Thomas and the Birthday Mail - Thomas and Friends Rewritten

When the Fat Controller's new engine Rosie arrives, Thomas is asked to take some birthday mail to his niece. However, when Thomas begins to think that Rosie is making fun of him trouble isn't far behind.
Roll Call by: Headmaster Hastings (sorry that I forgot go check him out he's very talented)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
THIS VIDEO IS MADE FOR A GENERAL AUDIENCE, IT IS KID FRIENDLY, BUT NOT DIRECTLY AIMED AT KIDS!
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I also have a discord so feel free to come over and chat ! : / discord
#fuck #Ifuckedyourwhorewife

[@bigmacsama]

Now that's what I call a better rewritten episode and introduction of Rosie the Pink Tank Engine.

[@BrendamProductions]

Thank you!

[@bigmacsama]

@@BrendamProductions anytime, pal

[@excitablepack7076]

I prefer this version of Rosie, than her being a yandere for Thomas.

[@ketanreffell2720]

Thomas The Tank Engines and Rosie The Pink Engines

[@neo-warkid4edwards222]

and you know what would make a good rewrite for the Funfair Special episode? if Emily alone was taking the titular Train, but Rosie sees that she accidentally left half of it behind when pulling out due to a faulty coupling, so then Rosie had chase Emily to let her know what happened@@BrendamProductions​

[@Gothenburg32]

That was brilliant! This clearly explains why Rosie wanted to be like Thomas and why she kept trying to copy him and follow him, it was because she didn’t know the way and she didn’t want to get lost. At first, I thought it was because she had a crush on him! LOL

[@BrendamProductions]

Thank you and yeah no I don't buy into any engine ships because they're engines not humans lol

[@primrosevale1995]

@@BrendamProductions You can make engine ships work if you want to but it’s not necessary.

[@BrendamProductions]

@@primrosevale1995 What's that?

[@primrosevale1995]

@@BrendamProductions Just saying that if ships are something a writer wants to include in a Thomas story, they can do that. But it’s far from necessary since they are machines,

[@BrendamProductions]

@@primrosevale1995 Oh I see now yeah I mean to each their own but personally I'm not a fan of it.

[@benbearce96]

Who agrees with me that this is “Thomas and the Birthday Mail” if it were done in the Classic Series.

[@BrendamProductions]

That was the intention so I'm glad that it came across :D

[@ClearwaterMK2]

Specifically a Series 2 episode...

[@BrendamProductions]

@@ClearwaterMK2 Series 2? How come?

[@ClearwaterMK2]

@@BrendamProductions Because that way, Rosie would earn her place in the Farquhar branch line.

[@sonicranger5418]

It's better than the Season 10 version of the episode.

[@Edward2Fan47]

And I thought Rosie came to the island because of what she heard about in the RWS that made her a big fan.

[@Bunbiichuffn]

I'm rather hopeful this ends with Thomas reassuring Rosie that she shouldn't try to always be like him, seeing as he got himself into the landslide, and that she should discover what makes her special. Development for both characters, that's what I like

[@BrendamProductions]

I've changed some things about Rosie but you'll see in the premiere :)

[@skylarthompson299]

@Slimkilla Studios (Cute.) (Rosie Is Red: Exists.) (Nevermind QwQ I don’t wanna ruin your hc but Mattel kinda…..uh….shipped it.-)

[@themightygallium9509]

@@skylarthompson299 (Am I a weirdo for shipping Nia and Edward?)

[@skylarthompson299]

@@themightygallium9509 No

[@worfsonofmogh1154]

I might actually disagree. From a storytelling them perspective you're right. That should be what Thomas does. But given his personality, Thomas loves the attention. Especially, if this is meant to take place earlier in Thomas' life when he was more vain.

[@engineboy53productions15]

Great Rewritten Season 10 Episode. This makes a lot more sense than the original.

[@BrendamProductions]

Thank you I'm glad you liked it!

