Top Ten Best Big Brother Players To Never Win

Only BBUS

[@TheChai0628]

Man, what a true Big Brother fan, you jumped all over the seasons instead of just 16-19. This list would have been similar to mine.

[@SamSamSamLawl]

Agree with this list, but I would maybe have include Nicole from BB2. Good to see a list without Janelle who I love but is often poor strategically

[@potatofamine9353]

No Janelle? She may not have been the best strategist but was definitely the best competitor of Season 6 & 7 and should've won.

[@welibra8914]

UnofficialKyle she sucks...

[@aries9934]

She is literally one of the worst players strategically EVER. The only reason she wasn’t evicted first in both seasons were because of competitions

[@unknownplays8059]

In s6 she really deserved it but in s7 idk if she really deserved it yeah most comp wins but will manipulated her for the longest time

[@noahf7y356]

please silence your self Janelle sucks she played 3 ssns and could never make it to f2 and now shes in all stars about to make pre-jury for the second time smhz. Even my man Paul could go to f2 twice in a row whether u love him or hate him hes better than janelle nk.

[@potatofamine9353]

NoahF7y you’re delusional lmao. She got taken out at final 3 both times cus she wouldve won if in final 2... paul gets to final 2 and loses both times lmao, he is not that good

[@TheCubinator]

Official List: 10. Diane 9. Memphis 8. Cody 7. Shelly 6. Kevin 5. Paul 4. Jason 3. Vanessa 2. Danielle 1. Eric

[@pesstonwuz3012]

The Venomoth well these all were pretty good players enzo was great too

[@thevenomoth3455]

pesston wuz Shelly didn't even remotely deserve to be on the list.

[@jasonbarnes6898]

The Cubinator the real list should have been 1 Danielle Reyes 2 Vanessa 3 Paul 4 Memphis 5 Nicole (season 2) 6 Alison 7 Frankie (season 16) 8 Shelly 9 Kevin (season 11) 10 Enzo

[@Eric_Reborn]

Jason Barnes can one of you guys please explain to me why you disagree with Eric Stein even being on the list. I just dont understand why you guys think he shouldn't be even in the top 10...

[@jasonbarnes6898]

gofor dawin cause his showmance was the only reason he went far people didn't trust but they like Jessica he talked he got blindsided he couldn't talk himself off the block everybody else like Vanessa or Danielle Reyes never got blindsided to that degree or had no way to save themselves with 5 other people in the house

[@cornetto27b83]

UMM EXCUSE YOU! ARENT YOU FORGETTING ABOUT RAVEN WALTON?? If you couldn't tell I was trolling lol

[@theaverys6941]

#RavenExposed Jk Well maybe...

[@burgerbuddy100]

lool

[@ja_cow_ski]

SHE WAS THE PUPPET MASTER

[@missgringa2560]

Cornetto 27b Raven was obviously the puppet master. She is obviously a part of Mensa. Of course she is smart enough to manipulate all these people. *i am obviously being sarcastic*

[@breenewi6405]

Ew!

[@madisonerb486]

Is anyone watch this during 22 and knowing Cody is probably now going to be a winner

[@reagangaddis654]

I know his season hadn’t happened at the time of this video but I think it’s safe to say Tyler earns his spot on this list but hey he is on all stars 2 now so that could change.

[@Eric_Reborn]

Well he moved down in the rankings after all stars 2 it turns out.

[@reagangaddis654]

@@Eric_Reborn I mean yeah he definitely wasn't as good as bb 20 but in my opinion he still played well. I mean he got 6th when his head really wasn't in the game (granted the committee really helped everyone in that alliance and Enzo). I still feel personally that Tyler was the biggest jury threat on this season and I think he beats anyone at the end except maybe Cody but I wouldn't be surprised if Tyler still pulled out the win. I respect your opinion though.

