Your Magic Deck Is Illegal…

Watch the full gameplay here: • Modern Horizons w/ Ced...
This clip is from Shuffle Up & Play 53 with Gavin Verhey, Cedric Phillips, and Carmen Klomparens!
#mtgcommander #magicthegathering #tolariancommunitycollege
►This channel is brought to you thanks to our wonderful Patreon community. Join to support the show, or just Shuffle Up & Play with other awesome people on our Patron Discord by going to / tolariancommunitycollege
►This show is made in part due to Card Kingdom. You can help us out by visiting our affiliate link at www.CardKingdo...

[@TolarianCommunityCollege]

Watch the full gameplay here: kzbin.info/www/bejne/qGmxXp6brZ14g7s This clip is from Shuffle Up & Play 53 with Gavin Verhey, Cedric Phillips, and Carmen Klomparens!

[@Kyodie-bz1sf]

The Professor saying "Apply Yourself" is so good. The man should use teacher lingo more often

[@joeblount7156]

I know that this is for the memes, but "you're playing an illegal deck because that version of the card is from commander" is 100% something i can see a Modern player actually arguing.

[@FallenAatrox]

Pettiness in its finest

[@anthonystaton3740]

.... And now I will avoid that format thanks

[@tnttv5360]

​@@anthonystaton3740 it is less toxic than commander actually

[@FallenAatrox]

@@tnttv5360 I actually can picture that

[@anthonystaton3740]

@@tnttv5360 I assume you mean competitive commander cause definitely not true in the casual pods I play

[@nzephier]

New format where we throw cards at each other, call it: fling.

[@OpusCulo13666]

Unban Chaos Orb for this format only.

[@rain4825]

commander game but everyone plays Brion Stoutarm for their commander?

[@shiro4833]

Borborymos enraged decks: "I've been playing fling all along"

[@BlueGriffin20]

Loved one of the Un cards that was just a mantis elbow dropping. You had to toss the card and hit a card to destroy it.

[@kamikazehansu]

Good thing they changed the text so I dont have to have an argument everytime I cast KC that it triggers itself upon entering.

[@jakebennett9130]

I don't get why people didn't think it would miss itself entering

[@kamikazehansu]

@@jakebennett9130 It's usually written in another way, suspect it wasn't supposed to trigger itself entering initially. But that's 100% speculation.

[@TheGuyPaddylongname]

It doesn't say another artifact it say AN. I hope you always tell people, reading the cards explains the cards.

[@kamikazehansu]

@@TheGuyPaddylongname Ofcoarse. ✨ You have to admit tho, it's not written in the most player friendly way possible.

[@leopardbunny]

Yeah I'm gonna be real, I had no idea until now.

[@phoenixgaming454]

Prof was like: let him cook. Prof: I'm disappointed in you.

[@SchneeWaltz]

You can take the red pen from the teacher but not the teacher from the red pen.

[@Gurmudgin]

The "apply yourself" comment, that cuts deep prof. Real deep.

[@globbaslobba]

Gavin came to my highschool back in 2013/14(?) for a day during our MTG deck building class (yes this was a real thing) and gave us all free packs of Theros/BotG's. I pulled my Nykthos that day :)

[@AllieTellsJokes]

Throwing the card propels the card

[@keremmadran]

Nice

[@mackenziemcdaniel-paul8163]

A+

[@DimirDaddy]

Throwing the card moves the card 😊

[@camoking3609]

Come on That at least deserves a B+

[@TolarianCommunityCollege]

Not in my class.

[@skyorrichegg]

"Minuses are made up!!"

[@Benusr]

​@@TolarianCommunityCollege I apologise sir!! I will fix his mistake!! Throwing the cards, Explains nothing about the cards, because you didn't read them and the keywords aren't explained...

[@andrewsparkes6275]

​@@BenusrDon't be weird.

[@Benusr]

@@andrewsparkes6275 ??

[@janelantestaverde2018]

Throwing the cards explains the sleeves.

[@keremmadran]

You've done it! That's the one!

[@janelantestaverde2018]

@@keremmadran I shall hand it in as the thesis for a term paper at the Tolarian Community College 👍

[@22neohenry]

throwing the card gives the creature flying

[@joshuaspector8182]

“Thanks, I don’t want that copy. I’m gonna keep using this one.” 😂

[@carlospolk5033]

Still one of my favorite episodes to date besides: the final episode of Season 1 where everyone tied, and the Season 2 episode w/Jim, Ced & Pat in the Mind Goblin game lol

[@Bl4ckBasecoat]

Throwing the cards translates the cards. It also elevates, and angles, and accelerates the cards.

[@dreamcream3738]

"Throwing the cards transports the cards." Same amount of syllables, with some added alliteration to boot.

[@robynmaag1266]

I misread [graphically ...] as [sapphically ...] And I was like, omg slay

[@definitelynotelj]

Might wanna apply cold water to that burned B- area as well.

[@lordflour8008]

B-urn

[@m.mulder8864]

Can't wait to play Gavin with my "Reading the card explains the card" commander deck.

[@KuganeFABTCG]

Throwing the cards moves the cards 😂

[@Epiclesis]

The thumbnail made me believe Andrés Iniesta was playing commander

[@justonky]

Shirou "people die if they're killed" Emiya, is that you?