[@MilesL.auto-train4013]

Holy crap, I remember watching the original air on PBS kids, and this just seems like such a stark contrast to what the had made for the show at that time. This is fantastic, I love it.

[@BrendamProductions]

Thank you I'm glad you liked it!

[@RonnieThePRRLoco3750]

I love the actual episode, but at the same time, I love the rewritten one.

[@DavidFlores-jp4vk]

I love how you make Rosies’ infatuation for Thomas make sense! I can def relate to rhe way Rosie try’s to imitate her coworkers on the first day of her new job. Incredibly well done, miles better than the original.

[@BrendamProductions]

Thank you I'm glad I was able to make rosie make more sense

[@JamestheParodyMaker7446]

This was a great one. I like how you put Rosie when she first arrived on the Island like shes a New Engine.

[@BrendamProductions]

Thanks I'm glad you enjoyed it!

[@JamestheParodyMaker7446]

@@BrendamProductions Your Very Welcome!

[@CraneProductions27]

That was awesome. I loved the change in character for Rosie and how she hears about Thomas. This works much better and I love how Rosie behaves all bubbly and excited when around Thomas 😀😀😀👏👏👏❤.

[@BrendamProductions]

Thanks Ross!

[@harrisonallen651]

It never explained why Rosie fancies Thomas from the beginning of the original. I really enjoyed your interpretation on what could’ve been once again!

[@BrendamProductions]

Thank you I'm glad you enjoyed the changes I made!

[@Sam_Brunt]

Only, wouldn’t Thomas have been annoyed if she fancied him?

[@tomthetenderengine663]

This actually gives Rosie more of a personality. I like that. Now I know why Rosie likes Thomas

[@Ethan-ey4jx]

If Gullane wasn’t bought by HiT, the stuff from Series 1-7 would extend all the way up to Series 12 just like this.

[@disneylover3434]

this is so million times better than the original episode from the hit era

[@TheBallWithTheShield]

I know that there are plenty of Trainz Thomas content creators on YT who all make really good stuff, but your, I guess you could say, style feels very comfy and natural, as if the camera shots, lighting, and narration are all actually from the show. I kinda like that!

[@BrendamProductions]

Thank you!

[@emersoninfinitystone5785]

Awww, the thumbnail makes Thomas & Rosie look so cute.

[@MrDankEngine1999]

This worked much better than the actual episode, well done Harry! 👍

[@Bunbiichuffn]

I like this. This was a good way to write Rosie. Sweet ending too

[@BrendamProductions]

Thank you!

[@TankEngine97]

Like a number of your other rewrites, this was better than the original episode.

[@BrendamProductions]

Thank you I'm glad you think so!

[@stepneybulstrodemusic1761]

This was a great rewrite! I also love the season 4-7 styled music

[@BrendamProductions]

Thanks! Also full credit for the music goes to Severn Valley Studios

[@yellowsqueak.4778]

Now I see what my friend meant about Rosie acting like Amy.

[@florjanbrudar692]

Amy Rose you mean?

[@yellowsqueak.4778]

@@florjanbrudar692 Yeah

[@DarthWill3]

Now that's how you start a good ship. Am I right? ;) Also, the thought of Sir Topham Hatt telling Thomas off right in that mudslide, and in the middle of the night, kinda makes me wanna smirk. XD

[@BrendamProductions]

Omg noooooo lol

[@DarthWill3]

@@BrendamProductions What? I 🚢 it.

[@BrendamProductions]

@@DarthWill3 To each their own I just meant that mine was not meant to be shippy at all

[@sophiebyers5496]

This rewrite is so relatable to neurodivergent people

[@tommybakes5972]

in the original Rosie seems like she's just a fangirl here they've never met

[@funnyclown2514]

Better than the actual episode.

[@CartoonBoi13]

Rosie is basically the tank engine version of Amy rose

[@BrendamProductions]

She really isn't supposed to be like she is in the original episode but if you still feel that about the Rosie I wrote then um... oops

[@CartoonBoi13]

@@BrendamProductions I meant in the original episode

[@Stuingtion]

So much better than the original episode! And a better way to introduce Rosie!