[@lukejohnson7201]

might be an unpopular opinion but, Britney Haynes feels really underrated. It felt like she played a great social game both times she played and never made any enemies. I truly think that she just got really unlucky and ran into insane competition in the brigade(one of, if not the best alliance in the history of the game), and Dan(one of, if not the best player in the history of the game).

[@connormackenzie5196]

Yes and no. I think she is a good player. On the other hand I don't think she wins BB12 even if she makes the end (other than maybe a F2 with Enzo, and that was her last choice she was trying for). And BB14 she made her target too obviously big, which is why Dan and some of the other HGs targetted her so far from the end, despite her great social game.

[@Eric_Reborn]

I think you can make an argument for her being on the list but I don't think she quite makes it

[@TheChamp33]

I feel the same way, if she’s not top 10, she’s at least top 15.

[@Nuggetworld9204]

I love that Danielle is higher than Jason as she was the better of that duo in bb3 and was still good in bb7 but just not as good as bb3

[@tdt8854]

Number 8: This list won’t age well

[@Eric_Reborn]

Well he's not even eligible for this list now. Lol

[@flavafee]

love that shelley made it on the list. she was one of the best floaters of all time imo (the actual strategy of being aligned with the people in power every week, not just being weak and being carried far)

[@Matt.Savage]

She's definitely the most overrated floater of All-Time, that's for sure.

[@Ho3e]

@@Matt.Savage under*

[@smitty5967]

My opinion of the best players to never win: Season 1- Chicken George Season 2- Nicole, Hardy Season 3- Danielle, Jason, Roddy Season 4- Allison Season 5- Diane, Nakomis, Marvin Season 6- Ivette, Janelle Season 7- Janelle, Dr Will Season 8- Eric, Jameka, Zach Season 9- Crazy James Season 10- Jerry Season 11- Jeff, Kevin Season 12- Matt, Brittney Season 13- Shelly Season 14- Frank Season 15- Gina Marie Season 16- Cody, Nicole, Donny Season 17- Vanessa, Johnny Mac Season 18- Paul, Victor Season 19- Cody, Alex, Kevin

[@soaps7796]

GinaMarie over Amanda or Helen?

[@escapethenighttea6450]

KEVIN he was on the block eighty times

[@Matt.Savage]

🤭SHELLY🥴😂🤣😂😭

[@connormackenzie5196]

@@soaps7796 Amanda overplayed so much she was never making the end, and even if she did she was so hated she loses to possibly everyone. Despite running a lot of the game. Not even sure if she beats McCrae or GinaMarie, who were the biggest goats besides herself.

[@soaps7796]

@@connormackenzie5196 yeah, I wrote this 3 years ago and clearly didn't have a super nuanced understanding of the game 😂 I do still stand by that helen should probably be the pick for bb15 tho

[@ethancostellostudent1698]

The lack of Janelle on this list is disappointing

[@connormackenzie5196]

@@thegooseman508 In a way she is way overrated, and I don't find her good at all besides being the all time comp beast perhaps. On the other hand she was 2 HOHs from probably winning twice.

[@Eric_Reborn]

@@connormackenzie5196 she doesn't win in the final 2 of bb6 but bb7 yes. But either way that's a very results-oriented way of thinking about it.

[@Nuggetworld9204]

Unpopular opinion, where is Matt form bb12? He was the brains of the second most dominant alliance in bb history.

[@Eric_Reborn]

I dont think that's a very unpopular opinion.

[@whats_holden_up]

Matt was a great player but he had the same problem that James from s6 and s7 had. He was too shady and showed his cards to early. If he kept low and peaked later in the game he would've been better. It's always better to show your true capabilities later in the game when it matters more.

[@TheChamp33]

The only problem with Matt was that he trusted the Brigade too much to betray them when he knew that he was on the bottom of the totem pole with them.

[@tristan4874]

why is paul even on this list ugh

[@thofmockel2577]

Tristan because you can’t denied he got robbed by a bitter jury and he is a great player

[@pesstonwuz3012]

Tristan he was basically robbed twice by bitter jorors

[@benjaminwill3155]

Tristan better than you Cody and Jessica just had bitter jury both years

[@pesstonwuz3012]

allstar22beast ben why you gotta bring jody into this ?

