keeps a cool head but when he needs to take care of business he will go to any lengths.

[@DD-ok2pt]

WAIT A MINUTE...I just realised something... Rick was NOT unattended for 60 days in the hospital. When he comes out there is a "freshly" killed medical person on the floor who had not yet reanimated. Remember, the military was already in the hospital killing patients and staff that is why Shane ran away and left Rick. There was also a helicopter at the hospital with the 3 circle CRM symbol. --- WHAT IF THE CRM WERE ALREADY THERE IN EPISODE ONE??? --- WHAT IF THE CRM HAD ALREADY EXPERIMENTED ON RICK AT THE HOSPITAL IN THE FIRST EPISODE??? --- WHAT IF THE CRM FOUND THE "CURE" AT THE BEGINNING WITH RICK??? --- WHAT IF ALL THE SCIENTISTS WERE KILLED BEFORE RICK WOKE UP AND ESCAPED??? --- WHAT IF THE CRM NEVER KNEW THAT THEIR EXPERIMENT WITH RICK WORKED??? Look at the hospital scene again... especially the lined up bodies outside... and the locked up Walkers. --- WHY DID THEY KEEP THE WALKERS LOCKED UP WHEN THEY COULD HAVE EASILY KILLED THEM??? THE CRM WERE EXPERIMENTING ON A's and B's IN EPISODE ONE!!!!!!! A's - Freshly bitten -"Don't Open Dead Inside" B's - Not bitten but carrying the virus - Rick Think about it Rick, is in the SAME physical condition when the CRM took him away on the helicopter as he was in season one episode one --- near death and unconscious. Both time Rick was categorised as a "B" What ever happened in this hospital is what we will see in the Rick Grimes movies but on an industrial scale. Also, in the last episodes with Rick there is a Wizard of Oz theme woven throughout. Like Dorothy, could Rick have had the power to return the world back to normal all along???

[@johncap5130]

Great Theory, Shane is suppose to be in the movie's so maybe he is there visiting him at the hospital when they do experiment's on him. But the helicopter didn't have three ring circle's it was three swords though, maybe the symbol changed as things went on. Remember season 2 those guys in the bar told Rick bout Nebraska being nice and they laughed and they also said they lived in Philly before everything. As for Shane maybe he hear's something at the hospital as to why he wanted to go to Fort Benning but he ended up agreeing with Rick because he knew they were doing bad thing's down their. Also those guys do say Nebraska was nice and they were from Philly. It stuck with me all this time because I live in Philly and I was a huge Shane fan so I pretty much am a wiz in knowledge in first two season's compared to the rest of the series. Anyway I remember those guys saying Philly was a bit worse then everywhere else and they came down there. Their group had about 90 people in it which we never saw but only heard about. We saw in Fear the Walking Dead and the in the first the season of the walking dead operation Cobalt when the chopper's dropped the bomb's on all the major cities after things went bad Well I believe cities were over ran because when they bombed the cities and everyone died by the bomb's they all came back as walker's. So maybe many of the higher members of the government took their families and other rich powerful people went to Nebraska since that state population isn't as big as state's with major city's they created a huge safe zone for themselves. Now as the rest of the country fell apart and little communities formed around the world but the CRM sent out their military member's in chopper's to find A's and B's to recruit and experiment on. Now maybe in Philadelphia Cobalt was a success. Maybe Philly had more survivor's compared to other places so they saved the entire city. Meanwhile everywhere else communication was down and everyone believed pretty much everywhere most people died. So in Philly the CRM could have made many of the lower end survivor's their slave's or they put them in their military. So those two guys might been forced to be put in Randall's group and had to go out throughout the country and recruit people and also find people for them to experiment on. Randal also said to Shane almost the same thing Jadish said to Father Gabriel about loving were we are going. Randall told Shane will love the group and she told Father G they could have a beautiful life together. Now we are pretty much ten plus year's into all of this and the CRM stayed hidden from everyone for the most part. Only Jadish knew of them. We have seen many group's throughout the years from Savior's, Woodbury, Terminus, the Wolf's, Alexandria, Hilltop, Oceanside, Kingdom and the Whisper's etc. Now the savior's were a massive group and they didn't even know about them. So as the show goes on and crossover's are planned I think the CRM should still stay hidden or be a rumor to everyone else. But the CRM are aware of everyone else around the world including the Commonwealth. Also Randall told Darryl they did some very bad things to weaker group's including rape.

