Update On The Quest For A Sock Knitting Machine

[@anro41]

I hand knit socks and have been fascinated by the sock machines but they are so expensive. Cracking job on the 3D printed version!

[@martajuliaaria412]

Maravillosa creación!

[@lightsoutdrillinstructor237]

I am an avid sock knitter both by hand, and with my CSM. I have to say, I can’t imagine learning to use my CSM if I didn’t already understand how to knit by hand, how the stitches are formed, and how to correct mistakes. Your aptitude for engineering is marvelous! The Kitchener stitch is called Kitchener because it was popularized during the war. The public was asked to knit socks with a grafted toe (which is what the Kitchener is)instead of a seamed toe to prevent soldiers getting irritation and infections from the seam rubbing against their feet.

[@harryrogers]

Thanks that's great to know, and makes sense re Kitchener...thank you.

[@IamChrisL712]

Another interesting video to watch. Learning never stops, which, of course, is a great part of life.

[@harryrogers]

Absolutely!

[@Needle2Needle]

I agree! I also love learning new things!

[@bigchiefleatherworks7245]

Another amazing accomplishment. Thanks for taking us along on your journey.

[@BrassLock]

That looks really fascinating Harry, just like a mechanical calculating machine of the 1950's.

[@SandyDandyAdams]

Hello there Harry! I truly hope all is well with you! I'm pretty sure youre taking as graceful strides as you can. When you're feeling a bit better we hope to see a hand knit of yours and/or whipping out a bang on sock on your super sweet sock knitting machine! We love you Harry. 😊 With all our hearts ❣️

[@harryrogers]

Thanks very much I am making good progress with the socks.

[@jamesconner8275]

That looks like a stunning Aran wool sweater!

[@KelikakuCoutin]

I too noticed that sweater. Probably knitted by an ancient seafarer while his vessel languished in the doldrums.

[@Sanderly1820]

Hi Harry it's so good to see your making awesome videos again, missed this.

[@harryrogers]

Thanks

[@mostlyoldthings]

Great work Harry. Very pleased to see your post. Yes, Fusion 360 is my favourite "virtual" tool, so versatile, especially for 3D printing. Impressed that you have had the fortitude to tackle the sock making machine as a 3D print.

[@harryrogers]

Thank you

[@Needle2Needle]

I’ve been so curious about these sock machines! I’ve only knit one pair of socks so far on regular knitting needles. But wow! This looks amazing!

[@crowznest438]

Hey, I've been wondering how it was going; thanks for the update!!

[@PaulSmith-rd8yc]

It’s great to hear your voice Harry and it’s great to see you back again on KZbin. And the sock making machine sounds pretty good.

[@jeremiahrex]

Very cool. I had no idea there was a machine, but I shouldn’t be surprised. It looks a bit like machines for making rope or braids on cables.

[@SandyDandyAdams]

Hi Harry 👋 Youre brilliant!! Your 3-D printing experience has been most educational ❤. Honest and true. You are truly appreciated and thank you for all your workings, experience, and wisdom sharing on all youve performed! Life isnt over,🎉 please share your hand knits no matter how wonky 😊

[@harryrogers]

Thanks...harryrogersmaking on Instagram for pics

[@americansewingmachineresto1545]

Great demonstration of the machine functions. Great job with the 3D printed version. Quite impressive and works great. I was so intrigued with the engineering of these units. It was a daunting task to actually make my first sock. It took me about about 8 months to set to my first sock. Not any size to speak of. Just picked some number of rows. It was challenging but I got a sock made. I’m hoping I can get back to is later in the year. It has been quite the adventure. I have watched hours and hours of You Tube Videos. Just ordered your book. Loved your leather shoe book. That is for retirement.

[@harryrogers]

That's great thanks...it's good to have some fun retirement projects to look forward to.

[@kboleather]

Thinking of you, Harry. Happy Christmas.

[@harryrogers]

Happy Christmas

[@ranielson2854]

Another very wonderful video. Thank you for sharing all of your experiences in sock making. Greatly appreciated!

