Today we'll be discussing a song that was recorded for the Let It Be sessions and was butchered so badly and handled so poorly that it's one of the reasons Paul McCartney decided to leave the band in 1970.
Пікірлер: 115
@terencehennegan14393 күн бұрын
J L asked a lot of the band in accepting Ono presence, no wonder McCartney got pissed off.
@I_Am_Become_Light9 күн бұрын
I think it's pretty magnificent.
@walterbriggs2725 күн бұрын
I’m tired of all the accusations and speculation about who said what! Let it be
@MFisher73469 күн бұрын
Personally, I prefer the Spector mix to the original. I find some of Paul's piano figures distract attention from the vocal, which should be the focus. All the same, I can understand his anger at serious changes being made to one of his songs without his knowledge or consent. The Beatles were not on the best of terms at this time.
@thomaspacker26267 күн бұрын
As Paul made changes clandestinely…
@garylester86214 күн бұрын
Can you imagine having Yoko in the studio constantly? Oh my God. It would be like one of your beer drinking buddies bringing his wife along when ya'll go out to drink some berrs.
@Not_Sure-20209 күн бұрын
Song was not ruined. I think what may have happened here is the same thing George purportedly left for. Even John had mentioned that since the death of Brian, Paul tried to basically take over and this just seems like he was angry because someone else made changes. I think any changes would have made him angry at this point.
@thomaspacker26267 күн бұрын
Not to mention that George Martin had given him a wide latitude because of his ability to write salable pop songs and they had similar taste in music. In fact George Martin was friends with the Asher and quite influential on Paul from those days when he moved in with them for a few years.
@peach4954 күн бұрын
I disagree. The whole album was ruined by the wall of sound. The Naked release is so superior I got rid of the original version as I would never listen to it again.
@LearnMusclescom2 күн бұрын
It was Paul’s song so it reasonable that he should choose how it was produced. Beyond that, this was part of the Get Back sessions which were supposed to be the Beatles getting back to their earlier rock and roll music without a lot of studio additions. And, George Martin, an excellent producer who did so much for the Beatles once described the Let It Be album as “produced by George Martin and overproduced by Phil Spector”.
@user-fu2mi1nd5l9 күн бұрын
It's funny that Macca used the Spector arrangement live in 1990 at Vet Stadium in Philly
@thomaspacker26267 күн бұрын
Mocka'
@triandfit16 күн бұрын
I was at that show and at MSG the year before.
@glennmorrell49076 күн бұрын
I was at that show too. I went upstairs and had a smoke. Someone spoke and I went into a dream…
@chipdice6 күн бұрын
I was at that show too. I was alone I took a ride I didn't know what I would find there....
@donaldbutcher12606 күн бұрын
I guess that is what was meant on the album sleeve by " over produced by Phil Spector "
@eltinjones45427 күн бұрын
It makes no difference now
@billfrohberg32063 күн бұрын
I was at a McCartney concert. His original version was fantastic.
@jacenoley259710 күн бұрын
It is true that Paul hated the Phil Spector treatment and there has been accusations even by /Spector himself that John's bass playing was terrible. Spector lowered the bass track so it could not be heard and covered it with strings , backing voices and all that. It's one of my favorite songs and was not ruined by all the mistakes and tampering with it. The beautiful melody and lyrics survive regardless and a lot of people like the Spector produced single that was initially released.
@nomarzepol556710 күн бұрын
I believe Paul played bass
@thomaspacker26267 күн бұрын
McCartney left the band because it worked out well for selling his first solo album, effectively going against what they had agreed-upon they all would decide when JOHN wanted to leave at first. It was like a knife in the back. He used to redo tricks without telling the other Beatlesand so would probably especially hurt him to get a bit of payback with Phil Spector. He changed his mind about the initial version after it sold so well…
@marcusphelan576 күн бұрын
@@nomarzepol5567 not on this. John did, and it's awful.