[@hartofnixie7060]

Great Theory

[@TWDExplained]

I didn't see a 3 circle chopper in S1 - a webisode showed who wrote that on the doors - I almost started a video on the theory "What If - CRM planted Rick or started from S1" ....but there were so many holes in it I stopped before it was started. Interesting though.

[@DD-ok2pt]

@@TWDExplained My bad it is another insignia but this is when we first see military and helicopters. Maybe they hadn't become CRM yet. But they were there awhile before Rick woke up. Previously, I thought Rick was abandoned when Shane left but clearly proto- CRM had been there. Also they went to great pains to link that hospital scene with helicopters and all to the first episode. Has to mean something...

[@TWDExplained]

I hear you...I was really thinking it up for a video - and it would make a great What If - but the actual clues all end up straw grasps in the end I think. But the 3 circle stamp on the can's Jadis had at the junkyard points to an operation that got up and going almost immediately which leads one to start thinking were they there before the outbreak also?

[@itspricila]

shane was a hot head but most of the time he did have good points

[@TWDUniverse]

He was about 4 or 5 seasons ahead of his time with how he viewed the world and what it takes to survive.

[@T-REX88420]

I still miss shane tho just imagine him in the war against Negan

[@asemg3598]

Imagine what the walking dead would be like with Shane and dale and Hershel

[@LocalKeegs]

@@asemg3598 well hershel’s actor died 3 years ago in November on I think the 10-18th so we wouldn’t have hershel for to long anyways

[@littlejezzey2515]

Shane was 100% a realized and had the ball to weigh out every desicion just like Rick but the difference Shane was willing to do whatever he thought needed to be done no matter what no second guessing or overthinking a problem for days just get it done and live with outcome

[@usasupersoccer]

They should make a Spin-off with Shane showing how he saved Rick's family and as the Quarry Camp was formed.

[@jeandowney4115]

Shane was young and wild,he was good until he was bad.a true friend should never back stap his friend. Nothing good will ever come of it.

[@bfac6460]

Shane usually did the right thing. However, the way he did it was wrong as he was too hot headed and alpha. If he carried out his actions a lot more calmly people would’ve seen reason to them.

[@z.incognito6259]

Daryl is what shane should’ve been. He had his own opinions about how certain things should be handled and rick would listen to him most of the times but its only because Daryl also doesnt belittle rick’s ideas and respects his position as leader

[@eyesonly1638]

Rick acted like Shane later but the two very important differences Rick cared about most of the people he ran across Shane only cared about Lori and Carl and with going to sacrifice all the people that went to the city for supplies

[@Angel_Phoenix94]

Shane's jealousy killed him, if he had not become jealous he would still be alive

[@lesliehardeman6212]

i never liked shane but hell yes, ed earned that beating...

[@ihadadogtwice27ordidi65]

Shane was ahead of the curve thats why hes hated look later on rick does things shane did early on

[@yigita3190]

@@ihadadogtwice27ordidi65 He was great, however he lacked to ability to connect with people and persuade them. For instance when he found the barn he went all crazy, a good leader would talk with hershel, explain there won't be any cure, that cdc is fallen and execute the walkers afterwards, the "Lori and Carl is mine" shit was quite bad as well.

[@ihadadogtwice27ordidi65]

@@yigita3190 yeah your not wrong there done people are obsessive

[@yigita3190]

@@ihadadogtwice27ordidi65 Also, he forced himself on Lori which is never a good thing.

[@ihadadogtwice27ordidi65]

That is true remember rick when he first gets to Alexandria he was gonna shoot pete in the back so he could be with his wife

[@RobbyByrne]

There was enough people in the camp for Shane to instruct one to be a lookout. Instead everyone is enjoying their fish dinner. That's on Shane.

[@jamesbandz1]

Exactly, Knowing that a walker gotten into the camp they should've done more to prevent this. There easily could've been a buddy system so no one is alone (easily prevented Amy's Death). Ed was gonna die regardless since he was the one furthest out. Everyone was fairly disorganized during the fight and it led to more death then it should've been. 100000% Shane's fault on this.

[@marcfield1234]

"Officer friendly died a long time ago."

[@DBTGAMER]

The quarry camp was pretty much doomed to fail it was to the City. Eventually they would have to make more runs into the city for supplies. Another thing at this point the group used guns more which attracted more walkers. 🤔

[@sydnitheromantictaylor112]

It was also doomed because when winter would've came blankets in a tent and a campfire wasn't going to be enough to keep warm.

