What is 'Wrong' With the Indian Judiciary | Central Hall

[@mohammedmurtaza3257]

The bottom line is that individuals in public service-whether from the Armed Forces, Civil Services, Judiciary, or Police-should not be associated with or participate in any cultural organizations. A sensitivity assessment and test are essential, and anyone found exhibiting bias against any religion, culture, caste, or language must be held accountable.

[@sm9214]

Yes India should follow gulf countries.

[@ranjeetkamble7646]

Very true Dave Sir,you have nailed the problem

[@AshwaniSharma-jb8ty]

Delighted to listen carefully to the important debate by legal luminaries. Sir, please do something great to clean up the mess in this system.

[@bgs-l6h]

YE DONO SABSE BADE DALLE HIN.

[@Options.Tactics]

What I have heard from ordinary people with non criminal cases is that their case isn't going anywhere because the court only gives dates, instead of hearing their case.

[@kfr7867]

Exactly 😢 Cases go on for years and years 😢

[@designerme]

🎉TODAYS DISCUSSION TO BE DEDICATED TO LATE JUDGE LOYA.🎉

[@AslamANSARI-yr5vy]

Sir agree by you

[@kalaimani5424]

Very very important topic. Judges are selected by govt friendly person

[@Devmew000]

People selects govt, govt selects judge, Indirectly people selects judge

[@raphaelpo2482]

Sir, you have beautifully presented and are presenting the way you are facing the current crisis in this country. We are proud of this. Sir, we offer our heartfelt support to you and others who are standing by this. Thank you very much 😊

[@Rajwendsingh]

बहुत शानदार ज्ञानवर्धक और जरूरी चर्चा और महत्वपूर्ण सुझाव

[@muthukumarchandrasekharan2485]

Strange that the four legal luminories suggested a solution which has not been not envisaged in the constitution. Not a word about creation of national judicial service.

[@hameedshahul6191]

Shocking revealations! If justice succumbs to political pressure, only God could save the nation going to shambles! Thanks for this lively discussion 🎉

[@David-u4u8v]

An enlightening brain storming session with greatest minds

[@raisahmad2363]

Highly excellent conversation

[@swarsangti-rkk185]

Respected Sirs and Madam, You really enlightened us. Thank you so much. Would also discuss the phenomenally high fee charged by Sr. Advocates like yourselves? Would you dare to discuss this also?

[@safarcl]

The discussion is quite interesting and genuinely motivated. After going through the entire session, it became evident that there is nothing right with our judiciary of late! It is astonishing and unbelievable... but, unfortunately true!

[@badanchandramondal1335]

Agreeing with Dave sir that the justice system.and department is with mostly working judges.in.the country are practicing corruptions instead of law. These are happening since 2014 .

[@hindeshrai8787]

C'mon man really? Are we gonna pretend that judges were pious before 2014?.

[@chandballabh8839]

Excellent conversation..thanks.

[@vijaypanwar8660]

Excellent discourse 🎉

[@VishalDangi081]

Absolutely very important and impressive decision

[@ghasiramdash1807]

The discussions are really very useful for us. 💯🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@ZainZain-ve3xf]

Thanks

[@ShishirPrakashadvocate]

Such good observation by Ms. Meenakshi Arora

[@mslightwala]

Educated people should be in Power

[@mohanchandran3221]

Honoured to be with such enlightened panelists, Kapil Siball, I..jaisingh.... MukulRohtaki.. The most learned Dushisnt Davee🎉

[@mslightwala]

If Criminals. Rule What happens to Judiciary?

[@thenaikvp6602]

FEAR OF A PERSON.NOTHING ELSE.

[@drsuratsingh2348]

Excellent discussion. WE NEED MORE DISCUSSION S LIKE THIS.

[@varshaalex3743]

Ratio of lawyers+lack of infrastructure applies to doctors as well in India….face similar issues….

[@NurulIslam-kc2jl]

Correct

[@vhkah]

Lower Judiciary is very very Important as well.

[@amiruddinkazi1781]

Sir, whole Judicially system has to be reformed to get the justice by public in short time. This should be done on periorities from every side, specially Bar council of India. After independent of india, no body has taken serious interest in the matter. Public is facing lot of problems mentally, financially, physically.

