Understanding the Life & Music of Amar Singh Chamkila | Diljit Dosanjh | Imtiaz Ali | The Quint

[@abhishekbose8665]

The fact that movie does not have any cliches tropes mentioned here🔥🔥

[@BohoDevi]

such a good video for non punjabi viewers to understand the context behind the man and his legendary status.

[@novacanemusic97]

Thanks. Chamkila's story is one of the most dramatic in Indian music IMO. I'm glad you liked the episode! 😊

[@gurchhindersingh7194]

Chamkila was a Dalit “Chamar which is a Dalit cast in Punjab. I hope Imtiaz Sir touched upon this also. That day and today how cast play a role in the music industry.

[@ozbeg8228]

I would be thoroughly disappointed if things are brushed under the carpet.Caste may been one of the reasons he was killed.

[@asmander6630]

Punjabi music lovers don’t give any preference to casteism or religion of any singer , that’s where Punjabi culture is different then many other states of India.

[@nitishsaxena1372]

​so many Punjabi songs have caste references @@asmander6630

[@pixiv9823]

​@@asmander6630 this is nonsense

[@libertybee1307]

​@@ozbeg8228well dont be it was highlighted

[@I_support_Secular_INDIA]

I would like to watch this movie for sure as I'm a fan of Diljit, Parineeti and Chamkila too.

[@annageorge1992]

Thank you for this. Going to watch the movie now

[@shaziawajid4641]

What a great explanation and indepth analysis of music, musicians, society and its standards of morality. Maza a gya. Keep up the great work.

[@baseballfan88888]

I never ever imagined that non Punjabi speakers will show their interest in Chamkila. Is it just because the movie or you guys already knew that legend ???

[@novacanemusic97]

Hehe I won't lie and say I'm the biggest Chamkila fan. I had heard a few songs previously. But since last year (after the film's announcement) I've been playing his songs non stop. I sort of went into a rabbit hole of him life and story... He was sooo good!

[@baseballfan88888]

@@novacanemusic97 👍😄

[@ksb7467]

My cousin from Ludhiana used to visit our home during summer holidays during the Bluetooth era. We used to exchange songs and discuss Punjabi music. He told me about Chamkila. This was late 2000s and early 2010s.

[@84manjit]

What an erudite way you have explained the phenomenon. I love it.

[@KillerMirzaX]

Chamkila was an amazing artist, great at singing, writing songs, performing, and making people laugh. His songs talked about many different kinds of people, both men and women. He could sing from the point of view of young folks to the elderly, showing he was truly talented. Comparing him to Sidhu Moosewala, who might be considered a C-grade imitation of Tupac Shakur, doesn't do justice to Chamkila's unique talents and contributions.

[@DanishAli-gw9ke]

Drake follows siddhu moosewala dude

[@KillerMirzaX]

@@DanishAli-gw9ke Every Punjabi artist, including Sidhu Moose Wala, followed Chamkila. Many hit songs were inspired by Chamkila’s compositions and lyrics. For instance, artists like Honey Singh, Gippy Grewal, Diljit Dosanjh, Karan Aujla, and Sidhu Moose Wala have produced songs that reflect his influence. In short, Chamkila was the seed from which the tree of Punjabi music grew.

[@nirbhaynandan72]

Market is not just based on demand and supply... You can create demand. Here every human has negative and postive side, negative side come out easily and ppl play on it...... Bhojpuira songs!!!

[@karatekid7640]

Indeed, i don't know about chamkela (who i heard also wrote against khalistanis and was forced to back down after receiving death threats) but seedhu musawala on the other hand romanticised gun culture, gangster and also khalistanis just for the sake of it. They should have free speech no doubt but should certainly not be encouraged like this and whitewash his character like this guy is trying to do...

[@Ramgarhia17]

Blaaast chamkilla jatttt❤

[@samaranjaykaundal5228]

You can’t compare sidhu to the great chamkeela

[@baajk2778]

omg !! what an amazing review !! I am impressed!!!

[@novacanemusic97]

Thanks a lot😊😊

[@Prabh892]

Sidhu Moose wala did not sing about alcohol or objectifying women , in that way he was different from Chamkila

[@DebjyotiMahato]

You are wrong, Imtiaz don't need approval from anybody. He already is successful and an auter if you say in bollywood!

[@niharikasharma678]

That’s what I thought ❤

[@JitenderKumar-lp2yv]

❤❤❤ Chamkils Amarjot Ji

[@dhwanitd]

Don’t glorify the nonsense, vulgar and anti social elements of the music world. They were not real stars. They just encashed the dirty psychological thought process of a common man which were never expressed otherwise.

[@MusicallyTanvi]

Hey this is such a well thought and well articulated review. Loved it! 😊

[@godisone7399]

Chamkila movie ❤❤

[@muditvarshney18]

Waaaao..great video and research.

[@Nooooooo0000]

Chamkila is way bigger than moosewala

[@anshrbhagat]

Very good narration.

[@novacanemusic97]

Thank you😊

[@shivanipatnaik3865]

Could anyone please share the video he shared about the Rahul Gandhi vs Modi. Curious to know what it is !!

[@labhsingh4024]

Punjabi Singer Amar Singh Chamkila is Rich Calture, Rich Singer..no Dalit,,Chopra..Same Face

[@aninditasaha2676]

Why are we talking about a person and glorifying who used to write these kind of Lyrics??? Am i missing something?

[@mimis.5139]

It's about Perspective. He wasn't a singer who writes from inside he was a writer of the streets. His inspirations used to exist in real.

[@amarpreetpaul6749]

Loved this perspective

[@salmarehman3021]

Amazing video

[@vibhasharma9179]

Very good analysis

[@alwinbenjamin]

👑

[@GurdeepSingh-ii7vu]

Excellent explanation with examples thanks sir

[@smoothcriminal5650]

Great analysis!

[@utsavthakur3187]

Excellent explanation thanks sir

[@f4life-l3v]

Only negative is praneeti.... She's dead both inside outside

[@timmypannu]

👍

[@roopsalve5083]

I wish the background music was muted

[@zfold4702]

Ye Aftab Sivdasani ka bhai laga mujhe.

[@rashmialone1894]

loved the video

[@Shruthirh]

Well said

[@kuleinderkaur2687]

No you can't compare chamkila with sidhu moosewala

[@sanjeevkumar2347]

Aaj kal to ye cheez sareaam ho rhi Hai...

[@chiragsharma953]

Ab toh dekh li

[@muralimd999]

Why you bringing moosewala in this video. Ita irrelevant?

[@beyondinfinity3658]

Please don’t compare sidu moosewala with chamkila. CHAMKILA was the legend.

[@randomguygogo]

An artist brutally killed. Heart pains.

[@chandujames77]

Only if it were made in malyalam would we see some content in the movie. Hindi mai bass wohi basic masala and movie khatam

[@MixXD947]

Yeh namuna kaun hai (Host)

[@manalitt]

Amar n his wife shudnt hv been killed...

[@trivendrakumarsingh5732]

Bhai is hisab se Honey singh , badshah , baki singers ko criticise karna padega Liberal Log porn ko justify karte hai freedom ke naam pe Lekin chamkila ko criticise kar rha😅 Bhai marne ke baad to chhod do

[@cinefile0075]

Criticize nhi kar raha. Wo defend kar Raha Hain video konsi dekh raha hain??

[@ECUBE-ef8qz]

Wo bhi khalistani tha kya

[@ShivamAroraa]

This video is so pretentious

[@Foodie2101]

Iska video koi nhi dekhna

[@bekartoka2823]

Why don't you stick with one language, either Hindi or English? Though your content is interesting but annoying at the same time.