Vigano: New Interview

[@janetbodell5639]

Watching from Oregon! God bless Archbishop Vigano for speaking TRUTH and showing COURAGE.

[@michaelspeyrer1264]

Those who are excommunicated automatically loose ecclesiastical office. He is no longer an archbishop.

[@cindycrocker2961]

Greetings fellow Oregonian ❤ pray pray pray for our state. We do have 2 good bishops ❤️🙏✝️

[@johnholmes9801]

@@michaelspeyrer1264. Consider the legitimacy of the Dicastery with Cdl. Fernandez, author of two pornographic books aiming to develop a pornocracy of the Church.. the pope appoint d atheist, proabortion protestant theologian, in addition to having “Rapenick” by his side. How can one be beholden to such a group who are leading people to damnation.

[@JeremiahAlphonsus]

@@michaelspeyrer1264Antipope Francis has no legitimate authority, and the entity he leads is not the actual Catholic Church.

[@rosalindaarquiza4028]

yes i agree

[@treeannie8831]

Hi gentlemen, from Texas. God Bless AB Vigano! 🙏✝️❤️‍🔥🩸

[@susiefromomaha]

From Dallas. :)

[@treeannie8831]

@@susiefromomaha just down the road from me in Rockwall!

[@beebella2800]

Thank you Robert and Matt. Excellent discussion. Questions we all have that needs to be addressed. God Bless and Keep His Excellency Arb. Vigano

[@MargaretGreene-y3c]

Powerful, powerful Dr Moynihan, I love your honesty and courage in discussing these very serious matters, it is hard to hear but we need to know the truth of the state of our hierarchy in Rome.

[@irenemoreirataitson1677]

Watching from Brazil. I totally support Arch Vigano, he is a real father, corageous, protective of our faith.

[@matthewschmidt5069]

You are in schism as well. Repent

[@dianneraimondi8382]

@@matthewschmidt5069 Oh you again/the papal police!!!!!! LOVE VIGANO!!!! Rome's in schism not vigano!!!!

[@matthewschmidt5069]

@dianneraimondi8382 Rome can't be in schism against itself. Impossible and absurd.

[@dianneraimondi8382]

@@matthewschmidt5069 Yes, personally a pope can be in schism as he is NOT impeccable therefore capable of sin!

[@matthewschmidt5069]

@@dianneraimondi8382 Schism means refusal to submit to the Pope. How could the Pope not submit to himself?

[@barbarachisolm145]

Love to spend this time with you. Barbara from Florida.. you are always fair, calm and clear. Thank you for bringing a clear, comprehensive presentation to us regarding Archbishop Vigano. Bless you both.

[@pwright6658]

Watching from Jacksonville Florida. Arch Bishop Vigano and the Holy Father are both in my prayers.

[@tinaq9554]

Am watching from Sweden. Abp Vigano is in good company. St. Joan of Arc was also excommunicated.

[@michaelspeyrer1264]

Nor by the Pope, not licitly, and not for violating canon law.

[@BlairGordon-g8c]

@@michaelspeyrer1264 No actual pope excommunicated him, no canon law was violated by him.

[@ccl754]

Thank you for the update. Much appreciated. We hope& pray for AB Vigano. 🙏

[@janetbodell5639]

It appears to me that the spirits of deceit, deception, debauchery, and disbelief have overtaken our hierarchy in Rome. We must pray for deliverance in the Name of Jesus!!!!!

[@dianneraimondi8382]

They are in total apostasy!

[@lindagaspers2529]

Dr. Moynihan and Matt Gaspers, THANKS For Exemplifying for us, The Faithful, how we can all be CLAY In The Hands Of The POTTER. WE look to you for guidance in this Difficult Time in The CHURCH!! GOD BLESS YOU BOTH!!🙏🙏

[@geraldinederycke6485]

Thank you for supporting Archbishop Vigano. I can remember when the archbishop warned Pope Francis not to send the disgraced crd. McCarrick to China to negotiate with the Chinese Party and negations regarding allowing them to have a hand in the appointment of Catholic priests. That had tremendous implications on the state of the church and catholic people.

[@joankelly7672]

Watching from Scotland UK.

[@lindagaspers2529]

Soo Much CONFUSION from Francis!!!

[@TheGenoveva7]

Respect for authority is earned. I have more respect for Archbishop Vigano than the one “excommunicating” him!

