Top 10 Most Memorable Conversations In The Red Dead Redemption Series

arthurs hat amzn.to/2ZPTUX8
Red Dead Redemption II Pin Set amzn.to/2H0Z2k0
Arthur Morgan Cowboy Hat Baseball Cap amzn.to/2DLDdTv
Arthur Morgan Genuine Leather Jacket Coat amzn.to/2VEXSmk
boah mug amzn.to/2PIrBW1
Thanks For Watching!
Hope You Enjoy!
==================================================================================================================
Sub: / @hotopgaming
Also You Can Support me On Patreon
/ hotopgaming

[@rushputin8672]

the most memorable moment in the game was Arthur: Hey there Someone: Hello Arthur: Alright well I’ll catch you later then

[@legion3356]

I felt that😔✋

[@reeceschrock396]

That gave me chills.

[@ratguy7800]

So wise😔

[@lanius3653]

How you boys doin Boah: all this trouble you caused, i should turn you in! Boahther Moahrghan: i think you got the wrong feller

[@FuraFaolox]

Or John: Sir! Someone: You better run before I blow your brains out. John: Calm down.

[@ivancena100]

The best sentence in the game is when Arthur says "Alright, I'll catch you later then"

[@jasminecharlotta4230]

thank goodness we hear it all the time throughout the game 😂

[@Hero_Of_Old]

Socially awkward Arthur

[@navidhaliwal3331]

Anyways I won't disturb ya

[@pedrorodrigues1956]

Well, let's talk more later

[@BigBoy-ok3eg]

Alright i should be on my way

[@larsbruinenberg767]

Dutch: “Don’t bring the law on us they’ll hang us all!” Also Dutch: *Fights the US army*

[@thorsal6208]

Also dutch: kills Cornwall in Annesburg

[@larsbruinenberg767]

@@thorsal6208 Yeah but the overall Cornwall situation wasn't really Dutch's fault. Sure he robbed his train but later on Arthur (or John) steal one of his oil wagons to rob another train. That's how the Pinkertons found the gang in the Heartlands. Him killing Cornwall wouldn't have been a necesserily bad idea since that would stop the main cash income for the Pinkertons, but he shouldn't have caused such a commotion around it.

[@edwardblack4674]

@@thorsal6208 Also leaves Arthur to get killed

[@patriot17764th]

Exactly

[@DavidMyrmidon]

Yeah, that was definitely a "Jesus fucking Christ.." moment. 🤦‍♀️

[@aerond7881]

Arthur in 1899 : "Our time has pretty much passed" Dutch in 1911 : "Our time has passed, John"

[@supaidaman2477]

Arthur: pretty much done* ;)

[@patriot17764th]

Truth

[@brokebankfishin4839]

Well we see who John listened too

[@faridagasiyev7042]

@@supaidaman2477 passed*

[@aguyonyoutube4sure]

Gravity

[@adamoo1386]

Idk why but the moment they decided not to smoke near dynamite crates was just funny af for me

[@MacenW]

I noticed that too. They stopped, took a look at it, then turned to light it

[@spotty4849]

Where was this? Nvr mind

[@LazzyVamples]

It's a reference, actually, to one of the most popular random encounters in the first RDR. Sometimes you could encounter two men unloading crates of dynamite from a wagon and if you stick around and watch, they'll take a break, light up a pair of cigs and then blow up. so when I saw this scene you're referring to, oh my god, I could not stop laughing.

[@wolfmannn2008]

Sausscery the other guy did not have TB. Does not make sense since both stop smoking.

[@robertrocha9512]

Trikki for 2020 they just stopped smoking all together 😂

[@royalewithcheese5639]

Arthur morgan: The best video game character ever created

[@COOLPEAK]

No one come and shit on this comment cause it’s true he’s the best Arthur Morgan is the best

[@brandonbautista9308]

@Honsh he must be a really good villain then

[@rolandngom5080]

Umm he definitely isn’t

[@shopekuax2067]

roland ngom No he really is one of the best. The “best character” title is a really subjective thing to say, there’s no objective standards to take into account. But the fact that thousands say that this character made them depressed, sad, happy or whatever really says something about the writing of this character and the game, after all, art is art when it makes you feel something. Not every game makes you feel like your character is or was a real person; this one does...

[@fallout7769]

What about me? I think I might be second

[@KramYEET]

6:43 That look between Arthur and John when they realize what they’re lighting their cigarettes next to is hilarious

[@davebob2884]

Played this game through 4 times and never noticed that hahahah

[@ghostf378]

@@davebob2884 same

[@maximilianklein9045]

One of my favorite scenes tbh, no matter how often I see it, I always have to laugh because of the instant reaction while they're talking. Crazy that almost no one mentions that scene

[@julidee_]

RIGHT

[@young_reezzyy]

Arthur’s reaction though 🤣💀

[@jonathanarmstrong1540]

Sadie’s line at 5:56 is so much better when you have honor. “Aside from my Jake, you’re the best man I’ve known”

[@BrainMeltGaming]

I ship them so hard, sad that Arthur had to pass

[@THETRUENEOCHAOS]

@@BrainMeltGaming *N O*

[@OverLorD768]

@@BrainMeltGaming we don't do that here.

[@Batcena]

@@BrainMeltGaming You fucked up so bad senator armstrong came in

[@danone_original]

@@BrainMeltGaming just because they work together and they are opposite sex doesn't mean you gotta "ship'em"

[@sxhv]

Arthur: I insist John: i implore you

[@king-ps3cy]

*OH YEAH YEAH!* **Trashes Head around constantly**

[@bottomgear3686]

Oh yeah yeah

[@davidpoa7775]

@@bottomgear3686 "YoU IMPLORE ME!? YOU IMPLORE ME!?? WELL, I IMPLORES YOU TOO LEAVE NOW!"

[@bottomgear3686]

Arthur Morgan shut up your dead oh yeah yeah

[@bottomgear3686]

Arthur Morgan he insists....

[@UnknownPerson-2004]

The "I'm afraid" line was incredible. Give Roger a Oscar

[@quarantinegamer8269]

he won best videogame voice actor

[@hs_deviant3759]

@@quarantinegamer8269 good!!

