Metropolis Street Racer (Dreamcast vs Xbox) Gameplay Comparison

A side-by-side comparison between Metropolis Street Racer for Dreamcast and Project Gotham Racing for Original Xbox.
Dreamcast Version = Left Side (2000)
Xbox Version = Right Side (2001)

[@vcdecide]

From now on, I'm banning people who engage in provocations in the comments... The section is for sharing your opinion on the games in the video, hardware, consoles, ports, etc. Leave others' opinions for others to express... This won't be your mother's house anymore; I'm going to bring order to this mess. X fanboy this and X fanboy that will no longer be tolerated. Just share your opinion about the games/companies/consoles, etc. And anyone who comes here to cry in the replies will be banned too! As for the video, feel free to prefer the Dreamcast or Xbox version, or comment on whatever you want about the game, console, company, etc., related to the video. Provocation = BAN Let's keep the section healthy, especially since this channel has been affecting my health for a long time now And please, avoid replying to this comment with complaints or objections; otherwise, you will be banned, no matter who you are. I'm not feeling well today. Thank you for your understanding.

[@Clodd1]

What happened?

[@Silva_GP]

​@@Clodd1People keep create agreesive discussion during on commentary chat of every video.

[@abdelatifpalestine7190]

courage

[@greatginger-gy9rf]

both are great games 😀 have very diferent style of conduction but both are great 😀

[@baronhausenpheffer]

I'm of two minds on this one. If this makes sense, I think XBox wins on the technical prowess (lighting, framerate, etc.), but the Dreamcast version wins on atmosphere. Whoever made the decision in the XBox version to set everything in the daytime and lose those cool night scenes absolutely didn't understand the mission.

[@kinorai]

I had the same thought!!!

[@Marmite101]

Am sure the lead creator of MSR left Bizarre prior to It's release. Think it was more they (Bizarre) probably still not fully happy with their understanding of the Xbox hardware and lighting effects at that time of game development? PGR3 on 360 eventually excelled in that area.

[@ADSLPL]

The Dreamcast version is a typical game for the Japanese gaming market, while the Xbox version was Americanized. At the time, it was believed that a racing game set at night would not sell well in the West.

[@CastleFamilyThe]

⁠@@ADSLPLMSR is a British game, not sure why night settings would have any impact on potential sales, plenty of driving games before this had day/night settings and sold well

[@JEY74]

Dreamcast tiene efectos climáticos y circuitos de dia y noche en tiempo real segun la region a la que pertenezcas programados mediante el reloj interno de Dreamcast, si eres de America y juegas de dia, una carrera en europa sería de noche y así sucesivamente.

[@sharpester7277]

I like how great MSR's soundtrack is. Special mention to Show Me Your Love and Am I Only Dreaming.

[@vcdecide]

I prefer the original tracks in MSR to the licensed music in PGR And the soundtracks you mentioned are great... I also like the music 'Come On Baby' 🎼 But overall, I like all the music... However, the ones I like the least are the country tracks.

[@gorkuspraxus]

"Am I Only Dreaming" was one of my favorite songs in the entire game. It was lively and had some special touches that reminded me of a car horn. I played the demo version a lot of times while listening to this song in-game!

[@Haywood-Jablomie]

I met TJ Davis at comic con a few years ago. She was so sweet !

[@akumajobelmont]

@@vcdecide Yeah, the country tracks are the ones I skip. Everything else is gold! Gimme that instrumental jazz fusion, dance and anything TJ Davis! :)

[@FranMatsusaka]

I also love the jazzy themes.

[@ВладиславЗимин-г2ц]

Metropolis Street Racer в свое время просто потрясла качеством графики

The graphical difference is impressive. I can see that Bizarre Creations had to remake the game from scratch to release on the Xbox, under a new title.

[@a.d.sstudioanimation6438]

The difference this time is truly night and day 😂

[@retrooutput]

A very early testament to how powerful that Xbox was really.

[@thebrutalwarrior56k44]

There are several very interesting things here: both games were developed by Bizarre Creations and there are several very important things about both games. MSR was very detailed on the subject of time as it uses the dreamcast time to represent the cities of Tokyo, San Francisco and London in real time. It has a website, the dreamcast live community long ago restored the MSR page, you can upload your ghost times or kudos and it's accessible to explore. on MSR there are more race tracks than on PGR (256 tracks than 199 tracks) Xbox promoted PGR as a launch game along with other titles like Halo CE PGR has better graphics than MSR and they used the same graphics engine in addition to an improved framerate Many knew Bizarre Creations for the PGR saga Both games have their own thing to enjoy.

