Where has BJP failed during the Modi Era? : Decoding the “BLACK PAPER” of the Indian Economy

[@ThinkSchool]

👉 Register for ChatGPT & AI workshop for FREE: link.growthschool.io/THA 👉 100% Discount for first 1000 people 🔥 ❤ Reshare this with your friends who will need this 😇 🌟 Growthschool has already taught more than 1 Million students and helped thousands of learners to grow in their careers. ✅ Join the workshop today and start your journey to become top 1%

[@ShivamThakur.257]

Love You Content ❤ Brother What is a percentage of Manufacturing Gdp Contribution Today By 2024 *Your Data Is From 2022 Only* ❤

[@lawyermahaprasad]

Proud of you guys for being brave and ethical to cover it on merits.

[@lawyermahaprasad]

@@ShivamThakur.257 India’s data pipeline is lggy so we can only get 2023 data by end of the 2024

[@thesaint9286]

For the past couple of days I did an analysis of all Pro-Modi comments on both sides of opinion on KZbin. Even in your channel, check their profile, they are all fake. These were generated by subscribers who opened their KZbin accounts as far back in 2022 and the newest ones being just a month old. You should do a story on it. I was so shocked to see that almost 96% of comments replying that Modi is disasterous, gets a volley of bad-mouthing, etc; in negative KZbinrs and almost 58% of comments amplify those showing pro-Modi stance.

[@thesaint9286]

ALERT!!!!!!!!!!!! ALMOST ALL PRO-MODI COMMENTS ARE FROM FAKE PROFILES...CHECK BEFORE REPLYING.

[@prasadshinde1092]

If this is a dictatorship then Modi is a terrible dictator.

[@prashantsinha6781]

this is the problem with people, obviously modi is not a dictator today, but the actions taken by the govt. nowadays indicates its shift from democracy to dicstatorship... it will take time and by the time you realize it it would be very late so many people want to know which action i am talking about so here it is- Until now, not a single leader from AAP has been punished by the court, so why are Manish Sisodia, Kejriwal, and Satyendra Jain in jail? Shouldn't they be considered innocent until proven guilty in a democracy? Why did the Modi government change this law in 2018? What does the Broadcasting Service Regulation Act bill mean? Wasn't the mainstream media enough that now even KZbinrs have to be controlled? There is a limit. Yes, the situation isn't like what happened in China, but if we don't raise our voices, it won't take long. What is the purpose of winning 400+ seats? A BJP leader himself said that they would change the constitution if they win with 400+ seats. Aren't these signs enough? Why isn't a single BJP leader in jail? Why aren't CBI and ED investigating BJP leaders? Is it possible that there is no corrupt leader in the world's largest political party? Why does all investigation stopped as soon as a politician joins the BJP? Why is banks of INC suddenly freezed for a case which is almost 6 years old. Is it just a coincidence? Even I was a supporter of BJP, but no doubt they are playing dirty game now. Look I am a patriots and that's why we are raising voice against what we feel is not good for our democracy. Also the people who are saying that some congress leaders like Indira Gandhi or nehru were even worse... i agree with you all but are we in that era?? no... i was not even born at that time.. why would i care about that... i should care about what is happening today. if someone did bad in past so repeating the same is justified? how?

[@Skeld_Colge]

@@prashantsinha6781 No

[@sivasankaranr388]

@@prashantsinha6781 Its not dictatorship. It means Modi and the NDA needs a new opposition that focuses on Politics of Performance

[@prasadshinde1092]

​@@prashantsinha6781if current action taken by modi government is shifting us from democracy to dictatorship then our country was never a democracy. History does not start in 2014 . Plz study history

[@AdityaKumar-qu7jv]

Lmao if anything, this comment is terrible

[@Generationupscat]

Wrt to GST let me say It made my father's business better. Reason: earlier (prior gst) we have to give money to Sale tax officer as 'RISHWAT' because we need his signature. But after the GST, govt removed the earlier provision and made everything online. It saved nearly 20-30k rs.

[@blueradiator]

The older System was crap... as every state had different tax, octroi, VAT etc !! it was just night mare to sell within the country

[@AjitSingh-f5q]

Par Anpad pagal public ko kon samjaye jo apne personal benefits ke liye vote dete h..

[@theprofessor2801]

Please.make a video on Congress and BJP manifesto...for 2024 elections.🙃

[@theprofessor2801]

Please.make a video on Congress and BJP manifesto...for 2024 elections.🙃

[@CAAkashAg]

@@blueradiatortrue, each tax had its own rules and website, very difficult to compile

[@anilkumarmallick1661]

I am more worried about Congress manifesto

[@rishabjain8975]

😂 they are not coming. Leave it

[@aravindhanv]

@@rishabjain8975 I wish the opposition took their time to build a manifesto that actually takes the nation forward - rather than just be an anti modi manifesto. Very sad state indeed

[@shadowking3757]

Even poor not gonna vote him. Everyone know how real congress is.

[@lemonado1462]

Can you genuinely tell me, what exactly worries you

[@rishabjain8975]

@@aravindhanv yes

[@adityashah93jan]

I am Business man from Delhi. GST has made work easy as compared to VAT, C-FROM AND ALL. EVEN I TIME OF C-FORM & VAT I remember taking all the hand written books + all cops of sale & purchase to govt. Office. IN GST we created a job for accountant & work is growing as we can focus on work then to keep collecting C-from & all.

[@southindianstatusvideos7511]

Coments from the experts like u will definitely help u to debug any kind of misinformation 👏

[@VY-zt3ph]

Congress wanted GST. BJP opposed it and did not let the bill pass. IN congress GST model 18% was the maximum tax.

[@MultiHeywatsup]

Gst congress ka brainchild hai modi Ji virodh kar Rahe the pehle 🤣

[@vinayakdoiphode7550]

Yes, I support your statement

[@aman6828]

Yes,GST is a good mechanism.But how to explain high GST??If all has been simplified why all commodity prices are on hike.You go to any market and see traders are blaming high GST for rise of commodity prices

[@theknowledgefox]

I am a ca student and my sir clearly explained how GST made the lives of small businessman easier and simpler

[@mk6049]

Ya bro but politics made it bad 😔

[@keshavladda5462]

Can summerize the explanation please

[@tushargoel3870]

but it made student life harder every month some amendment

[@Iamvengance191]

​@@tushargoel3870 come on bro tell my few points whete students suffer from gst... You are just soft brainwashed , which i was some months ago......... Being yadav from bihar ageeing with modi vision is crime......... .. Yadavs are being beaten if they agree a single point of bjp........ But the genz dont fear...... The new yadavs community not only study but challenge their parents, why they vote in name of cast........ Come on..... As we find facts from own , i recommended you to do also.... Chechk you point own... Not by public view and propaganda

[@onyxia3716]

I'm ready to learn all those amendments, if this will help in the development. ​@@tushargoel3870

[@ommapodi]

GST helped my dad's business, You know Input Tax Credit ,right that's the reason

[@SureshKumar-li5dv]

an example For businessman buying a car / High value utilities and getting tax credit, whereas middle class people need to pay complete GST without say anything. For 6 Lakh car need to pay 1.2 lakh roughly from midle class after paying income tax whereas Bu. guys get complete amount as credit.

[@kuralovien5524]

I don't think you know what input tax credit it, it's a system that ensures that the products doesn't have tax on tax after multiple stage ​@@SureshKumar-li5dv

[@mudit369]

One cannot claim GST input while buying a car. It's on the restricted list

[@ajithms8757]

​@@SureshKumar-li5dv GST on motor vehicle is under blocked credit only car selling company can get ITC on motor vehicle and all other business entities can't claim ITC because of Blocked credit

[@sinpiedad1503]

Please pay 100% tax instead of 18%.

[@triples5399]

Personal experience- My family grows arecanut in the coastal area of Karnataka and due to fungus issue in plants which arises due to lot of factors including rain. After the introduction of Phasal vima yojana basically crop insurance it has been a great help to my family. So how it works is we basically enter the crop data in a government app every year and pay a certain amount of money as premium per acre. If the rainfall rate doesn’t go as expected then the insurance will claim

[@koriroti]

How do they ascertain that rainfall reduced yield? I'm from puttur and would like to know your experience

[@thesaint9286]

@AnveshBanerjee-ov4hl Check his profile, I rest my case. GST has made my business easier, but GST was a process which, went on for almost 15 years. Execution was fucked up. Point is, the way Modi garners all the credit, now thats not done.

[@thesaint9286]

@AnveshBanerjee-ov4hl Check his profile, I rest my case. GST has made my business easier, but GST was a process which, went on for almost 15 years. Execution was fucked up. Point is, the way Modi garners all the credit, now thats not done.

[@andha_kanoon]

​@@thesaint9286the country itself was fucked up not implementation

[@alphaindian2847]

Bhai yeh to jhutha comment hai saaf dikh raha

[@kaustubhchoudhary6024]

This channel is 100 times better than the Modi Bhakts and Modi haters... This is what we can say is a neutral channel. Kudos for such a great job dear ThinkSchool

[@vamshikrishna9916]

Being neutral is a myth.. One need to believe a certain ideology and stand for it no matter what.. So, let us stop being pretentious Neutral brings for our sake.

