Top 5 Worst Decisions in Shadow of the Erdtree

[@SamBram]

I completed a whole new playthrough of Elden Ring to make this video, sourcing new footage and researching different branching paths for quests. I'd like to again thank Gamer Supps, as their drinks were great pick-me-ups for my longer gaming sessions, especially when grinding some of the tougher bosses. If you're interested, they do a good free sample pack and I also really like their melon flavour: gamersupps.gg/sambram

[@LawfulBased]

I summoned one player who had a tanky build just like me. We used blood build poky poky attacks too and won after playing it careful. Thollier survived the whole ordeal. Sadly that does not change the outcome of his questline as usual. FromSoft has this hard one for tragedy.

[@bakedawake]

😮9 7:06

[@LatinaSatsuki]

Clown

[@Buzztheshowhost]

Can you please make more cyberpunk mystery videos?

[@mattsilvaarmwrestling]

That's why I have several builds in the chamber

[@adawg3032]

Needle Knight Leda for better or worse is absolutely correct about everything. She was right that ansbach would want to turn on Miquella in the name of his lord, and she was correct that hornsent would never ever truly accept an age under marika’s kin. I always side with my man and the absolute gigachad ansbach but I give it to Leda she was able to read everyone’s hand the moment the charm ended.

[@morenoalv3105]

With only one exception though, being Thiollier. She assumed that since he's loyal to St. Trina, he wouldn't go against Miquella as St. Trina's other half only to find out that her last wish was for Miquella to die and stop his ascension to godhood

[@sportybaby797]

I sidevwith both for loot…..it’s a game ya know

[@THWOMPSHOTS]

she was also a paranoid zealot though so even if nobody turned on miquella you could argue she'd have these suspicions anyway

[@laylam.9314]

It ain't paranoia if they really out to get ya, I guess

[@todd5purlock497]

But she isn't right, you can change who is allied with her so she's just making 50/50 guesses

[@BuboStabbins]

Ansbach is real af. 100% bro's for life. "YOU"RE MY BOY BLUE!"

[@Skill_issue1984]

w referance

[@Mike-xp8zc]

So is igon. He acknowledged us as a fellow drake warrior. Something alot of people have pointed out, he hated Bayle so much he was never brainwashed by miquella like the other NPCs

[@BuboStabbins]

@@Mike-xp8zc You know.... you're right... Igon is a gigga chad too. Def in the club.

[@tylerpetersen6226]

Ansbach is the primary reason Mogh beat the allegations.

[@agxryt]

Anbach is a delusional feudal idiot. Mohg is a freak. Long live Miquella the Eternal!

[@KvapuJanjalia]

I went into DLC blindly (to avoid any spoilers) and, as a result, locked myself out of ALL new quests. All of them.

[@jegx1098]

Same, now I gotta speed run and start over in NG5

[@hannahloumen2241]

Sounds like a you Problem 😂

[@aestheticleviathan7028]

Pov you boss rushed because your impatient and are now blaming the game

[@superdoodzz]

classic fromsoft needing to backflip 7 times in front of a church at dawn before beating the second boss or else you cant do an npc quest

[@fiachra4623]

I just started last week and already beat Dancing Lion and Rellana, have I already locked myself out of some quests?

[@PhillipRubio578]

For anyone that made the mistake of hitting the forager brood but didn't kill them you can give celestial dew to the turtle in the church of vows to get them to be friendly again

[@Alex-uu8ic]

you mean the dog?

[@callmecreamy391]

Unless you killed the turtle 😅

[@daftpanda6533]

@@callmecreamy391 What monster would kill the turtle pope?!?!

[@PhillipRubio578]

@@callmecreamy391 You're a legend

[@fuckinantipope5511]

​@@callmecreamy391 everyone who kills the turtle pope should simply be completely banned from ever ppaying this game. How could you commit such a crime???

[@dovodremus5642]

I got legit chills. Become a Lord not for gods but for men goes so fking hard

[@SamBram]

Definitely one of the best lines in the game. Also the way Ansbach's voice transforms to a surrounding echo as he says it is very cool

[@daveh3581]

Goin into a boss fight with 2 buddies makes it infinitely harder but damn when you all work together and beat them down it's F-in beautiful dude!

[@ixiahj]

Big rule in souls games. If you can't lock on to it, do not attack it.

[@Monsterstrike7]

except those ghostly fuckers in the misty forest and path to Drangleic castle in DS2.

[@asuraphreak]

*attacked everything that moved* What?

[@deathandrebirth-y8x]

but they have kewl armour. its mine.

[@yourdad5799]

​@@Monsterstrike7 they become visible after obtaining the eye of the priestes in the ice DLC

[@yabarber9285]

I have sinned

[@FaeQueenCory]

Leda was charmed the same as everyone. Ansbach was charmed because he tried to kill Miquella. Hornsent was charmed as a foothold to redeeming the hornsent. Freya was charmed as a foothold to Radahn's army. Moore was charmed as a show of civilizing the Kindred for coexistence. Thollier was charmed because he was a simp for Saint Trina, to save him from eternal slumber. *Leda was charmed because she wouldn't stop killing people for insufficient faith to Miquella.* EDIT: I forgot Dryleaf!! He may be the only one who was never charmed. He doesn't talk... And his order is a group of monks who have endorsed the Heiligtree as successor to the Erdtree by choice... Dryleaf may be the only actually legit follower of Miquella.

