The Safdie Brothers and Ari Aster on Scorsese (2020)

[@budusbusham3324]

This feels like the two cool nerds bullying the nerd-nerd.

[@Valkonnen]

No it's two Sephardic and an Ashkenazi.

[@uvarovnikita]

Hahaha

[@Zehahahaa]

Freaking sefdies lol

[@oscarsalesgirl296]

The Safdie Brothers are actually intelligent and Ari Astor has nothing interesting to say

[@thumbprintn2413]

lol

[@lernernernerdicapricorn6914]

This is the most energetic I've ever seen Ari in an interview

[@shirleysonsproductions6187]

Probably cause he’s not with like a journalist or something. He’s with other filmmakers, likes he’s with his friends

[@brentulstad3275]

Comfortable and casual among like minds.

[@citeriorcf]

the future of american cinema here

[@TheWelchProductions]

They’re too good for mainstream audiences.

[@mogensgallardo3288]

@@Nonesovile96 Ummm, no.

[@TheWelchProductions]

John Not worse, just different. I encourage you to look at the evolution of film directors from a more open-minded perspective.

[@ng2603]

throw in panos cosmos and Robert Eggers and you're there

[@ng2603]

@@Nonesovile96 they've just started

[@TBPBP]

I can't imagine asking Josh Safdie to be quiet for 10 seconds of room tone.

[@ng2603]

benny is the quintessential younger brother … josh is always talking over him lol

[@TheShadyPenguin]

Not trying to knock him, but there seems to be very little substance to what Benny says in this. He sounds like he's stoned and just gesturing vaguely at things lol

[@GellertTV]

Weird in other videos it's the opposite lol

[@wiggly_anemone]

As if this isn't awesome already, but if they added Robert Eggers I would explode 🔥

[@serge791]

Yeah but Eggers is stuck in Northern Ireland working on a project

[@Wiz83]

Greta Gerwig too.

[@phantasmagorical4422]

@@Wiz83 I think Robert Eggers should have been there not greta gerwig because Greta's inspirations are not related to this discussion. Ari and Eggers have a lot in common.

[@juradojosh1]

Check out the A24 podcast Eggers and Aster talk to each other about cinema and their movies

[@martin.supertramp]

You read my mind!

[@flrnce]

24:05 the way all three of them are just silently judging the setup of the cameras is so hilarious to me

[@futuropasado]

You add Robert Eggers here and there you have the best young directors in the world. Pure talent.

[@kaseybones]

i was literally going to comment the same thing.

[@amincamus6337]

Exacly my new favourite directors (btw they all became famous by A24)

[@jdrummerdd]

and jordan peele

[@flensoest]

@@jdrummerdd haha jordan peele, good one

[@darrenbrown7037]

I really like Panos Cosmatos

[@WickedGoodWood]

It's hilarious seeing directors being interviewed and they can't help but critic the camera and setup. Directors gotta direct. I could probably watch them talk about movies all day. Love Scorsese, filmmakers from across the world are standing on his shoulders.

[@ClaudiusPtolemy]

critique*

[@craigmurdock4740]

LOL the safdies just never shut up and ari is too nice and quiet, this is amazing.

[@krokelhead232]

Even in real life they have Duel dialogs

[@Seeattle]

these guy are the freaking A team...some of the best most original creators out there right now!!

[@dakotaspruell1083]

Itallianamerican - 1974 What's A Nice Girl Like You Doing In A Place Like This - 1963 The Big Shave - 1967 It's Not just You, Murray! - 1964 American Boy: A Profile of Steven Prince - 1978

[@lonewalkerproductions]

Thank you!

[@finnanderson9941]

Man, this is just a bunch of cool dudes, talking about their heroes. And it is so wholesome to see. Their passion for film, and Scorsese is intoxicating.

[@Seeattle]

I feel like every Scorsese movie has a scene where somebody mentions how they need to keep stirring the sauce

[@jakek1735]

I'M STIRRIN' IT

[@HandsOfCinderblock]

Don't put too much onions in da sauce.

[@cremetangerine82]

Not in “The Age of Innocence” or “Kundun”, though. Unless there’s an outtake in the former movie where a maid burns the cream of watercress soup.

[@aniruddhagowda8072]

Something meta about them talking about Scorcese's search for reality through documentaries and the interaction between them and the crew

[@MasonJulianGregory]

I love the end where Josh is wordlessly saying like, "what's that third camera angle for?!"

