[아이브 IVE 무대] 에스파,뉴진스,라이즈 aespa, ZEROBASEONE, NewJeans 키스오브라이프 Reaction @231202 2023 mma 멜론뮤직어워드 직캠

[@zuzannabrzeszczak1578]

I love how hard they went for I AM, like the high notes were *popping.* That was a really solid performance.

[@stayinthemiddle99]

i know right. not a fan of IVE but at least this performance should deserve full applause esp for the main vocalists. i was super astonished as well as those idols stunned by perfect high notes...😮

[@jennieisqueen2448]

Not for ningning haha

[@jennieisqueen2448]

@@stayinthemiddle99perfect highnotes cause there have backtrack bruhh, not 100% lives, wonyoung obviously lipsync

[@yukispomu]

@@jennieisqueen2448you dedicate so much of your time to hate lol, every artist uses backtrack 😭 stfu

[@salma-ns4lg]

@@jennieisqueen2448get a Iife you keep hating on ive everywhere.. at least ive sing live some groups did not sing live at all

[@Nxox_]

No because the way IVE maintained their stamina throughout a 12 minute performance without showing it being boring WAS SO SLAYFUL !!!!

[@Blink-sf2tc]

In every ive's performance, Yujin always sings louder and tries her best to perform well. I love her attitude, her passion and her love for the stage.

[@kaipaljor5388]

Honestly, 4th gen idols interactions and reactions to each other are really improving. These days im very excited to see their reactions as there is always at LEAST one group who gives a lot of reactions. For example, these days I love aespa's reactions (they are my ult group but still), they didn't really have any sort of reaction at all before but now they are very fun to watch.

[@ayanaurora9984]

even the song I AM from start to finish has a very high pitch, even gunwook gyuvin and matthew Zerobaseone looked very surprised because they really performed it very well , highest appreciation for Ive, especially liz and yujin.

[@snowinapril6261]

Those high notes in i am are so damn high omg really respect Yujin and Liz to pull it off live while dancing

[@onwindydays]

that backtrack was carrying

[@arnolacosta6093]

​@@onwindydaysThey have already done it 100% live and they do it excellent, try again later.

[@kznnyx]

@@onwindydayslied.. 🌚 you can hear their voices getting loud during their high notes.

[@onwindydays]

@kznnyx If you hear their voices get "louder," it means that they are singing with a backtrack. 😭 So, definitely not 100% live. So where is the lie? 💀

[@aeriiel]

@@onwindydays youre mad this song too high some people cant even survive w bt w dancing lol

[@rurioky]

zb1 members were GAGGED by their high notes...it was so good

[@losnah9099]

안유진은 진짜 항상 열심히 부르는구나

[@PpY-jk1js]

유진이 멋져

[@雪花yukina]

❤

[@305_6]

@ZZZZZZZZ_11111그 당연한것도 안하는 아이돌들 있으니 그렇지

[@tlqkfsldoal]

+ 리즈

[@댕댕-l8c]

항상 열심히 부르지 명창강아지 고양이들 다른 멤버들도 이번 콘 보니까 다들 늘었던데 컴백무대 넘 기대됨

[@hh-nb1kc]

최고에용!! 안그래도 아이브무대 리액션은 없나 찾는중이었는데 ㅠㅠ❤❤

[@ciel_nocturne]

뉴진스 분들 따라부르는거 너무 귀여워요 ㅠㅠ 감동❤

[@peony13119]

Mathew and Hao discussing if they sing live or not and when they realized it was live, they keep saying wooow. And also Gun wook and Gyuvin amazed by their high note ♡♡

[@theoctobergirl23]

Were they singing live?I thought no group in mma sang live,there was an article by allkpop that mma stages weren't live blah blah I'm happy if they sang live though and it doesn't matter if its not live as well

[@peony13119]

@@theoctobergirl23 I'm not sure about all members are singing live. I don't know either. But you can see Yujin and Liz singing really hard.