[@SageArtemisia]

I would have love to see at some point that fight between Miquella and Ansbach. This would have been when Miquella still had his body, how would he have fought? Did he just immediately charm him? Did they fight a little? Was Ansbach close at least? I may be wrong, but he is also Tarnished like us? In his incantation he has a "fearsome reputation" so I'd assume he would be really good in combat especially with his scythe. Ansbach is truly a bro.

[@syckray]

​@@SageArtemisia yes he was close, lady leda speaks about it. He almost slaughtered miquella

[@Mike-xp8zc]

Igor was never charmed, that's because he hated Bale so much!!

[@thesnatcher3616]

Ignore how all of them were still loyal to him even after the charm breaks except for Thioller and Ansbach.

[@pfsnoronha]

@@Mike-xp8zc Gigachad Igon, hate trumps love all day.

[@ghostdreamer7272]

Another secret is Moore has a path to survive to the end and finding happiness. Tell him you don’t know, and after you kill Leda he has learned to think for himself and be happy.

[@DSG0805]

Is the actually true? Do you mean kill leda in the gank fight first?

[@ghostdreamer7272]

@@DSG0805 Yes it's true. After you kill Leda in Enir Ilum. As long as you only told Moore "I Don't Know"

[@christianriddler5063]

Nah, I want his armour, I want his shield. Time for Moore to go to sleep.

[@DSG0805]

@@christianriddler5063 his armor is okay but it is too chunky looking imo. Too bad you cant slim it down

[@christianriddler5063]

@@DSG0805 The shield is the most amazing part really. It's probably the best heavy shield in the game, the damage negation and stamina protection is insanely good.

[@adawg3032]

The hornsent grandma lore goes DEEP. She may have been around during the time when marika arrived and she could have a part in Marikas ascension, possibly being a part of Marika going to the gate of divinity. It’s possible the hornsent grandma was given marika after she came out of a jar processing that succeeded

[@pizzaman11]

She also could be the witch mentor that Ranni mentioned who taught her frost magic. Granted I’m not sure where the frost stuff came in but given the divine beast uses frost, maybe the grandma used to be able to wield magic similar to the horsent knights.

[@JonathanFlexx]

@@pizzaman11 Ranni looks like her former mentor in the guise of the doll she's inhabiting. It's not her.

[@pizzaman11]

@@JonathanFlexx I’ve always somewhat questioned that because Ranni specifically calls her a “crone” which could be a translation issue but to me implies that she was an old woman. Also she has the eye tattoo thing and multiple arms which are traits only seen among empyreans. (Miquella and Melina) So maybe she’s just referring to the hat or maybe the snow crone was another empyrean.

[@mallowloaf]

in the most recent patch, the text for watchful spirit has been changed to say hornsent grandam, not empyrean grandam

[@zakomimi4185]

The newest patch changed her text of empyrean to just grandam

[@lharsay]

12:26 Parttaking in dragon communion was known eventually turn one into a monster from the base game.

[@LuisLopez-zh9kh]

The coolest shit ever.

[@victorpaixao7281]

Yep magma wyrms

[@SnailSnail-lo4pm]

​@@victorpaixao7281 also probably eleonora. She uses dragon incantations as well and went mad

[@beckstheimpatient4135]

So, regarding Ansbach 'cleaving open' Miquella, I don't believe it. Ansbach recounts it as barely being able to touch Miquella. I think Leda's fanaticism is making a mountain of a molehill, trying to vilify Ansbach. She is a fanatic and a murderer, and it makes sense she would project on Ansbach the bloodthirst she feels. Even though Ansbach is the one who served the Lord of Blood.

[@Stanzbey69]

Miquella’s model IS missing an arm though…

[@WanderingKrow]

@@Stanzbey69 Miquella discarded his left arm at one of the crosses

[@lexibeard4404]

I think there is a law piece on an item describing that miquella did get wounded a little from ansbach

[@blackeddeath]

​​​​​@@WanderingKrow He discarded both arms in the realm of shadow. His lack of only ONE arm in the fight is 100% the result of Ansbach's assault at Mohgwyn Dynasty Mausoleum. EDIT: The right arm is the "arm dextral" at Shadow Keep, FYI

[@blackeddeath]

Ansbach is a cool dude for sure, but whitewashing his character like this is actually insane

[@Nemo12417]

Keep in mind that both Ansbach and Thollier inflict statuses on Radahn (bleed and poison, respectively). I suspect that is why they in particular are your allies, since statuses tend to target maximum hitpoints.

[@Nemo12417]

Also, I was sad that I kept Ansbach alive throughout the fight and he still died afterwards. I was kinda hoping he'd be alive.