[@thebrutalwarrior56k44]

Here are a few things to highlight in the bonus: in PGR New York City was added, cars gained more polygons and vertices and reflections were added, probably in real time in MSR you can customize the messages of the skid or kudos gain in single player mode and the messages of when you make a mistake or lose kudos in a free way

[@CALAdmin88]

Project Gotham Racing is a spiritual successor to MSR.

[@PurpleCarrotHD]

I didn't know that the first PGR for Xbox and Metropolis Street Racer for DC were basically the same game. I never played the first PGR because I didn’t have an Xbox at the time. I'll give it a chance later. The comparison is super interesting!

[@PositionOffsetGaming]

I miss these. MSR/PG were the perfect balance of simulation racer and arcade racing

[@Rocky1138]

I still play PGR and PGR2 once every couple of years. The first one, especially. I'm still stuck in the same spot all these years. I reach a local maxima and cannot progress. Secondarily, I played both MSR and PGR when new. Loved both, especially the soundtracks. As I remember the soundtrack for MSR was done by a French guy who did Sonic music previously. It's not for everyone, but it's definitely memorable and distinct. This video is a huge nostalgia trip 😂

[@Rocky1138]

PS, to you and to the universe, at large: happy birthday Dreamcast!

[@fabio78]

I love those games, but they are full on arcade titles. There's nothing simulation about them.

[@PositionOffsetGaming]

@@fabio78 they're much closer to a simulation than say Mario Kart or Hydro Thunder

[@madson-web]

All things considered. MSR is still a good looking game

[@Marmite101]

Yes considering it's running on hardware 3 years older than the one in comparison it's more than impressive.

[@gersonkirch87]

METROPOLIS STREET RACER é inesquecivel..

[@afronautexplorer144]

The Music Sounds like Sonic R

[@Marmite101]

Similar production

Search "TJ Davis" vocal.

[@afronautexplorer144]

Already did

[@dffagundo]

Same composer, Richard Jacques, and the very same singer, T.J. Davis 👍

[@Rocky1138]

I just want to say that I love your channel and to thank you for your work all these months/years. Thanks!

[@JohnCharb87]

Observations Part 2 1. The Dreamcast version your Audi TT is Left hand drive. While the Xbox version is Right hand drive. 2. Also the license plate on the Dreamcast version is American style. California plates with registration stickers. They look like green blobs but they represent Month and Year your plates are valid. On the Xbox version they appear to be United Kingdom or at least European plates. 3. The Audi TT on the Dreamcast version is missing the exhaust tips. Both are shown on the Xbox version. Those Germans were ahead of their time with Electric Vehicles. 4. The Xbox version the Audi TT must be turbocharged. To the right of the Mph is a boost gauge. Absent in the Dreamcast version. 5. Really cool at slow 0.25 the trip counter increases distance realistically. 6. The side views mirrors on both have reflections. The Xbox version stands out.

[@sharpfalcon6196]

On the Dreamcast game, most cars in MSR are RHD (correct for the Skyline, the FTO and a few others) while some are LHD (Fiat Barchetta, Ford Mustang and Opel Speedster), and this applies to the PAL version. The PAL version also has British plates.

[@JohnCharb87]

Correction on #5 I meant Odometer. Also it appears to be analog which is pretty cool. Before each race on the Dreamcast version the radio static reminds me of the opening to Puratania from Dimmu Borgir.

[@JohnCharb87]

@@sharpfalcon6196 0:06 Now that you mentioned it the Dreamcast cover of MSR does features a Opel Speedster. Which is interesting they went with that car instead of the Ford Mustang.

[@sharpfalcon6196]

@@JohnCharb87 They went with it to promote the then-new sports car according to the German Opel Speedster website (production started on July 17th 2000 but didn't go on sale until September 2000/March 2001, but dates might be conflicting). And according to one of the people who worked at Sega Europe, the Speedster was without its engine for the box art photo.

[@pgr3290]

Dreamcast feels faster because the camera height is slightly lower and a slightly tweaked FOV. Other than this the Xbox version of PGR has a bunch of visual enhancements, particularly the impressive reflections. It also had better physics and controls. The gameplay had been refined quite a lot between the two games. PGR2 blew them all away, it was a masterpiece of an arcade racer taking all the element of MSR and PGR but getting them dead on. PGR3 and 4 were even better, easily up there as some of the greatest arcade racers ever made. They still look great and play great. A PGR4 remaster would be insane.