[@paulreckless]

Just the best content on this channel period. I love it.

[@ClawMachineMonster]

I didn't know Jello Biafra played MTG. WHEN YA GET DRAFTED, WHEN YA GET DRAFTED!

[@_mrcrypt]

B- was generous, but you’re friends. Approved 😜🍷

[@steffenklein6352]

That Lego-Yoda scream got me. 🤣

[@milespaskel4776]

I run 2 of each printing in my modern affinity list to cause this exact reaction. 😊

[@Earthboundmike]

But why would it cause that reaction? Aren't they legal anyway because of the recent printing? Easy explanation that you can do BEFOREHAND.

[@halvsketchy9293]

Im pretty sure the printing doesn't matter in modern as long the card is real and legal? So whats the fuzz?

[@OvenfreshDeth]

Throwing the cards moves the cards. Gavin is spittin rn

[@victhefoxygamer_6180]

Throwing the card, moves the card

[@Chris2pur]

Unless they've changed the rules that is factually incorrect as long as it is the same card in its text and abilities different versions and different prints and even different languages are still legal to use

[@Tosolo-dh2co]

"Throwing the card, removes the card'" quality joke right here folks

[@malcolmcurrie7542]

"Throwing the cards displaces the cards." Cmon Gavin!

[@s0hlless]

most hardcore players wouldnt care because most hardcore players would buy the older and/or more expensive versions of cards to use.

[@ScoutingForZen]

Chucking the card invigorates the card

[@prosamis]

I love mr gavin

[@JO11190]

I felt that B minus apply yourself lol. True prof!

[@KarpetBurn]

I love when commander games end up a 3v1 because of one guy who wants to watch the world burn 😂.

[@tison7208]

throwing the card cannons the card

[@Yuri_USRK]

Isn't there a game mode where ALL cards are permitted in play from any year?

[@Fovulonkiin]

We're so lucky to have Gavin at WotC. But how can he throw that card ;-;

[@ashemabahumat4173]

Meme aside, why is this even a thing? odern has the card too, the printing shouldn't matter unless the cards are of a different physical quality(like size or thickness) in the opposing format

[@Earthboundmike]

I mean, that's funny and all, but that's not illegal so far as I understand. So long as it had a printing that is legal, and copy is usable.

[@SparkShadow212]

Just because we're called spellslingers doesn't mean we need to do that literally.

[@Knikon79]

I have never played in a professional tournament in my life, so forgive my ignorance in this manner, but I thought that everything was legal in modern if it was printed after a set date as long as the card itself is not banned? Are cards from commander sets not legal? I would think that if one version of the card is legal in the format that you are playing, then you should be able to play any version of it legally in the format as long as the abilities and text on the card are the same. Anything else just seems like nitpicking to me. It is the same card that does the exact same thing, and the card itself is legal in the format, so who really cares what edition it is from at that point.

[@lynnthalas]

Classic sooo good

[@fishbiter9409]

Yo Gavin's coat though. Has everyone seen Gavin's coat???

[@punkaerials]

Gavin is a good guy I think

[@bevrosity]

i didnt know paul scheer played magic.

[@jawesome769]

Cmon… throwing the card ex-plays the card was right there.

[@theanalogkidmodular]

Throwing the card causes falling of the star

[@ianstonebridge7324]

Kappa cannoneer, aka Blastoise

[@sigurdursine7763]

Throwing the cards defenestrates the cards.

[@KillSecureSona]

Okay but, where's Charlie?

[@SaltySparrow]

but I have extended arts...

[@clickpause8732]

Throwing the cards solves the cards.

[@MagicMalcetor]

nice ^^

[@magusofthebargain]

B- Apply yourself.

[@dragonmaster613]

There's literally no difference between the copies! I could understand before the reprint that card wasn't legal in Modern, but shouldn't it be after despite the copy being a prior print?

[@JackgarPrime]

It is legal, he's just having a laugh

[@dragonmaster613]

@@JackgarPrime oh good, I haven't played Standard/modern in ages, so I believed it for a moment. (I've stuck to Commander since Innistrad)

[@JackgarPrime]

@dragonmaster613 Yeah, once a card is on the legal list, all printings, even in otherwise illegal sets, are legal. That is indeed still the case, don't worry.

[@gspoiler]

They did reword his effect to make it clearer that he gets the +1/+1 counter for himself.

[@Thatguy223-vc4wb]

Judge!

[@BoostIncMotorsports]

Throwing the card, removes the card!

[@stephaniet9875]

I dont like this one bit

[@lordpepper6932]

The snobbery is unreal

[@zorbratron]

Who cares if its commander printing

[@audiophyll]

Stop shilling the new cards. Cards of any edition can be played as long as legal in format. You want more people to buy but Hasbro has made a killing in the stocks already. I'm making a whole deck of proxies to save money but you replace card editions? I'm playing Magic, while you're thinking about the stock market and Hasbro share price.

[@bevrosity]

i mean, it should be illegal.

[@izaiahsundquist6877]

I've played Titanfall 2 since 2019 and I wouldn't say it's a dead game. More accurately, it's on life support and it's barely kept alive by a passionate player base just like the other TF2, albeit worse at gaining new players because of the freakishly high skill ceiling.

[@jaykorner1391]

Painfully unfunny

[@GabGoten]

0:00