[@Onishiro]

I prefer the high honor one with Swanson. It was nice to see the reverend with his wits and determination again, telling Arthur that he should fight on and continue doing what's right.

[@THNF89]

@@Onishiro this is the one I got first. Honestly they're both incredible scenes

[@Rainstorm93]

Bro, that one line, how he said it coupled with his facial expression just got me tearing up

[@Abe4RL]

Most memorable conversation: John: hey Abigail Abigail: *disgusted face*

[@emily6288]

Hahaha

[@user-lm6qm1pi1u]

So true

[@snooppp8873]

Abigail: *bitch slaps john*

[@GTA-RDRverse2.0]

John: hello Abigail: *P A T H E T I C*

[@danthecrazy100]

I remember thinking after watching the first trailer for RDR2 “there’s no way they could make a character that is anywhere near as remarkable as John Marston” and now I think Arthur Morgan is one of the most well written characters in Video Game History

[@ufgbkgchehshid8115]

@bevjoejoe it wasn't about redemption it was about loyalty about what matters to trevor his story was one of loyalty and freinds and betrayal not to mention trevor would have never had redemption but arthur hes bad but he ain't trevor

[@obi-wank-enobi]

Still like John more but Arthur is definitely a 5* character

[@pucerino27]

I was hoping rdr2 to be a sequel instead of a prequel as i really liked jack's grown up design and wanted to fuck up those assholes who killed John, So when i saw this random Arthur dude i had not even heard about to be the playable character i was so butthurt i decided to just wait a week after the game came out and let the story get spoiled to me, Needless to say i regret it as i think Arthur is the best protagonist of any game i ever played, Sorry not sorry John.

[@chohasheroep385]

he is the goat

[@jackrobinson3833]

No…. Easily the best written video game character ever, and one of the best written and portrayed characters in fiction.

[@Yukiyak0]

Arthur: dont thank me Archie: thank you Mr. Morgan Arthur: *Did I Stutter*

[@soundwavesuperior28]

I don’t think you used that meme format right ngl

[@Yukiyak0]

Soundwave The Christian how

[@Libreom]

man that shit hit different. Arthur literally can't think of anything else to do but give them money and even then thinks it's not enough. and begs them not to forgive him. he has no self pity in the face of death. he wants no pity, because he thinks that all this is his reckoning. but I believe if you could regain your spot in heaven Arthur did it.

[@rushpan93]

@@Libreom Redemption. I made a screenshot of the Social Club post that gets auto-added as you complete various chapters. After the end, it said "Rushav (me) found redemption in Red Dead Redemption 2" . In a way, all of us who played it, did.

[@pollo4070]

*Quick draws*

[@bigsauce7099]

No one: Milton: who are you? John: rIp VaN wInkLe.

[@gangrenousgandalf2102]

John-Jimrip Van Winklmilston

[@r011ing_thunder6]

That part cracked me up idk why lol

[@ritalrital1808]

Good day sir

[@DondonII]

*H u H*

[@nathanhuelett9829]

@@r011ing_thunder6 Bc he’s dumb plus he shoulda listened to Arthur but then red dead 1 wouldn’t have happened 😂😂

[@justintimbersaw3934]

4:35 this is the moment my hate for Dutch went sky high. When they were talk of hanging Micah at Strawberry, he sent Arthur to rescue that rat but when they were talking of hanging John, this is how he responds.

[@Bananaaddict]

I got bad vibes from him when I first played the game.

[@zachcolgan2064]

I will say Dutch had the guidance of Hosea in chapter 2 with Micah. Didn’t have that with John and that’s when he went off the rails. Didn’t have hosea keeping him grounded

[@DarkMachine2501]

@@zachcolgan2064 Losing Hosea was the big blow for Dutch. He started going truly mad from that moment because he didn’t really want to escape, he wanted vengeance. On the Pinkertons, on the police, on the US government. To paraphrase another great game; he hoped that hatred would someday replace the pain, but it never goes away. It makes a man hideous, inside and out. At the end, I think he himself realised that.

[@Lu-bc3pl]

that is notable but don’t forget that dutch decided to have arthur go take lenny for a night at the saloon before rescuing him. dutch thought that if there was just talk of hanging, then leaving him for a night wouldn’t hurt

[@charlescalvin1186]

MABYE CAUSE WHERE JOHN IS IS A MAXIMUM SECURITY JAIL BUT MICHA IS IN A JAIL WITH BARLEY ANY SECURITY DUTCH AIN’T STUPID HE DOESN’T FIGHT PEOPLE HE CAN’T FIGHT

[@jangostras]

"I guess I...I'm afraid." The best line in the whole saga. The face of Arthur, his voice... What a masterpiece.

[@guilhermeosti9526]

This line crushes me everytime

[@michalrejdovjan7298]

"You're my brother" "OK I'll catch you later then"

[@bigamateur9055]

Then

[@michalrejdovjan7298]

@@bigamateur9055 thanks !

[@swamp2816]

@@michalrejdovjan7298.

[@teddybroosevelt6826]

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@naturesfrontier1745]

@ArneyX 😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@dalmallama4634]

I love how even Kieran brings out his gun. He was mistreated so badly yet still stood up for the gang. Wish he got more of a chance to be good.

[@sanawon404]

he died just as everyone was warming up to him :(

[@endoskel9262]

@@sanawon404 may he Rest In Peace

[@jordanashe7656]

I just came to comment this and it's the first comment I see.

[@bluepower1177]

Kieran was one of them. In the end I think they all knew that ❤️

[@chief5604]

I really wished that we have atleast 3 missions with him

[@Catmouflage]

"Take a gamble that love exists, and do a loving act" is one of the best and most memorable lines in general, not just from this game

[@bulufataulu4707]

💯💯💯💯

[@fuzzstergoat]

hit hard for sure

[@timesnewlogan2032]

I love how Arthur and Sadie basically became brother and sister by the end of it all. Only wish they had hugged at some point.