[@iboofer]

@@Nemo12417 "Righteous Tarnished.... That big redheaded mf blew out my back and now I'm going to the great blood bank in the sky. "

[@RenegadeStriker7]

​@@iboofer Fowl 😂

[@rwberger6]

Honestly Bael taking over you and regrowing himself from his essence within you reminds me of Fatalis from monster hunter. Armor and weapons made from him are supposed to still be alive and hunters who wear it for too long find themselves unable to remove it before being driven mad from voices in their head and going missing shortly before a new Fatalis appears.

[@Ankaris]

Fuck Hornsent Grandmam, even ENTERING Messmer's arena before finding the obscure red summon signs for Leda vs Hornsent locks you out of both the encounters between Leda and Hornsent AND Leda and Ansbach. I was so fucking pissed off when I learned that. I don't understand why it needs to be based on entering the arena rather than actually defeating Messmer. Or why they have to throw those summon signs off in a corner where they're easy to miss rather than in the middle of the path. Then there's also the fact that talking to Moore the wrong way upon first encounter can lock out his questline, which locks out part of Thiollier's questline, which locks off a potential ending for the Dragon Priestess' questline. Also if you give Ansbach the item when he's in the Storeroom BEFORE you talk to Freyja at the top then you're locked out of her questline because he disappears. Really, the NPC questlines in this DLC are a complicated web of obscure bullshit and some of the worst put together questlines FromSoft has ever done. I know it's like a cardinal sin to criticize these games for anything, but NPC quests are really some of the worst parts of these games and they seem to be getting worse with each iteration, not better.

[@thelopper43]

The npc quests have always been nonsensical. Just look at solaires quest from ds1. At this point i assume its an intentional feature of these games. Also, criticism is always allowed, granted that you have valid reasons for it, but people need to understand that others will always react negatively to criticism of things they love. Its not hate, its just human nature to be protective of things you love.

[@HiImMigz]

@ankaris Im glad somebody else has the same issue I encountered. I spoke to Ansbach before I was able to reach Freyja which loops her dialogue saying she’s busy. Ansbach is no longer at the bottom floor and I was searching endlessly for maybe 2 hours going through all the corners of the castle. It’s such a let down that these things happen with not just these two nps but with more questlines that give more impact to your dlc developement.

[@auronx]

I absolutely, unequivocally agree with you @Ankaris I fucked myself out of several questlines because I stumbled upon Shadowkeep by accident, having zero idea that this would lock me out of the questlines. It angers me because its an open world game that penalizes being open world; I care about the lore, so for this to happen was really disappointing.

[@ETBrooD]

@@thelopper43 If it's intentional, then it's intentionally bad. Miyazaki should be perfectly aware how many people strongly dislike his broken quest lines, and that includes lore tubers such as Wraff. Somehow he not only created more broken quests in the DLC, he found a way to make them worse...

[@ETBrooD]

I tried to get the Ansbach vs Freyja fight in my second playthrough and I did everything exactly as Fextralife described it. Guess what? The quest broke anyway, their summon signs didn't appear. Even Fextralife (including all the people commenting on that site to provide information) can't figure out Miyazaki's broken quest lines. The man really needs to get over himself and accept advice from professional quest designers because no one likes this mess he created.

[@DJYungHoxha]

4:00 For those who don't know, this description has been changed. "Emyprean Grandam" is officially no longer a thing, and seems to have been a mistranslation. Or rather, not a mistranslation, they straight up changed the Japanese from "神人の老婆" (Empyrean Grandam) [Literal: Divine Old Woman] to "角人の老婆" (Hornsent Grandam) [Literal: Horned Old Woman] Google Translate does translate "horned" as "horny" but... yeah I don't think that's what that means lol

[@mertgurcan2112]

I used to watch you obsessively when I played cyberpunk 2077 and I’m so glad you’re making shadow of the erdtree content now, and quite a unique spin on that!😊

[@NomadicDuude]

Same

[@shiroamakusa8075]

Summon Ansbach and Thiollier and then use bleed/frostbite/DestinedDeath/Blackflame to chip away at Radahn since those all do percentage based damage and are unaffected by his health boost.

[@lol101lol101lol10199]

The best reason to summon Ansbach or Tholier against Radahn is that it gets him off of you just long enough that you can summon Mimic Tear and heal up, instead of getting one-shot during the summoning as you sap your own health with the hp cost.

[@andreseh87]

Why would you summon mimic tear?

[@ledoubleagent96]

@@andreseh87why would you not use the game how it’s intended lmao

[@MarginalSC]

Just roll the spin then summon

[@GristlyRook9605]

Just roll first retard

[@samwizgamgie3rd828]

Can we agree that Sir Ansbach has the best quest maybe next to Thollier? A loyal servant to Lord Mohg, who we all thought was into his younger brother but another victim to Miquella's charms, seeking to once again honor his Lord.

[@JerichoDeath]

"Holyproof Pickled Liver might be extremely useful later" There's no reason to craft this. The Dried variant from the base game gives 10% more resistance to holy than the DLC version.

[@PatGunn]

Your sponsor's claims 5o boost brain power or eye health are scams. Avoid gamersupps

[@adawg3032]

It’s just caffeine powder and other natural stimulants in proportions that your heart shouldn’t be exposed to long term. Gamersupps is just 1 of a huge industry of heavily caffeinated supplements.

