True Apparitions vs False Ones

  Рет қаралды 32,908

Michael Whitcraft

Michael Whitcraft

10 жыл бұрын

A lecture I gave on how to distinguish True Apparitions from false ones.

Пікірлер: 132
@silenceetsolitude5649
@silenceetsolitude5649 9 жыл бұрын
Amazing lecture! This should be subtitled and promoted to the entire world! Many catholics are so confused by many alleged marian apparitions today and this lecture is so clear and balanced! Thank you very much for posting it!
@gisellekichi9499
@gisellekichi9499 6 жыл бұрын
Maybe you are confused because you are not a true Catholic
@franksam6818
@franksam6818 2 жыл бұрын
@@gisellekichi9499 That's a good thing he's not blinded
@alexchristopher221
@alexchristopher221 8 жыл бұрын
One can identify false claims by examining the messages of the Blessed Virgin Mary. If they contain grave theological errors and contradict Church doctrines, then they are false.
@TruthBeTold7
@TruthBeTold7 4 жыл бұрын
@Mike Bronson You don't know the definition of contradiction. They are implicitly in Scripture. Something can be outside the Bible while not necessarily contradicting the Bible. The popes have the divine authority to teach.
@TruthBeTold7
@TruthBeTold7 4 жыл бұрын
@Mike Bronson How does heaven contradict the Bible? Jesus said most people go to Hell. How is crowded Hell unbiblical?
@TruthBeTold7
@TruthBeTold7 4 жыл бұрын
He mentioned that. Did you listen to the whole lecture?
@stephenphillips4984
@stephenphillips4984 3 жыл бұрын
That presumes Church doctrines cannot be wrong. You are begging the question in using this as a criterion for judging whether claims are false. False logic. Sorry. You fail.
@helenlewis1065
@helenlewis1065 3 жыл бұрын
@@stephenphillips4984 In the name of Jesus Christ I command you, you spirit of Stephen Phillips, to depart without doing harm to Stephen Phillips. Amen
@stephanielane1821
@stephanielane1821 6 жыл бұрын
It worries me that so many people defend a supposed apparition that has not yet been approved by the Church! This alone is a cause for concern, the devil can appear as an Angel of light!
@Alwayslearnimg
@Alwayslearnimg 5 жыл бұрын
Stephanie Lane amen!!!!!
@Odo-so8pj
@Odo-so8pj 2 жыл бұрын
Satan wants they to worship Mary. Anything but Our father and Christ.
@chickasawstarrmountain9747
@chickasawstarrmountain9747 4 жыл бұрын
I'm a Christian and have been saved by the blood of JESUS Christ and Mary mother of JESUS is blessed among all women ever! And this world is worse than ever;we are hated ;but we must put on the full armor of God everyday to protect us and fight the good fight
@NaYawkr
@NaYawkr 5 жыл бұрын
satan, the foul, filthy and disgusting one, so fears Our Blessed Mother that he tries anything to discourage people from Hearing Our Blessed Mother, to heeding her loving statements. This tells us just how truly good, and Powerful is everything given us through Mary the Holy Mother of God.
@Odo-so8pj
@Odo-so8pj 2 жыл бұрын
Who died for you? Whos blood was poured out for you? Who is comming back?
@gamers7800
@gamers7800 7 жыл бұрын
Got to love the late arrival at 21:09.
@johncharleson8733
@johncharleson8733 5 жыл бұрын
She should have been ejected.
@billinfo4769
@billinfo4769 Жыл бұрын
even with multiple warning that he was talking about a false apparition they still missed the point
@bonnietremblay8929
@bonnietremblay8929 7 жыл бұрын
Good video. Padre Pio once said if it's a true apparition of Mary, you can see her feet. If it's false, her gown will cover her feet because Satan can not imitate her feet which crushes his head . The seers of Medjugorje said they could not see her feet. Enough said.
