'Disappointed' Anand Ranganathan Spills Hard-Hitting Facts On What's Draining India's Exchequer

Dr. Anand Ranganathan joined Navika Kumar on the Times Now Budget 2024 discussion. Watch the Times Now video to find out why Dr. Ranganathan is disappointed.
#budget2024 #anandranganathan #navikakumar #timesnow #budgetwithtimesnow #budget2024discussion #timesnowdebate #anandranganathannews #nirmalasitharaman #modi #modigovt #financeminister #gdp
Times Now - Times Now News channel examines news with in-depth analysis. We provide much more than the Get Breaking news, the Latest news, Politics news, of the day. Times Network houses upscale television channels.
Times Network takes the lead with its ground-breaking innovation and disruption of a new content category. The Times Network channels, which have a global footprint in 100 countries, inform, entertain, and engage viewers of all ages with fascinating and intriguing content, news, and information.
Subscribe to our channel - / @timesnow
Check out our website: www.timesnowne...
Facebook: / timesnow
Twitter: / timesnow
Instagram: / timesnow
You can Search us on KZbin by- @timesnow

[@ReturnDesi]

If Government can't afford pensions of soldiers then why there is pension for MPs and MLAs

[@nishantmishra9679]

Correct

[@vivekvs1992]

MPs and MLAs are the technical agniveers.. Take away their pensions... Let them have the NPS style pensions

[@ChandranPrema123]

Exactly

[@pavanshetty9806]

Its the numbers which makes pensions expensive and unsustainable.

[@ABHISHEKKUMAR-ry9qx]

​@@pavanshetty9806so these corrupt politicians who only visit their areas only during election time deserve a pension and those brave soldiers who live thousands of km away from their home and sacrifice their lives for the nation don't deserve pension?

[@sandeepkumarkhuntia8839]

Stop old pension schemes for MPs and stop wasting money of tax payers.

[@drpkc007]

Stop all pension to all POLITICIANS who are 99.95 are looters of Indian peoples money.

[@naturemeditation3751]

Not only Anand but many Indians and indian businesses are very very disappointed .... Modi is closer to communists and socialists he is all talk about business and now becoming more and more anti national closer to congress party...

[@ankurai1]

He is not either closed to communists or socialists.. He is only for super rich 0.01 percent industrialists working for their welfair and providing mechanism to Ensure cheap Labour (slaves) by pushing common people in poverty and monopolised market by killing the small/ mid scale Business

[@amazingdude9042]

blame goes to people of India itself and nobody else. if they didn't have diverted their votes for fucking freebies then MODI would not have to do this at all. now BJP has no other option to keep the votebank. freeloaders are the voters in this country.

[@Nick-qn6sp]

@@ankurai1 Pure din leftist logo ki baate sunoge toh ye he hoga.

[@pavanshetty9806]

@@naturemeditation3751 he has to be as long as voters vote for freebie promises by oppositiom. Else he will lose anyways.he can do things only when he survives politically. So we must punish people who promise unsustainable freebies forcing all parties to follow in same steps. It is the congress that does unsustainable promises .

[@dravidian667]

@@pavanshetty9806freebies cost way less than giving loan writeoffs to corporates

[@vikaspant8945]

Those who are enjoying privileged Malai generation after generation without any merits are feeling offended by Dr. Rangnathan golden words. Yes almost all PSUs must be closed just to run loss making PSUs for employment of xxxcx is ridiculous thought process.

[@the_good_citizen]

the PSU point is important.

[@crtp47]

PSU has made profit, and it can do so in future. Its a myth created so private players can fill their pockets, which could be filled by us.

[@the_good_citizen]

@@crtp47 PSUs have several intrinsic inefficiencies- the have high administrative expenditure, cannot sack inefficient employees and often require taxpayer money to stay afloat. So 10 ruppees spent in a PSU fetches returns of 1 rs whereas in an efficiently run private company, it will fetch returns of 11 rs. So PSUs need to be closed down and sold to highest bidders.

[@vivekanand5154]

It's not necessary to close down psu ..u have to make it more efficient.....

[@the_good_citizen]

@@vivekanand5154 80 years of running PSUs have shown us it's impossible. Profit motive is the only way a corporation can work. Freedom to Hire-fire. PSUs have to follow all govt rules of recruitment, etc. So not possible,

[@kk-ej5jx]

​@@the_good_citizenDude check the profit of SBI IOCL and other PSU like NTPC you will know

[@balakrishnanl7241]

Great observation by Ranganathan about PM’s double standard on one side Modi making propaganda Government not to run PSU but should be handed over to private company but in reality providing additional fund for survival Inspite of making heavy losses which are additional burden to tax payers money.Stupidity of Modi government in making mockery of their policy’s and fooling the common man.

