They Canceled My Favorite Show, So I Made It Myself

[@ScottCramer]

I made a playlist of all 3 murder mysteries we did right here! kzbin.info/aero/PL-RUZ4jigXRw2zLpTDCK2LA5Lp5nNiEul

[@drewisgooden]

dude this was so creative!

[@bextomoose]

Well hello

[@frogington3892]

Wow! Danny Gonzalez is in the comments!

[@ENTZY.]

Whats up checkmark

[@hailey_the_ace_of_hearts4127]

Hi kurtis

[@justin.gollnick]

Danny?? Why are you in his comments!

[@Joel-Haver]

Can’t believe KZbin let you show that crime scene, it was so gruesome that I punched my screen and now I’m typing this from a computer at the local library

[@redsoxrule75]

Says the man who has killed multiple people in the past month 🤔🤔

[@stypie3711]

does that make you jelous. Will you pay him another visit?

[@vulcanisvault]

It’s also on restricted mode

[@zagiproductions1630]

*me who read this comment before watching the video* 😳

[@sawyermurdock6521]

@@redsoxrule75 nahhh it’s all just for the videos right? like he was just visiting them

[@MistaGG]

omg scott you're glowing

[@NeverNotJune]

hi

[@chuckieboy343]

I get off a GG binge and see a comment from the man himself is evidence of manifestation 😂

[@elizabethanntarter]

It’s all those candles he’s been huffing

[@archbishopofthecrusades9579]

GG, you’re supposed to be watching more shitty dark web boxes

[@milkman8467]

aww

[@Nathanr016]

It’s crazy how accurate she was. My jaw dropped when she mentioned the coat that he wasn’t wearing and it all made so much sense

[@degeneratemale5386]

Lara would absolutely win on Whodunnit

[@inf3ct3d52]

“They canceled my favorite show, so I made it myself” imagine he got people together and actually killed someone

[@Mikaelamofu]

No comments.. interesting

[@UnitardZZack]

That was what Whodunnit had a controversy over. Viewers actually thought they were killing people on the show, and they had to start having the "deceased" do interviews at the end of each episode in their death makeup to prove the producers weren't murderers.

[@jiaverse]

@@UnitardZZack ??? how dumb are people why would they actually kill ppl for a murder mystery lmaooo

[@UnitardZZack]

@@jiaverse - No idea. I was 13 at the time the series was on ABC, and you could tell it was fake for a mile away. I still stuck by my boy Don, though.

[@jayinthekut8389]

@@jiaverse bro you gotta consider the time period this show came out in. Yeah, it was only 2013 when the show aired, but think about how foreign the internet STILL is to most adults and how easy it is to trick them with fake photos/videos. Now consider how easy it was to trick most adults back in 2013, which was a time when most adults didn’t even use the internet unless it was for work or music. The murders obviously look super fake to us because we know how simple it is to fake that stuff, but most adults in 2013 weren’t even aware of the fact that you could basically teach a monkey to create fake media. It’s not that people were dumb because they thought the murders were real, it’s that they were super ignorant to how “advanced” special effects, make up, and CGI had become at the time.

[@TheDerpyWerp]

Imagine this being a yearly thing where Scott's budget increases because of crowd funding and we get guest stars and really cool details

[@chatnoir9038]

I WANT IT

[@Big_Man_Kai]

@@chatnoir9038 I GOT IT

[@anjailbakeer]

So basically "Escape the Night" but with Scott

[@chatnoir9038]

@@anjailbakeer Escape the night sans the Gabby Hanna

[@-Teague-]

Please let this happen

[@maya-fv2go]

*moves scarecrow* “ah, rigor mortis has set in” *picks up head* “He didn’t have a brain 😦” This guy is hilarious lmao

[@caffeinatedkatie4696]

The rigor mortis comment got me

[@livelifeincolour]

And when he stood up to accept the award at the end... His comedic timing is brilliant!

[@htjjidr5rk]

Scott using his entire house and all his possesions as props so he can have a massive tax write off this year, smart.

[@StephenShepherdOfficial]

Big brain move right there

[@chigggg]

Genius**

[@micaelahannah6632]

More episodes of Scott’s whodunit PLEASE

[@azuradawn5683]

Yessssss!