[@AbareKillerFan-yo7pe]

This makes more sense than the actual episode

[@Thomas__Blue]

This was a really cool rewrite, alot of the shots of Thomas look straight out of the series with the lighting and all.

[@BrendamProductions]

Thank you also I'm not sure if the shots looking like the hit era is a good or bad thing lol but thank you either way :)

[@superxavxii421]

I like your version and the original, but I really love how you gave a reason as to why Rosie acted the way she did.

[@amitysluzara2022]

I love what you did with Rosie in this

[@esmondmerry]

Am I not the only one who feels like the scene where Rosie first sees Thomas and then starts following him does that sound very familiar to when Amy first saw Sonic the story almost feels like a fan made Sonic story establishing when Amy first met Sonic that's exactly what this is really in this episode this exactly from season 2 of Thomas in this rewrite Thomas and Rosie feel exactly like Sonic and Amy I think the Sonic and Amy of Thomas and Friends people!!!

[@user-wt1nb1cg6s]

Thomas has a crush on Rosie was in love with Thomas doesn't even notice that Rosie is in love with him Thomas and Rosie loves each other they haven't seen each other they are best friends ever since they met they care about each other for being there for each other they promised to help each other that's what friends are for

[@xenmartin9759]

HiT era is the best Thomas era and my favorite

[@radzieckigraczproductions3]

An excellent video. the character development in this video was excellent!

[@BrendamProductions]

Thank you! I'm glad you liked it!

[@radzieckigraczproductions3]

@@BrendamProductions :D

[@kylegraham6923]

Awesome rewrite! 10/10!

[@ItsCarlos563]

I like the actual episode, but this rewrite is much better.

[@TheSodorBullet]

This was a nice rewrite. Although, if I had it my way, I’d have Mrs. Kyndley be the one that Thomas gives the presents too lol. I like the changes you made to Rosie’s character. It gives more depth to her and makes her less bland. I also liked the ending with Thomas and Rosie at the shed. Seemed very classic series-ish. Good job, overall! 👍

[@BrendamProductions]

Thank you! I'm glad you liked the changes!

[@anthonymcpeters6762]

Rosie likes Thomas

[@dominicborrayo4112]

An e2 and a s100 having a dialogue. Nice!

[@EthanTheEngine7]

Rosie: ight imma follow tom Thomas: *I very getmadz*

[@ivattblue]

the music sucks total ass ngl in all seriousness this is a great rewrite and i had a good time working on it. thanks for having me on!

[@BrendamProductions]

Personally I think it’s the only bit that doesn’t stink 😉 Thanks mate thank you for making the music for it as well

[@SMPandanic]

I remember not liking Rosie when I owned the dvd with this episode on it

[@BrendamProductions]

In which case I'm curious if you like her in the way that I've portrayed her

[@thomastakenplaytakealongfa1656]

Will you do the same thing to Thomas’ Day Off with Dennis?

[@BrendamProductions]

At some point yes but I'm not sure when that will be right now.

[@thomastakenplaytakealongfa1656]

It’s ok, dude, just take your time.

[@steamzilla95]

I was thinking of Duck replacing Thomas in this rewrite.

[@swag-a-dellaman6555]

Uh-oh! Thomas has got a stalker!

[@SparklingJam]

Add an o-face and this is better than the whole hit era

[@TheHawaiianEngine]

Dang. I might miss this one but hopefully I'll see this video for myself.

[@BrendamProductions]

Yeah the video will always be here to watch even if you can't make the premiere

[@naturespecialist1489]

2:09 Sooo much better

[@Steamenginesunited3456]

Beautiful rewrite

[@BrendamProductions]

Thanks!

[@user-ek4gc7kb9q]

This is so cute and adorable Thomas x Rosie i didn't know that Thomas loved Rosie that much in his life Thomas x Rosie love

[@Sam_Brunt]

I would’ve thought Thomas would be annoyed about Rosie fancying him.