[@the_jingo]

Sweet home Alabama

[@young_reezzyy]

@@the_jingo 🤣😭💀

[@tyty-xm8fw]

@@the_jingo Have you never hugged your sibling?

[@fortniteballs57]

@@tyty-xm8fw they kinda could be lovers. They have chemistry.

[@kyloben8537]

@@fortniteballs57 kind of, but it's more chemistry of two best friends

[@alessias.3160]

Hosea - Arthar - Dutch - Arrrfur, maih boah - Micah - Black Lung, cowpoke - Milton - Mmmmisssstr Morghen -

[@alinasr7782]

Mary Lintion - Oh Orthor

[@EricCartman-hw6sj]

Micah-Cowboy

[@james0798]

*cowpoke*

[@therenx8385]

Mrs Grimshaw - Orthor

[@simjaa4688]

Leopold Strauss- Herr Morgen

[@dingusrevolver]

Red Dead 2. Starts with Arthur giving John shit for running off on his family. Ends with Arthur sacrificing himself so John can run off WITH his family.

[@robertlance5624]

Arthur was mad at John at beginning because Arthur was sleeping with Abigail before john comes back

[@dingusrevolver]

@@robertlance5624 ...that's not why at all. John had a wife and family, which Arthur LOST, and John was treating them like they were worthless. It's one of the main points of the game. He was fond of Abigail, but she wasn't the love of his life or anything. It was NOT jealousy over Abigail as much as disgust at his immaturity.

[@robertlance5624]

dingusrevolver it is prerty clear in Arthur journal they had an affair after john left.

[@dingusrevolver]

@@robertlance5624 So? Dutch says they all had her. You're missing literally the entire reason for paralleling John and Arthur. There's nothing to argue about whether I'm right or wrong. I'm just objectives right.

[@the_corvid97]

@@robertlance5624 If I remember correctly Arthur says he should have married Abigail himself, I don't remember anything about an affair. Arthur was possed because his own family had died, and John wasn't stepping up like he should have.

[@bamesjond2069]

The pain in Auther’s voice when Archie does say “thank you” hurts so much to hear. He truly did suffer from what he did to that family. The emotional toll was clearly what weighed on him the most.

[@mattikaghar1591]

Lol you sound British because of your typo "auther".

[@nercksrule]

He hates that it took wasting away from TB because he beat Archie's father to death for him to realize just how evil of a person he had become. If Arthur hadn't caught TB from Thomas Downes, he wouldn't have spared Edith and Archie a second glance whenever he was in Annesburg; he knows that, and he hates himself for it.

[@CryptidVania]

@@mattikaghar1591 as a British person I can say, that is no where near how we say Arthur. We just say “Ar-ther”. You sound like a 4 year old.

[@DieWorm]

"I know I ruined your life, I suffer for it everyday." 😭😭😭😭😭

[@RagnarokMic]

"He INSISTS upon it." Chills.

[@mikehulsman4735]

Something snappen inside him, outside him and in every single one of his bones.

[@brandon8045]

That scene really does expose Dutch as the true narcissist he was. John was always the living representation of what he hated- a person under his control who had bigger dreams of starting their own life, and was actually independent enough to do it. No wonder he left him and Arthur to die when they went against his own self-centred philosophy

[@faenatical_]

Loyalty was everything to him. With Micah pulling Dutch's strings, without knowing, he betrayed his family. And he doesn't figure that out until he sees Arthur dying in front of him. A victim of masterful manipulation. It's painful to watch.

[@rosewishes2232]

@@brandon8045 IMA CLAP IT UP FOR THAT EXPLANATION

[@johansegura2469]

@@brandon8045 You couldn't describe Dutch more perfectly

[@CrazySailor1637]

I love how they based Dutch’s “I have a plan” thing and personality on one little line in RDR. Terrific writing

[@aveteranplayer6403]

@Mike Hunt Now when you remember red dead, you always will remember Dutch's plan

[@NPCLIVESMATTER723]

Yeah that line from rdr 1 now makes much more sense.... Ingenious

[@jamesmcdaid1260]

Yeah it shows that Dutch wasn't as empathetic as people thought he was, he rehearsed all his big speeches the man just a charismatic orator. In the game you can find a prepared script of Dutch's first big speech with cues for pauses and certain words underlined for emphasis.

[@haloxxkiller]

@@jamesmcdaid1260 Wait fr? Where?

[@jamesmcdaid1260]

@@haloxxkiller It's at Horseshoe Overlook, there's a little dip on the left side of the camp with a broken wagon and barrels. There you can a piece of paper of Dutch's first speech.

[@basicbattles]

"When I'm gone, they'll just find another monster." Chills everytime

[@madkoont79]

That is a scary line

[@cmdrme3se3ks43]

8:20 this whole conversation is legendary. I feel like it's Arthur's lowest point of villainy and after this moment, he slowly but inevitably comes to realize how cold the world and the actions he commits actually are, culminating in him seeking redemption for his actions in the end.

[@arthurmorgan3619]

sees Archie glaring at him] Either you got a lazy eye or a lack of respect. Which is it, boy? I ain't got no lazy eye, nor respect for the likes of you. Well, maybe when your mother's finished mourning your father, I'll keep her in black on your behalf. You think on that, boy. Well, maybe you shall, sir, and maybe other events will transpire. [chuckles] You'd best stick to them book, 'cause mark my words on this: vengeance is an idiot's game.

[@arthurmorgan3619]

sees Archie glaring at him] Either you got a lazy eye or a lack of respect. Which is it, boy? Archie Downes : I ain't got no lazy eye, nor respect for the likes of you. Arthur Morgan : Well, maybe when your mother's finished mourning your father, I'll keep her in black on your behalf. You think on that, boy. Archie Downes : Well, maybe you shall, sir, and maybe other events will transpire. Arthur Morgan : [chuckles] You'd best stick to them book, 'cause mark my words on this: vengeance is an idiot's game.

