TSOAF - All Is Ash Or The Light Shining Through It

Live performance from the We Must Become The Change We Want To See DVD.

[@artdamages]

hearing this live in 2023 was life changing

[@davidbond689]

rich balling is a English teacher at my school i talk about music with him all the time.

[@blackpleg28]

TSOFAF Is basically a clusterfuck of amazing musicians making the best music ever!

[@mykol17]

the last dance moves performed by Anthony Green at the end there for us is simply genius. to perfect such a complex contortion takes years of training and dedication. Mastering these many ancient forms as one cohesive fluid movement is all but impossible. But here we are all witnesses to this amazing feat only accomplished by one man in this life. but then again, they don't need a witness.

[@thejokesonyou16]

this is basically Rx Bandits with added singers lol. It doesn't get better than that!!

[@CRAIGisGOD]

Not just any singer but Anthony Green. Greatest vocalist ever

[@darilietas]

Antony's voice is the best male vocal i've ever heard.

[@darthginski]

brilliance, it takes alot to impress an obsessed TOOL fan, but this is incredible

[@reysolph]

audience of one,jeer at rome,zolof the rock&roll destroyer,the sound of animals fighting,saosin and circa survive #anthonygreen

[@xXtoyhippieXx]

the man just loves music

[@FluffyThieves]

I was at this show, still one of my all time favorite concert experiences ever.

[@tommybegoske5372]

so envious

[@MrJimjimijimmy]

My third time seeing Anthony will be a SOAF show. Can't wait to dance around

[@ksportrait]

Bite down jaw! Lol, loveeeee this video! I l watch it every morning :)

[@ryanfederline8884]

at the end of 2016 still listening to this so many negative comments I think they BOTH did great

[@Raro404]

How badly I want to see them live. I can only hope they even consider playing in Australia. One of the best modern art/prog rock bands around. You can tell Green really feels the music. Just by looking at him on stage you can feel his connection with the art. Very rare to find these days.

[@ThatOneHxCKid]

0:04 - 0:37 Such a nice jam.

[@PatchBishop]

omg. it really is better than the album version. or exactly the same. I'm melting...

[@xblackholesun]

this mustve been one of the most incredible shows ever... to be at

[@MyoticTesseract]

God, I love experimental rock and post-hardcore.

[@nileakanile]

i like rich balling..how hes groving with his cane...

[@Jakuzadoc93]

god, what an almost perfect performance :O

[@keltondeoliveira]

So young and so great music.

[@nelson3300]

Sweet, that sounds about right!

[@troycarson1]

Funny... This DVD sells for $75-100 online now cause its so rare. I can remember watching it all day at my buddies house when it came out

[@happykyle18]

@Talvegue its a supergroup, a collective of musicians from different extremely successful bands. Another interesting thing is that the line up from cd to cd changes.

[@Lacesoutdan_]

Saw them on the most recent tour and Rich sounded sooo good this video did not capture what he is capable of

[@KevinTheCardigan]

Still here after all this time 😅

[@funkymonk36]

Rx and Anthony is sooo amazing

[@annialuise9772]

This is the best thing Anthony Green has ever done. Who wants to fight about it

[@CRAIGisGOD]

It’s up there but circa is by far his best project. 1a/1b

[@nofrbls3640]

this performance specifically is the best thing ive ever seen

[@reallyrox]

great song

[@xidreamtofyoux]

Lol, funniest comment I've seen in a while. Just wanted to let you know.

[@T00KAH]

@Talvegue yeah its supposed to be like that. listen to the original version of this song, they sound identical live.

[@conman12000]

I actually think the people saying that anthony is on drugs have a point. at this time in his life, (and even for some time after) he was struggling with drug problems. that said, green always has a really electrifying stage presence anyway, so its really anyone's guess. but what really matters is that he did an awesome job regardless.

[@juanramonsanchez]

love this fucking band 2019

[@saztradamus]

"you'll be the last ones to know ! "

[@hosway1992]

Where do i get this DVD??? I cant find it anywhere!!!!!

[@CameronForrester]

Superband.

[@Radical_edweird]

not at all, ever since i have heard him, i've listening to all of his stuff, including the songs he features in.

[@T00KAH]

@Talvegue nah just a collection of some talented dudes, what do you mean you don't understand the lyrics??

