Balochistan - An International Issue: The Newshour Debate (15th Sep 2016)

On THE NEWSHOUR, TIMES NOW Editor-in-Chief Arnab Goswami along with panelists - Dr. Seshadri Chari, Member, National Executive & Convenor, Foreign Affairs Cell, Bjp; Tarek Fatah, Author & Columnist; Ahmar Mustikhan, Journalist (Defender Of Human Rights Of People Of Baloch); Maj Gen G D Bakshi (Retd), Editor, Indian Military Review; Jan Achakzai, Leader, Pmln & Political Commentator; Lt Col Shafqat Saeed (Retd), Defence Analyst; Barrister Zahid Saeed, Former Diplomat And Liaquat Shahwani, Political Analyst- discus Balochistan.
Subscribe to NewsHour Debate | Click Here ► goo.gl/LfNgFF
‘Download the official TIMES NOW mobile app - Give a missed call on 1800 4190 300. Stay updated, stay ahead.’
Subscribe Now To Our Network Channels
ET Now : goo.gl/5XreUq
Times Now : goo.gl/U9ibPb
To Stay Updated Download the Times Now App :-
Android Google Play : goo.gl/zJhWjC
Apple App Store : goo.gl/d7QBQZ
Social Media Links :-
Twitter - goo.gl/FzJIpz
Facebook - goo.gl/CC7rGc
G+ - goo.gl/O1iEp5
Also visit our website - goo.gl/XPUXe8

[@danielbaloch565]

i am baloch and i live in balochistan quetta , and i love india we baloch want freedom long live balochistan ,long live india , greeting from occupied balochistan, vende mataram.

[@adarshharshan6392]

Salute to Brave Baloch

[@vickysharma3107]

we are with you bro

[@grimreaper7610]

some Indian from Gujrat has just said he lives in Quetta Balochistan and he loves India.>>WTF

[@vickysharma3107]

+Hassan Mahmood so what ?

[@grimreaper7610]

Just made me laugh out loud

[@pirdanbaloch3027]

Thanks again dear India for your unconditional support, once we get back our motherland we will never forget our Indian brothers and sisters bahrath matha ki jay

[@trojanwar760]

Very soon Balochistan will be free!

[@2901gagandeep]

Dude we don't care about Balochistan.We just use it to attack Pakistan.

[@ahmedal-qazi7918]

are u happy that very soon balochistan will be free don't be bcuz soon after that u will be an easy target for india and iran even for terrorists. I know that there are some problems in PAK but it does not mean that u have to submit your self to the enemy thats what india and America wants.

[@ahmedal-qazi7918]

Dear brother i am not talking about Bangladesh 1st plz go and search how they have this good relationship balochistan dose not have army to defend themselves, Bangladesh is near india but balochistan is near his biggest enemy which is IRAN and what about taleban.

[@nelson.j2998]

Lon live balochistan and their freedom from the shaitan from hell hole .

[@yogesh85d]

"you are concubines in Pakistan paid by Saudi and sleeping with Chinese" best dialogue by Tarek Fatah in this debate. 😁😅😉

[@subscriberswithoutanyvid-jm6df]

lol😂😂😂

[@srujanchowdhary7925]

yogesh85 best dialogue

[@boxersoho]

I guess Tarek Fateh was right in asking them which book you read in last 10 years, left to right.

[@talk2venu]

no books hahaha...

[@islamabadi2]

what an idiot who are....who is tarek fateh ? a bengali immigrant to first Pakistan and then to Canada...

[@boxersoho]

In all seriousness, i was expecting a reply from Pak panelist about the book. None of them responded. It was a simple question, doesn't even matter who asked it.

[@teacup_cake]

@ AK Terek Fateh is basically an idiot who makes indian hate Pakistan and for that he gets paid... this guy is full of lie.. and he is more like a joker than analyst.

[@baawarbaloch7860]

thank U India

[@saumyapriyankshrivastav6465]

we are with baloch brother 👍

[@kunalk2233]

We are with you brother.. balochis are our brothers..

[@BISHAL9100]

we are with you

[@playerone1746]

Sk Sarfaraz If pakistanis behaved themselves then there would be no Bangladesh and there wouldn't be movement to free Balochistan. 1971 bangladesh was free from torture. 2018 Balochistan must get free from torture of innocent. Baloch man getting killed, Baloch women being raped. This boils my blood and I am Indian Hindu. How can pakistani muslims do this to their baloch muslims!

[@rudainbaloch3915]

thanks Hindustan for supporting us....

