What if Rome Fell in 268 AD?

  Рет қаралды 74,758

toldinstone

toldinstone

Күн бұрын

Пікірлер: 188
@ClassicalNumismatics
@ClassicalNumismatics Жыл бұрын
Aurelian wouldnt let it happen! 💔
@primesonic4459
@primesonic4459 Жыл бұрын
Sol Invictus
@hannibalburgers477
@hannibalburgers477 Жыл бұрын
Praetorians be like: yea, but what IF...
@viniciusdomenighi6439
@viniciusdomenighi6439 Жыл бұрын
He didn't.
@Diogenes_43
@Diogenes_43 Жыл бұрын
⚔️ Restitutor ☀️ Orbis ⚔️
@JonBrownSherman
@JonBrownSherman Жыл бұрын
We should be nervous just talking about possibility of him not saving everything. He may come back just to teach us proper respect...
@TetsuShima
@TetsuShima Жыл бұрын
Aurelian: *Spares the Life of Zenobia after defeating her* Romans: "Why did you let her live?" Aurelian: "You see, I think it was necessary to do it in order to end all this spiral of violence that has devastated the Empire for the last decades. Rome was built, not only with blood, but with wisdom and morality too, even though it seems that the whole world only remembers the blood. As long as there exists only violence, there will only be chaos and lack of control everywhere. Perhaps sparing my enemy's life won't change anything, but what right would I have to call myself emperor if I only thought with my fist and not with my mind? Did Augustus, Marcus Aurelius and many others become gods just with their thirst for blood? I may have started my career as a very bellicose person, but these last few years have completely changed my life. And if I can change, then everybody can change..." Romans: "You just did it to bang her, right?" Aurelian: "Yep"
@theeccentrictripper3863
@theeccentrictripper3863 Жыл бұрын
Art
@gabrielalejandrodoldan4722
@gabrielalejandrodoldan4722 Жыл бұрын
Copiado y pegado Pero es arte
@snifey7694
@snifey7694 Жыл бұрын
Amazing
@alessadroc
@alessadroc Жыл бұрын
LOL I was expecting after that massive explanation to be something like “Palmyra declared independence again”
@matthewe3813
@matthewe3813 Жыл бұрын
@@gabrielalejandrodoldan4722 Quid est? Tuum Latinum sonat valde fractus
@dshock85
@dshock85 Жыл бұрын
I want to imagine a world where Aurelian lived for 20 years and adopted a capable successor and we had another 5 good emperors period.
@danielchequer5842
@danielchequer5842 Жыл бұрын
Probably christianity would be legalized way sooner. Sparing the occurrance of the prosecutions, which would have a deep effect on christianity's history, not only changing its development but preventing the negative view of the roman state during its later stage
@histguy101
@histguy101 Жыл бұрын
Well, the century from the 280s-370s was Rome's last golden age as a united empire. The geopolitical circumstances were so different in the 4th century, that I'm not sure even if you transported Trajan or Hadrian forward that they could've done any better.
@ryanjones998
@ryanjones998 Жыл бұрын
How does this guy not have a tv show of his own yet? I can binge watch his videos all day long. He’s got me so interested in history and encouraged me to read books I would’ve otherwise never picked up. Seriously great content being produced here.
@John_Fugazzi
@John_Fugazzi Жыл бұрын
I 'm generally very wary of alternative histories but you are a trustworthy source so the speculation was very interesting and thought provoking.
@laurencejenner1127
@laurencejenner1127 Жыл бұрын
Counterfactuals can get a bit silly (like what if the Romans had a machine gun at Cannae), but this was very fascinating & on point, leaving me hungry for more! Great work as always thanks Garrett.
@inspirednamehere6166
@inspirednamehere6166 Жыл бұрын
They tend to be very military focused too, which does not make a very convincing scenario when it ignores the cultural and social factors that contribute to an event. especially considering the fall of rome, which is more of an arbitrary point than anything else, deciding a counterfactual scenario based on military battles would ignore the language, religious, social changes that led the western roman empire to "fall"
@merrittanimation7721
@merrittanimation7721 Жыл бұрын
Really I think we should focus on more important things, like what if Caesar had an orange cream popsicle while at Pharsalus. I think that could have had far reaching consequences/s
@bluespy4050
@bluespy4050 Жыл бұрын
Could you imagine if they did tho lmao
@MisoElEven
@MisoElEven Жыл бұрын
@@inspirednamehere6166 Yeah as you say it didnt really "fall" in that single year..the people who lived on those lands didnt disappear and since their culture didnt really change that much either for a while, the changes probably felt a little bit more natural rather than abrupt like we "stupid humans from the future" often like to imagine
@histguy101
@histguy101 Жыл бұрын
@@inspirednamehere6166 Well, he's saying what if the Roman state was never reunited in the 270s. The empire was reunited through military action, and would've remained separate through military failure. And Roman history, especially in the 3rd and 4th century, is dominated by military action, the army, and the soldier emperors who commanded it.