@jacenoley25973 күн бұрын
@@thomaspacker2626 Paul has said that John stated he was going to leave first.I have read that Ringo went to Paul and asked him to delay his solo album, and Paul got mad and threw Ringo out. I never heard anything about Paul secretly redoing tracks without telling the other Beatles . I would be interested in finding out the source you have for that and the part where you seem to be saying that Paul wanted to chamge the time for releasing his solo album when I have read that the other three sent Ringo to ask Paul to change the release date of his solo album which they had all already agreed to.. What article or book did you get this information from as I would love to read it ?
@user-mk3vk7kb6b9 күн бұрын
I know Paul didn’t like Spector’s arrangement and production of Long and Winding Road, but I like that version with the strings and the women backup vocals. It’s what I heard first and the version I prefer. Many fans feel the same.
@auramac8 күн бұрын
John left the band he started. Kept quiet about it at the request of the others. Then Paul made his "big announcement" to promote His first solo album. I think Spector's gotten a bad rap- McCartney was no stranger to schmaltz before or after.
@jacobgordon79988 күн бұрын
Right, after the band without Paul's approval chose a crook to manage them, correct? On top of Spector ruining his songs, in his opinion, I imagine Paul was angry and felt justified in making the announcement early. Sort of disingenuous to judge him harshly.
@thomaspacker26267 күн бұрын
Hardly, Paul was looking out for number one with trying to get a relative to be the lawyer
@davidmanzi44912 күн бұрын
Spectre's "wall of sound" BS just did not work with ANY beatles song. Horrible.
@cezzajamboree6 күн бұрын
I think the strings are great. Perhaps a little cheesy but they help make the song. It was a massive hit so obvs most people loved the arrangement
@dominicbugattiofficial4 күн бұрын
Spector did a fantastic job, which ensured the song went to number one. The naked version would never have achieved that.
@ChrisVaughan-gj7ve8 күн бұрын
It’s sounds refreshing different actually. If it wasn’t produced by Spector any true Beatles fan - I am one - would be able to predict the production and what it would have sounded like. It deserves the embellishment and lifts it even higher.
@MrBarrystuart9 күн бұрын
You almost have to wonder if John Lennon was up to some creative sabotage, first by bringing Phil Spector on board and also by flubbing some of the bass tracks - it's no secret that by the end of the sixties, he was not a happy Beatle. Moreover, Paul later revealed that John is the one who actually broke up the Beatles.
@thomaspacker26267 күн бұрын
One needs our wide latitude when it comes to Paul's so-called revelations
@onargaroberts9 күн бұрын
My least favorite Beatles song, both versions. I love the way both of these men put a song together, but this one should never have been on the album in my opinion. Paul's vocals on the "Naked" version were exceptional though.George had several songs ready to go that would have complemented the album far better. Fortunately we got to hear them on All Things Must Pass.
@jusupdjidjimidjimilovic36775 күн бұрын
That songs were not ruined by Phil Spector. They were enhanced by Phil Spector. We heard Paul McCartney version, that was bad.
@peach4954 күн бұрын
Once McCartney's "Naked" version was released, I got rid of the original.
@Pedro9179522 сағат бұрын
Bad? Never!
@casaraku13 күн бұрын
Maybe we should add a banjo..... really... Its okay if they "the beatles" do versions of their work like they did with three versions of Revolution...but someone like him... Even Martin helped on a lot of Beatle songs but he worked with them...
@PeterStrachanMusic6 күн бұрын
Specter's version is the best... By a mile.
@just_ben19513 күн бұрын
The Phil Spector version is great. I didn’t like the silly chatter between songs though.