[@jaspindersingh8204]

Aapke balochistan aazad ho ga inshallah and a very happy new year to you

[@udaykrishnatej173]

Pakistan needs new map. lets donate to them for printing charges as already they are in debts.

[@habijabi1430]

well said . nailed it bro.

[@biplabganguly3455]

Tun Bada tej Hai Yaar!

[@rabindrakejriwal1364]

In fact Pakistan does not need a map anymore......the world/UN needs a new map where in one country will be missing that is Pakistan......in future people will read about Pakistan only in history books.....

[@biplabganguly3455]

Rabindra Kejriwal Tun to Baap nikla Bhai!

[@bgae8031]

pakistan doesnt need a map because there isnt going to be country called pakistan!

[@manjurazdan]

AAZAD BALUCHISTANI JINDABAD. India is with you our Baluchi brothers and sisters.

[@Aakash0619]

And here we go again, Arnab why don't you invite Maroof Raza? He's the only one to shut those pigs mouth.

[@sumitSharma-fl3ls]

totally agree with u bhai!!

[@agang225]

Im a christian and very happy in india. And have never encounter any discrimination against any religion.

[@rachit00786]

Balochistan should be named West India and Indian army should protect its borders...and Hindus and Muslims should live peacefully there😎

[@Surajkumar0770]

No, Balochistan should be Named as "Balochistan" as it is. Just like Bangladesh..

[@baawarbaloch7860]

we love and respect India and Indian peoples, but we want our freedom with honor and dignity in our beloved Balochistan.

[@rachit00786]

ok Mr. baloch agreed....but at least Balochistan should have very very strong relations with India even after it gets independence bcoz otherwise Pakistan will never hesitate to capture it again just like it did many years back.

[@mobitech4203]

brother can u tell me how many% of people in Baluchistan people want freedom,

[@rachit00786]

anyone can read the news....you can search online or even talk to army people of high ranks....as they know that many times people are even killed for protesting there. There is an Indian dish whose name perfectly represents the current condition of Pakistan,i. e., KHICHDI....This has what Pakistan has become now.... Balochistan should be freed before Kashmir as baloch people want freedom....where as in Kashmir issue which is quite overhyped (thanks to paid media) only 5-6 districts have curfew imposed on them not whole Kashmiris are protesting...that's the reality brothers

[@arjankaku3691]

I am missing Maroof Raza, one of the most respected person in India, in such an important debate.

[@islamabadi2]

no in reality he just couldn't face us Pakistanis

[@amish2394]

@@islamabadi2 in reality he fucked fuxkistan 🇵🇰💩🇵🇰💩

[@abubakeralbalushi3924]

Thanks India for helping baloch people ....soon freedom's

[@uddalakbhattacharyya5101]

We are with you Baloch brother and sister

[@jitendrabhosale3400]

akbar bhugati hum sharminda hai tere katil (pakistan) zinda hai

[@mentplc]

@Bhosale - arre bhosle-ji. I like. I like someone has used the line written by me 2-3 weeks ago. Jai Maharashtra. Jai ma-Bharti. Jai HIND. Sabki ma ki jai.

[@jitendrabhosale3400]

MRG ye line kiski hai muze malum nahi per ye line per kaam hona chahiye modiji ka abhi jalmadin humne manaya hai ab bas yahi parthana kare ki next birthday (modiji ka) tak balochistan mukth ho aur hum birthday aur freedom ek sath manaye bande mataram

[@raihan596]

take care of kashmir

[@viralcontent4281]

Sub Kashmiri logo hum sharminda hai tere katil harami india zinda hain

[@viralcontent4281]

Sub Kashmiri logo hum sharminda hai only 17 indian mar gaye aur baki sub katil harami india zinda hain

[@DeepakKumar-bm1ce]

The Baloch people need to stand in unity against the atrocities committed by Pakistan. Inshallah one day Baluch Kingdom will regain its freedom from the captivity of a rogue nation called Pakistan!

[@aa2398a]

joke of the century.....i've lived in Balochistan Province. the very word "indian" or "hindu" is a huge insult

[@aa2398a]

LOLLL "GAY hind!"

[@aa2398a]

another naanga bhooka hindustani haramzada

[@AnupKumar-oc1zr]

Hahahhaha chutiyee bhikhari bhukha manga khon hai jara aona gdp aur apna country ka situation dekh Kuch padha Kar bee chutiyee bhikhari failed state me rahta hai terrorist state ka bhikhari chutiyee

[@utubetruthteller]

Pakistan is in backfoot because of Modi proactive foreign policy. Please vote BJP for 20 years I assure you Pakistan problem will be solved once for all time.