[@edwinbetancourt3958]

@@sydnitheromantictaylor112 it may have been ok given they in Georgia. It doesn't get THAT cold really.

[@ablemagawitch]

@@sydnitheromantictaylor112 Southern winters especially in Georgia rarely get snow. If they went up two states to North Carolina they might have a 2-6 inches at the worst "blizzard of the year"(see the news media weekly coverage freaks outs for evidence) with maybe 3 less than inch to 2-3 inches snowing times with sleet more common. So Blankets and 3 season tent was doable with the rain fly on it. Homeless don't need shelters except for freak cold spells and even then there isn't a lot of frozen homeless death.... Although at that point(after several months) they would have absconded with motor homes or moved into mobile homes if not houses. As it would be obvious they are safer and more secure. Retreating mountain-ward in the southern states to the vacation and resort cabins would be easily survivable and even more remote. With strong white water rivers to provide fresh drinking water and anti zombie barriers for not freezing and strong currents sweeping zombies down river and through body breaking rapids towards the ocean. Zombies makes it out of the water with enough flesh intact to still function, then manages to walk the right direction and meets the same river hazard again.... Repeat cycle. Anyone would figure out bridges needed barriers pretty quickly. Bonus fresh game for food until gardens and farming was established.

[@mikeecko]

Bottom line is if Shane lived and he was the star of the show then the show would be totally different right now I think. I heard when they were casting the pilot of this show , John barenthal was going to be Rick Grimes originally

[@nuttydishwasher5377]

He probably would have thrown the rest of the group under the bus if it would have kept him, Lori and Carl safe. he was a selfish but also realistic character.

[@peacelove280]

If Rick hadn't gone to the CDC, Rick would not have known they all had the virus in them; Rick proved over and over again he was a true leader and he had self-control and integrity very valuable character traits!!!

[@starstuff5371]

Yeah when Frank Darrabont was show runner

[@Yionbot]

That’s called plot armor 🤣🤣🤣 but yeah that was a good call by Rick. But what if it happened panned out, then what? Shane would have been calling 100% of the shots after that.

[@bbybo]

That was just blind luck. Shane was thinking with his brains and not with his emotions except when it came to Lori and surprisingly (not really) it killed him. Rick just had great plot armor throughout the show,thats why he outlived many.

[@Hunter-pp5yt]

Well it's interesting to note that if they had gone to Ft. Benning like Shane wanted they would have found that overrun like Dave told Rick in the bar.. so that would have been a poor call on Shane's part. And they would have learned nothing. Although, they would have found out that everyone turns somehow sooner or later one way or another.. most likely a failed amputation like in the comics.

[@Hunter-pp5yt]

That's what's kinda dumb about the leaders trying to keep tallies against each others calls in the beginning like that because it's not like either one of them could have possibly known... they were just going with their gut and what they each thought was best. Both went bad in the long run...

[@Nurse_Shelly44]

I wish Jim had a minute or two of backstory since he mentioned the dream he had. It was as if the writers were hinting at mysticism(?) Which has no place in the TWD universe, but definitely peaked my interest. If it wasn't going to be expanded upon, I wish it wasn't mentioned at all.

[@dixieboyzxxx2175]

First time I watched it I thought Jim would live because they make him seem important

[@stitchez420]

I miss jim I miss jim so bad

[@geomara]

@@yuhvera it was also that the original director was fired and his ideas for Twd left with him.

[@codieomeallain6635]

A Chekhov’s Gun guy then?

[@duolingo7622]

6:46 could Amy be alive? Me: Yeah if she hadn’t got up to the bathroom and complain there was no toilet paper

[@emilianogalvez8814]

Yeah , sadly if they stayed in the camp , Amy would of died anyways cause they got her by surprise

[@angermacfadden2702]

Shane's character was treated a Bellona lot better than the comics that's for sure.

[@neilwilliams2883]

It's funny how soft Rick's voice was in these early seasons, especially season 1. From season 3 onwards, he growls. It also seems like Andrew Lincoln got better at the accent later on.

[@anthony68]

I miss Shane man,he made those early seasons great,gutted he died he’s my second favourite character after Rick hopefully he will be in the Rick movies

[@angiescott9692]

I miss Shane, and Carl So very much

[@devincarter9930]

Yes Carl and Shane they were the same

[@iluvforhonorwarmonger2000]

And Glen.........