[@joymarylawani9430]

pesston wuz Yeah but it was because of his bad action against them that they took personally not his gameplay. Everyone knew he was the better player but the way he acted cost him $500,000.Twice.

[@TheSuperTalks]

Prob the most accurate list I've ever seen.

[@mannymoreno8479]

My order: 1. Janelle 2. Danielle R. 3. Vanessa 4. Paul A. 5. Tyler 6. Danielle D. 7. Nakomis 8. Nicole A. 9. Kevin C. 10. Porsche

[@pesstonwuz3012]

it's honestly sad that some of these people didn't win UGH

[@angelornelas5139]

Out of curiosity where would you have ranked. Diane, Kevin, shelly, Vanessa, Danielle and eric in a winner ranking? Since you had them as the best player in their respective season. The only player i thought be in here was Nicole from bb2. Other then that spot on. (especially that you added cody and memphis who never get their credit. Diane and Kevin too kinda.)

[@TheCubinator]

You'd have stay tuned for the Top 20 Best Big Brother Players of All Time video!

[@angelornelas5139]

I am more interested in who are made the 20 to 11 margin then the top 10 (Since I have a solid idea on who made the top 10).

[@Agent7300]

Good list. I don't think Kevin, Shelly, and Cody are better than memphis but i feel this is the correct 10. maybe throw Alison Irwin in there too.

[@christopherjohnson1873]

Alison is Russell Hantz (or as close to him as BB has gotten). She'd have to at least be outside the top 10 in win equity in a random season, simply because of how hard a time she'll have winning jury votes.

[@icywindrocksmash9567]

Christopher Johnson I actually feel as if Paul is more of a Russel.

[@christopherjohnson1873]

icywind rocksmash I get that he's been mean at times, but I don't think he's that close to that level. He's closer to a Coach, in that he has an ersatz ethic ("friendship") he bases alliances off of, such that when he backstabs said allies they are more likely to be upset, and he then failed to own his game to the jury in the end.

[@angelornelas5139]

Paul just suck at who he choose to go to the end with much like danielle in bb3.

[@TheChamp33]

Strategically they are not, but socially easily. Main reason why Kevin & Shelly didn’t make Final 2. Cody just made a dumb mistake in taking Victoria to the end.

[@zachfrick7389]

looking back, Memphis' qna shit was WACK

[@burgerbuddy100]

Raven from BB19 was a puppet master. Don't forget her shes a legend

[@thofmockel2577]

Caleb U lol

[@flipcamgamer]

The true definition of a coaster

[@mcgaming8982]

The top three should be in no particular order Paul, Tyler and Danielle

[@callofthegame69]

It’s safe to say you can now add Tyler to this list

[@tannermcauliffe9325]

CROB’S Plan yeah he played better than Kaycee

[@Nuggetworld9204]

Replace Cody with Tyler but put him a few spots higher.

[@awsumg2168]

Honestly tho I gotta say Janelle should’ve won for being the best competitor in B.B. history, I feel like she should’ve won BB7 hands down, I’m still upset over that first part HOH comp in S7, her wins should’ve gotten her the win

[@jasonking8835]

Cody gets cretisized for taking Derrick but he had no idea that Derrick did what he did

[@connormackenzie5196]

I can see that but what he did know was Victoria SUCKED. He referenced being paranoid the jury could give it to the nice girl who did nothing, and basing that on recent reality winners at the time like Natalie White, Sandra, Jordan (would have won twice if got to the end of BB13) which I guess I can kind of get, but I really think there was no chance of that ever with Victoria. Even not knowing how much Derrick did, he probably should have taken Victoria, just because she so obviously sucked and was never winning.

[@breenewi6405]

Definitely agree with Danielle, and Vanessa. Maybe Eric too. If that ‘America’s player’ twist never happened, he could’ve won.

