This Has To STOP! We Need To Protect BUSTERS

Please help us in calling out Marbling! We demand better treatment of the girls, this can’t keep going like this. Busters has gone through enough mistreatment and it is clear the company wont stop unless they are held accountable!
Here are some links that can help us in this:
Share these posts, and feel free to make your own posts using the hashtags #PROTECTBUSTERS and #MarblingDoBetter.
Link to my Thread that people can share:
x.com/jihoons_carat/status/17...
Link to email template and email address:
docs.google.com/document/d/1-...
Links to Twitter Threads about Busters you can share:
How Marbling Has Failed Busters (pt1): x.com/kangjenseo/status/14885...
How Marbling Has Failed Busters (pt2): x.com/kangjenseo/status/14885...
Links to my first two videos about Busters:
First Video: • Why I'm Worried About ... (warning, one of my first videos so the video is not that great..)
Second Video: • Why I'm STILL Worried ...
My Socials:
Instagram: / jihoons_carat
Instagram (trades): / jihoonscarat_trades
Twitter: / jihoons_carat
FAQ:
What’s your name? You can call me Sun, or Jihoons Carat it fine too!
How old are you? I am 24 years old, born in 1999.
What are your pronouns? She/Her
What are your favourite groups? I have loads but my TOP favourite are Seventeen and SHINee
What is the song in the Outro? Like it How by GWSN!
Where can I request a video topic? You can leave it in the comments, or even DM me on Instagram or Twitter!
Timestamps
00:00 Intro
02:04 Disclaimers & Content Warnings
03:40 Their Career (2017-2019)
05:21 The ISAACS Incident
06:22 Their Career Cont.
09:13 Chaeyeon and the TokTok Boni Hani Incident
17:51 Their Career (2020)
18:43 Jisoo Plastic Surgery Modeling
22:22 Yeseo’s Stalker
24:42 Hiatus
26:15 ReDebut / Comeback
28:38 The MAIN Issue
41:31 Other Issues
44:29 Where Are The Former Members?
45:48 What Can We Do?

[@jihoonscarat]

‼️EDITS & LINKS‼️ Note 1: I accidentally say 2022, instead of 2020 when I’m talking about the Paeonia era. Takara end Minji joined in March of 2020, and they comeback in 2020! So sorry for this confusion. My dumbass just misspoke Note 2:In the start of the video I say that no comeback had the same lineup, but Futt and Tropical Romance did have the same lineup, however ORIGINALLY as we see in the statement, MinMin was supposed to be in Futt and was replaced last minute LINK TO MY THREAD Feel free to share, post for yourself and so on: x.com/jihoons_carat/status/1766155707512955322?s=46

[@gwenmloveskpopcecmore]

It’s ok 🩷❤️

[@bastetowl3258]

why are parents ok with their kids debuting as minors? this company is def marketing them towards p3dophiles. they should be having fans around their own age. the fact that those perverts cheered the loudest for the youngest member 🤢

[@erikascencen]

Those fans around their Age are just as perverted as the pds u talk about....13 yo girls wanting jungkook to rp÷ them and all...i mean just look at fanmade thirst trap vids

[@erikascencen]

I mean those fans around their are just as bad as oldies u talk about....the way 13yo wants jungkook to grape them ...or the thirst trap vids

[@erikascencen]

I mean fans around their Age are just as bad.Video Edits,comments with things theyd do

[@moongirl8807]

Whoops, it's almost like companies don't care.... *NewJeans Lapillus Babymonster UNIS Young Posse Le Sserafim IVE TripleS* ahum sorry had a weird cough there...

[@glaciemdraco]

I mean, most groups who have minor members are (lets be really honest here), it's just more obvious with these girls because they kept debuting younger and younger members (basically at the age where they would be the oldest in those equally questionable 'kid' groups) each time one of the members left or went on hiatus or something, made even worse by the implied 'she got too old' at like... 18-ish? Why is that suddenly old for anyone but the you know who's??? Either way, it's disgusting that they seem to believe that they can't make it without the money of those 'people' if you can even call them that.

[@Foxziewolf]

I followed Chaeyeon from Busters to TripleS, so I had totally lost eyes on Busters. I feel really bad, honestly. This is a good example of why the Korean government should step in with laws for age-appropriate entertainment. The companies dont care because they know theyre feeding into fetishes, and its okay as long as they arent just outright saying it. Someone else has to step in, but im scared that unfortunately something more sinister will have to occur for the government to step in.

[@snithasuresh9519]

They actually have new law protecting minors but I doubt its going cause even a dent in what's already happening in Korea

[@yesipan]

The video of the men cheering when they say their ages and how you can clearly tell they cheer louder for the younger members...my god. My skin started crawling.

[@jihoonscarat]

Right? It’s just absolutely wild that they cheered on so shamelessly

[@meredith_smith]

it's concerning that they're so comfortable with revealing themselves as creeps publicly like that. like usually creeps will hide but these men have no shame at all :s

[@vixxexo6855]

I always found it weird that girl groups with cute concept had all those old men fans. Like cute concept is not really what most elderly men even listen to. Now I know they don’t listen for the music, but for the poor young girls. I am glad groups like Blackpink, Mamamoo, Red Velvet, Itzy, StayC, Loona, G idle and Aespa mostly has female fans.

[@U.ups.uranus]

@@vixxexo6855don’t trust this user! they are acting as if they care about minors, when in reality they were slutshaming and saying disgusting things (that I’m not going to repeat bc 🤢) about NJ. so pls don’t trust them, they are hypocrites.

[@MayaLove777]

​@@meredith_smiththey dont hide it because they know the company is catering to them

[@karthikamallan5202]

This is exactly the reason why I stand with "no minors in kpop" opinion. We don't know what these companies do to these kids behind the scenes. And they use their ages to promote it to all the creeps and pedos. I feel chills hearing them scream after listening to their ages..especially when she said 15 And the fact that these kpop NSFW accounts exist still in 2024 makes me feel like I am losing faith in humanity

[@143RAYNE]

for a grown man to show that level of agression to a child is insane, even if he "didnt hit her" (if u believe that) for him to pull away with that much force is disgusting

[@jihoonscarat]

Also, the whole “role playing” excuse is also just… messed up? Why would you fake for a teen cast member? Like??

