【TVPP】After School RED - In the Night Sky, 애프터스쿨 레드 - 밤하늘에 @ Show Music Core Live

[@jusaintle6927]

노래는 씨스타 니까짓게2 느낌이네 용형도 참 돌려먹기좋아해

[@박박이-i2f]

밤 하ㄴ..나 정말 화가나~~

[@자빵이]

돌려먹기 ㄴㄴ 돌려막기ㅇㅇ

[@볼코기]

근데 니까짓게보다 이게 좀 더 좋음

[@김태연-y6w]

요즘 걸그룹 왜이래 다 작지 올만에 이렇게 길쭉길쭉한애들보니깐 뭔가 시원함

[@jusaintle6927]

@@nomatterwhatusaid 누구보다 잘알아요 그리고 애프터스쿨아니고 애프터스쿨 레드예요^^

[@youhooyoohoo]

다들 컨셉 안 어울려서 별로라는 의견이 많은데 나는 컨셉과 별개로 멜로디가 아련하면서 신나고 그래서 좋아했음 ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ 맨날 찾아서 듣고 그랬다...

[@NoSauceNoSauce]

222 컨셉도 잘 어울려요! 색다르고

[@정민김-p5t]

컨셉은 별론데 네명의 피지컬이 컨셉 덮어버림 외모랑 기럭지 ㅎㄷㄷ

[@rinnnn1e]

멤버구성만 보면 사자인데 노래는 두고봥 하는 아깽이..

[@kimhelena6305]

에프터스쿨 레드 나왔을때 충격이 아직도 가시지가 않아. 저 넷으로 유닛 나온다고 해서 진짜 역대급 파워풀 쎈케 나올꺼라고 예상했는데...저 넷으로 저런 컨셉들이민 플스는 뭔지..

[@hahalulu1775]

그러니까요 블루 레드 노래 둘다 핵 별로 컨셉도 어정쩡해서 제대로 듣기도 싫었어요.

[@모선-b6x]

ㄹㅇㅋㅋ

[@loveydoveymin52]

이 노래 좋은데..

[@NoSauceNoSauce]

What?!! This song is da bomb! 너무해요. ㅠㅠ 컨셉도 좋고 노래도 개쪌어요!

[@namgil_]

어릴때도 좋다고 생각했는데 지금 들어도 개좋음ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[@whatever6903]

안무연습 15분이면 끝났겠다 ㅅㅂㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ밤하늘에 할때 쉬는 팔다리가 아까워ㅠㅠㅠ저 멤버로 희대의 삽질ㅠㅠㅠㅠ

[@bbangdam]

15분ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[@양이바오]

컨셉 아쉽긴한데 노래 너무 좋음..

[@멍멍이-i9v]

역시 이때 시절처럼 라이브하는게 제일 좋다

[@aridian7787]

Here's why us second generation KPOP LOVERS will always be loyal to the 2nd generation. Just look at these girls! I mean seriously!

[@lomlexo8230]

Aridian super agree 😭

[@royery]

They are beautiful, more beautiful than you'll ever be.... hater. and if you mean their outfits..... just wait a couple more years bitch and next generation will LAUGHS at what idols wear now. Circle of life bitch. So instead of sitting begind your computer and judging talented girls, take a moment to look at yourself. But maybe you are super young and ignorant so must be hard for you.

[@koreaming1599]

Is this why 2nd generation loves to lipsync? Lol don’t compare ‘coz without 1st gen kpop, there will be no 2nd gen

[@lomlexo8230]

Koreaming at least we honor and respected 1st gen not like what 3rd gen stans doing now 😌

[@lomlexo8230]

Koreaming and where’s lipsync here? I gotta laugh

[@summerclaresta2930]

After School is one of the most talented and hard working kpop girl group ever I've been loving them for the first time I saw their performance The only thing I hate about this group is that graduation system I really want to see After School can perform in the stage again with full member, the graduate member and the current member

[@debbiegoh494]

U just speak my mind out

[@Brandon2ne2]

Wait what !?! I seriously did not know that ..

