Tighnari OLD vs NEW English Voice Comparison (Elemental Skill, Burst, Idle) | Genshin Impact 3.6

[@streetwiserhapsody]

Door to Khaenriah kzbin.info/www/bejne/npbPYnhmi6xpeJI Secret Heart Shaped Pond in Desert (Co-Op Chest) kzbin.info/www/bejne/b6PZkpqwltqjaMU

[@alpyri]

Love how accurate the hu uh heh hmm ha he hmm eh uhh hm tsk is to the original

[@wishntt]

Mmmmmm

[@Filcayra72]

Can’t tell if OP knows . . .

[@amaris3881]

Ah yes. The hu uh heh hmm ha he hmm eh uhh hm

[@mimiskye]

nice pfp. I used to have a larger scratch but people still were falling for it. your disguise is even better (didn't fall for it tho)

[@gnoot50]

the what

[@a.j.cookie9735]

I think the new VA can be quite promising: remember that Genshin sometimes has their VA’s re-record their lines after initial release (like Ayato’s “About Itto” voice line which got replaced nearly a year later, Barbara as a whole, Diona in her Hangout originally featuring Xiangling’s VA for almost a year before Diona’s own VA redid them etc, there’s more but these are the significant ones ), and given the unique circumstances surrounding Tighnari, there’s no doubt that the new VA had to rush through all these lines in time for the update and therefore probably had less time than a VA typically would to familiarise themselves with the character. So while these samples might seem a bit off right now and inconsistent with the voice direction, there’s a chance they’ll eventually be replaced with more polished recordings and overall better performances overtime as the VA gets used to this role naturally instead of the rushed work they had to do on such short notice. I won’t be surprised if the lines we have now are in fact placeholders just so we have something for actor consistency. Zachary is no newbie to the VA scene, and I believe he can do Tighnari justice with the proper voice direction.

[@yunamoonlight1015]

I really, really hope that is the case. His lines sound so flat now, where did Tighnari's sass go?! I pulled for Tighnari on his banner because I loved his sass. I really hope they new VA will be able to bring it back!

[@mrminecraftcubeable]

I hope these are placeholders, cause they sound kinda bad

[@YourMomsAltAccount]

@@yunamoonlight1015 Not all of his lines are flat, for example I think this Line, "I'll uproot you!" 0:56, is much more lively then the original and has that sense of impact that a Burst line should have. With the "I'll uproot you!" line it's the exact opposite and I personally feel that the original seems flat to me, so I much perfer that new one. If optimizations occur to bring all of them up to par I feel this new VA will surpass the original.

[@Mercyfalls]

Yeah, I think most fans don't consider just how short notice and rushed this recasting and rerecording was. It's great that Hoyo reacted this fast and the faster the old VA can be replaced the better, but that doesn't change that with this little time to work with, of course the performance will suffer. Voice acting isn't just reading a script once and be done. It's the director and VA working out over a long process just how exactly they want the character to sound (VAs don't choose that. The director does) And then it's recording every voice line and even every little sigh/grunt literally DOZENS of times. There's no way Gordon had any time to do that. I think it's even possible that for "one time" lines (like story and archon quest) they only took a single take and moved on. In comparison the skill/burst etc. lines imo sound much better, and those were most likely the ones they focused on and actually took many takes until they were satisfied with it.

[@jaxv3r602]

Barbara got his old lines mixed with new lines when Genshin get released, looked they somehow fucked up Barbara's idle tatara like at least 3 times.

[@evanrammstein9257]

I really love how new VA adding "heh" everywhere! In burst, and in his voice lines... Also 2 out of 3 burst lines are more emotional now! He did a great job. Some players just need more time to adjust

[@eath2606]

What do yoh mean? The "heh" make him sound like a little kid trying to act cool and tough yet fails miserably.

[@Cooc0a]

@@eath2606 yeah it doesn’t suit his more mature personality

[@Doobydoe]

New > Old, started to like him because of the new voice, him sounding more cocky in gameplay is amusing

[@Ainbo]

@@Doobydoe sameee, the old voice was so iritating imo , so glad they changed it 😌

[@reynamomo4359]

yea i like with more emotion

[@aeris143]

i love the new VA so much more!! it doesn’t quite match the same tone of the original, but honestly, i think zachary’s take on tighnari is much more suited to his character. also, i found that his lines in the archon quest (where he’s speaking more casually) are really well done!!