[@theoctobergirl23]

@@peony13119 in the bridge,wonyoung seems to sing also,her breathing sound could be heard,I'm not sure about it

[@benji0099]

@@theoctobergirl23 I think they were, you could hear Yujin and Liv over the backtrack (esp during I Am). I just think the backtrack overpowered the other girls, since they don't have as strong of vocals as Yujin and Liz to be heard.

[@jennieisqueen2448]

@@theoctobergirl23wonyoung obviously lipsync bruhh, just liz and yujin voice can be hear

[@theoctobergirl23]

Their performance was too good..Sad that people don't want to give them the recognition they deserve (mostly the int kpop fans).These people were calling this stage boring,while you can see how the idols were enjoying and how they executed the high notes in I AM

[@sinyuchou6930]

TRUE

[@5252-e2o]

I haven't watched the video yet. Did the idols react well?

[@theoctobergirl23]

@@5252-e2o yes Nj were enjoying much Aespa's karina and winter were vibing Zb1 matthew zhang hao were also vibing The other groups I didn't recognise them but I guess it was shinee and boy next door

[@jennieisqueen2448]

@@theoctobergirl23lol shinee, that riize

[@jennieisqueen2448]

Its fact, the performance kinda boring

[@rosalierodriguez_]

Thanks for uploading this! ♥️♥️♥️🥹🥹🥹

[@Fazry-wn8yi]

all of Ive' songs never disappoint

[@manahilshujah5588]

liz's highnotes are legendary

[@jennieisqueen2448]

She great vocals and yujin, the others lipsync😅

[@whitemoon2001]

@@jennieisqueen2448 Are you deaf?

[@ぐらしすみっこ-o3x]

@@jennieisqueen2448 There is also a video of them actually singing. Please take a look and tell me

[@Cloverferns]

@@jennieisqueen2448 yeah it's because liz and yujin are main and lead vocalist.

[@theoctobergirl23]

@@jennieisqueen2448 why don't you focus on your favs lip syncing issue instead of coming here?they are a 3rd gen group but still accused of not singing live..

[@sua_0712]

올려주셔셔 감사합니당❤

[@hanaj9932]

Yujin literally said her mic is on👏

[@wonyoricky]

zb1 really liked it!!! they're big ive fans

[@iamshaleeyn]

THE HIGH NOTE & VOCALS ARE LIVE yallsssss 💁🏻‍♀️🙆🏻‍♀️🙆🏻‍♀️🙆🏻‍♀️

[@abdxinnn]

아ㅜㅜㅜ 진짜 감사합니다❤️❤️❤️

[@자금성-j3c]

다떠나서 스타쉽 a&r팀 직원분들 듣는귀 인정 노래다 잘뽑음 ...스타쉽 직원들 돈마니줘라 어떻게 낸곡마다 다좋냐 와 .... 생각해보니까

[@K-PD_Random]

Sorry, i couldn't focus on seeing their reaction. Without realizing i focused on IVE's perfomance. Thank you for this video ❤

[@multi.kpopping]

Their performances are always so grand ✨

[@saraaturki7104]

It is live 😏 so that is who is IVE I AM proud

[@kamibrotas]

IVE really nailed this performance 🔥

[@byur_11]

비주얼,데니쉐르 의상,헤메 그리고 초대박 난 노래들 .. 다 최고 ㅠㅠㅠㅠ 🤍

[@응-z7s]

우와..🥹🥹🥹🥹 감사해요 덕분에 보고싶었던 영상들 다보고있어요💌

[@manifest3695]

IVE ATE as in THE best performance of the night by a mile like they came prepared they portrayed a whole story it was executed so well and damn yujin carrying that I AM chorus on her back beautifully

[@stayinthemiddle99]

11:50 newjeans hyped for the fullest how adorable they're enjoying!

[@cloudyyyy02]

thank you so much!!🥺💗

[@mawiifanai1028]

Thank you ..Been waiting for this ❤

[@hsangsangi826]

God I've been waiting for this ❤❤😂

[@Random19283]

5:04 5:17 6:15 9:05 9:51 11:11 11:52 wonyoung visual/vocal 😧 11:43

[@Stardew04]

thank you, been waiting for this!!