[@mirandalad2342]

and most of the members in busters are grown women. They are 18 or above. What you are saying makes no sense jieun is 18 takara is 19 nami is 19 sera is 19 or 20 minji is the only exception

[@ishathakor]

@@mirandalad2342 18-20 isn't a "grown woman". in south korea the age of majority is 19 so jieun isn't even an adult yet, she's still a child. that age is people who are still in school or fresh out of high school and like freshmen or at most sophomores in college. the transition from child to adult isn't some sudden and magical thing where overnight you become mature and creepy men KNOW that which is why they go out of their way to sexualize older teenagers and young women.

[@gwenmloveskpopcecmore]

I’m so happy Chaeyeon debuted in TripleS she’s better off there

[@gwenmloveskpopcecmore]

@@thinkyourebaby4000 yeah ik and I think that was their worst move

[@gwenmloveskpopcecmore]

@@thinkyourebaby4000 but Maud Haus isn’t as abusive as Marbling that’s why I said that

[@yangqi]

@@thinkyourebaby4000 now why would u say this..weird as hell

[@gflo_lover]

@@thinkyourebaby4000Joobin isn’t 13 and she hasn’t even debuted yet. Know the facts before commenting please

[@thinkyourebaby4000]

@@gflo_lover she was introduced as a member and has objekts idgaf about the technicalities lol and she was 13 when she was introduced so

[@OGseoulite]

I thought they disbanded long ago, I feel so sorry. I hope their fandom uses BBC’s boycott as an example that they can speak out and use their voices. The girls & women of this group have an opportunity to be released from that horrible situation if enough people protest against the company and call them out. Thank you for this information & update on the group Busters. I truly thought they already disbanded, the whole time they were still suffering.

[@vixxexo6855]

Most of Busters fans are not teenagers, but weird elderly men.

[@OGseoulite]

@@vixxexo6855 I mentioned nothing about those perverts. I said their true fans meaning those who have only stanned them with pure intentions. Not their uncle fans.

[@mirandalad2342]

you thought they disbanded because you were never a fan to begin with. an actual fan would know they are still around you wonder why busters has to rely on a perverted male fan-base to have viewers

[@blueberrybluetube1955]

They must treat the protest like a real protest, including what they are supposed to say, like, “FROM THE BUILDING THAT THEY WILL FLEE, BUSTERS WILL BE FREE!”

[@overwhelmed_cactus6820]

38:26 it’s sad cus you can see Hyungseo next to her being pretty taken aback by the reaction, smiling uncomfortably at the others. I mean they must sense what the company and the fans are up to

[@jihoonscarat]

Right? She tried to laugh but you can see her almost disgust. I don’t blame her, my reaction was the same

[@Chuu_Vault]

I honest to god, thought they disband 😦 Someone protect this girls #ProtectBusters

[@sabrinaleedance]

Well they did but then brought back with new members

[@lemondrop2609]

This makes me feel so icky. What’s worse is that even if they are 18, they’re still underage in South Korea. Their age of majority is 19, international age. This stuff is not okay

[@jihoonscarat]

Right. And before, people would use the girls Korean Ages to justify that “they were legal” like how predatory can you be?

[@anahyh]

Where are the parents in all of this ? Why let your child debut in a group like this or why not take them out ?

[@jihoonscarat]

My questions exactly!

[@sabrinaleedance]

I think this alot qhen I see idols who are minors where adult appropriate outfits, doing questionable dances and singing questionable lyrics, what do their parents esp their dad think when they see this? They must be uncomfortable and worried,no?

[@MayaLove777]

Because maybe the parents are neglectful and don't give a shit

[@MiniLinlin]

Like all child stars... for money most likely?

[@yu7699]

Thank you for this very informative and important video! I'm a Kep1ian and yet, I must admit I didn't know about the history of Busters. I'm incredibly sad that Yeseo and all the former and current members experienced that... I sincerely hope the situation gets better for the current members, and that current / former members are doing well despite all this.

[@TomsMusicCorner]

Yeseo is a smart girl who quickly realized that the group or the Company is not for her. The reason she left was because of stalking and because the company didn't even assign a manager to protect her. Nevertheless, I never forgot her and when she appeared in GP 999, I was just glad that she didn't give up despite everything.

[@gflo_lover]

I’m so happy that Chaeyeon joined tripleS but it’s awful what she had to endure in Busters. There’s even one instance during a Signal content that she was crying with a younger member about the things that she had to do at such a young age

[@ryanittodraws]

man, that clip of them introducing themselves with their ages was so harrowing. I know a bit of Korean so I knew what was happening right away and i felt myself become sick the closer it got to Yeseo's turn to introduce herself :(

[@CoCo-ov9eb]

These men and company are disgusting, I hope that more people call them out.

[@yarioi]

As upsetting and sad as this may sound, but they need to disband. I really like busters and I think they have potential. Truly. Marbling is terrible and so unprofessional. Please save busters!!!!!!

[@jihoonscarat]

I hate to agree. I think they should leave Marbling for good, and hopefully find better labels to train them. Takara even said she didn’t have access to Korean lessons when she joined, which is like the bare minimum

[@moongirl8807]

Idk what's with this saving nugu groups narrative. This group is terribly managed, has had many lineup changes and the music isn't anything great too. I don't know what we need to save here so desperately, potential or not. Get the girls out of there (they seem to have good chances in other groups), shut down the whole operation and never bring up that group ever again. Some things are better forgotten. And I don't mean to be rude bc I get how fans can get attached to a group but at what cost? Sometimes I think kpop fans can't seem to get over their own need for a group even if it hurts the members. A lot of groups would benefit from a good old boycott, only then the industry changes. But no, we have to make sure that the members don't lose their shitty and abusive career bc...it's their dream? Idk we act so progressive but nothing has changed.

[@yarioi]

@@moongirl8807 It’s not just about keeping the group though? It’s, like what you said, getting them the hell out of there whether they come out as a group or alone. I’d think they’d do amazing in other groups but it would be great to still keep busters with all current members together. I’m not even a big busters fan, I learned about them in early 2023. But what are you so worked up about? They need saving and with your view on how to help them, it’s clearly not helpful or bringing a good light to this topic. At least we are trying to bring awareness to the fact that they are being abused and mismanaged.

[@moongirl8807]

@yarioi yeah no I agree on the part that they need to be saved from that company but often times kpop stans also wanna do that without harming the group which just feels stupid - no group should exits at the expense of the member's wellbeing but I probably didn't explain that right

[@moongirl8807]

@yarioi I agree to save them from their companies but some stans want to keep the group intact before everything else when that shouldn't have any priority. That's what I meant sorry

[@ChaeryeongGirlfriend]

The photoshoots were disgusting...