[@falling-3186]

red, dead, redemption

[@history-jovian]

True

[@ultra-papasmurf]

I think it shows that the most true to cannon path arthur can follow is a low-honour run up into his faith in dutch begins to waver in chapters 4-5 and essentially a selflessness in chapter 6. It just doesnt feel right that the guy who helped micah massacre strawberry and beat a tuberculosis patient to death while still collecting from his family would be a honourful gentleman outside of it before his change of heart.

[@aheccinlemon6879]

“Hey there mister” “Oh do you happen to have the time there” “Ok I’ll catch you later then”

[@elisabeth6183]

I read this with Arthurs Voice in my head...

[@londonwatson7342]

"Hey there miss" ( simultaneously hits woman with horse) "What the hell is wrong with you?" "How about this weather?"

[@sirkyle5220]

“GET OUTTA THE DAMN WAY”

[@daydream_.1188]

Lol 888 likes

[@pietrorusticali4055]

In what times of video?

[@windowsdotexe4444]

Where is "i gave you all i had"

[@dantepalomino1653]

WindowsDOTexe and he just tossed it in the trash

[@ibarely187]

that would’ve been a major spoiler

[@samfenton4141]

@@ibarely187 did you watch the whole video? He shows 2 conversations from the last mission, the insists and you're my brother. Number 1 was where he reveals he has TB to the sister

[@ibarely187]

*[SPOILERS]*. I watched it but showing the scene where Arthur dies and how dutch leaves him especially with the conversation would piss so many people off

[@Penguin-Pulse]

WindowsDOTexe spoilers

[@r0esheen]

*Sadie, covered in blood & heavily breathing* Arthur: “you okay?”

[@madkoont79]

Guess I catch you later then “Okay Arthur”

[@chazzplayz9376]

In the last mission before the epilogue, when Abigail says “I always were a good thief” and then they go on the horse, the music starts playing and Arthur puts on his hat one last time, and then you ride, that hit hard

[@prodelite]

You missed one. The end where Arthur says. I tried, I really did. I gave you all I had dutch

[@Jhillert2XX6]

No its, i gave you all dutch i did

[@willknutsen7751]

"John made it, he's the only one. The rest of us? No. But I tried, in the end I did."

[@goxaviergo11]

Jackson Playz123 no, Arthur says “I gave you all I had”.

[@colincunningham4128]

@@Jhillert2XX6 Mandela effect

[@prodelite]

@@willknutsen7751 I forgot to add that part

[@thebestpig123gaming8]

You guys notice that when Arthur gets tb he talks like Hosea worrying about the children and Dutch’s sanity

[@chromehearttz-2283]

thebestpig123 Gaming I must’ve missed what Hosea was sick with, but supposedly he was dying too

[@DarkAngelNikita]

I never saw it in any of my playthroughs, but I watched a video in which Hosea and a few of the others are at the campfire and he confesses that he's dying. Never says what he's dying of, but he does cough a lot. There doesn't seem to be any blood, so I don't think it was TB.

[@j.r.2674]

Yeah there’s dialogue where Hosea is sitting, Arthur walks up to him and Hosea begins to cough (a lot).

[@DarkAngelNikita]

They know that this lifestyle of theirs is going to shit and just want to know that everybody is going to make it out alright before they go. It's sad that Hosea never got that satisfaction.

[@Kingbenford]

@@chromehearttz-2283 you dumb or something? It's so obviously Lumbago homeboy

[@ComradeBread]

"You lost my sick friend, you lost" "In the end Micah, despite my best efforts to the contrary, it turns out I've won"

[@youngshonshon]

Arthur helping out Mrs. Downes at the end is one of my favorite moments in the game. That’s a man that truly and deeply regrets what he did to them.

[@marknorwood7521]

Mrs Downes, Mrs Londenberry, Snow Goose. Arthur's realization of the BAD they had been doing and trying to make what ammends he could.

[@TheSquirter]

Does the “thank you” with Arthur’s horse count because it totally should

[@jooot_6850]

on god that was so sad

[@theyeetmeister4019]

I cried

[@Rakesssh]

I was really sad because I just bought that fucking horse. And it was really sad

[@blackmambo8702]

@@Samurai-Z same that was the only point of the story that made me tear up.

[@ceaselessdischarge1026]

That isn't a conversation

[@aheccinlemon6879]

6:45 when they realize it probably isn’t the best idea to light a cigarette

[@thibaultrivoal4131]

I laughed hard 😂

[@Raelarial]

“BOOM!” Lol jk

[@notakmsol8865]

Raelarial Skystriker what do you mean jk? it never happened in the real game, where’s your loyalty?

[@Lcrxss_]

Zapuboi where is your sense of humour?

[@notakmsol8865]

GamingGuitarist101 he said lol jk im telling him the boom never happened

[@salehbayram7046]

Also when Arthur met Trelawny for the last time at the camp, despite being a short conversation u can feel that it was the beginning of the end for the gang

[@PajamaPantsStudios]

I saw it as the beginning of the end when Sean died. I guess that was a bit early for some, but it just felt like there was no turning back from that for me.

[@BratMilorad]

@@PajamaPantsStudios that was pretty dark and a very sharp contrast to the overall happier and more lighthearted tone of the previous chapter. The gang camp up until that point almost felt like a safety bubble where everyone was alive and well, but after Sean's death, it starts feeling way less predictable and safe knowing that some of the people that Arthur's known for most of his life won't make it back there.

[@tannermurphy8230]

Honorable mention to John's conversation with Rains Fall at the Annesburg train station in the Epilogue. One of my personal favorites actually. It broke me knowing what Rains Fall had suffered through with the death of his son after Eagle Flies had been simply used as a pawn in one of Dutch's "plans" and his tribe being pushed north to Canada to seek refuge from the US government 😥

[@Synthwavu]

With dialogue like this, the writers can literally make a novel.

[@Saint_Wolf_]

They did it better by letting us live through it instead of having things be lived for us.

[@vlastoyz9502]

It's better than a novel. This is a full sense experience

[@kikosawa]

I believe some of then had made one probably

[@henryn5445]

I always say rdr2 is a book you want to read it a few times

[@user-wc4bm5qi9k]

I actually plan on making a graphic novel with the entire series If you want to check it out kzbin.info/www/bejne/b3WndmSsqdWfoqc

[@wuzbadnowded8612]

I like it when Lenny says “ There will be a party when you die” to Micah. It is also foreshadowing because John marries Abigail after that.