[@simmikaur2485]

It will remain in power for long time

[@animishkhatawkar]

we in India want free balochistan , an independent state and a proud country.

[@coolrliz]

Tarek Fateh as great n entertaining as usual "have u ever read a book in ur entire life" 😂😂😂😂

[@diwakarmishra3350]

yes mulla fake profile 😂😂

[@executiveauthority8518]

I m from Baluchistan & living in Turbat and I love my Pakistan. I don't want India to exploit us for her own political point scoring. we were Pakistani and we are Pakistani. we will die but not being used in the hands of India as I see India needs to do lot of work at home...

[@executiveauthority8518]

shut your gutter... who the hell are you going to decide who is Balochi and who is not... u r puppet and loser..

[@nazbaloch7892]

Executive Authority ur not baloch stop doing this...I am baloch and we wand free balochistan..

[@amartandon2812]

Baluchistan has an early identity than Pakistan

[@Skatte-fm6og]

Salute to Arnab ..great channel with great debate, keep up the good work.

[@DevenAbhyankar]

Keep only Arnab Sir and keep all pak panelists still Arnab Sir will make strong point for mother india and RIP all pak panelists.

[@none5130]

Dear Baloch brothers and sisters , v indians r with u.

[@punkdunk556]

If any one who claims these guys r sold out to INDIA or are India agents. i would rather be the same if it saves a single life in baloochistan.Long live Balochistan,India,humanity.

[@cayanaraycaudhuri]

We need programmes on Baloch culture and courses for Balochi language here.

[@yashvardhansinghsingh9747]

Look at the Pakistani panelists getting nervous whenever arnab sir puts a fact in front on them.

[@XDataDoctorX]

"John Lota" Enjoyed listening to the phrase that suits him best.

[@mohanudiavar]

93000 troops of Pak army were subdued by 2000 Indian troops

[@nimlokothi]

It is BALOCHISTAN, not BALUCHISTAN .pls correct ur pronunciation.Arnab too making this mistake.

[@Sprince1621]

Arnav , Bro Arnav is in damn great form. 👌👌👍

[@moiz0078600]

Free Balochistaan .......!!!! Never call these Pakistani people in debate ....

[@indianabroad8316]

Great Topic. Need more of this. But Arnab needs to change the format of Newshour Debate.

[@trueindian9126]

We Indians want to help Ballochi brothers in all matter, I suggest your authorised leaders or freedom groups seek indian govt. to raise fund in india by indian people in a humanitarian ground arised by pak's bad treatment to you.. we want to support you by funding please open a bank account in India by govt. permission.

[@akhtarbaloch7290]

i need free balochistan

[@localboy663]

afgan is our brother they have always helped india ..they were our brother n they will be....we have no doubt about our afgan brothers

[@jhaashu1]

Why to create a country in name of religion! Mistake made 70 years back and these are the after affect.

[@GovindSingh-oy5ex]

Only hope for Islam is people like Tarek Fatah lead the community.

[@Kapilastrology]

Nice debate we should always support baluchistanis

[@dr.agupta]

If Pakistanis are so openly, senselessly and crudely trying to silence, dominate and insult Baloch representatives, I can imagine how it would be if ISI deals with a normal Baloch citizen in Balochistan! Huh!! #IndiaForBalochistan #BalochistanAtUN

[@1945.6]

Like i said India should help Balouchistan in all matters (politically, internationally, etc) and be a wall of support for the people of balouch... India should also establish democracy rule in Balouchistan so the people of Balouch live in peace :)

[@InayetHadi]

How can anyone stand to hear all this yelling? Can't the host and guests have a discussion where they are talking at normal noise level and not talking over each other ?

[@1227anand]

Please invite Christine Fairchild with these people

[@tahirkhan-ob5vu]

baloch has to be freed

[@RajeshSingh-lj6oe]

These Pakistani speaking in English. A Christian language. and cloth? Pakistani? What these Pakistani gave this world? Don't sought. ... look yourself in the mirror.

[@islamabadi2]

More than what india has given you moron......

[@crococrash]

India has given a lot. Have you seen our space program? We launch satellites for USA Russia France etc.. Our launch capabilities are excellent and most cost-effective... Our IT sector is over 100 billion.. Fastest growing economy in the world... Even our single PSU, IOCL has a higher revenue than the entire revenue of the govt of Pakistan... Just coz pakistan purchased nukes from China they think they're so powerful and amazing...