@r0ky_M
@r0ky_M Жыл бұрын
Yeah like What if Terminator had his phased plasma rifle in 40 watt range..
@jdm9251
@jdm9251 Жыл бұрын
In 2000 years they might be asking what if America had collapsed in the 1860s
@SubTroppo
@SubTroppo Жыл бұрын
Or just, "What was America?"
@Dave_Sisson
@Dave_Sisson Жыл бұрын
Civilisation would have been restored from Canada, the Americans would then be ashamed of their grandparents mutiny against their rightful king 80 years earlier and Americans would have become proud subjects of Queen Victoria, just like Canadians, Australians, etc.
@Smile4theKillCam456
@Smile4theKillCam456 Жыл бұрын
@@Dave_Sisson Communist detected on American Soil. Lethal force engaged.
@jdm9251
@jdm9251 Жыл бұрын
@@Dave_Sisson that definitely would not have happened.
@pastorofmuppets9346
@pastorofmuppets9346 Жыл бұрын
Its unlikely theres gonna be life on the planet in 2k years let alone civilization
@rebralhunter6069
@rebralhunter6069 Жыл бұрын
Hey this guy is really good at making roman history videos. He should teach Roman history or something.
@chychywoohoo
@chychywoohoo Жыл бұрын
This is the most over done joke on KZbin good job
@Stupidityindex
@Stupidityindex Жыл бұрын
Hello, try around 936 AD for the 3 crisis we are taught?
@arsenalreign
@arsenalreign Жыл бұрын
He should maybe make KZbin videos on historic events
@hamslicemcdooogle8080
@hamslicemcdooogle8080 Жыл бұрын
@@chychywoohoo shhhh let them have fun. Being an ass is the most overdone thing on the internet so you’re not really one to speak here.
@origamiswami2275
@origamiswami2275 9 ай бұрын
Also he should make videos about other Roman stuff like Polanski and candles. Seriously though, I love toldinstone's content and am amazed at how many aspects of Roman history and culture he continues to find and explore. Thanks, Mr (Dr?) Ryan, for sharing your knowledge and talents and for the many hours of content.
@jtgd
@jtgd Жыл бұрын
We’d have a different DLC for Total War
@MisoElEven
@MisoElEven Жыл бұрын
Dont give CA such stupid ideas :D
@wadeguidry6675
@wadeguidry6675 Жыл бұрын
What if Nero's' fiddle was an electric guitar?
@basilbrush9075
@basilbrush9075 Жыл бұрын
Whoah Nero, that last song was *fire*!!!
@perceivedvelocity9914
@perceivedvelocity9914 Жыл бұрын
A Roman emperor shredding as the eternal city burned is pretty metal
@MarcusAgrippa390
@MarcusAgrippa390 Жыл бұрын
Nero should have been playing "Voodoo Child" by Jimmy Hendrix while tripping on some "Purple Haze" with his head right next to the amplifier while shredding on his custom Gibson SG painted in Imperial Purple and slamming the Wawa pedal. But nooooo.... He played the Lyre... SMH...
@andrewgillespie8537
@andrewgillespie8537 Жыл бұрын
"Let me stand next to your fire"
@quantumfoam539
@quantumfoam539 Жыл бұрын
No Constantine, no Constantinople, probably no Christianity, no Western Christian barbarian Kingdoms, no Eastern Byzantine Empire. So basically another universe.
@DieLuftwaffel
@DieLuftwaffel Жыл бұрын
Christianity was already a rising religion. Without Rome its spread would not necessarily have halted, but maybe only slowed.
@rockstar450
@rockstar450 Жыл бұрын
​@DieLuftwaffel this is true, but Constantine begun making it the structure society revolved around as it empowered the average person, not just the elite. This was critical during these turbulent times. We'll never understand the fear and hopelessness these people did. True genocide
@holechek
@holechek Жыл бұрын
Didn’t the Byzantine call themselves Romans?
