TWICE Reveals How They've Changed Over the Years | Then vs. Now | Seventeen

K-Pop icons TWICE (Momo, Mina, Dahyun, Sana, Jihyo, Chaeyoung, Nayeon, Tzuyu) have been together for six years, so we asked them to play a game of "Then vs. Now" and look back on how they've changed since their world debut. From how long it took them to learn their choreography to their fave TWICE song of all time, they're serving a huge dose of nostalgia. Listen to Formula of Love: O+T=❤️ here: twice.lnk.to/f...
Producer: Rachel Lieberman
Editor: JY Chung
Graphics: Kelsey Fink
Entertainment Manager: Emily Hausman
#TWICE
#FormulaOfLove
♥ SEVENTEEN SHOWS ♥
Bestie Picks Bae: • I Let My Best Friend P...
Lyric Challenge: • Video
Superlatives Challenge: • Dylan Sprouse and Hann...
Seventeen Firsts: • My First Birth Control...
Style Lab: • 7 Mermaid Inspired Out...
Bullet Journaling w/ Noelle: • How to Start a Bullet ...
♥ Subscribe to Seventeen! bit.ly/SUBToSEV... ♥
♥ Follow Seventeen ♥
/ seventeen
/ seventeen
/ seventeen
/ seventeen

[@Flyingpigs82]

They’ve changed so much, that they’ve even got a new outfit in a matter of seconds

[@emy5229]

i just laughed so hard

[@realnatys]

Yeah, what happen?

[@aahhhhbeeeeeee]

@@realnatys it was to include jeongyeon

[@pancheetoz4647]

I’m happy the editors got to include Jeongyeon, OT9 ftw!! 🥰

[@steamedbryce]

Wait but where was the other interview/outfits from? They still promoted FOL in it

[@tzunami984]

Aww that's nice seeing Mina and Tzuyu expressing themselves better now in this interview hehe

[@saracooper3435]

yeah

[@tathagatanaskar2802]

Yeah!

[@SurfersSilver]

Jeongyeon: Thanks for being on this journey with us 😭😭😍 Thanks Seventeen for putting Jeongyeon clip...bcus nothing is better than seeing TWICE being 9 💚

[@angiereo]

OT9❤❤

[@samanthakim5035]

❤️

[@angelinecaneta8880]

Look at the members they wrote thou.

[@saracooper3435]

yess

[@falafel777]

wait what happened to her?

[@kheshirekat9623]

This might be the first time I saw artist actually choose a favorite instead of saying the latest comeback!!!

[@FudgeeClydeChuckBlairKai]

They are consistent on feel special and what is love

[@TaNoY77]

@@FudgeeClydeChuckBlairKai And Jihyo with Dance the night away. She loves that song..

[@by.ayshahina]

Yeahh

[@rainbowgirl949494]

@@TaNoY77 that was her era. she was glowing that time. I’m still speechless

[@a.sulzyy]

Lol it’s funny because during Feel Special Era Tzuyu was self promoting the song so much

[@shakirashakira1296]

3:29 Mina suddenly got too comfortable like she's just at home when Once was mentioned, seems like she's comfortable with fans. I really like Mina's personality because she is a genuine person.

[@jenniesgirl8460]

{10:29} i love that nayeon likes to talk & lead the conversation but equally listens & gives others an opportunity to be heard. such a precious soul.

[@DorcasDiaries]

She exhibits the qualities of a good leader. I heard she's the oldest

[@jianligangoso4073]

Jihyo also, she tries to ask tzuyu questions and gives her the chance to answer. I think the quite members like to stay quite because they're comfortable that way. They don't force them to speak or anything... but gives them the chances when they can.