[@bradyhodges4784]

I bet you are fun at parties

[@alexharvey7660]

​@@bradyhodges4784 Making false claims that products can boost health is dangerous and unethical. It deserves to be called out.

[@sportybaby797]

Ads and sponsors need to go away along with all of KZbin and its community…All of them are bad

[@alexharvey7660]

​@@sportybaby797 "along with all of KZbin and its community" What makes you say that? Sure, a lot of youtube is toxic, but does that mean it should all go away?

[@Slitegoz]

My biggest gripe about this DLC is the fact that you can soft lock Freyja's quest by giving Sir Ansbach the scroll before meeting Freyja. The problem is you find Sir Ansbach and the scroll before meeting Freyja even if they are all in the same place: the first instinct is to deliver the scroll to Sir Ansbach as soon as you find it. Ideally, the best progression in the same area would have been meeting Sir Ansbach→Freyja →Scroll.

[@riotguards]

I killed the foriger not knowing it'd make him hostile so i got that locked out pretty early........

[@SharkJumper88]

When your only crime was venturing to near a certain keep...

[@Potato_Tomato-od2lz]

The only thing that going near the shadow keep locks you out of is thiollier concoction and thus the only thing you loose out on is the flortisaxxs dragon bold and her spirit ash

[@tiacool7978]

@Potato_Tomato-od2lz doesn't even lock you out of that, I got the concoction after going in the keep. Just don't beat Messmer and you'll probably be fine.

[@pugs4life241]

3:41 You actually won't miss out on this reward in particular no matter what you do, cause she drops it if you kill her.

[@Tofino888]

Can confirm. Ask me how I know.

[@pugs4life241]

@@Tofino888 You killed her cause she gave you the cold shoulder, didn't you?

[@Tangloa]

Can’t kill her after killing Mesmer…..

[@hellspawn22001]

In the Golden braid description the g in grandmother is capitalized like it’s a title. I wonder if “Grandmother” is more like “Grand Mother” maybe the head of the Hornsent society and that is who was betrayed and used as sacrifice for Marika to become a god. The Grand mother could have been the high priestess of the crucible because it became the Erdtree.

[@augustgurtisen]

Or it's just literally Marika's grandmother and thus a proper noun

[@hellspawn22001]

@@augustgurtisen then wouldn’t it say “her” not “the”

[@DSG0805]

@@augustgurtisen it isnt. It is a figurehead of the maternal society.

[@ultrabear1583]

It's a title used in matrilineality, especially one such as shaman village that has a belief and tradition of producing "maidens", the implication is that all of the maidens from this village are children of the Grandmother, and shaman village might be a little slice of the true Shaman origin or Numen belief, there might be other Grandmothers outside of the lands between and I won't be surprise to know that in the mythical background of the game there's a city of Numen who follows the same social structure.

[@Supernovice942]

“A braid of golden hair, cut loose. Queen Marika's offering to the Grandmother. Boosts holy damage negation by the utmost. What was her prayer? Her wish, her confession? There is no one left to answer, and Marika never returned home again.” Nothing about this item description implies she was a Hornsent, she was affiliated with the shaman village. The Hornsent tortured the shaman in the name of their twisted religion.

[@phthisis]

I don't play Elden Ring, but after watching some streamers, I'd say the "worst decision in SOTE" is fighting the last boss without a great shield. Chasethebro spent a good 5+ hours figuring out how to kill Radahn, but then he equipped a shield, and the encounter was done in two tries... Pretty hilarious that the best strategy for the final boss is to turtle with a pokey stick.

[@OTOxKRUGERxOTO]

Smh the same realization I had.. no wonder all these summons had freakin stone shields

[@vocaoanh2403]

It was so dirty and effective, it changed my playstyle forever. I might go for the Elden Bling while traveling the land between, but the moment I saw a fog gate, it's turtle time boi.

[@Sp1d3r_]

Can't blame him, I tried to beat Radahn on 125 lvl solo with no blessings and succeeded without shield but his bossfight's difficulty is so amplified by one exact attack, the double X-slash, which you apparently have to frame-perfect dodge on reaction while not early dodging other attacks, only reliable way I found to counter this attack was either blocking or sekiro-parriyng tear in my case

[@boogerspaz217]

​@@Sp1d3r_ I don't even think you can parry it, which in my experience is the second best way to beat the boss, that attack is awful, I guess just bring good damage negation

[@Sp1d3r_]

@@boogerspaz217 I think I managed to parry it when I tried golden parry tactic, but even then reaction window is very tight and it's easy to miss a parry on other attacks when you expect this one to come out. I also watched Ongbal's run and it seems backstep talisman is a pretty reliable tool to utilise, considering you can still dodge most other attacks if you accidentally backstep them beforehand

[@rexer5372]

just beat radahn whilst playing your video in the background god bless you it took me 4 days

[@Its.devonthelegend]

It touk me 4 days as well lol

[@oldschoolgamer5113]

I got the cookbook from moore after breaking the great rune. Not sure if they fixed it in patch. But after I told him stay sad for ever I talked to him again and he gave it to me, then I traveled to where he dies and got his armor.