[@ziahasan9817]

Appsulutly correct kapil sb and gud topic raise by u. .....Batoge to cuttoge. Jai Sudheer yadav Allahabad High Court.

[@mohibquadri4053]

Dave sir is highly knowledgeable 👍

[@Nitin_Killawala]

I completely endorse the suggestion of an independent committee of enlightened lawyers… the same thought I’m advocating as an architect to have an independent committee of talented architects /planners for infrastructure projects across many cities in the country !!

[@samarjitpattnaik1983]

Excellent

[@ShakeelAhmadAhmad-f8g]

Great sirji God bless you and your family and friends 🙏 ❤️ and wish you all the best 👍 👌 Allah hafiz

[@drshokatalisaiyed4733]

Delay in judgement is very dangerous in the Indian Judiciary .is it right or wrong??

[@faruquebaig2951]

Right sr.❤

[@Devmew000]

When demand is more than supply then the problem will rise, so decrease demand decrease population

[@ataulhaque1454]

The practices of unnecessary delay in the judgement, and, sometimes, pro_govt/ corrupt like judgements, accuses, seems, does not care of court/law and born more accuses. It is dangerousi

[@aboobackerakkarammal8769]

Justice delayed is justice denied.... Therefore, delay cannot be justified ..

[@jayapalantharavath8388]

What an enlightening discussion, so eloquent in style and content. The present flaws in the judicial system functioning are well deliberated and the suggestions that are brought forth sound compelling and convincing An expedient topic which paves way for improving the quality& integrity of our judiciary

[@khaliqmohiuddin7455]

Why not privatise low profile cases to lessen the pending cases in lower courts.

[@nirmalhazarika]

The main problem is that the judges are appointed by the government means the ruling party without involving the opposition !

[@sagarborah5359]

Only the district level judges are appointed by the central government. The High Court and Supreme Court judges are appointed through collegium.

[@jamespereira1202]

I look forward to listening

[@mslightwala]

Conflict of Interest is the only thing to be taken into consideration

[@athemk.chothe1416]

The problem is: No Judges or Chief Justices are not delivering according to the law of the land!

[@jayoopatwardhan4040]

Greed oppression and power are the main reason . No one wants to retire and live simply into the Vanaprastha stage in our lives . Things coukd not do with family or persue their hobby after a shinning work towards the country . But most are ready to ruin their reputation in one wrong step! All this judges / lawyers are great and honest Not appreciated by the regime but most needed right now to save our country going into a dark abiss ! You all are our hope and public must stand up to you guys ! 💐👍🏽

[@yogeshgogawekar5284]

Wonderful Discussion. We came to know many things of judicial system. Thank you

[@devendraparmar3332]

Great discussion and great suggestions by great lawyers for the improvement in judiciary to strengthen justice system. Thanks to all respected panelist

[@mniranjan9509]

Most shameful daily activity of a judge is just to give " dates ", no hearing😮

[@kfr7867]

True 😢

[@mslightwala]

Please you All go to Haryana High Court & make to help the court to consider the 23 members election to be considered

[@aap_amol_more]

It would be great if we had such programs in Hindi for the common people of this country to understand and assimilate more properly.

[@rajenlama.6850]

Jai Hind sir. All the panelists made very comprehensive analysis on the very topic for not having correct judiciary like nepotism, lacking consultation procedure and more to say lacking of particular idea of particular line resulting the delay of verdict. The topic is obviously very educative for all citizens and MP, MLA of our country must learn and observe the future of democracy. We enjoyed to hear such topic in your channel.

[@shantaramram]

Satya Meva Jayate, Truth Alone Triumphs, Jai Hind

[@ramakrishnacb7246]

Yes 💯 % appears to be facts Thanks every Adorable Noble personalities who participated in the debate ✅✅🇮🇳💐💐💐🙏🙏

[@harvindersingh9633]

Now judiciary, despite present Collegium has been largely saffronised by appointment of RSS ideology driven Judges.

[@krishnamurthyanantharaman6483]

Absolutely correct

[@Realchap]

Excellent panel and discussion 👍

[@khaliqmohiuddin7455]

Very good discussion.