[@vixxexo6855]

It reminded me of Stellar’s photoshoot, and atleast they were adults. Even then Stellar did not like the explicit photoshoot, and these girls are minors.

[@mirandalad2342]

@@vixxexo6855 they are adults now with the exception of minji. jieun is 18. takara is 19. nami is 19, etc. stop pretending they are still minors

[@meli8003]

@@mirandalad2342 They were minors at the time creep

[@mirandalad2342]

@@meli8003 minors at the time of what?

[@meli8003]

@@mirandalad2342 at the time that they had multiple foot shots taken and when a member took weird pictures for a "makeup ad"?? Did you not watch the video?

[@moonjoonn]

im glad someone talked about the issue busters is. i remember when yeseo was introduced on gp999 i had looked into busters as she had become one of my favs and i wanted to find out more abt her group, and im still disgusted abt the things i found surrounding them. i had the unfortunate experience of coming across the reddit you mentioned a few days ago and i still don't get how people can casually talk about anyone like that - and some of the people on there are some that are barely an adult. the clip of the "fans" cheering on the former members and being noticeable louder as the ones with younger ages talked is disgusting; im glad to girls were able to escape that and i hope the current members find a way out as well. and if anyone wants to keep up with yeseo's future, after kep1er (they'll disband mid-2024), she's said to debut in limelight along with kep1er's mashiro! she's doing well for herself

[@whippedtm8145]

That slime song is even worse than just the lyrics, you can clearly tell they made it specifically sound like a children's song and given how the company promotes them its obvious what the intent was

[@problemperson4221]

idgaf if that guy was close to chaeyeon and have worked for EBS for 15 years, i just dont think a grown ass man should even get close enough to a young girl to casually smack her arm like 2 15 year old best friends would, thats so inappropriate.. edit: also, you have literally been scammed on the album competition thing???? jesus christ this label is run by scumbags

[@jihoonscarat]

Right ? Like what kind of relationship can this be if they are joking like that? Anyway you look at it, it’s strange and Marbling should have had someone on set with her ! And yea, it sucks but what could I really do. Over all it’s just meh situation

[@jasoninthea.m7471]

Thank You for talking about this, because quite literally there's not enough channels who talk about nugu group incidents, and the incidents sometimes get forgotten because they don't get enough traction due to the groups being nugu. I was a huge fan of busters until I stopped following them once they had this rebrand and redebut thing with Busters X Futt, and I paid less and less attention to them. Also I didn't know BHS was a subunit debut of Busters. I never liked the song at all so I never bothered to check out about the group. Plus, the song sucks so bad. I can't believe busters' music production went downhill after their busters X rebrand thing.

[@jihoonscarat]

Thank you for watching. I agree, if this was happening under a company like SM, JYP or even a medium sized company, this would have been called out ages ago! I was a huge fan of BUSTERS, and I was so happy for them to redebut but I can’t in good faith support them as a group as that is supporting the label And yea not a huge fan of the song, in any sense

[@jasoninthea.m7471]

@@jihoonscarat It reminds me of Botopasses bullying scandal, where I didn't see it blow up as much as Garam's, Woojin's and Jimin's. And I did hear some talk during the scandal, but not enough for it to reach such high levels. Which is sad, because I still don't know who's right and wrong.

[@kmac639]

I am getting flashbacks of Stellar and all the shit they were put through with Entertainment Pascal.

[@jihoonscarat]

Oh my god their story is heart breaking. This is a similar situation, people not calling out the company for their treatment of their idols. These companies make money of exploiting young women that just want this dream of being an idol

[@romifox_k]

Marbling ent really took "Writer's Barely Disguised Fetish" very seriously and made it worse huh.. Just hopefully, the company should be investigated for this and the girls be protected for once Edit note : I Shared this on my KZbin Community Post and 2 discord servers Hopefully this would reach out to other people!

[@chuu_guevara]

i know busters since 2018 and i used to like them a lot. even if i dropped them in mid 2019 because i lost interest, i kept updated with the members. it broke my heart every time a new controversy came out, i cried a lot when the chaeyeon incident happened, i supported yeseo on girls planet (thankfully she was out of busters at that time if i'm not wrong) and tried hard supporting jieun on universe ticket, but everyone was giving their back to her as she struggled a lot on that show:/ i didn´t even care about the ''untalented'' allegations, i just wanted her to be out of busters as much as she can, sadly she was eliminated and my concern got worse as the christmas event released. all these years i've been sharing info about them and sending emails to marbling but nothing has changed... kpop stans should really seek out for these girls i'm seriously so worried. chaeyeon has been open about how she felt debuting very young and it's heartbreaking, at least she got out of there but i can't imagine how the other girls who are still in busters must feel. i don't even want jail at this point, i want HELL for everyone working at the company, the male fans and the member's parents. they shouldn't let these things happen to their daughters for a minute of fame or a paycheck. i'll try my best to share this info so something can ACTUALLY happen or change this time.

[@candelita__]

I'm tired of that shitty company. they has done everything wrong with them groups, first with kirots, then with Pritz and now with busters

[@xxpurplexxrosexx]

I remember Pritz Nazi concept

[@_L10]

Now that I think about it, the name BUSTers, just makes it all the worse. It makes you wonder if this is what the team behind creating the group just wanted all along.😬

[@gwenmloveskpopcecmore]

Yeah something with that name just didn’t sit right with me at first but then I ignored it lol

[@axeltheking4157]

WHAT 😭😭😭 k-pop fans are insane like y’all will actually, LITERALLY say ANYTHING 😭😭😭

[@els_bells]

this situation is bad but i dont think a korean company is going to use decently niche american slang as an innuendo in their group name

[@gwenmloveskpopcecmore]

@@els_bells exactly bruh

[@lovelymill]

@@axeltheking4157 if you don't like someone's opinion you can just say it, no need to dramatize like that

[@choerryontop]

I love Chaeyeon in tripleS and didn’t know she went through all of this when she was younger :( there’s an old Signal episode where she’s talking to Hyerin about how she was sad about being in the entertainment industry at a young age disrupting her childhood, and she was offering support to Hyerin who was 15 at the time. #protectBusters Update- I found the episode: kzbin.info/www/bejne/eIrdnXqvj96arc0si=cq3wYL-JLTfIzfiM

[@jihoonscarat]

Yea, her reaction just tells me how horrible her time with the company was

[@33SAGEY]

this is so upsetting. thank you for bringing attention to this.