[@vcdecide]

I found the AI of the opposing cars to be significantly worse on the Xbox...(Extremely aggressive and dumb) and it's also important to remember that although PGR1 has one more city, it has a lower number of tracks... Dreamcast (MSR): 262 tracks Xbox (PGR): 199 tracks However, MSR is an extremely punishing game, which makes it difficult; you lose Kudos for almost anything, and in this aspect, the Xbox version made it much easier...

[@pgr3290]

@@vcdecide Quality over quantity. MSR's handling is just very basic with little feel for the weight shift of the cars making it harder to hit braking points and turn in. PGR simply had way better controls and handling making it seem 'easier.' Not to mention Xbox had better controller options for racing games, specifically the triggers and thumb sticks. It was ultimately a better more rounded game, MSR 1.5 if you will.

[@thebrutalwarrior56k44]

the reality is that in MSR it was intended to mix arcade and simulation features perfectly, in PGR they were more respectful of realism

[@Marmite101]

PGR3 is peak that Gen Racing

[@vcdecide]

@@pgr3290 I agree that quality is better than quantity... but out of those 199 tracks on the Xbox, only the tracks from the new city are not present on the Dreamcast (which has 262 tracks). And the tracks from this new city on the Xbox are terrible-they are by far the worst tracks in the game, or the worst city in the game, with very poor track design. And regarding the AI, did the opponents in PGR need to be so stupid and aggressive? They drive straight at your car and do everything they can to make your car skid and mess up your race... In terms of AI behavior, the Dreamcast version is much more realistic! Also, the Dreamcast version has faster cars, not just a matter of camera positioning. Yes, the framerate is higher on the Xbox, but the feeling of speed is greater on the Dreamcast; the cars complete laps more quickly here. However, for having fun, the Xbox version is better, as it is less punishing regarding Kudos compared to the Dreamcast version, where you lose Kudos for almost anything you do. It becomes difficult to progress in the game if you lose too many Kudos.

[@ElsweyrDiego]

ainda lembro quando vi metropolis street racer no dreamcast pela primeira vez. o salto de qualidade em relação aos nfs e gt do ps1 era de cair o queixo xD

[@kimitachi22]

The Dreamcast version is very impressive, considering it’s on a console from 1998 compared to a console that came out three years later, in 2001. Additionally, there are more races available. The Xbox version is Obviously more advanced and realistic, but I find that the Dreamcast version has more charm with its pure arcade 3D rendering Is the Dreamcast version in VGA? It seems to be the case because it seems to have more depth than on the Xbox ( Especially in the environments, ) All the 3D elements stand out separately and distinctly on the screen on Dreamcast which are typically signs of native 480p VGA which is much more refined than the 480p of the Xbox or GameCube (not native 480p)

[@rubendarioreymartinez2073]

Las dos versiones están bien 👍 buena comparación saludos desde colombia 🇨🇴

[@DaveVoyles]

“Watch out asshoe” laugh😅

[@vittosphonecollection57289]

Gotta love how they didn't even censore the bad word, but just took a random letter away from the less bad sounding word from the two words the swear word is made from. Word Take a shot each time I say the "Word" word 😂😂

[@SAN-cd1px]

MSR OST is beatiful ❤❤

[@tabora1234]

This video bribgs me good memories. I have both of them and played when they came out. Xbox version has a better framerate and reflecta but I enjoyed dreamcast version because of Kudos. Thanks for sharing this video.☺️

[@vcdecide]

The Xbox version also has Kudos, but on the Xbox, it's more generous both in terms of earning and not losing them... On the other hand, in MSR, it's an almost impossible game due to the difficulty of earning Kudos and the ease of losing them. Changing cars costs Kudos, crashing costs Kudos, quitting the race costs Kudos... pretty much anything you do results in losing Kudos on the Dreamcast. It's a good game, but it's extremely punishing; you have to use a soft reset (A,B,X,Y + Start) to return to the menu just to avoid losing Kudos from a poor race, for example.

[@tabora1234]

@@vcdecide hi, again! I didnt explain well, I meant that the first time i saw Kudos was in MSR. That I said before I like both of them. I didnt know that MSR IS harder than PGR.

[@drift180x]

I’m always impressed what devs were able to achieve on the Dreamcast hardware.