[@Dottol-]

No don't they get married before the final mission

[@ata6240]

@@Dottol- no John asks abigail if she wanna marry him before american venom But the party is after it

[@Dottol-]

@@ata6240 no they literally go for that boat ride and stuff and then Sadie shows up like next mission

[@AnakinS86]

@@Dottol- thats the proposal, not the marrige.

[@Dottol-]

@@AnakinS86 ahh right gotcha

[@Evan24_7]

The Way Sadie says “My Jakey” is so cute. “They turned me into a monster, Arthur. But my memories of him, they still pure.” 🥺

[@keenanhorne1539]

That “I’m afraid” line makes me tear up every time I hear it. Rodger Clark is so good at what he does.

[@unconventionalderp1544]

"Im afraid" Knowing death is coming his way but he only wanted enough time to make his life worth doing something for and making it right, i honestly find this as one of the most saddening parts.

[@fistingthecomp]

It may have been red and he may have been dead but he did get redemption

[@ZzonkedMCFC]

The preamble about his son just makes it hurt 10x more.

[@lil_biscuit]

Honestly it should’ve been Arthur before dying Idk what it is about the “I gave you I had dutch”

[@wiktorialyzwinska8039]

He gave me Hosea vibes I always thought that Hosea will die anyways during chapter 2 I saw him coughing and well you know. I never expected that he will die in such a 'painful' death. Arthur knew after he was diagnosed with TB that he will die so he tried to repair everything and tried to give some peoples and gang members a new chance by telling them to flee. And so Hosea did but in the other way he wanted to keep the folk safe before he will go but no Dutch's plan by robbing Cornwall's train ruined it

[@undeaddragon0977]

“No, I think I’ve pushed all I can” Him sayin that hit me like a bullet in the gut

[@lv.30boss65]

Clorax Bleach at the end, on top of the mountain before him and john split up

[@alex-ki6tw]

That’s what my ass says after holding it in for a 2 hour exam

[@sauce6746]

Lol stop bein a bitch

[@peter_buck7074]

19:37 That pause and then that delivery... I remember when I played that part in the game and it broke something inside. That's his honest feelings that he's had for a little while and he didn't know who to say it to and he may not believe in anything at that point in the story (no person or religion) but asked someone who had beliefs and hope and asked for help...

[@mixcypher9041]

Hearing Arthur, a hardened gunslinger who’s shown so much bravery and courage for the ones he holds close say “I’m afraid” is gut wrenching. He is by far the best character written in gaming history, at least to me.

[@jaredonion1041]

“I’m afraid” will be the quote I remember forever from this game, those words shook me so god damn hard, i instantly broke down.

[@frog8553]

Jared Onion word

[@oldsoul1384]

I liked it when Arthur told John to "get the hell outta here and be a goddamn man" it helped my tears stop 😂

[@flatwoodsdaemon]

“You’re my brother” had me BAWLING.

[@Winters95]

I agree, it showed much more of Arthur than expected. He is normally calm and collected. That is the only time I feel that he lost his composure, not due to rage, stress or even just aggravation. He in that moment was truly fearful. He knew his days were numbered so he made them count.

[@HalalMan99]

I gave u all I had

[@megailadan]

"Take a gamble that love exists, and do a loving act." What amazing words to end on.

[@caglnoah]

Roger Clark was incredible in this role. He really did a great job of making his words feel like actual off-the-cuff dialogue, not like pre-written lines.

[@SirDieALot666]

This whole game is an art masterpiece. Like those books or movies you wanna repeat over and over and you don't get tire of it, you just still enjoy it and feel like the first time.

[@sekoncen9559]

RDR2 moments that made me tear up or outright cry: -“I gave you all I had... I did.” -“I said don’t thank me.” -“I’m afraid.”

[@punkoykolokoy3318]

You forgot about "thank you" he said to his horse

[@yuzbasi1044]

@@punkoykolokoy3318 yeah that scene was something else

[@blankplayys9426]

All that ever mattered to me was loyalty

[@sekoncen9559]

@@blankplayys9426 “and to what, exactly? An idea that don’t work no more.”

[@blankplayys9426]

@@sekoncen9559 "Be loyal to what matters"

[@wakazzotsapa7107]

The high honor conversation with Sadie after she avenges her Jakey is wayy better than the one you showed us..

[@jessicak8651]

I agree!

[@charliemcguire5051]

I Agree!

[@Randomized_tv]

Didn't know there was a difference, do you have a link?

[@jacobramos6445]

I want that one but my Arthur is a bad man. I'm trying but...

[@punnily7743]

It's a one sentence difference my g

[@prathameshraut9413]

Joel : I'm the best character Arthur: out of the damn way

[@ranikarnan1960]

This comment is so underrated

[@imjustacake6535]

It breaks my heart seeing how skinny Arthur is at the end of the game.

[@arthurmorgan3619]

Maybe feed him

[@conviresco9514]

@@arthurmorgan3619 that doesn’t make his weight go up near the end once the tb gets worse.

[@arthurmorgan3619]

@@conviresco9514 I know he gets skinny but if you feed him more he gets bigger my Arthur got huge at the end

[@uncleb6391]

Best line Arthur says outta the damn way

[@eggistopia9013]

Rides away on horse

[@seandewall2563]

You mean "it's Arthur you dumbass"

[@SQUAREHEADSAM1912]

You mean when he calls him self mr.cornwall in guarma

[@Chandfam7]

Eggistopia move next time

[@misc4580]

you sir, are a fish

[@davionelliot]

“Vengeance is an idiots game” not so subtle foreshadowing

[@SquatLight55]

John killing Micah 😳

[@jamesw9873]

@@lelandmann5681 Are you sure you know what redemption actually means? Based on your comment I think you've confused 'avenge' with redemption. Revenge and redemption are two completely different things, and are not even remotely similar. You could argue John killing Micah was avenging Arthurs death, or getting revenge for Micah breaking up the gang. But the redemption in Arthurs story is him saving John, Jack and Abigail, and giving them a chance at life.