[@bajrangdalwale363]

Ghanta neutral 😂

[@v-rex3206]

Name detected opinion rejected ​@@bajrangdalwale363

[@aadu.thoma44]

I have witnessed the growth of this nation under current Gov and I appreciate it. But they must find a solution for: 1) Manipur 2) Unemployment 3) Increasing our Manufacturing Sector 4) Pollution in Cities 5) Lack of Urban Planning in Cities. 6) Increase funding in R&D 7) Encouraging more indigenous Private Companies. 8) Reviving the Startup Culture (which took a hit in Covid years). 9) Funding for AI and chip manufacturing (Once we lag behind it will take decades to catch up with others) People who have same opinion 👇

[@dawn_alex]

Agreed.

[@shyamreddy9701]

what about section 3 of waqf act 1995 ? anyone seeing this comment just search in google about this. you will be shocked to know.

[@shreyahenley25]

One more to be added 6) research and development otherwise they had done Termindous work in other sector

[@Blackwidow559]

Trye

[@vishalpatil-fy2ot]

Need time bro I understand 👍 ( no hate)

[@Sanatani_Sherni]

They celebrated the death of -Atal Ji -General Bipin Rawat -Lata didi -Sushma ji -Manohar Parrirkar -Rohit Sardana They mourned the death of -Afjal Guru -Burhan Wani -Yakub Menon -Atiq Ahmed -Mukhtar Ansari The mindset… And yes “they” includes secular Hindus as well..

[@GloomyGlue]

Bro get a job rather than using a not so good girl's image in your profile and spamming under every channel

[@shubhambhoite7039]

Kya logic hai didi is point ka related to the video , Real problems pe baat karo kuch bhi Non sense mat likho

[@Benzene-xw7oq]

​@@GloomyGlueshe is Reaching out as much to spread the truth, how does that burn you?

[@soumyaranjanparida1907]

​@@shubhambhoite7039mane apne town may muslo ko hijab kay lia Wp dp lagate dekha hai Sale khud ache kapde pahen tae Hai muslim girls ko bolte hai Hijab peheno

[@lemonado1462]

Why you bringing religion to an economic discussion

[@Seriouslyfunny1]

My cousin owns a transportation business. Earlier, there were lot of delays and issues in filing taxes, specially when transporting material between different states. There used to be long traffic jams because of checkpoints and paperwork required therein. Many times, his drivers were harrassed by officials present there and forced to pay bribes. Introduction of GST eliminated much of the paperwork, removed a huge chunk of checkpoints and solved the problem of forced bribery. This not only is helping in greater profits, it also reduced transit time and helped expand business in other states.

[@ANKURTAH]

If India is going to be Dictatorship, then I really want this kind of Dictatorship in India..😍

[@Meerkat-lm3ub]

Good info..

[@Dev-jp4rn]

Yeah I also have a shop of building materials and previously sales tax officer use to come and harras us to pay bribes .But bjp govt made certain changes in policies like a sales tax officer can not come to your shop and tax will only be checked by it departments . It really helped in ease of business.

[@pranayrajshetty1395]

Bold of you for covering both sides and havibg neutral approach. Keep it up 👏

[@sudhanshupalav8504]

You are initiating a good culture of critical thinking. Thank you for both White paper and black paper video.

[@aravindshakamuri3643]

Yes the GST made the life better, I am cofounder who owns a pvt ltd company and also studies CA though I didn’t finish it. Through GST, being small business, I don’t have to worry about multiple touch points and filings.

[@295_01]

We want to win 2029 not this year we want a hard collation so that bjp cannot change waqe board rules from our constitution so we divide hindu as his caste ...

[@ahlawatkashish1921]

What about middle class people who buy anything have to pay GST even at water and Studying online ... Buying any course for study... On education also there is GST ... Only helpful for the businessman !

[@vinayakgarg4501]

@@ahlawatkashish1921what you are saying is that you didn’t need to pay taxes before GST on these things you mentioned. Check your facts bro.

[@PoojaSharma-ze1uj]

Look at andh bhakts arguments. 1) G.S.T when Congress offered Modi opposed it. Then he implemented it but with higher rates. 2) Question is not adminstrative ease but high rates of G.S.T which killed & is killing small businesses as customers change shops for Rs 50 difference in price.

[@manbeh4u]

@@PoojaSharma-ze1uj Thats incorrect, the GST draft of Congress and BJP werent exactly the same. Besides, Congress under Gandhi's influence woudnt implement any reform without caveats to undertake corruption.

[@yash3]

Kids nowadays think Modi brought GST and we have to pay extra and its bad. They dont know there was Sales Tax, VAT, Service tax for service, Excise duty for manufacturing and state VAT plus 6 other Taxes which were all subsumed in GST. Implementation could have been smoother but it was definitely good upgrade from the previous indirect taxes which had no credit set off among themselves.

[@achu10mech41]

And for each state it is different so one seller has to make different types of bill to every state even though its same product

[@WC2FAR]

Isn't it Congress who wanted to introduce GST and bjp opposed?

[@CHATGPT248]

And so much tax chori...😂😂

[@CHATGPT248]

​@@WC2FARno congress thought of doing so but never passed a bill..They were happy with whatever they are getting be it black or white..

[@krishna3311]

Absolutely! The GST is a much better indirect tax than its tax predecessors.....it is integrated...

[@tech_stocks]

Bro, you didn't mention, why there's lack of ease of doing business in India. And also in that context, you didn't even mention about the lack of skilled workforce in India, which is a big concern.

[@abrakidabra]

Babus are main reason than politicians of any party. Laws needs to be strengthened by center. Rest is upon state governments to create conducive environment for businesses and people training.

[@tech_stocks]

@@abrakidabra yes bro, there's the need of inclusive efforts.

[@Snoozefor10minutes]

Uneducated politicians are worse than babus

[@abrakidabra]

​@snoozefortenminutes9550 .Many uneducated politicians gave far better governance than educated buy fool or criminals can. Check Indian history of last one century, no need to go beyond.

[@HarshaVardhan-fw3vs]

This channel is more interested in blind folded than smartness

[@anshagnihotry1555]

when govt incentives the big companys to setup manufacturing units in india or decrease some restrictions then opposition says "govt sab bech rahi h paise kha rahi h" and then they complaint about unemployment

[@alok.01]

That's a typical Congress mentality

[@prince.kumar_1978]

I support your statement bhai but we need to work on MSMEs primarily and not just corporates, 50-65% Indians are employed directly or indirectly by agricultural sector but there we can't see any reforms, out of the rest people 90% are employed by MSMEs or are self employed so for employment we need to create 100k TATAs and Azim Premji and not just 2 Adani sir and Ambani sir...I mean empowering adani Ambani is also good since they are providing an alternative for foreign products, adani Ambani too donate a ton of money but for employment the most effective way is by empowering MSMEs, 1 apple can provide 80k jobs but it takes an year for it to establish 1 store while easily 80k people can start their own business and then automatically they will be empowered and then they can further provide employment. Ofcourse BJP government have done a good amount of positive step in this direction but we need to book vande bharat and then travel so as to see a difference 😉🇮🇳

[@aby-8k]

Investors need to feel that it’s cost effective to manufacture in India…. than to import from China…. And competing with China is nightmare for any country let alone India. Still India has put duties on China goods. When duties are imposed too, some pro China people like Rahul Gandhi and his supporters feels bad😂. They want cheap goods and compete with China in manufacturing. Sometimes I feel we need a better opposition to atleast challenge BJP, you cannot just argue every point the ruling govt is making. This is wastage of parliament time.

[@aby-8k]

Having read my first point I think we are closer than ever to start manufacturing big time. EVs, chip manufacturing, lithium mining projects, hydrogen manufacturing etc and I see many startups setting up manufacturing plants now. Just watch Shark tank. That’s just tip of the iceberg. Point is you need to be smart against competition and understand business properly - easily said than done. Make in India is also working. I can see many phone manufacturers manufacturing in India. Electronics slowly is gathering pace with Boat, etc. So the process is slow I agree, but we need to be patient.

[@krishna3311]

The problem with the opposition is that no one even believes them now..... Obviously, they cannot admit defeat so they have to say something and desperately hope that it will stick....

[@vaibhavgupta7498]

Yes, I am involved in the business of spices manufacturing company alongside my father. Having recently joined the business, I inquired about the impact of GST on our operations. My father mentioned that while it took some time to adapt, overall, GST has proven to be an improvement over previous tax policies. He has shifted from conducting a significant portion of transactions in cash to adopting proper invoicing procedures.

[@thesaint9286]

Fake profile

[@drury2d8]

Isn't the concept of gst manmohans idea?

[@Raj-mb6uk]

@@drury2d8 then why is Congress crying about it? and no it's not Manmohan's idea, the Atal Bihari Vajpayee government in India first proposed the introduction of GST in 2000.

[@arjavgarg5801]

Ostrich head in sand 😂​@@thesaint9286

[@DA6SH]

@@drury2d8 In that sense, Dr. Manmohan Singh presented the idea of The Citizenship Amendment Bill, in the 2003 Lok Sabha session. Now why are they crying about it?

[@karthickambur1397]

I was running a msme business for 6 years gst makes business easy because now goods can be procured from any where in india if we have a GST number. So we can do business even in tier 3 city with the best quality products procured any where from India. And selling products all over India is also now easy with gst.