[@josikalathil]

nice discussion

[@omkumar-ww1lh]

Thanks Kapil to hold such an important deliberation & deep discussion. Our judiciary system is sick of favourable appointments of the judges. 51:15

[@aap223]

Informative discussion; nice initiative.

[@Iftakhar9671]

Good and healthy Discussion for our judiciary . Keep it up ❤🇮🇳❤️👍

[@NurulIslam-kc2jl]

Always a good discussion ♥️♥️♥️♥️👌

[@bravikumar8950]

Discussion is useful. 👍👍👍

[@randolphalves3031]

Innocent people are incarcerated with bails not being granted. If this is the situation, it is no use to have a judiciary

[@arsalanmirza3411]

EVERYTHING ‼️😂😢🥵😭

[@PraakashRanjann-fz7rc]

Question is what was wrong with the Indian judiciary

[@gurdeepsingh1616]

Kotha hai ji

[@vijaykumarsingh1374]

लगता है कि कोर्ट फिक्सरों से सुप्रीम कोर्ट मुक्त हो रहा है। इन्हें मनपंसद बेंच तथा मनपसंद फैसला नहीं मिल पा रहा है। ऐसा समय आ गया है कि ये शोर मचा कर भी कोर्ट को डरा नहीं पा रहे हैं। उल्टा शोर मचाने पर डांट मिल रहा है। छुट्टी के दिन भी दो दो बेंच बनवा कर ज़मानत न दिलवा पाने का दर्द उचित है।

[@pushpendergusain4262]

Shri Mukul Rohatgi has raised a very important point about the simplification of law. The simplification of laws can help to a very large extent in solving the problem of clogging and backlogs. The ambiguous, complex, and cumbersome laws are a delight to bureaucrats and those who are in powerful positions. Many of them use these to deny the people their rightful dues. Therefore, people flock to courts even for minor problems that would not have occurred had the laws been simple and unambiguous.

[@purushothamadass2912]

Our Government needs to start seeking suggestions from legal luminaries to ensure judgments to raise confidence in the courts.

[@aurangzebansari3007]

Nice program ❤

[@sambasivaraonimmagadda7705]

All three are more or less equally responsible for delayed Justice and huge pendency of cases. The three are: 1.lawyers 2. Judiciary 3. Litigants The problem is each part is blaming the other two. Situation is very pessimistic and hope less. Only time will tell how situation is going to go.

[@anildubey7764]

What problem is there these people are biggest beneficiaries. Now they are not getting perhaps VIP treatment

[@Paulsmiththea]

These ring of five self-serving high profile advocates, practice, advocacy, of the most inimical kind , highly prejudiced in their arguments, twisting the constitutional intent to serve their ends. As a first step, no Advocate should be hoisted by any political party into the Rajya Sabha , as they go in as independent, but can they forget the diabolical needs of the party which hoisted them into Rajya Sabha 😮😮😮

[@shrestaassociates4063]

Even at your caliber u could not do anything, how is the common man get justice.

[@KrishnaKumar-so6gr]

Even many or our local courts judges asks the lawyer to write the order for them then they sigh same orders with some corrections if not so suitable.

[@sanjayambulkar]

Unfortunately, no one discusses the population explosion, the root cause of all difficulties.

[@MathewThomasFET]

How does the judicial system work in UK WITHOUT a WRITTEN CONSTITUTION ❓️🤔

[@asathyamurthy2481]

People have lost confidence in courts. The courts don't seem to understand the urgency of some cases and have no qualms about postponing hearings at will.

[@KrishanGupta-w4u]

Is there any solution for ADJOURNMENT in CAT Highcourt and Supreme court where no witness is to be examined . Decision is based on the apeal and the reply filed by the other party .

[@sagarborah5359]

All of these lawyers featuring in this video including Sibal is responsible for deplorable and pathetic condition of the Indian judiciary.

[@mittemari]

It's shocking to know that cases are alloted to judges without knowing their strong domain. It's a basic 101 of governance. You cannot ask someone to do something which they don't know about. Shocking state of governance and system of court. It's time to stop assuming that judges are holy cows. Those days are over.

[@teluram3925]

Quite healthy debate on most vital part of our cnstitution which is now seems to be compromising frequently, never before, under influence of the present regime.