[@addisonsiburn6228]

At 2:26 Kieren has his gun out. I think it’s crazy that after all they’ve done to him he’s still so quick to defend them. They really gave him a new family and a second chance.

[@teodorpedersen1285]

I love the parallels between chpt 2 and 6, Micah was inprisoned and went through "talks of hanging", Dutch sent for his rescue, but when John was in the same perdicament he had a "goddamn plan". It truly amazes me how they created such a gradual, seamless and amazing arc for a character.

[@moniqueray2974]

Also the "thank you" quote when Arthur's horse died

[@grayson7677]

I cried everytime when he says that shit

[@badreedinedjellali1328]

"I give you everything I have"

[@markgreen3308]

My heart broke when Arthur's horse died

[@The_guy_who_asked]

May snowy the white Arabian rest in peace

[@LucifersAngel-mu4mw]

"And there's always a god DAMN train!" That line always makes me crack up. Seriously there are so many train robberies.

[@novastar7275]

Lol me too

[@averagesoenjoyer4150]

All you had to do,was follow the damn train Arthur!

[@smuggaming3730]

Its definitely some sort of reference to the train mission in San Andreas.

[@caronte1447]

In all rockstar games

[@MRtorch69]

but the worst train chaser is Carl

[@ThatSurvivorPony]

If Arthur was real, he’d be an American hero.

[@laum5371]

An American hero, as many others who were forgotten while trying to be good. Most people who do good re forgotten and ignored, but the villains like ducth are the ones remembered. Just check our own society, where we have channels developed around serial killers. In words on the sister, "life is full of pain, but love too" try to seek for the heroes, and help them.

[@ghostrunner3909]

@@laum5371 ye world loves idolizing killers and promoting them on shows movie even books and games

[@madkoont79]

He would of been known as an outlaw no matter what. There was a Australian legend that Is alot like Arthur he stole he killed he rob but gave to poor he was a outlaw but did good things some of us Australians see him as legend or a criminal

[@b0nkiesp0nkie8]

For me, it was in the mission when Sean gets shot, like who doesn't remember: "Wait a minute something ain't right" "Something ain't right? I could'a told ya-" *proceeds to get his head half blown off*

[@CatAtomic99]

"You're the feller who beat up Tommy, right? The whole town's still talkin' about that". "I ain't." "..."

[@umbrellaman8987]

and then tommy said something like "heiffhhjadkoakd" touching

[@ata6240]

Tommy Vercetti

[@thegamerno01]

@@ata6240 sadly no... :(

[@zSTALKn]

Dutch: I got it... a boat! **Some days later boat is in flames**

[@user-gv2rn4jx2g]

@Collin Caperton BECUASE DUTCH HAD A GODAMN PLAN HE JUST DIDN'T HAVE ANY FAITH

[@CoCoLightning]

@@user-gv2rn4jx2g AND LOYALTY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@firsttimeauthor2050]

Sandy knee.. 🤣🤣🤣

[@littleluisiscool]

John couldn’t swim

[@ericedling6829]

I love it when otherwise hard hearted characters show their vulnerability. “He was a good man, my Jakey.” Is a kick to the stomach every time.

[@amediocrealligator2431]

Arthur's facial expression when he's says "I'm afraid" is just so good you can see the pain in his eyes

[@HEARD201]

My favorite line in the whole game is the conversation with the old Native American man. "people don't change, they become more themselves." It's so true and I think an incredibly underrated moment in the game.

[@rushpan93]

Rains Falls

[@vikramdeveshkolla3437]

I love that mission with Rains Falls

[@The_guy_who_asked]

RAINS FALL HOW DARE YOU DISRESPECT RAINS FALL THE GREAT CHIEF

[@MultiRainday]

Arthur's Character development is really strong!

[@krainzyrumie6426]

man, this game is such a mindfuck, we hate Milton, even though, when it comes down to it, he is actually the good guy in this story.

[@NA-AN]

We hate him cuz he killed hosea and overall acts like pos, but yes, I do know what u mean.

[@Acuteapie]

@@NA-AN we also hate him because we have grown connections to anti heroes sure they're bad people to others but we see the humane stuff that Arthur and John do throughout RDR2s story so we grow attached to the characters and eventually hate the people that affect the characters in negative ways

[@hoshistarfish4992]

Perspectives sir, Perspectives

[@coryhardwick7308]

In terms of the law yes. But he also does unquestionably evil things such as holding Abigail hostage and potentially torturing Mac Callander before he died. He was doing his job but to me he’s as morally questionable as almost anyone in the gang.

[@nokachi3339]

@@coryhardwick7308 i think him and ross are ruthless in their pursuit of "bad" men.

[@BasicShapes]

Arthur: How much you cost, anyway? Prostitute: That's no way to speak to a lady! Arthur: Oh, I didn't know I was _speaking_ to a _lady!_

[@zzFlare]

Arthur gay question mark

[@infernostormy2985]

@@zzFlare Arthur cool?

[@sahirdamani1264]

Arthur never simps

[@emiliojavier8268]

@@austindrinksfanta man chill out, it was just a joke...

[@austindrinksfanta]

@@emiliojavier8268 perhaps I overreacted...😬 I was pretty tired when I wrote that

[@dbzayan]

Arthur to his horse, saying "Thank you."

[@Saint_Wolf_]

Rest in piece, Gemini

[@ozdal3434]

but its hardly a memorable conversation..more like a memorable quote

[@fnzer0]

Buell... you were a good, feisty boah. We can go hunting with Hamish later.

[@holy_crusader5153]

yo #RIPEGG he was my homie

[@PVAPlayy]

RIP Horse-on Wells 😔 … you’re galloping with the angels now.

[@00skill]

The face that Arthur does when he says that he's afraid always broke my heart...