[@MáireNí-b1e]

I have learned so much from your talks about the ChatholicChurch which is in crisis. God bless you both

[@auspiciomiranda-rodrigues9336]

Watching from Goa in India

[@michellelococo4023]

Good Afternoon dear Gentlemen. Thank you! Only wish I could have tuned in live.

[@patriciamathews5975]

Fr. James Martin S.J. is Editor at Large for America Magazine. His agenda is multi-fold. The main objective is to fundamentally change the Catholic Church.

[@genevievekelly1792]

Vigano is the modern-day Lefevre. 🙏

[@Vexx_Line_]

And St. Athanasius!

[@auspiciomiranda-rodrigues9336]

Many of us as Believing Roman Catholics from india are concerned about the Crisis we are witnessing in Our Church. It is really painful to hear " Who am i to judge? " and yet to judge!

[@joannnelander9791]

As Malachi Martin famously said “the cockroaches are in charge of the citadel” 29:35

[@susiefromomaha]

Yes and Vigano has shown the LIGHT of TRUTH on them and they are scattering and very pissed off now! Overreaching thus making it easier to spot the heretics and blasphemers, and that is a good thing.

[@mayetamayo7954]

I believe that it is time to confront everything that has been happening and is happening in the Church with more courage and bravery. We lay people are witnessing so many inconceivable things that come from within the hierarchy of the Church, and it seems that those who try to find the truth keep going around in circles so as not to find it. Thank you

[@dianecopeland9245]

Thank you

[@susiefromomaha]

Papa Benedict XVI said the Church will become smaller but more holy. Pray for holy and final perseverance!!! We need it!

[@sandybabyak3188]

Robert- you have a lot of information to offer. You may want to put a timer on yourself - just saying Not saying I’m not interested or appreciative- but, this is focused on Viganò. Love you and Fr Muir and now Matt on board.

[@robertryan2542]

Thank you gentlemen. From Ireland ☘️

[@johnqpublic3766]

“It requires a delicate and sensitive analysis.” No, it requires COURAGE.

[@susiefromomaha]

BOOM! So true! Vigano, imo, certainly knows more about all of this than any of us, even more than these good men of this podcast, who I admire. The time for 'delicate' is long past! Courage and holy zeal for God's House is needed and now!

[@arunarodrigues6478]

with due respect, Bergoglio's position especially on sexual abuse is amply evidenced when he was 'bishop' in Argentina.

[@rosalindaarquiza4028]

we are sinner who cannot judge souls, but we learn JESUS teachings is that sin is a sin ,

[@vimmi_8]

Please also see Dr. Taylor Marshall's new interview with Archbishop Vigano for more on this, and pray the Rosary about it!

[@joannnelander9791]

Many of our bishops are failing us, not Vigano. Bishops shouldn’t wait for a consensus from a body like the USCCB. Each bishop is responsible for his diocese to lead and inspire it as an apostle of Christ. They are not to poll and test the waters as though running for office or pandering to public approval. We have the gospel and they are to help us follow Christ in living it out in difficult times.

[@dianneraimondi8382]

Unfortunately ,God doesn't come first as they don't believe in God!! Catholics need to wake up/pope bishops /apostates!!

[@Vexx_Line_]

Exactly. The USCCB is a relatively recent creation where previously no such body existed. Each bishop was responsible for his own diocese & parishes without having to consult a conference of other bishops.

[@dianneraimondi8382]

@@Vexx_Line_ They still are, this is a novelty from vat2!

[@arunarodrigues6478]

the huge problem for all of us is to make sense of how the Catholic Church will show us how to stay on the straight and narrow and discriminate between the real teaching of Christ called the Doctrine of Christ, from the rest, which is add-on or peripheral. I include and dare to some aspects of the Catechism which I personally have never believed in. . I respect Vigano enormously who goes beyond legalism and wants to protect and project the TRUTH. In this he shows uncommon courage that most clergyman have not shown. We need the support of the CHURCH which includes us LAITY

[@Vexx_Line_]

Which parts of the Catechism concern you? Thx!

[@rosalindaarquiza4028]

i do believe in vigano , strickland anyway,

[@sophiachavez3377]

As soon as he says “I want …..” he’s wrong! Robert is always looking to give Bergoglio an excuse.

[@horizon-one]

What Pope Francis says does not match what he does. His actions do not align with the Faith handed down. He has created a lot of scandal. This is not being disrespectful but speaking facts. This Pope needs to be seriously admonished. I don't believe Pope Francis knows the Faith. That is a shocking state for he Pope. The state of his soul at this point in time is grave. I wonder whether he will receive the Grace for conversion before it's too late.