[@ezeqpoeck]

buddy, the video started with a whole ass npc I'd never seen before. I really gotta follow a guide in my next playthrough lol

[@TheGerudan]

Summoning allies BEFORE you enter a boss arena always increases the bosses health. Summoning them INSIDE the boss arena (like Igon for Bayle, the Hornsent for Messmer and Thiollier for the Putri Knight) doesn't. Those really make the fights easier the "outside" NPCs arguably make them more difficult a lot of the time. The best tip I can give for the Radahn fight is to use a big shield and use a bleed weapons like Garius' sword lance. Killed him first try with that one. Also you can just tell Moore to be sad forever after you've got all the cookbooks and he will apparently kill himself, also giving you his equipment without having to fight him during the Leda fight later.

[@SetariM]

Fingerprint Shield and Bloody Helice.

[@parkersaunders5698]

@@SetariMthe antspur rapier is a really good option aswell since it can apply both bleed and rot!!

[@SH19922x]

You didn't kill him first try stop lyin bruh 💀

[@TheGerudan]

@@SH19922x It was my 2nd kill overall, but it was 1st try with that (my 2nd) character that I started completely from scratch after finishing the DLC with my old NG+1 character which I used to play through ER twice after it was released 2 years ago. So yeah, I beat him first try with the finger print shield and the Sword Lance with Seppuku on it. Radahn just doesn't have much attacks that go through your shield. You can also stack Holy resistance very far with the talisman mentioned in the video und the appropriate buff spell. And with the bleed build-up on the weapon he dies pretty quickly. And my first character was a mage and used spirit ashes etc. so I kinda knew the boss somewhat, but I didn't know all his moves by heart or anything.

[@NeoNaito]

I can't believe you left out Joe Lee from that list.

[@clearandsweet]

I can't believe there was all this NPC content that I never saw. I just played the game normally, didn't even realize anything about them being enchanted or having their own quest lines or anything at all.

[@HankShvader]

Shout out to Ansbach Man stuck with me the whole journey Love you Ansbach 🔥❤

[@LordShrub]

I'm happy I figured out that I should return to granny as soon as I obtained the Lion mask. It made so much sense because she wouldn't talk to me initially and was a sculpted keeper fangirl even having some Lion masks in her storage room.

[@AnthonyFleagle]

Bayles age- the age of dark (cue dark souls one menu music.)

[@Count.Saruman]

More like the Age of Tyranny, if he killed Placidusax. Bayle is referred to as 'Tyrant Drake', the hefty red lightning pot calls him 'Tyrant', and his signature incantation is Bayle's Tyranny.

[@lucianoroberti1734]

or maybe the age of dread?

[@eetfuk3571]

@@lucianoroberti1734 Age of CURSE!

[@bahamutkaiser]

Bayle can't surpass the Tarnished, they killed all the Empyreans and gods in Elden Ring. Bayle is fortunate to be assimilated.

[@notveryartificial4486]

I'd say that "one day it will burn its communion devourer" is more of a thought that Bayle himself has, and we can hear from his heart. Wishful thinking, so to speak :D

[@mercylavigne]

Bayle will take over, bro. Bayle is literally a god-slaying threat. He's on the level of beings like Marika. Doesn't matter if it takes a thousand years, HE WILL come back and consume your body and soul.

[@notveryartificial4486]

@@mercylavigne it'd arguable, he lost to Placidusax and had to run away, was damaged much more than him so he was weaker than Placidusax. Who's *definitely* a god-slaying threat is us by the end of the game

[@mercylavigne]

@@notveryartificial4486 Yes, weaker than Placidusax. But for everything we can gather from the Lore, Placidusax was stronger tran Marika/Radagon and evenly tied with the Elden Beast, knowing that Metyr is the strongest being in the Lands Between. But the thing is, powerscaling doesn't really matter in that regard. The lore of the heart literally tells you that he will take over you someday. You character will succumb to the rage and turn into a dragon, that's inevitable. It's something abstract, not something you can just fight against. It's actually VERY similar to the Scourge of the Beast in Bloodborne. Doesn't matter who you are, if you get infected, that's it. it's just a matter of time and how much you can "Endure", just like Midra. You will just turn into a even more powerful and evil dragon...And that's pretty rad, actually. Turning into the king of dragons and dominating an entire continent? Hell yeah.

[@notveryartificial4486]

@@mercylavigne again, we beat Placidusax, we beat Radagon, we beat Elden Beast - we're stronger than they all, and we'll only grow stronger. Bayle, however, is already dead, he won't be able to grow any stronger than he is. He was unlucky to have met us Also from what Florissax the Ancient Dragon says, we're on our way to become THE ACTUAL DRAGON. Not Bayle, not Placidusax - our very own and complete dragon form. We will be a new Dragon Lord, surpassing all dragon lords and contenders who came before us. Imo, it's much cooler

[@ironicdutchmoonshade]

You can access forager brood cookbook 6 before the shadow keep. You just need to start at Moorth Ruins, drop down to Bonny Village, and go around the cathedral and approach the Shadow Keep from the east.