[@sevenlambs7]

MY FAV STAGE !! 🤍 I LOVE ALL THEIR SONGS SO SO SO MUCH! kitsch baddie blue blood and I AM all are amazing songs with such beautiful and meaningful lyrics 💗 IVE IT GIRL GROUP 🫶🏻

[@treasured0lv]

음향 뚫고 나오는 라이브에 다들 놀라네 ❤ 아이브 잘했다🎉

[@Inlce19]

SM aespa 💯

[@lilacbambi]

I AM THAT SONG GIVES ME CHILLS EVERY TIME ITS SO GOOD 😭💗

[@애옹-f7t]

키스오브라이프도 올려주시면 감사하겠습니당 !!

[@해질녁]

네 ^^

[@jxdelle]

@@해질녁 thank you so much from kissy~💋

[@JeonJungkook-gp1sq]

@@해질녁 Do you have a part for STAYC?

[@Asade-xo1cq]

듣보돌?😊

[@dyun410]

하지만 실력탑

[@a.a677]

IVE did so well with live vocals, I am so impressed, they sound so good even after 10 minutes of dancing

[@lifeisggood-e6z]

They were only back from thier tour in japan three days before MMA and they also needed to practice for thier performance at MMA without having any rest they are so hardworking starship should give them a rest 😢😢

[@chwisoxk]

와 정말 보고 싶었는데 감사합니당ㅎㅎ

[@leen5949]

Nah they went hard for I AM 🔥🔥🔥

[@dawnlee7518]

That's singing, Rei is a singer holy cow!

[@더블유-d4d]

기다렸습니다!!! 아이브 리액션도 많이 부탁드려용❤

[@해질녁]

네😊

[@ayishathnahda2272]

너희 Boysnextdoor 반응 캠에서 승리하니?@@해질녁

[@라임-x9o]

11:20 유진 고음에 다들 리액션 좋다. 안유진 넘 멋져

[@유튜브-k9g]

안유진 찢었네..대박

[@beomgyuwinter]

Winter enjoyed it very well ❤

[@kc3121]

감사합니다❤❤

[@yujinlee4165]

감사합니다! 수고하세요^^

[@Ronaa_Huu]

Thank u so much for this video, u r the best👍

[@bloperslove1543]

Thank you so much 🙌😻

[@iamacutie]

Highnotesnya ive nyaman banget didengar

[@unknownbliss3342]

IVE ate as usual

[@lovleylovley99]

hyein loves kitsch😭

[@uchihashisui6922]

I was waiting for this tyy

[@choumoong]

This will forever remain a legendary moment for me. 5:04 And also for I AM! HELLO? Those vocals are crazy!

[@K-POP_Anime_Drawings_Official]

Giselle seems to Believe in the performance of IVE I AM ❤❤❤

[@iyugee]

thank you so much can you upload for stayc performance too please😢❤

[@HibaAlsaadi-y2o]

leeseo I love you ❤

[@jeffersond.c.5464]

Aespa seat like Professional and Queens. Love their confidence with poise

[@kepianmaybe]

ウィンターまじで性格良さそうで好き❤

[@ahnyujinive7106]

Thank you 😘

[@은은-g6m]

멋있다 아이브

[@capacsis]

최고!

[@akidiaz6908]

stayc full stage reaction plsss badly wanna watchhhhh

[@9yu_0]

Thx u ❤️

[@ほととぎす-v4l]

thank you❤

[@Rimi-ow8jj]

레전드! 아센디오 저 때 나왔었으면 ㄹㅈㄷ였을듯 ㅠ

[@yedeeeeee8771]

FINALLY!!!

[@Inlce19]

SM aespa 💯

[@토벅]

장원영 얼굴 진짜..공격미쳤다.. ㅈㄴ독보적임

[@strawberryjam9880]

Idk much about Karina and Yujin's friendship but I can tell they got along well after their tiktok challenge collab. Right? So happy for Yujin for having more "unnie" friends. Also, I was amazed by the marching bands and flags. IVE was like the majorettes. It was superb.