[@ChristopherPortorreal-ol2mj]

But I think they were rushed and they could've found a voice that sounds exactly like him. Moff tarkin has like 3 different voice actors that sounded just like him and I think they couldve took their time and actually find a person who's voice sounds exactly the same

[@irinapanova7577]

​@@ChristopherPortorreal-ol2mjZach sounds amazing as Tighnari tho, I find him to fit the character more than his old VA..

[@ChristopherPortorreal-ol2mj]

@@irinapanova7577 tighnaris old va was more peaceful but I kinda prefer him than Zach because he doesn't sound as imtim as his old one. Sometimes you gotta delay gameplay to get voices that are the same

[@aaaa-sz8hw]

Old Tighnari: Tired adult New Tighnari: Stressed highschooler

[@lefterismplanas4977]

He should sould adult in my opinion. That's what i don't like about the new va.

[@Sally-g4v]

​@@lefterismplanas4977 I prefer new VA

[@milkanddonuts7077]

Imo,i still like old one

[@cogpamp21schannel4]

Diary of the Wimpy Forest Watcher

[@witchbetelgeuse]

Gotta admit Old VA voice fits better. But after i learned things he had done everytime i hear his voice my skin crawls. And im not a victim. Now imagine how hard it must have been for them. I think we should stop being selfish and we should just leave him behind.

[@carlosteixeira2157]

what he did?

[@nevaskomaeda3051]

@@carlosteixeira2157 He was a child groomer, and saying that is an understatement considering everything else he's done. It got so controversial you can find out what he did with a single google search. That's why he is being replaced. Mihoyo stepped in and took away his role because he abused his fame to groom some of his fans.

[@ganqing8946]

i genuinely like his new voice ngl

[@stqrrica]

​​@@ganqing8946 fun fact, his new va was in a series "Diary of a Wimpy Kid" back in 2010.

[@Filcayra72]

@@carlosteixeira2157 Well @Nevas Komaeda said the big part of it. What’s worse is that he supposedly kept trying to groom even After the accusations were made

[@arbiterdream]

I've fallen so hard for Tighnari in the Chinese version that his old English voice no longer crosses my mind! But I'm glad Hoyo got his new voice so EN players can enjoy Tighnari without having to be reminded of him.

[@Valevoovoo]

@gem SAME

[@izzypaige07]

I've always played in Chinese so I was curious to hear the English and yeah, same! Tighnari's Chinese voice actor is very, very good!

[@queenofwrath7823]

Who would switch to chinese? I could understand the original JP one, but you can't understand nothing. English ist best actually...

[@arbiterdream]

@@queenofwrath7823 Chinese is the main language of the game. The scripts are written for and by Chinese speakers before they get translated to other languages. The lip movement and camera angles are only synced with the Chinese voiceover.

[@jisungwon2915]

The more I listen, the more I love Gordon's portrayal! So much more lively, fun, energetic and mischievous! His "heh"s are so CUTE. And big TY to MHY and Gordon for literally redubbing and rerecording so quickly !! I'm so excited to play Tighnari with his new lines

[@thepinkelephant2520]

Mhm! His new voice can take some getting used to, but I personally like it!

[@danielbee2399]

His new voice sounds so bad?

[@prettyfish6747]

@@danielbee2399no? It sounds so good?

[@danielbee2399]

@@prettyfish6747 nah the old voice was 1000 x better if he didn’t touch kids everyone would also agree

[@prettyfish6747]

@@danielbee2399 well 🤷‍♀️ he did so now its ruined for a lot of people and it sounds creepy now. Nothing is gonna make things go back so whats the point in complaining now? Seriously tho it doesn’t sound bad you’re buggin lol

[@muczkapl]

The new va nailed the combat lines but everything else feels Mikafied

[@Mrs.Ragnvindr]

Yeaa the combat like was good, I was like "oh I guess those line video is only that one- oh nvm....." I literally can't unheard Mika 😭

[@Nekuni]

Although the new voice doesn’t give off the same vibe as the old one, I quite like the new one. Like don’t get me wrong I love the old voice lines even if the old VA is disgusting for what he did, but I also like the new one cuz it kind of shows a different side of Tighnari’s character!

[@nevaskomaeda3051]

I will have to disagree. I do feel the old VA did a better job with the combat voicelines, particularly the "hah. can't see?" and "i hear everything!" It just feels so flat, no oomph. But the new VA did nail the idle and "longer" voicelines. Such a shame he had to turn out to be the creep he is...

[@AnnieDowns2000]

Genshin but mikafied mikapact

[@pearlzluv]

RIGHTTTTT

[@lavenderlemons888]

I think the old VA had a smoother and calm... more of a mature/"smart" voice. Granted the new VA likely had to rush and couldn't get much practice in .