[@CollegeLincolnBHall]

give this editor a raise god damn

[@hollywoodswinging3785]

Bravo to whoever put this together

[@Gabriel2000Brescia]

Criterion did this

[@tonywords6713]

ari should really have backup here

[@stickwoodthebrand]

I say they should’ve gotten Robert Eggers to back him up

[@wyattjohnson3714]

There really needs to be like an A24 directors conversation. Like this but with Eggers, etc.

[@navigatingmadness180]

@@wyattjohnson3714 there is an A24 podcast. Aster and Eggers had an episode, and the Safdie Bros were with PTA

[@NemorisInferioris]

I don't think he needs it

[@BenGunnx]

@@dx315 way better than Eggers but Eggers is closer to Aster, stylistically speaking

[@moosemush]

Film school kids see the title of this video and gasp with joy

[@aslan9334]

Not just film school kids but anyone that loves film

[@cremetangerine82]

I cried when I saw this on KZbin!

[@omipeople7071]

The crossover I’ve always wanted

[@MidnightVideo]

Haha. Btw if you like horror: kzbin.info/www/bejne/oqC6nGWNpslrnsk

[@ftuT]

Still weird to see Robert Pattinson's handicapped brother talking like a smart guy. Still, it's cool to see this film geniuses are just typical nerds. First noted the trend with Todd Solondz.

[@turq1824]

Seriously can't wait for what he releases next. This guy brought back horror in a new refreshing way.

[@reflexjat3822]

Have you watched Beau is afraid yet?

[@kennethlisungan5734]

yea whatd you think about beau is afraid man

[@neilisalive4892]

I love Josh but the man's gotta let other people speak lmao

[@49dwalin55]

These guys are pushing cinema in the right direction

[@stephatflashpoint]

the future of cinema

[@oscarsalesgirl296]

God help us

[@renn4913]

​@@oscarsalesgirl296 why? They are good directors

[@grantkistel3411]

I love how much focus is given to Martin’s clear vision to describe and contemplate very human and familial feelings, through a lease always so expertly crafted to that time, mixed with his own view, and those that inspired him.

[@midkrylegda7887]

Safdie Brothers, Aster, Eggers, Zhao, Chazelle, Jenkins, Peele and Gerwig. The future of American cinema is in their hands.

[@10md.]

s craig zahler too, and hopefully David Raboy can put out a second one equal to or above the giant

[@Jim-iz3oy]

Safdie, Chazelle and Eggers are going places. Aster is a one hit wonder, Zhao is talentless, Peele is a hack and Gerwig surely can’t make another autobiography of herself again.

[@dionatasmartins4719]

@@Jim-iz3oy "one hit wonder" wtf bro scorsese loves midsommar and hereditary and midsommar is bong joon-ho's favorite modern horror picture (and in general)

[@braytechexoscience2790]

Safdies, Aster, Eggers, Chazelle, Jenkins and Gerwig - sure. Nomadland's great but Zhao just made fucking Eternals, so there goes almost all of her credit considering how awful that movie is. Get Out is a great film largely for its writing (which, to be fair, credit deservingly goes to Peele for), but the direction is nothing too spectacular, and his endeavors since haven't been that great. He's not a talentless hack or anything, he's just second to all the others listed.

[@Jim-iz3oy]

@@dionatasmartins4719 “this celebrity filmmaker likes this movie therefore it’s good.”

[@Israel_Girmay]

This interview felt like watching 'Uncut gems'; I guess the Safdie's just lend that energy.

[@DizzyBusy]

Ari already asked if it were going to be them yelling over each other at the beginning. This is the Safdie energy indeed 😂

[@morallita]

The crossover of the decade

[@Eliaskoch111]

I was nodding my head this entire video

[@mohammedmahmoud8667]

Had the biggest smile while watching all 24 minutes

[@RADFLIKINCRRQT13]

Poor soft spoken Ari, trapped in a room with these 2 motor-mouths and they're discussing his favorite topic. It's like watching a tricycle competing in NASCAR Fun little discussion though. Love the Safdi bros and Ari

[@tonywords6713]

lol

[@StereoChimps]

you just described how their film feels like, like a running unstop motor hehehe, theyr the coolest brothers in film business after the coen brothers... just chill Ari was enjoyning

[@LeslieDugger]

He doesn’t need your sympathy

[@beavisdoge237]

Yeah poor him, hanging with his bros talking about stuff they love

[@RADFLIKINCRRQT13]

@@beavisdoge237 is this reply fueled by your top comment envy towards me?

[@filmisjustmovingpictures]

I love this. I've learnt so much about Scorsese films I haven't even heard of. Can't wait to check them out. And it's so awesome seeing and hearing other directors talk about other directors works. I find that therapeutic for some reason.

