Comparison: Vincoroor V33-06 Fire of the Sky VS Takara Tomy MP-57 Skyfire VS FansToys FT-10X Phoenix

[@rubenlopez7142]

People like the Fanstoys Phoenix because is a more stylized version of the character, but for me it's the least appealing since it's the less faithful to the original character.

[@jpatt1000]

I have what I guess is the second release of the Seige Skyfire as mine has no weathering. I do like how they cheated the very tip of the nose into the hips in robot mode so it can have a waist rotation. Not a fan of all the holes in his jet mode, but it is what it is. (I do fold his front and rear foot sections so they touch and sort of come to a streamlined point.) I did mask off the canopy and airbrush the frame white so you get the notch in the leading edge of the canopy. (It's molded in, they just didn't paint it.) I didn't pay attention after pulling the figure out and din't realize he had a flight stand, I'll have to go pull those out of the box. I do think I want to pick up an MP-57 though.

[@WaywardTraveler77]

Awesome video man. You sold my on the KO after the first unboxing. I also love that it doesn't have that dirt wash that the series had.

[@TMReviews]

Thanks for watching

[@michaelscholes8956]

I agree, that dirt wash was terrrrrible

[@LetsGetitBoah]

Phoenix is still my favorite. Best overall build, best face sculpt by far, and I love his "heroic" proportions. Just a truly bad ass looking bot that is fun to transform and looks great in both modes.

[@denozed6554]

Absolutely 100% Facts. Love my Phoenix.

[@RID01S]

Yup you can’t beat those proportions

[@LetsGetitBoah]

@@denozed6554 he’s truly one of the best masterpiece figures ever made.

[@denozed6554]

@@LetsGetitBoah He was my first Fanstoys I ever bought. I was in shock how different level it was I bought another one while on vacation. Keep one in alt mode for display.

[@BWiskey3]

Really great comparison between 3 fantastic figures! Couldn’t agree more with your assessment as there’s definitely now a Skyfire that fits any category a person is looking for. That last shot of the figures cracked me up. MP-57 looks like he’s begging for mercy. Thanks TM I really appreciate your versus videos!

[@TMReviews]

Thanks Wiskey. You seem to get what I'm doing every time. Even down to the last shot in the review 🤣

[@mechgouki7999]

Huh??? Why is this comment 7 hours old when this video was posted 1 hr ago?????

[@TMReviews]

@@mechgouki7999 because members get videos ahead of public posting

[@mechgouki7999]

@@TMReviews oh.....

[@gtoney]

Only if TT was fun to play with would be my pick.. I'll have to go with the Siege ko for transformation and most fun. Nice VS. ✨️😃

[@TMReviews]

Thanks G

[@mcloutierg8201]

Great vs. as always. I am glad I stuck with my FT-10 and FT-10X. The Takara might be the most toon accurate but he just looks small compared to the other two.

[@TMReviews]

Thanks, Definitely very different looks for all 3

[@thetitan914]

Great review, I love versus videos. Always find them educational, such as now I've learned I need to get all three......😟

[@nocturnalcockroach]

You forgot to mention an extra compartment to store a mini figure on the TT and the Cargo Bay itself during the gimmicks section.

[@lowellmartens6135]

I have found the same about the build. I have had Phoenix for years and it is as solid as the day I got it. My takara had loose parts out of the box, and has not got any better over time.

[@BlackCanvasAudio]

Great comparison. I absolutely LOVE the WFC Jetfire mold so the Vincoroor KO isa my preferred choice. I sold my copy of the TT Skyfire, the quality wasn't worth the price. Different strokes for different folks I guess! lol

[@Okabe009]

I like the ko oversized one 👌

[@bigfornoreason1]

I have TT Skyfire and he is an awesome figure. The only issue I experienced is that his backpack is difficult to deal with. I have been able to completely transform it though, i.e., get the backpack fully compressed, albeit through having to use a bit more physical force than I'd like. I have to say, though, that these figures are really not for play, and certainly not for rough play. If you want a figure that you can transform back and forth without having to worry, buy a chug figure. Masterpiece style figures are delicate, and rightfully so. They have more engineering, which means more moving parts, which means more potential points of failure. Sometimes I see reviewers being almost purposely rough with their figures almost like they're trying to see how much the figure can take. Welp, the figure can't take much. It's not meant to. It's an expensive high end collectible. Tossing the figure around like a rag doll and abusively manipulating its joints is most likely just going to break it. These things are shelf queens, and pretending they're something other than that is just going to result in wasted money when you inevitably break your expensive figure.

[@TMReviews]

With all that being said, the ankle failed just by articulating it, you can see it on camera . That's not acceptable to me

[@knot3d_]

Not including the Gerwalk mode as a feature? That is so fair. The sculpt score outcome? Gosh.., seems pretty obvious the FT version is riddled with bulletholes aka visible screwholes, the most. Fugly. And the Membership vote outcome.?, yeah could have seen that coming from a billion miles away.