[@tothebeyond6318]

2:40, 2:48, 2:57 are the only new voicelines that fits tighnari imo

[@andrewmurphy8234]

Yeah he has sonic vibes for me I'm not feeling it but all things considered it's a change we can accept

[@woofbark44]

FINALLY SOME GOOD FUCKIN COMMENT , thanks for saying that

[@bluegreen8625]

​@@andrewmurphy8234RIGHTTTT I just kinda wish they picked a new VA that had a deeper voice or something

[@ChristopherPortorreal-ol2mj]

​@@bluegreen8625 or someone with the Same exact voice just like moff tarkin who had 3 different voice actors and all sounded the same

[@marneybarneyboop]

Am I the only one who thinks the new VA is way better? He adds so much more emotion to the lines. The old one sounds so dead and boring to me… the new one has the Tighnari sass we all know and love, and the VA adds a nerdy touch to his voice which I think fits very well for Tighnari’s character Edit: Valid points on both sides! Looking back, I still think the new VA is better, but I can definitely see why a lot of people prefer the old one

[@randyrandom3358]

Well I'm sure to most, the old va sounds like a professional/mentor rather than a nerdy outcast. (Sorry Gordon)

[@YourAverageLoser763]

I just loved the sass in his old voice lines, they also low key sounded more alive and fitting to his character. New VA did fine tho considering he was rushed

[@manabdas7876]

Nah just u

[@starrybeidou]

I like the new one because he doesn’t say farest instead of forest

[@gnoot50]

I AGREE

[@shinybearevidra]

The new VA feels sassier and more enthusiastic, I have to say I really like his spin on the character! I loved the "tired of everyone" attitude the old interpretation had though.

[@TheDramacist]

I think Zachery flubbed a lot of the lines, especially the combat ones. They sound flat. He really didnt get time to figure out the character and they musta had him churning out so many lines! I can hear him thinking "Im so done."

[@Sally-g4v]

​@@TheDramacist I actually like the new one tho

[@Queen-lb6uu]

To be honest, I like both and I start liking the new one more

[@TheTopHatToyBonnie]

Nice

[@nanamiita3576]

same

[@Vixenschuuring]

Yep, same

[@eyebrowdimension]

Ironic how people criticise his new English voice being childish when he sounds more childish in Japanese. But since the language is Japanese and the JP VAs are practically worshipped, hardly anyone bats an eye Edit 2024: Tighnari doesn't have any decent English VAs so it's about time I get used to his Japanese VA. New VA didn't age well either because he's alleged to be a z1on1st.

[@StarberryWishes]

I didn't like the Japanese dub due to how feminine and childish it sounds.

[@arbiterdream]

Coming from someone who watches anime with subtitles, I have to agree. Like the Chinese version is literally there and he sounds so fricken good!!!

[@supayambaek]

People always look up to Japan as this perfect blameless nation lmao

[@001-x1b]

Why do we need to compare one Language VA to another, hmm? Just because JP department decided a higher/lighter voice is best for them doesn't mean the same for EN. Different market has different preference in voice acting.

[@lionixk6887]

I love only Eng version, i nevermind what with other language ...

[@luna_lilac19]

Personally I like the old va's voice better (NOT THE VA HIMSELF BTW) but I still really like the new one! Though it needs some time to get used to but it still fits tighnari very well!

[@UnCursed]

@WackyChu trueeee, new sound got me like 0 sass about tighnari. like you said, its a complete 180° from his personality.

[@kaitlin1902]

Especially the "I hear everything" line. It's so bland, where is the enthusiasm????

[@UnCursed]

@@kaitlin1902 the "lock me up" sound is just so... like he just give up at this point

[@cyaa7595]

​@WackyChu he does have a sass but more sarcastic one. Hes new VA also rushed on his voice lines and he didn't quite know how to fit with the character, but his quest lines are much better and you can tell that he has found right tone for him!

[@TheDramacist]

They did ZacheryG dirty. Tigh doesnt suit his voice. I think Zachery could have suited other characters better, but he's been lumped with Tigh now. Or vice versa depending on your own opinion.

[@countspersecond]

" *But what are they going to do - lock me up?* "

[@Minty_shark]

As a Tighnari main I got him on launch I was use to his old va but I love the new va with my heart he gave him so much love and i respect him and love his work with Tighnari

[@silentspirit8923]

I wish the new VA luck! He's done pretty well despite it being a short notice run.