@marykalinowski3730
@marykalinowski3730 7 жыл бұрын
Bonnie Tremblay yes I have heard this same theory about the feet
@antneyfatts665
@antneyfatts665 5 жыл бұрын
I'd like to give my testimony about Medj. Before I go on, forgive the grammar, spelling. Trying to make this short, might be tough. So, if you don't like reading long replies, go to the next vid! Lol I was born in 1970 and only went to church on the holidays, after my parents split up, CCD was given up since there was nobody to watch me. 7th grade came along and opened my eyes to the world of drugs. From 83-93, there's not a drug that wasn't consumed to the fullest. I became the person we tell our children to stay away from. My favorite of all was Angel Dust (PCP) and what crack/heroin addicts do to feed their habit, I did for this drug. Accept sell myself on the corner, but car radios, cars and the church's in my town had to start locking their doors because of me. In no way, shape or form am I proud of these things, but it was who I was. Though PCP is not habit forming, it made me feel complete and offered a false sense of hope/courage. 12 days before my 19th birthday I became a dad and it slowed me down a little. We broke up 3 months later and I made up for lost time. At this time I graduated to heroin. Speedballed the very first time I did it and like most that start, sniffing it was the justification of not being a "Junk bag." As much as I liked it, it was not going to get the best of me like dust had. Moved in with my devote Catholic grandmother a few months later ( Nov 89) and came across a newspaper that read "...I come to tell you God does exist!" By the time the first paragraph was read, my soul knew that this place was on radar for a future visit. How and when was the question of all questions. At this time I was a full blown atheist and said the Lord's name in vain every second. After reading that paper, it stopped in an instant. A few years went by and I was still living the life, accept for robbing and stealing. I came into a boat load of money in early 93. My mom found out about a woman that went to Medj every month, (but little did we know this woman was great friends with one of the visionaries) despite the war that was raging. My mother's birthday is in April, but the trip was fully booked, so the May trip is when she decided to go. As she was begging and pleaded with me to go, I was too busy being the "Prodigal Son." Well, 2.5 weeks before she was to go and before I even opened my eyes one morning, I heard with my heart and soul, not my ears, "Go!" It shook the very fiber of my being. As my mom was talking on the phone down stairs, I shouted, "Before I change my mind, call that woman!" Like any mother would, she hung up without saying goodbye and made the call. Once there and hearing horror stories of 13 year old girls and their mothers talking about being repeatedly raped for days on end made my hate for America vanish and finally realized how great we have it. After going to confession for the first time since first Holy Communion, what seemed to be 10 minutes, was really 2 hours. When coming out of the confessional, my mom's jaw dropped because she could see I was glowing with happiness and peace. We hugged each other and cried/laughed with joy. We looked towards Cross mountain and saw a huge rainbow above the Cross in the cloudless sky. By the 4th day, I wanted to return the following month for the 12th anniversary. It was booked solid. After coming home, my soul was on fire beyond words. Seeing I was the worst of all my friends, if it could happen to me, then my friends stood a greater chance. Well, I was truly wrong. They harassed, belittled and tormented me with endless mocking. The heartache was above and beyond immense torment, because of them. I lived the messages to the fullest, Rosary, daily Mass, weekly confession etc...about a week before the June trip were to leave, that woman called me up and said an open seat just became available. I was all over it and couldn't wait for that trip. I've known about Medj since 89 and watched many vids on it, my fav was the one when Martin Sheen as he went for 88 anniversary. However, with all I've watched and read about over the years and even being there a month previous, nobody could have ever told me what it's like to be in a room as Our Lady appears. Whenever I think of this day, even right now as I right this, I well up. Moments before she had her apparition, there was total chaos going on in that house. Italians were climbing through her windows, barging down the door, pushing, shoving etc...before letting my anger get the best of me, I went to the other side of the room and could not see the visionary. Well, not knowing what time it was, 12 40 came