[@bomat761]

Merle was an idiot for sawing thru his arm instead of the threaded rod, for sure. Nuff said!

[@thomasallison4858]

Yeah! And even if he couldn’t take off the rod, he could have just got off so much as just his pinky in order to get out

[@TWDFAN-ot5zp]

But Merle’s character grew so much from the choices he made, I love rewatching the episodes on Netflix 🥰😍

[@SomeLad12]

Pretty sure the saw was too blunt to cut anything else other than his hand

[@symeremeyers4148]

and if that didn't work he could've just sawed his thumb

[@trump-totalwar6509]

he didn't have time to cut the rod because walkers were coming.

[@Fullcontactreacts]

Don't forget Shane was gonna leave the Atlanta group stranded. It was Ricks plan that got everyone out alive.

[@TWDUniverse]

Shane was before his time with his view of what it takes to survive this new world.

[@edwinr.vasquezjr.991]

Liked this. I'm rewatching the series again. I'm on the beginning of season 3..

[@TWDExplained]

Ahhh the first few seasons....thanks for watching and the comment!

[@jackmarshall3255]

I'm at season 4 after the prison and the death of the governor

[@userjlj]

@@jackmarshall3255 where can you find the series.. wanna rewatch it too..

[@jackmarshall3255]

@@userjlj oh I watch it up on a website not many people know of called myflixer it has some problems to it like it goes on to different tabs when I click on things and it loads a bit but it free so I will take it I think you can look it up and find it and it has some problems too it just want to point that out oh and fear the walking dead is good to if you want to watch that too.

[@Confederate-hj2dc]

Shane’s a hell of a better character than most of the future cast of TWD. Hell, most of the character introduced in seasons 5-8 never lived up to the expectations set by the season 1-4 characters. Except Negan, Ezekiel, and arguably Dwight. Characters did get better once they got rid of Scott Gimple when season 9 came out.

[@inlovewithaghostgirl5940]

I would put Eugene and Abraham on there too

[@gavincambridge9952]

@@inlovewithaghostgirl5940 idk about Eugene but Abraham was great.

[@apod5325]

Simon is also an interesting character imo

[@1o1beauty]

When Shane lined up Rick in the woods with the shotgun and Dale saw him... Bad bad guy

[@TWDExplained]

Yep - busted

[@midnight-fox7456]

Season one is so frickin small when compared to later seasons. It only has six episodes :0

[@apod5325]

Wait, really?!

[@midnight-fox7456]

@@apod5325 yep. It ends after the arc in the research station. Which was ep 6

[@apod5325]

@@midnight-fox7456 daamn

[@weskerkings651]

But it is better than the other seasons except 2

[@Austin-sw3mf]

One of my friends said Rick was in the wrong for going back for the bag and that fewer people would have died with them present. Imo, they would have been boned when the zombies attacked without those guns. At that point in time, just fighting one zombie in melee combat was tough for them, basically a miniboss fight.

[@BroTF4591]

Let’s be honest we all miss Shane 😔

[@TWDUniverse]

I do

[@lesliehardeman6212]

shanes body is what i miss...lol

[@Skelstoolbox]

@@lesliehardeman6212 I'm sure Lori agreed on that part too.. Probably Judith is Shane's daughter most likely.. Maybe anyway..

[@lesliehardeman6212]

@@Skelstoolbox way I see it, Lil Ass Kicker has the same hair color as Rick, so she's Rick's daughter. As for Laurie never did like her. No matter what is going on, you don't have sex with your husbands BESTFRIEND, even if your husband IS dead, wait at least 2 to 4 years out of respect if you do.

[@lesliehardeman6212]

Nah, great bod, scary face. I ain't missing him at all.

[@tomcat9727]

8:29 This is the momment when Shane started going crazy, love that :) This reminds me, Lori was such an ungratefull bitch. Shane actually fall in love with her, saved her and Carl's life multiple times and she threated him like that?

[@BuddyRitt]

Then she got pissed at Rick for killing Shane. Lori was such a shit character

[@masterbaiters1183]

Just rewatching the first season every once in a while is so refreshing after getting sucked into the later seasons.. while some of the other early seasons are technically better the first season works so well because it’s short and digestible

[@TWDExplained]

S1 rocks!

[@RustCole01]

Shane was a great badass. "The world needs bad men. We keep the other bad men from the door".