@oldsnake1551
@oldsnake1551 Жыл бұрын
They did. So did everyone else then. Muhammad himself refers to them as the Romans in the Quran.
@TheMaster4534
@TheMaster4534 Жыл бұрын
Christianity would stilll be around, except Arianism would get off the ground instead of Nicene.
@denizalgazi
@denizalgazi Жыл бұрын
"Nobody has to learn French" LOL Garrett!
@sebastianbarros8916
@sebastianbarros8916 Жыл бұрын
awesome video! i hope there's a few more what ifs down the line
@behrensf84
@behrensf84 Жыл бұрын
Like Mike Duncan said, if you measure emperors by their best season rather than best overall rule, then Aurelian was the best of the best…
@SobekLOTFC
@SobekLOTFC Жыл бұрын
Fantastic job, per usual, Garrett 👏
@claytonreid8262
@claytonreid8262 Жыл бұрын
Excited to see this!
@dmdrosselmeyer
@dmdrosselmeyer Жыл бұрын
I love everything you do and not only is your content of the highest quality, but you inspire me to finish my degree in the humanities (philosophy, ikr? lol) for nothing more than my own fulfillment. Anyone can tell you love your subject matter; I'm sincerely grateful you share these videos with us🙏
@juanelorriaga2840
@juanelorriaga2840 Жыл бұрын
I love “what if” history what a great vid
@llo0okii2994
@llo0okii2994 Жыл бұрын
Excellent content.
@QuantumHistorian
@QuantumHistorian Жыл бұрын
Only touched on at the end, but the big long term consequence IMHO would have been vis-a-vis christainity. Without the long distance travel and philosophically (/theologically) inclined aristocracy that a solid Roman empire supported, I struggle to see a foreign religion sweeping across Europe as it did. Even the much smaller change of not having a Constantine (only a tiny part of Rome falling in 268) would have changed Christian history so much. Considering just how much the Church impacted both cultural life and high-level politics for the next 1500 years, removing that would have drastic consequences on the rest of history. Encore plus que si personne parler francais
@Toverneger
@Toverneger 9 ай бұрын
I'm a history student writing my thesis on the iconography on Postumus' coinage. If there's one thing that I learned during this project, it's that the 3rd century was like the year 2020: it started out okay and only got worse due to poor choices. By the time capable management arrived, it was already too late.
@Planemeld
@Planemeld Жыл бұрын
By far one of my top favorite channels. And I mean I really only have a handful of them.
@janerkenbrack3373
@janerkenbrack3373 Жыл бұрын
What if Spartacus had a Piper Cub?
@lipingrahman6648
@lipingrahman6648 Жыл бұрын
How the empire fell is just as important as to why.
@robbabcock_
@robbabcock_ Жыл бұрын
A fascinating "what-if" indeed!
@diannewheatleygiliotti8513
@diannewheatleygiliotti8513 2 күн бұрын
Thanks!
@toldinstone
@toldinstone 2 күн бұрын
Appreciated as always!
@miguelcorpus2279
@miguelcorpus2279 Жыл бұрын
The Crisis of the third century had many different inflection points where it appeared history might swing wildly from one end to the other, however I think we place too much importance on any one man's ability to influence it. The changing demographics of Europe (including the growing Christian religion) were leading to the same result.
@jkelsey555
@jkelsey555 Жыл бұрын
Wow too harsh on Gallienus at the beginning there. Reformed the army and held things together as best he could, was well on his way to reconquering the west but was constantly betrayed. Fought on the frontlines with his men and took wounds. Lasted 15 years as emperor during a disaster that alone is impressive
@aaronmillersoutdooradventures
@aaronmillersoutdooradventures Жыл бұрын
Just bought your book! I love it!
@UraniumChef
@UraniumChef Жыл бұрын
Gallienus got that supreme drip
@JustinCage56
@JustinCage56 Жыл бұрын
Interestingly enough, the rank and file of the military didn't like him initially because he was seen as a pretty boy who worried more about reading and other nerdy stuff.
@string-bag
@string-bag Жыл бұрын
Very interesting video. Thank you.
@sashiniranjannair922
@sashiniranjannair922 Жыл бұрын
Love the video!
