TOTAL DRAMA: WHAT IF Only The Winning Team Gets To VOTE in Total Drama Island

[@Catathyst]

The finalists are honestly amazing :D

[@eddiealaniz5281]

From a plot standpoint I think Lindsay should be the official winner here and Noah be the alternate. Both are deserving however.

[@Notorious_Critter]

Well in the canon the male is the winner of total drama island (Owen) wich is mentioned in the total drama reboot

[@MadChristoph]

Chris would be happy if Lindsay won

[@blues5087]

This has gotta be one of my favourite what ifs frfr

[@MysticDreamCatcher.]

ty ty 🔥

[@EthanEdits1392]

I have a feeling that if this was real and in the final 4 where Noah talks crap about the other team and then whenDJ and Lindsay are gonna be running to camp like they did it first we were gonna hear Noah’s voice saying something like what took u guys so long😂

[@donutmaxgaming9674]

It’s strange how both DJ and Heather made final 4 despite them both being threats physically and mentally respectively.

[@OCM_AidenMc]

What if there was a season with all the people who have never made merge nishelle noah samey dawn ect

[@RuaidaJajimin]

That would be a great idea

[@cheesetuple]

Non-Merger Island

[@terrantitanium6441]

Noah Lindsey finale goes hard

[@blankblankness2971]

5:27 I always hated that they had to kick Tyler in the canon season because all he had to do was stand in the chicken coop, not touch the chickens or anything.

[@AlejandroGarcia-co8uk]

Idea: What if Heather did not form the alliance between Beth and Lindsay

[@Charles-xe4ow]

Important but unrelated: I don't get why people get Sadie out in Dodge-brawl if the killer bass looses, because Courtney literally stated that if Duncan didn't help them, they would vote him off

[@RF-4C.95]

for the screaming gophers: Noah. for the Killer bass: DJ

[@HunterOfStarz]

Gotta say this outsells the canon TDI so hard

[@strawhatluigi1849]

I feel like in the animal challenge it would be hilarious if Tyler had to catch a chicken and that’s the reason he loses

[@Something_official.]

BOTH WINNERS WOULDVE BEEN AMAZING

[@Mitocomic]

Yooo! Wazzup? This is very awesome, glad to see Noah going really far! Could someone send me the tierlist used for this video, please?

[@CG_-iv1fn]

CODY FINALLY GOT THE SCREE TIME HE DESERVESSS TY MYSTIC

[@SamuelDoherty]

Duncan tried the guys alliance in total drama

[@elitettelbach4247]

Neat concept! I think extending the team phase really worked well here. This is a Lindsay win for me. Noah felt a little too inconsequential imo but he’d be a good alt winner here.

[@blankblankness2971]

2:37 I actually thought you were going to choose Duncan because he was Gwen’s main opponent, and most of the other campers probably know he has a criminal record.

[@omaster2814]

Damn would this twist Change so much

[@alexphillips1935]

9:48 its actually Extreme torture

[@BenHenderson-j8x]

My to favourite characters are in the final! I want Noah to win

[@matheusdemello2323]

What if past winners of seasons became host of next season? If Gwen and/or Owen were co-host with Chris in Action.

[@powerkids7201]

Heather from screaming gophers to win and Geoff from Killer bass to win

[@Charles-xe4ow]

Can you please do "What if Trent was in world tour" I'd love to see his interactions with Gwen, Duncan, and Courtney.

[@devriasst.9717]

Lindsay winner for sure, Noah as alt winner. Lindsay despite not being the brightest is a better overall competitor, would’ve had more support in the final challenge and should’ve actually been a contender to win a total drama season irl anyway. lol

[@barneythedoge8690]

This idea was absolutely amazing

[@Kapuccinow]

Bro this is actually such a cool idea

[@CypherGogeta2011]

i dont think trent lucky number wont be nine any more lol but its real claer who wins,the goat himself noah

[@blankblankness2971]

Final ranking: 22. Geoff 21. Justin 20. Ezekiel 19. Katie 18. Owen 17. Izzy (arrested) 16. Gwen 15. Courtney 14. Beth 13. Harold 12. Eva 11. Bridgette 10. Duncan 9. Trent 8. Sadie 7. Tyler 6. Cody 5. LéShawna (4.5. Mr. Coconut) 4. DJ 3. Heather 2. Noah 1. Lindsay

[@CeruleanPlate]

I think Heather should be in the final because since Lindsay’s there Heather can’t be bald and that’s how she lost originally

[@crazerrazer6778]

I don't think "How they lost originally" should determine who loses now since this situation is purely theoretical

[@txtally_notmars]

I feel like Noah 1st and Lindsay alt because Lindsay would’ve won in action

[@Agustinlarreas8888]

I need this but with Action and World tour

[@olaf-chan-728]

Nahhh 17:38 lindsay and DJ already were a duo Noah x Lindsay on Jungle would be hilarious

[@AllyandTessShipper-rp6my]

Good video. Also I don’t think Harold is weak. And btw I think with him the killer bass would’ve won the talent challenge anyways like in the original. Also I think not having Izzy comeback in this game like the original makes the theory a bit off and drastically changes the outcome of what it could be with this rule. Same thing with the merge happening at a different time.