[@spikescafe3940]

Damn, just killed one of the brood this morning. Nobody ever warned me to avoid killing them.

[@blakefenslerjr4858]

Try targeting before slaughter dude if it don't work then it's friendly or it doesn't attack you 🤦

[@spikescafe3940]

@@blakefenslerjr4858 True, but targeting doesn't work for certain mimic enemies like baby jars in the base game that eventually aggro. So it's not a clear sign of friendship.

[@xXLunatikxXlul]

@@spikescafe3940you’re correct, the game should give better indicators imo

[@GristlyRook9605]

@@spikescafe3940it’s stationary and will not attack you

[@pfsnoronha]

@@xXLunatikxXlul Oh please the guy is lying there in prostration. After I attacked it a few times and it did not hit back I knew it was wrong. Killed it anyway, but knew I was doing something wrong. But since I will play this DlC multiple times, I'll go for worst ending first, as always, aka BURN!

[@Nimno74]

I had no idea what a forager brood was when I heard that dialogue. So when I saw what I thought was a sleeping pest, I first tried interacting with it. When there was no interact prompt, I thought I could smack it, to wake it up. Oops. And double oops, because that was the first one I had seen. I received zero cookbooks, and some dumpy looking, oversized armor. Sigh.

[@officialulti]

The DLC is so compact. the map might be smaller than the base game but layers like a cake. So hard not to lock yourself out of guests on the first play through avoiding spoilers

[@thomaslui7824]

The word "empyrean" grandam has been replaced from the text in lastest patch update, I believe it is a typo mistake since 神人 and 角人 is one word different in Japanese

[@donimmortal7692]

Using summons in Radahn fight also making him significantly harder to predict, he can change target mid-combo, he can cancel the cross-slash which has the biggest punishing window, sometime he will use long-range move like Gravitus or Lion's Claw pointblank.

[@masonsdemoneye245]

Drugging the dragon communion priestess and making them your slave seems evil to me

[@GristlyRook9605]

No she willingly becomes your spirit you just make her fall asleep and then she asks to serve you since you got her old master to abandon her

[@daftpanda6533]

@@GristlyRook9605 Stockholm syndrome at its finest!

[@GristlyRook9605]

@@daftpanda6533 to be fair we kinda just make her sleep not torture abuse or kidnap so idk if that is still Stockholm syndrome but yeah pretty much

[@hansenlife9554]

I was trying to stay way from guides and tips in the DLC and after spending DAYS trying to beat Radahn with Thiollier and Ansbach because I liked the idea of them helping from a story line perspective. I went with just Ansbach and couldn't believe how much easier it was and beat him first try.

[@KalenTomlinson]

16:20 Yeah! Just ignore those summon signs entirely.. can't have noobs knowing what OP weapon is hidden here

[@Mor_D_Kaiser]

Better just to side wotj hornsent on one playthrough and leda only on the ng

[@KalenTomlinson]

@Mor_D_Kaiser definitely lol I'd say use the swiftslash bs before they nerf it entirely.. but it's already ruining arena imo.. so maybe it's a good thing he kept silent about it.. Besides the talismans you get from Leda are more useful in the long run with more builds and same with her armor.. Definitely need to try Ansbach's bow before it gets nerfed too

[@Mor_D_Kaiser]

@@KalenTomlinson I meant it as in to get all items in 2 play throughs, noobs will always google most op build anyway and still get wrecked

[@unknowngaze6781]

@KalenTomlinson Both Swift Slash and the Bow have been nerfed a week ago, give or take. While Swift Slash is possibly still a tad troublesome, it's not as obnoxious as before

[@SameReasons]

4:20 the Moschet Manor theme from Crystal Chronicles?!? Holy shit dude, my feels!!!

[@Magical_Flower95]

I love elden ring lore and you make it engaging enough that I decided to subscribe

[@BeginTheCrusade]

could you imagine playing these games back in the 90's? before widespread internet?

[@crazyyobbo]

With the amount of walking mausoleums with apparent children of marika in them Grandam might have a point

[@BrunoAlves-rj5uw]

7:02 weaker alternatives? How so?

[@hideyourturtles]

Just when I thought the video couldn’t get any better, the GamerSupps sponsor started. Instant sub. I’ll be using your code for my next tub!

[@kingjester3628]

Well partaking in dragon communion would eventually turn the devourer into a magma wyrm and I believe Flortissax says that if you consume Bayle you will eventually become a lord of dragons (possibly similar to Bayle even tho he’s a drake) which would keep you from becoming a wyrm and either become a dragon or drake which is why Flortissax will become your follower (also wife) if you have her sleep

[@crosis2]

Summoning npcs depends greatly on your build. They are quite good to use if you use a blood build as they give you some time to breath and the hp buff is less effective

[@carlossique9604]

To be fair. Ansbach isn’t wrong about the children of the golden order they have all done wrong. Ansbach is a great character, the part where he doesn’t hold any grudge against you for killing Mohg is like in Yakuza 1 when Majimas boss was killed he says it’s part of the life of the Yakuza and he isn’t mad that he’s been killed

[@AizenSosukesama]

Can you link the reddit post?I dont see it

[@ReeYoz_Realm]

Use Shattered's 5 part video walkthrough. It will cover all NPC side quests, missable items like weapons, Scadu Fragments, Spirit Ashes etc. And he gives spoiler warnings too and is all on a convenient playlist.