[@tomchhakchhuak4670]

Nana is the only member now😢

[@quartzrosenity2159]

THEY WILLL😭😭😭 thankyou for jaejae and seungkwan they will perform on 11th June in mmtg

[@CesarNoelQ]

The Red SubUnit stands out

[@ssalmini]

0:36 진짜 나나 음색 사기

[@이응-k8x]

아니 나만 노래 좋냐... ㅜㅜㅜㅠㅠㅜ 밤하늘에에에

[@reggiinn]

don't think i'll get over this era of afterschool red it was so great, this song too i still really like it. Nana and kahi are stand outs

[@pvn2474]

Uee is the greatest stand out.

[@altaircain]

Everyone in this sub unit is actually the popular ones

[@000000ab22]

유이는 저런 부족장 딸 같은 옷에 메이크업 해놔도 진짜 이쁘네

[@bongbong6578]

뚜벅좌여도 예쁨

[@salsa2506]

They could've just gone to coachella after this performance

[@angelshen2]

true though.

[@kg5463]

OMG HAHAHAHAHAHAHAH

[@hopelser]

ss_s25 literally💀

[@appl3.149]

Nahh

[@hxnwz]

lmao

[@michaelc8275]

I really think Kahi carried the group. When people thought of After School that's who came to mind, of course Uee and Nana were popular for looks but all the talent was Kahi. It's so sad seeing this group heading towards disbandment

[@stanstraykids7556]

Michael C kahi is the best dancers

[@larissamartins1116]

Michael C all the girls were talented,not just Kahi

[@Symononymous]

all of them are talented. Jung Ah's vocals were slaying since 2009

[@carlsmith4062]

All of them were talented but it was kahi who more or less made the group and trained them. When she 'graduated ' they left the driving force behind the group.

[@dh1476]

kahi, uee do better than someone

[@깜쟈-q2l]

이거 나올 때도 저 멤버들로 더 잘 못했을까 엄청 아쉬웠음 노래는 좋긴 한데 쎈걸 나갔어도 인기 더 많았을듯

[@밥잘먹고잠잘자고]

저 멤버들이면 헤어지자고하면 울줄알앗냐? 이런노래 불러야했을 포슨데...

[@brokims5264]

저 멤버들이면 여자가 우는게 아니라 남자가 우는거 아닌가....;;;

[@ArYaMdI]

I will forever admire Kahi. One of the best dancers in kpop (if not the best)

[@pvn2474]

Yes, Kahi is a level or two above all other dancers, sure. But Uee is more attractive, hehe ;)

[@pvn2474]

Yes, Gahee was the best dancer. Seriously skilled. But Uee was the most attractive girl - by far! ;-)

[@thunderstrifed]

pvn2474 honestly for me Nana and Uee’s visuals beat those of their era and today. If they were promoted right, they would’ve been really successful

[@SoshiStars]

*Omg they're singing live and so STABLE unlike groups now :/*

[@hexaciousjinx6923]

I don't think this is a live .. Nana's mouth wasn't moving and you can hear the backtrack 1:37, also the track got louder on one of Uee's verses . They may be singing along with the backtrack but it's hard to tell .

[@nguyenhatien1787]

@@hexaciousjinx6923 Man, how can you see her mouth here, the camera was way too fast, but I can say she did sing live.

[@жизньотстой-ю1ф]

Hexacious Jinx What you hear at that moment is the backtrack voice that’s why she’s not moving her mouth lol

[@wiktoriakohman2200]

Not all groups are good at singing live but some are really amazing tho

[@kimikhwan8533]

@@hexaciousjinx6923 u maybe use some kind of local cheap earphone, pls , some part nana dont sing maybe bcz of the dance move , she's taking breath , but the rest is LIVE

[@임선영-s2r]

와, 아름다운 무대!! 노래도 예쁘네. 유이 얼굴에 쯔위 있다 ^^ 근데 유이 원더우먼같다. 가희 노래 잘한다~~

[@kristiatupas2157]

damn imagine THIS group shine in this era. i dont have words, everyone will definitely in awe of these amazing talented girls. 2nd gen will always be THAT standard. came here after the reunion stage of Bang (although there's just five of them) oh i miss Afterschool so much 😭

[@주바리-f5o]

중딩때 꼭 저녁에 집가는길에 듣던노래,, 다시 들어도 좋군 ! 이노래는 꼭 저녁 깜깜해져야 들어야함 ~~

[@2시23분]

다들 너무 예쁘고 매력이 흘러넘친다...... 노래만 좀만 더 좋았으면 좋았을텐데ㅠㅠ 가사.......훌쩍훌쩍.........