[@ecksdeeexd9622]

xBreeGaming No way it’s actually you Bree

[@ecksdeeexd9622]

xBreeGaming Do you remember me?

[@ecksdeeexd9622]

Frikin heck you probably have air pods and you can’t hear me

[@abrandnewpairofsocks]

Shelly was a bad player, all she did was clean

[@BokuGlack]

Where is Janelle at

[@tdt8854]

MikeEdits not on the list

[@noahf7y356]

She sucks so shes not on

[@VictorHernandez-sd3fw]

Janelle would have won BB6 had she won the final HOHh over Ivette. Paul? Proved he can make it to the end, but can never convince most of the jury that he is deserving. Ever.

[@angelornelas5139]

Victor Hernandez I mean it be close I think Ivette would have maggie beau Jennifer james and possibly april. Against maggie who would have april jen beau and ivette locked

[@VictorHernandez-sd3fw]

Angel Ornelas Regarding if Ivette would have won BB6, April went on a podcast this time last year and said that if Jenelle we’re in the final two with her, Jenelle would have one. And April was in the same Friendship alliance too. I believe it all stems from the fact that Jenelle would be regarded as more of a respectable and more well liked player over Ivette according to April.

[@angelornelas5139]

Victor Hernandez it depend how james vote. He and Ivette had that weird relationship in the house that works for them and he wasn't high on janelle. But it is close. Against ivette at least

[@tannermcauliffe9325]

He is only one of two people to ever make it to final 2 twice him and Dan geisling so he’s gonna be playing better game but the jury be haten

[@tneggs4115]

Can you imagine how well Eric would have done if it wasn’t for America’s player?

[@thevenomoth3455]

Good list overall, except one question. Where is Enzo?!

[@theaverys6941]

The Venomoth ikr

[@missgringa2560]

The Venomoth yeah he controlled basically all of bb12

[@michaelhartfelder4381]

I would add Nakomis from Big Brother 5&7 and Tyler Crispen 20&22 too this list.

[@Nuggetworld9204]

The reason Tyler isn’t on here and that Cody is is that this was done before bb20. (Edit: I think Kevin would be lower if it was made today thanks to bb22)

[@whats_holden_up]

Nakomis was better than Diane imo. The list was made before Tyler so now Tyler would definitely be in the top 5 of this list

[@whats_holden_up]

@@Nuggetworld9204 probably and truthfully I never thought Kevin was that amazing, even his BB11 wasn't that impressive he was made out to be better than he was because the gameplay was weak that season for most part. People like Frankie, Matt (bb12), and JC I would argue are better than Kevin

[@whats_holden_up]

Memphis should be higher. I would put Janelle on the list as well. I'ma say this if it wasn't for the Americas twist, Eric wouldve definitely been a top 5 player of all time.

[@awsumg2168]

Two things, finally someone is mentioning Jason Guy from season 3!!!! But ummm Janelle where she at?

[@80sports20]

As evident again by this season of all stars, Janelle really only had 1 solid season. I don't think she's an all time great. Of course it's not really fair to judge her at this point because she's past her prime, but she's now lost 4 times! She's only had one good season and it was based on her win in a lot of competition that season, which is only one facet of the game. But each times she comes on and loses, her legacy is tainted.

[@awsumg2168]

@@80sports20 I personally agree Janelle isn’t the best game player but I still believe she should’ve won a season. But I see what you mean. Personally if she wasn’t with Kaysar in All-Stars 2, I think she would’ve done better

[@tdt8854]

Janelle is only good at comps stop hyping her up. Even with her threat level a truly great player will be able to overcome that. Tyler for example was just seen run BB20 but was still in a position to win very early on. Danielle Reyes aswell. Janelle hasn’t been able to do that in 2 tries with a massive target

[@Eric_Reborn]

@@awsumg2168 I think she's not that far from making the list simply cause she was so good at comps that she has a legit shot of winning her way to the end but she's so spiteful and not great at the game other than that. I feel like if she goes ona comp streak then has just 1 week where she doesn't win a comp she's probably gone because she just makes herself such a target with her celebratory behavior and just the fact that the house sees her as a huge comp threat overall.