[@jakegetscake4672]

Ari is amazing can’t wait to see his next movie

[@nextabe1]

Wow I'm sold on the Scorsese shorts

[@cremetangerine82]

They’re all on KZbin!

[@jimmysevillano3428]

lmao Josh and at the end like "what the hell is this shot just taking the black backdrop"

[@giuliorasi]

I think he’s saying that the wide shot is “crossing the line” with the single shots

[@TheWhills]

I enjoyed every minute of this, but I really wish they had let Ari talk more

[@Guccicurry]

Ari: "he was just so incredibly nuanced and such a energetic film maker back then" Marty in 1980: *_anybody got cocaine?_*

[@jermyhopkisn9654]

Yeah, he was so energetic he very nearly died.

[@brentulstad3275]

Be real interesting to see these three collaborate on an anthology.

[@vilentman111]

6:52 Holy shit. Fight Club

[@WyniciusRothstein]

Um dos melhores debates que eu já vi(entre diretores) sobre a obra do Scorsese, diretores promissores que prometem moldar muito o cinema pelas próximas decádas. Se adicionasse o Eggers a essa roda de conversa, teriamos uma trindade santissima.

[@StevenSclafani]

I need that sync device at 4:15. I've been trying to figure out exactly what it is since I purchased the Italian American laserdisc in 1990. I'm guessing that the person that edited this clip knows what it is. Please divulge.

[@StevenSclafani]

Bloop Slate

[@Teerapatkongrat]

These guys is gonna become legend of our times, them with Robert Eggers and Jordan Peele.

[@powerofmovies687]

This is really great discussion

[@ElenGlazova]

Omg I can watch it endlessly!

[@patrickomalley9716]

Thanks for posting

[@shanewatts5115]

In a medium that has become so dominated by superhero movies the likes of The Safdie Brothers, Ari Ester, Robert Eggers and Jordan Peele make me hopeful for the future of cinema.

[@shanewatts5115]

@Puertorican Santa i think Get Out and Us were brilliant. Love his style. Like Eggers, he has a new, unique way of blending horror with comedy. How many good films have you made?

[@shanewatts5115]

@Puertorican Santa Wow, that's great man. Looking forward to seeing it. Hopefully it's not as cringe as your KZbin videos.

[@raineyelaine]

@Puertorican Santa Aster, Eggers, and Peele have all only directed two feature films, all six of which were critically acclaimed. What makes Jordan Peele any different than them?

[@lonewalkerproductions]

Preach Shane!

[@freshness222]

Why? Most superhero movies are better than theirs.

[@jamesoconnor7888]

@17:33 sound guy in the back is like yo dude... don't do that... don't do that

[@mikehawk439]

i love that they took a second to check on the crew true directors

[@Neat0_o]

All I want to see is ari aster and Robert eggers talk about horror. Is there a convo with them out there?

[@peach_cinema8662]

check out the extended discussion they did for the a24 podcast

[@Neat0_o]

@@peach_cinema8662 is that here on KZbin?

[@peach_cinema8662]

@@Neat0_o I’m not sure but you should be able to find it on Spotify

[@SaulEli7]

@@Neat0_o I believe it’s on that a24. If not, google it, it’ll pop up.

[@isaakkimmel6951]

Spotify A24 podcast, hour long convo

[@keepyoureyespeeled1]

That description of him shooting a guy on speed is also said again, essentially verbatim, in one of the vignettes in Richard Linklater's Waking Life.

[@driziiD]

this has to be from The Criterion Channel

[@HandsOfCinderblock]

Marty's mom seems like the nicest lady tbh.

[@cremetangerine82]

R.I.P. Catherine Scorsese.

[@chrisharp8362]

my two favorite upcoming directors talking about the god of directors

[@driziiD]

lol, it legit looks like Ari Aster is interviewing the Safdie brothers 😂

[@justinhopper5941]

Nice of Joe Pera to show up

[@joshprice3730]

this discussion is like hectic jazz

[@alvarogutierrez9906]

I feel like the waiter walking in a conversation

[@willgipson5837]

Could be a coincidence (doubt it) but at 7:38 the echo sounds just like Joan yelling "get out" at Peter in Hereditary

[@deshong5047]

This might be the best video on the internet. Or at least my favorite..

[@ianhodges2524]

This sounds like a discussion between me and my friends while doing cocaine at 3am

[@christinapaterno5585]

Can i come?

[@HLMProduction003]

This conversation is a Safdie bros. scene 😂

[@roach9397]

lol I was thinking the same thing. Everyone's talking over each other, they keep getting interrupted by audio problems. Wonderfully chaotic.