[@rapthor666]

Yea, in Jihyo they got a pretty good leader, but Nayeon is indeed very smart in keeping the spotlight so the quieter members can rest a bit but gives them their time to shine when they want to

[@jianligangoso4073]

@@DorcasDiaries Nayeon almost became a leader aswell but she was outvoted by Jihyo. I found it quite interesting at first because Nayeon was the oldest and I wasn't sure if it'd work out because Jihyo was younger by a few years. But oh well, it worked out pretty well. Jeongyeon is like the mother, Jihyo's the father, and Nayeon's the spoiled oldest😌 Jeongyeon is the heart, Jihyo keeps the members together, Nayeon she's the mouth✊🏼 It's 3mix power😎

[@alanlopez2180]

She’s such a Virgo 🤣 my fav tho ❤️

[@durgav2378]

I love how Jihyo always tries to include Tzuyu and Mina by asking questions and kindling them to talk ❤️❤️❤️ such a precious soul she is. She's such an amazing leader. 😍😍😍❤️❤️❤️

[@eeyre]

on that aspect Jihyo >>> self centered Nayeon. That's why she's the leader

[@zyedelric]

Nayeon really said it, they didn't even tried hard to get in sync, they're just perfect with it. They are that GOOD.

[@Minatozaki_Icarie]

You can really tell that all of them wants to be healthy and happy. I can't imagine another member having hiatus. Everyone, Stay healthy and happy.

[@zheke_music]

*i love how we always get to see tzuyu's zone out face whenever a member is talking, how is she so pretty even when zoning out* 😍😂

[@Johnsmith-rb8sw]

Ikr.. especially whenever the camera shows Sana or Jihyo talking, I just keep looking at her glowing face..like "wahhh..yeppuda...💕💕💕💕" 😂😂

[@stanyoojeongyeonforworldpeace]

It actually made me cry realizing how many times they mentioned health and happiness as something they want and prioritize now considering their very hectic schedule and having to perform without some of the members (first Mina, and then Jeongyeon). I hope that they're always happy and healthy.

[@bluebee29]

I genuinely hope they will last more than 7 years. They are such a tight iconic girl group. The members are the same and no member goes solo. If there is one successful Kpop gg out there that can have a 15th anniversary concert in the future, it's TWICE no doubt! They can be the historic gg versions of Shinhwa, but better. There's no other Kpop gg that come close as of now.

[@rapthor666]

Apink until Naeun decided to do more acting had their 10th anniversary tho Just hoping being madly successful doesn't weigh too much on the girls

[@sentienttrash2179]

Yes!

[@bluebee29]

@@rapthor666 yeah I know about Apink. They did well too. It's really difficult for gg for some reason. Let's hope Twice can do it too and hopefully longer and still together

[@beltrangarrote1982]

The fan base is stronger than ever. They really seem to love each other and enjoy what they do. I agree they have the potential to sign another contract while becoming more mature and Global. Not having had individual endorsements has allowed to keep the TWICE brand impeccable and tight. Work is very well done, time for pay off. One thing is sure: ONCEs will be there.

[@steamedbryce]

No like honestly Twice are a great selection for this series. They've been in the industry for 6 whole years. They've changed and evolved so much- their singing abilities, their dancing abilities, their cohesion as a unit and as a sisterhood, as people, as songwriters, and as artists. They've changed with Once too and we all feel how their growth has really shined

[@poi_99]

You know they’re successful because they’re just hoping to be healthy and be happy with their lives.

[@nathanp2007]

I love that what they care about most is their health and properly resting when they have time to rest. That's such a healthy mindset to have and so important for people as busy as they are. I hope they aren't empty words and they are truly making the best decisions for their health and happiness.

[@stelrex7293]

When it comes to TWICE you can always expect honesty. Honestly, Sincerity and Modesty are the 3 core values taught in JYPE.

[@donlee4105]

"Feel Special" was a real masterpiece. i dont find anyone who dislike the song

[@GOMAWOUPDATE]

One in a million 🍭

[@kokoo1322]

[@fel9ne]

Hi we are Twice

[@ot9732]

Hi we are twice

[@user-kg9kr2zk6j]

I was once a blink but ended up as once and now I can't let go of them. I swear Twice hits different bro

[@julsegs]

Same. But I'm still thankful to BLACKPINK, especially Lisa. If it weren't for her What Is Love dance on their interview I wouldn't be able to appreciate TWICE and embrace them as my ult girl group. 💛

[@carolynyap6378]

Omg same. I like the fact that Twice always have more content, like how many comebacks they had for since they debuted?! Include TTT!