[@matinsarkar296]

Sir GST was proposed and start working on it by Congress Govt and brought into action by BJP govt

[@vsrationalbeing]

he won't answer you bro 😂they have propaganda to spread

[@karthickambur1397]

I didn't mentioned anywhere about bjp or congress I just told gst system is good

[@matinsarkar296]

@@karthickambur1397 but your comment is already indirectly directed to BJP only. As the video itself is somewhat against Modi.And you pitching about gst here and boasting it itself says you are saying about BJP here

[@abhijitmidgule6693]

@@matinsarkar296जैसी नजर वैसे दिखाई देता है, उन्होने जस्ट बोला कि gst इस better टॅक्स system,its you who take it against congress

[@aprayaga1]

Thank you for an unbiased decoding of both the white paper and black paper. Appreciate ThinkSchool team's efforts.

[@Clean09]

Sam pitroda of congress party said that to fund the freebies announced in the menifesto, they will increase the existing taxes by 10%... So if current tax is 15%, it will be 25% or may be 15+1.5% i.e 16.5 !!! And he goes on to say that"can't we give extra 10 Paisa for poor people of the nation?" And here is own party uses the word "tax terror " 😅

[@ANKURTAH]

If India is going to be Dictatorship, then I really want this kind of Dictatorship in India..😍

[@ayubshaik2907]

10% increase of 15% is 16.5% . Dude here skipped basic math

[@kritindixitstudentvr1130]

@@ayubshaik2907 So u r ready and happy with the 16.5% taxes

[@yuvraj4084]

bro 🙂 tax overall people me se bs one thing hi dete h 🙂... tax chori start

[@Aman-pr3po]

​@@ayubshaik2907😂

[@va8085]

Ganesh, please do a video on the Congress manifesto & show the cost to the exchequer. It’ll bankrupt the country & disrupt the macro economy. Compare it with BJP thereafter.

[@arunkurian9367]

Like bjp hasn't done that with their surplus already from rbi😂😂

[@animeka1444]

@@arunkurian9367 come on , lets it be real, congress's freeebies would cost much much much more than whatever BJP did

[@tanmaynawghare9855]

​@arunkurian9367 really Now who's bhakt

[@dkstudios2326]

Good idea

[@achu10mech41]

Bro no need for video every subscriber of think school already knows how bad it will be for economy and those congi supporters won't understand the facts.

[@aaryandeshpande6173]

Today India has a wide variety of offers for EV automobiles from Tesla, BYD, Vinfast, these companies did not want to do manufacturing and just wanted to sell their cars in India, the Modi government denied this and now Tesla has agreed to do manufacturing in India. This WILL create Employment. The government would have promoted the EV initiative with Adani, Ambani or the Tatas but our lovely opposition will again say that the PM is in pockets of these billionares. This would hamper the growth of Make in India for EV automobiles.

[@kkr8710]

I agree with u, but i think BYD was not allowed to set up its manufacturing unit in India

[@yuvraj4084]

​@@kkr8710bro byd's proposal of 1b$ is denied.. so, they are back again with another bigger proposal 👋🏻 so, sb aaega india chill gois

[@shyambajekal8084]

Tesla is now coming it seems

[@yuvraj4084]

@@shyambajekal8084 obviously bro 🙂 it's in final stage and byd is coming too but with manufacturing setup 😅

[@mk6049]

@@yuvraj4084 yup but on India’s bareminimum req which will not as much harmful

[@ViprasCraft]

Nice job as expected by Think School. Kudos to your balanced presentation. 👍 We hope the Indian public will learn to see at both the sides of the coin, particularly in the social media era of "eco-chambers" creating a lot of noise. It is unfair to judge only listening to one side of the story!

[@RahulGamesYT]

I have only one question from congress supporters. What is the vision of Congress? Most of the supporters didn't know

[@mareddy5696]

Tough question. Ask them what’s wrong with Modi.

[@karthikkarkera7225]

Reduce unemployment, remove agniveer, loan waiver to students. Clearly their main focus is on youth along with GDP growth and reduce wealth disparity Also GDP growth % is more in UPA than NDA 2004 - 2014 : 290% growth 2014 - 2024 : 90% growth. Sensex Growth: 2004 - 2014 : 500% 2014 - 2024 : 300%

[@Aditya01251]

​@@karthikkarkera7225 🤡

[@HalfBloodPrince12]

​@@karthikkarkera7225 Also check that during those 10 years , india faced double digit inflation 3 times.. There were many years when gdp growth was less than inflation rate.. Also they negligibly invested in Infrastructure . They took loans to give subsidies on railway tickets ..

[@parkavispeaks]

Read their manifesto

[@VikramKumar69696]

The hate you guys are getting for nothing is phenomenal 😅. Don't worry brother @thinkschool .. Remember Jorge Soros's 1 Billion dollars pledge to remove govt. Usi ka asar dikh rha h 🫡.. Stay strong, we love your content unconditionally ❤️

[@feedback9996]

1 billion is not enough to remove modi ji 🤣 I assure you

[@amaycraft7039]

👍👍

[@sauravshoww]

💯

[@VikramKumar69696]

@@amaycraft7039 9 min pehle 100

[@kakun63]

😂 bhai 2029 tk 10 billion bhi km pad jaega​@@feedback9996

[@KushagraChaudhary91]

I am tired of the youtubers playing the right and left wing politics especially the left wing which are getting extreme at this stage. You are one of some youtubers who actually thinks about the country and its people. Keep it up. Bharat Mata Ki Jay! Jai Hind!

[@mk6049]

Same here bro….earlier i used to be a left winger but they are headung far left becuz of which they are ruining their own image

[@prajwalmuralis2101]

U don’t really need to belong to one side as its just a label created by humans. U can agree or disagree with both the sides and choose which points you agree and disagree. No need to fall in nonsense left and eight

[@mr.allout5500]

​@@prajwalmuralis2101Nice bro 👍🏻👌🏻

[@jaypatel4256]

@@prajwalmuralis2101 ya true but if you are right you can agree with some left talks but if you are in left wing and agreee on anything which is left ,you are no longer in their team😅🤣

[@samrat.Biswas]

Very true, left is going bonkers.

[@chef.devansh]

While the GST has streamlined administrative processes for many businesses, it has presented challenges for mine. Let me illustrate with an example and some data. I run a Mithai Shop in a tier 3 city, and my primary market is limited to offline sales in my city and Zomato. Mithai falls into three different GST slabs: 5% for Mithai without coagulated milk (Khoya/mawa), 12% for Mithai with Khoya, and 18% for Mithai made with dry fruits and chocolate. Currently, I operate under the composition scheme, meaning I pay 1% of my total sales as GST regardless of the type of Mithai I sell. However, this scheme has a sales limit of 2 crore rupees annually. If my sales exceed this limit, I have to switch to the normal scheme and file under the three different slabs mentioned earlier. This setup is burdensome for micro-businesses like mine. For example, let's say I currently make sales of 50,000 rupees a day, totaling 1,82,50,000 rupees annually. Under the composition scheme, I pay 1% (1,82,500 rupees) as GST. But if I want to expand by opening a new outlet in a nearby city and maintain the same level of sales, my combined sales would reach 1,00,000 rupees a day, totaling 3,65,00,000 rupees annually. This would automatically put me under the normal GST scheme. Now, some might argue that I can simply pass the GST burden onto the end consumer by adjusting prices. However, in India's price-sensitive tier 3 markets, this is not feasible. For instance, let's assume the average selling price of Mithai is 500 rupees per kilogram. Under the composition scheme, the tax is 1% (5 rupees), which is manageable for the business. But under the normal scheme, the tax shoots up to 12% (60 rupees) for the same product, making my business financially unsustainable. Even if I attempt to pass on this cost to the customer, setting the new price at 560 rupees per kilogram would likely drive customers to competitors. Moreover, as my primary raw material is milk, which is GST-free, switching to the normal scheme is not beneficial as anyhow I can't get the benefit of input tax credit. Additionally, the lack of adoption of POS systems in tier 3 markets makes it nearly impossible to track the three different taxes on Mithai effectively. Overall, this scenario hampers the growth of my business and reduces the potential return on investment for expanding to new outlets.

[@Anurag_2307]

You can open your next business with someone else's PAN card (someone's name) like wife or mother,father, brother and still enjoy the composition scheme till they increase the limits. Bas tax consultant aapka clever hona cahiye ya aap

[@Anurag_2307]

Aur milk ke alawa kuch inward supply nahi lete ?

[@chef.devansh]

@Anurag-hr6eq This is very true, but if I want to build a brand with 9-10 outlets and not just a small business with some 2-3 outlets, it is difficult.

[@chef.devansh]

@Anurag-hr6eq sir aur inward supply hai but tab bhi I did my calculations on a rough book for over 2 months, and the above mentioned were my findings

[@Anurag_2307]

@@chef.devansh ha difficult toh hai. You can do backward integration or increase items which attract Input Tax Credit. Wisa kaarke aapka tax burden average hojayega. And mithai is a bit affordable thing so people come behind quality and taste.

[@official.rajarshidutta]

This video is the exact reason I subscribed to your channel. Although Im a staunch supporter of Modi, the points that you made raises some serious pondering. Questions need to be asked.