[@alexanderduverne3416]

One thing that they never talk about is that Rick made the decision to run back to camp instead of finding an other car to drive back, which would have saved them some time. And they would have made it back sooner. I think that was a mistake on his part.

[@matteoclementi]

As I said in a previous video, I love so much these type of content, maybe is just nostalgia. As always keep up the great work!

[@TWDExplained]

More to come! And thanks for watching and the comments!

[@joelara1652]

Ed definitely deserved it, however I want to add it was in the right place at the right time and Shane wanted an outlet and there it was. He can look like the good guy while doing it.

[@coltonpatterson7632]

I loved shane because he knew how to survive and if he didnt go crazy then he wouldn't have died as soon,maybe the govener would have killed or he got to negans line up then died or lived when Rick blew the bridge

[@Evenhand]

With no actual law or courts, Shane was in law enforcement (they don't go for that type of abuse). In a normal everyday scenario... Also he exacted as close to justice as you could get in this world

[@Evenhand]

He didn't kill him not directly anyways

[@skylordjojo8454]

Am I considered a bad person when I cheered when Ed got eaten by a walker

[@beezzus86]

Shane beating Ed was just his way of venting frustration... At that point, he was starting to realize everything he had was falling apart right in front of his very own eyes and the source of the problem was Rick. He was struggling maintaining that leadership role with Rick around, he immediately lost the 2 most important people to him that he considered his family. I feel like Shane was a pretty misunderstood guy the more I think about it, like was he really a villain like people say? All of the bad things he did, it was for a justifiable reasons. All I’m saying is, if I led a group from point A to point B, while doing so found a couple people I really care about giving me a reason to keep pushing on then out of nowhere, some guy rises from the dead and makes me feel dismissed as everyone adheres to him over me? After I put my life on the line repeatedly for those same people? I’d be pissed too lol.

[@cristiancontreras4001]

0:17 I was in the dark when I heard this.😓

[@honeybadger4244]

I know Im late.... But... "You told me my husband was dead you...SOB....Stay the...F... Away from me...and he was just pissed off anyway..... Kicking Eds ass..... " I laughed.

[@ronnieweatherly7222]

That scene where the camera goes from Jim to Carol the dude in the back in the purple shirt was in Wood berry in season 3.

[@rickershomesteadahobbyfarm3291]

He should have given Ed another kick right into the water.

[@GrumpyGenXGramps]

LMAO!! I said the same thing about Merle! All thread is MADE TO BE CUT WITH A HACKSAW! The point of all thread is to cut the length you need. Not to mention it bends like hell! Pulling it in the middle woulda bent it like a “V”! LOL

[@aminri367]

After season 2 after he killed Shane, Rick becames cold cause of shane but I don’t know he becames to that because Shane told Rick he can’t be the good guy anymore or Rick realized that getting cold is the solution to survive

[@FirstnameLastname-ni9uh]

I love that in season one Therese all these cool older vehicles In The camp like the Suzuki Samurai and the jeep that Carol had.

[@rubahall5596]

You always have great videos, James! I love how how much detail you put into them and all the different explanations!

[@TWDExplained]

I appreciate that! Thanks so much for the views and the comment Ruba and James Hall!

[@JohnMarston290]

Imagine shane vs negan

[@stephenmagill2937]

Imagine Rick/Shane vs Negan?

[@thegovernor1406]

@@stephenmagill2937 7 months ago but still if Rick can easily kill Negan in a 1v1 Shane can too. Shane vs The Governor would be better since he almost killed Rick in a 1v1 if it wasnt for Michonne. Even Michonne almost got killed one of the best fighters in the show but almost got killed by The Governor if it wasnt for a glass

[@frankballard3378]

James thanks for all of your videos. I’m also in Nashville. Your videos are such a great distraction to the real life craziness out here.

[@TWDExplained]

Awesome! Thank you! - Nash rallied after the flood and have stood together on so many things but find it hard to stay 6ft apart haha

[@dalewhite3914]

Shane was awesome I miss him. And hell yes ED got what he deserved

[@shiftee7treez631]

He played the Punisher perfect, best one i think

[@alexpayne5914]

Shane was totally wrong coming at Rick after the camp got eaten. Let's say they left Merle: 1. Ed and Amy are dead anyway. Rick, T-Dogg, and Glenn would have been just part of the oblivious yakkity-yak around the fire just like all the rest. Nobody even knew there was an attack until Amy was getting chewed up. That wouldn't change. 2. No guns. Rick doesn't go back for the bag, you have 3 more people fighting a mini-herd with sticks and stones. Wouldn't have helped much. And 3. It's not just the dead. Daryl's going back for his brother regardless, after finding nothing but a hand you think he's returning for hugs and handshakes? Nope, the survivors would have been getting shot at as well as being eaten. Can't come down on Shane for the day before, but he knew ALL these things when he was chastising Rick the morning after.