and I dropped to my knees. My whole life was flashing before my before my tear filled eyes, everything I ever did, saw, said was being erased from my mind. Just like we clean out our Pc's with useless files, that's what was happening to me. The best way this can be described is, if I were to digest every drug and experience every bodily pleasure at once, it couldn't remotely come close to what happened that June 25, 1993. I couldn't remember family, friends, names and for the life of me couldn't even remember what my bedroom looked like. The term born again finally made sense, because my life never existed before that day and it was if I was born and raised in Medj. We'd be here for days if I explained all of my 22 trips and the miracles that happened, I'll start wrapping it up with this. I was born and raised in the projects just a mile north of Boston. Before going in June of 95, i was getting my things together before heading for the airport, when all of a sudden, that same voice from 2 years earlier, said a womans name that amplified in my room. As i shrugged it off, i grabbed my passport and went out thw door. There was a family from a town I never heard of by Cape Cod. We became close on that trip. However, one of the daughter's and I became inseparable. Her name was that of the voice I heard before leaving my house. I couldn't tell her because we both know she would've high tailed it out of there. Lol I proposed to her on the 96 trip and we brought our first born for the Jubilee in 00. Haven't been there since 12 and every June that passes is unbearable. If what you claim is false, then it's a miracle in itself that the devil is telling people to go to church, follow Christ and receive all the sacraments. I was the devils disciple for many years....in the sense of the lifestyle I lived. Haven't lived that way since May of 93 and had I not gone, I would have met the same fate my close friends had.....most of them are dead, some in prison and the ones God chose to hear my prayers about, are alive and doing fine. Though they still don't believe, prayers are still said for them. As far as what St. Pio said, it wasn't the feet, rather the eyes. Just remember this, every apparition from the past as it was going on, including St. Pio, was thought to be false and of the devil as well. Unless you go and experience it yourself, do not listen to what the others that haven't say. St. Pope Paul II once said, according to Pope Benedict, "If I could go to Medjugorje in cognito, I'd already be there!" That's a fact too. Though my life is far from perfect, Mary introducing me to Her Son and God the Father, forever changed my life above and beyond words. To all those reading this that feel hopeless, suicidal, miserable because you feel the world and every one it, especially friends and family, are against you. Just know that God does exist and do not give up! You might hit rock bottom a few more times, but DO NOT GIVE UP AND TRUST IN HIS MERCY!!!! If He did it for a person like me that stole from His House, he'll do much more for you! MIR
@fortitude120
@fortitude120 4 жыл бұрын
@@karragullenwaterdrilling5618 Just because miracles happen at Medjugorje, that doesn't have to mean that the seers are actually legit. Remember what Jesus said? Any congregation in his name will inhabit his spirit and show his spirit.
@wilts43
@wilts43 4 жыл бұрын
@@antneyfatts665 Thank You for your witness Antney. But _this_ is the best film about Medugorge kzbin.info/www/bejne/f17GqWeVnbmJbqs
@ezekielvallada3997
@ezekielvallada3997 4 жыл бұрын
True
@AdvocatusDiaboli92
@AdvocatusDiaboli92 9 жыл бұрын
Very helpful and enlightening. Thank you
@TruthBeTold7
@TruthBeTold7 4 жыл бұрын
Apparitions like at Fatima (and the miracle of the sun), Guadalupe and Lourdes contributed to my conversion, because they are so powerful.
@organicpots1941
@organicpots1941 4 жыл бұрын
Apparitions like Fatima also dispel heresies such as Sedevacantism.
@mathewcatherine8172
@mathewcatherine8172 3 жыл бұрын
Organic Pots can you elaborate on this ? I'm just very curious how. Thanks
@lorichet
@lorichet Жыл бұрын
@@organicpots1941 In what way? And in what way is Sedevacantism heresy? I'm not a Sedevacantist, btw. I just don't believe they're either heretics or schismatics because they believe Catholic doctrine and the authority of the Papacy in principle.
@ebels5918
@ebels5918 4 жыл бұрын
Can you imagine the sacrilege the devil brought about after Vatican II , example being that woman you’re speaking being told by some apostate priest she can be a Eucharistic minister when the Church never allowed anything but the consecrated hands of a priest to touch the blessed Sacrament . Horrible . Fatima was about the apostasy that would begin at the top .