[@AlxanderVII]

7:00 the pickled livers are improved versions over the normal livers (25% DR) but holyproof is bugged and negates less than the base game version

[@crisnmaryfam7344]

2:03 Note - The "Divine Beast" isnt really a Beast at all. Its Two dudes in a costume doing a "dance". So dont feel so bad about "wearing the head of the beast" as its just a costume head.. Not an Actual head..

[@crisnmaryfam7344]

Another note. AFAIK Summoning a friend for ANY boss fight bolsters the bosses health. Not sure about NPC's and previous bosses, but it would appear as though they do, IF you summon before the fight starts, Examples - Freyja and Relanlalallna, you summon her outside before the fight, where as with Hornsent and Messssmer you summon him inside, Same with Putrescent and Thiollier, you summon him inside during the fight, thus the Hp "buff" to the boss is not applied.

[@tiacool7978]

The fact that it's two guys in a costume should make that worse. Since you killed two people to get it. And regardless of whether it was a real beast or not, it was still considered divine.

[@MrPuddle01]

Fighting Bayle to early can be bad because the dragon lady won't give you the ancient dragon blessing anymore

[@davepresley4689]

So i talked to ansbach as much as i could but accidentally approached the castle and triggered the ruin shattering. I got the "pure and radiant" dialogue but now he has disappeared, have i locked myseld out of his quest?

[@vikinglord11]

FromSoft has had 15+ years to fix their games, yet the NPC side quests are just as buggy and flawed as ever. It's stupid how easy it is to fuck up NPC quests.

[@Nebula_303]

Womp womp

[@themurderbass6551]

I missed out on a lot of npc quests during my first spoiler-free playthrough. I needed that retaliatory crossed tree talisman for a pvp build so I rushed through the game with my old NG+2 character to transfer it to my pvp character. It broke my heart to have to invade Sir Ansbach for the talisman. It was the Milicent's Prosthesis scenario all over again.

[@Mikael_Ore]

Really good video

[@Dreadhead2889]

Worst decision in DLC is the devs making the entire main storyline exist in the top L 1/4 of the map and the rest exists to find scadtree fragments to deal with Radhan. Imagine the base game only having main story in Limgrave but hey, the rest is there if you want to explore it.

[@meredith18352]

I killed Ansbach because I thought it was the only way to get his bow and still feel bad as he is my favourite NPC. Radahn was a nightmare, tried summoning with Thiollier but ended up just taking my mimic when I was finally successful. Hefty rot pots were probably the tipping point in my fight. On my first attempt I accidentally broke the great rune and messed everything up, got punished for exploring without spoilers.

[@Ventus_S]

Honestly base game is already pretty bad in terms of how they design side quest, but dlc somehow makes it 10 times worse, given how easily you skip everything by just moving to x location (is not even a boss fight, you cross a certain point and you miss so much lore or your quest get perma locked. In old Souls game this type of design works cuz you cant really skip any intended area, so you'd come across most npcs in the end. But being an Open World, ER is not the case. You WILL miss sidequests if you don't follow a guide and you like to explore...

[@williamgardner9596]

I missed every quest line by just playing and finishing the game 😂

[@Orpheusftw]

I always do, too. I _try_ to be thorough, but I like my first playthrough to be blind, and these games can be so damn cryptic.

[@bryanmckeithen899]

I missed out on forager's cookbook 7 because I talked to Moore, told him to move on before I had gotten the other 6 books. So if you break Miquella's charm, DO NOT do anything other than purchase and sell things from Moore before getting the other cookbooks.

[@mysteryneophyte]

Every choice I made I'm glad I did I play through the first time blind and it's an awesome experience I would never want to know everything ahead of time and be checking guides and all this that would totally kill at least half of the fun out of it

[@arrenmund8732]

I summoned both during Radahn and had an epic fun fight where the three of us were teamed up to destroy the ultimate threat in the DLC. Honestly, I didn’t notice the fight being any longer than when I solo’d it. I assume the damage they do makes up for the increase in health. The main reason I find fights where you summon NPCs harder is because the boss isn’t focused on you all the time, and can just suddenly switch focus. That’s even more difficult in DLC bosses where so much just one-shots you. First Radahn was so much easier for me to solo than try and fight with all the NPCs, even though I prefer that version thematically.

[@MichaelRigoni]

If it's your first playthrough you're not really going to notice the summons causing the boss to have too much more health but if you're playing on new game plus 7 it really ramps up the health a lot to the point of them just being unreasonable

[@superxdale9715]

Summoning a phantom for the Leda and friends fight, if they go uo the elevator before you it will completely skip the last boss fight stealing your chance to even fight them once. It will still give you the rewards though.

[@cbanks5289]

For souls games and DLCs i just explore as much as i can and beat everything i find during my exploration then on the second playthru i pull up a guide-and knock all the side quests out!