@latinhellas63837 күн бұрын
In my view, The Beatles are not complete without George Martin. I prefer the "naked" and Glyn John's versions of the Get Back/Let It Be songs, and even some of the rehearsals and outtakes, especially Across the Universe and All Things Must Pass. Similarly, I never liked the All Things Must Pass album and have been looking for a "naked" version. Just recently, a certain yorick22 did the compilation work and published it on KZbin: kzbin.info/www/bejne/sJi4lJmNrdF2qZo The Beatles had already made our world much better than it otherwise would have been, but it would have been that much better still if George Martin had produced Let It Be and All Things Must Pass of which four or five songs should have been on Let It Be and a would-be 1970 Beatles album. At least Phil Spector didn't ruin the 1970 John Lennon/Plastic Ono Band album because its most striking feature is its raw simplicity.
@jimbo62222 күн бұрын
He was born in liverpool
@pauloslferes8 күн бұрын
O trabalho de Spector em "The Long and Winding Road " foi muito bom.
@UkuleleBobbyKemp6 күн бұрын
Bullshit 'Ruined!' Spector vs. The Beatles are f*cking Masterpieces! They're an essential part of the Beatles Story *And* an essential part of their Canon. Deal with it!!...
@janiceastets54258 күн бұрын
I love the orchestra, strings, horns, etc. It really makes the song beautiful & classy. Paul sings it just right, the right tone & emotion. I love it! ❤️
@Not_Sure-20207 күн бұрын
Right? And the Beatles had done things like that numerous times in the past.
@robertallan63737 күн бұрын
I agree, its the only version I listen to.
@wadestevens56593 күн бұрын
Have you listened to the raw version? Turns out Phil Spector ruined the song by pouring audio syrup all over it.
@deanevangelista6359Күн бұрын
Yeah, you can actually hear Billy Preston’s Hammond on it.
@jacquismith327719 сағат бұрын
Phil Spector was something of a loose cannon. He put out Leonard Cohen's Death of a Ladies' man before Leonard heard the final cut. Both are good, but why upset the artists?
@sallybrown49475 күн бұрын
Wrong!!! That song was #1 and sold millions. Phil took crap and made it a pure classic.
@robertallan63737 күн бұрын
Spector did a great job.
@PeterStrachanMusic11 сағат бұрын
No, it was not ruined in the slightest..
@colmfox37524 күн бұрын
Anyone that thinks Spectors. Version ruined this song is fucking high! There was a lot happening behind the scenes with Martin and McCartney and the rest of the Beatles hence their biased option to the mix, but any object listener thinks Spector messed up 😂😂😂
@TheAnarchitek8 күн бұрын
Neither version of the song, Spectorized, or Naked, meets the standards the Beatles set on every other album. It's tripe.
@thomaspacker26267 күн бұрын
Kind of like yesterday, Paul's answer to John's song help which was so much better than less maudlin. We could tell that John was much more sincere and heartfelt and creating this song and singing it. McCartney was essentially like a paperback writer…
@TheAnarchitek7 күн бұрын
@@thomaspacker2626 Yesterday evokes a theme common to humans over the age of 30, and those empathetic enough to recognize the approaching deadline we all operate under. John was beginning his tab-of-acid-every-day period (his first time was in Spring 1965, around the time the song, Help, was recorded (April 13). Paul wouldn't do acid for another five months. There was no excuse for Long and Winding Road. It mines the same territory as Yesterday, without its timeless connect with the human condition. I didn't like it the first time I heard it, the first time I'd had that kind of reaction to a Beatles' song (Revolution 9 doesn't count, as it is not a song, by any definition). John's songwriting was always different, more in tune with his worldview than Paul. John was a child from a broken home, whose mother passed tragically in an accident, just as he neared adulthood. Paul's mother passed, too, when he was only 14, but his family life was more secure. Yesterday harks back to that feeling, where Long and Winding Road reminds me more of Stevie Winwood's (Sometimes I Feel So) Uninspired. The latter is at least honest about its inspiration.