[@pluviophile8427]

Indians are way too optimistic about Balochistan.. I've seen dozens of talkshows in past few days particularly on Balochistan issue.. Yes there has been a bit of unrest in Balochistan since Akbar Bugti's death and a rise in the anti-state sentiment, but i don't think Indians (and other enemies) should get too excited about it.. Here are the reasons... Over 50% of the Balochistan's population is comprised Pashtuns who are NOT a part of this struggle by any means.. Same is the case with Lassi, Mengal, Raisani and Achakzai tribes.. Marri's and Bugti's are the only tribes that are carrying out an armed struggle against the state but they are a minority.. And even the among these these two tribes, pro Pak elements also exist in numbers.. In fact the brothers and cousins of the current leading Baloch separatist Brahamdagh Bugti which includes Sarfraz Bugti, Shahzain Bugti and many others, are the part of political process in Pakistan and they do not want freedom.. Same is the case with the other leading separatist Harbiyar Mari, whoose brother, Changez Marri is the member of the national assembly of Pakistan.. So i don't much success for them on the political front.. The only chance for them is a military encounter by India with the support of Afghanistan which is very unlikely..!!

[@user-pl9mw1ef9h]

Pakistan loss Bangla 45 years old ..now Pak loss is very fast baloch..

[@Kapilastrology]

Abe 30 sec ki ads itni lambi ads Kitni ads doge thodi kam kar do re

[@artistrahhul4244]

KZbin ke haath me hai sab.

[@varunsharma902]

youtube ad bloker krke softwere h bhai , install kriye khush rahiye...thnx bd me kriyegaa

[@jaysaviod9581]

KZbin ke haath mein nahin hain, Download the adblock for youtube extension in Google chrome browser, no more ads will appear..think this works only for Google Chrome, not sure about other browsers..

[@nageshkatkur680]

use add blocker plus and enjoy the full debate

[@suyashkatare967]

tarek sir u spelled it wrong u should have said 'B' 'U' 'K' than he would have understood

[@shashanka134]

G D Bakshi was so silent in the starting... i thought his screen froze

[@virensingh1122]

arnob wherz maroof

[@adityagupta7727]

yes

[@pranjeetprakash2991]

he is such a logical person and talks on facts.

[@shriyashrivastava5992]

I think maroof, being highly knowledgeable and logical person, refused to come cause arguing to these pakistani sides is a total waste... they just shout. Anyhow we like to hear Maroof's view always.

[@ladsmirror3247]

You really think such debates are helping india, it's a mockery how can you even call it a debate, I mean really how???

[@tusharkapoor24]

Mirrors Lad because its a true debate with unbiased uncensored view point from every side. Its a debate most watched in India and in the world. Its what happens in countries where media truly has absolute freedom to discuss anything they want and not where media is controlled and manipulated by military/ non state agencies through fear. I didnt expect people from your country to comprehend this but every free nation including first world countries has some form of variants of debate shows like the Newshour.Please do your homework nex time before exhibiting your ignorance in the comments section. :P

[@hrishabhdivya]

first time i saw arnab so quite

[@sainaveenbali]

ha ha

[@Harshanalluru_3]

nice climax

[@createart004]

4:18 compose yourself !

[@sushilpandey9111]

the concluding lines of arnab would have made raheel sharif piss in his pants.

[@Rix99]

read a book. might be baa baa black sheep, might be Jack and Jill. :D

[@talk2venu]

when I see baloch mother and sister crying for their father and son, my brother baloch fighting for years. how come india is silent all these years. now i am feeling ashamed of being indian. india must free baloch, otherwise i will form a baloch army in hyderabad.

[@playerone1746]

Share this video everyone.

[@indiaonly9285]

Azad Balochistan Zindabad

[@sureshkapoor6875]

Instead of giving progress to balochistan Pakistan's greedy jaws crushing balochistan.

[@sachinsondh8499]

My ears are paining man! But the debate is quiet funny!😂

[@rajeshclick]

we are with Balochistan

[@indianviking6477]

Poor Baloch. We need to stand up for them and not chicken out like ususal. We the people of India will only vote for the party that promise the baloch independence with deadline.

[@Manjeetkumar-vn7nm]

Mr tarik Fatah will be always told right word for all the thinking of Pakistani gest.

[@punjabigundaa]

Dr. Seshadri Chari really went after them today and shut them up at the end.