[@sketchyzxch2958]

Great katana+25 and flame skewer for the erdtree avatar absolutely smacks

[@solairesolalalalalemon1198]

In regards to chaos and the frenzied flame vs Bayle’s possession, both chaos and Florissax counters this what we perceive as inevitable ending of Bayle consuming us, we simply cannot be consumed since we will eventually inherit the elden ring, and the Rune of death also we keep ignoring the one thing that we don’t want to admit: we are chaos, we are order, we are actually the greater will. We never die, time stops for us unless we proceed. We see other versions of ourselves spread throughout other realities where we can even summon our other selves from distant realities to help us achieve our obstacle. We master every single weapon or spell we hold, almost instantly. We are order and we are chaos. We are what Marika waited for all these years.

[@TheDemidem0n]

Why do we think that the picked liver is weaker than the base liver? 6:59

[@trissy8820]

Ansbach like a true from soft G perishes in the end but he’ll live on with all of us. Ansbach is indeed one Jolly Cooperator

[@Kay_august787]

I knew this sounded familiar I use to watch this channel when he did cyberpunk, and I started playing Eldenring And just rediscovered it

[@team3d180]

Honnestly who has the best written guides for this game? In terms of doing things in order and going place to place. Idm beating it once blind but if im.go NG+ I Wanna pick it apart.

[@Andrew11017]

Little late but fightin cowboy

[@certifiedcib7958]

Just a heads up, in the last update they updated Hornsent Grandams name from what used to be Empyrean Grandam leading me to think it was probably a mixup with the grandma that Marika leaves her braid with

[@craigheartwell5142]

It's trivially easy to get locked out of all the main NPC quests. With such an emphasis on collecting scadutree fragments to survive, you can do "too much" exploring without storyline progression, and then you are just playing a series of bosses without any good story development... YANG (yet another new game), here I come.

[@jonaswhite256]

I got in the situation where I played through the entire DLC, without doing any of the questlines HAHAHA! Only realized it until WAY later, defeated radahn and I was like," ok where's the next main boss and what quests do I gotta do." 🤣

[@tenenbaummark]

Because of how hard it is to find that map for the jagged peak area, I completely missed the NPC at the dragon communion who told me about Bayle. Kinda pissed, didn't find that area until after I beat Bayle

[@By-s]

You can infuse the black steel greatshield with sacred ash of war infusion and it will give you 100% holly damage negation but I think you need to upgrade it first, that's how I beat the second phase.

[@justdom1801]

You should tell Moore to stay sad forever, then after you kill Mesmer he’ll be dead embracing the forager brood that was injured, you still get his armor, shield, and bell bearing, but you won’t have to fight him with leda.

[@rustkarl]

Ansbach for life. Personally I ran a bleed weapon with some mid-combat buffs and a spirit ash so taking him along to draw attention away while I was casting, as well as contributing to his bleed counter was worth the health buff. Sadly Thiollier, not so much.

[@adubseven]

me at 00:02 "yeah dude" then heavy sigh

[@elijahsouza2238]

I actually killed one of the forager brood before learning their connection with Sir Moore. Felt really bad about that when i learned it

[@Aceinthedesert25]

I had the Moore questline glitch in my game. The forager near the church was somehow already dead when I approached. I don't know if this was patched in the .13 update but super annoying for sure.

[@ALegendarySol]

I hated the pests so much that when I saw that one in the grass, I saw RED. After looking up a guide for Moore, I was like "wait..a pest...by the church where you fight Queelign..not attacking..ohhhhhhhhhHHHHHHHHHH FUUUUU"

[@mkulchar]

Three, playthroughs and I never knew that you had to actually use the warming Stone at the forger. I always just use the leave option and I always wondered why it never worked

[@nicktalope]

Thanks. I know now why I was not able to find all the forager broods !

[@Liednard]

Loool I faced the final boss with 85 holy resist (with buffs). Still got my ass mopped nice vid ;)

[@AleXelerate8]

Thank you for this video. I missed that one ash of war everyone is dashing across with in pvp i hear thats op pve as well. Also messed up the old women merchant first playthrough as well.

[@crypt1k755]

I played the whole game blind and when Leda said she was going to kill Hornsent, I immediately knew something fishy was going on with Miquella.

[@kacperd2331]

Ansbach: you have defeated mogh in fair duel *Me during fight: kamehame ha

[@namersonuncle4971]

I actually managed to lock myself out of all but one of moores outcomes, which is the one bout attacking by the forager brood, but I refuse to do it. I’ll just complete one of the quests endings in NG+ 4… or NG+ 2 of my SotET playthrough

[@antoinefabre8476]

I love the fact there are no indications for quests on the map or on the menu, and you have to figure some things out by yourself. Its way more immersive. But then quests should be more explicit or its just bad design.

[@badgerbane]

Oh. I killed hornsent grandma after the DB fight because she was unresponsive and I was mad at her for summoning that thing on me. Got the incantation and the stew off her body though so who had the last laugh in the end, eh?

[@vecryn8494]

I would say my first time through I did all those wrong and more, I went straight to the last boss and broke every quest line before checking with half of the npcs and missed some entirely. I didn't even find Igor until I had already beaten the dlc.