@thomaspacker26267 күн бұрын
I like Tripe however
@TheAnarchitek7 күн бұрын
@@thomaspacker2626 If you like it, you are welcome to it. I happily cede all interest in it to you, my friend. Lotta people bought Sugar Sugar, too, but good luck finding any of 'em who'll admit it, today!
@TheAnarchitek6 күн бұрын
@@thomaspacker2626 It's as listenable as Green, Green Grass of Home, or Tie a Yellow Ribbon, appealing to our maudlin sides. The word lugubrious comes to mind.
@edtamboni47526 күн бұрын
The spectorized Long Winding Road is a stone masterpiece...anyone who repeats this bullshit about it being ruined is just ignorant about music.
@amadeusendymion12724 күн бұрын
Anyone who throws insults like ignorant around without knowing who they are talking about is a total jerk.
@edryba48679 күн бұрын
Reliable? How could Paul McCartney have been born in 1968 WHEN THEY APPEARED ON THE ED SULLIVAN SHOW IN 1964???
@paulwielgosz60469 күн бұрын
The song was born
@eddiemissey2668 күн бұрын
This is absolutely true! You will find telegram sent by McCartney to either Allen Klein, or Phil Spector, in the Beatles Anthology dvd, or the book, or the Beatles Forever book! Paul was totally Pissed!
@thomaspacker26267 күн бұрын
Nobody likes eating crow...
@groovermctoober45089 күн бұрын
Phil Spector was a master producer who created some of the most legendary recordings of the rock/pop era, especially "Da Doo Ron Ron!' But he had no business whatsoever messing with Beatles' recordings. John admired him, even using him on his own solo recordings, because deep down that was the type of music he really liked. But The Beatles weren't into that. They were The Beatles, not The Crystals. In my humble opinion, Phil Spector not only ruined this song, but every Beatles' song he was allowed to mess with. Just listen to 'Let It Be Naked!' It is far, far better. Thank God, Paul had the idea to do it and see it through.
@marcusphelan576 күн бұрын
Naked is just as manipulated and edited as the Spector production. Not 'naked" at all.
@ignatiusjk8 күн бұрын
Sorry Paul but like Spectors version better. I can see why Paul got mad; he should have but Spector's version is much fuller.
@ploppill346 күн бұрын
The version Paul liked was released on let it be naked And no it didn't go to #1 and isn't loved By 10s of millions of people
@joeerickson51613 күн бұрын
"Blatant lies,🤥 to me?"
@MarvinThiessen6 күн бұрын
"The Long and Boring Road", not one of his better songs. He was trying to emulate something from "Pet Sounds".
@andydporter51366 күн бұрын
McCartney schmultz. It's a hideous song
@jasperchance33827 күн бұрын
Spector did an amazing job. Paul was ticked off because he had not been asked about it, but he liked it.
@marcusphelan576 күн бұрын
He did know it was going to be orchestrated cos Spector asked Paul to suggest an arranger, which he did (and Paul used the same arranger for his solo work.)
@jasperchance33826 күн бұрын
@@marcusphelan57 yeah, but it was published without his approval.
@marcusphelan576 күн бұрын
@@jasperchance3382 incorrect, he signed off on it.
@carlcushmanhybels81599 күн бұрын
In contrast to some other comments: When it came out I hated "Long and Winding Road" --Later I found Paul hated what was done to it by Phil Spector. I agree with Paul. Including brought out well here that it was a heartfelt song RE the Beatles' journey, not a sappy lush 'here's another blah love song.'
@nicholasbrowning45586 күн бұрын
Spector did a great job on this song
@fvmcnabb13 күн бұрын
This is simply not true
@paulcritz62176 күн бұрын
What little life there is in this dirge was breathed into it by Spector.
@maddielee4eva1238 күн бұрын
Its a terrible song to stsrt with
@davidgraham82997 күн бұрын
It's the albums highlight
@thomaspacker26267 күн бұрын
I actually liked I've got a feeling…
@maddielee4eva1237 күн бұрын
@@thomaspacker2626 Yes, that was good but Don't let me down was terrible
@maddielee4eva1237 күн бұрын
@@davidgraham8299 I was 14 when it came out. I didn't like it then nor now.