[@peenprincess]

YES! i got so invested in the storyline lol

[@jazmynemapstone8549]

yes!

[@ObeyTheLaw7]

Cane her to say this!

[@nate_storm]

yes please this one was so good

[@barpe4514]

Omg, that's why he wasn't wearing a jacket. The details. So perfectly planned. This was amazing. And probs to Laura for noticing that!

[@iseeyousleepdad6463]

Big brain moment

[@EiffelGiza]

Fr, her description was so well thought out

[@milesfraser6722]

Why is no one talking about how good Scott's story was lmao props to you man

[@lemontree9518]

His family is so wholesome. all of them are so willing to work together on a random homemade game show

[@meyou8189]

My interest in you talking about one of my favorite least known shows of my childhood: 100% My interest in the rest of this video after you covered the first episode: 2%

[@maddu8437]

Scott: THERE’S BEEN A MURDER! His family: oh shit, here we go again

[@KWils249]

His brother didn't even turn around and was literally like "he's wearing something weird isn't he?" Haha

[@jamesp3992]

Scott: There’s been a murder! His family: **sigh** and you obviously weren’t the victim…

[@cheneethompson5756]

He'd be a ghost if he were! Lol!

[@halwilche4366]

“It’s not like you’re gonna get murdered for dropping a glass” My mom: “Well actually yes”

[@nickwittednonpareil]

Scott if I may for one moment rip off Daniel Craig's character in "Knives Out", there's something about this case that simply does not add up to me. It's donut-shaped, with a hole in the middle. It nags at me, and I hope you can clear up some confusion. Because you see, you'd have us believe this was an impromptu crime of passion. You were insulted by the refusal to pay, you viciously attacked the master of the home with an ice scraper, you ran upstairs to remove your jacket, and then addressed your master's guests. Frantic. Scrambling. Yet, that leaves you no time to order a replacement ice scraper. Even with Amazon Prime, it's unlikely you'd receive one so quickly. Time of death wasn't established, but the body clearly has not sat there for that long otherwise you'd order a new jacket and dispose of evidence. You'd cut up the bones and close your web browsers. So how were you so ready to replace the murder weapon? I'd say this was premeditated and the ice scraper was bought in advance, but clearly a person with those Fantasy Football picks lacks the foresight for something like that. The only explanation is that the ice scraper was not the murder weapon at all. That it was a clever red herring. But why? Why would you do that? What reason could you have to plant false evidence and point the finger at yourself? Unless you are protecting someone you care about who did commit this terrible crime. Because you see, if the ice scraper wasn't the murder weapon it would need to be another sharp object. I went over the video again and again...then at 12:37 my blood went cold. There she was. Jim-ing the camera like a cold-blooded Super-Villain, murder weapon in hand. You tried to protect her Scott, but justice must be done.

[@mic4600]

this is beautiful

[@AndrewmanGaming]

Great Scott! (pun partially intended) We've all been bamboozled!

[@miriamrobarts]

Scott should invite NICK MAUDLIN to his next murder mystery party!

[@scrbusaucuparia]

she was pretending to not remember his name at first… that look to the camera was her threatening reminder for scott/rick to stick to their ice scraper story 🤔😳

[@Baiileylynnhall]

Hahahahhahahahahahahahah yes.

[@adam.e2154]

I love the Cramer family. A family of nice and sweet individuals. I appreciate how much effort you put into this, Scott. Thank you.

[@Projectsunduck]

Can I second this sentiment ?

[@moabelen8942]

Literally my thoughts in one comment. This video was so wholesome

[@stepans2167]

@@Projectsunduck oh yeah, there's a whole like button for that 😄

[@nunpho]

They could be secretly evil 🤔

[@skarletcharity]

I wish to live somewhere with such a wholesome family.

[@jackk9497]

I’d watch a full series of Scott and his family recreating old game shows

[@futuristic.handgun]

Same.

[@anamelessyoutuber1462]

Back when I used to be big into Wipeout, I saw an ad for this show where they said something along the lines of "Or face the ultimate elimination," and I thought that meant that they litterally killed the losers.