[@TWDExplained]

All good points!

[@ronnieweatherly7222]

I like this Dude talking.He goes into a lot of details on what he is Talking about.

[@peterwong8028]

In an alternate universe Shane would've been Negans right hand man at the sanctuary

[@TWDExplained]

Many people think so but I do not think Shane would settle for "right hand man" to anyone. (unless it was legal old school military or police)

[@jason_martin_uk]

Another great video!

[@TWDExplained]

Thanks Jason!

[@owenscull2531]

Rick gets people kill pretty much all through the walking dead, his bad leader. First thing you should do is building defenses to defend your group walls/ trenches/ spikes in ground and set traps. Next step food and water. The group look like they had some weapons, make this bigger by make bow and arrows/ spears (this would also help with hunting). Craft armour to protect people getting bitten. Setup a 3 in a team group for scout out supplies (food, medicine, weapons, police body armour/ sport armour/biker leathers etc). Look for more people to join you, the more people you have, the more people you have to help defend/ scout/ build/ farming etc. You would slowly build small town through this.

[@Jyoelmejor]

Yes, that is the beauty about Shane..You can relate to him..This is why it was so good starting off..Not black and white..It was a real decision that us as the viewers had to decide since Shane had things under control until Rick showed up..I love Rick and Shane so this was easily the best part of the first and second season..

[@nuttydishwasher5377]

Indeed, and I am quite sure that if he hadn't fallen in love with Lori he would still be around. The love triangle poisoned his friendship with Rick, and Lori handled things poorly afterwards.

[@hartofnixie7060]

Thanks for commenting about Merle and a better way to remove the handcuffs. The stupidity of Merle cutting off his wrist when he could cut off the connecting metal piece has always driven my husband bonkers.

[@TWDExplained]

Maybe the blade was really really dull and could not cut that either - but I would try breaking my thumb or removing just the pinky maybe to get my hand out??

[@hartofnixie7060]

@@TWDExplained Definitely

[@johncap5130]

@@TWDExplained Even in a close call so crazy out your mind not a second to think clearly type situation you are 1000 percent correct, if you had to cut yourself to escape, it would been a lot faster and whole lot less painful to cut a thumb or a pinky instead of the entire hand( your WRIST at that). Great video's as always. You are def by far the best fan walking channel host with your report's of rumor's, fact's, theory's and prediction's. Especially prediction's part! Some host's say something then totally contradict their comment with the next sentence or give every possible scenario then three video's say as i said in a prior video this or that would or could happen. Yea not to mention the 6 other type of situation's in that video they no longer talk about. I won't bash anyone publicly because I know you guys put much effort in these video's but this one says the writer's can do this because and then at the end of the statement he say's but the writer's may very well do and he say's the same thing he just said they wouldn't do just using different words and terminology!! Anyway great job brother. Shane's my favorite character of all the dead one's and I still rank him with Darryl, Rick and Negan.

[@petergilfillan8340]

I wished they'd kept the Shane Character alive for the rest of the series. Would have made for some great Story lines. Yes Shane was justisfied to beat Eds arse.

[@aaroneudell4388]

I just rewatched season 1 with my GF who never saw it. I realised..... Shane was right. You only realise how right if you have already watched Rick's full journey.

[@MaxmadV8]

10:20 yes that all thread or whatever it's called is good. I have some that isn't rusted up.the way I cut it is with my hacksaw. And you can cut with a bluntish hacksaw. But it risks snapping the blade

[@TWDExplained]

It's hard to say what I would do - especially if the walkers were coming through the door about to be on me.

[@MaxmadV8]

@@TWDExplained when panic sets in and you are dehydrated with a numb hand. Feeling like an animal in a trap. I could see how someone could do that I guess

[@edmorris2466]

Miss shane. He was amazing. So much better if he and andrea left and we followed their story seperately from the main story. Loved this video

[@TWDExplained]

Thanks as always!

[@yuvyork6915]

I love the Shane videos keep it up

[@johncap5130]

I agree

[@TWDExplained]

Thanks and thanks for watching!