[@susiefromomaha]

I agree.

[@theressaunders2945]

I am listening from the Bahamas.

[@arunarodrigues6478]

finally -- tyranny is prohibited whether in Govts and still less in the True Church (we will from now onwards have to keep defining our TRUE CHURCH!). Francis has shown his sympathy with the pharmaceutical Industry and may be also the great reset. This is a certain indicator with regard to Francis' deep errors

[@zanafin8684]

Timeline 24:40 - the circumstances are also very different with pope Francis; 1) The St Gallon Mafia bragged about there illegal actions related to Francis’ election. 2) Francis declares many heresies, and never corrects his heresies when questioned about them. 3) Francis has refused the title Vicar Of Christ. 4) Francis continues to protect Rupnik and use his “art work”. 5) Many men Francis has elevated have cause scandal in the church. 6) Many good and faithful leaders in our Church have been publicly persecuted by Francis. And there are many many more! Time will tell who stood on the side of truth. As in the time of Saint Athanasius, much time will have to pass before the many brave men, like Archbishop Viganò, will be recognized for their loyalty to Jesus Christ and his one true Church, the one true Faith, The Catholic Faith!

[@dianneraimondi8382]

He was, Because He was a communist, during his young days and after, He said it himself! His Boss was a communist and introduced communism to him and he enthusiastically embraced it!

[@BlairGordon-g8c]

His best friends say he doesn't even believe Christ was God.

[@dianneraimondi8382]

If the pope's magisterial teaching does not conform to the apostolic faith, it is not magisterial.

[@littlerock5256]

It is impossible for a pope's magisterial teaching to not conform to the apostolic faith. If that happens then the papal claimant in question has no authority and really isn't the pope.

[@dianneraimondi8382]

@@littlerock5256 I disagree. I think he remains the pope because it is a juridical position not a sacrasodal one. We have had popes that taught error in their ordinary magisterial teaching and were considered the pope. John 22nd is a good example.Also if they teach error ,Fr Wendy's opinion is it is not magisterial, that it the erroneous teaching. It makes sense.

[@littlerock5256]

@@dianneraimondi8382 No pope has taught error in their ordinary magisterial teaching, including John XXII, that would put anyone's soul in jeopardy. Any 'error' is incidental.

[@dianneraimondi8382]

@@littlerock5256 Wrong!! You're suppose to know your faith!! All catholics are obligated to pursue studies to enhance their understanding of their catholic faiths papal, episcopal errors are picked up. The pope etc is not impeccable,whcih includes making errors out side the extraordinary magisterium.

[@littlerock5256]

@@dianneraimondi8382 Catholics are obliged to assent to the ordinary magisterium which cannot teach error.

[@wraithoftheirish]

EXCOMMUNICATED. FROM THE APE OF THE CHURCH..?😢

[@anndonbrinson2520]

Not all Catholics recognize "Pope" Francis. Many do not, but they have no voice.

[@elainemgardens874]

It seems to me that Robert has a hard time believing that there may be an Anti Pope on the Seat of Peter. It’s too hurtful to his conscience to even entertain the thought., like a Mother that cannot accept the fact that her child was a serial killer. But I ask is it really impossible?

[@susiefromomaha]

I have heard we've had anti-popes about 2 every 100 years, so we are due and PF is certainly one, imo. I admire Robert a lot, but he could use a bit more zealous 'fire in his belly' about this rotten stuff from PF. It doesn't cause division to actually be 'righteously angry' about this despotic papacy!

[@donaldlippert6374]

Dear Dr Monahan, I hold you in highest esteem. You are a genuinely good man and faithful Catholic who loves the Church and is seeking the truth in these dark times. There are two related issues… The validity of the election of Pope Francis (PF) and the validity of the excommunication of Abp Viganò (AV). Regarding the first, I think there is no convincing argument in the public sphere that can deny the validity of the election of PF. The argument clarifying this is the teaching that the universal acceptance of the cardinals together with the universal acceptance of the church throughout the world includes a kind of “sanatio in radice” of any improprieties that may have taken place in the conclave or even before. Jorge Bergoglio was never accused (let alone convicted) by bishops or cardinals of being a public heretic. And no one can get into his mind to know exactly what was the character of his consent when he accepted the keys. Even his later actions are no clear proof of what he intended at the beginning. In the depths of his conscience however, AV is free to believe what he wants to believe… and make whatever arguments he can to defend himself. But his arguments cannot transcend his own self-justification and cannot extend to any moral demands on others. On the other hand, I think there are worthy arguments to be made showing the defect in the excommunication of AV… some related to the Davies arguments…. I believe that a mitigating factor is that a subject cannot be sanctioned if he does not follow the law of one whose authority he questions or cannot accept. These arguments need to be developed more and I believe that they will be, perhaps in a future pontificate. The church is in a terrible way. We seem to be in a unique historical situation in which the church finds itself in a problem for which there is no historical or canonical resolution. As you (and Fr Murr) have said, it will lead to church the clarify these matters in the future, but in the meantime, we must pray, study, do penance and trust in the ultimate victory of Christ.