[@Jack_Saint_Archive]

This sounds like Squid game with extra steps...

[@elsie8757]

A shocking amount of people did!

[@r3ady780]

@@Jack_Saint_Archive i can see squid game being a new game show 😅 It would actually be a good marketing strategy minus the killing, of course

[@Solollamamekim]

Danganrompa?

[@cfa1998]

13 Fear is Real anyone?

[@imaginekudryavka9485]

Petition for KZbin to pick up Scott's show for Premium! He NEEDS his own game show, it's his destiny.

[@LaptapGamer]

YES

[@nerdleturtle152]

Dude that last half of the video is so entertaining and fun. Your family is super funny just like you! Great vid Scott aka Sir Pumpernickel

[@phosphorus4]

Sir?!??

[@nerdleturtle152]

Yes. He was knighted at some point I'm sure of it

[@offbrandsoda]

Aka "RICK"

[@lynxjynx16]

The second half of this was genuinely amazing. Even for a short mystery a lot of effort went in to this and it was really entertaining to watch. It would be really cool to watch you put one of these together every year

[@cowdew]

Laura is a goshdang detective jeez she knew all the details from both rooms even stuff I didn’t realize and I could pause the video!

[@akasakikawasaki1890]

Ikr! That was so impressive

[@candygonemad]

You should make an escape room. This was so creative and I feel like there would be a lot of transferable skills

[@simly5189]

Scott needs his own show. This was genuinely done so well, it was fluid and engaging and well thought through - imagine what Scott could do if he had a crew and a big budget to work with I want a complete Scott game show, pronto

[@nickwittednonpareil]

Scott's Show - This Fall on NBC! 20 contestants will have 3 weeks to conceptualize, cast, and film their own reality television show from scratch. Each week Scott will introduce a new challenge theme to each production based on his own nostalgic memories of other TV shows. The winning show will get produced by this network and/or stolen for Deal or No Deal Promotional material, and the winner will get a cash prize delivered by awkward Publishers Clearinghouse representatives! Critics say it's "incomprehensibly meta" and "probably works better as a KZbin series". Tune in Mondays at 8PM!

[@becauseimafan]

@@nickwittednonpareil 😂😂😂

[@echowood1732]

I would pay for KZbin premium just to have access to this show

[@madalynwatson8351]

Thank you Scott Cramer for introducing me to another MASTERPIECE and then creating your own version of that MASTERPIECE.

[@SpookyGhostHands]

I love how your family is so willing to get involved and into the story

[@Greenskull]

The callback to "Whodunnit" at 14:44 gave me a chuckle.

[@Sheekers]

First of all, Scott would make an amazing Dungeon Master Secondly, please post your notes because I want to do this for my own family

[@becauseimafan]

Yes this!!! Please share the notes, Scott!!

[@sarahkaiser8709]

My family and I were OBSESSED with this show when it came out. We would race home after church every night to watch it live. This was a great video, and maybe I'll have to do the same thing with my family soon!

[@abcdeisthekeygaming277]

Did you ever make your own version?

[@sarahkaiser8709]

@@abcdeisthekeygaming277 Not yet but we so need to!

[@futuristic.handgun]

​@@sarahkaiser8709If you still haven't done it, you still should and you should film it like Scott. You could even make it to continue off his storyline somehow, that'd be neat! 😊

[@wildoneizzy]

If you haven't yet, check out the Whodunnit novels, which fleshes out a lot of the background of the house and Giles involvement.

[@TheColinMontgomery]

You know you’ve made a good game when dad breaks out the reading glasses.

[@Nadiawuzhere]

I had the same thought lol

[@maxhydekyle2425]

A lot of my favorite creators are just deciding to do bigger projects now and it's really awesome. On Twitch they're having camps and cons, Critikal made his own Squid Game, and now Scott is making his own reality show. This is awesome. It really shows that the best talent of this generation is all online. They don't need studios or TV networks. They have fans who actually love them and will help fund big projects any time.

[@sannyfranny]

Scott’s been doing bigger projects like this for years. Dude’s way ahead of his time and light years ahead of all the other amateurs on this website. Criminally underrated and under appreciated.