[@geethavishwanathan9500]

The ease of doing business index has actually become better in India. India jumps 79 positions from 142nd (2014) to 63rd (2019) in 'World Bank's Ease of Doing Business Ranking 2020'.

[@srikanthsv79]

It was always easy, come to Bangalore

[@thusspokezarathustra1847]

@@srikanthsv79 Genius, Bangalore isn't entirety of India!

[@srikanthsv79]

@@thusspokezarathustra1847 except it's part of India & it did everything without Modi so proves it's not because of Modi or BJP though

[@spectrum1909]

​@@srikanthsv79Until recently it had a bjp government lmao.

[@srikanthsv79]

@@spectrum1909 startups have existed here since 80's when Modi wasn't even a thing

[@naturelover.3763]

If this is dictatorship then modi is not enough dictatorship we need more of it 😢

[@Tirth-Patel]

Indira Gandhi ke Emergency rule me bhi unke kattar supporters wahi bol rahe the. Aaj dekh Indira Gandhi ki legacy, emergency ki wajah se unhe lok pasand nahi karte.

[@Tirth-Patel]

@Titas20059 Of course, the rhetoric about 'dictatorship' is all exaggerated screeching for not being competitive enough to BJP, but it's also important to recognise the harms of authoritarianism of any form, especially when the constitutional institutions are allegedly misused for party's gain, I know it's been happening since day one, but still questioning and raising voice is important.

[@blessonvarghese1125]

I am an MSME. GST is so complex and fluctuating, it’s difficult to comply and has with flaws like double taxation.

[@chemalakondashravan8459]

what exact problems are you facing please let me know because i am a CMA final student and i have read GST act please let me know some situations which are causing you frustrations

[@abhinavvv_1]

​@@chemalakondashravan8459 binga, on the spot 😂😂👍🏼

[@skuller2032]

I am a CA student and GST literally counter the double taxation because of schedule 7 of the GST act. Counter it with facts please

[@Getfit_wid_batman]

This is how journalism must be done. Explain both the side and let people decide whom they want to lead. Great work!

[@RootedReflection-Official]

💯

[@TedoR2011]

He's just waiting for the feku creator award. Balancing act 😂

[@saurabhkumar-vt6im]

You want to see how he balanced himself so when he was discussing ECONOMIC INEQUALITY he didn't mention that people earning 25k per month comes under Top 10 percent of India 2 he never mentioned that the consumption expenditure of the bottom 10 and top 10 has a vast gap 3 when he was discussing the Rampant unemployment he never said that disguised unemployment problem in agriculture, stagnation of manufacturing and lay offs in service sector has increased. So he did good at balancing and when you are putting the facts then put is holisticaly and explicitly and then let the people decide These DAYS PEOPLE ARE LEARNING HISTORY GEOGRAPHY ECONOMICS AND OTHER STUFF IN 70 - 90 SEC

[@parthdave1827]

Exactly people like druv blem Indian news channels to get biased but but he also get biased we it comes to BJP. I had no problem with this video because he is telling truth without any masala. He is analyze both sides. Good work sir

[@ShriNidhi-zu2im]

Do you think he is creating balance! 😅

[@crickbull3456]

The Best Thing of Dictatorship Is Nobody talked about Sandeshkhali. No Mangal, Dhruv, Ravish, Ajit Anjum and you as well. So keep your Neutrality for yourself.

[@SurajThakare0]

Really I heard very little about it on KZbin only. Maybe it was instagram. I'll have to see

[@SurajThakare0]

Hey can you suggest any great source, when I search all news channels came up and I have hard time trusting them

[@CLOud-Ship-g6l]

You can check out deshbhakt on sandeshkhali

[@kakun63]

​@@SurajThakare0hmm nitish rajput he is neutral. If ur a patriot follow jaipur dialogues they are right wing but chew up bjp when they do bad.,Then buddy dont reap any opinion or video fact check it urself for example people say modi is dictator coz he removed cji from electing cheif election commission . Truth is for 75 years there was no rule and pm inducted directly sc intervention was temporary unless rule was made govt mad t a rule. Yes we can argue it should be transparent but blaming it on him is biasness

[@devadutts6888]

This is business channel and not a political channel To make videos on these topics.Even ganesh hasn't made A video on manipur or sandheshkali

[@tatsatsolanki9292]

The Manipur issue needs a whole video to make people understand what exactly is the dynamics of that land.... How three different communities are so divided from the colonial era that it is not easy to calm the situation. I request you to make a video on it! The history and what is the burning problem so that people can understand Manipur and its history.

[@HariKrishna-lk5wx]

This is economic channel for God's sake this is not channel to make vdeos on sandeshkali ad manipur stop it guyzz u ppl get triggered for no reason

[@rahul0898]

Tell your dhruv Rathi to make on it its business channel not propoganda channel

[@MDsahil77743]

cookies vs hindus

[@aayushmankatiyar5862]

watch Nitish Rajput for Manipur Incident.

[@ANKURTAH]

If India is going to be Dictatorship, then I really want this kind of Dictatorship in India..😍

[@omeckhawbung3676]

All i see is... Business class saying in favour of GST yes it is... But for the commoners GST has made a hell for our daily commodities...

[@FakeFake-j4y]

😂

[@damuvizianagaramap4530]

A hell for students life 😢

[@spiritofshadow4860]

I agree with you..they think only for their family ..instead of thinking it out of the box ..

[@Workindia29]

Why hell?

[@akankshaagarwal3302]

How did gst make life hell for you guys, students and commoners?

[@therandomthings6933]

On Manipur, Congress part doing dirty politics for two tribes issue, instead of supporting government to resolve issues. During Telangana agitation BJP supported Congress party to resolve issue between Andhra and Telangana.

[@ashish.k5529]

What is politics here Raising issue is not a bad thing 😅😅

[@Prince-ys7xg]

They are only raising issue and making it difficult for the ruling government...is this how an opposition should be???should they be thinking about coming to power only...or should they be working for the integrity and security of their nation regardless of whether they are ruling or not...​@@ashish.k5529

[@himanshusinghal242]

@@ashish.k5529 politics is that Manipur isssue is not a new issue. it exist since independece, and congress stopped it in 2008 by promising solution. but in 9 years of congress (congress has state goverment in manipur till 2017), no a signle progress was made. Manipur issue is fight between two (three of you include naga) gangsters; not attack on a peaceful community by a voilent community.

[@ashish.k5529]

@@himanshusinghal242 dude modi can stop Ukraine Russia war Then why is he not able to control it😛

[@anon4685]

​@@ashish.k5529are u in manipur now?

[@SafiurRahman-s7n]

"Democracy is not just about voting, it's about ensuring that people's voices are heard." ~BR Ambedkar

[@pavanajsridhar939]

Yeah and the Same person destroyed education…. What’s ur ducking point?

[@santhoshkumar1000]

Don't quote his quotes, he was not worth to remember.

[@eyemyou6590]

How?​@@pavanajsridhar939

[@Aman-pr3po]

You guys need to study about Ambedkar keeping your personal biases aside

[@abhinavmaharaj4804]

@@pavanajsridhar939 wtf bro , u clearly no nothing about him then

[@neelghosh4979]

I'm more worried about Congress manifesto, they will destroy our economy. Wealth distribution and too much freebies will stop our growth. I don't understand why Opposition doesn't have long term vision for india?

[@LalitKumar-bz1cv]

Right 😢

[@arunkurian9367]

Then ask govt to stop collecting taxes if freebies are the problem😅

[@neelghosh4979]

​​@@arunkurian9367 according to you Government taking tax only for freebies? What about infrastructure, healthcare, defence, industry, internal security etc. Government should focus on these things more, unlimited freebies is dangerous for the economy. Look at the situation of West Bengal, Kerala, Karnataka.

[@HariKrishna-lk5wx]

​@@neelghosh4979I'm ain't against taxes but luk @ the indirect taxes we are paying in India a tax even for a water bottle parle g biscuit dude the middle class is being bleeded in india to run govt😢

[@rajtharun7883]

​@@arunkurian9367dude you are lost. Congress will ruin the country of the give freebies. It's will have the same state of my state Kerala. Which is in the verge of bankruptcy

[@sam_bamon]

We need more videos like this to spread awareness. Just amazing. ❤

[@dwivedikaustuv]

The amount of research Ganesh Bhai did for this video, I don't think Congress did even half of it while writing Black Paper !!

[@ISHIKABotany]

Congress has their own plethora of national and international NGOs😅, I doubt, if Congress had read any one of its pages.

[@dwivedikaustuv]

@@ISHIKABotany Yes. I do feel the same for it's manifesto too.

[@sarvajanhitaay]

GST made our life better Because of 1. single portal to pay it 2. due to digitization it is easier to reconcile data correctly. 3. I can chose as MSME for monthly or quarterly filing of GST. 4. Having waiver for export is easier.

[@NetherFortress-vl5fo]

GST did not affected nepo kids it affected middle and poor class

[@abhishekmahadik5919]

​@@NetherFortress-vl5fo Can u please explain how?

[@Chemistryscore]

How ??​@@NetherFortress-vl5fo

[@MikeMessiah]

@@abhishekmahadik5919 it destroyed small business and the unorganised sector. People on youtube usually dont belong to the poor class so they only see the bright side of GST.

