This Is Why I Love RDR1 More Than RDR2

#rdr2 #rdr #reddeadredemption #arthurmorgan

[@danim8414]

RDR1 feels like you’re in a Wild West movie, RDR2 feels like you’re in real life.

[@g_nj]

And real life sucks

[@jasperdreamer9342]

The rdr2 version feels like your in gta5 while rdr1 looks like your in gta4 by the graphics

[@3to4characters]

​@@jasperdreamer9342not gta 5. Gta 4 and gta 5 arent far enough so that they could be compared to the vast difference in graphics and detail between rdr1 and 2

[@NilaMuddassira]

@@g_nj bro is depressed

[@detectivejojo7025]

rdr 1 is set in wild west so

[@RealSoapz]

RDR1 has GTA VI physics

[@zeenathismail8054]

I like rdr1 better

[@TheSpoonThatBends-mx1wj]

youre the type of person who cant appreciate good games?

[@FunnyRedemption]

​@@TheSpoonThatBends-mx1wjYou're the type of person who can't accept different opinions?

[@TimmyTurner_765]

@@TheSpoonThatBends-mx1wjIt’s just they might prefer the wacky gameplay of RDR1 more

[@averyjernigan6036]

​@JasonDude-mx1wj when did he say he didn't appreciate good games?

[@LOMAZKO7]

​@@TheSpoonThatBends-mx1wjbro come on you're better than that

[@FrankGelbeet]

Moreover, - you can't buy a house in rdr2 - you can't visit MEXICO - no Undead Nightmare - no cheat code for a skipping the storyline - no cheat code for an opening of locked areas - wrong scenery - worst horse-riding, where you can smash yourself and your horse - rdr2 feels like Kingdom Come Deliverance with guns, heavily inspired with this realism-shit stuff

[@RedOtter100]

RDR1 aged like fine wine but your not being honest with yourself sir!

[@vicevilla9949]

i like how rdr 1 is stylized more than rdr 2

[@gubsnubs]

@vicevilla9949 I've seen rdr2 and I play rdr1 but rdr2 has more design on buildings and rdr1 is bland

[@vicevilla9949]

@@gubsnubs i've played both and wouldn't agree rdr1 is bland, yes i think rdr2 has more and better design on buildings and world graphics, more animals that are also more detailed and a lot more stuff, but i think rdr soundtrack and atmosphere is better than rdr 2, and the story holds up really well. Also rdr had undead nightmare and a proper multiplayer mode unlike the dogshit pay to win red dead online. Both are great games but if rdr 2 didn't have fishing going for it, rdr would be be better.

[@NilaMuddassira]

@@vicevilla9949 the soundtrack , atmosphere and dlc isnt enough to make rdr better. nostalgia is crazy

[@Stirfry47]

​@@NilaMuddassirawell I'm pretty sure the soundtrack, and atmosphere are kinda big factors of what makes a good game, not just graphics, and rdr still has a better story bruh

[@Wertyber]

did John just hit a backwards griddy

[@tbago8783]

Ah yes with the slippery-ahh horse riding 🚬🗿

[@FrankGelbeet]

RDR 1 IS THE BEST GAME EVER! I have played for 100 hours for each RDR game. And I find RDR1 as the only WESTERN OPEN WORLD GAME. RDR1: + that beloved scenery of southern California, Nevada, Arizona, northern parts of Mexico. That beloved yellow and orange scenery, cactuses. + that beloved towns with saloons + that beloved white cowboys with hats and guns + that not less beloved mexican vaqueros, mexican rebels, MEXICANS! + I love MEXICO. Yeah, Blackwater is architecturally best city with a bigger amount of entertainment... Armadillo is cool and one of the best cities...but...I LOVE MEXICO. Mexico is like a land of unlimited freedom. I love Mexico and Mexicans. + I hate stories in games, but I loved completing John Marston's story. + I like John Marston. He is even humourous. + I like the best of all - Jack Marston. He is the best protagonist ever. Rebellious, independent, intelligent. He loves books. Quite ideallistic character. I like him. + Great shooting. + Great horse-riding + Great cheat-codes, with the help of them, you can even open THE LOCKED AREAS! I couldn't believe my eyes that it works. I was always dreaming about such cheat - code in GTA SA 😂😂😂. RDR 1 IS A REVOLUTIONARY GAME! + YOU CAN BUY A HOUSE + YOU CAN PLAY AS JACK MARSTON + UNDEAD NIGHTMARE You can expect different stuff from this game, but... zombie-apocalypse with a story? WOW My point: 11 out of 11 RDR 1 easily beats RDR2, KCD, The Witcher 3, Skyrim, GTA SA, The Outer Worlds, even horrible Baldur's Gate 3. ******************************************* RDR 2: + it is a game, not a product containing game elements That's it. You can play this game and be entertained with it...but... I didn't fall in love with it. - RDR2 lacks THAT ATMOSPHERE AND SCENERY (Yeah, I know that Wild West included different regions, even with a snow, even with forests and all this stuff...but... GIVE ME THAT YELLOW AND ORANGE SCENERY from westerns of my childhood, GIVE ME THAT VIBE FROM CLASSIC BRONCHO BILLY, LEONE'S MOVIES WITH MR. EASTWOOD, GIVE ME THAT VIBE FROM SUNSETRIDERS ON SEGA MEGA DRIVE). - RDR 2 is heavily inspired by Kingdom Come Deliverance. I hate this REALISM stuff. I hate it with all my heart. Feed a character/feed a horse. ENJOY MORGAN'S COUGHING, BLOOD, VOMIT AND WASH YOUR FACE WITH HIS TUBERCULOSIS Why do I have to watch these disgusting moments IN A VIDEO GAME? I came to game in order to ENJOY, not to SUFFER or watching symptoms of tuberculosis. - ARTHUR I do not even know what to say about this character. He is NEUTRAL like Geralt of Rivia, which I hated so much. He is emotional like a LOG. Even John Marston is more humorous and emotional that Arthur. Jack is the best of them all. I also like Dutch and Micah. ******************************** And now...Imagine me. I finished RDR 1. Expected to see yellow and orange scenery. Expected to play as Jack Marston. And what did I get ? I play a huge amount of minutes in order to see: - SNOW. I hate snow. I hate it with all my heart, because 7 months out of 12 are in snow in my motherland. - Forests like in my area. I am fed up with them. - Cuba??? WTF? But okay... - TUBERCULOSIS and enjoying the symptoms - Neutral and non-emotional Morgan, like Geralt of Rivia - soap opera elements - interactive movie My point: 5 out of 11

[@OperatorDan2034]

what the fuck

[@OperatorDan2034]

Yk that you don't need to feed your horse or Arthur everytime? Did you know that there is wild west scenery from your childhood in rdr2? I love rdr1 and especially I'm a big fan boy of John Marston but in my opinion story in rdr2 is written a bit better also horse riding is way moreeee better in rdr2 than in rdr1

[@OperatorDan2034]

Also saying that Arthur is non-emotional is crazyyyy did you play the game yourself or you just watched KZbin gameplays??? Idk man your points are invalid as hell probably because you didn't play the game yourself

[@OperatorDan2034]

Also where the hell rdr2 is inspired by Kingdom come deliverance?

[@FrankGelbeet]

@@OperatorDan2034 There are FACTS mentioned here by me. If you feel a butthurt, you are definitely an annoying fan of rdr 2. It was a pleasure to see your hysterics. Your hysterics is my victory!

[@rodriguesblaine2]