[@markigirl2757]

This is insaneeee and so sad I hope somehow this works and we get them out this is very exploitive and very obviously a form of grooming from both the company and the disgusting older male fans.

[@shockofthenew]

This is horrifying. I'm almost embarrassed to say I used to like Busters and had some of their MVs on my playlists because I liked the music, the MVs themselves seemed harmless, and I just naively assumed the members were late teens to early 20s. Learning they were as young as TWELVE puts those seemingly cute outfits and dances in a different light, and that's before you get to any of this stuff with the soft-porn style photoshoots, inappropriate outfits etc. I should really be checking ages and so on, but when there are 100s of groups I tend to be a very casual consumer and forget that the kpop industry has no goddamn standards. That video with a bunch of men going feral as these young teenagers announce their ages sent chills down my spine. These are the exact same kind of guys who are talking about "what they want to do" to girls like this, and for all we know some of them actually are abusing children/teens in real life. Them all gathered in a mob, barely contained, screaming at these girls who are instructed to smile and thank them... it's just terrifying. It's not only Busters, it shows something about an entire culture of misogyny and sexualisation of minors (I don't mean all of Korean culture, I mean specifically idol culture). It's easy to follow these groups in a genuinely innocent casual way, just watching a few fun MVs, and forget what's really going on off-screen. This was a needed wakeup call. I've been a kpop fan for a long time, I grew up with kpop, and I used to view it in a very innocent way... but with scandal after scandal I'm at the point where I think I'll mostly withdraw my support. It doesn't feel right to be promoting an industry with standards like this. There are a few older artists I'll keep up with, and I'm not saying I will boycott all new Korean artists, but I'll be checking ages carefully, and I'll only stick with groups where I have the time to research thoroughly and make sure they seem to be treated fairly and marketed appropriately. It sucks because I used to support a lot of nugu groups back in the day, but I just don't have time to be vetting every artist like this, and I don't want to support abuse so I will have to stay away. The reason I used to like nugu groups is that you have these young people (hopefully 18+) who seem very passionate, often quite talented, and it feels like "they deserve to follow their dreams! They deserve support!" I HATE that in reality these shitty abusive companies are often the only venue where passionate, talented young people can get an opportunity to perform. I wish there was a better more regulated industry, with high standards of safety, so that we could all support young artists with a clear conscience, knowing they're being given the opportunity to follow their dreams in a safe way. But that's not the world we live in.

[@jihoonscarat]

I used to be a huge fan, back in Grape times the incidents were serious but the Chaeyeon situation and the VLive were kind of one offs. With the promise i doing better I stupidly believed them. But it was clear it was empty promises. This is why I’m being so vocal, again and again. Because this keeps happening with them and no one seems to do anything

[@shockofthenew]

​@@jihoonscarat Seriously thank you for all the work you put into making this video, I can tell it must have been really time consuming, but I'm seeing it getting shared around. Hopefully it will at the very least help a few more people wake up and get informed! (sorry I ended up going on another rant but this just really gets to me) It's so ridiculous that most of the people leading this conversation are girls/young women themselves, who should be the target audience, and were following these groups in a genuinely innocent way. It's outrageous that young girl fans also have to be exposed to this stuff, forcing them to grow up too quickly along with their idols. They have to become aware of these darker patterns underneath a cute image, and then they have to shout and campaign to try to get anyone to take it seriously, while grown adults continue profiting off this whole mess, or just dismiss it like it's no big deal or "oh that's just how it is, it'll never change." Well it can change. I don't know exactly how, but I know there are technically some legal changes in Korea over the last few years as a result of fan/media pressure, it's just not nearly enough. People need to keep pushing, and they need to keep actually standing up for their values instead of going "oh well, it's just for fun, it's just a guilty pleasure." If enough people protest and boycott and get these issues picked up by the media, hopefully we can push the industry bit by bit into changing, even if the only way to do that is by publicly embarrassing them into changing. Another frustrating thing is that there are actually good aspects of kpop, and I would ~like~ to be able to promote those good things, but I feel I can't because of this kind of crap. It frustrates me how Western media gets SO focused on the 'dark side of kpop' narrative that they end up dehumanizing idols, claiming that every single kpop star is a controlled abused puppet, interchangeable robots with a ton of plastic surgery, and none of them write their own music or have any artistic merit or any freedom etc. And this is done in a way that often ends up being genuinely racist and/or xenophobic. So I want to push back against that narrative and stand up for Koreans who are either making art, or just want to perform fun music like any other nationality....... but then there really *is* a dark side of kpop, and I can't ignore that. There's a dark side of the Western industry too, of course. But it seems like it's impossible to have a nuanced conversation with most people about how there are good and bad aspects to every industry and every culture, and that doesn't mean none of these artists should be given a chance. And cases like this make that conversation so much harder.

[@143RAYNE]

i remember when i wanted to be an idol at 14 and now that im turning 20 this year i think that is insane, to be in that industry so young and being stuck in it for a miniuim of 7 years is crazy i feel for the people that thought they wanted that life and now cant find a way out of their contract :(

[@user-my9ob9cd7q]

I sent the email. I'm pessimistic, I never believe that these emails can actually do something... but I really hope I'm wrong this time. Busters have been mistreated and sexualized for YEARS. I'm the same age as some of the members, and I can't imagine going through what they went through when we were younger. My heart hurts for the former and especially the current members. Thank you for making another video on this topic

[@143RAYNE]

so this company debuted kids 14-16 and literally didnt have proper protection for them or a setdorm with a manager with them? and they made a debut around the time or after exo saseangs followed them into a awardshow bathroom, this company is so mismanaged i hope that girl feels and is more protected now

[@keylock_345h6]