[@Voiceofsanatani]

These poor people you saying was paying cst in prior to GST ​@@MikeMessiah

[@KshitijMadduri]

Yes! This is the POV of a young entrepreneur who had set up 3 companies in the past 4 years. The GST compliance and company incorporation has been a very straightforward and transparent process since everything is digital. While applying for GST licence we had used an agent (minimal cost) but since then no other additional costs as I do the filing and payment myself. Obviously, I cannot compare how this fares against the old system, but I can definitely vouch that the new GST system requires a minimal learning curve for regular filing and can be done by the business owners themselves. SInce everything is digital it is a very seamless process that reduces any instance of corruption from local beaurocrats.

[@gautamwadhwani4394]

You dropped this 🧠 when you said that bottom 50% paying more tax is better. They are paying more GST not more income tax which means that basic essentials are being taxed more than luxury items which will further increase the rich poor gap

[@TheNiceshow.]

use your ears to hear

[@leerockx357]

Check out gst rates of essential items vs non essentials and then rant.

[@gautamwadhwani4394]

@@leerockx357 Those who can afford non essentials can also afford 1% extra GST

[@leerockx357]

@@gautamwadhwani4394 which they are paying - atta @5% and gold @15%.

[@gautamwadhwani4394]

@@leerockx357 Education 18% diamond 3%

[@prakashbishwal2770]

This is good that both parties are providing atleast data based information. Thank you for decoding it .

[@StayAware9]

Rahul Gandhi should become a chief minister first then he should talk about bureaucracy and implementation of government schemes.Congress Party's repeated choice of Rahul Gandhi as the face for 2024 elections echoes their 2014 & 2019 strategies. This lack of fresh leadership alternatives in Indian opposition weakens democracy. BJP's unopposed rise highlights the need for change beyond familial loyalty.

[@psingh007]

Aukaat nahin hai uski

[@maxverstapanfromkerala]

Okay, bro we need more washing machines

[@Sailed_away]

there is NO requirement for being a CM to become the PM , we had PMs before who didn't serve as CM. moreover he involved heavily in UPA 1 and 2.

[@mayank.9203]

He is not even good enough to retain a historical seat of congress , amethi , he lost it to an outside like smriti Irani.

[@syedmedia3573]

Already Rahul Gandhi has put Congress government in Karnataka and we are very happy with new government ❤❤

[@va8085]

Finally someone like Ganesh is coming up with a video on this topic. Hope it’s objective & not based on fraud subjective international rankings like v-dem etc.

[@AdityaKumar-qu7jv]

Why do you need v dem when you can clearly see arrest and killings happening ?

[@va8085]

@@AdityaKumar-qu7jvarrest & killings? What are you talking about?

[@akshayshastri6498]

@@AdityaKumar-qu7jv just go and search who funds v dem, open society foundation which is goerge soros

[@AdityaKumar-qu7jv]

​@@va8085arrests of ministers, journalists, encounter of criminals, even journalists

[@akshaybengaluru1212]

Ganesh is just reading out the black paper released by Cong which is baseless. Hence it's more biased to jobless Cong. BJP has given clear cut and stringent report on the wrongdoing of Cong. He doesn't emphasize on Cong misrule.

[@shibili_poompatta2]

I appreciate your efforts to stay neutral and simplify the issues at hand. In my opinion, the current government has made significant strides in infrastructure development, international relations, foreign reserves, and Make in India projects. However, there are still pressing issues such as lack of employment, inadequate medical assistance, security concerns in certain states, bias against minorities, and the troubling trend of mob lynching based on prejudice. It is important for us to address these issues and work towards a more inclusive and progressive society. We need a more skill-oriented education system that prepares students for the future job market, especially in fields like AI. Government schools and colleges should make better use of technology and innovation in their teaching methods. We should strive for a society where everyone has equal opportunities and where individuals are not forced to work for low wages. Let's work together to create a brighter future for all. 😊

[@alexjoseph5542]

As my opinion , I can’t say the current government is the best government ,but current government is the best when it compared to the previous governments 👍

[@rickghosh9278]

I agree

[@BeingStoic086]

agreed

[@HINDUrashtra....365]

We need this govt 🚩..for our economic growth....

[@BLINKSMART]

​@@HINDUrashtra....365and for Ladakh exploitation we need this government

[@Burnido]

@@BLINKSMART ladakh is the issue that need time to solve , because i dont find govt wrong here neither people wrong here , and we cannot give article 5

[@__ansh]

Bhaiya you are the only one who is sharing both side arguments. Other KZbinr(s) like (Dhruv Rathee) is showing just one side of opinion. I mean they are leaning toward one side and clearly showing that current government is fully corrupt. They are not showing corruption or bad decision taken by other parties. You rock👏👏👌

[@maxverstapanfromkerala]

Thanks for showing BJP, and BJP leaders only. Or else people will think we are biased

[@kshitijonkar5223]

yes because andh-bhakts don't accept truth and most of the media is ONLY praising ruling party. It is important to criticize ruling party and accept reality.

[@jenitdoshi3169]

Dhruv Tatti is a perfect synonym for him.. Staying out of India and showing as if he understands India and its complexities perfectly.. Gyan zero banne chala hero

[@PR-ol2hr]

​@@jenitdoshi3169 you are right

[@sujitparida2501]

​@@jenitdoshi3169bhai uske analogies toh out of the world hai🤣🤣..kbhi wo ramayan nd spiderman ko compare krdeta hai...abhi wo karan thaoar ko burger wala analogy de rha thaa....wo apne guru ravish kumar ki tarah hi narcissist haii

[@Instinctivefarming]

Iam a ca inter student and my 20years experienced teacher taught that GST is really a game changer for small business men...in terms of introduction like composition levy scheme and many more.... GST is way better than any taxation system india ever been operated on

[@sidra1401]

its good no doubt from revenue perspective to Govt but its really not based on the idea of 'Justice, Equity and Fairness' since its not progressive in nature

[@lubdub01001]

first tell me why are you doing CA how does it help you a natural farmer :)

[@ashwinimanwatkar4359]

The smaller businessman ran out of business ..check the ground reality

[@BuJyo]

talking about vishal bhattad?

[@Instinctivefarming]

@@sidra1401 ohh I see

[@arvindk29]

Liked your unbiased analysis. Other you- tubers shall learn from you.

[@SamarthAcharya-th7sl]

Thank you for making such unbiased episodes Ganesh sir. I'm 21 years old law student. Earlier when I didn't had internet access, I used to watch only mainstream media who only used to praise the government. After the access, I observed that majority of internet was against the government. Then I found you. Your whole team helped me to critically analyse both goods and bads of the government and opposition and formed opinion based on facts💯.

[@rishabjain8975]

Then according to u who is good

[@Ace78928]

dude if you want neutral perspective of anything watch nitish rajput and sham sharma show .

[@thesaint9286]

​@@rishabjain8975 Its a fake profile, check it out. Must be BJP IT cell.

[@maxverstapanfromkerala]

Thanks for the washing machines

[@Tirth-Patel]

Sham Sharma Show, really? Nitish Rajput is understandable.​@@Ace78928

[@crazyrj6899]

Bro smartly escaped the controversy 😂 without any damage done to him

[@aumprajapatii]

Exactly!! Thats what I was thinking too...😂

[@No_One1231]

Well it's not his job to tell you which side to choose. His job is to state facts and let you decide who's right and who's wrong, which he's doing right now. So what's wrong lol

[@arijit1809]

That's not his job to choose sides, it's yours after watching the video

[@swapstaps]

I run a small scale IT company. I gotta say, there is no taxation system simpler than GST. GST is exactly what India needed when it was engulfed in loads of direct and indirect taxation which was very difficult to manage. There is a reason that most developed countries is the world have employed GST system. There will be challenges at start when you do a project of this scale, but that's the way for future.

[@supersathvik2091]

Hi, I'm a 2024 soon to be graduate from btech in CSE department from Andhra Pradesh. Please let me know if you have any vacancies for 2024 pass-out freshers in your company.

[@voyager43]

😂us bhai us​@@supersathvik2091

[@prasadambrule2133]

That's true

[@ЭдгарРожков]

​@@supersathvik2091If he is a bot he wouldn't answer.

[@Shahhussain1-x4h]

What's the turnover of the company?

[@avengergirl_0464]

This is really most unbiased video 🔥❤ Great Work !

[@Sanatani_Sherni]

NO GERMAN SHEPHERDS WERE HARMED IN THE MAKING OF THIS VIDEO ❤

[@Suiiii12_7]

It bots are getting crazy it's 7 comment from this account

[@amaycraft7039]

what about u german bot

[@JJay1823]

@@Suiiii12_7 So this means you are also a bot, reading and replying to other bots...

[@TheChronicle_edit]

tu fir aa gyi school se bhag ke?😡

[@maxverstapanfromkerala]

Yeah, we need more washing machines

[@Sanatani_Sherni]

Sardar Patel was a great person, and you cannot compare him with any other freedom fighter. His achievements are indeed significant and essential for the Indian subcontinent. Being the strong political leader and merging 555 princely states in the Indian Republic is a significant achievement under his belt, and that’s why the people started calling him as the Iron Man of India.

[@aravindhanv]

Even that great Patel considered Gandhi to be a better / more effective leader and followed his leadership. That should tell you something.

