1 actually surprised me. It's not bad, just funny.
@hughstark4882 Жыл бұрын
I actually love how different this list is. Even if I don't agree with all the rankings I still think the uniqueness is very good.
@tobismusicchannel3033 Жыл бұрын
Thanks! I appreciate your comment.
@ThomazAmorim-ty6vp11 ай бұрын
1 - Echoes 2 - Dogs 3 - Shine on you crazy diamond 4 - Comfortably numb 5 - wish you were here 6 - Us and them 7 - time 8 - Money 9 - High hopes 10 - Hey you
@donremi76 Жыл бұрын
My top ten could be something like: 1. Dogs 2. Echoes 3. Comfortably numb 4. Shine on you crazy diamond (1-9) 5. The great gig in the sky 6. Hey you 7. A saucerful of secrets 8. Welcome to the machine 9. Atom heart mother 10. Nobody home.
@tobismusicchannel3033 Жыл бұрын
Great Top 10 as well!
@martinbarrios79203 ай бұрын
Wow, Granchester meadows top 10! Is awesome and controversial...I think Echoes is a little too low and Brain damage, too high My top 10 Echoes Dogs Shine on Confortably numb Time High hopes Atom heart Us & them Fletcher memorial Eclipse
@thejtd21 Жыл бұрын
Sorrow is a powerfully underrated song
@parjunwijken6406 Жыл бұрын
Interstellar overdrive my No 1
@aedin2044 Жыл бұрын
LOVE seeing Ummagumma, Atom Heart Mother, and Final Cut love... some of my favorite PF albums
@pedrokropotkin9045 Жыл бұрын
1) Echoes 2) Us and Them 3) Comfortably Numb 4) Shine on Your Crazy Diamond 5) Welcome to the Machine 6) Hey You 7) Dogs 8) Time 9) Wish You Were Here 10) High Hopes 11) The Great Gig of the Sky 12) Goodbye Blue Sky 13) Sheep 14) Set the Controls for the Heart of the Sun 15) Another Brick in the Wall 16) On the Turning Away 17) Brain Damage 18) Pigs 19) Money 20) Astronome Domine 21) One of These Days 22) Interstellar Overdrive 23) Mother 24) Young Lust 25) Atom Heart Mother 26) Mathilda Mother 27) Breathe 28) Learning to Fly 29) Marooned 30) Careful whit That Axe Eugene
@samradcliffe3745 Жыл бұрын
AHM no.1 love it
@frankarena838 Жыл бұрын
Great list, thank you very much. Tough job to pick 50 songs from their catalogue. Some really good songs miss out.
@jeremybrown52396 ай бұрын
My top 30 1 echoes 2 comfortably numb 3 shine on you crazy diamond pts i -v 4 pigs 5 interstellar overdrive 6 the trial 7 time 8 welcome to the machine 9 wish you were here 10 dogs 11 a saucer full of secrets 12 the happiest days of our lives 13 see Emily play 14 set the controls for the heart of the sun 15 sorrow 16 brain damage 17 louder than words 18 high hopes 19 one of these days 20 jugband blues 21 marooned 22 burning bridges 23 signs of life 24 astronomy domine 25 careful with that axe Eugene 26 when the tigers broke free 27 sheep 28 Alan's psychedelic breakfast 29 learning to fly 30 hey you 31 goodbye blue sky 32 the gold it's in the 33 Matilda mother 34 apples and oranges 35 empty spaces 36 what shall we do now 37 lost for words 38 on the turning away 39 have a cigar 40 mud men 41 Arnold layne 42 fearless 43 bike 44 chapter 24 45 a great day for freedom 46 let there be more light 47 when you're in 48 any colour you like 49 yet another movie 50 not now John
@donremi76 Жыл бұрын
Obviously each of us has a ranking of his own. Mine would be different, but I appreciate your choices.
@Pencake2112 Жыл бұрын
Wow, Atom Heart Mother at no.1, didnt expect that. I for sure thought it was dogs, or soycd, or echoes
@tobismusicchannel3033 Жыл бұрын
Yes, it's a rather unusual choice for No. 1, but I love Atom Heart Mother a lot
@Pencake2112 Жыл бұрын
@@tobismusicchannel3033 Very Understandable and very underrated as well in my eyes
@paradiseoctagon21794 Жыл бұрын
I personally think it's better than Echoes. It really feels like an amazing journey through life or something.
@lopolik Жыл бұрын
hard to make a top 10, I actually like your list, my favorite album overall is Animals and you have the main 3 songs pretty high on the list. Other than The Nile song or Ibiza Bar (both are similar and heavy) Sheep might be their heaviest song, also Animals definitely the most angry sounding album from Pink Floyd, Roger Waters really does a good job with the vocals. I would definitely include ''Careful with that Axe Eugene'' just because that song is so ahead of its time, especially the Live at Pompeii version, those shriek / inhale screams are like black metal scream, so just for that I'd put it in top songs.
@tobismusicchannel3033 Жыл бұрын
Kinda suprised but happy to see you on here. Animals is a great album for sure and 'Careful with that axe' Eugene' is fantastic (the Pompeii version is also my favorite version)
@lopolik Жыл бұрын
@@tobismusicchannel3033 Yea - I am sorry, I've been watching this one channel guy from Hells headbangers, and I think it rubbed off on me, and I went overboard I admit with my comments, I kind of acted like him, I am usually not like this, I was a bit arrogant with my calling people ''poser'', I'll try not to do this, I am generally cool, and we have music in common so I don't see why we couldn't get along. Yeah, and also Echoes from the live at pompeii version is amazing. (The drumming on that version is even faster, towards the climax of the guitar solo is really cool.)
@tobismusicchannel3033 Жыл бұрын
@@lopolik No problem. I don't really see a point in arguing over opinions and calling others "posers". We're all on the same side, right? We all like music that's meant to be an artform (unlike a lot of today's music that's just a mere product, meant to sell and only to sell). I don't think it really matters whether you prefere Echoes or Shine On, Pink Floyd or Yes. I think we can all agree that they are all great in their own right. I think, it's kinda interesting that Pink Floyd decided to start the concert with the first part of Echoes and end with the second part, just like they did it 3 years later with Shine On on the Wish You Were Here album.
@lopolik Жыл бұрын
@@tobismusicchannel3033 yea, I mean I love both yes and pink floyd, pf were the first prog band that I loved, when I was like 11 or 12 my dad bought some CD compilation of pink Floyd, and from that I remember my favorite even back then was Echoes and comfortably numb and a few more, I think Sheep was on it as well. But around the same time I got into Yes and like I'd buy all their 70s albums, they were my favorite, but of course I also bought some other prog greats Genesis selling England, King crimson, Jethro tull, Rush and so forth. Yea interesting with the echoes parts and shine on being at the beginning and end of the albums. I used to actually fall asleep to both Shine On and Echoes its very relaxing.
@simonbellamy67 Жыл бұрын
No 1. Are you kidding me. Atom heart mother, no way. Better than SOYCD, better than Dogs no chance......
@tobismusicchannel3033 Жыл бұрын
Well, it is my No. 1, you can have your own No. 1 😉
@jackalproductions46294 ай бұрын
It's not your list pal
@simonbellamy674 ай бұрын
@@tobismusicchannel3033 your right my bad! Sorry
@Mc_wowo Жыл бұрын
My top ten would be something like : Us and them Marooned Learning to fly Young lust One of my turn Sheep Dogs Wish you were here Shine on ur crazy diamond Breath in the air