[@namehere903]

“It’s man so in love with greed, he has forgotten himself and found only appetites” he ends up as one of them

[@tallstar513]

"Arthur.." "Go." "Arthur!" "Get the hell outta here and be a goddamn man!" "You're my brother." "I know.. I know..." My heart melts every time I hear that.

[@lexiplays1252]

Rip van wrinkle

[@markfnl2005]

kinda wish more was said but

[@youngchrisbaby9009]

Kinda wish John would have put a fat hole in Micahs forehead for what he did to Arthur. Would have been better in my opinion.

[@tallstar513]

@@youngchrisbaby9009 He does. I believe up to 6 in fact.

[@joedemelfie5509]

I will use tacitus Kilgore as my fake name alter ego from now on.

[@leonecartelremastered3020]

Man that 1st scene with Milton, even Kieran pulled out his gun to defend Dutch. Damn !

[@solodolo8291]

Its crazy they would all die for him but Dutch doesnt want the gang to live their lives out as they truly want to...

[@oglordcoolfan4206]

Leone Cartel Remastered Kieran was a good boah, but nobody but Arthur and Mary-Beth saw it, so they were the only one that cared about him

[@malaizze]

*I want a DLC where we get to give Kieran a hug* (before chapter four, of course)

[@oglordcoolfan4206]

teacup salamander sounds gay but I like

[@malaizze]

@@oglordcoolfan4206, you misunderstand. It is *entirely gay.*

[@ChocolatePiazza]

I like the dialog in the fishing mission with Arthur, Dutch and Hosea. it is really sad because it is pretty much the last time the three of them actually had fun together before stuff started going to shit.

[@RalphGiezer]

I gotta hand it to agent Milton for having some form of meta knowledge to understand that Dutch to an extent is manipulating people who are at their lowest to create his own occult like group

[@IvaArtemiev]

It is Milton’s job to deal with people like Dutch, he wasn’t fooled by his egocentric illusion of grandeur

[@Marios-io9qg]

That moment when Dutch repeats '' John'' and' '' insist '' only for Arthur to stand his ground, made him realize that he is not going to be able to manipulate him anymore. He's free to make his own mind and I think at that point Dutch knew he lost control of the gang

[@zalandkhan4043]

Dutch wasn’t manipulating the gang until Chapter 6 that’s because of Micah and also he hit his head in chapter 4 when he, Arthur, and Lenny went to rob the place which neonate told them to

[@ohnoimatrap856]

@@zalandkhan4043 He was manipulating since colter. There are subtle signs of it, but after guarma he stopped hiding it.

[@henryofskalitz4879]

@@ohnoimatrap856 I agree, if you really pay attention to the character you can see he was always subtly manipulating these people. It's just that early on he had a good mind for hiding it, but be also had this air of almost "robin hood" about him. Y'know that of the people for the people. Obviously this was just a cover but..well yeah

[@hemlo_it_me6874]

@@henryofskalitz4879 to be fair that’s technically what every leader does. That manipulate you in some form or fashion, especially in a situation like a gang like this. And as you said, early on I believe Dutch at least believed he was doing everything for the greater good.

[@CreamToast]

@@zalandkhan4043 I actually remember a quick dialogue in chapter one when, you’re in the mountains, and dutch says something along the lines of “good. I… We need you strong.” Which basically showed that he WAS manipulating from the beginning just wayy better at hiding it. I think the incident you referred to, where he hit his head, most likely made him more irrational and obvious.

[@aidansilvia2663]

“You ever heard of eternity?” “I hope it’s hot and terrible, Ms Downes”

[@MrBillybilly28]

Otherwise ill feel ive been sold a false bill of goods

[@shaunwarz1910]

Billy Gardner now please. Give me that money

[@shipmancinema]

I like how during the I insist conversation as Dutch says “nobody is going to die” he is cut off by a small cough from Arthur

[@chinchy5545]

"It's man so in love with greed he has forgotten himself and found only appetites." I love how well this foreshadows Dutch's whole arc

[@WarmRepeat]

Memorable Quotes: "John has a Family" "Dutch has a Plan" "Arthur has Tuberculosis" *UNCLE HAS LUMBAGO*

[@jessmakesmusic]

Dutch... IS a plan?

[@Mintberry_Crunch03]

Unlucky Valentine it’s very serious

[@manguitofruit8335]

Hahahahaha

[@walkingstickman1]

Dutch: *HAVE A LITTLE FAITH*

[@azetenth]

Don't forget "All the best now."

[@bu5tedb3cky6]

"you're my brother" and "i'm afraid" really got me. I cried like a baby during these games and i'll love them forever.

[@rosewishes2232]

sameeeeeeeeee ;(((

[@ranikarnan1960]

Thank you Arthur to his horse.

[@jackrobinson3833]

I think John and Arthurs friendship needed more development

[@henriquebarguini3608]

@@ranikarnan1960 Damn dude that hit so hard

[@romella_karmey]

@@jackrobinson3833 I think they need a bromance

[@terryqokov6999]

I'm so happy Sadie & Charles got a happy ending. By the end of Arthur's part of the story, those two plus John felt like the saving grace of the gang. I wish those four had more missions together. By the time I got to the epilogue, I was so happy Charles & Sadie were in it so much.

[@coolaman5]

2:02 This and the walk to the Braithwaite manor was one of the most legendary gang moments in the entirety of RDR2 imo Such a badass way of raising the tension to the roof, on god

[@vornamenachname2858]

Sister Caldèron is the most wholesome character in this game, not because she's a nun or whatever but because she is genuienely intelligent. She knows what's right and tells Arthur to do a loving act. I really like her, she's very well written

[@matthewhood6889]

You can kill her in rdr1

[@x3pt.0]

@@matthewhood6889 :(

[@jimmymurphy898]

Totally agree. Such a great character. Her missions and cutscenes were some of my favorite parts of the game.