[@nikhildharra-4345]

@@aravindhanv so what , is that gandhi still alive? all i see a single corrupt family using his last name and ideology to get votes.

[@plusultra7258]

@@aravindhanv Because Gandhi was non-violent. That does not mean he is a good leader

[@Bruh01699]

@@aravindhanv no? Gandhi literally put him down, he was going to be the first prime minister of India but he made Nehru the pm. Its literally wrong data.

[@redefined4657]

And he wanted to ban RSS. Shows that hyper-nationalism is strength for some and exclusion for others who are not included in the narrative.

[@cleanmessengers]

I campaigned for this dictatorship in 2014 during engineering college days .... Long live people's Dictator❤

[@mk6049]

Op bro😅

[@MaoThakur]

Blind devotee, Godi supporter

[@unknown.145gvgugbj]

@@MaoThakur Yeah like you are khangress supporter

[@MaoThakur]

@@unknown.145gvgugbj Yes I support secular party. Not uneducated politicians

[@sameerkakkar8554]

@@MaoThakur Bjp is way more secular than any party of indi alliance there are many instances when leaders of indi alliance demean and abuse people for their religion but there is not a single instance when a leader of bjp abused any religion. this is not only limited to abuses and slangs even the policies and laws made by leaders of indi alliance are anti secular

[@iamyouu]

Actually it's not unemployement that needs to be addressed but the employability, the skillset of many recent grads and under grads is so awful they can't apply basic abcs of their major. Now they go to other countries and actually really study hard there and then get the skillset and work overseas. This is not a systemic problem but a societal issue. One cannot employ someone who cannot work

[@sahilvij7]

Thanks for the unbiased video 👍

[@sahilvij7]

But as a leader Modi is far better than opposition leaders 😅

[@sahilvij7]

I will vote for BJP now 👍

[@sahilvij7]

@@EDUCATIONISTHEKEYTOSUCCESS415 Congress menifesto if implemented then middle class will destroyed and more communal problem will arise 🥲

[@sudit011]

That's what true educated liberal guy who helps the indians to know the reality not like Dhruv rathee , deshbhakt etc . who are showing half facts and nor like other youtubers who blindfoldly following the ruling government.. Keep it up bro , you are continuously winning our heart ❤️

[@kisansantosh9127]

Watch this video again😂😂😂, then comment 😂. He almost said the same thing like dhruv and deshbhakt.

[@akshaykumarsingh9879]

i have one argument, dhruv said that he works for no political party , but he was working for aap, how tf is he unbaised

[@sudit011]

@@akshaykumarsingh9879 that aint argument , he is biased bro

[@sudit011]

@@kisansantosh9127 see the difference is dhruv, deshbhakt don't show or appreciate good things of govt , they only work on their agenda and i.e how to fool people and Target only bjp

[@mk6049]

@@kisansantosh9127 i want to ask you one thing bro …..dhruv ne nationalism and patriotism ko measles se compare kiya tha ek time pr and aaj wo patriotism dikha raha h ……kya iska matalb saaf ni h ki wo brainwashing krta h maipulate krta h

[@aditya.lakhani]

12:30; while I was pursuing MBA, one of my professors of International Business explained that because our country couldn't be a part of any international community like it has been of ASEAN, it is really diffucult for us to attract manufacturers. Simply because these communities have mutual understanding of stuff like import duty, ease of import/export etc. In my opinion, the current government is really trying to attract manufacturers, but we had golden oppotunity from 2005 to 2010 and we missed it.

[@deepajmera3359]

man our people want growth like capitalists but want policies like socialist and communists, and with a diverse population like india it is very easy to group people out based on caste, religion, region etc to divert them from major issues.

[@realityshow1016]

What about 18% Gst In Education 😢 Education Must Be Free From All The Taxes

[@murthys743]

education is a business , accept the reality, and taxing it , we can get money to teach poor students in gov skl for free

[@jayantsurana]

GST is actually great for me as a proprietor. I can claim the ITC for my purchase and get goods for a cheaper rate when I buy for my business needs.

[@lokeshv2238]

Hi bro, For your question i can answer Yes, GST made business taxes simpler. I don't know about the mindset of small business, startups and MSME owners. I work as a finance executive in a IT startup in Bengaluru. I am responsible to file taxes and have filed for many companies as freelancer for small companies. The owners say that GST have made the tax payment simpler eliminating coruuption and complex network. Many people are happy with GST . Its useful for small business.

[@sumitac503]

Unbiased . It is essential for a good democracy to question the governance. More such voice like Think School need to increase.

[@coupe97]

True, hopefully we will get a really genuine opposition one day, cuz the current opposition is not at par with current government. They need to get good people on their part and a great learder

[@sumeetmoray]

The only video i saw till date that is impartial and isn't biased on one side ... Greatly appreciated ... Keep up the good work 👍👍👍

[@harshajain8979]

We need to have media channel like this so that each and every citizen of India is well informed and more focused on facts and data rather than being on any political side. We as a citizen of India, need to do more thorough analysis in addition to collects sources and opinions from these informative YT channels. Thankyou @thinkschool for the information.

[@anshkumawat1548]

The Clear & true Analysis by Thinkschool 👍🏻 ,

[@annie.2022]

Dear Think School, I think while discussing such topics, we need to discuss 1. Scams made by UPA Government that ate all the common people money 2. Foreign Relationships improved by NDA Government which avoided war and made our lives peaceful 3. India is moving to self reliant phase, by increasing young entrepreneurs 4. Which section or community of the country has more unemployment. Because, one popular community has no control on population increase and if they claim unemployment, it is wrong. 5. Unemployment should be analyzed with respect to the population growth. Indian population increased drastrically in the past 10 years.

[@laxmiprasadkonduru816]

On top of it, the merit people are suffering because of reservation.. The reservation must be given only based on financial status not based on caste or religion.. This is the reason, merit people are leaving country for the sake of survival.. but all political parties ready to provide reservations based on caste/religion especially congress is in front line.

[@fayyazhilal]

The majority of suicides committed by unemployed youth of tolerant community. Not the community you are talking about. 😂😂

[@mridulsarmah2939]

Please provide data which says that India's population has grown exponentially since 2014.

[@siddharthk2304]

Amazing job man! I thought I'd never see a practical, realistic and neutral reporter again. Kudos!!

[@Bi_Pro]

The #opposition was insulting the #NewEducationPolicy #NEP telling it was a terrible idea, I'm a student studying in Bsc. With NEP courses trust me i can never be more faithful to our #BJP government & #Modi ji , my seniors used to study just nothing but notes, today I'm studying about Blood composition Preperation, How to do XRay & USG & SO MUCH MORE #ThankYou #Modi ji #NAMO ❤❤

[@NerdCentral_]

Nep will make the disadvantaged communities children's education worse

[@srilakshmidevanathan8334]

​@@NerdCentral_ Kindly Elaborate. This is a complete new perspective I haven't heard of till now.

[@kvk2606]

Kuch Bhi

[@spectrum1909]

How? Reservation is there. Mtlb kuch v fek do​@@NerdCentral_

[@sushantpandey897]

​@@NerdCentral_kindly explain your insights.

[@jasveer4074]

There are various other important reasons for unemployment- 1. Huge Population- India's youth population and population in general is on record breaking scale. 2. Unskilled youth- Most of the youth in their college prime time is busy on reels and distractions. There is only handful of students who train themselves to get placed and face competition in the market. 3. Inflation- It's the worldwide wave currently, companies laying off employees on large extent. 4. Exams- Many among the unemployed youth are not seeking job, many of them are preparing for various exams, be it govt exams, forces, cat, gate, etc. 5. Delays- As soon as industries and companies will start getting easy and early permits to clear the required paperwork, sooner will the work began and will provide employment.

[@balasubramanianthiruppathi7369]

Due to COVID-19. also lots of companies closed, so that lost their jobs

[@objectsmedia4523]

Quality of education many have gained is absolutely garbage, the grasp of English or engineering is unemployable. This has been mentioned many times by top companies. Once higher education is taken they will only do job inside office or wait for government sector which is not sustainable

[@purvasawant6169]

Rightly put and promising jobs to an overly increasing population is setting up very high expectations. In reality there are many other factors including the ones you noted Govt. should take care of and work accordingly.

[@studyAt6]

i totally agree with You , ill like to add that we will not be able to do anything concrete on employment front in this times as AI is doing jobs of 10 people and simultaneously populating is booming, people are living long. Untill and unless we decrease our population in Net terms this will keep happening no matter the Gov in power. I do not have data to suggest but i feel Around 100cr is a good population threshold for india.

[@gtmsddrtheva]

We also need to consider that a lot of new gig jobs were created because of internet penetration. No matter how it's perceived but jobs created by logistics companies, quick commerce, 2w and 4w cab drivers, food delivery apps, content creators, editors, animators and and all the micro businesses which popped up due to the internet. But all of these do not come in the radar of conventional employment measuring frameworks. Most of these guys are making better money then entry level jobs at IT Giants. But yes, the problem with these jobs is they may not have long term career paths laid out. But that's a second tier problem. They do put food on the table.