One thing that makes me so incredibly mad about this situation is because they are a smaller group, there aren't enough eyes on them to call this out. This video is good at compiling everything wrong with their company, so thank you for that. Now, about the sexualization; it doesn't shock me that the company doesn't care because Hybe, the biggest company in the industry also does shit like this. NewJeans as a whole has issues with this, I constantly see grown men listening to them, but I KNOW it is not about the music. I see them calling Haerin and Hyein pretty and attractive and it's disgusting. I see comments like "Real men stan (insert girl group)" but I, as a woman, hate praising this because most of these men are actually creepy, are responsible for oversexualization, and are feeding into the stuff we're discussing here. When I hear a crowd at a performance of a girl group being mostly men, it makes my skin crawl. Because I know what men are like. Like these men flock to girl groups with minors. I see shit like it under LE SSERAFIM's stuff too. Especially with the choreos they are given (especially lately) that have inappropriate moves included. Smart is definitely the worst, and the most recent. Eunchae is a minor, and while the other 4 girls aren't, they originally had an issue with this even in Fearless. They had to change the choreo. And then I'LL-IT. Oh my god where should I start. The reason a that minors were so sexualized on that show, one was rigged into first, and the grown women who brought ao much talent (and should have all debuted) was because of incel p*do men on Reddit bashing them. They mass voted for 2 minors because they are creeps. You had to be 18 or older to go to the live performances for the show, when half the contestants weren't even 18. And Hybe has literally done nothing to protect them because they don't care. This is a few of many examples, but the reason that small companies get away with it is because even the biggest ones do too. It's always "you all are weird for making it sexual" or "it's just a dance, concept, etc." It is so hard. All this to say, thank you for making this video. I am glad someone with a decent platform is saying something. Honestly, the group needs help and protection. I hate this shit so much and wish it wouldn't happen but unfortunately so many executives in Kpop are creepy.

[@savannah4019]

i was the owner of what was the biggest update account for busters and i fought all the time to bring attention to what the girls were going through, but the only thing i managed to get non-nugu fan eyes on was the incident where chaeyeon was hit by a coworker because people are so used to the sexualization of minors that it's just not "entertaining" enough for people to boost, but physical assault on a child by an adult? yeah, people talked about that one after i translated the info about it. id even have frequent contact with monstergram/marbling and busters manager(s) where id bring up concerns of their treatment, yeseo's stalkers, the sexualized photoshoots, etc, and their management would just brush it off or tell me that i simply didnt understand the situation. it made me so mad.... and ive been into kpop since 2008 and im familiar with minors debuting even way back then, but nowadays its not one or two members are minors, it's entire groups are minors and rarely is there ever an adult debuted straight away. so im sitting here just watching what ive already seen happen time and time again but it feels significantly worse because theres just SO many minors and theyre being sexualized even worse than before and it's just so overwhelming and it feels like theres no amount of protesting that will change things... or at least, kpop fans arent willing to protest the way they should. if people stopped supporting groups of minors entirely EVEN if you think their music is good, then maybe itd start leaving a message. but nobody is willing to do that (cough cough look at newjeans, who literally debuted with a track explicitly about eating someone out and whose being run by a freakzoid borderline pdf file herself) so it seems like nothing will change. but you're right! videos like these from people with sizeable platforms speaking out about this stuff will absolutely bring more eyes to these worries and justtttt maybe one day we'll see a change start to shift...

[@yushii7276]

So true! Big company like hybe is getting away with it. Also I completely agree about the le serrafim situation they have a more mature concept then why put a minor in it? And then there is new jeans with their creepy ceo and that song cookie I couldn't even fully listen to it. Also the whole bam bam situation and then there where so many fans defending him, just disgusted me. I lost the respect I had for this man. Also I'm still pissed over ru next jiwoo, chanelle and jeongeun deserve so much better. But if you share your concerns then the fans will storm you with hate comments and call you an anti.

[@keylock_345h6]

@yushii7276 yeah and i have seen too many people excusing it 😐

[@moongirl8807]

I saw Smart and it was an ok song and in general the vibe fits for them but I couldn't stop thinking about the sexy concept groups of the 2nd and 3rd gen. I got into kpop later but I saw a few of the popular mv with the short shorts and mainly focus on, well, the booty. Actually my ults Dreamcatcher started out as a cutesy group with a questionable concept and two minors and have called out that exact behaviour. They're one of the only ones that grew past that and criticised it. Anyway I've been seeing the outfits for Le Sserafim more and more critically, the only thing people seem to talk about is Kazuha's abs which is weird to begin with but all of them only get bralette tops now and short skirts. My point is kpop companies seem to wanna avoid the connection to their old groups but Smart was the first time where I thought "wow, this could've been a 3rd gen song with a weird mv". It's mainly booty shaking, the only difference is that they don't focus on that now. But I'm telling you, they'll go further. As soon as Eunchae turns 18, they'll probably do even more mature stuff. They're just testing the waters now and since no one cares they can continue. Look, without Eunchae they could even get away with it but no, we have do drag a minor into it. Kpop is still mainly about being pretty and thin, whoever thinks differently is delusional. Le Sserafim is actually a great example bc their vocal coach seems to actively make them worse, but I won't beat that dead horse.

[@keylock_345h6]

@moongirl8807 the song is fine as far as i know, like the lyrics aren't inappropriate (correct me if i'm wrong) but the choreo is the problem. it's based on smth that shouldn't be sexualized but it is unfortunately so we need to be realistic when criticizing it. and they've also had "sexy" moves in other song like fearless (they changed some of them but) and also perfect night. like eunchae has never been safe because hybe doesn't care.

[@stay_in_paris5351]

....hum.... groups including 12 years olds just should not exist, we all agree on this, right ?!?

[@UncleMarco]

I’m glad you continually use your platform to advocate for these girls, the kpop fan community seems to always brush their situation under the rug or treat their mistreatment like a stan twitter punchline. The clips of Chaeyeon getting punched and taunted still makes my blood boil.

[@jihoonscarat]

The whole situation with Chaeyeon still haunts me, I can literally hear it in my head. It’s wild that the situation over all is being ignored like this

[@noni4315]

I really hope this video blows up. I'm sitting here at the end of the video in absolute shock. I didn't even realize how much time went by because I've been listening so closely. These poor, innocent girls. My god. I feel sick. I can't believe this is so unknown. It's so very clear that the company is marketing these girls to literal p3dos. I can't imagine what must be going on behind the scenes. I have heard that there are rumors that small companies will force their trainees and idols into s3x work to make money for the company. It would not shock me one bit if that is going on with Busters. These girls need help. 💔

[@yushii7276]

The company is obviously a complete thrash and they are purposely attracting certain audience. Also where are the parents!! im pretty sure since most of the girls where minors its probably their parents who signed them in. Im worried for the girls safety. Finally, love your videos the effort you put onto them is praiseworthy 💕

[@discordanceplays]

With that many member changes they had plenty chances to make an older group but no they wanted to keep kids to exploit and take advantage of because it would be easier. Such a shame i discovered them on simply kpop and became a fan never there was such turmoil surrounding them. =/

[@puddingcake39]

I don’t have Twitter but I just sent the email. Apart from the Tok Tok Hani incident i had no idea about the things that have happened to Busters and I am honestly so shocked. Thank you for raising awareness, I hope the girls will be in safer situations following public outcry.