[@saracooper3435]

same

[@saracooper3435]

@@julsegs same thats exactly how i got into twice

[@jasonnosaj858]

Same. No other GG can compare to TWICE's group charm, bond and je ne sais quoi

[@aubreycaswell2747]

so proud how far they've come, i do love it that they're more focused on happiness and contentment now. they've worked so hard to earn that stability

[@christiancesarcalderon5296]

They really talk about how important to take care of yourself and Ii think I didn't said that its is the reason but I think Mina and Jeongyeon conditions made the members snap into reality or getting awake about how important health is about how important to take care of yourself and to not overwork.

[@grethelknow1778]

I love how Tzuyu and Mina really did get a chance to talk 💖

[@kyoe_mmr]

Stay healthy in both mentally and physically and also stay with us: ONCE for many more years! Love u TWICE!

[@blue_hour_wolf]

10:29 Aw, Is it just me or are Nayeon and Tzuyu so cute together right now

[@once4ever97]

Tzuyu attracts our eyes like why would they put her in front, she's too pretty. So angelic to the extent i just stare at her💝😧 and not focus on whos talking at all

[@idontwanttosaymynameonyout1486]

Hearing Sana say “it’s been six years since our world debut” just made my whole year 💗😍

[@jenniesgirl8460]

{9:33} chaeyoung poking fun at how much the other girls mention health is so funny to me

[@723-s8g]

it's so fun watching twice talking about casual things in life like this. I wish there are more contents like this

[@joshanmr3260]

Tzuyu looks so attractive. She's the visual of visuals for a reason

[@naefelluces2643]

I'm living with Tzuyu spacing out most of the time Hahaha she's so cute and that OT9 at the end.

[@marieee2985]

It feels like they have already achieved their dreams. No matter what your decision next year, I will still support you!

[@knightstrike7220]

TWICE this was an amazing interview , also congrats on your new album The Formula of Love: O+T=

[@DavidJohnson-ku3zu]

Don't forget to vote TWICE at the MAMA awards

[@tracklauonly]

Nayeon is such a goal person. She listens, is funny, encourages the rest. I am 100% convinced that a great deal of Twice success is because of the great support jihyo and nayeon are.

[@ellamfw]

i love mina so much! her break from the industry really payed off. she is expressing herself more and more and is literally shining. she is so confident now. love her 💞

[@rajvirsingh5754]

It's nice to see Tzuyu talk so much during an interview

[@shaktammeeks]

When Jihyo speaking. . Tzuyu totally looks like a doll

[@Dan-wg8mr]

I was shocked when Jeongyeon suddenly appeared. I MISS YOU JEONGYEON❤❤

[@beyondthebop]

2 years later and they've finally been to Europe! We were so blessed!

[@izzymorgen62468]

I really enjoyed this interview. None of the questions felt redundant & the girls got to speak in Korean. It struck a nice balance between being interesting for fans and not pressuring them into saying things they didn't want to share. I hope more groups get to do interviews like this!

[@nrfafau]

BROOOOO IM SO SHOCKED WHEN YOU PUT JEONGYEON AT THE END THANK YOU SO MUCH 😭💚💗

[@aidanrlow104]

4:27 tzuyu looking at me like i brought cupcakes to the class and didn't give her one

[@heinricklucena8704]

MINA and TZUYU are getting more comfortable in expressing their feelings and are not talking more in interviews. LOVE THAT!!💖💖💖💖

[@xocxox]

They have become more mature as their six years have passed.

[@KyagiJo]

That was kind of odd at the end when Jeongyeon appeared?! They must have somehow summoned her, with all that talk about staying healthy 😂 Seems odd to bring her in for just the one line, maybe there is more footage to be released? This was a really informative interview with a unique format though, definitely worth watching!