[@NasirKhan-ci4kn]

Nice

[@anjivkumarsrivastava8853]

Send its recording to CJI

[@mnam9582]

Babri masjid judgement spoiled judges credentials.

[@vikrantk7]

Judiciary is primarily upper caste & upper caste dominated Judiciary cannot provide true justice. Judiciary needs to be made more equitable.

[@shivendrabahadursingh2356]

यह देश का दुर्भाग्य है कि हमारी न्याय प्रणाली जा कहा रही है?न्याय कहा है?अदालतो मे पडे करोडो केस हमारी न्याय पालिका की असफलता बता रहे हैं

[@GilbertMenezes-pd7sv]

Emery happened and many blame it. What is the solution we brought to practice from 1998

[@ahsanakhtarzaidi12]

Excellent team of lawyers. Intact good lawyers play with jumble clauses and laws where intent of laws is lost.All judgements remain under pressure of govts due to quality of incumbents with no courage and ambitions after retirement. Our courts were known judgements

[@xxyz2023]

Imagine you're trying to do your job, but you don't have the tools or support you need. That's what's happening in the judiciary right now. The union govt is responsible for making sure the courts have enough staff & resources, but they're not doing it. This means that judges & staff are overwhelmed with these pending cases. There are too many cases & not enough people to handle them. It's like trying to hold too much water in a cup at once - something will give out. It's not just the judges & staff who are affected. Lawyers needed from govt side, are also feeling frustrated & leaving their jobs. This makes the whole system even more overwhelmed. It's a vicious cycle that's hard to break. The ruling party wants to follow the pak examples who can hire & fire judges. We are following in pak steps, by trying to be a religious nation full of religious radicals shouting religion is in danger. Assam state wants to remove non-citizen individuals, regardless of their religion, as per the 1985 official agreement. nrc was initially intended exclusively for assam to identify & deport foreigners, regardless of religion, to prevent demographic changes that occurred historically. However, politicians in India may use the hindu and muslim non-citizens to impact their electoral landscape, potentially influencing voter demographics in certain states, particularly where the ruling party lacks a majority in places that's outside the northeast area. Such tactics of targeting a groups is counterproductive to maintaining law & order since it creates fear & mistrust within communities. This ultimately leads to destabilising & weakening our beautiful nation.

[@navaneethanad2516]

The test of a fair judgment is "that the common people should not go with an impression that the judge concerned had delivered the judges with malice and prejudice '

[@navaneethanad2516]

"Judgement" My above observation to be read with this correction pl

[@RR-wn8rx]

MR SIBBAL IS IT THE TIME OF DISCUSSION? PLS DO SOMETHING ALL OF YOU HAS POWER

[@sujitmohanty2730]

Judiciary must adopt to the fast changing society in age of social media and artificial intelligence.

[@johnjoseph3622]

Mr. Dushayant, if the practice of delaying court proceeding by repeated vaidas with out conducting the case, what benefit will be of increasing numbers of judges.

[@kaushikanand9864]

The expertise should come forward and raise voices which should reach the common man.

[@theOne-wx3vh]

Merit should be selection criteria not caste,religion etc.

[@krishnajena2622]

Do a national level exam for selection of High Court judge

[@arjun.islampur]

Answer is 🤏 Judiciary is 🤏 Not Giving Judgements As Per The Wishes Of The Opposition And Press 📰 & Media 📺 Supporting Them.. 👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏

[@punnavanamsubbiah7434]

Abdication of responsibility by egalitarian society is the route cause of failure , 360 degree Indian democracy and economic predicament. This was a topic given to me for group discussion in a MBA entrance exam. Year 1974.In 2025 it became the worst by best brains of Delhi

[@vssmanian]

Unfortunately every such debate converges into who should appoint judges - which is not the topic. Irrespective of who appoints, for sustainability, the system should create capacity to decide more cases than filed to ensure net disposals. Who's really interested?

[@everythingunderthesun9122]

The real problem with Indian Judiciary is that Congress is not in power.

[@satyanarayansinha4463]

😂

[@melvillejackson4048]

"Accountability " if fixed for any lapses on Beauricrats or any govt officials then only the Common Citizens will get disciplined.

[@shaunbird8051]

Very true that the times have really changed, but it is mainly because of Money & Power. Truth & Patriotism completely takes a back seat. Jai Hind !