@i_eatappI3
@i_eatappI3 Жыл бұрын
Love your work doctor, wish you did some Japanese history because that is my true love, but anything Roman or Greek I have in my head it's cool to see that you have already done a video on.Really great channel just subscribed.
@brendancullinan7126
@brendancullinan7126 Жыл бұрын
Aurelian to the rescue. One of the true badasses of Roman history.
@christopherevans2445
@christopherevans2445 Жыл бұрын
Gallienus is so underated
@TheHylianBatman
@TheHylianBatman Жыл бұрын
A very interesting alternate history! The kind that I like.
@Posttraumaticgrowth
@Posttraumaticgrowth Жыл бұрын
Thank you😍
@LucyKosaki
@LucyKosaki Жыл бұрын
I don't know if you already made a video about that, but I would be interested in how someone from the outside, let's say from what would be considered a third world country at that time, could become a roman. I know they took war prisoners, slaves from conquered areas, but what if a nation or an individual wants to become a Rome by themselves because of all the luxury they have there? Was there a process for that? If yes, what were the requirements? Learning roman language? Are there any examples of let's say asian romans or black skinned romans?
@MisoElEven
@MisoElEven Жыл бұрын
Depends on the time period.. at the beginning at least your father had to be a roman citizen and later around 212ad (or something like that :D) an emperor (sorry, I forgot which one :D) granted citizenship to every free man so at that point as long as you werent a slave and you lived within the Roman Empire you were a citizen.. Asian Romans, very unlikely... black sinned romans also quite unlikely - people of importance from Africa were also usually white, often descendants of other "important" people who came in years-centuries ago as already Roman citizens or even Greeks back then
@brollyhessianovskov-ph1jc
@brollyhessianovskov-ph1jc Жыл бұрын
Hey dog, what's the tabs to that Roman song in the first bit
@basilbrush9075
@basilbrush9075 Жыл бұрын
Ask Nero
@ImminentAl
@ImminentAl Жыл бұрын
All well and historically researched but I was hoping for Manichaeism becomes the primary religion of Europe or possibly Parthian space programme
@t.robinson4774
@t.robinson4774 Жыл бұрын
Just Subscribed to both of your other channels. At first I did think Scenic Routes To The Past was Secret Routes To The Past from your pronunciation BTW. Just saying.
@madderhat5852
@madderhat5852 Жыл бұрын
Well, if you fall over, dust yourself off and believe in yourself . 'cue the music and singing animals'
@RemusKingOfRome
@RemusKingOfRome Жыл бұрын
What if the Roman Republic fell in 396 BCE ?
@russell2910
@russell2910 Жыл бұрын
Honestly, I think it was so long ago that no one would care. 😢
@sinothreebody4252
@sinothreebody4252 Жыл бұрын
If no Latinized French, then no English, shaped by Norman Conquer, today
@paulkoza8652
@paulkoza8652 Жыл бұрын
What if, what if, what if. This is the macro perspective. However, from the micro perspective, we can all relate to this. I often think about my past. What if I had made decision 2 instead of decision 1. How would my life have been different? It reminds me of the scene in "The Wizard of Oz" where Dorothy confronts the scarecrow and has to make up her mind on which path to follow. Think about it. I do often.
@rickclark7508
@rickclark7508 Жыл бұрын
Is it just me or did the question in the video title not get answered?
@francisjo3
@francisjo3 Жыл бұрын
Singing in the rain!
@slimkhalifadogg
@slimkhalifadogg Жыл бұрын
5:25 only good ending
@binalith4898
@binalith4898 Жыл бұрын
putting in my vote for long form. anyone second?
@DrakeMonroe
@DrakeMonroe Жыл бұрын
@toldinstone Dear Garrett, have you heard it said that Octavian was Landed Gentry in Rome?
@astrotog7265
@astrotog7265 Жыл бұрын
Russell Miller did a good job with this video.
@HVLLOWS1999
@HVLLOWS1999 Жыл бұрын
RESTITVTOR ORBIS INVICTVS Invincible/ Unconquerable Restorer of the World. The epithet given to AVRELIANVS by the senate after he saved the empire’s ass. Well deserved.