[@shakeworldwide2031]

🎵🎶 In heaven, there is no beer. That’s why, we drink it here 🎶🎵

[@erol9259]

Shane is still the best.

[@sussynomad8282]

I love twd bc it's just the cruel reality that eventually everyone dies sometimes painfuly and slowly or sometimes fast and easy and people go crazy kids die.. It's real not that fake stuff like " oh she got shot 7 times but she's alive somehow" no it's real it's sad ya but still

[@twistedfoot6808]

They should’ve died peacefully in the CDC. Almost everyone including the children died in lonely, gruesome, horrifying deaths.

[@sussynomad8282]

@@twistedfoot6808 yeah, true not everyone had to die a brutal death

[@mike7652]

People can survive being shot seven times. Not in the face or vitals obviously, but by no means is that example fake.

[@Nightwalker-zk6ce]

Omg, I don’t know anything about construction or building materials but I always wondered why Merle didn’t just try to cut whatever the handcuffs were hooked to!

[@marcfield1234]

Kicking Ed's ass was the only decent thing that Shane did as far as I'm concerned.

[@johnryder1713]

One thing hadn't happened was any of the living had threatened anyone yet, so putting up signs to an undefended refugee camp would've been a bad idea if they had

[@TWDExplained]

yeah, they had not learned that lesson yet

[@bryanhaynes2002]

Dang ole Glenn and that car alarm rallying them monsters out from the city. Amy was damn cute btw!

[@keeganliveslife7399]

I say Merle didn’t think about cutting that metal because of the sun exposure he wasn’t in his right mind

[@woodstv4808]

Love the vids keep at it bro

[@TWDExplained]

Appreciate it, thanks for watching!

[@shawns1694]

he brought up lori saying that it was a bad idea but she volunteered him

[@tinapatterson9234]

I've always had a problem with the early timeline. A person can go only 3 days without water and 30 days without food. But Rick had been in a coma for over 50 days?!? Even taking liquids out of the equation, he certainly didn't look like he had starved for over 50 days. Not only that, but the wound on his side from the gunshot still had not healed by the time he met Morgan, nor was it grossly infected. I'd have thought that it would have either healed or festered during the time that had gone by.

[@TWDExplained]

You speak truth - but it's just production flaws. They did put out the webisode The Oath - which tried to show a nurse that stayed and took care of patients.

[@tinapatterson9234]

@@TWDExplained I didn't see that webisode, but if that was the case, it sure was nice of her/him to keep replacing that gurney that Shane put against the door as he left Rick there.

[@IsaacJM9900]

I think shane beat up ed because after rick showed up Lori basically left him for dead and he became increasingly angry so he let it out on him to blow off steam

[@guinnessruffing7589]

I thought long and hard about this and if Shane led the group. Amy would still be dead since by the time they saw the zombies she was already bit. Since Rick wasn’t there to make Shane mad he would’ve told Ed to back off instead of hit him so Ed would be at the fire with the others and would survive. They would then make their way to Fort Benning, but on the way their Merle and Daryl would steal their supplies so they would have to hurry their way their. Along with that we Fort Benning falls early in the outbreak since a character in season 4 who was in the governor’s group said it was close to being overrun so he abandoned his post meaning some characters like Shane, Ed, & Tdog probably wouldn’t survive. They then join the group the the Governor would’ve taken over but now Woodbury is still standing so he won’t. I think they’d end up meeting Terra who ran off after her undead grandpa killed her family.

[@guinnessruffing7589]

I meant Dale, Ed, and Tdog

[@whitephillip6997]

I just thought it was a rat move for Rick to instantly take command right after showing up... acting like Shane had no right to question him even...

[@jeffpraterJSF]

It’s Shane’s fault. Rick was Shane’s superior before, the second he showed up Shane fell in line and everyone noticed. Rick became the leader by the next morning. But only because of the situation. Rick challenged Shane by saying “I’m gonna take 5 of your guys and rescue Merle.” And Shane can’t stop him, Ricks the leader. If nobody wanted to follow Rick and Shane got his way with everyone staying at camp, Rick never would have became the leader.

[@Daggar97]

If Rick had died in the hospital, what would've happened on the roof? Remember Rick cuffed Merle there. Would he kill someone? Try to be the leader as he proclaimed? Or would have he and Daryl robbed the group?

