Unearthly Cosmetics Sorcerous Smoke & Fall Magic Palettes | Swatches, Comparisons, 2 Looks

[@TracyD2]

Love it when a brand owner is receptive to constructive criticism. I have cancelled companies for acting foolish before. It’s À saturated market nowadays. Companies have to be all things to succeed. I wish Unearthly Cosmetic all the best. 🧙‍♂️ 💨 Yes honey Unfortunately my daughter took all my allotted money for car repairs this month.

[@amandaflippin5368]

They're both gorgeous, but Sorcerous Smoke is definitely more my colors. Curious how it compares to Ensley Reign Harvest Moon. They look like they would compliment each other so well! Props to Amanda at Unearthly for taking constructive criticism and upping the formula, how wonderful to have a brand owner who works so hard to keep consumers happy! ❤

[@seekingshifts]

Ooohh they do have similar vibes for sure with the muted grungy tones!! I will take side by side pics on my IG stories at some point today ❤️

[@amandaflippin5368]

@@seekingshifts that would be awesome! Thank you 😍

[@Haydenhaunts]

❤❤❤ I’m so happy you are enjoying your palettes!

[@daphnemaldonado8098]

Amanda, sometimes you ask on instagram lives if something is missing from your line-up. I would love to see a trio/quad/small palette of these sparkly shimmers I neutral or sheer topper shades!

[@noopur_makeup]

Omg you're making me want Sorcerous Smoke even though I definitely do not need and should not buy any more makeup!

[@arielts06]

What space cowboy wishes it could be 😭🤣 Facts. I have not put Sorcerous Smoke down. It’s a spicy neutral girl’s dream.

[@blendofdays]

I was in the chat when Amanda did a live showing these two for the first time & sorceress smoke for sure immediately piqued my interest! Beautiful looks Riley & ty for all the swatches & comparisons! 🫶

[@seekingshifts]

I feel like I completely slept on it until I saw it IRL! Omg thank youu 😍

[@MariaMadeleine2809]

I... NEED this!!! 😱😱😱 Love and light from Denmark, Scandinavia ❤

[@hes01231]

I love Unearthly so much, it has been lovely to see them grow and evolve. I bought Sorcerous Smoke because it is absolutely beyond stunning, there is just something about it! I am excited to see more with their new holiday Dreamer release.. I impulsively purchased it when the pre-order was “leaked”… I’m not even a blue girly but they know how to curate a color story that is just perfectly well-rounded. Fortunately I haven’t had trouble with my DBJ so far, but my collection as a whole is a bit out of control at the moment lol so the wear and tear each palette gets is spread out a bit.

[@hes01231]

Ps- Obsessed with your looks! 💚

[@seekingshifts]

Thank you!! 🥰 I’m so tempted by their holiday release too! I’m glad you haven’t had any trouble with your DBJ because it’s a gorgeousss palette outside of the hard pan issue

[@hes01231]

@@seekingshifts It is a tempting time of year for sure! If you do get the Dreamer palette I would super love to see what you create with it if you had the time💜

[@kirrasenne4852]

I am obsessed with the sorcerers smoke palette and I just realized that it resembles the master palette by Mario (the collab with ABH) only WAY BETTER. Does anyone else see the similarities? Regardless, obsessed and will use your discount code Riley! Thanks for another amazing video ❤

[@not_your_basic_olive]

Not planning to pick any of their palettes atm, but I'm glad they sorted the shimmer formula issues. I can make more sense of the price if the shimmers don't hardpan, but even then it still remains overpriced for what it is.

[@daphnemaldonado8098]

Such a great review and the owner did a great job reformulating! I picked up the Valentines Mystery Box and noticed 2 of the shimmers still picked up but did have a hard pan seal like in your Don’t be Jelly review. The mattes performed very well. I also own All I Ever Wanted Vol 1 & 2 Palettes and none of them had hard pan. I’m interested in this palette but I currently have the 2022 edition of the Melt Gemini palette in my collection & I feel like this palette is a bit too similar for me to pick up. I hope they continue with the improved twinkling shimmer formula it looks great!

[@NicsSparkleSpace]

I didn't see your review video, but I do own Don't be Jelly, and almost every palette they've come out with in the last 2 years+ and I'm disappointed in their shimmers a lot of the time, but this palette just got me!! Fall Magic is more what I gravitate to, but I have a few palette that have the same color story so I passed. When I first saw Sorcerous Smoke honestly I passed on it, but the more swatch videos I saw, I needed it, so I ordered it with the new Holiday Collection box and I can't wait!!