[@kgwoolthuk7547]

아나이노래진짜좋아했는데ㅠㅠㅜ 이때나나넘이뻐서 초딩때 저런스타일 막따라하려하고.. 저춤도 기억나..옆으로밀어내고훌쩍훌쩍 춤ㅠㅠㅠㅡㄹ하..춤도연습하고 .. 근데 이노래애들은 잘몰라서 슬펐음 나만아는띵곡이였는데...

[@MilkWithIce]

Imagine if fan cams were made, this performance and the group would blow up

[@영롱-d7b]

와 진짜 씨쓰타 니까짓게 존똑인데;;;

[@김양갱-y4k]

둘다 용형 노래죠

[@moonbyby]

Nana Uee Kahi JungAh are the best girls of all of any girl groups

[@moschapravie]

@thefashiongirl23 help for answer. They are Uee and Jungah

[@moschapravie]

No, the one with the pony tail is Jungah. The american flag shirt is Uee

[@laibaadil2177]

가비 Elle I 100%agree with you

[@아름다운사람-i7q]

유이진짜이쁘다

[@달새벽-z7z]

유이는 저때가 제일 이뻣는데 지금은 해골...

[@freebritney89]

Kahi....omg. She just exudes an aura about her when she performs

[@김뭄낸]

초딩때 엄청 듣고 불렀었는데 ㅠㅠ 드뎌 찾았다ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ

[@noname-x4m5z]

지금 들어도 너무 세련되구 좋은데...ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ 이 노래만 들으면 내 학창시절로 시간이동...

[@kjh91827]

어떻게 저 멤버들로 "훌쩍훌쩍 울다가~" 이런 노래나 하고…

[@김현수-r4z5q]

이 노래 너무 좋은데 왜요.. 너무 좋음 진짜 아직도 들어요

[@kkang1996]

@@김현수-r4z5q 진짜 인정합니다!😢👍👍

[@권권-d8l]

뚜벅초를 만들구..

[@쌔쌔]

가사가 너무 멜로디와 노래 제목과 안 맞죠. 이 노래의 단 하나의 단점. 얼굴에는 센언니의 상징인 짙은 아이라인 화장을 시키고 가사로 훌쩍훌쩍 울다가♪를 부르니 아구가 안맞는 느낌이 강하게 옵니다.

[@365일춤만출래-w8t]

뚜벅초ㅋㅋㅋ

[@aa-qw8ry]

와 이때 정아 메이크업 스타일링 찰떡이다

[@johnnygil5409]

This was a great and well balanced Kpop unit in the 2nd generation.

[@winteryash]

pledis wasted so much talent and potential... i miss after school

[@cidenasiwonida6340]

I miss this era 3 generation

[@sushiluvrluvzme]

cidena siwonida technically this video is 2nd generation since SES was first generation girl group then GG+AS+ etc. and red velvet is 3rd

[@ahyanrahardian132]

their in 2nd generation

[@papayask8]

they are from the 2nd generation, the best generation for the kpop

[@sion511]

노랜 너무 좋아.....

[@snsthddl397]

이때 다들 겁나 예쁘네요~ 이노래 엄청 중독성있어서 매일들었는데....

[@margaretheo]

i cant take my eyes of jungah. it looked sparkling

[@LdhSky]

Nana is so beautiful outside.. she shine like a diamond... really beautiful

[@yb87811]

나나랑 가희 노래 캐 잘한다 진짜 ㅋㅋ

[@rouronikenshin9324]

They all looks like models wow, so beautiful.