[@mohammedgeedi2541]

MOHAMMED GEEDI: From 00:00 to 10:11 In my personal opinion, Rosie should be voiced by Gretchen Gritcherson herself - Melissa Altro.

[@mohammedgeedi2541]

MOHAMMED GEEDI: Also in my opinion, Rosie should have a human incarnation of herself.

[@mohammedgeedi2541]

MOHAMMED GEEDI: And last but not least, there should be a future Thomas episode where we'll get to see a romantic relationship arc between her and a certain silver tank engine - Stanley. (Stanley should be voiced by Scott McCord, by the way)

[@FerdinandProductions2021]

I wonder what the next rewritten episode will be.

[@nganson8785]

What A Wonderful Splendid Remake Episode We'll Done and With Different Scene Original Episode We'll Done Brendam Productions and Good Job Indeed Keep It Up 👍🏻 ❤

[@Az14900]

Honestly just Stanley being in the rewritten theme song roll call surprised me

[@BrendamProductions]

It's my favourite chorus of the one Headmaster Hastings did so Stanley being in in is a kinda accident. I'd have it be the normal lyrics if I could but yeah

[@Az14900]

@@BrendamProductions ah that makes sense, maybe there’s a way you could rewrite it, but don’t know tbh

[@BrendamProductions]

@@Az14900 I don't know if I will ever rewrite tgd cause I actually quite like it

[@Az14900]

@@BrendamProductions true true

[@Thebreakingbadthomasfan23]

Well done

[@BrendamProductions]

Tah!

[@BriceInkling138]

While I like the original version, the rewrite version is kind of nice. So far.

[@bluebellsfan8704]

I loved this! Great job!

[@BrendamProductions]

Thank you!

[@bluebellsfan8704]

@@BrendamProductions np! Loved it!

[@Ninja11125]

Thx

[@jrjigtujlrh.yujeffreyzyirr4285]

Your version is good to.

[@thomthomthetanktankengine6475]

Great

[@BrendamProductions]

Tah!

[@thomthomthetanktankengine6475]

@@BrendamProductions no problem

[@Mariofan2.1]

I thank that Rosie like Thomas 😏

[@RayPeng-07]

This is so cool like the original version or even cooler :D

[@lightbendstudios832]

The ending should have Rosie join the steam team

[@ironcityrailfan8467]

Nice!

[@BrendamProductions]

Tah!

[@ironcityrailfan8467]

@@BrendamProductions np!

[@zacharyspinks6207]

That Was Fantastic!, great Job.

[@BrendamProductions]

Thank you!

[@edwardo6834]

Well Done, Perhaps you can add a Reference like Nickelodeon’s Rugrats the next time you release another Thomas Rewritten episode.

[@BrendamProductions]

I think a Rugrats reference would be a bit out of place personally.

[@garricksl]

@@BrendamProductions Rugrats is so 90s nostalgic trap. I love to see how you include it in a cross-over episode.

[@garricksl]

@@BrendamProductions I love the episode anyway.

[@Oliverfan2010]

What Thomas & Friends roller call did you use?

[@BoyTrain872]

Which re-written Thomas stories are you going to first is it? Percy and the Haunted Mine, Middle Engine, Rusty Saves the Day, The Old Bridge, Harold and the Flying Horse, Trusty Rusty, Molly's Special Special, Tuneful Toots, Rheneas and the Dinosaur, Toby Feels Left Out, Thomas and the New Engine, The Magic Lamp, Thomas' Day Off, Duncan and the Old Mine, Skarloey the Brave, Thomas and the Jet Plane, Duncan Drops a Clanger, Fearless Freddie, Wharf and Peace, Duncan's Bluff, Thomas and Skarloey's Big Day Out, Emily's Rubbish, Hector the Horrid!, Skarloey Storms Through, Duncan Does it All, Sir Handel in Charge, Rosie's Funfair Special, Mountain Marvel, Heave Ho Thomas!, Duncan and the Hot Air Balloon, Tram Trouble and The Man in the Hills.