[@monicamartens3659]

The part Matt skipped going over --the page that he did not read, of his questions and the Archbishop's answers----contains the KEY to all of this: (Vigano's words:) "The same Masonic lobby that for over two centuries has systematically demolished civil governments, has managed to penetrate the Catholic Church, to appoint its own emissaries, to progressively eliminate all internal opposition and to impose a series of radical changes that subvert the magisterial teaching of two thousand years.....Are there two churches? Of course not,: one is the True Church, the other is the deep church, that is, its counterfeit, the counter-church, the anti-church of the Antichrist." There is our answer! Understanding THIS KEY POINT of Vigano at 52:03 above, is our hope of finding our way in this turmoil. Because if the leaders in the hierarchy are anti-hierarch's , then we are in the FINAL APOSTASY predicted by Paul the Apostle in 1 Thessalonians chapter 2. And our Lady's prophecies to Sister Mariana in the 16th century apply to today: We need to pray for the placing in the See of Peter a TRUE PRELATE, A TRUE SHEPHERD, a True Vicar of Jesus Christ, who will rule justly the Flock of God. ...Many prayers. 🙏

[@xoox-g2b]

Ah, 1:03:30 -- to be fair, you need to let Abp Vigano respond to that.

[@arunarodrigues6478]

Francis is the guardian of the Doctrine of Christ and His vicar in the performance of this mandate and duty -- if he fails this mandate and this is the test, he is no longer a 'son' of the Church, still less the Vicar of Christ

[@Vexx_Line_]

Except he dropped the title "Vicar OC".

[@vonniestanchfield2849]

Watching from California. Thank you 🙏

[@JeremiahAlphonsus]

I recognize that as a non-Catholic and indeed rabid anti-Catholic, Francis cannot possibly be an actual pope, since actual popes must be actually Catholic. One cannot be the visible head of a body of which one is not a member. I further recognize that he’s not just a "bad father." One must first be an actual father to be a bad father. But Francis has never been an actual spiritual father at all. His status as an impostor has nothing to do with any electoral irregularities or any attempted bifurcation of Benedict XVI's "papacy" in 2013. Francis isn't a father, isn't a pope, solely because he isn't a Catholic; and he wasn't a Catholic long before 2013. Just as only actual Catholics can be actual popes, only actual Catholics can become actual popes. I also recognize that since we’re divinely promised (Mt. 16:18) that hell shall not prevail over the actual Catholic Church, the entity now led by Francis cannot possibly be the actual Catholic Church, since hell HAS prevailed over the entity now led by Francis. To call the entity now led by Francis the actual Catholic Church is to simultaneously call Jesus Christ a liar. Finally, I recognize that it takes absolutely no legal authority to recognize all of this manifest reality, just as one need not be a coroner to recognize a manifestly dead body. Our minds were made for truth. It's permissible, indeed essential for us, to recognize the truth. Any future legal judgment by the actual Catholic Church, which is now in the catacombs once again, will simply be a recognition of the present factual reality spitting in our faces daily. Scripture repeatedly warns us to flee the ravaging wolves. This presupposes that we have the capacity to recognize them as such and therefore to flee them immediately; that is, to flee them without any intervention from authority. It's time to get real; really real. Be not afraid. Man up. Seek truth, not comfort. Flee the Novus Ordo Antichurch. Flee it entirely. “Bear not the yoke with unbelievers. For what participation hath justice with injustice? Or what fellowship hath light with darkness? And what concord hath Christ with Belial? Or what part hath the faithful with the unbeliever?” (2 Cor. 6:14-15)

[@johnqpublic3766]

Amen!

[@rosalindaarquiza4028]

is it because, he holds that POWER,

[@Vexx_Line_]

👍👍👍Is there a link to Matt's interview with AB Viganò?

[@tf8066]

From Alberta Canada. Thank you!