@Odo-so8pj
@Odo-so8pj 2 жыл бұрын
Fatima was Mohammad daughter. Islam. Never listen to "Mary". Trust in Jesus
@FpeEddie2
@FpeEddie2 Жыл бұрын
Our Lady of La Salette said the same
@stephendufort4154
@stephendufort4154 5 жыл бұрын
I contacted the then head of the Congregations of Saints. He was kind enough to answer my questions one of which asked if there were a recent fully approved or recommended by him, used by the said Congressions as to the guidelines, medical spiritual, etc, etc which I might really get some depth as to all proceedings, used local BISHOP, and the Vatican which investigates and in detail what is required of the Local Bishop to actually prepare and fulfill all that is required by the Vatican. I also had taken part in a very small way, when the Servant of God Luisa Piccarretta was completed, in Bari Italy where I was invited to attend by the Bishop there on a week-long stay some years ago. Firstly, people do not realize, but unfortunately, there are many cases which are yet to come forth, due to pure lack of finances, and or, lack of the necessary theologians. So there are cases where they just do not have sufficient funds yet, or theologians, etc., some going back far, and others even recent. My point is just because a seer or believed saint, is still not even begun, it does not follow they should be considered false. Not that you did not make that point, but I think we should make that clearer. Yes, it cost a tremendous amount of money. In the case of Luisa, in addition to being a saint, her writings on the Divine Will had to be all gone over for any shred of false teaching, by the proper type of theologians, also certain Priests all head to be sworn in under oath in Rome, I believe, all witnesses all medical Doctors and of course the Bishop had to find and have sworn in proper medical people scientist, psychologist, witnesses, and it took him Years, in the end at the local level,there were two extremely large boxes, nearly as large as a Volkswagen, sealed, with large seals. He had on the diocesan, had to approve all her writings, all miracles, all medical the spiritual life, etc. It was no easy task before it could be sent to Rome. There a similar long investigation ensues which focuses on; if she practiced heroic virtues, She will be canonized, I sure, I hope within my lifetime The devil cannot produce any miracles, only false ones, the devil has no power to instantly cure leprosy for example ,but there are GROWING LIST OF DISEASE which is not and does not qualify as can be used to lift a servant of God to Vulnerable like MS, CERTAIN TYPES OF tumors and the list is longer. Anything so-called miracle, which the devil is the author, always, always is false he has zero power to cure anyone, only fool us, for example, he disturbs one soul to the point of madness, and he wishes though to fool us the audience to follow his false healer. The false healer and the mentally ill person are brought together, and the fake healer heals him, supposedly. All that really happened is the devil ceases his torture on the mind of this unfortunate individual. There is no miracle, only the false perception of one. The devil cannot perform any true miracles. I just wanted to elaborate these points u correctly brought out
@832existentialiste
@832existentialiste 10 жыл бұрын
O Holy Spirit‚ lead us‚ enlighten us.
@TyranyFighterPatriot
@TyranyFighterPatriot 8 жыл бұрын
at 13:11 They say Our Lady doesn't like roses? Our Lady of Guadalupe is not impressed!
@ritateehan1133
@ritateehan1133 7 жыл бұрын
RestoreCatholicismForStability it was Satan [the false apparition ] that said that.
@NaYawkr
@NaYawkr 5 жыл бұрын
Our great weapon from God is the Rosary, and every prayer is a beautiful Rose for Mary. Hmmmm . . . gee, why would the evil one who fears her and her weapon from God try to convince us not to pray the Rosary and grant Our Holy Mother the Abundance of Roses she deserves from each of us. DHHHHH !
@mwhitcraft
@mwhitcraft 8 жыл бұрын
Maria, if someone honored your mother, would you disown them?
@alexchristopher221
@alexchristopher221 8 жыл бұрын
To dishonour the Mother is to dishonour the Son.