[@fitrisetiawati2313]

i miss them i miss after school first generations i miss old kpop 😢😢😢😢

[@hjs6519]

와 생라이브네 진짜 에프터스쿨 그립다 다시 한번이라도 뭉친 무대 볼 수 있었으면

[@johnnygil5409]

The fact that Nana and UEE was together in a group, all men fans are going crazy.

[@iicareyes]

2019 and I still belive that Nana and Kahi are one of the most beautiful kpop idol in history.

[@Winter.Prince]

I miss After School :(

[@geegee1O]

Omg! These song gave me chills. I really missed them 😭😭😭 These song made me want to go back to my HS days.

[@yogiepratama7604]

I still think this is the best sub-unit ever...

[@ia1569]

My favorite song of theirs, honestly.

[@시아야몇시야]

나나 노래도 잘하고 너무 목소리 좋다ㅜㅠㅠ 배우만 하기 아까워 다시 나와 주세요 젭알,,

[@imyourblink247]

I came here after they performed Bang on MMTG🥺

[@찌니-m1p]

노래 귀욤뽀짝

[@웅성웅성웅성-u2b]

와 이 노래 개띵곡인데ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ 이 노랜 나나의 웃기지말어~ 이 부분 목소리가 포인트임

[@보니비-f5e]

추억이네요.노래의힘은 대단해요 이노래들으니 그때 추억이떠올라요

[@swnrud]

다 떠나서 노래가 개명곡

[@stillportra]

until now im still admiring After School for being girlgroup that really excellent at singing life. like their voice is so stable and powerful.

[@woorikim447]

난 이노래 가끔 요새도 듣는데

[@젠틀몬스터-r1p]

컨셉 안 맞다고 생각할 수 잇긴한데 걍 다 좋음ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[@너나잘해라-n8m]

역시 플디 칼군무에 라이브 개쩔고 저멤버들데려다 이정도라니.........역시 플디

[@7tosquare]

Their best ever performance in my opinion... they lip sync too much nowadays ..

[@emsalem8497]

They've not performed for years... what do you mean?

[@juliapagnoncelli3457]

Em I Think she means other groups (Sorry my english)

[@griffinlin1236]

I really think now groups use backtrack that's too loud. Back then I don't even need a Mr removed to see if they're singing live or not.

[@maddybg]

Even after school is using backtrack . No hate tho , they sing really well.

[@velvetyspringofficial9234]

@@maddybg yep its just that their voices are louder than the backtrack.

[@maddybg]

@@velvetyspringofficial9234 Yeah . But that doesn't mean that they aren't talented coz they are Hella talented .

[@jamesartemio1312]

maddybg they were using backtracks just to fill in tiny gaps. Nowadays, they just lipsync the shit out of the live performances.

[@franciscotapia7565]

They are singing 100% live, this is nothing for them, they didn't train all those years to make play Black, they're hella talented

[@Heykyon]

진짜 추억이네 너무 좋았는데..

[@juandenz2008]

Great performance ! I miss After School ! Kahi especially could give a very powerful performance. She had to train herself in singing and dancing, as her father wouldn't support her dream. Then she had to run away from university and go to Seoul to try and pursue her career without any money. She didn't communicate with her father for 7 years. Apparently Kahi was a very strict leader, perhaps because she had to struggle so hard to achieve fame, she had a very high expectation of everyone.

[@YenNguyen-yu5dc]

juandenz2008 : the girl with American flag is UEE. She is still doing drama. She just won her excellence award in 2016 for her drama Marriage Contract which was Super! And her newest drama is My Only One.

