TRAIN vs CARR!

[@cashbanooka9166]

I'd imagine that if Sir Handel were asked on the question, he'd have something like this to say: "The car only delivered half of its men before me. I, meanwhile, delivered all of my passengers at once. Most of those car men arrived after me, therefore, I should be the winner!"

[@Pongothemerecat]

Skarloey would be disappointed that his friend risked his passengers safety to win. WE NEED THIS AS A FAN STORY

[@AbbeyYard]

​@@Pongothemerecat "YOU BRING DISHONOR TO THE RAILWAY"

[@whytheheckarewedoinginhere1886]

​​@@AbbeyYard DISHONOR, DISHONOR ON THE WHOLE RAILWAY, MAKE NOTE OF THIS, DISHONOR ON YOU, DISHONOR YOUR SHEEP, DISHONOR....! Sorry, I couldn't resist. 🤣

[@DavidBContentExtravaganza3967]

@@Pongothemerecat Especially with Ace as the car.

[@TheGreenJ50Teen58]

I think the Carr team won because half the people on team Carr beaten Train team at the station. But like you said, in the ending of the video, it’s not about winning. It’s about good sportsmanship and fun. and this video was a lot of fun. Someone should make this into a Thomas and friends adaptation.

[@Nutmonk]

Carr

[@Bearthediesel]

Same

[@TheBlueE2]

^^^ this man gets it 👌

[@Archiebugg]

Maybe if it was a Thomas adaptation maybe sir Handel and George should challenge themselves into a race and sir Handel was surprised that George somehow managed to beat him and it ends with George saying “well I had a little help with someone…” and bulgy showed up and sir Handel says “oh for goodness sake” and he sulks on the return train

[@Bearthediesel]

@@Archiebugg i whould pick Caroline remember train stops play

[@thethingfromthelivestreamchat]

Don't let this distract you from the fact that we have documented proof of someone saying "Gotta go fast" in Railway Series canon

[@susanlua4792]

really??!?

[@CakeKingYT]

Wooo! Go Adam! Awdry Extravaganza #5 in 2025 be like: “My car keys got ran over by Talyllyn/Skarloey.”

[@thegamingwolfkingofthemult37]

Lol! You must not leave!" Said Talyllyn/Skarloey darkly.

[@Avery_Productions]

The shots of sir Handel reaching dolgoch station are really cool

[@PlayDontPause]

Dang, this Top Gear reboot hits different.

[@emersoninfinitystone5785]

And just like most of the Top Gear Car vs. Public Transport challenges.... the car wins.

[@cody9526]

Hmmm the key stealer

[@CTTE06]

Now this could turn into a Thomas Story!

[@thefatcontrollershat]

Percy won against Harold because he couldn't land. The car couldn't actually get to the station so train wins by the same logic

[@LimpBizkitMix]

This is more epic than any race episode from Thomas except Thomas & Bertie (because nothing tops that)

[@CraneProductions27]

This felt like watching a classic 'Top Gear' race. I thought the car had won, because I believe from looking at the video that two or three members from Team Car arrived at the platform before the train arrived.

[@Remnant09]

On the bright side in the rain. The ballast lets the rainwater sink through into the ground. Asphalt or Concrete roads don’t do this. They literally have to have drains installed

[@mayohoskotwrandttte]

Look there’s Sir Handle. He tried to race the car but the car nearly beat him. Oh wait it did win. Sir Handle doesn’t mention cars now

[@ps7372]

3:15 just completely dodged the second guys high five😂

[@alexproductions7219]

Was waiting to see who else spotted that 😂

[@Rails-Of-Illinois]

Me when the CP 2816 Final Spike Tour happened because people kept crashing and getting pulled over just because it's a train lol.

[@DuckShowStudios]

It's really cool that you guys got to race Sir Handel! And I'm not sure who won! Great video guys!

[@GoofyCharizard]

This race was so fun to watch this should be a yearly thing

[@eastlancsesteem]

You’ve officially made it to the railway series!

[@EggGuy461]

Carr having 2 rs reminds me of Bigg City Port having 2 gs.

[@jameswasslainbyatree]

5:12 this reminds me so much of that one illustration from Thomas and Bertie, nice to see it somewhat recreated in real life!

[@DavidFigueroa-ns6ij]

This became canon to the railway series

[@Gooberengine]

My American self was so confused when I saw a steering wheel on the right

[@BlakesTrainsandMore4014]

Lol me too

[@Arkay315]

CARR is my favorite railway series character and an inspiration to all

[@MaxwellTheTrainFan]

Both Tho between you and me … the buffers at the end of the line … they were there before any of you started

[@liamnixon4428]

Glad this made into the Unlucky Tug's official Railway Series timeline!!

[@paulschaumkell2724]

GO SIR HANDLE!!!

[@thedanishtrain2004]

THE CAR TEAM WON. ME AND RONAN arrived at the station platform before the train

[@TheBlueE2]

Exactly! Who stopped at the platform successfully first? 👉👉👉👉👉👉👉 me and you

[@DukLoverEKT]

4:30 perfect song choice😂

[@GwrDuck8-8]

When's episode two coming out?

[@shanestrains548]

I feel like the train won because everybody on the train made it to the station before everybody on the car.

[@Chescat124]

I’ve still been waiting for someone to put a race theme over this

[@paulschaumkell2724]

GO GOG GO!

[@Steamlocomotivefan52]

Ah yes, we saw thomas vs bertie, then Percy and halord, now we have sir handle vs carr

[@jeremiahsisaias8677]

Sir Handel vs Ace and other stories. Someone should make a story from this. 😊

[@aliciashepherd8912]

Carr

[@JojoCat2008]

"Look! There's Sir Handel! He tried to race a car, but it and the theorists nearly beat him!"