@wilsontexas
@wilsontexas 3 ай бұрын
If people prayed to my dead mother, called her the queen of heaven and said they were devoted to her I would tell them to not worship the created.
@reynaldosantiago2552
@reynaldosantiago2552 4 жыл бұрын
What can you say about the addition of another mystery of the rosary the luminous mystery? What about the changing of the sabbath day from saturday to sunday?
@ezekielvallada3997
@ezekielvallada3997 4 жыл бұрын
How about the non declared one with true miracles
@E-Kat
@E-Kat Жыл бұрын
14:45" they'll make strange noises" and he proceeds to make one of these strange noises!!! 😂
@morelmaster
@morelmaster 5 жыл бұрын
Article 66-67 of the Catechism says: ... Yet even if Revelation is already complete, it has not been made completely explicit; it remains for Christian faith gradually to grasp its full significance over the course of the centuries...Throughout the ages, there have been so-called "private" revelations, some of which have been recognized by the authority of the Church. They do not belong, however, to the deposit of faith. It is not their role to improve or complete Christ's definitive Revelation, but to help live more fully by it in a certain period of history...Christian faith cannot accept "revelations" that claim to surpass or correct the Revelation of which Christ is the fulfillment...
@kathyborthwick6738
@kathyborthwick6738 5 жыл бұрын
john mizak Now this makes a great deal of sense - Thank You!
@Paulkazey1
@Paulkazey1 8 жыл бұрын
What is the cape thing he is wearing?
@TyranyFighterPatriot
@TyranyFighterPatriot 8 жыл бұрын
He's a member of the TFP (American Society for the Defense of Tradition Family and Property) Look them up. These guy's are modern knights of Christ, and live their lives completely in the service of God's Honor, and the defense of his rights, against the poison of society today.
@jetc4332
@jetc4332 7 жыл бұрын
6:17: Doesn't make much sense to me. If devils will do only what God allows them to do, and Lourdes is authentic, why would God allow devils to sabotage Lourdes?
@mia795
@mia795 6 жыл бұрын
JeTc Why did God allow the devil to tempt Eve in the garden of Eden at the very beginning of creation? Why would God allow the devil to tempt Jesus in the desert? God allows what God allows for reasons we may or may not understand. He gave us free will, so evil exists. It is our job to know Him and His laws well so that we can properly discern the spirits (read St. Ignatius) to protect ourselves and avoid evil.
@Alwayslearnimg
@Alwayslearnimg 5 жыл бұрын
Sera Tesan I wish it wasn’t always so difficult to discern. That’s why I love the magisterium. The true church will not be taken down by the evil one
@E-Kat
@E-Kat Жыл бұрын
What are you wearing?
@bigbadboy6776
@bigbadboy6776 8 жыл бұрын
Mother mary was just used by God so that The lord jesus christ might be born, She is a chossen one, But she doesnt want anyone worshipping her, But The father in heaven alone, I love the mother but i love her to enjoy all the splendor of heaven with his son since she went up to heaven, So whenever you see an apparition make sure its the real mother, or else youll be knelling down to satan, and doing his tricks, Test the spirit first before you believe any appartion, look at the feet, if its a goats feet its a demon. if its a human feet its the Holy mothers.
@alexchristopher221
@alexchristopher221 8 жыл бұрын
wordpress.com/stats/month/blessedaboveallwomen.co
@bigbadboy6776
@bigbadboy6776 7 жыл бұрын
Mother mary was choosen amongs women, by the father creator God to give life to his son jesus christ, the savior of mankind, God choose here then claimed to be a teenager from the house of david,--But whatever happened to her on her life time was neverwritten in the HB, The last part of mother marys life story is that when christ was hanging on the cross and told peter to to take care of her mother for him----Catholics cliam that mary was taken in to heaven alive was not written and could be a hearsay, If there is any written evidence of the assumption by then i would consider almost all the proven apparitions were true.
