Types of Relations (Solved Problem)

[@ir2001]

Homework Answer: NOT Transitive For example, (2, 1) and (1, 3) belongs to R, but (2, 3) does not belong to R

[@karimabou6493]

But what if we take (1,2) and (2,1) belongs to R. Is (1,1) belong to R??

[@ir2001]

@@karimabou6493 Yes, but note the "for every" part in the definition. Hence, one such example doesn't show that the relation is transitive, but one counterexample is sufficient to show that the relation is not transitive.

[@karimabou6493]

Okey i get it now. Thank u so much😊

[@jayap8355]

Can you explain me why it is symmetric then? We should consider all real numbers right... So we can also write 3+2 and 2+3 ..won't be it then non symmetric?

[@ir2001]

@@jayap8355 The "relation" discussed in this thread has been with reference to the given homework (focusing on the disjunctive proposition: x=1 OR y=1), so I'm not sure what the implication is by your premise involving addition (3+2, 2+3)

[@aditianand6966]

I promise to contribute the day I will get a job because right now my condition is not so good. This channel is the best I have ever found. Thank you so much neso academy

[@marvhartigan3677]

Great thought!

[@TheAI-Tutor]

[@fluxytwin]

so whats your contribution now???its been 2 years

[@pinkmangooooo]

It’s been 2 years

[@deeppandit6992]

Hello Neso Academy, First of all thank you so much you guys for these awesome videos. Your content really helps me. But at some point, it feels like videos are not coming much frequently. No offense, I know it's not easy to make these videos and you guys make videos on many different topic too, and it's so much time consuming. But you guys started Discrete Mathematics series 3 years ago and it's still not half a way. I know it's a very huge area, it's going to take time, but it's just a genuine request from your student (your fan), that could you guys please upload videos much frequently. You guys said anyone in college who have this subject in syllabus or anyone preparing for GATE could watch it, but since the series is not fully completed, we can't understand the whole subject. Kitno ki to exam nikal jayegi jab tak yeh series khatam hogi. Just a genuine appeal, btw I love you guys and your content. ❤️

[@alauddinsummy7168]

your voice is so much clear

[@Enthub47]

The last relation {x,y| x=1 or y=1 } is NOT TRANSITIVE because When we have a set A={1,2,3} (1,2),(2,3),(3,1) in this not all the all the pairs include one hence there’ll be a case where y is not = 1 or x is not =1 ((2,3)).

[@corinaalexeynov1283]

H/W Answer ; Relation is not transitive since (a,1) belongs to R and (1,b) belongs to R but (a,b) does not belong to R

[@usamaahmed4885]

the answer is :not transitive see why if a=1 the answer will be transitive (a,b)=(1,2) and (b,c)=(2,3) then (a,c)=(1,3) but if b=2 the answer will be not transitive : (a,b)=(2,1) and (b,c)=(1,3) then (a,c)=(2,3) and it isn’t satisfied the condition of a=1 or b=1 . i hope it’s clear

[@satioOeinas]

Very high quality. Thank you!

[@harikaburagapu]

Thank q so much neso acadamy.....❤❤❤

[@rajeshprajapati4863]

Answer to H.W : R is Not Transitive. For Ex - a=2, b=1, c=2.

[@satyajitjena19]

Ye to fir transitive ho gaya according to ur values

[@ramanrajagopalan3215]

Hi @4:01 why did you take x and y as 0 for reflexive and symmetric and why did you take 1 and -1 for antisymmetric and transitive? If we take same 0 for antisymmetric and transitive they will be accepted right?

[@harshitasharma7665]

Coz relation should satisfy all values..

[@chibuikemchigbo3680]

it is transitive. considering a=1, b=1 and c=2, then result will still be 1,2. x=1 or y=1 doesn't mean that both can not be equal to 1

[@anniemannie6]

It won't be transitive. Let a=2, b=1, c=2 (a,b) = (2,1) (b,c) = (1,2) (a,c) = (2,2) doesn't have a 1 in it. And you cannot consider both a and b as 1 because the condition says that only one of the elements can be 1

[@chinazaekperechinyere1252]

What if we take a as 1, b as 2 and c as 3 (a,b) = ( 1,2), (b,c) = (2,3) and (a,c) =( 1,3) Making it transitive I think the solution for a relation to be transitive in this case is conditional because when a is 1, it's transitive and when a is any other number but b is 1, it is not transitive.

[@TheAI-Tutor]

[@Joonie1206]

Hi, great video. Please cover equivalence relation and equivalence classes in the next episode.

[@shahllansheikh]

thanks

[@jackshih6084]

In my class, we just end number theory... Maybe I will review discrete using your videos lol. ps. most i love is your c programming and data structure

[@acriziosouza]

Homework Answer: Not Transitive. For being transitive, it's not sufficient that X or Y be 1, the union of ordered pairs (a,b) and (b,c) must implies in the ordered pair (a,c). However, it's possible to not reach this answer. For example: a = 3 b = 1 c = 2 (a,b) ^ (b,c) ^ (a,c) (3,1) ^ (1,2) ^ (3,2) Although "b" fits the criteria (Y = 1), the ordered pair (a,c) isn't a implication of the union of the ordered pairs (a,b) and (b,c). Of course if a=1, b=2 and c=1, the implication of the union of the same ordered pair would fit the criteria. However, it isn't the only possibility. Therefore, "X=1 or Y=1" is not a Transitive relation.

[@MrGustavier]

Isn't relation b) an equivalence relation on the real numbers ?

[@harshitasharma7665]

Yes it is..

[@learninginstudentscafe7284]

Good job

[@mohammadtarig2083]

My answer to homework is not transitive. Why? ⬇️ For it to be transitive: (a,b) belongs to R AND (b,c) belongs to R implies (a,c) belongs to R and that is not true. For example: (0,1) belongs to R AND (1,3) belongs to R but (0,3) doesn't belong to R.

[@haiderkhan2518]

how can you say (0,3) doesn't belong to R ?please tell me.i'm confused.

[@huntergathr]

@@haiderkhan2518 remember a or b has to always be 1. I find it helpful to play with different numbers and then make sure all conditions are satisfied.

[@ChandramouliPatra-l5r]

Not transitive If a=1 and b=0 then (a,b) belongs to R and (b,a) belongs to R but (a,a) does not belongs to R

[@anasgujjar7485]

❤❤

[@mithunr8459]

ig it is transitive(homework problem)

[@JustScript99]

x * y != 0

[@JustScript99]

is it reflexive or not and why

[@learninginstudentscafe7284]

Not transitive

[@peshal0]

💀

[@Quiet_Wanderer015]

Not transitive

[@yadeedyadesabattula2291]

Not transitive

[@JustScript99]

x * y != 0 is it reflexive or not, do you know that, please help me

[@harshitasharma7665]

​@@JustScript99it is not reflexive coz it's only true for 0×0!

[@Bun.n.i]

Not transitive

[@ArtemisWrites]

Not transitive