[@AnupKayande]

Congress doesn't say GST is bad. In fact, the GST bill was tabled in Parliament in 2011 (and was opposed). The Congress talks about its implementation. The GST slabs and the commodities under them keep on changing. It is necessary to have a single GST in India. Then only can businesses prosper. For example, food attracts 5% GST whereas the baby food (Cerelac etc.) attracts 18% GST.

[@balajidbv]

No German Shepherd was hurt in this video. 😂

[@ankitvasman3928]

besides few andh bhakts I guess.

[@arpitsadariya201]

Jali na dono ki jali na😂

[@kiranova153]

Don't bark 😂😂😂

[@KuldeepYadav-161]

German shepherd of Indian breed 😂

[@arpitsadariya201]

@@kiranova153 you too my 🐶 friend

[@devanshlakhotia3813]

it’s not GST which made our life difficult, but per say the regular amendments. For small business owners like us it is not possible to have a very equipped accounts team, we have to rely on our CA ( who works part time ). Moreover when we saw couple of CA’s fighter over the effect of an amendment, this exacerbated our concern. If the community dealing directly with it is not clear how small business owners such as us can understand this. For example. I have heard many people being slapped with fine for delayed filing of GSTR9. Fines have been served for not filing GSTR9 of 2017 in 2023. Without any notice in the years in between.

[@Ronit_9977]

In short :- Unemployment Taxation (Sir pointed his point) GST (Sir pointed his point) Exports (down in terms of percentage of GDP) Well fare scheme point (not proper spending) Democracy (destroyed) Internal issue (Manipur) Though I am a BJP supporter, but I also agree that Unemployment is an issue as well as internal security is also need to be worked. Naxals are also a major issue in central Indian region. Edit: The two things I had mentioned in second paragraph is what I felt genuine, rest I am just telling what was there in Video, I don't fully agree with them as there is other picture of logic also exist in it.

[@rishabjain8975]

😂😂

[@andha_kanoon]

If we go by the video, you are dumb for saying democracy has been destroyed - as the video says 😂

[@arunkris7299]

You guys don't know what freedom and democracy is, kindly visit china, there the govt will decide how much child you should have, people can't own a land only they can lease, private sector had always risk of shut down by govt which leads to massive umployment, if you have enough skills you will be employed

[@smartbuys3118]

I am not defending anyone but-- Unemployment - Exponential rise in population, post COVID and multiple wars causing economic slowdown in world, and AI which is taking over jobs across the world

[@smartbuys3118]

2) Taxes- just see the comments section of GST is good or bad

[@vikramganesh3095]

Summary: Unemployment has increased Investigation authorities are misused GST has made things difficult? (Data not reliable) Manufacturing sector contribution to the GDP has reduced from 16 to 13% in 10yrs National security (Manipur issue not taken care of)

[@kellai1959]

I am from manipur ur data about manipur is somewat mistaken.. Nearly 60 thousand people displaced and over 200 people were killed while the central government remains as spectator as nothing happens to the citizen of India... They are playing electoral politics on both hills and valley

[@spectrum1909]

They are closing the border with Myanmar to stop illegal immigration.

[@SaifKhan-gc6os]

He is a gootuber so showing reality is not his job but to manipulate the audience

[@daaxab]

Of course, this video is made by a person who supports BJP and the video itself is a red herring to take your attention off all the corruption that Modi and his party has done over the last ten years.

[@tengames2982]

U did the disaster by burning and killing manipur and blame the govt waoooo ...thinking the people hv with St status and all hv brought u here ....don't blame everything to govt ..instead of both the community sit and talk calmly with their problems they started killing each other ..and here some are blaming govt ...shame on u

[@kellai1959]

@@tengames2982 when civillian property were burned down why don't this government didn't interfare to protect the civillian property. Law and order is state subject and it's their responsibility to protect civillian but they failed... Isn't it not reasonable to blame for govt for the conflict not the civillian. And india is regarded one of the finest military power. Why can't they interfare this present conflict and result for peaceful coexistence for both the community. They remain spectator for both the community civillian dying

[@yashraj4288]

Hello Think School looking at your comment section,I think u have made the most matured audience in indian yt community. As always keep educating.❤

[@Sahil-11-kr]

​@@maheshkurana5809 He is not like your Godfather Dhruv, who even blocks people from commenting on his videos.

[@yadaardhavaadhi]

Go and check nso data bro ​@@maheshkurana5809 he is lifting data some where on his own.

[@yashraj4288]

​@@maheshkurana5809 how do u know?? Secondly i am not interested in politics

[@prashastithakkar1876]

​​@@maheshkurana5809let me tell you my comments are blocked by your so called neutral, unbiased German shepherd 🥱

[@mayankjha3563]

Hi Think School team, i am thankful for the content you keep bringing, i have some video recommendations for you: 1. Manifesto analysis of all political parties in this lok sabha elections and its feasibility to be implemented. 2. Whats the whole thing around land acquisition laws and how are they becoming a hurdle in our development. 3. Why does judiciary take so much time in delivering justice and how did we end up on such massive pending cases in our judicial system and its possible solutions. A video on these issues will really help us, hence i request you to please take it into consideration. Regards, Student, Think School

[@Sumanth33-q9j]

very interesting topics

[@ASeeker-9999]

I think he talked about land pool in Gujarat where the government acquires land n keeps its ready for the companies when they want to invest.

[@mayankjha3563]

@@ASeeker-9999 i feel land acquisition hurdle is more than that, in the podcast with nitin gadkariji, there was a moment where this topic was discussed but it was juat for 15 to 20 seconds

[@ASeeker-9999]

@@mayankjha3563 oh ok. Thanks. I haven’t watched it yet. It would be good if they did a similar plan for the rest of the states!

[@KunalKumar-oe4ni]

Nice to see that think school believes that Soch does a commendable job when it comes to explaining the political situation of India. These are only two channels that I watch and I feel that they always have a balanced opinion which makes me believe that these channels aren't biased. Calling things out correctly and understanding the desires of the masses is something that this country desperately needs

[@Rahulsharma80558]

German shepherd ke followers Ganesh ko ye b nahi bol skte thats why education is important sarr😂😂

[@nikhildeshmukh6221]

Din bhar Pakistani content dekhne wale andhbhakt😂.... Sach pehachana ki nahin maine?)

[@cannibalgaming3752]

Vhai video dekha accha se what he meant? Or you are bot?

[@amaycraft7039]

@@nikhildeshmukh6221 anbhakt bol deta hu cool lagunga🤡🤡..

[@varundave6860]

​@@cannibalgaming3752still better than German shepherd propoganda University students 😂😂😂

[@Rahulsharma80558]

@@cannibalgaming3752 i watched it carefully.. he decoded the black paper released by Congress 🤡 In one of their allegations even think school wasn't able to find a credible source for that.. even though think school is known for its deep research.. And ganesh disagreed on the tax payers allegations also.. While i agree that the BJP didn't focus much on manufacturing which will create Mass jobs.. but you also need to understand that in the manufacturing sector, aisa nahi h ki kahi h muhh utake manufacturing unit khadi kardo.. the main thing is infrastructure and land acquisition and other things such as water and electricity supply 24/7.. Central government ne bahot bdhia kan kiya h highways wgera bnane mein everyone praises nitin gadkari... Esliye infrastructure ke baad hi dheere dheere investments aani shuru huyi h.. jaise ki latest news mein Elon musk aa raha h manufacturing unit kholne . A huge chunk of apple iphone assembling is done in india now... Main maanta hu ki bjp ko ye cheez bahot pehle karni chayie thi covid se pehle tak lekin ye baat b toh gaur karne walli h ki agar Central government ne apna kaam theek se nahi kiya toh jo har state mein alag alag government bni baithi h woh kya jhakk marne ke liye h 🤡 Unka kam sirf tax collect karke bakchodi karna h kya,?? Mera conclusion ye h ki agar criticise karna h toh har party ko karo . Aisa nahi ki bol bachan ban jao jab BJP ke upar baat ho lekin Congress TMC AAP ki baari mein gunge ban jao.. Main BJP ka follower hu lekin main manta hu ki bahot sectors mein woh naakam rahi h.. lekin dusra option kya h BJP ki jagah?? Congress ??🤡🤡 Jinka har saal naya scam nikal ke aata tha.. commonwealth games tak ko nahi shoda 🤡 eska Padnana PM tha eski Dadi PM thi eska baap PM tha aur abb ye khud pm banne ke sapne dekhta h.. nepo product se toh 1000 guna behtar h bjp

[@thegreatindia1947]

Ab jinke era me 97% tax rate tha wo tax terrorism ki bat karenge 😂

[@rishabjain8975]

Purani baat chodo naya menifesto padho😂😂. They will take money from rich and Middle class and give to poor and they call others tax terrorism 😂

[@AjayKumar-yv3yg]

​@@rishabjain8975 go and watch Sam pitroda interview he said middle class should give more taxes don't be selfish

[@rishabjain8975]

@@AjayKumar-yv3yg 🤣🤣🤣then why they cry over tax terrorism. I have seen that. Congress is always hypocrite

[@Sanskarmodi16]

Looking at the opposition leaders, we are left with no choice.

[@kumar.193]

Is it no choice or opposition is silenced?