[@LahRasa]

Wonderful creation and of course well done for sticking to the finish line. Very impressive piece of kit.

[@harryrogers]

Many thanks!

[@andyc972]

What a fascinating machine Harry, the sock looks great, well done, you are very modest ! So pleased that your book is selling well too !

[@harryrogers]

Thanks Andy

[@gatheringbaskethomestead9942]

I love your videos - you make me smile. You seem like such a nice person .

[@Josh_Luijsterburg]

Great to see the progress you made, well done. You also look great my friend 👍

[@mikesymmons31]

Glad to see you're doing well Harry.

[@gijsbo2000]

Just to say how incredibly helpful both your videos and your book are. Many thanks!

[@harryrogers]

Glad you like them!

[@berniesr]

I think that this is quite amazing. The sky is the limit with 3D printing I quite enjoy designing and making things with my 3D printer, well done.

[@scottdellinger4996]

Harry, YOU MADE A SOCK!!!! That is amazing!!!

[@rosieflaherty3169]

I love this. Thank you so much for sharing your journey with us.

[@harryrogers]

Thanks for watching!

[@carlospitcher4335]

I have been waiting for this update! Excellent!

[@Sanderly1820]

Hi Harry Nd Mrs Harry, i hope you are ok and on the mend, you tube isnt tge same without having your videos to watch, taje care from Cornwalls number 1 fan

[@thomashverring9484]

Very interesting, thank you! It's quite an involved process, but learning something new needs a good project, and you're learning 3D printing and sock making all at once!

[@harryrogers]

Very true!

[@chrissrutt]

Hi, I got your book on shoemaking for Christmas and it's great! Really well written. Hope you're doing ok and look forward to the next video, whenever it comes.

[@harryrogers]

Thanks that's great to hear.

[@closertothetruth9209]

so funny Harry i grew up watching nana sew sockets it was very relaxing like a sedative but you make it interesting

[@judygude]

Well Done! And I love your beautiful Sam! ❤

[@knitrxsews7040]

Very very impressive! From a hand sock knitter :)

[@harryrogers]

Thank you! 😊

[@frogslips]

What a splendid jumper

[@770743b0]

Hi Harry, hope your’re doing well. I was inspired by your Video a few months ago and also printed a sock machine for myself. I’m currently in the process of getting the ribber plate running. Quite a challenging task!

[@plainnpretty]

Good job great looking sock

[@easygarden777]

Wow what an awesome project... must have been some long intense hours put into that.... You're brilliant 👏

[@DovetailKitchens]

Harry, you are an inspiration thank you for posting. I love your videos!

[@sheilaluta]

Wonderful! Thank you for sharing your project!

[@timdybala7127]

Howdy from western Colorado!!!

[@WillemoesJ]

This is very inspiring, very nice video!

[@palamambron]

Back to cottage industry. English dissent was always based on it. Wool is going to make a comeback.

[@js8039]

I neglected you Harry, and for that I am ashamed. Merry Christmas and happy new year. I’d like to add that your videos on stained glass practically saved a 1920s entry door.

[@harryrogers]

Hi there is nothing to be ashamed about, it's great your entry door is sorted, thanks and I hope the new year goes well for you.

[@AntW11]

Well done. Good machine and a great sock! I have a CSM but it doesn't have a rubber, so i may have to 3d print one... 🙂

[@BrassLock]

Wishing you and your family a Happy New Year Harry 😂

[@harryrogers]

Thanks, and likewise to you 😊

[@InArcadiaSum]

The Return of Heath Robinson-but this machine actually works.

[@Sanderly1820]

Hi Harry and mrs Harry, hope you are ok. Missing your awesome videos

[@SusanAmberBruce]

Very impressive, thanks for sharing.

[@davidblake1663]

My God! I'm grateful for this content before NASA inevitably head-hunts you for some black project!

[@pinkerbot]

My sister is an avid knitter, and when she knits socks, she uses a blocking device that is just a flat piece of cardboard or plastic (i believe) that is foot shaped - only flattened.