[@Phillyd0gg]

why did you put shelly

[@prestuhnn4493]

i don’t get what’s so great about shelley

[@whats_holden_up]

Truthfully I'm pretty much the same. She was good but I don't find her to be amazing. There's players not on the list who are better

[@Nuggetworld9204]

Where is Dani?

[@TheChamp33]

Honorable Mentions: - Janelle - Brittany - Austin - Frankie - Danielle D. - Alison - Nicole & Hardy (BB2)

[@whats_holden_up]

There's lots of people you can give honorable mentions to like Nakomis, JC, Enzo, etc. My list would be a bit different from that actually one probably as I don't think Shelli should've made it

[@TheChamp33]

@@whats_holden_up Why not Shelli, she easily would’ve won if it wasn’t for Pandora’s Box.

[@whats_holden_up]

@@TheChamp33 Shelly is a good player but there's far more non winning players that played better games than her. Her game imo is like a lesser version of JCs

[@TheChamp33]

@@whats_holden_up Don’t get wrong, I love JC’s game, but only Tyler viewed him as a threat whereas Shelly planted seeds early in the game, got on the block twice staying over an obvious target and a veteran. I put Shelly over JC.

[@whats_holden_up]

@@TheChamp33 I feel like JC was more active in planting seeds as he was responsible for lots of evictions. Also JC was unbeatable at the end in BB20 where he beats anyone from level 6 because he bonded with Foutte but also beats anyone from Foutte because he bonded with Level 6. He played a good middle game and I feel like he's stronger socially than Shelly was. Shelly was good but I feel like JC orchestrated the middle game better. JC while I'm not his biggest fans should be in the discussion for best players to never win

[@zagshoops23]

Jerry should definitely be on this list from BB10

[@pesstonwuz3012]

Randy Russell no he was dragged

[@survivoramazing5733]

Where’s Jeff or Daniele

[@nikhilramkrishnan2018]

You forgot Natalie and Da

[@Insulindependantfati]

Danielle should’ve been number 1 then Eric. But I have no complaints... except Kevin Campbell

[@devin597]

lol ur judging hows hes playing rn but on season 11 he was good

[@Insulindependantfati]

Devin Ortiz he was okay. He came up with that lie at the end, but I wouldn’t say he was one of the greatest who never won. Definitely not taking into consideration his horrible gameplay now. But Kevin’s season 11 game is always a topic of contention

[@alexanderray9053]

Janelle Should Be #2 And Danielle Should Be Bumped Up To #1

[@connormackenzie5196]

Danielle should not be #1 since she guaranteed herself having no chance to win by going to F3 with Jason and Lisa, two people she stood no shot in a jury vote. All Stars she was more of a threat to win if she made the end, but this time came nowhere close, and had virtually no shot of making the end.

[@justinpascal8332]

Where’s Britney

[@hettybridgewater3676]

# 2 that black girl wow she had the game in her hand Omg she was very good coady should have sent drick home he would of won over celeb

[@cobracmr4]

Janelle got robbed

[@Eric_Reborn]

My list 1. Danielle Reyes 2. Vanessa Rousso 3. Eric Stein 4. Diane Henry 5. Tyler Crispen 6. Jason guy 7. Memphis Garrett 8. Paul Abrahamian 9. Shelly moore 10. Alison Irwin (Edited updated opinion as of May 10th 2022)

[@ja9852]

gofor dawin what vanessa is no were near 10 if it wasnt for a nerd she wouldve won

[@Eric_Reborn]

Jake I put her as the #1 to never win

[@ja9852]

gofor dawin oh my bad i think jason still deserves a higher spot

[@Eric_Reborn]

Jake yeah I could see that. Maybe putting him over paul, but it was pretty hard to compare 2 players who played in 2 completely different eras of the game.