[@vladimirgalicia9331]

People who misunderstand "I like the old voice" as "I defend the voice actor actions", are the same entitled Karen/Ken idiots who tell you to "fuck off" for something it's not your fault.

[@ris8961]

the new voice actor actually puts more life and personality to the character. . I like it. .

[@dieguin5304]

?

[@natalienatz1903]

Are we listening to the same new VA 💀💀💀

[@lordzanthartehallen8963]

Bullshit

[@kevatchiralzin3495]

@@natalienatz1903 these hypocrites gen Z pieces of doo doo are all about cancel culture 😂😂 new dude gets a 7/10 his tone is too heavy imo

[@natalienatz1903]

@@kevatchiralzin3495 it's pretty fair to cancel a pedo like old Tighnari VA but new VA just sounds like a Mika clone and the voice sounds too strained/forced, and as flat as Hu Tao.

[@pearlzluv]

They mika-ed the new speaking lines, combat lines weren’t as bad but honestly the old softness of the voice fit his character more

[@cake7922]

Indeed

[@thepinkelephant2520]

When I first heard it, it did sound like Mika 💀

[@mangooo1234]

no that’s what i was thinking it sounds like mika 😭 i rlly liked the old voice better BUT ofc not the actual VA just his voice for tighnari

[@akiradrake1043]

Uhh ... honestly the old voice sounded more natural and fitting.... Tho the old VA did disappoint in actions he did better with voicing the character.

[@beans665]

i hate to admit it but ur right i did like it better idk if i naturally dont like the new voice bc of mika i just find it sounding so weird i cant take it seriously

[@lefterismplanas4977]

​Same. I stopped plaing tignari after the VA change. He now sounds like an edgy teen instead of a serious adult​@@beans665

[@jack5mikemotown]

0:47 idk why but he sounds like sonic lmao

[@cristianorodrigues7283]

Think you mean Sliver 😂

[@jack5mikemotown]

@@cristianorodrigues7283 no, definitely sonic. the new VA

[@cristianorodrigues7283]

@@jack5mikemotown oh ah yea I can hear it lol

[@Ironluke_2001]

I'm happy his VA changed, but I'm not really a fan of his new voice. Tighnari's supposed to sound like a sassy Forest Ranger who's confident in his actions, like a strong willed leader. His new VA makes him sound.... Uncertain and shy (for lack of better words I can think of). Maybe I just need to listen to his voice to help it grow on me but I'm currently not much of a fan. *Regardless, happy the VA has changed!*

[@archerdamo9160]

They did that on purpose, because a similar voice could make victims unconfortable, confirmed via Cyno VA.

[@Ironluke_2001]

@@archerdamo9160 Ah I see, that makes sense. Thanks.

[@Misaka_neesama]

Same

[@LunyBasy]

I guees the new va want to sound more friendly

[@LunyBasy]

​@@archerdamo9160 thats nice of them

[@saltyfries2766]

In my opinion I miss he's old sassy voice it fits the character more better but don't get me wrong I like the new voice it sounds really good but just some voiclines sound like Mika which is why it bothers me a little but after hearing what the old VA did it really bothered me too listen his voice as a thignari main I just wish that the new VA did the same delivery as the old one did still the new VA did a pretty good job

[@cake7922]

Same, also i hate the fact how similar it is to mika

[@mikanayumi5646]

i completely agree i think the new va has this nasaly tone that makes it overall sound similar to mika and childish, when they said they were going to get a new VA i wasnt expecting them to change to someone like this. wished theyd pick someone with maybe a bit more of a mature tone? or maybe the new delivery just needed more directing? idk i just feel like he cant get rid of that childih nasal tone regardless. hmm who knows. but i deffinitely missed his old voice a lot it was so perfect for tighnari. i l ook forward t omore improvement but for now i have no reason to play in english anymore haha

[@RymFero]

Thank you! I miss the old voice to😢😭😭😭😭😭

[@nugget8018]

Imo the older one sounds more like "Tighnari" than the new one. He has a gentler and calmer voice.

[@irinapanova7577]

More than a year later and i can confidently say Zach did an amazing job. Sure, VA changes can be jaring when you are uaed to something, but thats why you need fo give it some fime before you comment on it. Ive had experiences where i havent been happy with VA changes but im actually so in love with the way Tighnari is right now. And im confident most people share my opinion.