[@sonikku9173]

Very good really for a 1998 console, but little can be done against the most powerful console of that generation

[@SomeOrangeCat]

A lot of people slept on the OG Xbox. I'll admit I was skeptical when it was first announced, but I couldn't argue with the results. It was basically a mid-range gaming PC, for the price of a console.

[@Azziee]

Looks much better on much more powerful Xbox but those Dreamcast graphics are still impressive.

[@CurtindoAqueleDrama]

Gosto que no Dreamcast o jogo tinha um grafico mais colorido, mais saturado. No Xbox ja deram um ar meio realista, que ficaria mais famoso na geração seguinte. Com tudo acinzentado, com fog ao fundo, meio esfumaçado....

[@MiguelGonzalez-oe1yr]

MSR es el padre de PGR , obviamente la saga PG es una evolución de Metrópolis Street Racer . Me quedo con MSR♥ , todavía recuerdo aquellas noches en las que recorría sus calles escuchando una de las mejores bandas sonoras creadas para un videojuego.♥

[@carloscuello8814]

Car´s models is one of weakest spots on MSR, but with certain cars, like this Audi, gap is a little bit shorter compared with the likes of GT 3 or this PGR. If just bizarre would had implemented at least fake enviromental map (as Tokyo Xtreme Racer or Teest Drive Le Mans), just with that alone car models would had held up muuuuch more. Stages are unbelievable! Also love the glow of the trailights on DC. In other hand, the stage details and cars models and actual reflections with probably cube maps on Xbox PGR are something out of this world for a 2001 launch game. PGR alone is like mid gen ahead of most of the racers from entire 6th gen. Also, watching the video for second time, i realize how good and vibrant the colors look on MSR, while on Xbox they´re not bad, but they look dull.

[@indask8]

Big fan of the MSR soundtrack (Richard Jacques/ TJ Davis).

[@gorkuspraxus]

Look, a billboard advertisement of "Roommania 203" in the background at 6:21. When I first played MSR I really liked the realism in all aspects, although I found it quite difficult. It holds up well graphically to this day, especially in night races, where the lighting effects are more noticeable (the replays almost seemed like a real scene). When I tried Project Gotham Racing on my XBox I was quite impressed with its graphics, with the reflections on the bodywork of the cars and the brightness of the sun on the asphalt. There was a really significant graphical jump with greater smoothness, things that this video has reminded me of. Good work.

[@rewrez3187]

Good vision

[@drunkensailor112]

Metropolis street racer has a soul. That's why I still play it all the time. Pgr doesn't imo

[@avflashback8913]

As someone who owns MSR and all the PGR games since release I feel like PGR1 is a stripped-back arcade style version of MSR. I feel that PGR1 has sharper, cleaner graphics but not as detailed as MSR. All the railings, & most of road markings are missing in PGR1 and the car handling is inferior. MSR is a bigger game, more circuits, more options, better music and plays great with a wheel. The Kudos system in MSR is convoluted and can mess-up 1 player progression. The Kudos system is better in PGR1.

[@Bronxguyanese]

Project gotham racing for Xbox 1 was amazing. I prefer project Gotham racing series over Forza Motorsports.

[@vcdecide]

I also preferred Project Gotham Racing over Forza... I only started liking Forza with Forza Horizon. Microsoft probably saw that it didn't make sense to have two racing game IPs dividing their audience's attention.

[@Bronxguyanese]

@@vcdecide I agree. I wish Microsoft can do project gotham racing with updates visuals

[@Ricck_DiazZ]

MSR é o meu jogo de corrida preferido até hoje! Quando joguei no meu saudoso Dreamcast, eu quase chame o SAMU pois nunca tinha visto um game tão bom como ele. Passei mau na época hahahhahha. Eu gosto muito do PGR, zerei umas duas vezes no meu Xbox caixotão, mas ainda prefiro o MSR

[@lostboy626]

I wish you could have captured both at the same time of day. The DC’s greatest strength has always been its texture detail and this is no exception. It might not be able to throw around as many polys as the XB but, it can hold its own quite well with the right hands. To think that MSR was running at 60fps while in development and had to be restricted to 30 is a shame, but they had to get the game out and they hadn’t gotten performance to maintain 60fps just yet. Glad we did get it in the end, it was so late that they canned the JP version. Which in hindsight is a bit strange considering how long they kept pressing new DC games through 2007 😅 I really like the update to the car models on the XB, but otherwise it still shows its MSR origins very strongly. The tracks look more simplified in details, but it could be just the time of day difference throwing me off. I do miss these games and wish they would relaunch the franchise as a 3rd counterpart to Forza Motorsport and Forza Horizon.

