Top 50 Survivor Players: 30-21 Rankings (2024)

[@somebol9047]

Rob Cesternino THAT'S WHY HE'S THE GOAT!!! THE GOAT!!!

[@antoineharris2176]

Honestly, I look at John Cochran's South Pacific game as more representative of how he truly would play as opposed to his Caramoan game. In Caramoan he essentially got a game in which he had a bunch of allies lined up for him (including his best friend in Dawn). The only real opposition he had in terms of strategy and social prowess was Brenda and Malcolm. Malcolm flamed out and John (I refuse to call him by his last name) outflanked Brenda by voting her out early. Typically in a game of Survivor you don't have ready made alliances hand picked for you like he did in Caramoan. In South Pacific you saw that on display as we struggled to make any real connections outside of Dawn. He was used repeatedly as a pawn by both alliances.

[@jackfallon1629]

i feel like jesse should be a bit lower, he is incredible strategically, but he also has a bunch of areas he needs to work on to win a season of survivor. his social game is also underrated but i think some of his decision making in conjunction with his physical limitations hamper him a great deal. it's probably impossible for him now on a returnee season, as he'll go in as one of the biggest threats, no doubt

[@jimbom2g57]

Malcolm’s a great player. List has been pretty good so far. Need Clement on here somewhere though even if only an HM

[@bigbrotherspoilers9756]

james isn’t a good player

[@thepanpatriotsfan9295]

LETS GO

[@valkyrjavalhalla]

Sandra is way too low. I think it's important to note that number of times played can absolutely bring down a player's overall showcase of their abilities, but if you're putting her below someone like JT, that's just straight up wrong. She played an excellent premerge game in Game Changers, where she ended up being swap screwed. And thanks to the Edge in WAW, overplayed her hand and went home in an *idol play*. Neither of those are particularly the fault of *her* gameplay, rather circumstances out of her control. Sure there's maybe 5 or 6 players I'd personally put above her, but 23 is CRIMINAL.

[@mikenadj.j4355]

Sandra would have been gone anyway if she didn’t have the idol as Denise wanted Sandra out since pregame. Giving the idol away that she had from EOE was a massive mistake obviously as she would have been guaranteed merge as Jeremy would have been voted out in a re vote. Even if they lost again Denise would have went next. Tony and Sandra are tied for 1 and 2 for winning twice in my book. Sandra won twice in a row but Tony had more dominant wins so they cancel each other out.

[@igorsteinberg3533]

Aubry above Michele, Tina, Yam Yam, Wentworth, Faiplay... basically above anyone in the 50 to 31 list?! Aubry is perhaps the most overrated player of all time, she doesn't belong even in the top 100 players.

[@jtp360]

Need jesse in season 50

[@tstrike4742]

denise might be the most overrated player of all time. i really don’t see surviving every tribal as this big booster. she played mediocre at best both times she played.

[@bigbrotherspoilers9756]

ditto

[@DanielHawthorne-zi2dl]

WILDLY disagree

[@dbarller]

Just quit now bro