[@big_mango]

The interview looks like it must have been filmed during “the feels” bc of their hair, especially nayeons. I’m not sure why they brought them back in before releasing it lol

[@sacha3296]

this was filmed in august, because they released tiktoks in these outfits back than. they must’ve done another interview with the channel/magazine and the used that as the outro. also they probably didn’t have all the information about the comeback. so they filmed an outro now when everything is set in stone.

[@shashasatzu6228]

Then: Gorgeous, Goddess, Angel Now: Gorgeous, Goddess, Angel Nothing changed🤭

[@strawberry-eq6bi]

It's really nice to see Mina and tzuyu participating

[@AliceBz]

They are at the point in their career where they value health and happiness over winning, that's really what truly matters in life, im glad they have reached this epiphany so fast and together, like everyone feels that way.

[@nicolechinchilla4936]

Fue lindo oír a todas las chicas, y en especial es lindo ver a Mina y Tzuyu cada vez más confiadas

[@Dcond3]

So many Close ups of Tzuyu!! It’s amazing!!

[@kathleenl8813]

"I hope I do bad?" Tzuyu you're just too funny for this world 😂

[@jarrah1996]

This are so comfortable especially Tzuyu 😊

[@timidddle]

This is the feels era, and suddenly Jy appeared, oh come on, 17, bring out the latest interview we really love ya..

[@Pipiroro2422]

8:05 look how jihyo look at tyuzu...so lovelly eyes on u... 😌❤️ And ask tyuzu about favorite song... Tyuzu always say"Feel special"... 😁 Same i love feel special too... 8:57 u like dahyun explained about this one....🙂....

[@brahimsalki4982]

Man Tzuyu is so beautiful I can't get over it

[@ahjinnn_02]

Tzuyu is like spaced out again... So cutee

[@estar2245]

It shows that they have mature throughout the year with their answer especiallly in term of finding happiness within ownself and its health

[@JokerCrowe]

Loving the focus on health at this time! They definitely deserve to rest after all the hard work they've done, so I'm glad to hear that they feel that way too. Also, yes more travel please! Concert in Europe!! TWICE FIGHTING

[@yugoalyssamaed.3331]

They've grown so much

[@harambeatemydog5283]

Jeongyeon coming out of nowhere caught me off guard had to rewind to see if she was there all alone

[@user-wb3vv]

i hope they found their real happiness despite all these hectic schedules 💗

[@jenniesgirl8460]

{8:19} jihyo chose violnce, exposing sana like that lmao

[@denissewoo]

Omg there's so much content. I'm so excited ❤❤

[@BrianChen0701]

Tzuyu Queen You’re so beautiful and elegant.

[@jenniesgirl8460]

{2:53- 3:02} jihyo + dahyun promoting twice better than JYP ever could

[@virgantaraaa]

I know it's just a joke (or maybe not), but JYPE really promoting Twice better than some of their artist (even group from another agency that debut at same moment with Twice) eventho Twice on their six years

[@julsegs]

JYPE are promoting them even harder than before though, no? Since last year, we get to see these kinds of content, interviews, and more promotional performances in the Western. So, yeah, I just begged to differ. Peace. ✌️

[@telkomselm3465]

2:57 momo shocked

[@shootoki]

Its nice seeing tzuyu talk, i noticed that she became more social and cheerful with the members :>

[@veritasastro]

To block spoilers for "The Feels", this part of the previous interview has been released now! So nice to watch this!

[@user-jq1ud8kr6c]

I love how they able to put jeongyeon on the outro

[@user-ii2tf6sg7h]

Sana's Korean improved amazingly I can notice that her accent n vocabulary r the best among other foreign members

[@jenniesgirl8460]

{0:25}: momo saying "*some members*" took longer to learn choreo {0:29}: jihyo confriming that she is indeed the "*some members*" in question

[@RadXXI]

it's Jeongyeon,Sana and Jihyo

[@Sanas_Shy_Language]

I remember watching TWICE TV all those years ago and being so happy for them, now, here I am rooting for them to find their happiness. Also, opening up the outro with Jeongyeon Seventeen? We stan-

[@aruakise5180]