[@paperstrawmedia]

I know people love the 100% toon aesthetics and more power to you for your preference, but the normie sitting beside me just pointed out that the TT looked cheap. And it just happens to be standing next to a KO. I then had to do the obligatory job as a TF collector to explain that it's the one that most people want. It still blows my mind that a tiny nub was all it needed to fix the issues of that Siege Jetfire. And with all the funding for R and D that Hasbro has, they didn't think of that design-wise. Anyway, great comparison review as always.

[@michaelscholes8956]

"tiny nub was all it needed to fix the issues of that Siege Jetfire": What are you referring to exactly?

[@paperstrawmedia]

@@michaelscholes8956 I'll take a stab at a guess that you still haven't watched TM's review of the Vincoroor Jetfire. Highly-recommend watching it first before this comparison.

[@TMReviews]

Thanks

[@lowellmartens6135]

Overall I am with you Sony, just keep all, but touch the Takara the least amount. Thanks for the comparison. I imagine it took quite a bit of time, but very appreciated (other then watching your videos keep costing me money) 😀

[@TMReviews]

Thanks Lowell, glad you appreciate the time it takes. Sorry it keeps costing you 😂

[@lowellmartens6135]

Hahahaha, I'm sure you are.

[@donaldjackson4456]

Hands down FTs has the best alt mode. For me Takara is last in alt mode just looks unfinished and the landing gear was an afterthought. My favorite all around is the KO siege Jetfire. For me anyways. Keeping all regardless. Im a magnus and jetfire collector for sure

[@polarisrustinpeace1797]

And still the reigning champion! Not surprised TT is trash, sadly. Great review Sony! Thanks.

[@saysoun752]

I actually love Takara Tomy's version of Skyfire and I think Phoenix is actually the weak link as he's very stylized. I happen to love Skyfire so I usually buy most of them, as long as they look the part so I do have all of these figures. Really depends on what you're wanting from him and since I grew up on the cartoon, it's Skyfire for the win. With that said, NewAge probably has the best version of them all.

[@gdjaybee742]

Hello, I'm planning to get both th e Vincoroor and MP57 KO, and hang one of them on the ceiling in its jetmode. Do you remember which one is lighter weight wise?

[@TMReviews]

Mp-57

[@dkkanofkash8798]

I'm going to be honest, these may be great, but I am waiting for a potential MP-57 Oversize to happen in the future. I don't even know if it's possible to do. I have MP-57 and love that figure, but even at his size I feel like he's too small, especially with all the compartments, gimmicks, and pockets that he comes with. And, potentially, making the figure bigger might fix all the brittle errors, like the ankle tilt on yours.

[@LordChumley]

What's the story on the Autobot emblem on Phoenix? It looks larger than out of the box in terms of the space they leave. You have a special piece in there?

[@TMReviews]

Yes, that is from Iacon 3D labs, I have a review of it

[@carltam9264]

Now you wait until the oversized KO Newage Jetfire with those crazy articulations...

[@chriskiefer7493]

Nice screw holes, Fanstoys.

[@pupunoob]

If im not mistaken, the netflix cartoons actually use the 3d models they use for the toys.

[@MinimusAmbusIII]

Yup

[@davidcauley9400]

I love my phoenix but the knee joint placement is on the upper thigh, and looks really bad the more you bend the legs. And if you want to be picky, it has an extra section behind thr cockpit that kinda unbalances the placememt of the wings, i. E the front is too long. Takara gets the knee engineering right but frankly it looks derpy, mainly the face. I wish TT would quit the Toon accuracy, and return to faithful but 'realistic' aesthetics they started with. Hands down the coolest looking is the siege, and it also has knees in the right place. I wish it came with articulated hands and a clear flight stand, but otherwise I think for pure badass looks it beats the other two.

[@markcarloestabillo5461]

If Fanstoys wasn't that expensive, I would have gotten it. So it's the OS KO for win.

[@atomD21]

For me, I have the original Siege figure and love it, but don't want the KO. I picked the Takara figure for my collection because I wanted it to look like the character I saw on TV. As far as the ankle issue, it was doomed to fail. Takara used way too strong of a spring then chose a pin to hold it all together. I have one that failed and I'm sure the other one isn't far behind. I'm planning on seeing if I can source the ankle pieces from the recent MP-57 KO as they corrected that.

[@mechgouki7999]

I too own 2 Sieges, and have no intention of getting a KO siege. As for the KO mp, I heard that the tolerances are worse. Saw it on mangmotion reviews.

[@atomD21]

​@@mechgouki7999 Oh yeah, the KO MP is a mess, but they did the ankle joints better. Those are the only parts I want.

[@mechgouki7999]

@@atomD21 Tmreview broke his ankles without even trying. If the KO mp has good ankles it shd be worth picking up. Personally I once tried to replace the chromed parts of an MP 10, only to give up when I couldn't get the pin out. Screws are easy to work with. Pins not so much. Good luck on the replacement process.

[@atomD21]

​@@mechgouki7999Yeah, my ankle broke while I was transforming him, not even using the ratchet joint... disassembling the foot and removing that part is pretty easy overall. If I could find even just the right screws, I could replace the pins and fix the joints.