[@dawnshrewsbury4881]

OMG I am obsessed with Sorcerer Smoke I think I'm going to order it. I love Unearthly. Your looks are always 😍

[@seekingshifts]

Thank you!!! The palette is seriously so beautiful 🥹

[@AislinSidhe]

Riley, I must ask because it's GORGEOUS, but what is on your nails? (Please say press-ons, please say press-ons!) I need Sorcerous with my soul. Thanks for such a comprehensive look at these palettes!

[@biogirl1381]

i loveeee unearthly’s formula and she definitely hit her sweet spot with her formula. i have the og fall magic, and it’s one of my all time favorite fall palettes, and i plan on getting the remastered, BUT i want the sorcerous smoke palette soooo much more, because that color story is everything and it’s screaming my freaking name every time i see it. the looks you created were absolutely STUNNING and i’d LOVE to see you create more looks with this palette. 😍😍😍

[@michellerocco5073]

Girl omgosh Where have you Been??? Miss you 🙏 ❤❤❤

[@Betterthanbasicivy]

I clicked on this like LIGHTNING! Thank you for doing the most always :)

[@kristentrep5038]

I ordered both, and I’ve been binging on your vids while home sick with covd! Lol

[@megl2562]

I just talked myself out of this and then you do this to me. How dare you? 🤣🤣🤣

[@seekingshifts]

💀💀🫣🫣

[@catherinelynnfraser2001]

I am glad Amanda is receptive to feedback. I do with the initial release had been larger. I have been waiting since early October. I can wait but it is diminishing my interest in independent brands.

[@irinatanase7150]

These palettes look amazing! Definitely on my wishlist, but I do have a lot of similar colors. Passport from Adept Heather Austin palete looks similar to that pink shade. Hope this is not limited edition cause I don’t have the money for them rn

[@heatherphares7035]

These are both so gorgeous! The color stories kind of remind me of Anastasia palettes, yet somehow more amped-up and approachable at the same time? Sorcerous Smoke is SO up my alley that I already have most of the similar shades you showed so I might just dupe the vibes for now, but maybe I'll cave and get it eventually...

[@seekingshifts]

Yesss I’ve seen other people compare them to ABH as well! Abh could never make shimmers like this but the vibes are def there haha

[@MShaiqable]

Sorcerus Smoke is SSSOO pretty! Great video! Def adding it to my wishlist

[@Butterflymessages]

I didn’t want another pallet this season. After you swatched those and created those looks though 😅. I might need Fall Magic

[@naomilasby7744]

I just ordered sorcerous smoke using your link/code 😁😁😁, my goodness shes pretty. My first unearthly was the dead of night palette which I full chest love, and then I got a few lipglosses, and became obsessed with the gloss in the shade Glint, and then the devour collection, also fully love the palette. So I'm super excited, I dont know why this one didn't catch attention before now, thank youuuuu 💚

[@seekingshifts]

Ahhh thank you for using my code! 🥰 you have me curious about the lip glosses now!

[@naomilasby7744]

@seekingshifts they have a really nice non-sticky shiny formula. Glint has blue/purple sparkle reflect that is so pretty on the lips, and actually more wearable than one might think, still smooth even though a gloss with glitter. Totally recommend

[@naomilasby7744]

@seekingshifts it's a purple gloss but it's not, it's translucent on the lips and gives such a pretty mirror soap bubble shine and reflect, probably especially good on cool skin tones, and with cool tone looks. But I digress...

[@livgraham257]

I’ve heard several reviewers saying they got hard pan in the Don’t Be Jelly palette but I honestly haven’t! I bought it on launch and have had no issues whatsoever. So weird to me that some people had such a dramatically different experience

[@seekingshifts]

I’ve heard other people say this as well! I’m glad you didn’t have any hard panning bc outside of that issue it’s a gorgeousssss palette !!

[@trishhykes5574]

I wish Potent was sold as a single!! I would snatch that up SO FAST!

[@seekingshifts]

Omg or if they did like a quad of spicy neutrals in that formula 😩 manifesting this for 2024

[@trishhykes5574]

omg yessss you get me! A quad of spicy neutrals 😍@@seekingshifts

[@MsG110]

I wonder how the Devour palette compares to the formula in these palettes.

[@andyl3449]

I purchased this after your post because it just looked stunning its like a fun everyday palette that can be dressed up or down and I kinda miss the curated palette vibe. Like don't get me wrong I love the creative spin on palettes but sometimes i just need ease lol i dont wanna have to think up what combos to put together or when im traveling having to create my own magnetic palette so this is soooo good an I cant wait to receive it.

[@teresaglina]

Groun = gold + brown?

[@richardwright9292]

Noooo... these are too beautiful 😭 I was honestly shook by some of those comparison swatches! Sorcerer's Smoke is what I wish Melt Gemini had been. Are these palettes (semi) permanent or limited edition? I hate being broke ass eurotrash, lol.