[@AloyImpact]

Nah I def like his new voice actor. OK EXCEPT WHEN HE SAYS I HEAR EVERYTHING LOL

[@ezrymii]

what about the 'ill uproot you' gotta say the old va did better, imo the new va made tighnari sound like grown up mika 😂

[@mrminecraftcubeable]

I hear everything is so bad in the new voice, it doesn't have any impact

[@AloyImpact]

@@ezrymii I like both don’t get me wrong but the new Va tried to be as close as possible to the original so I give him credit where it’s due

[@J3llyF15hy]

​@@AloyImpact new VA was not allowed to listen to the original VA's lines, so I have no clue where you got that from

[@Thetrue_dumpling]

Idk I prefer new voice actor. I like the soft of his old but I still prefer the more firm voice

[@2Poor4Fun]

I feel like most of the people who say the old VA was better only say that because they were used to it more.

[@vladimirgalicia9331]

Not really, the old one you can tell Tighnari's personality, he's a smart sassy guy who was confident and was wise. The new one I barely see those traits, Tighnari doesn't sound bad, it just doesn't compensate his personality. In the new one he feels kinda shy and a newbie schoolar more than what he is, an veteran.

[@lefterismplanas4977]

​@vladimirgalicia9331 exactly. The thing that bothers me the most is that his new VA sounds like an Edgy teen Scholar. He supposed to be a confident leader. The Old va fit his character so much more. Anyone who likes the new one more just doesn't understand Tighnari

[@chrisshroom8375]

I remember when he sprinted he used to do something like a little woof and I loved that, now it's not there anymore and I kind of miss that one

[@karoisart9266]

It may be bc I got to know him with the new VA, but I like the execution a lot more. Same with the vocal color! He sounds more sassy and lively which goes well with Tighnari's character

[@irinapanova7577]

It's just what people were used to back then. No matter who his new VA was gonna be people would still complain. Regardless, enough time has passed and I genuinely think his new VA brought more life to the character than the new one

[@Sakurakitto]

It's interesting how the intonation and inflection completely changes the implied attitude of the lines. When it Snows line: Old: In awe and distracted by the weather almost talking to himself. Gentle surprise. Kind offer. New: Excitedly talking to traveler about weather. Confused surprise. Matter of fact offer. In general the new voice sounds a lot more peppy, matter of fact and lacks the same sass that the old voice had. I imagine they might do a re-record over time. But I do enjoy the new idle, feels a bit more lively.

[@Someone-zn4dh]

He felt like an adventurer but also that quirky nerd vibe friend that you somehow always get along with Some do feel a bit flat or too exaggerated but I wish they used the Barbara VA treatment. I will not be surprised that this audio are just a quick voice over to just replace the OLD VA line

[@martynshirra2836]

At the very least they can rerecord over time should people say what they don't like to Hoyo. Since they listened to the community backlash at the old VA's doings, I would say they're still listening and will read the feedback.

[@enk335]

I miss his old voice, even though it's good that Elliot is gone. But a friend of mine once said that this VA sounds more like the kind of person who would mouth off to the 2nd Fatui Harbinger, and I agree. His combat lines are also way better.

[@shiningvioletwishes3162]

I think the new VA adds more personality into each of his lines like different emotions while the old Vas tone is almost the same.

[@z3eplaysroblox]

I like the old one more But the change was also very much for the better… (Look it up if your confused)

[@vladimirgalicia9331]

When it comes to personal life and outcome as an individual, yes it's better. When it comes to performance, nah. the old one was better.

[@prim16]

The new VA 100% fits the character better, and also has much more emotion in his lines.

[@StayFruityYall]

2:15 this voice line is so fucking cute, he sounds so proud of himself! "One swish and it's dry :]]"

[@EvaValenti]

That one is very cute.

[@lefterismplanas4977]

He shouldn't sound like that though. He's not a student. He's a full on graduated, and confident adult. Sure this new voice would fit if he was still a student. But he's not

[@liragordon3670]

I know why the va was changed, but I still like the old one much more. And it is such a sad thing, than it was needed to be changed. I still play on english, but think to change - because for all that time i just can`t get used to it( ande decide which language I prefer too). I like the old one much more because it was so calm, and just fits the character more. now Tignari is sounded like some nerd( so sorry, but it is how I feel it).

[@CallMeEchoNow]

i love his new va so much he really pulls off the sassy fox that is tighnari

[@mrminecraftcubeable]

How? His voice is so flat

[@CallMeEchoNow]

@@mrminecraftcubeable i personally think he does i dont think his voice is all that flat

[@yrrtmjrmahj-]

@@CallMeEchoNow ooh, same opinion. I like the new one better, maybe because I'm a new player and have never heard of his voice until the drama starts, but I really like the new voice.

[@Kisune.]