[@LeShark75]

My heart is with the Dreamcast version here. Loved it back in the day.

[@dougs408]

Versão do Xbox está mais bonita, também né, o Xbox era praticamente um Pc.

[@SomeOrangeCat]

It really was, and its HDD actually made it perfect for games other consoles couldn't pull off, because it could be used for decompressing and streaming stuff like texture data.

[@dougs408]

@@SomeOrangeCat Exatamente como eu disse, ele era praticamente um Pc, inclusive, as próximas gerações de consoles seguiram o mesmo exemplo de hardware, e é assim até hoje, menos o switch que é outro tipo de hardware e arquitetura.

[@nikoforu]

I love everything they did on MSR. But PGR was obviously a major graphics upgrade.

[@kinorai]

Other than the graphical effects (reflection, fog, etc) on the Xbox - I am surprised at how well the Dreamcast holds its own! I wonder if they kept the same textures (and resolution) from the Dreamcast when they made the Xbox game?

[@sobesons]

xbox

[@CosmixReflection]

this was posted yesterday but I'm seeing this today on my birthday. thank you for this upload

[@JohnCharb87]

First of all their is quite a bit of swearing in the Dreamcast version. Overall very straight forward arcade racer. 1. I feel the sense of speed is a lot better on the Dreamcast version. 60MPH feels like that speed. 2. Really great car models on the Xbox version. Also the physics engine looks realistic with the body rolls during cornering. 3. I do like the HUD on the Dreamcast version. Easier to read Speedometer, Tachometer, and Gear selection. However I give Kudos to the mini map on the Xbox version for the highlighted opponents.

[@dffagundo]

Regarding the swearing, it's not that like that on vanilla messages. You could customise some text messages that would show up during races (when you crash, etc...)

[@JohnCharb87]

@@dffagundo Really...intriguing. Makes sense why it seems very blunt. Also one of the swear words is spelled wrong.

[@sungketpatel30]

yes @@JohnCharb87 the message you are seeing is customised. The original message simply says "Watch out!" and when you get kudos for driving well it says "Wey Hey!"

[@SomeOrangeCat]

The Kudos system is definitely more brutal in MSR. It's hard to enjoy a game, when the developer puts an arbitrary system in place that penalizes you for...everything.

[@retroboy-fh1ji]

5:02 sounds like Sonic 3d Blast (Sega Saturn version) - Green Groove act 1 (melody part)

[@Shyning77]

Same composer (Richard Jacques). Sonic R shares the same composer AND the same singer (TJ Davis).

[@retroboy-fh1ji]

@@Shyning77 yes i know about the composer Richard Jacques, also contributed with some songs on Jet Set Radio (Dreamcast)/JSR 2: Future (Xbox)

[@toostepsback5119]

I love MSR, it's so relaxing to play. Unfortunately I've never played PG, but it seems to be a great game. Thanks for sharing friend!

[@fordmanx3]

Basically the same game and these 2 systems were soo much alike back in their Hayday

[@SomeOrangeCat]

How was the Xbox like the Dreamcast? It was literally a PC in a console case.

[@jasonlee7816]

Dreamcast 200 MHz CPU + 100 MHz GPU 16 MB main RAM GD-ROM disc media unlike Xbox 733 MHz CPU + 233 MHz GPU 64 MB unified DDR SDRAM DVD disc media supports Dolby Digital Live 5.1 and Dolby Surround in games

[@CastleFamilyThe]

I owned both on release, both amazing games, Xbox version has slightly better graphics sure, but for a console that came out in 1998 MSR was the most impressive of the two at time of release.

[@sgogo]

Wow, Xbox blast the poor Dreamcast, anyway any of them are great, great games with a lot of fun.

[@rawdiamond89]

Thank you for the comparison but i wanted to see the levels on the same Daytime.

[@helderestrela6958]

Nunca percebi porque os jogos de corridas no dreamcast usavam poucos ou nenhuns reflexos exeçao com o tokyo extreme racer. Mas fora isso msr é bastante bom

[@IronicSonic83]

Hold on. PGR was a kind of remake of MSR? I had no idea

[@Shyning77]

Not really. It was kind of a spiritual sequel by the same development team (Bizarre Creations), which started a new series on a different system. MSR was the game which the PGR series was based on.