[@harryrogers]

I need to make a couple of those!

[@lightsoutdrillinstructor237]

My sock blockers are just wire frames in the shape of a foot. You can make them pretty easily with wire hangers. The plastic ones are also great, but I like how fast my socks dry on wire blockers!

[@clerydesigns729]

The wire coat hanger sounds very good. Please can you tell me a word I couldn’t catch when Harry said: “You can get … to make some wooden blocks.” It didn’t come out on captions either.

[@clerydesigns729]

Actually, maybe the captions did get it: “and I need ..”

[@harryrogers]

@@clerydesigns729 Yes absolutely correct...I am going to make some sock blockers. I notice you can get them on Ebay UK etc.

[@HayleyXLunasopal]

I would love one of those knitting machine

[@deltajohnny]

What a complex machine! 😵😵😵👏👏👏

[@bennyhill3642]

That is sooo cool and Cute.. you will master that soon I'm sure!!!😇😁

[@jamesconner8275]

Best of luck with your book sales.

[@harryrogers]

Thanks James

[@base2solutions861]

Rmmbring you in prayer... hope u are well. Jehovah Rapha.

[@ooslum]

Hope you're going well Harry. That's a remarkable improvement in operation. Can you modify the tension around the calf? The best socks I have were from Tesco and had a very soft grip around the calf but we're never baggy, of course they no longer sell their best sock. Cheers.

[@harryrogers]

Hopefully Alan

[@dolphinlover1691]

"Every day is a school day" 🧦

[@dolphinlover1691]

"Education is what remains after one has forgotten what one has learnt in school" Einstein

[@massmanute]

Maybe a dumb idea, but I wonder if you could print the parts in PLA, and then use them for making molds for investment casting of the final parts. Cast aluminum parts might be more durable than the original PLA. Brass or bronze might be even better, though cost might be too high for those materials. One would probably have to do a pretty careful calculation on thermal expansion/contraction to get the parts to come out the right sizes.

[@KelikakuCoutin]

The book is now on order. Glad I found your channel. Subscribed. We need you. Thanks for the content. Keep up the good work. בס'ד

[@harryrogers]

Thanks very much

[@KelikakuCoutin]

@@harryrogers Good luck with the knitting. I taught myself to knit quite a while ago, as well. Just because I wanted to learn to knit my own socks. It went on for a few years before I was able to do it, and even though I was finally able to knit socks pretty well, it was pretty slow going, and I knit with much larger needles (#4 American) and worsted weight yarn, never attempted sock yarn and the tiny needles. They're pretty heavy socks but I can still wear them. Most of the people nowadays knit with circular needles, but if you refuse to be intimidated by DPNs, there's really a benefit to it. I really have wanted a sock machine for quite some time as well (since before I taught myself to knit), and I might follow in your footsteps, as far as going with the 3D printer - due to the same issues you encounter (cost of machines, availability). As you probably know, a good sock machine can run well over $1000, and may even run over $2000. In the video it appears as if your machine is working quite well, and rivals what I've seen of the traditional vintage models. ... EDIT: It occurred to me, you cast on to the machine with "waste yarn" and mention that you "unravel" it in order to finish the sock. I think you should look into an item referred to as "ravel cord" which is basically fishing line, you can use that instead or just use conventional ravel cord; Ravel cord is a tool that is used with knitting, more often machine knitting. After casting on the waste yarn, before you change to your sock yarn, knit in one row of ravel cord. After your cast-off, when the job is finished, your ravel cord can simply be pulled out of the work; it will separate the two sections, the waste yarn will be easily removed from the sock in one fell swoop. Ravel cord is available online, it's pretty common to obtain, or as I say, fishing line will work in a pinch. ... I really needed this video - very much appreciated.

[@harryrogers]

@@KelikakuCoutin Thanks, I have been making socks on a MrRoboto19 on Thingiverse but I notice now there is a remix version ForMyMom V2 which looks a bit easier to get right first time. I had quite a struggle with mine having not 3d printed or knitted before.