I love how they have been getting more and more involved in the creative process. Like they started co-writing some lyrics and now they chose what songs are gonna be in their albums and some of them even compose... I'm really proud of them

[@AllieOk]

Thanks for putting the clip with Jeongyeon 🥺🥺🥺❤️❤️❤️

[@jaustmike9001]

I agree, What Is Love is just a masterpiece of a music video. I mean, it got me watching Kpop music videos. Also, looove Dahyun, but she's always like a company's spokesperson in these interviews. Generally, never candid with her answers. 😁✌

[@lyssacaros3755]

you really see their growth and how they matured. now theyre more free and more involved in the music making, but at the same time theyre not chasing records anymore tp prove themselves. its important theyre happy and healthy and still continue to progress as a team, they really are getting global. such organic growth

[@gilbertoespinoza6179]

TWICE best K-POP group

[@kheshirekat9623]

11:19 Outfit change caught me off guard, Dahyun looks so good here

[@prasithoudomvilay8454]

I bet they will have that outfit fir next KZbin channel interview

[@zehraparlak3842]

I love that all of them had time to speak especially Tzuyu an Mina. Ir felt like in other interviews they didn't feel as comfortable with the questions or sharing their thoughts.

[@gamjahyuhjah]

When tzuyu smiled at 9:22 I couldn’t help but smile too

[@mia-ci2ur]

aw them putting in the formula of love clip next to their the feels looks just to include jeongyeon is so sweet i love my OT9 twice!

[@juliasousa6299]

Twice have matured so well.... It's so nice to see a group grow up❣️I love them

[@ONCE1729TWICE]

9:21 they're in sync here too!

[@ashoka230]

Being a leader of a group which was the first group with J-line and a taiwanese total of 3 cultures. But still Jihyo succeeded in keeping them all together like glue and grow successful together. The members also knew how they worked hard to be in the group and they have to stay together to be successful. Twice should always be Nine or None group.

[@rajatsandhu3995]

Indian once ✌️

[@ashoka230]

@@rajatsandhu3995 Hai my co-once..

[@lightthunder5265]

Thanks for inviting twice

[@BriskSundew-cl4ug]

Wishing for more & more years with TWICE.

[@RinRin-wr4dp]

Twice are amazing ❤️ Tzuyu and Mina is talking 🤭wow ❤️

[@tenzero5274]

always great having twice on 🥺

[@kevinross6235]

0:11 she's so... Baby? I don't know how to describe it better

[@nudi9099]

This something I’m say n I’m not afraid nobody in the whole kpop industry lover their fans like twice honestly oh god I love thhem so much

[@subhajeetchakraborty1791]

its everything , they all are sooo adorable, everything, their personality, acts , everything

[@SurfersSilver]

Our favourite kpop group: TWICE, then and now it's TWICE 🙆🏻‍♀️😍😍

[@minariot6792]

YOW IVE BEEN WAITING FOR THIS!! SINCE LAST MONTH I SAW ITZY DOING THIIISSS!!!😭😭☹️ TYSMM!!

[@um_runa]

RIGHT AS SOON AS I SAID “Baby i~” CHAE SAID IT AFTER ME 😫

[@sreeharidascloud]

6:50 the way nayeon said what is love to imitate momo just like she said on one interview...ugh peach sisters i cant

[@syauqijamil5170]

There's so much twice content, and I'm here for it! 😄

[@Jouda5923]

One of my favourite interviews !! May our girls have the happiest and healthiest lifes ..Once will always be with you 💞

[@anthonyrevate8048]

TWICE are the best love these interviews!

[@oifelix1568]

they’ve grown so much

[@sh8835a]

When tzuyu was zoning out , i looked at her pretty face and zoned out too. 😳

[@s-davidmav7770]

4:15 I stan and support the 9 of them but, at that moment, all I can do is watching Tzuyu xD xD

[@remuspierre8038]

Incredible thank you for giving me confidence in your music

[@baraborneo7999]

WHAT IN THE WORLD JEONGYEON SUDDENLY APPEARS ON THE LAST SECOND OF THE VIDEO.... I WAS SHOCKED