@grggitonga
@grggitonga 5 жыл бұрын
you should read the book city of God. to understand better we dont worship mary we venerate her
@christophewakim7878
@christophewakim7878 5 жыл бұрын
I always look at feet when i am talking to girls 😂😂😂 I am strugling with lust plz God help me
@ToTheeOBlessedJoseph
@ToTheeOBlessedJoseph 3 жыл бұрын
Excellent talk - thank you.
@gatometeotologico1229
@gatometeotologico1229 2 жыл бұрын
Very good explanation. That makes me wonder if Medjugorie is true. Because I though that Pope Francis was being mean, somehow, but through the example of Madalena da Cruz I understood why this is a whole of signs that Will tell if it's true ir falar. 👍
@gatometeotologico1229
@gatometeotologico1229 2 жыл бұрын
* true or false
@FpeEddie2
@FpeEddie2 Жыл бұрын
Its false. Anyone who believes its true is making a sacrilegious assumption about our Blessed Mother with the over 47,000 apparitions, they obviously do not know her enough to understand she has the virtues of prudence and silence. A mother won't come down that much to speak to the same seers.
@amascia8327
@amascia8327 2 жыл бұрын
《Magdalena de la Cruz (1487-1560) was a Franciscan nun of Córdoba in Spain, who for many years was honored as a living saint. However, St. Ignatius Loyola had always regarded her with suspicion. Falling dangerously ill in 1543, Magdalena confessed that her stigmata and claims of performing miracles were fraudulent. She was sentenced by the Inquisition, in an auto-da-fé at Córdoba in 1546, to perpetual imprisonment in a convent of her order, and there she is believed to have ended her days most piously amid marks of the sincerest repentance.》Wikipedia 🖒🤠
@walterroberts5694
@walterroberts5694 7 жыл бұрын
what is Medujorge, are the apparitions true or false?
@el-sig2249
@el-sig2249 6 жыл бұрын
Medjugorje is false! The apparitions threatened the local bishop with curses for refusing to accept it and the visionaries made alot of money before the Church finally declared that it was actually demonic.
@garymccann5079
@garymccann5079 6 жыл бұрын
Yes they are true,Medujorge has drawn many people back to Mass and confession. U Tube Med Apparitions see the video and they have been going on for many years.
@raysierra4279
@raysierra4279 5 жыл бұрын
medujorge is false the apparition.t he apparition says all religions are the same.saying Muslims and catholics are equal before god!.its the devil!
@KenPaulsenArchitect
@KenPaulsenArchitect 10 жыл бұрын
If Pope Pius XII condemned the Divine Mercy apparitions, and later, Pope John Paul II approved them, what does that tell us about the possibility that a local bishop's ruling might not be the final word? Incidentally, the local bishop's ruling for Medjugorje was not a condemnation. For apparitions, one of three determinations is typically rendered: 1. constat de non supernaturalitate (determined to be NOT supernatural) (condemned) 2. non constat de supernaturalitate (NOT determined to be supernatural) (neutral) 3. constat de supernaturalitate (determined to be supernatural) (approved) Note that the local bishop determined that #2 applied to Medjugorje. Often, people confuse #1 and #2, but #2 is the more neutral determination which basically means that authenticity remains a mystery.
@anila1970
@anila1970 10 жыл бұрын
Yes, but compare the humble, obedient and hidden life of Faustina Kowalska and the lives of the seers of Medjugorje and you will see the abyss that separates them.
@KenPaulsenArchitect
@KenPaulsenArchitect 10 жыл бұрын
Anila Maria Korbi Hi Anila. God Bless You. Some of what you may have heard about the seers of Medjugorje is probably false. The rumors and twisted stories have been propagated by the enemy. But also, God uses all sorts of people for His plan... Not all good people are identical. I hope we hear the pope's decision about Medjugorje soon - perhaps by the Feast of the Assumption. The Vatican's commission completed their 4 year study months ago with the Vatican Insider publication indicating "no hoax". (Google: "Medjugorje no hoax".)
@anila1970
@anila1970 10 жыл бұрын
Ken Paulsen You are right, not all good people are identical. I'm all ears for Vatican's say on these apparitions!