[@KelikakuCoutin]

@@harryrogers OK. I'll let you know if I get the 3D printer going. I, too, have never tried it. Don't forget to try using ravel cord on your next sock attempt.

[@Dardrum]

Very impressive

[@stevem6259]

Brilliant! Go, Harry GO

[@lopsidelarry1556]

Love your determination Harry, not only socks but the machine to make them on, hope your doing good, is there any slight difference between left and right?

[@woodturner1954]

Fascinating, this is the most unusual use of 3D printing I've seen. Did you make the needle/hooks yourself ? Have you put one of the socks on yet. I wonder how they will feel and wear-ability. At least you'll be prepared for the next virus out break when socks get hard to find instead of TP. Brilliant build job.

[@harryrogers]

I got the needles from Angora Valley

[@meemamakes]

Thankyou for this! Very inspiring. Hoping to make the Mom V2 and also in the UK, where did you get the needles from? They seem expensive from the recommended link + shipping from US.

[@harryrogers]

Hi thanks...Angora Valley in the US for the needles....can be expensive with Customs as .well.

[@fijaystudio]

Fabulous!

[@MicroMidas]

Neat! Nice work! 😊

[@Fingerchisel]

Just found your very informative channel. I did use my shed to do wood turning, which I have had to give up now. I do sew, quilt, bag make in the house and really want to get involved with leather since being given some off cuts. I am thinking of a more industrial machine and would need to use the shed again, due to its size. Problem! my lathe etc started to suffer with the damp in the shed showing bits of rust. I would not want this to happen to the sewing machine. How do you work in a shed and not suffer from this damp problem. What do you use to keep it dry and not moist? Thank You

[@harryrogers]

Hi I have insulated my shed with loft fill, and I have a heater on frost setting and sometimes use a dehumidifier.

[@yorkshirepartybooth4541]

Do you know if the needles can be bought in the UK? Can only find them in US.. This is great, thank you!

[@harryrogers]

Hi for this machine I am only aware of the seller in the US. They used to be made in Europe. Some crank in groups do bulk buys to save on postage.

[@crystalrose.wellness]

I printed most of the parts and when I tried to start putting it together I got overwhelmed and gave up. lol I'd like to try again at some point because I know it will be worth it!

[@harryrogers]

Don't worry about the ribber just get it so you can knit the sock tube, and take it from there...step by step.

[@crystalrose.wellness]

I'm not even talking about the ribber. Just putting the main CSM together is a LOT lol@@harryrogers

[@pinkerbot]

It is looking good! Did you knit that lovely sweater yourself?

[@pinkerbot]

Ps That is a really long sock 😁

[@harryrogers]

That was made by my wife!

[@davewhalen2735]

You obviously have a MOST talented wife!!@@harryrogers

[@closertothetruth9209]

so harry went from making shoes to making socks, ive gotta build a 3D printer , been watching robbert murray smith fun and interesting, hope your doing better Harry, NAC may be interesting for you to research.

[@jigarp999]

Why won’t you upload anymore?

[@jesebsp]

does the download files have hardware list? I've been deciding whether to make one. did determine it's Chepstow to get 3D machine and make one.

[@markelder5101]

Harry you haven’t posted anything for a while hope all is well with you

[@harryrogers]

Thanks Mark, I have been researching socks!

[@ivan55599]

l'd like to hear later how well this machine lasts without changing parts. But in the other hand, you can print many spare parts. l've been thinking that l should make this kind of machine too, then you don't need to rely on anyone else on sock-making. Next thing is that l need to learn how to make standard size yarn with a spinning wheel. All local yarns contain 25% plastic...

[@harryrogers]

Hi I found it quite difficult to get even yarn, I gather Blue Leicester has long strands, so might be easier to manage on the wheel?