[@headbanger1220]

really? i enjoy his music, so i was curious what he's doing now. thought producing or something maybe. but thats cool

[@Peter-hx5zp]

Great energetic progressive art band Anthony's voice does it all. Rage Against the Machine could learn something from them 😉

[@nickfromjonandnick]

@Exhume2Consume That's called falsetto; it's always a fuck of a lot weaker than modal range. But I completely agree with you.

[@Juuliannn]

oh so artsy!

[@Samitch04]

who is that giant on the stage?

[@fabiancampos6484]

La voz de Anthony green siempre me va a llevar al 2008 ctm

[@boblong002]

@OhAaronBarton he actually quit two weeks before saosin

[@WalkingIsStillHonest]

rich balling is his name. he was my english teacher. haha

[@aaronjim]

But there is Matt Embree, Joe Troy, Gack, and Choi in the band...you know there's gotta be something passing around... :P

[@T00KAH]

i love rich ballings falsetto voice, it's so unusual... almost like it's not meant to be or something... so great.

[@alexander9213]

forreal?

[@alexrea3771]

To the people dissing on Anthony Green. You're a true son a of bitch. Nigga knows what he's doing. The other guy is a little off, but all I know is, Anthony Green is the definition of a lyrical genious, and he can sing like a god. Listen to Circa Survive/Old Saosin. kthanks

[@clavinicle]

@hosway1992 I got mine on the merchnow website

[@abeautifulcancermusic]

I don't get the dancers, but the guy painting in the background is a great idea. This is the perfect music to inspire some great art

[@TheLksdrunner]

abeautifulcancer .music dont question TSOAF, none of us get it, we're all here for the ride

[@fergar0206]

Its a good addition. The whole point of the show was multi faceted performance art. They're an experimental side project that barely tours so they wanted to make sure the show was different and gave something to their fans that they couldn't get from listening to the studio albums. I wish more bands thought like this, I don't want to go to a show and see a perfect rendition of a song being played, I want improvisation and passion. Dance is something that barely intersects with this genre so it's definitely something that was interesting to watch.

[@ray02946]

80 are you kidding me? they have like 800,000

[@kennymusician777]

@Baekmagoji hahahaha I know!!! :D Awesome! haha

[@berto1337]

anthony green is such a great frontman.

[@marcusclasson90]

@xXxilurvyouxXx I feel you.

[@saztradamus]

you'll be the last ones to know!!!!

[@jjhnerjn]

look at anthony dancing u can tell hes so @#$%ing high

[@Radical_edweird]

2:46 he's conducting the music with his cane xD

[@alexander9213]

sure. but it's still likely they at least took at least a little sip of some type of alcohol ;) its fun to play shows buzzed

[@xYOSHIONMYARMx]

@ImNotRightlyMade hahahah. Coke head Anthony.

[@Grosstradamus]

Trippy fucking band, but so damn good.

[@NickGuitarMalfara13]

DO THE STANKY LEG

[@starglancer]

Great point... They put on a show... doesn't make them energetic AT ALL.

[@543diditwork]

really?

[@DrVonNostrand]

@shitfeast explain?

[@thekingjestex]

rich bailing reminds me of a chubbier house.

[@shitfeast]

Anthony says "you"ll be the last ones to know", a special little circa survive easter egg for the circa fans out there.

[@yellowsmoke666]

420 long

[@kickin30s]

this wallet's too full. (went on) for if i yield before god, it all it all, it all.

[@Exhume2Consume]

richard balling should stick to his range because its terrible when he hits his highs.

[@EctorSinH]

Matt Embree had a sore throat so he let these dudes sing. Rx bandits FTW

[@ivoryline13]

QFT not really comparable to any other band

[@xkupi]

yeah the guy doing the talking/falsetto didn't do so well Anthony did great tho just my opinion.

[@pharaohbhang1172]

That's Rich Balling and he may not have crushed this live, but without him there would never have been TSOAF.

[@MiguelPerez-cx4mm]

i kinda hate rich ballings voice in general but especially his falsetto lol

[@nelson3300]

Yeah, it sounds like a guy walked onto stage and started talking :D Pretty crap performance here, I love his voice but it just sounds.. confused in this performance. word