[@cm-nk4li]

@@matthewhood6889 lmao nun go brr

[@mirror1001]

Damn I missed that part on my first time, I got the swanson one, I’m on the second play-through so I’mma try to get her convo

[@megaFAUCET]

The fishing trip with Arthur, Hosea, and Dutch was memorable for me because it was literally the last pleasant time that the original three ever had

[@Pro_Butcher_Amateur_Human]

Moments like that also really helped establish the strong relationship between the three men, and explains why Hosea and Arthur stay loyal for so long even when Dutch starts going crazy. Explains why they tried to justify it for so long, and refused to see it for what it was. Most games would cut that sort of scene out, and it's absence would make me not believe the relationship betwern the three being strong enough to withstand Dutch's failing mental health for so long.

[@unconventionalderp1544]

Then micah came in and threw it back into the choas they were so happily running from

[@pondaction9506]

6:25 Where’s “I wish things were different, but it weren’t us who changed”

[@indycole396]

He played low honor...

[@pondaction9506]

@@indycole396 didn’t show that part of the cutscene though

[@catalinbostan3542]

I love Micah's worrisome expression,really gives reasoning to his betrayal. If Pinkertons could walk in your camp,it's not too far from them shooting it.

[@dyessman9022]

My personal favorite is when you save Sean. "Nothing means more to me than this gang, the bonds we share. I'd kill for it rob for it, heck I'd happily die for it. Despite all that, I would've left you here to rot if Charles didn't stop me." Or something like that.

[@cloudthekell]

The Gamer Version C-137 mine is “As long as we get paid or you get shot, I’m happy”

[@dyessman9022]

@@cloudthekell I love that one

[@obsidiankrystal3308]

@@cloudthekell Mine is Boy: Thank you mister morgan. Arthur: I said don't thank me.

[@dyessman9022]

248 likes holy cow. Thanks

[@javierescuella2960]

I personally liked, "There He Is." Good quote to say to your friends if you want to live like Arthur.

[@Alexalmo]

"So, is RDR an imitation of GTA but in the past?" "No, GTA is an imitation of RDR but in the future"

[@jeevan3832]

more like the present

[@Legacy-vi6cv]

Imo they are 2 different games gta will never hit as hard as rdr rdr is the only game that makes me wanna help people because u can die any second

[@Juicyzigga]

@@Legacy-vi6cv right I played gta then rdr2 when I compared the story’s ( not in terms of the era or time) gta is basically garbage compared rdr2 in terms of story imo

[@Legacy-vi6cv]

@@Juicyzigga true

[@scottrjmatmsncom]

I got to say GTA don't have anything on RDR

[@chief5604]

These are the conversations I liked from best to worst of rdr (2) 1. "Run and don't look back" -Arthur 1899 2. "Dutch, we did our best for you!" -Arthur 1899 and John 1907 3. "Go to your family, John" -Arthur 1899 4. "Will you marry me?, Abigail?" -John 1907 5. "We can't always fight nature, John. We can't fight change, we can't fight gravity, we can't fight anything." (Rdr) -Dutch 1911 6. "You can't always fight nature, you can't fight change, you can't fight gravity, we can't fight anything." (Rdr2) -Dutch 1899 7. "You will die SAVAGELY!" -Agent MoRoN 1899 8. "Who made you the messiah to these lost souls you've led so horribly astray" Agent MoRoN 1899 9. "We're more ghosts than people" -Arthur 1899 10. "I HAD A GODDAMN PLAN!" -Dutch 1899 11. "We rob Uncle Sam, then we leave...... the poetry of it all...... what do you think?" -Dutch 1899 12. "When your mother is done mourning your father, I'll keep her on black on your behalf, you think on that boh" -Arthur 1899 Some honorable conversations 1. "Sons of Dutch, which makes us brothers...... and brothers makes mistakes" -Micah 1899 2. "We don't need to kill any of ya, any more of ya" -Dutch 1899 3. "I'm a change man, Arthur...." -Reverend 1899 4. "Why can't we all just get along??!! They're good men, Arthur they're children of god, they're children of god....." -Reverend 1899 5. "I'm dying, sister. I got TB, I got it....." -Arthur 1899 6. "Don't thank me, leave" -Arthur 1899 But the best one is...... *"L U M B A G O"*

[@briang11]

Arthur: I’m afraid Everyone: sad pogger face

[@FuzzyMF]

It Always breaks my heart hearing Arthur admit to being afraid to die.

[@Phoebe-ev1ok]

I think he's afraid residually because of his father...and that he acts in anger to protect himself. The scene is a true confession

[@joshuatraffanstedt2695]

Everyone is. Because secretly we all either know this is the only form of consciousness we get or they're afraid they're going to burn in a mythical place like hell. Life is beautiful, despite of and because of its flaws, heartache, and misery. If it werent for the flaws, heartache, and misery, happiness, love, and the Joys of being a human free on this earth wouldnt really matter as much, would it? Wed have nothing to look forward to accept for dying. I think rockstar did a fine job of capturing that truth. We all go face to face with our own mortality at some point.. some sooner than others.

[@joshuatraffanstedt2695]

We all share the same exact fate.

[@arthurmorgan4087]

Arthur: hello officer Officer: howdy Arthur: I used to fancy being a police officer Officer: really Arthur: but then I grew up

[@wortwortwort1686]

John says that not Arthur lol

[@scarletthecat632]

Arthur Morgan John said that and it's "I used to fancy being a lawmen"

[@Kanyeforpresident-hd5ms]

Limited ᛞᚢᛗ I think Arthur Morgan would know who said it 😐

[@noblenormie1179]

Arthur Morgan interesting profile picture you got there ARTHUR

[@astonished-scout]

Adolf Morgan

[@flemmingmatiasvermeulen9608]

0:25 I like how Milton explicitly singles out Arthur just to make sure everyone knows they met before, in case Arthur hadn't mentioned it or was considering taking the deal.

[@rhysobrien2439]

Arthur saying that he's afraid gets me every time. In 2020 I suffered two strokes and had an aneurism. The night before the brain surgery to remove it was absolutely harrowing and terrifying. Facing death like that does change you and the way you see things. In a heartbeat it turns everything upside down and makes you question every decision you ever made, it brings priorities and values into question to say the least.

[@slapa.shlong3510]

The fact that dialogue is so meaningful in this series just justifies that this is the best gaming series of all time