[@vivk2932]

I had heard about that livestream with the MCs and the incidents on EBS but I didn't know things were this bad for the Busters members. I think I was naively assuming that their company was otherwise giving them age appropriate outfits and concepts, but this video has made it very clear that that isn't the case, which is upsetting to hear. Thank you for making this video and bringing light to this situation!

[@glaciemdraco]

I wish I could be surprised but this is the place that gives men who do SA (of any kind) only 8 months to 5 years in prison so.... I really hope the situation as a whole starts improving. If you know of the Burning Sun situation, you will also know what I mean by that. I dont know these girls but I wish them all the best and I hope they are doing better now.

[@AzazelCodex]

Re-Watched your previous videos on Busters, Jihoons and glad to watch this one as a update 👍

[@t3m077]

I think a similar thing is happening with newjeans and le sserafim's eunchae, just on a smaller and lesser scale. (Cookie having extremely provocative lyrics for nwjns, sexualized outfits and dancing for 17 yo eunchae (le sserafim), putting her in a sexualized schoolgirl outfit) Kpop is just not meant for minors

[@user-el7wj6pc5h]

The way they were hitting that young male cast member make me feel physically uncomfortable. WHAT the heck is the Korean Broadcasting Commission even doing? HOW is THAT appropriate for CHILDREN to see, but a dance by a female girl group is banned because they rub the side of their butts in the choreography? No wonder there's such a big problem with bullying in South Korea when physical violence is made to seem like a joke. It's not. What they did to him was literally Battery and Assault.🤬

[@sabrinaleedance]

Sigh Chaeyeon apologizing for what happened to her on that show is giving Tzuyu apologizing for being Taiwanese Why did she have to apologize for inappropriate behaivor?? She did absolutely nothing wrong and it's a perfect example of how in alot of cultures blaming the victim/woman any way they can its so sad

[@soomi]

I'm honestly surprised for how long this company has been able to just go on - getting support from both fans, employees and investors - and I'm especially concerned for how long parents have been sending their daughters to these companies willingly despite knowing it's reputation. All adults in this situation should held accountable and due to companies like these I personally stopped investing myself into nugu companies and nugu groups all together. If we don't send money or give attention to these sketchy companies, the sooner it will stop existing and just dissolve and the sooner these idols will be free. Boycotting IS effective. The problem is that sadly the main public audience in kpop isn't aware as they are too busy focusing on the same 10 trending groups atm. We should pay attention and support nugus, but for the right reasons and only from companies that seem legal and fair. I am absolutely appalled children are unsafe in this industry. I do support some groups that have minors in them, but they are definitely not 12 or 14. I always make sure there's at least an adult fellow member with with them at all times before consuming the group's music. Groups like busters and even similar young adult groups make it really hard for people to easily get into new groups as we all want to actively avoid supporting the exploitation of young idols in toxic environments. This is and MUST be a standard for all. Normalize calling out any kpop fans who are NSFW creepy about any idols. Minors or not. This is a music hobby. Not an adult industry. Thank you wholeheartedly for this video. I re-tweeted it on twitter. Bless.

[@junghwanz3593]

BUSTERS have been my uband for over a year now and i'm so sad seeing the way Marbling treats them...

[@gwenmloveskpopcecmore]

I’m so sorry I’m late to this. But thank u so much for spreading about this situation it really deserves so much attention and spotlight. Especially since they’re so nugu and not many people talk about nugu groups cuz they’re so nugu ofc. #ProtectBusters

[@lepidopteraxx]

I have no doubt Marbling knows exactly what they are doing.

[@jihoonscarat]

I agree. At this point there is no way they don’t know how the group is being viewed and are in my opinion using that for financial gain

[@lepidopteraxx]

@@jihoonscarat I would go as far as to say they aren’t a company as much as they are predators. I hate we can’t do more to bring attention to that part of it.

[@Molly-iw1rc]

I'm convinced 100 percent that there is no way to ethically have minors in a kpop group. Because there is a 100 percent chance that people will sexualize them simply because of the job. Companies who debut groups with minors know that they will be sexualized and do not care. Obviously, Marbling is taking full advantage of all of this and is clearly purposefully doing things to increase the horrible exposure. But I think every kpop company does this as well, just not as bad, but they know there is a specific audience that specifically wants a minor. It's generally creepy.

[@jihoonscarat]

I agree. It’s just a bad idea over all. There are strict rules in minors working regular jobs and even they are screwed over and taken advantage off. It’s just unethical to place a minor in a situation like that

[@gwenmloveskpopcecmore]

I’ll share this on Weverse cuz there’s very phew people on there that would know them

[@jihoonscarat]

Thank you! I appreciate it

[@femmedemort]

My theory is that the first guest member, being an adult, was blocking the faces of the members to protect them as they were all minors. She writes kind messages and clearly held them in high regard. Maybe she wanted to give them the privacy they never had.

[@chaengster4946]

Thank you! I will be sharing.

[@gwenmloveskpopcecmore]

I had heard of the group’s name before but I checked them out more in 2022. Also thanks for clarifying about their company because I thought their company was Marbling since day 1

[@henrybanchieri8305]

Hi man, I totally missed you but I’m glad you’ve returned

[@gwenmloveskpopcecmore]

If u ask me I hope there will be more laws out for minors in kpop (when the Korean government gets a wake up call and stuff) plus some of the most recent ones took so long to be passed like bru

[@yunaii4595]

Thank you for making this video

[@mattevans6752]

I started following Busters during Tropical Romance era (that song is a bop). It became very obvious very quickly how much of the company's business model was based on sexualizing Takara and it makes me sick. At first I noticed she seemed to be the most popular member so I figured that she had been in a different group in Japan or something before joining Busters, but no, it's just that the company sexualizes her that much.

[@pico2260]

The other sad thing about this situation is that they are a good group with good songs which they interpret well, yet their company is more interested in promoting them to all kinds of fetishists than in promoting their songs. Quite a disaster, whichever way you look at it.