[@leahdavis9434]

Look into natural fiber yarns from yarn shops, not regular yarn from craft shops. 100% wool for example

[@PunCala]

Harry, I would like to buy your shoemaking book, but I don't want to support Amazon. Is there a way to buy it directly or via some other, more ethical shop?

[@harryrogers]

Hello I am sorry it's only through Amazon which does actually support one person publishing.

[@juliweather1103]

What is that yarn winder? I really want one like that.

[@harryrogers]

Hi it's called a cone winder and is no longer made but they appear on the likes of Ebay, made by companies such as Empisal, Knitmaster etc.as per the old flat bed knitting machines of the 1980s onwards.

[@SheepBanks]

I've made 2 and the ribber doesn't Cooperate on either.

[@harryrogers]

I had to really file and smooth the top rim of my cylinder and the underside of my ribber.

[@RochelleASalas]

Hello just checking on your health..? I pray that you are well❤…

[@harryrogers]

Thanks

[@dougdavis8367]

Will you consider making and selling them?..

[@harryrogers]

Sorry no, the creative commons licence from MrRoboto19 does not allow that.

[@KelikakuCoutin]

I don't know, but if you think you'd go for a ready made, 3D printed machine, I've seen them online elsewhere. The company is called Dean and Bean's Sock Machine.

[@simonrichardson4289]

Hi is there anywhere in the uk that you can get the needles from. Thanks.

[@harryrogers]

Hi I don't think so....Angora Valley in the US has them.

[@harryrogers]

P.S. I am thinking the Autoknitter type needles with the dent in the stem so they can be raised for the Mr Roboto19 machine. I think some people use Brother flat bed type needles in one of the 3d prints.

[@simonrichardson4289]

Thanks for the reply.@@harryrogers

[@connieh2851]

How much did it cost to print with all supplies. Would it be cheaper to buy one?

[@harryrogers]

Hi It took a spool of PLA+, and the hardware bits like rod and bearings added up. Then there were a few extra tools like files etc. Very roughly £100 to £150 UK. I learnt a lot and enjoyed the project and making socks, and went on to restore an antique machine and write a book on this that is on Amazon...A Beginner's Guide To Using A Circular Sock Knitting Machine.

[@deezynar]

Hi, Harry, how are you doing? This is your last video, and it's 6 months old. I hope you are well.

[@harryrogers]

Hi I am doing OK thanks. I have sold all my camera kit!

[@deezynar]

@@harryrogers You mean you have sold your video equipment, and you will not be making more videos? That sounds like you are not doing OK, but you are being brave about it. I hope I am wrong about that.

[@harryrogers]

@@deezynar Thanks I am adapting and doing other things...we all only get one life so best to enjoy it 😊

[@deezynar]

@@harryrogers Yes, absolutely. I wish you all the best. I have really enjoyed your videos and appreciate you a lot. I will miss seeing new videos from you, but you have to do what is best for you and your loved ones. God bless you, sir.

[@harryrogers]

@@deezynar Thanks very much

[@SidekickElements]

How long does it take to make a sock (roughly)?

[@harryrogers]

30 -45 minutes or so, it depends on the type, how fast you want to go, how you sew up the toe, how much practice you have. Some people are very quick and some will take a couple of hours or more.

[@martajuliaaria412]

Harry que lindo su gato Sam. Yo tambien tengo uno, negrito se llama Milo. Harry como puedo hacer para acceder a los planos o programa para hacer esta maravillosa maquina. Soy Argentina, de la Patagonia, Neuquen . Estamos atravezando una crisis económica brutal. Estoy pensando en organizar con otras mujeres, y producir calcetines para la venta. Así solventar los gastos personales y de nuestra familia. Sin que las mamas tengan que salir de sus casas. Y así seguir cuidando de sus niños. Espero con anhelo, su respuesta.- Marta

[@harryrogers]

Buenos Diaz Marta...negrito gato es muy bueno. Los planos www.thingiverse.com/thing:4695746

[@hrxy1]

excellent vid very informative and interesting, thanks

[@scrap_donetsk]

respect from colleagues shoemakers 🪡🧵🔨👠