[@BrendamProductions]

Whichever is voted for by people in the comments of a video coming out in 5 days :)

[@BoyTrain872]

And after the first lot there is another re-written Thomas stories from seasons 13 to 16 I want you to be aware of like Play Time, Steamy Sodor, Hiro Helps Out, Charlie and Eddie, Diesel's Special Delivery, Victor Says Yes, Thomas and Scruff, Happy Hiro, Spencer the Grand, Stop That Bus!, Stuck on You, Big Belle, Kevin the Steamie, Fiery Flynn, Race to the Rescue, Thomas and the Rubbish Train, Percy and the Calliope, Muddy Matters, Whiff's Wish, Welcome Stafford and Don't Bother Victor!

[@LegoWormNoah101]

I'm a bit upset that Rosie is incorrect. She's a Southern USA Class dock tank, which had a completely different valve gear

[@astridzilla1954friendsandnight]

This is amazing I really wish that they introduced Rosie a little bit better

[@BrendamProductions]

Thank you I'm glad you liked how I introduced her!

[@astridzilla1954friendsandnight]

@@BrendamProductions You're welcome and may I do a reaction to this

[@BrendamProductions]

@@astridzilla1954friendsandnight I'm sorry but no thanks for the kind words again though!

[@astridzilla1954friendsandnight]

@@BrendamProductions You’re welcome and I understand

[@emmagill399]

I know Alice from Thomas and Friends.

[@CJDimes]

Cool man new sub!! What game do you happen to use by chance?? I have T:ANE but can’t get mods to work so was just wondering if you can help?

[@BrendamProductions]

Thank you for subscribing! The game I use is TS19 which is the newer version of T:ANE. I don't know of any mods though sorry

[@CJDimes]

@@BrendamProductions is T 19 any good by chance if it is then I’ll maybe get that, but yeah no problem for subbing, this is the first video I saw and I was amazed at the production and how good it was

[@BrendamProductions]

@@CJDimes It looks better and you get some very nice models from people like Sodor Workshops but in other ways it's a pain and it also takes a lot more processing power than TANE does. Also thank you again!

[@thomassimpson95]

I wish they explained in the episode how Rosie was a new engine and joined the Sodor Railway.

[@joshproductions07]

Just wondering but what was wrong with the original story?

[@BrendamProductions]

I didn't like the motivations for the original characters. Also I didn't like the fact that Thomas just delivers the mail to a random girl. It's not as drastic as a change like in Don't Be Silly Billy though but I think it's still an enjoyable video :)

[@joshproductions07]

@@BrendamProductions ok, that makes sense

[@Superaccount393]

Great video! Also, where can i get the windmill route from 0:00??

[@pranavrao6370]

You need to rewrite Rosie's Funfair Special

[@UnbreakableSodor]

Nice

[@BrendamProductions]

Tah!

[@memazov6601]

I wonder if Mattel would shoot this in the face

[@jrjigtujlrh.yujeffreyzyirr4285]

She likes Thomas.

[@jackthefrontloader6266]

Nice job 👍👍👍👍👌👌👌👍👍👌

[@BrendamProductions]

Thanks!

[@jackthefrontloader6266]

Your welcome

[@joshua2337]

Wait a minute here. Why did you rewrite Thomas and the Birthday Mail in your own classic series style?

[@BrendamProductions]

Because I don’t like the original and I’m not the most fond of the hit era style.

[@joshua2337]

@@BrendamProductions Well, I'll tell you what. I know don't like the original and you're not the most fond of the hit era style. I'll interface with

[@kathyholt7523]

Did you give credit to the creators of Thomas and friends

[@scaryfun200]

This is really good.......for the love of God please rewrite Fearless Freddy

[@scaryfun200]

To go with season 4 Narrow Gauge Railway

[@BrendamProductions]

Thank you it's certainly on the list but I'm not sure when at the moment

[@scaryfun200]

I see

[@Jedi-ge6lr]

I'd say I would rewrite almost all of the Narrow Gauge centered episodes, exept for a few. One on the one's I would leave the same would be the one that reintroduced Sir Handle. I really like the idea that all that time at the quarry allowed him to mature.