[@akshay-vo6qt]

As selling PSUs is like plucking an apple from a tree. Your so called ultra stupid opposition will allow? Never. All they know is to politicise the matter, but in reality they do not want any benefit to the country. People are blind to see how much Gandhi, Mamta, Akhilesh, Kejriwal and others crave for power. All they need is power for which they condemn government at every step.

[@BHARATHKUMARK-yg2ul]

Keep voting for freebies....

[@ritswik]

PSU are there to provide jobs for OBC SC ST muscleman

[@surajkumar-fi2tf]

Hahaha... Muscleman

[@dravidian667]

Bank employees 80% from one community

[@rocka_bye3455]

in pune maximum pmc run medical dispensaries have class 4 employees from relatives of local MLAs

[@ntraj-c1s]

They loot it mainly from OC or Forward community work private companies after rejected on the basis of reservation

[@tranceravi7]

Just 40 likes says you hit the nail

[@aniketsawant2240]

When they are wondering why they lost in 2029...Budget 2024 was the final straw.

[@shanthalakshmi2082]

@@aniketsawant2240 BJP.. Begger Janata party... They only grab and give back nothing 😂

[@rk54322]

Lol in Budget 2028 they will introduce huge tax breaks and public will forget.

[@shanthalakshmi2082]

@@rk54322 well.. you can't cheat all the time. Why do you expect this government will last that long? Election may come next year also. Where are those ED actions now. Why silent mode.. LoL Suddenly they realise they may be need any one's help anytime. People realise they are power mongers.. On top of Hindus will only get ramar temple and Muslim hate speech but nothing in budget. Hindus are noticing this

[@kartikkailas9123]

​@@rk54322No, they will not

[@debankadey7357]

Nahh bro they will suck money till 2028 and will grant relief in 2028's budget

[@Deepnandy148]

Modi govt implement the Gandhian socialist policy 😅

[@amazingdude9042]

blame goes to people of India itself and nobody else. if they didn't have diverted their votes for fucking freebies then MODI would not have to do this at all. now BJP has no other option to keep the votebank. freeloaders are the voters in this country.

[@binakhimji6509]

Here to listen to only Anandji

[@ramji_ki_katha]

Navika be like :- Lado pencho 😂

[@TrekVenture1408]

😂

[@vbill]

So called professor and he does not have numbers. What sort of professor is that?

[@antarshakti3093]

24 different types of taxes in India every citizen pays : Income tax Capital gains Sales tax Service tax Excise duty Property tax Value Added tax Securities Transaction tax Goods and services Tax Payroll taxes Customs duty Gift Tax Act, 1958 Indirect tax Other taxes Effective taxes Entertainment Octroi Wealth taxes Excise taxes Road tax Tangible personal property (tpp) taxes Dividend Distribution tax The Income-tax Act, 1961 Stamp duty

[@SP-oc7dm]

So called Economist is just fake.

[@spiceleo]

Anand Ranganathanji is the best. How he roasts the woke prof

[@balwirpasha]

PSU 😂😂 is all filled bihari Especially national banks All PSU should be closed down⬇😢

[@ankurai1]

Its weird that after providing 16 lac cr loan waiver to private Sector from social funding, the government is shamelessly saying that despite huge profit, private Sector is not creating Employment opportunities... Instead they are getting greedy by asking for 14 hours working day!! Who will Ensure that after spending social fund on corporate, they would return to society when their turn comes... Like British they are expecting Risk to be social business but profit is of individual

[@sudheerk67]

A very smart game you played.. You are simply gas lighting here.. Without naming which govt was proposing 14 hour work day.. 😂😂

[@LAkSHMIPRASAD-c1j]

The game is played by many people on every party in many more subtle ways I don't think he is wrong in doing it when others arent​@@sudheerk67

[@Logicalmind59]

​@@sudheerk67he also smartly called loan writeoff as loan waiver, without understanding the difference between the two. Typicall congressi chamacha.