[@enssunn]

I feel like both yujin and karina are easy to get along with, so I also think they must be friends now ❤

[@luna-cz2ll]

IVE!!🩷❤️‍🔥

[@ray_scy]

slayedd!!

[@tegwen6062]

so cute how karina cheered for gaeul at 7:00 omg

[@Iegln1]

에스파 무대 reaction 부탁드려요

[@IveKajja]

Finally thank u❤

[@원-w5p]

리액션 영상 기달려왔는데 넘감사드립니다😊수고가 많으세요ㅠㅠ 혹시 에스파 무대 보고 리액션보는 가수분들도 기대해도 될까용❤❤❤

[@해질녁]

네😊

[@eungin8218]

에스파 드라마 무대 리액션 영상 왜 막혔나요 ㅠㅠ 🥹🥹

[@LilySaa12]

Thankyouu❤❤

[@ikuk7]

Thank you

[@luvliyxz]

11:11 I’m obsessed with Wonyoungs part here!

[@chrysanthemum45258]

zb1 vocal lines talking about ive live highnote

[@whitemoon2001]

They I AM sing live

[@duhhe7956]

they ateee they devoured.

[@notminghao]

Omggg YASS ❤❤tysm

[@Inlce19]

SM Aespa full stage reaction video upload

[@diamond-fp3dg]

I think I AM performance 100% live...while me listening and looking at zb1 member suprised face... dont know his name beside zhanghao

[@neyterlandyt8033]

Kiss of life 무대 reaction please 😢

[@rafaellecunha]

Meu Deus isso está perfeito♡

[@adadadadad1630]

Reaction both Winter and Karina are so pretty as hell😊

[@ElianaRodriguez-fq6nh]

Soy adicta a la voz de Yuyin enserio creo que podría escucharla todo el día 🤩🤩🤩

[@My.aespa-winter2]

겁나 쩐다ㄷㄷ

[@HateFilledDonut]

Look at my baby Hanni dancing along.. she's so adorable 😭

[@NgocMinh-zl1ej]

Hanni and Winter should be sitting together. They reacted excitingly to every performance

[@moonchxld3829]

can someone tell me who the two backup dancers at 5:50 are? the crowd and a few idols reacted to them showing up on screen and they performed very well so i’m curious!

[@ligaya0508]

Lachica

[@briizeju]

Karina vibing to their songs is so cuteee ❤❤❤❤

[@onerealize9304]

이거쥬❤

[@ryedrn]

omg matthew’s reaction to the high note 11:09

[@BeatrizVillegas979]

I really wished that They would be the ones to bring back Izone back together to perform together one last time I hope they do that in 2024 because I miss Izone they were the original 4th gen leaders I’m ready to see them perform together one last time in 2024

[@liss3603]

No.

[@theoctobergirl23]

Not sure but given how people microanalyse everything about wonyoung and ive,if yujin and wonyoung take initiative for bringing back izone in a stage,they might get immense backlash from netizens saying they didn't care about present group members feeling and blah blah

[@SuperChika32]

Not thank u and stop commenting on that, this is a ive video, thanks :)

[@raspberryland_]

Iz*One has disbanded.. please let them go.. you can still support IVE and Le Sserafim. It would bring quite numerous backlash if they did that bc where would IVE and Le Sserafim’s members be ??? They wouldnt be performing alongside ex Iz*one members would they.. it just wouldnt make sense for that to happen ..? Anyways support IVE ♥︎

[@jadeball4932]

This wasn’t for me per say, I do think yujin ate however it wasn’t something I could watch all the way to the end, the girls are all continuously improving but I definitely think a lot of parts of this could been a little better. I’ve fighting !

[@gutifilms1135]

Yup instead of rei and Liz awkwardly walking they could’ve had a dance break but they can’t do intense choreography yet