He was mika-fied 💀

[@yrrtmjrmahj-]

@@Kisune. what's wrong with sounding like a nerd? It's not even really a nerd voice, his voice is much more calmer. TBH, it fits him IMO. Isn't he is supposed to sound like that?

[@kuromized]

This aged like milk

[@Parakerusuu]

LMAAOOO

[@littlejay773]

why?

[@justaguy4656]

Uhhh why?

[@stxllarsu]

@@justaguy4656 I’m guessing because people found out the new VA supports Israel? I’m not too sure though

[@bryanr8398]

​@@stxllarsuso the old va killed his family member, and the new one supports Israel 😂

[@noasaysbye]

Old voice sounded like he was on the verge of tears half the time, he just sounded so dead and monotone. The new VA did SO MUCH better, giving life to tighnari, his battle voice lines sound more alive and aggressive, and sassy at the same time. Zachary perfected the voice, giving him a nerdy, but sassy sort of character. His new voice 100% suits him way more

[@wlink639]

Agreed, there are some lines where old VA seems to not be trying at all.

[@Alissa_lilih]

I think he previously showed a purity and calmness in his way of speaking, which suited the character perfectly.

[@dreamboi4268]

I've gotten used to the new one now but it sounds kinda memey when you compare it to the old one which had a more chilled out aura

[@luckypaw2016]

I think the old voice sounds softer and more mature. The new one sounds less emotional, clearer and younger I don't know what suits the character best, I would like to mix these qualities to get the ideal

[@nonloso839]

0:20 tighnari minecraft s villager side was on

[@arkanamare]

I actually think old tighnari souds more in character. The new voice sometimes cracs and sounds like a child... ":)

[@habunai]

Same.. whole character changed. Doesn't feel the same to me anymore.

[@rebzyyxstar]

ssshhhhhhhhh

[@midwestprincesss]

fr :,(

[@lighty2884]

I like the old va's "I Hear EVERYTHING" more than the new one's "i hear everything"

[@pido1234]

So I know some information of situation with old VA and why his changed. But I really like more old voice of Tighnari than new. Old voice is really calm, relaxing and suitable for the atmosphere of the character.

[@MakennaWilson-hb9pr]

Tighnari's old VA souned so relaxing 😭

[@yocael]

The old voice sounds wiser and calmer, too bad the VA wasn't :(

[@sdoublekblackk]

tbh watching this so much time later I do prefer the new over the old one, I guess the old one only sounded more fitting because that's what we were used to listen at the time

[@bang-naim]

Adult Mika that graduates Biology from Sumeru 😭

[@Kurukurukuruin.]

Welp bad news you may have to make another version

[@EmergxcyLayla_xx]

WDYM

[@Dollettepaws]

​@@EmergxcyLayla_xxdiluc i think

[@EmergxcyLayla_xx]

@@Dollettepaws diluc did nothing wrong I watched a video abt it the person was on 18+ web

[@Kurukurukuruin.]

@@EmergxcyLayla_xx nope his new VA is a Zionist

[@shhsjwjwkwkjw]

​@@Kurukurukuruin.what does that mean?

[@conniemelboure3696]

I miss his old voice so much.. It fit him so much better 😭 I never played him anymore since the change.. 😔

[@jmde.e]

damnn me too, at first I didnt mind about the voice change but it literally made me leave Tighnari on my account even when I pulled on his banner.

[@HDevol]

Same, I especially miss the line at 02:09 I used to hear it all the time

[@GamePlayShare]

fr

[@natothecringyfurrfox6380]

Yall are on smth, the last one sounded so souless

[@DeathSkulk]

@@natothecringyfurrfox6380 exactly, it was accurate to the character

[@orcality]

Tldr old tighnari is calm, has had enough coffee, and ready for the day. New tighnari is DONE with it, needs a raise, but will still bandage you up after getting attacked by a scorpian. (I think it has a little more personality too)

[@danxxc]

2:14 y’all are saying this one is better ??? hell nah

[@Toby-oh3ym]

Old guy sounds like hes reading lines, new guy is a bit more in the role. Cool

[@Marquipuchi]

Why is no one mentioning the fact that the new VA is literally Greg Heffley

[@Bugdoll]

Love the new voice, but I ADORE how the old one says "forest" (generally love the accent)

[@livin0000]

His old voice made him sound more mature and sassy, his new one is quite inconsistent tbh.