[@DGamesChannel]

não sabia que tinha as mesmas pistas não joguei esse jogo no xbox e hoje em dia nao roda bem no emulador ja o de Dreamcast joguei de mais amo muito a trilha sonora espero um dia conseguir jogar o project gothan no xbox com qualidade

[@MrKeitaroSama]

Joguei muito MSR no DC na época de seu lançamento. Achava a vibe, ambiente e trilha sonora muito bons, mas achava o sistema de Kudos muito punitivo e desbalanceado. Muitas vezes o computador jogava o carro em cima de vc, e vc recebia penalidade.

[@RJAY63]

Thank for the upload. While I have done lots of research and spent many hours playing MSR, I have to concede Project Gotham Racing (PGR1) is the better game. Unfortunately the Kudos system in MSR is too easy to exploit; there's no incentive to improve your driving when you can get the highest scores by simply driving backwards/forwards and powersliding all over the place. In fact there is only ONE challenge in MSR where that exploit does not work. While exploits exist in PGR1, you still have to be a good driver to get the best results. PGR1's Kudos system is also much more fleshed out (medal awards) and you can see your Kudos scores in real time. MSR does do Time Attack better than PGR1 but the majority of players find that boring. Time Attack is the main reason I played MSR so much which is quite ironic considering MSR was trying to get away from standard racing. People may consider MSR to be a glorified tech demo or 'proof of concept' for PGR1.....and in some ways it is. But MSR needed to happen first so Bizarre Creations could learn from mistakes and make the necessary changes in PGR1.

[@JenifeWarnes-b6b]

Dreamcast have a fantastic graphic for you year

[@nezxd5516]

Los juegos de Dreamcast tenían vida propia. It's thinking!

[@bizarroeddie1]

Project Gotham is considerably more advanced. Better modeling, better lighting and twice the frame rate. And it's a launch game.

[@vcdecide]

MSR = 256 racing tracks PGR = 199 racing tracks And yes, it's obviously more advanced, but it has a lower total number of tracks, despite having one more city.

[@DLAOx]

La cantante y la primer canción me recuerdan mucho a Sonic R, buscando información veo que es la misma cantante (Teresa Jane Davis) y el mismo compositor (Richard Jacques). Hermosas canciones que no han vuelto desde entonces.

[@albertovilan7439]

La versión de Dreamcast, la única a la que he podido jugar en su día, resulta muy meritoria, sobre todo para el año en la que fue lanzada. Recuerdo que la construcción de las ciudades me alucinó, aunque la tasa de imágenes por segundo me había decepcionado un poco. El juego de Xbox se ve increíble. Realmente sorprende la potencia que tenía esa máquina, muy superior a todo lo existente en el mercado.

[@mro9466]

Still playing MSR on emulator

[@riazyusufkhan]

The xbox game isn't... nevermind. It is good seeing those both side by side.

[@JEY74]

Dreamcast tiene efectos climáticos y circuitos de dia y noche en tiempo real segun la region a la que pertenezcas programados mediante el reloj interno de Dreamcast, si eres de America y juegas de dia, una carrera en europa sería de noche y así sucesivamente.

[@Cricket-qd5ri]

Would be incredible if both matched the same time of the day. The Xbox cars reflecting the real scene is insane and almost unbelieveble at that time. Even for now is such an eye candy. The higher FPS and the smooth graphics is also crazy, because Dreamcast is good at this department, specially if you compare to PS2 smoothness. However, Dreamcast had an amanzing work at night, so the textures looks brighten just like an shiny city as Tokyo. And Dreamcast and running this game so well just proves that both systems belongs to the same generation, of course assuming the Xbox as superior.

[@toejamandearl8110]

I liked them both.

[@FranMatsusaka]

There's a obvious improvement in the Xbox game, although it's impressive how realistic the graphics looks on the DC. Bizarre Creations made a unbelievable job.

[@lavosier2]

a versão de dreamcast destruiu a versão do xbox...

[@JEY74]

Hermoso Dreamcast

[@Silva_GP]

Bizarre Creations created the greatest racing games during 2000s, sadly Activision killed the development studio after Blur commercial failure and Microsoft doesn't give attention to Project Gotham Racing.