[@Flyingdurito]

I personally would give this one to the car, only because I could see a few things making the big difference Main one being the keys, if your key wasn’t broken and if you didn’t drop it on your way up to the station like you did, I could see that little bit of extra time being saved from having a proper working key being the big difference maker

[@Trainboy17]

Wales Vs Ireland 2025 should make a grand 80th anniversary race

[@Steamlocomotivefan52]

I think sir handle won, all the boys arrived at the same time while the carr boys didnt

[@alexproductions7219]

I'd personally say the train won since the driver of the Car didn't reach the platform before the train and since Adam was still parking the car it'd be unfair to say the car has won when the driver was still parking it when the train arrived. However I think a rematch at Awdry Ex 5 would be great so a clear winner can be found.

[@cgregistry]

0:52 Thomas And Bertie's Great Race Refrence

[@pugtrainmaster5326]

Sir handle one the race in a glorious victory I imagine his fireman was singing like percys after his race with harlod

[@frantasramota1359]

Imagine if somebody would wrote a fan story about this race.

[@kellyrogers3250]

Hello thomas theorist I'm from Ireland to

[@numtraingames5713]

Also I met you on both Saturday and Sunday.

[@soilightausanimation]

4:15 Gotta go fast sonic impression

[@tanyaburton3122]

LOOK HERES SIR HANDEL HE TRIED TO RACE A CAR BUT THE CAR NEARLY BEET HIM!

[@ThomasFangthe-j3d]

7:04 car

[@242mtproductions4]

could we adapt this into a story it would be funny

[@kajsalzman272]

What car it was i mean manufacturer and model you Were driving in this race

[@awesometrain77]

Train because it made it to the station first I'm not counting running

[@joshuaW5621]

Honestly train should usually be the winner here, unless you’re in Wexford.

[@DavidBContentExtravaganza3967]

This ought to be made into a fan Thomas story around Sir Handel racing Ace.

[@spyfan62591]

How salty was sir handel when he returned to the SKR, RWS story anyone, someone make a fan story based off this.

[@Duncan6173]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/l32TmpaCicSEsJIsi=B9I3AsxEWSq7SPz7 made it a two weeks ago

[@GwrDuck8-8]

Keysssssssssss!

[@tjmfarming9584]

So is Carr officially a railway series character? I didn't get to watch the TR livestream during the race so I missed a bit of it

[@Wishiwashi_64]

Man, too bad they didn’t own a bus! DX

[@Nutmonk]

Where EEEERRRRRRNNNNNIIIIEEEEE

[@TuckerFriends]

Isnt ser Handel blue?

[@FallenFlagFoamer]

Average American railfan when they see a 80mph train running near a highway.

[@ok1147]

make a viddeo about the little engine that could pls

[@EMITablet0596]

Technical the some people made it to the station before the train i will say that the car won

[@ashooaway]

Who won, I think we need a sequel.

[@Hacksworth_Sidings]

Would’ve won if they had a Eurobeat playlist that screams “MY VIRGINITY IS STILL IN TACT” blasting in the background smh

[@営団地下鉄有楽町線]

タリスリン鉄道?

[@maiyo8518]

To be safe, I would say the car won

[@KristyUnderdown]

Go Carr!

[@robrice7246]

Does the Skarloey Railway have their equivalent of Carr?

[@RicardoGaming09]

I don't known if he was a Joke or a canceled character

[@GwrDuck8-8]

Car team

[@RogueProbe]

EPIC

[@isakdahlgren8335]

hi thomas theorist

[@tonanleo3494]

Sir handle and the car.

[@drewlorence4889]

Carr will appear in cgi animation

[@supermaomaoholdensmo3400]

Thomas and friends

[@harrisonallen651]

*C A R R*

[@ThatGuy38757]

Choo Choo vs Vroom

[@jaanshersaeed4541]

Grown Adults Drive and Run Like Maniacs Over Racing a Train and Other Stories

[@VeryBigEngines]

Thomas and Bertie be like:

[@Jamestheredproductions5]

I made a video about this.

[@CAMPBELLOBK97]

Sir Handel and Car

[@RustonProductions-AVRE]

You were both first and third

[@elmavandenakker8794]

Train

[@elmavandenakker8794]

Car

[@programmepafe3934]

One shall stand,one shall fall

[@buzzlightyearstudio3522]

Car definitely 😁

[@frgoodbadstuffp600]

cer 7:10

[@NitroIndigo]

Why is it called the boat train?

[@ThomasTheorist]

Is based off the boat train that was pulled on the Mid Sodor in the railway series to the harbour.

[@iamatrainfan]

​@@ThomasTheorist Hi

[@mispinchergamings3470]

Lost your keys?//

[@numtraingames5713]

CAR WON!

[@OldEdward-q7p]

train sir handl

[@judesir]

Carr Won It was never a rule that everyone had to be there at the station

[@TheBlueE2]

Exactly 👌👌 *A* representative of one of the two competing parties got to said platform before anyone of the opposing party did, therefore *Adam and the car boys won...!!!!*

[@mario_master1]

i say car won as half made it ther befor the train and they had to go back as they droped somthing so car won

[@Ninja11125]

I won

[@elishaturner-sherratt31]

Train wins (my opinion)

[@KianWesternRailway]

The train won

[@nickdoe6058]

Car

[@brettolson3905]

I think the Carr won

[@wegoeverywhere6710]

Car won

[@Test_key]

Sir Haydn look better in red ngl

[@TransportForHK]

Thats not Sir Haydn,thats Number 10 from the Corris Railway

[@CarsonsPlushiePalooza]

CARR won

[@masterJ2004]

Bish carr won lol

[@Damon_Drawings]

Train

[@traincrash7099]

Car