[@gautamkhanna118]

In the end when he says about the sauce is ✨✨

[@orphanion9468]

Damn, this was dope

[@thegreasystrangler5031]

Love these guys and their movies.

[@itamarhurtadoparavicini9432]

En este grupo faltaba Robert Eggers y son el futuro del cine

[@abloshow91]

The end is so fkn loud 😂😂😂

[@iamsheep]

I wonder how Ari Aster feels about Scorsese calling him an "extraordinary filmmaker".

[@cremetangerine82]

11:07 - Adjusted for inflation, a $20 tie would be $168.76 in 2021 dollars.

[@respobabs]

couldn't believe it, looked it up, true

[@gxrsky]

Hey! We're in a groove!!

[@Petergonzalezcomedy]

film is safe in the hands of these guys

[@Guz1316]

Best directors of today

[@aaronpwh33ler]

Loved Josh silently critiquing the other camera setup during room tone

[@thenightmarecircuspodcast9999]

TO be honest I clicked this because I thought it said Safdie Brothers and Ari Aster on SUNSCREEN

[@austinchaseofficial]

I love Ari ❤

[@boopa2518]

My three favorite directors

[@_fidelio]

Jesus, leave the sound guy alone

[@cremetangerine82]

They’re directors, that instinct is hard to put down.

[@tnreprasentog7769]

Ari is the best director in that room by far imo

[@4r1777]

definitely not by far, ari's films resonate with me more but the safdie brothers are absolutely incredible.

[@beflygelt]

17:29 "don't do this?" :O "ok" (;

[@lolamento4511]

someone knows who was the photographer Ari mentioned on the minute 7:58?

[@砂糖市-d6q]

La Grand Amour 1969

[@camilominon9249]

Love this!

[@NothingProductiveProductions]

I would pay money for them to do a podcast

[@RamiroEloy1997]

Robert Eggers, Safdie Brothers, Ari Aster

[@DendyJungle]

Martins mom had such sweet Mediterranean eyes. Reminds me of my ex. I'm crying now

[@ruffserafin]

These Sadie brother interviews are just too damn short.

[@rosiemurray2611]

could we get a whole podcast of this setup

[@idontevenlikemoney]

These men aren't the future of cinema, they are the present. They are the now. And it's exciting. Just because Disney and Warner have taken over the block buster slots, doesn't mean jack shit. The idea of a theatre being the only way to experience cinema these days is just wrong. When i watch great personal films, stuff like Uncut Gems or Hereditary, I don't wanna watch it in a theatre with other people, I wanna watch it at home alone or with my friends. The only time I go to the theatre is to watch Super Hero shit because my friends invite me. If you think Cinema is dead, that just means you don't respect it enough to go out and find it.

[@vgrepairs]

I watched midsommar and hereditary in silent movie theaters and they were amazing. I watched them each again at a time slot in a theater filled with teenagers and random families and they were the worst movies I had ever seen.

[@Pumpkinking64]

No wonder Benny left to make his own stuff... he is the quintessential little brother.

[@brynleyjones2674]

The movie brats of the 2010's

[@46metube]

Uncut Gems is the film Scorsese hasn't made yet.

[@ss-to7ii]

Okay im at 8 mins in. Im going to stop here. Watch as many Scorsese films as possible, and then come back.

[@gastonmamy7107]

Taxi driver, raging bull, the king of comedy, goodfellas, the aviator, the departed, shutter island, hugo, the wolf of wall street, the irishman. Watch those works!!!! You must

[@brandoncelaya2806]

After Hours as well, super fucking underrated

[@charlie__a]

i literally did that

[@cremetangerine82]

Don’t sleep on “The Age of Innocence” and “Bringing Out the Dead”. They don’t get enough love.

[@dumbledorethegreyhobbit6055]

I hadn’t seen Ari before this I had only seen his work, I didn’t expect the dude who made this super disturbing avant garde shit to look like a nerdy Bill Burr lol

[@lauramerlier5872]

hahahaha three film nerds talkings sound like a 100 people in a cafe

[@H1K8T95]

24:06 benny safdie looks like he's locked in his million dollar answer for Who Wants To Be A Millionaire and knows he's correct

[@rikoguitar]

Music at the end?

[@itamarhurtadoparavicini9432]

Los hermanos Safdi son los hermanos Coen de nuestros tiempos

[@cemaldindar771]

Where is this from? A dvd?

[@pacielsadboycinefilo]

So apparently, Josh is literally me