[@Strawberry_Angelic]

Atat 37:20 you can actualy start seeing there faces of concern and scared, wtf they are making them uncomfortable

[@TomsMusicCorner]

About how you can help: There is one weak point that every company fears - a total boycott. Don't share their videos, don't buy their albums (if available), photo cards, merch etc., stop streaming, don't go to concerts or fan meetings. Delete them completely from your memory. It all makes Marbling money. At the same time, bombard Marbling with emails and be loud on X, just like Orbits back then. It helped. I'm happy for Chaeyeon, that she has a good company now and 19 (23 soon) sisters ;) The future of Yeseo is uncertain but she will probably join Limelight together with Mashiro and two other trainees. I'm only sad for Hyungseo bc the lack of CLASS:y content. At least they have a normal contract (7 years).

[@jihoonscarat]

That is something that kinda confuses me. As they don’t have a lot of merch, and they don’t have a lot of Spotify listeners. And minimal fan events. It makes me wonder where the money is coming from to keep them afloat, especially in covid times

[@TomsMusicCorner]

@@jihoonscarat I can't say anything about that. I don't know how the company is structured

[@lovelymill]

@@jihoonscarat probably sponsors, but special ones that want young idols to wear revealing clothes and etc.... if you know what i mean://

[@_mon_tego]

I'll share this message and video and use the email template!!

[@jihoonscarat]

Thank you so much!

[@_mon_tego]

@@jihoonscarat You’re welcome! Thank you for bringing this to my attention

[@GIRLYISMS]

so happy chaeyeon is in tripleS. they are my current ult group so it’s crazy to see where each girl came from, and as a kep1ian, i kept seeing this group busters. horrible management,,,,, weird undertones…..

[@miyamuni]

This is so disgusting.

[@jasoninthea.m7471]

Is there a way you can post a link to the picture to download? My X (Twitter) doesn't work as of recently, and I would love to inform my subs on my ktube channel, and share to other people!

[@jihoonscarat]

Hi! I also posted the photo on my Instagram! You can get the photo there ❤️instagram.com/p/C4QxoFPoguM/?igsh=MXN5b2p0NTd4ZWRweQ==

[@jasoninthea.m7471]

Thank you.@@jihoonscarat

[@Bom.3d]

This is so so scary i hope this gets more attention

[@itsrayyyyxd]

I downloaded twitter for it lmao... I shared it:D

[@nobody-vk1oe]

Thank you for bringing attention to the mistreatment of minors in the kpop industry. It's such important work to raise awareness around this. What's so disheartening is when you don't see people call this irresponsibility out on the part of the parents and the adults involved in exploitation of minors. So thank you for doing what should have been the bare minimum in the ideal world. I hope the girls disband. There's no point to Busters because their company and their target audience of creepy old men ruined it for everyone else.

[@mangojelly23]

Just found this video and it's horrible what these girls are going through, I'm completely disgusted. I don't have X but I just sent the email, I hope they can set free from that weird idiots

[@naevisual]

oh my god i am SO disgusted by the COMPANY and also the PARENTS. this is so scary. it's so eerily obvious who the company's target audience was, like it just grosses me out. i hope they all get better treatment or even switch companies because WTF.

[@thepiizzaman4489]

my jaw is on the FLOOR how tf does this shit fly

[@gwenmloveskpopcecmore]

Yuck those comments 🤮 🤢 poor girls. These poor girls ate being s*ulized

[@jihoonscarat]

Absolutely repulsive

[@gwenmloveskpopcecmore]

@@jihoonscarat exactly bruh reminds me of some older kpop groups like Dalshabet and especially Stellar

[@bastetowl3258]

@@gwenmloveskpopcecmoreyes. even if the members were grown in those groups, they were obviously sexualized and made to perform fan service/ more explicit choreo and concepts, bordering on p0rnographic. things have gotten a little better nowadays but not by much

[@gwenmloveskpopcecmore]

@@bastetowl3258 yeah unfortunately

[@cegy4765]

25:57 ive been a fan of busters for a WHILE and i think i know the reason y minmin left all of a sudden, but its kinda scandelous/serious so feel free to delete this comment! so basically there was a livestream that i didnt tune into, but a busters clips account posted a video from this stream where minmin sings a rlly innapropriate lyric from a starboi3 and dojacat song kinda loudly(?) but whispers a profanity and thats where the clip ends. the clip didnt go viral or anything but i remember comparing the views of this vid and the rest from that acc and yea it had a lot more.. my guess is someone from marbling saw it, or somebody couldve notified the company of that incident. it could also b that marbling got her in trouble directly after themselves but i cant imagine them caring about busters reputation unless driven to by controversy. obviously marbling never said anything about y she left tho so it could just b coincidence but thats what i always attributed it to 🤷‍♀️

[@jihoonscarat]

That could be a reason or played into it for sure. I definitely don’t trust Marbling to be honest in their statements so I don’t know if we will ever know

[@littlekittyloves1740]

#ProtectBusters 💖

[@sparksparkle]

34:03 NOT THE AI GENERATED COVER HAHAHAH 😂😂😂😂😂

[@gwenmloveskpopcecmore]

Also at one point they had twin members

[@camelama]

I had no idea this group was still going. I remember checking them out when they originally debuted, but I was put off by their ages and decided not to support them. The people at Marbling absolutely know what they're doing. I feel like kpop fans sort of lose sight of the fact that agencies are not these abstract entities run by the magic of "industry practices". There are living breathing people at Marbling (most likely predominantly middle aged men) making the conscious decision to exploit minor girls for a chance at financial gain. Any agency that replaces members on such a regular basis has no affection or respect for those idols as people. They're entirely replaceable, even moreso than other idols. I hope the current members are able to get out of their contracts quickly and move on with their lives in a safer environment.

[@kazuverse_]

busters has to be a front for money laundering

[@blueberrybluetube1955]

26:29 So, you’re telling me that this music video was filmed with a phone?

[@kuya_d17]

we need the members to leave marbling. THE LOONA WAY.

[@megh_is_chillin]

This is disgusting. Kpop needs to STOP debuting minors and doing this to them. #ProtectBusters

[@anaclaraschuenck2383]

its só sad, they were so good and so talented

[@Molly-iw1rc]

34:31 this makes me sad. Because she is a GREAT dancer. But a lot of companies (and fans lets be honest) convince kpop idols that Sexy = Good dancing. A lot of young trainees learn overtly sexual dances because they think those are the main technically good dances. You also see many main dancers in groups also are the "sexy" members. I wish this connection would stop, sexy doesn't mean technically good dancing. You can show dancing skills in many ways. Please don't be convinced that sexual dancing is the superior way to show skills. I see this thinking a lot from idol trainees who want to improve their dancing, they think sexual dances 'look cooler'. There is absolutely nothing wrong with sexy dancing, but minors shouldn't think it's the only way to prove they can dance to adults. The whole idea of that is creepy and we need to stop letting companies push this idea to children.