[@spg6651]

I worked in 1990 built one PAINT PLANT . That had 700 laborer -- in 2006 the same company went ahead for NEW sophisticated plant 3 times bigger than my plant where I worked with only 100 laborers due to AUTOMATION .. This is purely due to efficiency -- Automation brings in efficiency ... Not that company wants to " Reduce " labor force -- We individuals use READY MIC CONCRETE ( RMC) trucks for our house construction which use to be done using 40 laborers before 2000 . ISD / STD booths gave lot of employment from 1990 to 2010 .. Today it is not there .. Cyber cafe gave employment -- Today it is not there .. At the same time PNG started hiring people , GIG workers for AMZON deliver is a big job today .. Hence JOB is trciky subject

[@neerajpurohit3032]

Anand is savage....

[@vsk6448]

Budgets is annual Tamasha.

[@sukarnaacharya9615]

Once I have read- 'Economics at best can give job to economists'.

[@prabirmondal4708]

The host is way too annoying

[@RaulVincitaly]

BSNL funding is no use, waste drain

[@kumarsrijan8377]

This is the same reason forest cover is increasing, because we started counting shrubs and bushes as forest.

[@mrgz999]

Anand Ranganathan is Govt Spokesman. He must be fully supportive of the Budget

[@ramaraocheepi7847]

Debate is fascinating and appreciated. Fm presented a brilliant budget particularly embraced the pressing problems of all commoners, in the present political ambiance.

[@7guitarlover]

I respect Anand Ranganathan BUT this time he is not right. He claims senex is an all time high..Well...any conuntry that is developing will have highest levels of sensex at that point of time....For example - In 1992 we had the highest Sensex (Compared to 1980's)...You can take any year..in future and say its an all time high sensex. For ex - regardless of the govt , sensex in 2030 will be the highest ever. Also in 2035 regardless of the govt the sensex will be all time high. Its not the govt but the economy is in such a phase you will have such conditions. These numbers always increase and will increase till your gdp expands. ( cetrus peribus)

[@Parthoo]

Absolutely false. There are MANY developing countries whose indexes have either fallen or stayed stagnant (inflation adjusted) in the last 10 Years including CHINA. So please do your research. The only markets that have given great returns are the US (developed) and India ( developing) You are taking for granted that the market has risen at all points for India. It is absolutely to India and it’s vibrant markets and companies that it’s has done so well.

[@kartikkailas9123]

Sensex increasing indicates that companies' current and projected performance is increasing. That's owed to Govt policies.

[@Parthoo]

@@kartikkailas9123 not for all companies and certainly not the companies in the Sensex which are taxed quite heavily compared to the world average. In india companies do well DESPITE the govt. The Indian govt has always been traditionally socialist (not including the BJP years) and has always been low key anti business.

[@kartikkailas9123]

@@Parthoo . I disagree with that. Companies doing well despite Govt and companies benefitting from Govt policies is a different game.

[@jimmylee1273]

Didnt the 1992 sensex rise occur because if the scam that took place? HM

[@0xsan-w1h]

Someone please reduce the volume on the large speaker in the middle.

[@kotamrajuprasad2742]

What economic progress..when people with 30,000- has to pay tax ...

[@voltzz5283]

It's according to old tax regime implemented by UPA New tax regime 0-3 LPA no tax 3-7 =5% but this also becomes zero because of 25000 rupees rebate. Which means no tax for 0-7 LPA slab.

[@kartikkailas9123]

In no regime, people with 3.6L salary have to pay income tax

[@voltzz5283]

@@kartikkailas9123 You don't need to pay taxes upto 7 lakhs .You can claim for rebate .

[@gsnijjar7931]

Why is no one talking about POPULATION EXPLOSION. It is offsetting ALL GROWTH. Bring in a rule only TWO CHILDREN per family will be considered for benefits from the Govt

[@LeeNaidoo-hm9xf]

It's not spoken about because if they do those receiving government hand outs won't vote for them then their ATM is gone

[@spg6651]

Constitution allows Population explosion .. It would be unconstitutional if government advics on population -- in 2047 , 100 years of Indepedence , India will be 175 crore population

[@kartikkailas9123]

People do not vote for development or betterment of the country.

[@vinestervega19]

You need to read more. As the rate of educated people increases, and the cost of living is already rising, these will automatically lead to less births generation on generation, you could probably already see the drop in the rate of birth rate, pull data and analyze yourself.

[@jimmylee1273]

You need to research more about what doom these "child policies" have brought upon China. They are in a steep demographic decline due to it. Their total fertility rate has fallen because of this and hence they are going to growing old as the population is not replacing itself with newer generation. In short, the country is gonna grow older quicky (average age).