[@kiman6]

Laura just comes in for the kill with that almost perfect story 😭

[@SpiderQueen971]

My mom and I were OBSESSED with this show and were heartbroken when they canceled it. I’m so glad to hear someone else talking about how great it was

[@shannonceleste5557]

Gotta love how Scott stuck with his “only ever wears shorts and has to show himself wearing said shorts at some point in the video” schtick

[@thapeacock2601]

“Is he dressed up weird” killed me

[@jesussaves_28]

the cramers are the best. this is like the second time they did a reality show without question. i love them so much. keep doing what you’re doing.

[@sashatalkstech1247]

Thanks for making this video! I was part of the cast and it’s pretty crazy how many people to this day hit me up with whodunnit related questions !

[@laurenmiller9143]

Poor Giles didn’t deserve getting roasted like that ☹️ The dude was just walking in a nice suit!! Don’t worry, G. We appreciate you, you beautiful man.

[@Jhfisibejoso8pkabrvo2is8]

My chemistry teacher in 10th grade actually set up a game/project like this for us towards the end of the school year! She made a crime scene and we all had different characters to play and had to solve the crime! I remember one of my classmates jokingly said "I want to be a cadaver when I grow up" and our teacher said "Well, at least that's a very attainable goal for you" 😂 Also, both of the guys wearing red shirts in this video are cute lol

[@Noise_floorxx]

You find big face, huge face cute?

[@_tangera_]

kyle: ah rigor mortis has set in i laughed way too hard lmaooo

[@annie-jy1tk]

i was so obsessed with this show when I was a kid!! im so glad this is being “brought back”

[@berrybaby1570]

Is it really?

[@cheneethompson5756]

You mean it's being "resurrected"?

[@monkey0427]

Scott seems like the type of dude who says stuff like “Aw freak” or “dang it”. PBS vibes

[@micahwright5901]

He’s the most wholesome KZbinr. He radiates positive energy and it’s great. I want to be more like Scott.

[@MarcyBowkew]

As someone who recommends this show to their friends annually, I sincerely appreciate the Whodunnit love. Giles and finger sandwiches for the win!

[@Scorch04]

“I’m really into candles now” -everyone over 25

[@tropezando]

Big mllennial energy

[@jinxd4398]

I got reallyy into candles at 11-12

[@Arvak]

Scott isn't even over 25, I'd say it's more everyone over 21 tbh

[@nate10465]

I loved 'Whodunnit?' and it was so exciting to finally see you talk about it. But you also went the extra mile and gave us the season 2 we deserved but never got! It was so well done, and I loved how willing and engaged your family and friends all were about it, lol. Great job, as always!

[@ridgeball6421]

Absolutely one of your best videos. I'm gonna be honest, I was going to click away after your synopsis of the show was over but I am glad I stuck around!

[@ScottCramer]

Glad you liked it! 😊

[@RJnottheraccoon]

Thank you Scott for such a good TV show recommendation! I just finished watching “who done it” and it was amazing!! 🤩

[@BoostBlix]

dad really turned into an early 2000’s hacker “i’m in”

[@jalissa8773]

swear to god scott you deserve way more views on your videos. The ideas, the humor, the editing like everything is top tier, please never stop

[@SAM114lol]

I loved this show and I was so disappointed when it didn’t come back for another season. It was such a cool concept.

[@ichangedthename]

Same here! I so glad I'm not to only one who remembers it! I'm also so glad Scott is reviewing it!

[@cartergames2742]

yes me too! i loved his episode it brought back so many memories of the show and as a big football fan the fantasy team got a laugh out of me

[@JordanKyle]

I hope this was as fun as it looked. If you ever want to do it again with creators, I will absolutely fly out and be a part of the show!!

[@RGDVA-jj6wh]

I don’t understand how you’re so talented at reopening memories i forgot I had. I swear every video it’s brings something back.

[@the_skrimbler]

Ok

[@Sharklops]

Don't know how Scott isn't at a millie subs yet. He's so damn deserving of as much success as can come his way. Good dude!