[@Supervisor360]

I swear xbox and dreamcast can handle the most wonderful looking games ever mase

[@guillaumenunes9319]

Unfortunately, we'll never see pgr on dreamcast, only the father but there are a lot in commun.

[@Marmite101]

Can we do compare GranTurismo4 and GranTurismo5 plz?

[@thompsonpatrick79]

Wait project Gotham racing is the dc game???

[@SomeOrangeCat]

MSR was the prototype.

[@catboyxx]

xbox c

[@marcocinquini1985]

MSR is a pretty game for the time, considerably good to drive, but, the kudos unlocking system is terrible. You don't just try to get the necessary points of each section to unlock the next car, but, if you try again and fail, you LOSE points.

[@Shyning77]

Yes, the worst decision that ruined the gameplay. They should've kept the highest Kudos score instead of resetting each time you try again... Trying to improve was too risky!

[@MoonSarito]

The Xbox looks better, but this games looks so impressive on the Dreamcast.

[@SomeOrangeCat]

Yeah, the Xbox is barely flexing its graphical muscle for this game.

[@athos5359]

test drive le mans on dreamcast is more impressive,msr had better textures,the best for a dreamcast game up to 40mb of non compressed textures for the langer tracks.

[@solidshinji1]

a primeira musica é muito sonic R

[@liquidsnk]

For me PGR improves handling of cars specially at braking. MSR is impresive on Dc but the flickering was horrible at night

[@MegaMeHaHa-h1h]

Dreamcast has got that good arcade look and feel. Xbox has got a sim look and feel.

[@solidshinji1]

the first song remind a lot of sonic R

[@Shyning77]

Same composer (Richard Jacques) and same singer (TJ Davis).

[@albertodiez4215]

En la pantalla de un movil no se aprecia la diferencia. Los desarrolladores dijeron que la unica mejora que metieron al juego fue mas poligonos a los coches y mejor framerate, por que no les dio tiempo para mas. Supongo que los filtros de las texturas y la iluminacion tambien seran mejores. Hay que recordar que xbox salio mas tarde y a un precio mas alto, por lo que hay que ser indulgente con la diferencia tecnica. Otra diferencia es que mientras en la xbox se hizo muy famoso nadie recuerda la version de dreamcast y es casi el mismo juego. Una demostracion mas de los juegos buenos que pasan desapercibidos, y de que la historia la cuentan los ganadores

[@DontKnowDontCare6.9]

セガは本当に哀れだ

[@MistesYuusha]

Love MSR

[@vittosphonecollection57289]

OMG Xbox wins already just because it doesn't swear and, mostly, it doesn't swear AT THE PLAYER 😂😂 Ok but seriously, the colors on the cars look so much better there, so do the models themselves, as to be expected from the like 3 years difference. Still the Dreamcast one isn't too bad! Still looks better than the average 90's racing game. (And even tho this is from the 2000s, you probably still has your '94 3D racing game or even 2D/Mode 7 like racing game. Plus how are the customers supposed to know that these games are the same with a name and artstyle so different?! Like imagine being someone who bought the Dreamcast version of the game and later buys this "Project Gotham Racing" game for Xbox, only for him to discover it was the same game, but with better defined visuals...

[@giovannimarcelodasilva768]

Achei os gráficos do game mais bonitos no Xbox Classic

[@sonicstyle8008]

毎回楽しみに観ています。　ところで、VCDECIDEさんは、日本に来たことはありますか？ 為替と観光客の増加で、東京、大阪のレトロゲームは高騰しています。 I look forward to watching it every time.　By the way, VCDECIDE, have you ever been to Japan? Due to the exchange rate and the increase in tourists, retro games are becoming more expensive in Tokyo and Osaka.

[@vcdecide]

日本でのレトロゲームの価格は過去にはもっと魅力的でしたが、ゲームを買うためだけに日本に行く観光客が増えるにつれて、さらに悪化する（値段が上がる）傾向があります。レトロゲームは今では高くなっていますが、それでも世界の他の地域より安いです。私は日本に行ったことがありませんが、''ドラマ''が大好きなので、日本のことはよく知っています。渋谷や秋葉原（アキバ）、お台場などの場所に詳しいです。 Retro game prices in Japan were more attractive in the past, but the trend is likely to worsen (prices will increase) due to the growing number of tourists going to Japan just to buy games. Although retro games are more expensive now, they are still cheaper than in the rest of the world. I’ve never been to Japan, but I know it well because I’m a big fan of 'doramas', and I’m familiar with places like Shibuya, Akiba (Akihabara), Odaiba, and others.