[@byunsehun9847]

miss this era

[@moomonii]

miss u guys :(

[@RainbowCover]

i miss them so much i miss the good old days

[@쁘뿌-b9c]

초딩 학예회때 췄던 노랜데 갑자기 추천에 왜 떠 돌아가고싶은 내 어린시절 ㅠㅠㅠㅠ 어릴땐 마냥 성인되고싶어 자유로워지고싶어 했는데 성인 되고 나니 어릴때가 젤 좋은겨 정말 ㅠㅜㅜㅜㅠㅠ

[@purplequokka]

아 나 이 노래 너무 좋아했었는데 ㅠㅠ 춤까지 기억하네 몸이 그냥 반응해

[@paboooo8986]

omg i miss after school so muchhhhhhhhhh i hope they still together

[@alann5003]

Only discovering this group now from Uee's kdramas(my only one). She is so talented.

[@메모리-h5t]

멤버들 표정연기 너무 사랑스럽다...

[@rosieposie3712]

This song is underrated. I love it so much! From the music, dance and their outfit. 100 pointssss

[@CesarNoelQ]

When all your group visuals in one sub unit. Damn.. Kahi, Uee, Nana

[@afrezanurafifah5285]

Amazing KAHI 💖 miss them After School 😇

[@SuperJuniorKings]

After School are queens ♥️👑 i miss them. Uee is still one of my top female biases.

[@mingmingsworld269]

Kahi the queen ㅠㅠ wow i miss after school so so much!! The 100% live vocals are amazing af and GUYS NANA IS ACTUALLY TAN AND HAD A CORRECT SHADE ON FOUNDATION ON HER IM SO SHOCKED

[@joesumat]

Haha

[@元張-t1i]

很棒的表演……讚！uie nana 嘉熙都很漂亮

[@queenshaneul]

Uee eonni ❤️😘

[@christianyu6830]

#bodygoalssquad.. Nana and uee the bodies,kahi and jungah the leaders lol

[@HuyLe-gw9ed]

Best Unit !!! Visual 100đ Vocal 100đ Dance 100đ Rap 100đ

[@gypsi963]

I used to watch this performance alot back then. So when (G)i-dle debuted I felt like Miyeon looked like someone else but I couldn't exactly pinpoint who. Then when I watched this today again, I realise it was Jungah. Miyeon gave me Jungah vibe.

[@josephjlzt8662]

echan meikam wow now that you mentioned it, they definitely have similarities

[@semiprotita]

I always watch this clip whenever it gets in my recommendations and i think this sub-unit, song, choreo, mv, even line distribution gives me 2ne1 vibes. AS is one talented group only to be trashed by their agency.

[@marfsalem7401]

IT'S ALREADY NOV 25, 2021 BUT I STILL REMEMBER THE CHOREO!!!!

[@정정수-c4g]

I MISS THEM !!! PLEDIS.. PLS BRING THEM BACK !! KPOP NEED THEM

[@rin_box]

say what you want about how pledis manages their artists, but uee and nana are actually transitioned smoothly from somehow popular idols into pretty decent actors

[@nguyenhatien1787]

they work their ass out to prove the public's prejudice wrong, amazing women.

[@kittyong5576]

2020 AND I STILL STAN THEM TO DEATH...OH WHY AFTER SCHOOL :'(

[@alwayshappy9430]

The best of AS unit

[@babylevyofficial]

They really so beautiful body tall face บุคลิกดีมากเลย

[@GreenBaicha]

เพลงเกาหลีเก่าๆ มีเพราะๆหลายเพลงมาก คิดถึงสมัยก่อนเลยยย❤️

[@heraldmedal]

uee love you

[@elleanypost]

2nd Generations are the best among the rest why? Because even if they are in a nugu company they can still shine and well-known unlike today, some of them struggles to came to top and be known. Beside of that, 2nd Gen really pave the way to be well-known not only in Asia but throughout other continents. I miss 2nd Gen, I miss them.

[@afunggracia8982]

aq ska bgt sma after scooll

[@MrHang2002]

I miss you Uee

[@deuiskhalaf2094]

Uee still in drama until these day

[@veranovita6074]

miss this era😢

[@울쁘띠]

이노래는진짜내가좋아하는노랭

[@wonuinu9946]

Missing Nana and after school on stage so much

[@adf92]

유이 미쳤다,,

[@ambardwi2722]

The 2nd gg is the best... no lipsync... and their voice is so stable...