@832existentialiste
@832existentialiste 10 жыл бұрын
Ken Paulsen Another red flag for me besides the errors (theological and doctrinal) replete in the messages of 'Gospa' is a goose-pimpling video capture of Vicka in obvious mimicry of a supposed religious ecstatic experience.
@KenPaulsenArchitect
@KenPaulsenArchitect 10 жыл бұрын
***** Please quote any "theological error" that you're concerned about. I would appreciate demonstrating that either you've been mislead by an inaccurate interpretation, or have not understood exactly what was said. (Let me begin by saying, God loves EVERYBODY - of all religious faiths and even those who have not come to know Him yet.) Secondly, the one video that I believe you may be referring to (where Viska seems to flinch when someone attempts to strike her), must be understood in context. It's important to realize that Our Blessed Mother is not omniscient. Only God is. So Mary may not know all the things that may happen during the time she is appearing to the Visionaries. Mary does not interfere with free will of the Visionaries, or those around her. However, during an ecstatic vision, she may make gestures or motions that influence those who see her. Mary, upon understanding that someone was about to strike Viska, reportedly made a motion that caused Viska to move at that moment. Viska did not see the attacker, but Mary did. From our limited perception, it appeared that Viska moved in reaction to that attacker, but she reported that she moved because of Mary's movement.
@ChristianSaintSavior
@ChristianSaintSavior 3 жыл бұрын
A very good presentation on Apparitions, especially the false ones ,involving Sister Magdalena. I would have liked it more, if Michael Whitcraft addressed in detail, the "apparitions" at both Garabandal and Medjugorje. Those two are still extremely controversial 'til this day, and Faithful Catholics need to be on their guard against them.
@paolody438
@paolody438 4 жыл бұрын
Immaculate Conception means sinlessness would The Mary of Scripture really claim to be the Immaculate Conception? Lk 1:47 "My soul magnifies the Lord and my spirit rejoices God my Savior" Lk 2:22-24 "In the time of their purification ..."
@ritobonito
@ritobonito 11 ай бұрын
at about 59:00 or thereabouts he says we have to have good reasons for rejecting private revelation, but he does not say what those reasons might be. I am totally skeptical about Fatima - it's all about money - think about it. It's as wild a story as Alice in wonderland :: just one of the many problems :: Lucia says the lady appeared "brighter than the Sun" - well, duh, how could she see the lady if she appeared so brightly? See? there's actually two miracles there - the apparition PLUS Lucia and the other children suffered no eye damage. Oh, it all sounds so serious when he talks about Russia, but even that :: how does the pope and ALL the bishops of the world consecrate Russia? Is that consecration like casting a magic spell on the atheist country? Lucia got trapped in her own fantasies and had to live with them for the rest of her life. Whitcraft said Fatima consisted of 6 apparitions ending in 1917 - not at all -- Sr Lucia said she had many other apparitions and conversations with Mary later in the convent because she couldn't remember everything.
@alittleofeverything4190
@alittleofeverything4190 7 жыл бұрын
If enough people in the body of the church believe it, then it's true. The Assumption is a perfect example.
@el-sig2249
@el-sig2249 6 жыл бұрын
It's not about "enough people" believing it. These things cannot be judged democratically. It's about discerning through the gifts which our Lord has given His Church. Medjugorje was very popular for decades before the Church declared it to be false.
@carlos2408
@carlos2408 5 жыл бұрын
Church has not declared false that is the problem. I hope they decided soon
@wilsontexas
@wilsontexas 3 ай бұрын
The assumption needed otherwise they are contacting the dead which is forbidden.
@stephenphillips4984
@stephenphillips4984 3 жыл бұрын
His arguments for inferring that some apparitions at Lourdes were demonic are plain silly. They have no weight! Just easily refuted opinions or interpretations. "Our lady would not ask people to climb on an altar up to her level." What ever makes him think she did ask them? The people clambered up of their own accord. His various other reasons for doubting some of the apparitions are just as flimsy.