[@johnjoyce1958]

If what The Pope is doing is wrong, herectical or, destructive or, leading souls to hell, then anyone who is baptised can challenge The Pope. A cardinal can address him or, an imperfect council can depose him.

[@littlerock5256]

It is impossible for a pope to teach heresy or lead souls to hell. It is always absolutely safe to follow the pontiff. No valid pope can be deposed. Vigano maintains that Francis never was the pope, which is the only possible answer.

[@johnjoyce1958]

@@littlerock5256 only if a Pope speaks Ex Cathedra is he infallible. So he can actually commit heresy even if he doesn't believe he is. Heresy can be material or formal. However the only ones who can address a heretical Pope is the College of Cardinals in an imperfect Council. Both Thomas Aquinas, Robert Bellarmaine and many current Cannon Lawyers and Theologians have covered this in detail. There was a Pope who excommunicated himself for Heresy. He repented and the Cardinals revoted him in as Pope.

[@weemouse1959]

Dr Robert, for goodness sakes No more Excuses for the pope ... please. Thank you. 🕊️

[@rosalindaarquiza4028]

this pope is the "CHAMPION OF LIACIZE CLERGY NOT ONLY PRIEST BUT BISHOPS, CARDINALS AT THAT,

[@pinknickelvidz]

FYI: I just unsubscribed and re-subscribed - selecting to get notifications again - because all your notifications disappeared from my KZbin list of notifications. KZbin has an issue, again.

[@dianneraimondi8382]

All we hear is man is God! This is from vat 2. WELL, I got news for you! God alone is God. The God of Abraham , Isaac and Jacob.God and Lord and Savior, Jesus Christ,the second person of the Blessed Trinity! God one in three and three in one!!!!

[@sophiachavez3377]

“He can’t run amuck….” But isn’t that exactly what Bergoglio has done? Why is it all of you video guys refuse to state the obvious that Bergoglio believes himself to be God? Anyone familiar with the hispanic character would have recognized this a long time ago.

[@wraithoftheirish]

A great sadness

[@susiefromomaha]

Yes, but also a GREAT HOPE! Where sin abounds, grace abounds all the more!

[@rosalindaarquiza4028]

do you agree on his concept of synadality, to love sinners with their sinner

[@benmoi3390]

I dunno what you are talking about not having any mechanism to settle such case... we have time where there was many pope excommunicating each others... the matter is serious and anyone have to take a side... and bear the consequence and responsability of their position... who is a cesaropapist of the church of modernist and who is of the apostolic church of Jesus... let's just recall...Isaiah 22:15-25... the little children of the church... the lamb aren't bound to choose, they are just following.. but woe to those who lead them astray...

[@rosalindaarquiza4028]

as a flock, do we still follow even if pope's teaching is different from Christ

[@joannnelander9791]

Jesus’s sacrifice on the Cross brings good out of evil.

[@rosalindaarquiza4028]

was'nt fr gruner, at fatima center, who was not incline about Vatican II

[@lindagaspers2529]

Francis does not PRESERVE THE TRADATION... NOT POPE FRANCIS...HE CONTRADICTS TRADITION?????

[@littlerock5256]

Popes cannot contradict Tradition. If Francis did then it means he isn't the pope.

[@glennhumphreyshumphreys2492]

Ok. Then I guess he isn't Pope. Is that your point? If not then you need to open your eyes and stop defending Francis.

[@sophiachavez3377]

Please stay on topic. Stop interrupting by acknowledging viewers.

[@mary-w7w6l]

understanding Vigano: NOTICE we might incorporate re: Vigano, by the explicit virtue of his fidelity to his priestly office, this fact which is: his countless blessings, inc. numerous charisms, come forth from God, to put forward Truth in ways, we the laity, may be (in degrees) in (& at times sharp) contrast to. the brilliant complexity of a mind like Vigano's, in addressing our times, is unsurpassed in profoundity, because of its complexity. his insights into the nature of the Church and the context which surrounds Her up to now, and the implications that radiate forth, now, mandate attention. More than having only a set of casual reactions, is a clear mistake. Hopefully, robert moynihan/matt gaspers' careful exam, of all the moving parts, will give, esp. the laity, a chance to develop further critical thinking skills, on the implications of the complexities involved therein.

[@RobMathMiller]

I am no theologian, but to say the essential characteristic of the Catholic faith is to stand with Peter seems blatantly incorrect! The essential characteristic of the Catholic faith is to stand with Jesus Christ! Peter left Jesus at the Cross! St. John did not stand with Peter at this moment! Nor did our blessed mother. And I would argue critically questioning a papacy and second Vatican council that has blatantly attempted to at least water down if not destroy Catholic Tradition and doctrine is being a faithful son of the Church!