[@juliaava104]

I feel for Giles…I mean, how many job opportunities are there for antiquated, British butlers? The show getting canceled must have been a huge blow for him

[@theduckler5770]

He is voicing Alfred in the upcoming batman video game. Not too bad

[@calboy2]

He’s also married to a famous actress

[@viderevero1338]

From the sounds of these replies, there’s more job opportunities for a butler, then apparently 60% of college degrees

[@Liger-Inuzuka]

So nice to see this KZbinr having fun with his family, it seems healthy

[@metakarp_]

The "Hello.... Rick..." was GOLD. Very good video! Would love if you made another one of these as a halloween special next year! :D

[@midoriya-shonen]

This show sounds really interesting, I wish they would make a new one like it! Loved your version of it too, it made me smile

[@nunpho]

"The other jackals... which are my children" 😂. I loved this. I've never heard of the show before but it looks fun. You truly do have shorts for every occasion.

[@livelifeincolour]

I thought he said "jack holes" 😩

[@Evanz111]

There’s a new Channel 4 show in the UK called Murder Island! First episode came out last week and it’s a very similar concept, just taken a bit more seriously (not sure if that ruins the fun of Whodunnit? though!

[@stevenbridges]

Greatly appreciate the effort that went into this! Great video! 😂

[@alexdeppaye4140]

This is genuinely one of the most entertaining and original things I’ve ever seen on KZbin, I’m also high as shit so I might be a little too amazed but I just wanted to say (in my opinion though it does really matter) incredible job and I can’t wait for more content

[@defvent]

Scott is just next level. Anyone can talk about a game show but Scott remakes it. Well done. When's the remake of Bigheads?

[@ADHHollow]

I could watch a full season of Scott’s Whodunnit. This was really well executed, very charming, and a joy to watch. Wholesome entertainment!

[@cheneethompson5756]

"Executed" eh?

[@robp5469]

The last clip is actually a POV of Scott awarding us for being great fans of his

[@abbycollins]

God I love obviously British inspired murder mystery plots…between weapons drawn and this show i think my weekend is all set.

[@vernalbug]

Omg! I loved this show so much. I still watch reruns of it 😄. The creator of the show did a really interesting interview on Afterbuzz where he talks about how all the contestants were actually free to do whatever they wanted. The teams being formed, how they would miss clues was all natural and not scripted. An interesting fact is when Dante appeared running on fire they actually did not tell the cast about it. So they're reaction is 100% genuine.

[@kiiturii]

that's cool to know, some of it felt super scripted to me ngl but I'm assuming the cast was hired based on certain personality traits and they were acting a bit too hard to fit their role

[@vernalbug]

@@kiiturii It's interesting you say that because even the writer said that the contestants would over act sometimes and he didn't like it when they did. He said the only things that were scripted was Giles, the kills, and the rhyme. Other than that everything was up to them.

[@vernalbug]

Here's the interview. There is spoilers: kzbin.info/www/bejne/rZ-ohWmlequpm7c

[@slickwillie0000]

Before I watch the video, I just want to say Whodunnit is SEVERELY underrated. It makes me love Scott even more that he likes the show

[@ozymandias7]

This was a super fun idea, and you pulled it off great! Also, if I had a nickel for every time a character named Giles made a comment about finger sandwiches in a tv show, I'd have two nickels, which isn't a lot but it's weird that it happened twice.

[@brennadryl]

Scott Cramer could totally have his own escape room business. This was such a cool storyline and I honestly didn’t see that twist

[@matthewmaxwellpeterson9770]

“The Scott Cramer Show” credit segments are Scott at his best

[@chloetaterka121]

omg i didn't know ANYONE else knew about this show. this is why i love scott, he brings up stuff from our childhoods that a lot of ppl don't know and he also knows such obscure stuff lol

[@4-.Cryb4by.-4]

Legitimately some of the best content I have ever seen on KZbin that wasn't created for streaming platform or a TV station. Bravo Scott! I am in awe. I don't know how you haven't been scooped up and given your own show yet because you totally have the voice and the charisma!