@MsDormy
@MsDormy Жыл бұрын
I don’t agree. At least one visionary of the ‘alternative’ white lady in the Lourdes grotto had terrible nightmares, which is an indication of evil influence. Another jumped three stories from an attic, and landed on his feet - again another indication of the superhuman ability that manifests when people are possessed by demons. Our Lady tends to choose very innocent, young visionaries, and expresses her love and sympathy for them. Often rural girls much like she must have been herself once, on earth. Secs workers are not her first choice of spokesperson for her holy message (though they could well be her Son’s choice to save)
@E-Kat
@E-Kat Жыл бұрын
14:40 strange looks in their faces, grimaces "? Jesus had more than a strange look on his face when he entered the temple and he saw the money lenders!! Jesus was angry and he pulled all the clothes of the tables, scattering the money everywhere!! He was shouting at them!! Your talk is more than weird and after almost 15 min of you playing infallible god, I'll say thank you, that wasn't very good. I wonder what will happen with Dali Lama? Will it be brushed under the carpet along with other cases of child abuse? I dread to think what he must've done to children when he was alone with them!! I hope they'll all come forward!!! That's organised religion.
@Headspace101
@Headspace101 4 жыл бұрын
All apparitions are false, not scriptural at all
@billinfo4769
@billinfo4769 Жыл бұрын
So when the bible says an angel appeared to St. Joseph. Did St. Joseph believe the angel because it was scriptural?
@wilsontexas
@wilsontexas 3 ай бұрын
Some are so focused on Mary that Jesus comes in a poor second place.
@jsalgarme
@jsalgarme 8 жыл бұрын
I'm convinced: the bald toad is wearing a red doohickey rag !
@caroline-9672
@caroline-9672 6 жыл бұрын
John Algarme I think he handsome and cute
@renariwoods9014
@renariwoods9014 3 жыл бұрын
This is the most bizarre...
@atheistmommy3710
@atheistmommy3710 4 жыл бұрын
There's no such thing as true apparitions!!!
Garabandal: What the Church Has Said
53:05
Divine Mercy
Рет қаралды 203 М.
Total Consecration to Mary Part 1 of 5
1:06:34
Sensus Fidelium
Рет қаралды 95 М.
DAD LEFT HIS OLD SOCKS ON THE COUCH…😱😂
00:24
JULI_PROETO
Рет қаралды 16 МЛН
НРАВИТСЯ ЭТОТ ФОРМАТ??
00:37
МЯТНАЯ ФАНТА
Рет қаралды 7 МЛН
What it feels like cleaning up after a toddler.
00:40
Daniel LaBelle
Рет қаралды 82 МЛН
#PopeFrancis speaks out against false Marian apparitions
1:32
ROME REPORTS in English
Рет қаралды 24 М.
Why Be Catholic and Not Just Christian?
8:59
Ascension Presents
Рет қаралды 3 МЛН
Men in Black: Why Do Priests Wear the Roman Collar?
9:51
Risen Christ Catholic Parish Denver
Рет қаралды 19 М.
Pope Francis' opinion on the Medjugorje  apparitions
2:59
ROME REPORTS in English
Рет қаралды 448 М.
Why I am no longer a Christian | By Paul Williams
20:18
Blogging Theology
Рет қаралды 576 М.
Apparition of the Virgin Mary - Orlando, United States - 08/01/2017
1:03:04
Misericordia María TV - English
Рет қаралды 303 М.
Reflections on Marian Apparitions: A Lecture by Fr. Benedict Groeschel
1:24:13
International Institute for Culture
Рет қаралды 163 М.
Denmark official faints during Covid-19 conference
0:23
TRT World Now
Рет қаралды 13 МЛН
The Coming Chastisement
1:03:30
Michael Whitcraft
Рет қаралды 24 М.
DAD LEFT HIS OLD SOCKS ON THE COUCH…😱😂
00:24
JULI_PROETO
Рет қаралды 16 МЛН