@vigolivenca
@vigolivenca Жыл бұрын
Hello, great video, Here are a few questions related to it that I would love that you could dig into in a later video. Did the former Romans in Germania and Britannia just run south with the fall of the empire? and that is why there are little to none Mediterranean faces and languages among the current population. It looks like that did not happen in Hispania and south of France. Are the Visigoths that controlled Hispania after the fall of the empire related to the later nobility and royal families? Why are the romance languages closer to themselves than to Latin itself? Is it a sign that what was spoken in the empire was not exactly Latin? Was the Middle Ages' former Roman Empire more connected than expected?
@RomanOf2002
@RomanOf2002 Жыл бұрын
This is so important for Latin Europe… there would be none outside Italian peninsula it Rome fell 2 centuries earlier.
@keizan5132
@keizan5132 Жыл бұрын
Rome was falling for years but the real fall of the ancient mediterranean world ocurred in the year 380 AD.
@EricK-ff2ff
@EricK-ff2ff Жыл бұрын
OKAY so big question i just thought of. how did roman people eat? not what they ate but how did they eat there meals?, like was it chinese style were food was put on the table and every one shared the dish? or was it individual plates and bowls? like in america?
@untrueman
@untrueman Жыл бұрын
they would recline on the floor and eat off a plate on the floor
@reeyees50
@reeyees50 Жыл бұрын
Tables but also what the other guy said. Today, in many parts of the world (example, central asia). People eat on the floor, without chairs and with almost no utensils, but still use plates and vases
@EricK-ff2ff
@EricK-ff2ff Жыл бұрын
@Myth yah I know how they sat. But how did they eat? So indivual prepared plates? Or a center food and every one just took some.
@primesonic4459
@primesonic4459 Жыл бұрын
All Hail the Sun God
@markcannon8522
@markcannon8522 Жыл бұрын
You like helegabulus 🤮
@joelavalo
@joelavalo 2 ай бұрын
Rome fell in 68 AD
@nathanscarlett4772
@nathanscarlett4772 Жыл бұрын
A small patch work of german-speaking non-Christian states...man that would have been sweet. I wonder if paganism would have remained Polytheistic?
@Rorschach120
@Rorschach120 Жыл бұрын
Please read the audiobook yourself. Thank you for all you do.
@TetsuShima
@TetsuShima Жыл бұрын
4:28 Speaking of Zenobia, the Steven Saylor's novel "Dominus" gives a really interesting background to the Roman senator who married her. In said novel, the senator, whose name is Gnaeus Pinarius, is a man who became miserable after losing his wife and son in the Gallienus plague. However, his life seems to make sense again when he falls in love at first sight with Zenobia during her entry into Rome as a prisoner. Unable to forget about her, he manages to convince Aurelian to let him marry her. However, the matrimonial experience with the queen ends up being really disappointing and distressing, since the woman shows him little affection and barely agrees to make love with him, always with great reluctance, making him feel enormously powerless, since he doesn't dare to force her for fear that she would poison him. Then, his soul is completely destroyed when he finds Zenobia having a torrid and passionate lesbian encounter with his own sister. Feeling the most unfortunate man in the world, Pinarius watches his whole world and dignity crashing down, until an apparition of the God Antinous (Hadrian's lover) makes him find his way and also gives his life a 180 degree turn. Instantly going from being a pitiful Simp to King of the Chads, Pinarius confronts Zenobia, blackmailing her into not allowing her to sleep with his sister again if she didn't agree to make passionate love to him whenever she could until he impregnated her and gave birth to a son (instead of a daughter, as the Queen actually wanted), finally managing to arouse in her a certain interest in him. The most curious thing about Pinarius is that he lived past the age of 90, not dying until the Roman Empire was Christianized under Constantine
@Michael_the_Drunkard
@Michael_the_Drunkard Жыл бұрын
Lol
@Snp2024
@Snp2024 Жыл бұрын
Jesus Christ that's a actual twist
@markmartin2819
@markmartin2819 Жыл бұрын
holy shit
@TheChronoG
@TheChronoG Жыл бұрын
This story is horrifying. Not based at all
@Sp4mMe
@Sp4mMe Жыл бұрын
Eleven people liking an exemplary paragraph of "why alt.history is always cringe fanfiction"?! What the heck ...
@rickb3078
@rickb3078 Жыл бұрын
Where is the photo at 8:32?
@mononoklegymen8947
@mononoklegymen8947 Жыл бұрын
...and way more continental celtic residues, at least when compared to none...
@mileslong3904
@mileslong3904 Жыл бұрын
The dream of Rome is invincible.