[@tyler_totaldrama]

Hey Mystic! Can I do the same idea (on a powerpoint) an credit u? I will try to do it kinda different

[@Kapuccinow]

An amazing final 3 lol

[@Charles-xe4ow]

Weird Fact: When you search "Who gets together on total drama" on google one of the answers is Heather and Ezekiel... LIKE WTH

[@ProfessionalTwitterHater]

Weirder fact: searching the same thing has one of the answers being Katie and Noah.

[@alfieburgess3358]

YOU HAVE TOO DO THE OTHER SESONS! (this is realistic,and im not forcing if you don't want to!)

[@Maddyrainbowz]

I love the Noah and Lindsay finale

[@alexander-k5b9y]

Can you do total drama safety chain island so the cast are all merge and whoever wins the challenge chooses someone to be safe and they choose someone over again

[@terrantitanium6441]

Imagine a Leshawna Tyler finale

[@AlexLovesArsenal]

yo this looks interesting

[@Teardrop_3rd_Place]

I feel like it’s a tie and they both win so no alternative ending

[@happytomiityou]

tier list link?

[@MysticDreamCatcher.]

tiermaker.com/create/total-drama-chars--15147694

[@Longrun10]

Noah - Main Winner Lindsay - Alt Winner

[@xxsyl0]

I love the finalist alsoooooo how about reverse elimination order

[@xoxobrynn]

I love ur vids!

[@MysticDreamCatcher.]

ty!

[@terrantitanium6441]

Trent getting ninth is insane

[@Daniel-td5gi]

Honestly in this situation Lindsay should be the alt winner because the only reason she got far was because heather was using her

[@funtimephyrex]

Dude my 3 favorites made it to the merge, and they filled both finalist spots. But imma be honest Noah I think should be the winner, as pigbacking off of the villain ain't worthy of an official win. Also Lindsay probably not smart enough.

[@jumanhack0103]

Man all of these ROBBED Players But This is really realistic tbh

[@Tdibridgettelover]

there was alliance in rr

[@Dino_Nugget_33]

Actually Beth had enough of Heather in the episode where Cody was mauled by a bear

[@villekarasen2487]

this was so good

[@Ballxhan]

Noah and Cody are pairs , wow it’s giving Noco honestly I rather have this what if .

[@sniper.-_bat]

Please I want Lindsay it would be so funny to see her win😂❤

[@stefaniarusso]

Yes I would like the winning team gets to vote in total drama island 🏝 😊

[@overlyfixated21]

Leshawna should've gotten eliminated so many times, she was the strongest team member and if they think it's a jury vote wouldn't they vote leshawna??? That's what the final 5 vote was? Idk just found it a bit strange lmao

[@kingclav6710]

Maybe because they trusted her? I mean she’s pretty sociable and Courtney even told her about Duncan replacing Bunny. Maybe they thought that keeping her would help them not getting eliminated?

[@aayanusman]

I WANTED EVA TO WIN BROO I also wanted Sadie and Katie to win:(

[@פפפפפ-ה9כ]

Do it for the rest of the seasons too❤

[@Nextlevaltheorys]

Lindsey cannon winner and Noah alt winner

[@smn7414]

This is smarts vs dumbness. Also i know i am late.

[@Queenlizzy440]

You should make action

[@darkix8650]

Brains vrs beauty

[@TDI279]

Trent gets 9th as usual 😅

[@cheesetuple]

Trent be self commenting real

[@AlexLovesArsenal]

Rooting for Geoff and Gwen

[@olaf-chan-728]

Tyler and Izzy

[@DamianHendriks-xi6mg]

LINDSAY!

[@NinetyOne999]

All hail plankton

[@Lawsongamez802]

Ezekiel

[@KawaiiSabreNorris]

IK JASMINE WASNT IN THIS VIDEO, BUT CAN YOU PLEASE LET HER WIN ONE TIME

[@פפפפפ-ה9כ]

❤❤❤

[@NessAnimations397]

I think Noah

[@powerkids7201]

Please get Lindsay the winner

[@BFAW_Official7421]

Can you do a season with this character Please??? Team 1 (The team that never lose) Brick Beardo Heater Spud Alejandro Pete Team 2 (The team that some time win and some time not) Geoff Bridgette Katy Sadie Lindsay Beth Team 3 (team that lose all the time) Zee Wayne Sadie B Dawn Justin

[@THE_UNKNOWN_JESTER]

Team w team l and team so so

[@פפפפפ-ה9כ]

Owen's impeachment is unjustified

[@MysticDreamCatcher.]

It probably would get MAD Annoying after awhile

[@L123ucider]

I want noah to win

[@gamerboyjude]

Noah

[@zack-sv8tv]

Noah!!!!

[@Exlosia]

Chef wins

[@MysticDreamCatcher.]

2ez

[@Jimmydean200]

Hi

[@MysticDreamCatcher.]

hi

[@NegativeTree]

3rd!!

[@DontAskForFanart]

HIII

[@MysticDreamCatcher.]

whats good

[@DontAskForFanart]

idk you are amazing have a good day!

[@rogeruwu7776]

first!

[@sandras5674]

Dj and Noah

[@LucasDolls]

Rooting for Heather and Duncan