[@arrdeenadventures]

Hi I’m here!!

[@jimmymccartney2049]

Series 10(2006)

[@jimmymccartney2049]

Narrated by: Michael Brandon

[@TCFSJace]

will SpongeBob be in this episode 🥺

[@ianschwartz08]

no it won't have sPuNk BoP 🥺🥺🥺

[@lilredrobyn44]

do you plan on fixing misty island rescue?

[@BrendamProductions]

At some point in the far future yes all I can tell you right now (because I haven't thought about it too much) is that I'd make it a bit more horror esc and dark

[@littlebacongreengreatweste2606]

Plz rewrite wonky whistle and up up and away

[@littlebacongreengreatweste2606]

And do some rewrites of the bwba era

[@Thebreakingbadthomasfan23]

@@littlebacongreengreatweste2606 no people are already doing those

[@BrendamProductions]

@@littlebacongreengreatweste2606 They'll come at some point but right now the CGI models I'm making aren't ready

[@irishshakespeare7373]

Can you rewrite Middle Engine? We want to see Henry's mistake and got blamed by the manager not Percy who is blamed and Arry and Bert's defeat by Sir Topham Hatt and learning to be careful what you said is the life lesson for Middle Engine. It was the worst season 6 episode and needs to be rewritten and fixed. Good Luck.

[@BrendamProductions]

Middle engine is a story that I will rewrite eventually but I'm not entirely sure when. I know what I'd change about the story including the things you said but I'm not sure when I will make it. Currently rewrites are sub goal rewards until i make content on s3-5 but a lot of people have asked for middle engine so if I reach 10k subs I will add it as an option in the poll

[@irishshakespeare7373]

Here's the sneak peek script section hope it helps. The Manager was very crossed with Henry. Manager: You have cause confusion and delay! (Narrator: He said.) I'll have to report this to Sir Topham Hatt. Narrator: That night Sir Topham Hatt spoke severely to Henry. Sir Topham Hatt: I'm very disappointed, Henry. (Narrator: He said.) You know it's against the rules to shunt engines on to the tipper's loading ramp. Henry: Sorry sir (Henry said sadly.) Sir Topham Hatt: You'll shunt freight cars in the yards until I can get to the bottom of this. Percy: Excuse me sir (Narrator: Percy jumped in.) I don't think Henry didn't meant to bump me... it's because these diesels made me a middle engine. James: Pah! (Narrator: Said James thinking that he can hear.) I can handle those diesels with bent buffers and a busted boiler! Will this script section will do for your rewritten Middle Engine? Thanks.

[@BrendamProductions]

@@irishshakespeare7373 Sorry but I'll probably write my own thing for it but thanks for the offer

[@irishshakespeare7373]

You're welcome

[@annanowak2868]

26 MINUTES LATE!

[@reedbradwahnnatahvera3883]

series 10 episode 23

[@katiepeterson7565]

Can you rewrite toped off thomas.

[@BrendamProductions]

I'm sorry but I just don't even know where to start with topped off Thomas usually I take a part of the episode I liked and embrace that but the closest I've ever come to figuring out what to make of that one is to a parody. It might be the one episode that I can't rewrite lol

[@swag-a-dellaman6555]

@@BrendamProductions What abot Rosie's Funfair Special?

[@susanray6293]

E

[@amandaaahj3878]

No thomas x emily! ❌ Yes, thomas x rosie ✅

[@BrendamProductions]

I mean personally I don’t buy into either of them.

[@Bwhfrlrbx]

​@@BrendamProductions I Ship Thomas X Emily

[@tv-kj4ni]

바봌ㅋ

[@amaraatugbokoh8851]

The original is better than this garbage

[@EndYouTubeShorts_]

Don't you know? Thou shalt not call interesting and child friendly content garbage.