[@RID01S]

Phoenix is still the best looking jetfire imo. Its so good it makes me feel like I don’t have to get another Jetfire into my collection unless it’s very stylized

[@BoozyBeggar]

I got the MP ko, and the bot mode is excellent, one of the best looking bot modes I own, but the transformation is AWFUL in the backpack section. I'll most likely never transform it again. I might get the osko siege mode at some point just to have a fun Jetfire transformation.

[@darrellford4022]

Seige skyfire wont look like g1 skyfire in jet mode because seige is its own cartoon version. So to me KO and fanstoys would have been a tie

[@DragoonMS]

Dig it out

[@waynewest6160]

Is anyone surprised to see a failure on camera?!?! Dude, you beat the hell out of em & yank them around so hard I'm surprised anything is still standing. 😂 I watch your reviews because of you don't break the shit out of em, I know I'm not going to.

[@TMReviews]

Thanks I guess? Lol

[@waynewest6160]

@@TMReviews 😂

[@sidearmsalpha]

Had I known they were going to KO the TakaraTomy, I would have passed on it and waited for the KO. Definitely not worth the original price. I even got two because he's my favorite Transformer and I wanted to have one in each mode but the fighter mode looks bad with all those gaps. Oh well.

[@lowellmartens6135]

Just looking at the three in bot mode the proportions on the Takara really are the worst. I really may need to grab this oversized KO.

[@TMReviews]

Yeah it's crazy to see them next to each other and how different they really are

[@hotforteacher7540]

8:25 Are you kidding, "cartoon accuracy" Goes to Takara all the way. Come one man!!! And the folded wings are a NO!!! Beside, if anyone is collecting for the long run it will always be Takara and Hasbro. Period.

[@TMReviews]

Wait Takara did win cartoon accuracy here. I'm not sure what you mean.Also with the recent announcement of the MP line ending and merging with MPG, we may not have a guarantee that "it will always be Takara", but that is my opinion

[@MinimusAmbusIII]

You do realize that the netix show used the toy models right? You're acting like they made the show first and the toys based off of the show.

[@razoray78]

No Daca Toys Jetfire? lol

[@mechgouki7999]

No, Vincoroor is not value for money. I would argue this over and over and over again, and again. I expect an oversize KO to be CHEAPER than the original. NOT more expensive. The Vincoroor simply copied someone else's homework. I expect it to be 70 USD, 80 tops. NOT 105, more expensive than the retail price of a Commander class. No, I strongly disagree, and I condemn this thing. 80usd should have been the max price. This is not value for money, period. I know I am a broken record player now, but I cannot stress this enough. KOs MUST cost less than the original.

[@mixolivera]

If that's the way you think then it seems like you can't afford this KO haha!. Get it through your head that this KO is leagues better than the original with tons of improvements. So if they want to charge more they can. Stop crying just because it hurts your wallet 😂 Let me also stress that there is NO rule or law that states KO's should cost less than originals specially if they are way better made. The original doesn't have anything on this KO from the material, paint, size and improvements.

[@joose-pin3220]

If it were the 11 inch original version I would agree. But the 14 inch version with metal parts added does deserve the extra $20.

[@mechgouki7999]

@@mixolivera Where do you think they copied this from? If the original sucked so much, then maybe the copy of the original sucked too! Don't get either! Wow, contradictory much? With your kind of lame argument, one day they will charge fake diamonds more than real diamonds cos it looks shinier! Mark my words, if they get away with this, next time all you will be getting are KOs with improvements but bigger price tags. And eventually they will start to KO each other, while slapping a bigger price tag. If that sounds like a good prospect to you, then go ahead and buy a few more copies, let them know you want more.

[@mixolivera]

@@mechgouki7999 fix your brain man. These days most 3rd party KO's are way better than the original. They copy the base model and improve everything wrong with hastak garbage. Buy all the orignals you want but they will always be inferior. And what a lame example bout the diamonds those are different than toys and have far greater value. What really should be KO'd is that brain of yours. It's way too faulty and could use some upgrades. Maybe that way you could earn enough money to afford more expensive toys you crybaby 😂

[@samhillier9607]

It is larger, is painted better, uses better materials and improved the design. Due to those reasons, I feel it is worth more than the original. A fake diamond? Not an apt comparison. Fake diamonds are made of weaker material (usually glass) than a true diamond. A fake diamond does not look as good as a real diamond on close inspection. This figure is made of superior materials than the original and looks much nicer as well. So, yes, I'd always be willing to pay a bit more for a K.O. if it is such a signifcant improvement on the orginal. Just as I would expect pay more for a bigger & better diamond. If the quality was merely equal to, or less than, the original, I would not buy the K.O. unless it was priced lower. Fine if you don't agree with that, just try to understand we don't all have to feel the same way as you do.

[@BMANTIS1]

Takara made some poor engineering decisions imo

[@bastard2134]

Awesome comparison! I love Skyfire as well. Where can we get the Over sized KO? I haven’t seen it at any of my normal retailers.

[@TMReviews]

Only Chinese retailers

[@bastard2134]

Great, thanks! I’ll see if I can locate one. Thanks for all you do!😊

[@TMReviews]

showzstore.com/vincoroor-v33-06-fire-of-the-sky-oversized-version_p4672.html