[@abhisheksonawane4678]

Only Anand Sir knows how to deal with these Librandus!!🔥🔥🔥🔥👍

[@dbavhadadvocate]

Sir speak on one sided provision of GST LAW. GST concept is best but draft is most vague

[@hawkgrab]

Who is the chief economic custard advisor? Better of earning the living by pimping

[@vilasambre]

Livelihood is the right word and adjusts perfectly with our economic context. Investments are in we have to make it organic and realistic

[@Rk_1978]

Why is that lady shouting

[@kalyanbanerjee2869]

And another is the farmer's repealing bill

[@rookiesmarts]

Godi analyst told to shut up 😂

[@Avinab2]

Time for a libertarian party to become mainstream now.

[@rajivrajgarhia2883]

Anand you are too good…kya dhoya hai…false economist ko

[@kunalpareek8321]

Bechaare ko sabhyata se bolne bhi nahin diya. Asabhya logon ki jamaat hai Modi ke fans.

[@sm-ph8uf]

do you even know E of economics... the point that old man is making is absolutely valid...

[@dravidian667]

What about false exit polls rejoicers before result?

[@RaulVincitaly]

Railway also should be privatised, only price control like Power sector

[@RG-ml1sm]

Why this truth being stoped for public knowledge?

[@NatrajChaturvedi]

As many times, starts to speak in the interest of the people then reverts to being a bjp spokesperson, player in the bjp congress tu tu mai mai fixed match which is of no actual benefit to the people.

[@Mahadev_Shiv18]

Why can't u cut off politicians salary maintenance if political parties have more than 500cr should donate to poor

[@70newlife]

I discovered this guy anand ranganathan few months back in the KZbin headlines. I still dont have the answer to the question as to who the hell is anand ranganathan!!??? 🤔🤔

[@1x1x1is1]

He is the guy who blames opposition for bad policies of BJP but won't blame BJP

[@shanthalakshmi2082]

What is there for Hindus n this budget by the Hindu party 😂?.

[@aniketsawant2240]

If you're lucky...babaji ka thullu

[@shanthalakshmi2082]

@@aniketsawant2240 They are saying for Hindus we being generous had given ramar temple and Muslim hate speech continuous to their egos..that is enough.. LoL

[@g.kcurrentaffairsadda542]

Godi anchors aur godi economist achachank se rone kyu laga😅😅

[@syams84]

Anand is a comedian

[@spg6651]

In a long run every one is dead .. This future looking fiscal glide path where in by 2047 India would be great and all is nice to hear .. UPI in not a part of any Budget speech before it happened .. Today it is force to reckon with the Indian economy , Step change happens through Innovation not by gradual glide path. 1991 STEP change happened .. there was ample opportunity to take STEP change in this budget -- Missed that opportunity grossly

[@Teja_S]

ये प्रो BJP किसीको बोलने ही नहीं देते बस टाइम कहा जाते हैं

[@samg7123]

Economic survey last chapter on climate is absolute nonsense. It talks of people eating beef and toilet paper use in west. Will that save the issue of smog and pollution in Delhi? Completely out of sync of reality and not worth of a serious research document. It is a typical politics of talking everything else when you have no answer

[@manandinkar6115]

It would have been better if he had left the debate when he said he should. This old guy having yhe audacity to tell a person to shut up since he's a scientist and not an economist but himself cant answer a question which is as easy to find by just googling it. The channel should ask yhe debaters to prepare and do some homework before they appear on tv to rant and make a fool of themselves

[@vkumar6693]

The BJP Government doesn't care about the middle class and lower middle class people . The Salaried employees already Pays Income tax as per slab rate and whatever balance amount invested in Mutual fund/ Stock market, we are imposed to pay STT tax, CST Charges, Sebi Charges, STCG Tax, LTCG Tax, Depository Charge and Brokerage. All these taxes are increased by this BJP Government every year. This imparts huge burden on private employees. Mutual fund/Stock market was the only way to save some money and get inflation beating returns for the retirement benefits of private employees. At least Long term capital gain tax on equity investment should have been completely removed. Before year 2018, there was no long term capital gain tax on equity. The BJP government imposed huge tax policies. This government is doing injustice to the tax payers .

[@rohitashkhaitan4578]

Why does ranganathan speak like a 4th grade kid reciting poetry.

[@bharathkashyap4435]

This economist is a big liar. Thousands of Bangladeshis infiltrated here especially in Bangalore's kudlu gate, harlur, btm layout, HSR layout and begur area only because they can find easy jobs. There are carpenters here, plumbers here, works for Zomato, swiggy, zepto here. This economist needs to hush and read and listen to the society formed here. What is he talking about. It really doesn't make sense.