@a.s2205
@a.s2205 Жыл бұрын
More content on persia
@MrGksarathy
@MrGksarathy Жыл бұрын
I think it would have been a good thing because first, any empire falling is good on its face, and second, because Christianity hadn't fully spread throughout the Roman Empire, we might have gotten a more religiously pluralistic society in Europe, which is better. EDIT: A lot of people dying is bad, but that would have been the case no mstter when it fell.
@TheMaster4534
@TheMaster4534 Жыл бұрын
Don't forget Arianism being evangelized to the barbarian tribes outside of the Empire.... the barbarian raids were excaberated by differences in Christian faith
@robyn051
@robyn051 Жыл бұрын
What if Rome fell in 286 BC?
@jamesr.jennings8296
@jamesr.jennings8296 Жыл бұрын
Rome didn't fall in 268, so your title is incorrect. I think that you meant to say "What if Rome had fallen in 268".
@33Donner77
@33Donner77 Жыл бұрын
The division of the Roman Empire may have resulted in a "more flexible and eduring commonwealth". (Maybe the U.S. today?)
@elviskoo548
@elviskoo548 Жыл бұрын
👍
@beejls
@beejls Жыл бұрын
This was fun. You didn't guesstimate anything which couldn't have actually happened.
@Jamarkus_Delvonte
@Jamarkus_Delvonte Жыл бұрын
Amazing We are watching history repeat itself.
@LTPottenger
@LTPottenger Жыл бұрын
We are watching traitors invite them in this time
@garedmorort
@garedmorort Жыл бұрын
We would be 200 years in the future…
@bhartley1024
@bhartley1024 Жыл бұрын
I've noticed you make some very slight pauses between words. Is that a purposeful narration style, or just the way you talk?
@reeyees50
@reeyees50 Жыл бұрын
Mah man probus
@SubTroppo
@SubTroppo Жыл бұрын
It is spooky fun, this. If Coventry had not been bombed by the Germans in 1940, I almost certainly would not be making this comment.
@basilbrush9075
@basilbrush9075 Жыл бұрын
That's true. If the Human League hadn't written Dare I probably wouldn't be writing this comment right now
@SubTroppo
@SubTroppo Жыл бұрын
@@basilbrush9075 I recall a girl who during the 'new romantics' craze who got an eye infection because of her hair-style. Your existence is perhaps due to a chance meeting in the waiting room of a doctor's surgery?
@tylerhaigler7409
@tylerhaigler7409 Жыл бұрын
This was just a history lesson
@stevejohnson3357
@stevejohnson3357 Жыл бұрын
I think Christianity would have survived in a more diverse Europe. Over time, religions rise and declined based on how people think. Once people started thinking in terms of 1 creation 1 God there were serveral religions in contentions but beliefs based on local spirits were due to decline.
@shaundavenport621
@shaundavenport621 Жыл бұрын
Love that.Nobody has to learn French!!😅Nor should they!!😅😅
@Diogenes_43
@Diogenes_43 Жыл бұрын
Europa would still be pagan.🥲
@666supersir
@666supersir Жыл бұрын
...had fallen...
@basilbrush9075
@basilbrush9075 Жыл бұрын
...had did fellened...
@reeyees50
@reeyees50 Жыл бұрын
Fell upon
@TetsuShima
@TetsuShima Жыл бұрын
To think history would have drastically changed forever if Aurelian just said: "Meh. Palmyrian women are not my type. Let the Empire be ruled by other loser..."
@khalidalali186
@khalidalali186 Жыл бұрын
Lol 😆
@Michael_the_Drunkard
@Michael_the_Drunkard Жыл бұрын
8:29 non-Christian? Unlikely, Christianity was already on the rise before Constantine. A 200 year earlier collapse of the Roman West would have forced Diocletian and other emperors to accept Christians in the armies of the still stable eastern provinces due to manpower shortage. In the late crisis, the Edict of Gallienus was valid, giving this new faith the liberty to spread far outside the empire.
@theeccentrictripper3863
@theeccentrictripper3863 Жыл бұрын
Without a transmission system like a centralized empire Christianity would have a much harder time rising to the same critical level of prominence necessary to achieve total cultural hegemony like in OTL. It would probably still exist but be much more heavily concentrated in Greece, Anatolia, and the Levant and would most certainly not enjoy the reputation of universal truth without significant dispute.