[@princeyranjan-np6ld]

​@@kumar.193no choice..... Congress ne jaise statements ram mandir and 370 abolish ke time deye hai uske baad vo option me se kbka ht chuka hai.... Aam aadmi party option tha bt usne Congress ke alliance bna leya aur waise bi Congress option me ni tha AAP uske saath mil kr khud bi option se ht gya.... Mere state me jo government hai vo criminals ko zayada security and priority deti hai common civilization se toh waise bi unko vote Dene se rhe.....BJP ke baad koi major party mere leye toh option me ni hai....hn baki Jo small parties hai unke bare me socha Jaa skta hai

[@pujaridevanjagadeesan2170]

It is better to avoid Modi and making the india worse . Big time lier and dictator . Only marketing no real achievement

[@rti630]

​@@princeyranjan-np6ldsara Gunda to Bjp join kr liya hai abhi...ab congress hi better hai

[@gowrinaidu921]

GST could be better but, not on some specific human needs as i'm farmer's son i suffered to buy pesticides with extra cost(GST ) on that. Human basic need i.e food as i'm from lower middle family i'm suffering to buy food and other necessary items. It's really hard to live.

[@prachiverma0209]

You have got brilliant diplomatic skills. Your point on bipolar opinions shown by the media is 100% agreeable. Thank you so much for this video. Great Job !!👏👏

[@Hussainaminshah776]

Nahi dega😂

[@neerajshukla9516]

Thanks a lot! Please also make a detailed study of Manifestos of INDIA and NDA alliance!

[@GaffurGhisela]

As a nation, our journey has just begin. We have to do a lot of hard work to develop our nation, improve the condition of our people. The Modi government policies and achievements make us hopeful about bright future of our country. We got to see immence infrastructure development, record breaking investment in key sectors like chip manufacturing, EVs, green energy. Who could think that one day we would manufacture Semiconductor chips and I Phones. Our exports has been multiplied, agriculture sector is continuosly growing. We have made millions of people come out of poverty, There is nothing wrong in choosing Narendra Modi for third time. 😊❤❤

[@adityaabroal2896]

Have you seen the data . In the shown manufacturing share in GDP has decreased and about your comments journey has began - it's to build nation so in 70 years nothing was done our country would be like sirya not India. Please come out of your Bubble and see things rationally.

[@frustratedmind2772]

Because of us we want job only Not to become entrepreneur

[@adityaabroal2896]

Either you are a bot/IT cell because you can't understand what I said above. Check the data we have 50 years minimum household savings. Education inflation is at more then 10% per year. Medical Inflation is more then 10%.Retail inflation is at peak. We are really doomed.

[@Shubham-yc6nz]

Think school considers arguments from both side of coin and not like German Shepard trying to brain wash indian youth. BTW He has been brain washing from 2016 ? There's something black in the dal of german shepard.

[@RohitKumar-ml4hu]

​@@adityaabroal2896people who never seen poverty because they're born in good family they only blame poor for being poor.

[@KCTSANTHOSHS]

bro did they actually included the informal economy of India I think it would contribute 45 % at Indian GDP and if so what about the informal workers engaged in this workforce , if I'm wrong please clarify

[@MrBlackjack456]

1. What specific data sources or methodologies were used by Congress to calculate the unemployment figures? Are there any alternative estimates or perspectives on the unemployment situation? 2. While the video mentions tax burden falling disproportionately on the middle and lower classes, what is the rationale or justification provided by the government for the current tax structure? Are there any plans to address income inequality? 3. Regarding the 'Make in India' initiative, what are the specific challenges faced by businesses in terms of ease of doing business and land acquisition? What steps is the government taking to address these issues? 4. For the underspending on welfare schemes, are there any reasons provided by the government for the underutilization of allocated funds? What are the bottlenecks or implementation challenges? 5. On the alleged misuse of investigative agencies, are there any specific cases or instances cited in the black paper? How does the government respond to these allegations? 6. In the case of Manipur violence, what is the government's perspective on the handling of the situation? Are there any logistical or operational challenges that may have hindered a quicker response? 7. Are there any independent or non-partisan sources that corroborate or contradict the claims made in the black paper? 8. What are the counterarguments or rebuttals provided by the BJP or the government in response to the criticisms raised in the black paper? 9. Are there any alternative policy measures or solutions proposed in the black paper to address the issues highlighted? 10. How does the performance of the current government compare to previous administrations on the issues highlighted in the black paper?

[@AdityaChaudhary-oo7pr]

You can do your own research quite fast to answer most of the questions !!

[@MrBlackjack456]

@@AdityaChaudhary-oo7pr try answering a few questions yourself. Log trigger hone ke liye tayyar baithe rehte hai.

[@AdityaYadav-nv7sb]

Ajit Pawar: PM Modi himself said that he is involved in a scam of 7,00,00,00,00,000 CR ( remember the Modi dialogue of "" Chaki piising and pissing"") and ED was investigating him but as soon as he joined BJP his case was moved under the rug, No Progress has been made since then Ajit Pawar : scam of 840 cr ( BJP made a huge deal about it ) CBI was investigating but as soon as he joined BJP his file was closed Hemant Biswa: scam of Agricultural land and Irrigation but he joined BJP and was made CM 23/25 Opposite leaders (who joined BJP recently) got clean chit or no investigation got stopped from ED CBI Every party uses Gov. Machinery against opposition but under Modi ji 95% of ED cases are against opposition leaders with conviction % of ~ 0.6% 83 MLAs of BJP Have serious criminal cases against them highest among all parties The problem with the BJP is that they think people are fools ( some are) that's why they hide data and use Hindu Muslim to divert attention BJP target AAP over freebies but they are also giving free ration to 80 cr people meanwhile they claim that poverty has declined in India to only 12% so why give ration to more than 50% of the population either the poverty data is fake or this is rewdi Congress is no saint either but They are not in power BJP is

[@venkatasubramanianshanmuga7032]

People like you are proving that future of India is in Good hands🫡 What a bold video🔥 proud of you Think school🙏

[@coderpritam9119]

Haha manipur dekh😂 bhai

[@devaroraa]

@@coderpritam9119 afspa laga hua h vha kya dkhna h ab?

[@coderpritam9119]

@@devaroraa he is talking about right hand so answer is there

[@Slayup_13]

​@@coderpritam9119 Tell the manipuri women not to stop the 🪖 while entering

[@devaroraa]

@@coderpritam9119 brother there are both good and bad instaces by BJP but if you look at the overall status as compared to others, BJP is better

[@TheSapta15]

Leaving aside the amazing analysis by Thinkschool, It's a shame I have to come to KZbin to get balanced exposure to the governance of my government while mainstream media is called the 4th pillar. More power to you @ThinkSchool!! Hope you reach all corners of our country! Not only the KZbin audiences!

[@LAVANYA_LAKSHMANAN]

I am surprised to see that no one talks about cash flow and locking up of additional funds due to GST. In addition, there is a burden of interest on the additional funds if the fund is raised through loans. High GST rates of 18% and more have affected cash flow, with monthly filings locking up funds upfront. Delayed payments from customer further exacerbate the situation (generally payment terms are 2 to 3 months, in addition the customer can delay payments further). VAT was 5% for majority products before GST but the high GST lock up the funds and hence the cash flow is highly impacted. The businesses needs to file GST every month and lock up their funds. Even if they miss twice, they will not be able to generate eway bill and they face consequences. But if the Govt needs to refund GST, it is a very complex process!

[@MangaLocalisation]

No I think you can file GST Return Monthly, Quarterly, Half-yearly or Yearly as per the size of your business

[@aadityadengle]

The business cycle involves conducting trade or business transactions where parties agree on payments. Government regulations typically don't dictate specific time frames for payments or billing. If someone struggles to recover funds or offers extensive credit, it's their responsibility. Moreover, if filings are done monthly, it allows for availing Input Tax Credit (ITC) regularly, thus easing the financial burden.

[@muddassirmohiuddin3511]

All I know is that the lifestyle of a common man in urban cities has grown significantly in the past 10 years. Just for example, the number of cars middle-class people are purchasing and the stylish model of the cars that car brands are launching in India is a thing that no one can deny. Yes, the present government hasn't performed well in some sectors, but the overall economic growth is significant, and many sectors have grown significantly for example, Aviation, Automobile, Marine Industry, Telecommunication and many more.

[@Sirisha08]

As always great delivery Ganesh!! Thanks to you and your team’s efforts!!! I always wanted to understand two-sided perspective to make a conscious decision, but when what we watch is mostly dictated by algorithms, it gets difficult. This was a good opportunity to understand where the govt is not concentrating and what as a citizens of India should demand from a govt, no matter which party comes to power. Unemployment is seriously worrisome, I think it’s directly linked to lack of (expected) investments which in itself is a result of difficulties surrounding land acquisition and ease of doing business (which you’ve nicely covered in one of your videos). Whilst BJP may be trying to address these issues, the end result says otherwise. I saw a video on Congress manifesto and their promise to address unemployment problem, but what is not clear is how they plan to do that, most of the things mentioned in that manifesto felt heavy on the expenditure side without any economic return. If you plan to do more political series, an episode on decoding manifestos of both the national parties would be great!!

[@avantikabadgujar8467]

Thankyou for posting videos on political case studies as well. You have put both the sides arguments. Kudos to your team!🎉❤

[@verghese4u]

The youth should raise the voice, what is right and what is wrong. Because this is New India🇮🇳 and our country.