[@kumarsrijan8377]

what kind of illogical discussion just transpired, what was being talked about what nonsense got discussed eventually. And it is so shocking to see that Anand R. took the bait and got fully distracted to another topic altogether. What has PSU making losses got to do with unemployment and AI. Bahut high quality ka fookte hai ye log.

[@KS0607]

Psu nahi rahengi to govt job b kam ho jayengi....fir sab private job krenge ....lekin india me private job = harassment....localised in some 2-3 cities.....12 hr jobs...no family life... When ull make india Europe then remove govt job

[@millennialmind9507]

Even government sector me bhi harassment hoti hai

[@vinsin328]

That is not how europe became europe. And why do you want to be like EU not USA or China?

[@Davids677-e1w]

Only under Modi @@millennialmind9507

[@nikhilvithalkar7767]

Kaale coat wala kitna bachkana hai yaar

[@aniketsawant2240]

Cant handle the truth?

[@MohammedJaweed-jw3xv]

A sanghi rarely adopts trueism.

[@16kumar]

Navika can u lower down ur volume u are just shouting

[@ranjanroy82]

Ranganathan 's behaviour is truly boorish and obnoxious

[@gurukiran7211]

Anand is the only person who can handle any idiot in the world.....😂😂

[@shivarajkumbar2439]

Ye news wale tu tu me me karnewale logoko hi bulate hai hamesha 😂😂😂😂😂 Koyi bhi shanth hokar nahi kehta apni baat ko , koyi present questions utathe he tho samne wala wyakti purani baate batata hai koyi conclusion nahi 😂 Debate karna accha baat hota hai Aakhir me thark ke samne kutark haarjata he , lekin Aaj kal ki news debates me cheekam cheeki bas yahi karlo 😂

[@NehruJuliets]

He doesn't know the number...illiterate professor 😂😂😂

[@vivekvs1992]

He knows the number.. But numbers are contrary to his point.. It's the general academician's adjustment during lectures

[@sm-ph8uf]

he very well knows.... but do you even know the formula for calculating such numbers.. if i dont include school fee..rent..etc in inflation calculation the number will automatically come before 6...which is a completely false number....this is what government is doing right now.... THE numbers are not matching up with the ground reality...

[@NehruJuliets]

@@vivekvs1992 if u know the number..u state it and then make your point. He is an urban naxalite...they don't make a point...they uses verbal violence to kill logic and reason.

[@vishalgupta5024]

Go Modi go , ur govt will get curse from all tax payers , may all vote against you and bjp does throw u and Nirmala Sitaraman out of bjp. From a all time supporter of bjp , I am now bjp hater till these 2 are in power

[@Abhishek-hs8zi]

Crying like Lil bich

[@dravidian667]

Washing powder 😂

[@rajivrajgarhia2883]

Yeh bath ka badatameez bhi hai

[@sandeepkumarkhuntia8839]

Taxation like England and facility like Somalia.

[@LeeNaidoo-hm9xf]

You have no idea about what you are saying it's a koad of hogwash

[@gurushivpranav7772]

BJP not again bro😢

[@crazymamle]

Hee bhagwan , tai ko uttha lo ab to

[@RamReddyRaghu]

Bjp🎉🎉🎉

[@2859abhi]

Only those who love slaving themselves towards a private individual will shout against Public sectors

[@vinsin328]

Because those slaves are funding the public sector.

[@atharv2010]

Ye safed baal wala khusat buddha kon hai ?

[@venkatanarasimhamkadambari242]

Disgusting Economic Discussions

[@arnabdatta2505]

What did BJP GOVT do in last 10yrs for the PSUs ?? Nothing..!!

[@LeeNaidoo-hm9xf]

Financed them although they are running at a loss to save jobs.

[@ArthurLeywin-bg9tj]

All these are bogus number by BJP..... Shame

[@thehinditeacher_shree]

Anand Ranganathan is absolute NONSENSE speaker

[@Exposingdevils365]

I can understand you are totally uneducated 🤣🤣🤣, how can you justify the psu fund allocation, they are bearing losses since long time bcz of idiot ppl like you and waste our money.

[@Exposingdevils365]

You are absolute nonsense, how can you justify govt bearing losses since yrs???

[@Peace-vs9yi]

I can understand ur n congis incapability

[@NehruJuliets]

And you are as brilliant as pappu😂😂😂

[@parthachem83]

To get sense, one needs education and gray matter 🤡

[@ntraj-c1s]

Modi fooled those patriats looks for a saviour dor this country . So nomore foolishness

[@theone6306]

Ranga Billa😅