@thomaspacker26267 күн бұрын
@maddielee4eva123: I like don't let me down...
@richbailey81743 күн бұрын
I don't think it is even a good song anyway....a typical McCartney soupy ballad.
@bronzesnake70044 күн бұрын
You can't get a clear picture of how Spector ruined the album until you hear "Let It Be Naked" which, in my opinion as a 30 pro lead rock then metal vocals/writer hythm guitar, is a superior cut which gives you a look at how incredible these four ruffians truly are! They created that iconic Beatle sound which the rest of the world's bands tried very hard to duplicate, however, you just can't get there!! Jack ~'()'~
@lylecampbell90367 күн бұрын
It's an awful song regardless. The Long and Boring Song....
@davidgraham82997 күн бұрын
Best song on the album
@ploppill346 күн бұрын
Amazing that ruined song went to #1 And is be loved by 10s of millions of people
@kevinwaters58728 күн бұрын
The song itself is maudlin in the worst way. I am a Beatle fan from way back , and I know a lot of Beatles fans. I don’t know anyone who even mentions this song. The Spector production was shit , but the song itself was no great shakes.
@thomaspacker26267 күн бұрын
Kind of like yesterday coming back to bite him the ass…
@JackCarlock568 күн бұрын
I have hated the long and winding road ever since I first heard it in 1970. Pure rubbish.
@davidgraham82997 күн бұрын
It's a masterpiece
@JackCarlock567 күн бұрын
@davidgraham8299 Hey Jude is a masterpiece. The Long and Winding Road is rubbish.
@thomaspacker26267 күн бұрын
Both are all right McCartney pop tunes
@dcarlisle1234 күн бұрын
Beautiful lyrics, mushy production
@dinahnicest65256 күн бұрын
Spector should be in prison for that.
@rickmayer40027 күн бұрын
That song is pretentious and lame not every song is gold.
@davidgraham82997 күн бұрын
No, it's not gold, it's platinum.
@rickmayer40027 күн бұрын
@@davidgraham8299 Ya I guess Paul's worst songs are still better than most. But to me it's lame.
@peterrichards9316 күн бұрын
Oh so the heck what. The result was a #1 hit, and the pre-Spector version wouldn't have made it to the top 20. Listen to the 2 versions objectively.
@ruttles2 күн бұрын
Clickbait rubbish. So we should see a masterpiece we've loved for 50+ years as faulted in some way?...
@richardhawkins46219 күн бұрын
I dont agree the phil spector production is much better than the original it is a masterpiece
@grahamtowers55134 күн бұрын
I can't here the song here, just a lot of talking, pointless video without being able to hear what the hell you are talking about
@glenbard65710 күн бұрын
What a bunch of crap! The Phil Spector version is much better no matter what a bunch of Beatles sycophants say. Paul McCartney also thought it was a good idea to marry Heather Mills.
@donhancock799210 күн бұрын
Thank goodness for Let it b3, Naked, a superior product!!
@davidgraham82997 күн бұрын
Yep, not all of Paul's decisions have been winners.
@thomaspacker26267 күн бұрын
I actually have trouble understanding Paul's feelings toward Phil Spector. He put Brian Wilson at the beach boys on a high pedestal and Brian Wilson loved Phil Specter's treatment…
@Aikitide7 күн бұрын
The Naked version is far better. The first time I heard it I let out a strange sound and giant exhale of breath, a release of the tension the first version always gave me. Spector was completely wrong for the Beatles.
@marcusphelan576 күн бұрын
it's a different take. Spector used the Glyn Johns' choice/
@ceediddy9257 күн бұрын
Phil Spector...most overrated producer in music history. This song, and every song on All Things Must Pass would have been much better with George Martin.