@Michael_the_Drunkard
@Michael_the_Drunkard Жыл бұрын
​​​​​​@@theeccentrictripper3863 It's not like there weren't Christians in the Roman West (Italy, Gaul, Spain etc.) who would have had contact with the Eastern Christians on theological issues (there were councils, called synods, before Nicaea and the bishoprics that made up the Church). While the road systems of the empire helped the spread, the conversion of the Slavs in the 9th century showed that that wasn't necessary, all they needed is relative unity and no persecutions. The Christians had successfully defended their claim to universal truth to their pagan opponents (their debates with pagans are attested) and were about to compile the canon by the late 3rd and early 4th century. Most heresies by them were just technicalities. They were rising in number, while Greco-Roman polytheism was decentralized and devolving into mistery cults. Some were led towards hellenistic philosophies (among them Marcus Aurelius), Aurelian founded the Sol Invictus cult to rival the monotheism of the Christians. This proves, that Christians were not reliant on Constantine's victory over Maxentius, who himself promised them privileges. Plus the Edict of Serdica, which was issued by Galerius, guaranteed them all necessary liberties. All that hasn't happened by 268 but these developments were set in motion by the period of peace thanks to the Edict of Gallienus (259). So I do agree, that Christianity would have been diffused slower but certainly not stopped.
@Navak_
@Navak_ Жыл бұрын
In this modern age we like to pretend violence doesn't solve anything, especially political violence. In the words of Justin Trudeau, "If you kill your enemies, they win." Justin Trudeau definitely said that. Yet look at Aurelian. Do you think he was soft? He knew war his whole life. He was no stranger to political violence, having won a civil war that he arguably started. And yet if only he had been just a bit more ruthless, just a bit more paranoid even, then he could have purged the Praetorian Guard and avoided his own assassination. If only he used a little more political violence, like Augustus did with his proscriptions, then maybe Rome could have had a lasting renaissance. I know we say violence is not the solution. History, however, seems to think it is.
@JustinianG
@JustinianG Жыл бұрын
Wanna do a collaboration?
@joaomramalho1
@joaomramalho1 Жыл бұрын
When can historians stop calling Iberia simply Spain? Really bothers Portuguese people and it’s incorrect. Call it Iberia or Hispania....
@HeliodromusScorpio
@HeliodromusScorpio Жыл бұрын
Dont worry he is not a historian
@Michael_the_Drunkard
@Michael_the_Drunkard Жыл бұрын
Spain is derived from Hispania. Roman Portugal was Lusitania. But the term Iberia was used first by the ancient Greeks and later as a less common name by the Romans, so I agree with you there.
@theeccentrictripper3863
@theeccentrictripper3863 Жыл бұрын
Take a chunk out of Spain then we can talk, until then videos for plebs will almost certainly default to Spain to denote the rough geographical region as easily as possible as to move on without data-overload. Personally I agree, Hispania works and is more accurate (Iberia less so though cuz Caucasus Iberians intensifies), but getting bothered by it is just silly. Edit: Fixed a typo
@joaomramalho1
@joaomramalho1 Жыл бұрын
@@theeccentrictripper3863 Sure let’s just start calling Gaul France to simplify and annoy the plebs... 😂
@Mortyr45
@Mortyr45 Жыл бұрын
I agree. One thing in spain other is Lusitania, better call hispania. Its more accurate . And plz Stop saying that Portugal is spain. We dont says that USA its UK.
@cerberus6654
@cerberus6654 Жыл бұрын
Dr. G! I have watched your posts for all these long years not for 'what if?' but for 'what was!'. Stray not from what made you great, or Nemesis will turn her stony gaze upon you and all your works. PS - all the toldinstone merch finally arrived, though those disposable Roman sponge toilet wipe things, well, not the quality I was expecting. And those sponges, Jeez, rough...
@basilbrush9075
@basilbrush9075 Жыл бұрын
Use Sphagnum moss instead.
@cerberus6654
@cerberus6654 Жыл бұрын
@@basilbrush9075 That does not grow up here. I just use smooth stones, like the Greeks.
@grumbogee1772
@grumbogee1772 Жыл бұрын
can you do a what if Rome discovered aliens and were given incredibly advanced alien technology?
@jameshaines789
@jameshaines789 Жыл бұрын
True Christianity doesn’t rely on the empires around it, True Christianity lives in the shadows were the light shines allowing full clarity of an individual’s actions… It always has, It always will be, Now, and forever.