[@ja9852]

gofor dawin There both good but Paul was handed going to the final 2 and but Jason kept jury mangement and was the first ever person to win hoh and pov in same week Jason and Danielle also were the first people to never get nominated and i was really surprise not to see him in all stars.

[@Ajpowers02]

Shelly and Kevin but no janelle? Corny

[@survivor8615]

it’s fair janelle isn’t on this but i feel she could’ve been on this over memphis

[@noahf7y356]

Nah at least he was able to make f2 unlike the 3 times janelle played

[@connormackenzie5196]

@@noahf7y356 He made F2 and got 0 votes as a goat, and honestly there probably isn't anyone in BB10 he wins against. I think he even loses to Jerry. All Stars he was more of a threat to win if he made it, but didn't come close to F2 this time. Janelle was literally one comp from winning probably two different seasons.

[@Scarface615]

My list Paul Abrahamian Vanessa Rousso Danielle R. Tyler Crispen

[@Eric_Reborn]

You have Diane way too low. I have her at #7 at the absolute lowest now but thats also factoring in that cody is a winner now. But it's also factoring in tyler being above her and you made this video before tyler ever played so at the time you made this video I would have had Diane at 6 cause before Cody's bb22 game I think Diane was better than cody which I dont think anymore after his performance on bb22 but it doesn't matter cause he won now so right now I'd have Diane at #7 at the absolute lowest behind only Vanessa, dani R, Eric, Paul, Jason, and Tyler. No doubt Diane is better than Shelly, Memphis and Kevin those 3 could never even dream to be as skilled and masterful of a player Diane was in bb5. Diane in bb5 played one of the best non winning games I've ever seen. I've always viewed Kevin as overrated by superfans but underrated by casuals, same with Shelly. Shelly was good but she kind of made certain moves at the wrong times. Memphis is decent his bb22 game didn't change my opinion on him as a player too much. If Diane ever played bb with any of those players she'd run circles around their gameplay I mean come on there's not even a comparison there for me Diane was a stud of a big brother player #10 is disrespectful. I say 7 is the lowest she can be and I think there is an argument to put her as high up as #3. Vanessa and Dani are the only 2 players who haven't won that I can't see any argument for her being ahead of. Since you made this list before tyler and when cody hadn't won yet I think you should have had her still in the 7-3 range just with maybe Cody in the conversation instead of tyler at that point.

[@connormackenzie5196]

I think you overrate Diane. She allowed herself to get totally dickmatized by Drew, and made numerous stupid moves near the end. I think Karen was the best non winning game of that season, not Diane. Diane also probably does not beat Drew as some assume. The twins and Cowboy are locks for Drew, and Marvin said post show he votes Drew in that F2 which already gives him the win. Karen was super bitter at Diane after her boot, so probably votes Drew too.

[@RoomFiller]

#1 all the way

[@juliafanrose3572]

Janelle isnt on here? She should be. But i dont think cody deserves the win over derrick

[@dianawertz1264]

Agree, these are definetly top ten...

[@TheChamp33]

10. Diane 9. Memphis 8. Enzo 7. Tiffany 6. Paul 5. Tyler 4. Jason 3. Vanessa 2. Danielle 1. Eric

[@Eric_Reborn]

Tiffany? Why?

[@TheChamp33]

@@Eric_Reborn 1. Having the Cookout making side alliances with the other players in the house just in case they both get targeted so the Cookout member will have the numbers to stay. 2. Even without the Cookout, she was easily best positioned in the house with everybody. 3. Wasn’t thought of as a target until winning her 2nd HOH. 4. She could’ve aligned with anyone in the game and could’ve made it further but she sacrificed her game to make sure that it will be a first African American winner in United States on Big Brother.