[@aniyilator]

That applause at the end was honestly so wholesome. You’ve got a great family on your hands Scotty

[@Miyananana]

“Those jack-holes….which are my children” is one of the most Midwestern dad sentences I’ve ever heard

[@sam-jf7lk]

scott’s game was so interesting and well done

[@Tclay1996]

There was an old reality show that aired in 2008 that I was obsessed with called “Groomer Has it” where it was basically a reality competition show featuring dog groomers doing crazy challenges and shit. I thought this was just a weird fever dream of mine until I re-looked it up a earlier this year. I’ve never heard anyone else talk about it and I feel like Scott would have a blast diving into that show…

[@Kennieson]

I really thought I was the only person who remembered this show. I was so disappointed that it never got a second season. The Cramer murder mystery was really well done too!

[@babymariobrother3793]

This was such a good video! I don't remember anything about the actual show, but for some reason I remember seeing that Whodunnit graphic with the knife, so I got some serious flashbacks.

[@satanicchameleon1928]

Laura, the frickin genius really comin in with ALL the receipts lol this was amazing

[@elitettelbach4247]

Ahhh I loved Whodunnit! It was the perfect blend of murder mystery and reality competition show for me

[@taylorh1872]

YES! This was my absolute favorite reality TV show as well. I used to watch it a lot when I was younger and have occasionally rewatched it for nostalgia’s sake. I’ve never seen anyone talk about it until now (thought my sister and I were the only two to have ever watched it.) Thank you so much for making this video, Scott. I’m a big fan of your work and you covering Whodunnit was just an awesome spooky treat for me.

[@rockinraven101]

This was honestly one of the best vids I've seen in a long time lmao I loved it, if you ever make more episodes like this I would 120/10 watch it (although would be hard to top this one)

[@dekadevgg]

Scott, your loving and supportive family is beutiful, adorable, and so inspiring. Family goals.

[@gabbyb9939]

The show looks so cool and your recreation is even cooler! It gave me like 2015 HigaTV vibes

[@seankurkjian4096]

You love Whodunnit too? You remember whodunnit?! God, there's a reason you're a blast to watch Scott!

[@jalel_z2867]

I thought I was the only person who remembered it

[@seankurkjian4096]

@@jalel_z2867yep. I loved that it was like that show The Mole, which sadly died here in the states

[@4IS44C]

I miss Whodunnit? 2013 :( I will always remember watching it on my tv when I was 7

[@Syonide]

these videos were you create your own game show are easily some of your best work

[@xxminglexx]

He shouldn't be cast in one as a contestant, he should host one!

[@xfusee]

I'm so impressed by the editing. Could've easily have been dragged out to like 1.5-2hr long video but you managed to make it a solid 25 mins

[@vincentb725]

DUDE I was obsessed with Whodunit when it was airing, I can remember like five separate times over the years that I've looked it up to see if it really got cancelled or if I just never saw that more was made I can also still remember rewatching episodes on ondemand over and over after school because I thought the practical effects were so cool

[@savkenn]

the different lightings during the conclusions was such a nice touch

[@sydneydunham9619]

I'm so glad this show wasn't a fever dream I had.

[@cyberesss]

Right?? I swore I couldn’t even find this show for years after, so I thought I just made it up or something lol

[@AS_I_am25]

I remember watching this show and wanted to go on but was devastated when I found out that they canceled it. It was so much fun!!!

[@mimoo-69]

This was so creative! I loved this show. My favorite thing was allegedly that people complained or may have been convinced about the contestants getting "killed" that they included like dead contestants in full makeup doing exit interviews during the credits.

[@KSan357]

I genuinely forgot this show but seeing Dontai flail about on fire unlocked some kind of memory

[@B10PitLover]

I love how much effort you put into your home games! If I had someone like that in my family I wouldn’t need TV, we’d just play family games like that everyday lol

[@hamilcross]

this is my favorite video you’ve done, and interestingly enough this is one of very few shows that you’ve covered that i didn’t grow up watching. so creative. your family is so fun!

[@Hamsterbacke09]

That was my highlight of this entire year. Not even kidding. Well, a little bit. But it was so funny, Scott, I need yours as a series 😂

[@danakelley9972]

Scott’s reacts to their answers and popping up randomly in the background made me laugh