@Faustobellissimo
@Faustobellissimo Жыл бұрын
But Rome did fall in the 3rd century! Constantine is not Rome anymore, it can be considered a kind of Roman renaissance, but it was fundamentally different, christianized, authoritarian and empoverished in the Western half.
@sidneygray51
@sidneygray51 Жыл бұрын
Rome fell in 1848 when schools started teaching national languages instead of Latin.
@alibuhlaiqa8384
@alibuhlaiqa8384 Жыл бұрын
Is this written by Chatgpt?😂
@FirsteMann1929
@FirsteMann1929 Жыл бұрын
Sounds like the U.S today. As they say history repeats
@jtgd
@jtgd Жыл бұрын
It doesn’t repeat. It rhymes. We don’t see presidents and vice presidents taking generalship or VP’s being declared president while their former superior has to face them with a rival army. The US is MUCH more stable than Rome ever was. If anything, the US resembles the Late republic before Caesar’s conquest and after the social war You seem to make numerous takes based solely on your opinion, rather than points you can actually defend and prove
@FirsteMann1929
@FirsteMann1929 Жыл бұрын
@@jtgd Really? How about starting with 200 Trillion in unfunded unpayable liabilities and the decline of the U.S dollar since 1913 with the debasement of the currency which will get worse now that the yuan will also be used to purchase oil. And all melting pot of culture which is being accelerated through illegal immigration for starters. Sure, real stable with all the bank failures over the years as well Facts not opinion
@theeccentrictripper3863
@theeccentrictripper3863 Жыл бұрын
@@jtgd This right here, in glowing lights with sparklers and river-dancing.
@oleeb
@oleeb Жыл бұрын
Great content, but your wooden, monotone delivery is nearly unbearable.
@garlicbreathandfarts
@garlicbreathandfarts Жыл бұрын
You live in The USA and I live in Albania, yet you explain a lot of my history. Thanks for that!
@pisse3000
@pisse3000 Жыл бұрын
"Nobody has to learn french." *The* *good* *ending.*
@fkboyStalin
@fkboyStalin 7 ай бұрын
"nobody has to learn French" 14 year old me would have loved this timeline, French class was a real bread.
@ogrejd
@ogrejd Жыл бұрын
"The empire seemed to be on the brink of ruin - and we might imagine a few scenarios that could have brought about its effective collapse two centuries early." The city of Rome, perhaps, but certainly not the Roman Empire - that would be eleven and a half centuries early. :)
@keizan5132
@keizan5132 Жыл бұрын
​@@jindrichsedlacek7704Good to see someone that understands this.
The Treasures of the Byzantine Emperors - where are they now?
12:11
Education in Ancient Greece and Rome
15:20
toldinstone
Рет қаралды 147 М.
Bike Vs Tricycle Fast Challenge
00:43
Russo
Рет қаралды 95 МЛН
когда не обедаешь в школе // EVA mash
00:57
EVA mash
Рет қаралды 2,5 МЛН
Man Mocks Wife's Exercise Routine, Faces Embarrassment at Work #shorts
00:32
Fabiosa Best Lifehacks
Рет қаралды 4,2 МЛН
Incredible: Teacher builds airplane to teach kids behavior! #shorts
00:32
Fabiosa Stories
Рет қаралды 8 МЛН
What was Rome like after Alaric's Sack in 410 AD?
11:57
toldinstone
Рет қаралды 162 М.
The Life Expectancy of a Roman Emperor
10:18
toldinstone
Рет қаралды 111 М.
Augustus and the Altar of Peace
14:26
toldinstone
Рет қаралды 133 М.
235 AD: The Collapse of Four Great Empires
10:41
toldinstone
Рет қаралды 206 М.
King Arthur: What Everybody Gets Wrong
34:04
Cambrian Chronicles
Рет қаралды 959 М.
Bars and Restaurants in Ancient Rome
9:03
toldinstone
Рет қаралды 75 М.
What Did Ancient Rome Smell Like?
12:35
toldinstone
Рет қаралды 110 М.
Why the Roman and Greek Gods were Different
8:34
toldinstone
Рет қаралды 80 М.
The Roman Cults that Rivaled Christianity
8:10
toldinstone
Рет қаралды 122 М.
Was Caligula Insane?
12:05
toldinstone
Рет қаралды 210 М.
Bike Vs Tricycle Fast Challenge
00:43
Russo
Рет қаралды 95 МЛН