[@kevatchiralzin3495]

Thank you, finally someone who doesn’t believe in cancel culture and hypocrisy

[@killian_ve]

Indeed

[@ssignment]

Probably because it's rushed

[@parkchimmin7913]

The voices at 2:40, 2:47, 2:53 are the best. He sounds more calm and less… Mika-fied? His voice is lower too.

[@UnCursed]

​@@ssignment yeah, its probably rushed to hell. the consistency is just... bad.

[@scaranation01827]

Completely forgot how his old voice sounded like lol

[@Hoooshiiiii....]

Although I think Elliot definately made a perfect voice for Tighnari his voice might make a lot of people uncomfortable. Maybe the new va could put in a bit more sass

[@pinky102zanexd]

Being a new player to Genshin Impact, I'm used to Tighnari's new voice, so it gives me a different picture from how the old players see Tighnari as. I like his new voice better. I don't get why people think it didn't sound mature, but to me, it sounds mature enough, but had a little bit of youth and life in it. The old one was bland and stuffy, I wouldn't even enjoy playing Tighnari with that voice whether he was voiced by the old VA or not. He sounds like he has confidence in his knowledge and actions with his new voice. That's just my opinion.♥️

[@SongChin-f4g]

0:50 "One with the fart!"

[@zenith-boi]

I don't care what y'all say. I'll accept Tighnari played by Greg Heffley every day of the week. (Zachary Gordon played Greg in the Diary of a Wimpy Kid movies)

[@DottorNapoli]

I really miss old Tighnari. His voice was perfect for a good and mature leader and teacher. This new dub makes him feel like he's a 20 years old dude who's new at his workplace but studied more than others so they can't complain about his position

[@qepwo]

Old va better 😭😭😭😭 He has such a gentle voice, it really suited his character.

[@ChristopherPortorreal-ol2mj]

It's sad they got rid of him but that guy deserves it. They shouldve took their time instead of rushing for a new VA because moff tarkin had like 3 different voice actors that almost sounded the same

[@Osamxxx]

​​@@ChristopherPortorreal-ol2mj sorry, but what wrong with old VA? I really don't know about this situation.

[@kd08082]

@@Osamxxxit’s a simple google search. long story short he’s a groomer and so I’m pretty sure he either stepped down (for “guilt” or something) or Hoyoverse outright fired him.

[@patricksusulin9335]

I honestly loved the old one. he sounds like a smart sarcastic asshole. the second one is basically just benette role playing as tighnari

[@kirbs-the-silly]

gonna have to make a new one of these🥳

[@ErmThatsKindaSilly-]

I prefer new tbh he sounds better and more clear to me He also sounds more nerdy and it fits him really well! I also feel like the old one keeps the same tone the whole time while with the new voice actor he gives tighnari more life and stuff love the new one wayyy more!

[@lolahusson5213]

at first I thought the old voice was better but now rewatching it, the new one is definitely better. I just love it

[@lefterismplanas4977]

Nope. For me, this confirmed the fact that hai old va had done a way better job at voicing him

[@EmergxcyLayla_xx]

@@lefterismplanas4977bro ur like 1 year late and do you even know what ur supporting

[@lefterismplanas4977]

@Taya-uc9oe The og guy was an awful person, yes. But credit were credit is due. His voice was the obly one that fitted the character

[@papajohnsy6659]

New VA sounds like Mika reading quotes from Tighnari

[@Wings_of_Genshin]

I prefer the new voice because of the combat lines. For hearty lines that need to be delivered with lots of emotion like, “I’ll uproot you!” The old VA didn’t do a great job.

[@ventithedrunk9506]

Though Old VA was vile after what he did. He suited better. His work as a VA is good but wtf was that crime man.

[@lefterismplanas4977]

Agreed. He let us all down

[@SirsasthNigam.]

Why didn't they mention Old VA here? Voice Actors English Zachary Gordon[1] Chinese Moran (莫然)[2] Japanese Kobayashi Sanae (小林 沙苗)[3] Korean Jung Ui-taek (정의택)[4]

[@JastisLej]

Old Voice is much better. You can think anything about actor, but his Tighnari sounds original and “clean”. The new one is trying to grimaces like Mika and it sounds disgusting. If not for the scandals, I’m sure no one would have supported the new actor

[@Yanfei-gg4mm]

You are absolutely right, people prefer morality over good work.

[@GlassRosy]

Sigh, though I do understand and I agree with the change in VA... The fact that the old VA had a nasal quality in their voice gives me the image that Tighnari is in fact a researcher and scholar and not just a BOI TM.

[@Arcian]

Never played with the old one but hearing this I feel like nothing of value was lost.