[@anaclaraschuenck2383]

❤

[@dt4654]

do the people on kpopfap want to end up with CP charge or something? busters are real people, not some anime characters anymore.

[@XuiLeeEv]

#ProtectBusters

[@stay_in_paris5351]

34:34 omfg this is even worse than I thought. What kind of parents they have?????

[@ILikeBreadBro]

Off topic but I think you should make a vid on how busters is one of the luckiest girl groups! After the members left all their carreers took a toll for the better!

[@shoyuramenoff]

It would be in poor taste right now, I think.

[@kanakanaa.]

It is also worth to mention that the CEO of Marbling has a problematic past behind him SQR/SQUEAR/Lee Jun Kim (김이준) has previously produced for a few j-pop groups and has been the representative/producer for two self-established companies. The first company, 302:SKOOL was originally a soundtrack company which released songs for games such as R2Beat. In 2006, they announced that they will be debuting an 8-member girlgroup (two of the members are associated with MYDOLL, the company that has collaborated with Marbling). The group had a member-rotation system similar to what the japanese girlgroup Morning Musume does), meaning that the lineup changed with each comeback (In total they had 16 members, three of which debuted at 17, two at 14 and one at TWELVE. All ages are most likely in the korean aging system. The ages of 4 members are unknown to me). This has caused controversy even predebut, due to the similarity to the rotation system of the famous japanese girlgroup Morning Musume. What's worse is that the members were fans of the group, and SQR lied about it which fueled the fans' anger even more. The hate got so big that they ended up having more haters than fans. Even an "fancafe" was created specifically to harass the group. The anticafe is still available to find on the internet, but most posts are unavailable to read for non-members. In the public posts however, we can find one that says that the members are well aware of the cafe's existance and saying something about the home adresses of two of the members (one of them being the 14 year old ☹) Summarising, the young members had a big group of adults harrassing them and the company has done absolutely NOTHING to protect them. The second company was named Pandagram (which is similar to Marbling's previous name, Monstergram). In 2015, they debuted a girlgroup with a metal/rock concept, similar to babymetal. During the early stages of their career they had no controversies, until their last comeback. That is to say, they were given a n4zi concept. The armbands in their MV outfits resemble the ones that n4zi soldiers used to wear. SQR explained in an interview that "the thought [of the n4zi symbolism] never occurred" and that the arbands were meant to express the groups ambition and their desire “to expand without a limit in four directions". Even though the group was never known, the matter got so big that it caused the group to disband. Even to this day, the pictures from this era are used either as a meme by regular kpop stans (which I find increadibly weird) or by incel kpop fans in far-right communities. **[TRIGGER WARNING FOR THIS PART]** Allegedly, the members were s*xually ab*sed by the company, however I have not found sources on that. If that was true, then we can speculate that the n4zi concept was used to cover up the ab*se. Considering all of the above, I don't think Marbling will ever change. Of course, I'm not suggesting that we should stop trying to get them to do something, but the opposite. Let's all work hard and get the girls to leave that company !!!

[@kanakanaa.]

I forgot to mention that one of the members of the first girlgroup dated an EXO member. I have no idea when that happened, but it definitely worsened the hate towards them. So basically they had 2 popular fandoms against them, and they still weren't protected by 302:skool at all ☹

[@kanakanaa.]

I also think that we should start boycotting all of Busters' content, along with SQR's previous gg's

[@jihoonscarat]

Thank you for this comment. Simone did mention they thought the groups were connected but when I tried to find information in English I didn’t find anything. I think this is just further proof! Any chance you can dm me on Twitter or IG, so i can ask you a bit more about the CEO?

[@panic.3426]

I hope to god this video gets traction

[@blueberrybluetube1955]

I hope K-pop Stans will protest on streets, lanes, and roads even though they aren’t Buchus.

[@markbowley5780]

Is Chae still in touch with the girls I wonder? I follow TripleS but haven't heard if she is

[@jihoonscarat]

I honestly don’t know how things are now, but I know that before Hyungseo joined classy she, Chaeyeon and Jisoo met up often and shared IG stories but now that they have all kind of started their careers again they might not up as often. But at least after they left Busters they were in contact☺️

[@markbowley5780]

@@jihoonscarat thanks ..I do remember chae talking about her redebut and how she had hard time and how happy she was to redebut it was quite emotional..glad she got out from that company. I get feeling maybe they are getting on with their respective careers and maybe don't keep in touch to avoid any bad publicity coming into their new situation.

[@starijen8547]

chaeyeon, hyungseo, yeseo, jisoo & minji are all still in touch (they auditioned for girls planet together & slept over at hyungseo’s when the results for who was participating on the show came out) but i’m not sure about the other girls

[@no4528]

​@@jihoonscarat what areJisoo & Minji's instagram accounts please?

[@kasparov85]

Yeseo recently said that the reason why she left Busters WAS NOT because of "extreme fans" (sasaeng). MARBLING said that without her consent. And that night when the fan came, she was not alone, but with her parents. She also said, that she was sorry for that fan, and was happy to see him at Music Bank last year. So Marbling lied about the real reason why Yeseo (and probably Jisoo/Chaeyeon) left Busters.

[@jihoonscarat]

She did say the stalker was going overboard. However it is a very odd situation, and the concern is still valid, she should be protected especially in situations like that. Over all it’s very odd

[@blackatblu]

#protectbusters

[@kobyspawdios]

I have email marbling, i hope it works!!

[@glaciemdraco]

Also, maybe it's just me and it could be just how they sound normally, but I think what 'adds' to this is the fact that - to me - they all have cutesy, high-pitched voices. Combine that with the styling and a *lot* of this choreo Im seeing in the video and it's... yeah, not a good look. If the company is somehow still around, Im hoping they will end up shut down like that TS company was (if you know then you know again)

[@beccikinomoto5651]

I hope y'all finally know how much the Best New Artist Award means Chaeyeon (TripleS) after all she went through! Also hopefully y'all still support the other former Members as well! Stream TripleS, Classy, Kep1er and Minji Solo Song y'all!

[@kikygustami3359]

Actually i stan buster because minji, but i still listening until yeseo depature. But how i can't even remember chaeyeon on triple s 😂