[@Eric_Reborn]

@@TheChamp33 shoot I'm sorry I'm such a dumb ass. I tried to forget bb23 existed cause i just got so bored with it I barely remember it so when you said Tiffany my dumb ass thought you were saying Tiffany bb18 Vanessa's sister. Tiffany from bb23 from what I remember was pretty good. Never mind.

[@Eric_Reborn]

@@TheChamp33 as soon as Sarah Beth got rid of Derek X I basically ragequit watching the season lol.

[@Eric_Reborn]

@@TheChamp33 My list is 1. Danielle Reyes 2. Vanessa rousso 3. Eric Stein 4. Diane Henry 5. Tyler Crispen 6. Jason guy 7. Paul Abrahamian 8. Memphis Garrett 9. Shelly moore 10. Alison Irwin If I rewatch season 23 I may put Tiff in somewhere. I know she started off very well and was really good but from what I remember she also didn't have very high win equity most of the season and wasn't setup to go the furthest out of her alliance so I'm not sure but every season other than 23 I certainly know well.

[@Flareboxx]

Half of these shouldn't be on here. Eric didn't even play a game because he was America's player, Shelly played a terrible game, Memphis deserved 2nd place. Kevin, Paul and Vanessa all played decent games but definitely aren't in the top 10 players to never win. Diane, Cody, Jason, and Danielle deserve to be on the list, but you could have found much better houseguests for the other 6 slots.

[@flawessgrace4604]

1. Danielle 2. Janelle 3. Vanessa That’s my top three I don’t want to do the whole list

[@noahf7y356]

Janelle sucks ummm....

[@Matt.Savage]

@@noahf7y356 YOU SUCK, I literally see you hating on Janelle in every damn comment, FUCK OFF! Just because YOU didn't like her doesn't mean that she's not 1 of the top 5 greatest players to never win the game. Just STOP!

[@noahf7y356]

@@Matt.Savage yes it does as u see in the video dumazz

[@Eric_Reborn]

@@Matt.Savage dude she isn't top 5 to never win come on there is no way someone who made as many poor decisions as she did can possibly be a top 5 player to never win.

[@mr.griddle615]

This could soon change for Memphis, Cody, or Kevin.

[@anrajsoni2596]

As iT did :)

[@michaelhartfelder4381]

I didn't like Memphis at all. And not big on Cody.

[@whitwilliams5722]

Not even close

[@roselynschwichtenberg9202]

I'd like to see Nakomis on the list, just because of the fact that she created the backdoor strategy and overall was better than people like Diane and Memphis, but a good list indeed.

[@pesstonwuz3012]

Roselyn Schwichtenberg no she was not good

[@Eric_Reborn]

Created the backdoor is overrated. Anyone could have come up with it she just happened to be in the 1st ever season where it was possible to come up with.

[@blitz_swaggym7873]

Where is Janelle

[@andrewmcdonald1614]

This list isn't good.

[@scoobydoo3888]

Cody Won!

[@jenalef]

WHERE THE FRICK IS JANELLE

[@pedromartinez1595]

Where's janelle

[@connor2953]

Why are Shelli Cody on this list

[@JohnnySportsNetwork]

Paul needs to be #1

[@ja9852]

Johnny Talks Sports No Jason Guy needs to be 1# he went to final 3 without being nomed not only that he won around 9 food comps and was a robbed icon.

[@MidnightUmbra]

@@ja9852 everything you said can go to Paul lol, at least in Season 19. While I dont agree that he should be #1 on the list, he definitely should've won Season 19

[@MidnightUmbra]

Just replace food comps with actual comps

[@ja9852]

@@MidnightUmbra Even if paul did do the same as jason paul wasnt gonna win in the first place and if jason had made final 2 there was a good chance he wouldve won season 3

[@MidnightUmbra]

@@ja9852 thats why I said he doesnt deserve #1. The fact of the matter is, you gave reasons why Jason Guy is better and used reasons that paul had as well. It didnt help your case in the slightest

[@huntre1011]

Janelle?