[@chedmacr]

I like the old tighnari's calm and friendly yet sometimes with a sarcastic and funny voice. Best example for me is when he was talking about a plant-based waterproofing oil. OLD VA: One swish....and it's dry! 2:10 you can imagine him doing the spongebob's imagination meme. NEW VA: One swish, and it's dry! Feels like he's not proud of it. Feels like it's a meh for him. But can't blame hoyo for changing. They know they must change it so some people wont be grossed about his old VA, knowing the history. but it's really gonna take a while before I can forget how the OLD VA sounded like. Hope the best of luck for Zachary.

[@UnCursed]

the new VA voice is (probably) rushed to some extent. the inconsistency can be heard on some lines.

[@_Chessa_]

Points all hit for me. This honestly ruins the character for me in many ways. I loved his old voice. And now to find a mod to bring it back.

[@gundamsetsuna2899]

the new voice is good, but I don't know about the voice direction his cadence doesn't give me sassy collage drop out vibes. (I now he graduated from the academia and just refused to stay as an alumni, but he gave off drop out energy)

[@Sue-rs1zq]

I love the new voice, I think it fits tighnari intellectual side of his personality better. he sounds less sassy but smarter and even cunning with his "ehe", he's vicious/playful just like the animal he represents haha cute

[@Sean.A.M]

I miss the old Va he sounded like a young adult and a intellectual. New one sounds like a child it’s odd and off putting. It made me like his character less and completely changes him as a character and his personality . It’s just way different. Like new one just doesn’t know the character well enough or decided to do his own thing? I’ll never get over fact he sounds like a kid now

[@Yukio..]

I have always used to Japanese version to the game, never heard the English version of Tighnari so I think the new one sounds well and he adds more emotions to his lines!

[@CCLyssCC]

Seeing the comments I might be the only one, but I really, really like the new voice!

[@yrrtmjrmahj-]

You are not the only one. I really like the new one too

[@LUEANATOR]

Agreed I really love the new voice and it fits perfectly with what I imagined him sounding like in my head!

[@just_a_randompanda]

me too

[@DawnyXO_]

He sounds so much more cute and cocky and silly now hehehe I love him :3

[@noruchishiki8090]

i feel tighnari being a good boy with soft heart than before 😂

[@kenpanderz]

its pretty close most of the time, but i think the old VA had better sounding combat phrases, while the new one has a better dialogue sound.

[@kumashock4074]

If you’ve heard the song about Kaveah being jealous…I wished they used the va from that for new toghnari. He sounds perfect and has the sassiness we love. New guy is fine but Zachery Piser is better

[@yoimiyawanter2384]

Old:I HEAR EVERYTHING!!!! New: i HeAr EvErYtHiNg 🤓

[@Mr.Holandas]

where is the location on 3:01?

[@primogem5197]

The teapot.. I have one of THE best teapots, if u want to join tell me Ill give u my uid

[@skyskils5452]

Kettle

[@primogem5197]

@@Mr.Holandas u can use my teapot if u want, its really beautiful I promise

[@nightravenn24]

The new va is nice and adds more emotion to tighnaris character but for me the old va suits him more because i see tighnari as a more calm person

[@Anocrockett]

Maybe, Elliot is bad as a person, but he surely is good as VA. The new VA doesn't sound as bold as him. To my mind that childish voice doesn't suit Tighnari well enough

[@ezrymii]

bro sounds like mika now

[@gradenegamer7232]

​@@ezrymiiliterally

[@debopriyadutta3736]

I agree. I liked his old one better, the new one is...very weird I cannot unhear Mika. To be honest it really doesn't suit his character sounds very childish and stuff.

[@lefterismplanas4977]

Same. His new voice sounds like an edgy teeen who's unsure of himself and is trying too hard. I don't think his voice fits

[@beausweater]

I got Tighnari like 3 weeks ago and I just now found out that he used to have a different va but I like his new one better!

[@Thesmus]

man, still sucks to this day. his old voice helped a lot in making me like his character. i keep thinking how i could never get tired of listening to him. it's so distinct and it just sounds like how someone like tighnari will sound like. no hate to the new va, but hearing his voice just felt like he sounds like a typical anime boy. he kinda lost that charm of having such distinct soothing and sassy voice.

[@patrickanderson3373]

New VA sounds way better imo, it just has so much more emotion

[@ergi8783]

The old one was so much better, the new one makes him sound so general and soft

[@hayden6383]

The old VA even sounds like a zesty predator, lmao

[@bvdf84]

Im glad the new voice is more similar to japanese and chinese voice over