[@RajeshSingh-lj6oe]

How many nails did you put in Pakistani's chair they are sitting on.😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@sumanbiswas6359]

India with Balochistan

[@NoVideo2024]

There's no need to debate with Pakistan. It's like talking to dog and it barks in return.

[@nazbaloch7892]

ViralFever they don't want to lesson any just know how to do bk bk without giving any reasons.

[@9durga787]

Shafqat Saeed- bro Achakzai that Voice of India(Arnab Goswami) has again called us for the debate on Balochistan, what to do we will be exposed??? Achakzai- let him talk about Balochistan , we will only say one word Kashmir as we do everytime

[@anujrana1865]

#IndiaStandsWithBalochistan #IndiaStandsWithPOK #IndiaStandsWithSindh

[@akashmondal784]

If pakistan thaught that china is helping then ; you must also have to thaught about" the goat ,which has feed before being halal"

[@bhavinkataria9427]

This pakistani panelist says that is wrong footage of 1971 war. So How & why was Bangladesh created? To play cricket?

[@createrk123]

I guess Arnab is not doing this debate by heart, he is just forced into him, Anyway good topic.

[@rishisubedi5547]

Pakistan is worried about to losing Baluchistan

[@naturebeauty5037]

Arnab is a candid and outspoken personality..

[@sainaveenbali]

that pak guy accent is hilarious xD

[@nemavil]

n.a. p

[@RavikantSaluja]

Mr. Lota.... (Bina Talli Ka)... LOL

[@devkamal7705]

Arnab Ji I protest As I cannot find any video of Modi ji in General assembly but only of Arun Gandhi . I recently tried to call you after getting your number and there lady said there is no arnab there. What the hell. Where is video depicting Modi ji in UN I cannot find. I Edit it its in 9:30:10:40 Pardon. Sure Balochistan Shall be free republic of Balochistan and Same be Republic of Sindh we Indians shall support them in all ways.

[@sassikhan562]

When Balochistan is raised by India, Pakistan can counter with the instability and state-inflicted violence in northeast India.

[@adarshharshan6392]

Ok go for it.Even they dont want to listen abt kashmir.LoL

[@JitendraYadav-qq6nl]

we support Baluch people

[@mrbaloch1304]

arnab asks best is best best is best

[@habijabi1430]

jis desh me doraemon and chota bheem se khatre may pad jati hai ush desh ka haalat soch ke hi haasi aati hai . :P

[@pankajharane6300]

ok means in debate one thing also clear archakzai have great power to bark continuesly and loudly ...congrates archakzai

[@XDataDoctorX]

Probably half of your viewers closed this video because you keep inviting an empty box with stones (also called as John Achakzai) that makes irritating noise without any sense. Next time search & invite human beings in Pakistan even if it is too hard for you to find.

[@rajawaqar7329]

Pakistan media should start discuss indian internal matters on talk show as well..........

[@siddharthjain2503]

I may be digressing but that guy Mahmood Khan Achakzai has some accent!

[@greatrajput7553]

LONG LIVE ISLAMIC REPUBLIC OF PAKISTAN💚

[@SatenGaming6060]

Epic

[@Bunny-mr3ep]

star 1 i love your comment thanks for supporting pakistan

[@KHANKHAN-fx6pi]

I HAPPY WHEN I SEE THESE INDIAN PAID DEBTORS IN PANIC MOOD

[@kayasharma2995]

hahaha he said to us Indians you are nothing....our Ambani one company makes more money than whole Pakistan bahaaaaa

[@brandonblair1057]

You're a Lota lota!! 😂😂

[@krupasai44]

Why r u calling the barking dogs from Pak ? They r nuisance .

[@Param051]

Even peoples of pakistan will laugh at their panelist.

[@RajkumarPattnaik]

pak panelists don't know how to listen to others.

[@avi1984singh]

Shafak shaeed always wanted to speak truth , But he can't . he always seems nice person

[@akashhbakshi6735]

Balochistan will be free soon

[@burhanahmadkhan6150]

if UN could not do any thing for kashmir in the past 50 years except passing resolution,,, then what can it do for balochistan ,,, keep dreaming india

[@amdavad100]

Why alwAys pakistani debaters never listen and always emphasysing on lowering india and opposing any indian comment its nt that we are against pakistan its that the people over there are also tired of gov.and the gov.people or diplomates never understand the situation and denying always by showing aggresion ..people in pakistan tired of their isis and gov.

[@shashanka134]

Seriously why do Pakistanis come to this debate eventhough they get humiliated again and again?

[@Param051]

Referendum would be a tight slap on the face of these peoples barking like dog