[@TWDExplained]

Merle might have killed Tdog and when he got back they (Merle and Daryl) would rob the group and leave them.

[@thezealot4159]

I 100% think Shane was right when beating up Ed, there are things that make you instantly lose your values as a person, and slapping your wife or anyone for that matter is one of them.

[@donutpredator4945]

That always bugged me about merle in story line he would have known to cut what the handcuffs were attached to that was stupidity on the writer's part

[@SeraphimRoad]

If he had time. The walkers were about to break in. Sawing through flesh and bone is quicker than steel. It was explained in a flashback when he was in service with the Governor.

[@acednewgate419]

The Point with the Handcuffs. I Think the same thing all the time im seeing this episode :D

[@dixieboyzxxx2175]

Amy wouldve died either way her death was basically what set off the zombies, noone knew they were there until she got bit

[@HeyImHamdrew]

I wish that he would have beat Ed down at least one more time on screen before Ed died.

[@ronnieweatherly7222]

The way Shane was hot headed he would have gotten every one killed.

[@maddtaggz]

Bahaha "don't be a merl"

[@keelykiwis]

Okay, in this case if there's something that sticks out or separates from the hive mind, it should be taken into consideration. The norm won't always be the norm. You must know when change is needed. Questions SHOULD be asked. When they are, contemplate. Ask if it is time to evolve.

[@HaXaW5150]

The fight with Ed is a good example of Shane's weakness. Yes Ed needed his butt whooped"a long time ago", but Shane didn't have control, after a certin point he becomes a pit bull. Maybe it was all about a girl , wars have been fought over those lovely ladies.

[@aaronbabcock9922]

The quarry in season 1 looks identical to the quarry near Alexandria.

[@rickershomesteadahobbyfarm3291]

Shane ticked me off when he tripped the guy when the walkers were after them.

[@TWDExplained]

yep - it was sad

[@MynameisTMP-]

Never forget Otis

[@thedarkprince305]

After rewatching TWD Shane did made some good call as leader and yes he was right for beating Ed. When Rick was radioing in that he was heading to Atlanta but Amy was the only one who heard his voice. Shane said that no go off alone however I found out that Lori was saying for a week that they should’ve left signs warning people. So Shane was right for not leaving camp but was wrong for waiting a week to do something. When they found out that they were trap in a department store, Shane was right for not going after them it’s just that he didn’t know how much of a good call that was because Rick was working out a plan to get them out. Imagine if he did went after them but took a different road. Shane and Rick would’ve miss each other completely. When the walkers came to the camp my theory is when Glenn came with the car alarm, that’s what got the walker attention. Rick was right to go after the guns because if they didn’t they could’ve lost everyone. The only weapons that they had was Shane Shotgun, Dale Rifle and both Morales and Jim had a Bat, that’s it. Going to the CDC wasn’t a huge mistake. They get to relax for one night, they learn how the virus works and Rick learns that they are all infected. Remember we found out that Fort Benning was lost in season 2.

[@trizard3940]

I think s1 Shane was a good balance and he was a good leader its uo until he kills otis that he rly changes and becomes eaten with guilt and lashes out but i think his real turning point is when he sees that walker on yhe road by it's self since i think thats when he realizes that hes truly alone which is his biggest fear. Hes a good guy but he just couldn't cope with the actions he had to do and became increasingly more like an animal

[@edmorris2466]

Fyi they stated on the show the hacksaw was not good enough to go thru metal so he had no choice

[@ronnieweatherly7222]

When Shane sided with Rick to go to the C.D.C he was hoping that Rick's plan to go to the C.D.C would fell and then The group would want Shane as the leader.He would have said "see I said Rick's plan would fell "!That would sent the group to want Shane as leader.

[@0000mot]

First off welcome to the dark ages. I've seen that scene Shane vs. Ed a thousand times each time since it originally aired never gets old. For Shane sake the anger needed to be placed somewhere with that he had a fair amount of morals, the one thing I haven't understood is Shane infatuation with Laurie. Why possess another person why couldn't he just have let go, or live and let live?

[@TWDExplained]

Love - it's a crazy thing

[@0000mot]

@@TWDExplained Maybe that's how it started but not how it ended.

[@freddieg.3387]

And I really hated how the other women looked at Shsne like he was a monster

[@bear76009]

one thing i didnt understand.. in a nation with more guns than people why would he need a bag of guns in a dangerous area when you could literally find them in safer areas without the risk

[@TWDExplained]

best answer: different universe