[@sonicstyle8008]

@@vcdecide 　ご回答ありがとうございます。今後も素晴らしい動画を期待しています。 　Thank you for your answer. I look forward to seeing more great videos in the future.

[@Guilnc]

04:01 Essa música é muito parecida com a da fase "Green Grove Zone" de Sonic 3D Blast de Sega Saturn... 🤔

[@Shyning77]

Same composer (Richard Jacques). Same composer and same singer (TJ Davis) as in Sonic R too.

[@more7642]

Obviously Xbox version looks drastically better. Higher poly count, better lighting, reflections on the cars etc. After all, Xbox could run Dead or Alive 3, Fable, Ninja Gaiden, Doom 3, Half-Life 2, Halo 2, Jade Empire etc. which even nowadays looks fine.

[@SomeOrangeCat]

MVG's video on the Xbox port of Doom 3 is a must watch. Does an amazing job of explaining how the Xbox was the only 6th generation console capable of running the game, and its not for the reasons most people would assume!

[@alexandernorman5337]

@@SomeOrangeCat It's because only Xbox hardware had an eight bit stencil buffer. A hardware component that all Nvidia graphics chipsets had since the TNT.

[@SomeOrangeCat]

@@alexandernorman5337 Well that and an 8GB hard drive that could be used for data streaming.

[@SpeedsterBlur]

Well this is the first time I learned Project Gotham Racing is the same game as Metropolis Street Racer. Huh.

[@Shyning77]

Not the same game, obviously, but a spiritual sequel by the same development team (Bizarre Creations), which started a new series on a different system.

[@toadzuera7543]

Caramba, que gráfico bonito ! (DC)

[@a.d.sstudioanimation6438]

How are they comparable? Not even the same game right?

[@Shyning77]

Yes, it's more like comparing a game with its sequel.

[@megabyteDeSu.]

Both games are the same???

[@Shyning77]

No. Same development team (Bizarre Creations), but PGR was more like a spiritual sequel to MSR.

[@n64fan60]

Xbox win, but it was great on Dreamcast, as shown here in the video.

[@ElsweyrDiego]

pera, pgr não tinha de noite, só de dia? e achei um pouco acizentado tudão no geral também

[@j.c.s7762]

The stages of both games are very similar. Are the games made by the same company?

[@Shyning77]

Same development team, yes (Bizarre Creations).

[@juarezmiranda]

Xbox q video game ins@no, agora ta explicado pq tem Sonysta do Astrobobos ficam desdenhando os consoles da Microsoft, olha o nivel do grafico, olha nem é o melhor do Xbox classico, Forza ainda é bem mais bonito.

[@akael2010]

Aí a diferença é enorme

[@wangtang32000]

i never knew these were the same game :o

[@vittosphonecollection57289]

@@wangtang32000 No but fr, how was someone even supposed to know, when the promotion is so different?

[@Shyning77]

Because they weren't the same game. PGR was the start of a different series on a different system, but was a spiritual sequel to MSR, which PGR was based on (both developed by Bizarre Creations).

[@vittosphonecollection57289]

@@Shyning77 Oh ok. So basically like Paper Mario being Super Mario RPG 2 in Japan, but it's the start of its own series?

[@Shyning77]

@@vittosphonecollection57289 Kind of, yes.

[@No-vq1iv]

Dreamcast fanboys be like: BuT tHe ArT sTyLE iS BetTer

[@athos5359]

msr has the better color pallet,better ai drivers,the rest xbox wins.

[@retrooutput]

Which is a valid response if that's their opinion ...

[@No-vq1iv]

@@athos5359 Lmao, right on cue.

[@No-vq1iv]

@@retrooutput That's a nice way of saying something without having anything to say.

[@Idktbh80]

True they basically are denying the fact that a failed console looks better than the xbox

[@unknownx3601]

i had this on de xbox didnt like it

[@Ren547]

Xbox é melhor.

[@aderitosantos1695]

Nao esqueço primeira vez vi jogo, dia primeira vez franquia Grand Turismo PlayStation sentiu ameaçado, aliás peso aumenta segunda rajada ...sequela exclusivo Xbox, após notícias adiamento grand turismo 4😅😅😅

[@SomeOrangeCat]

I'm guessing the Xbox game is a sequel, rather than a port. Even in its early days, the OG Xbox's graphics were exceptional.