They can’t get away with this…

[@Bencar_8]

We need Tom Mitchell in the side he’s the type of play who gets the contested footy for players like daicos and degeoy

[@RobKieranz]

Not a Pies fan, but McCrae is one of the greatest motivators I've ever seen. He could take them to the promised land again. And yeah, agree, the age factor is not such an issue for me. The list is good and a lot of guys are still in their prime. They should look to Geelong 2022 for inspiration. The oldest team to ever take the field.

[@Tim_Bo_]

There's a reason why the AFL gives Collingwood the hardest draw in 2025. Barring injury the numbers will stack up

[@TMELOMAGPIES1892]

Bringing in the best player of the trade period in Houston the best half back in the game. perryman has shown he can be a good player plus membrey as another dimension to the forward line which will free up mihocek and Elliott it will help them stay up there I see them finishing top 4 and rebounding after a disappointing 2024. They look ready to attack from training vlogs

[@stevenprice6957]

Pies no chance. Lions very rough chance. I’d be looking at hawks dogs blues and Freo giants as the outsiders.

[@craigcombridge6353]

Collingwood have gone all in if they can win it next season, the next 10 years won’t matter 2 much, if they don’things won’t b easy, Tassie coming fast, the age of the list, Gold Coast having a strangle hold on all the top draftees & Collingwood couldn’t have cap space, I wish Fly good luck but , I have seen this play b 4, Taranto & Hopper, this could go the other way, maybe Fly seen something that Dimma didn’t, & Leppa just like Caracella, they c things whilst the game is in play that other coaches miss, both a part of the Tigers success, but if injury’s hit & things don’t go to plan, well u seen what happend to Richmond except Collingwood is never going to get the Currany the tigers got, anyway good luck Collingwood but I think u might b hanging around Richmond in 25, at least Fly not going to go up the shop 4 milk & bread & find himself in Tassie taking a spell

[@TomHowes-h1f]

Collingwood have not found a replacement for Nathan Murphy, they have bolstered the forward line but have not found any tall key backs. Frampton is useless, they will have too many opposition key forwards kicking goals on them

[@richardbehan8118]

Its Fremantle for me this year.

[@Power_Prawnstar]

The team that gets massively under-rated every year forever is the Port. We love it. 12th with the bookies at the moment.

[@Collingwoodfan420]

Cause they never make the granny

[@kevsmagpies1306]

Port Adelaide aren’t underrated they are overrated

[@crashwoahcoot6478]

Collingwood are basically Hawthorn 2020. Everyone overrated them, but Hawthorn crashed to 15th, and Collingwood may not finish that low, but they are finished and you have to be heavily biased and delusional to think they're giving finals a crack. They're screwed when Tassie join.

[@CL-gd3ig]

cry big boy

[@SilentHotdog28]

We got lucky in 2023, but do you think we'll be worse than this year if we have a fairly clean bill of health? We were destroyed by injury this year and still finished 9th.

[@Johny-jy5vo]

@@SilentHotdog28old playing lists tend to have a lot of injuries

[@crashwoahcoot6478]

@SilentHotdog28 everyone said Mitchell returning for Hawthorn in 2020 will give Hawthorn a crack for finals, maybe even top 4, and to no normal persons shock, they finished bottom 4.

[@CL-gd3ig]

​@@crashwoahcoot6478 lol that's what you're basing this off? mitchell didn't propel hawthorn in 2020 so mcstay, mihocek, houston, perryman, etc. won't this upcoming season? right