[@susiefromomaha]

Well said! Thank you! Spot on!

[@arunarodrigues6478]

the sad thing is that ultimately when the CHURCH argues this sit, it succumbs inevitably to legalities. For us the Laity ultimately, we must obey our conscience which has absolute primacy. However, being informed is part of the duty imposed on us.

[@littlerock5256]

This is not Catholic teaching.

[@dianneraimondi8382]

@@littlerock5256 It is catholic teaching that you must go with your TRUE conscience not what you want to do!

[@littlerock5256]

@@dianneraimondi8382 A truly formed conscience will align with Church teaching.

[@dianneraimondi8382]

@@littlerock5256 Authentic church teaching, not the modernism that France's dishes out!

[@littlerock5256]

@@dianneraimondi8382 If Francis dishes out modernism, which is a heresy, then he in not the pope.

[@rmhernandez777]

I want to donate money to Archbishop Vigano ! How !

[@Mutasis_Mutandis]

Exsurge Domine. That’s his website.

[@annehammett8771]

Please turn on captions

[@rosalindaarquiza4028]

how come some cardinals hve resulted to "dubia"

[@rosalindaarquiza4028]

was'nt bnedict 16 opn this topic the serious cause of his resignation, which resulted to tbis pope now. now is pope francis real ?

[@rocaz6629]

Dr.Moynihan seems to me a fearful person to emit his real position, he expresses his thoughts on favor of Archbishop Vigano, but then he walks backwards rapidly. So what’s the point of this discussion if he doesn’t affirm his position. I don’t believe “to stay in the middle “, that’s being “warm and coward”. It’s a really difficult situation, but I stand with Vigano. We have many samples of Bergolio’s wrong doing and he evidently is working on the side of the WEF and NOT on the side of humanity and Jesus Christ

[@susiefromomaha]

Yes, it is frustrating to listen to the back and forth.

[@fernandorojas4212]

She forgot six, “the will of God” which is destiny (fate) 🤷🏻‍♂️

[@rosalindaarquiza4028]

if pope b 16, was true , how come pope francis accepted as pope ?

[@monicamartens3659]

No, Mr Moynihan, we do not need a process or a mechanism---we need to PRAY FOR A TRUE POPE.

[@JoellHedges-dm1mu]

WATCHING. Two words. Father LaCaze.

[@JoellHedges-dm1mu]

WHAT IS WITH THE “DARK” Guadalupe Picture??

[@anng.4542]

​@@JoellHedges-dm1mu Possibly a sepia-toned photograph or sepia print. Not sacrilegious.

[@rosalindaarquiza4028]

pope benedict himself sowed this confusion

[@rosalindaarquiza4028]

however, my position remain s as taught by JESUSCHRIST, but no choice , meantime, whatever

[@ClairLapinski]

Perhaps begin with prayer. Moynihan gets way off topic. I always want to listen to these but an hour later you’ve barely gotten anywhere

[@rmhernandez777]

NO MERIT ! Excommunication

[@michaelspeyrer1264]

If you are supporting Vigano and not condemning him as being in grave error at this point, you are not in communion with Christ and his church.

[@BlairGordon-g8c]

I can see someone wasn't paying attention to church history for the last 200 years. Vatican II was a partial repudiation of the Church and an embrace of condemned modernism. Bergoglio completed it. Any who follow him is an apostate.

[@dianneraimondi8382]

Vigano believes in the catholic faith, he's not in error,Francis does not believe in the apostolic faith, he's a modernist.He's in error!

[@matthewschmidt5069]

Vigano is leading souls to hell

[@BlairGordon-g8c]

No, he's leading people away from the sin-odal "church".

[@matthewschmidt5069]

@@BlairGordon-g8c Who are you to judge the Pope?

[@BlairGordon-g8c]

@@matthewschmidt5069 I know the Church's moral teachings, I can see with my own eyes he's encouraging people to ignore them. No judgement at all, just observation.

[@matthewschmidt5069]

@@BlairGordon-g8c And yet you think Vigano is correct. Repent.

[@dianneraimondi8382]

Francis is leading souls to hell,and so are you with your nit wit reasoning!!!!!!

[@donaldlippert6374]

Dear Dr Monahan, I hold you in highest esteem. You are a genuinely good man and faithful Catholic who loves the Church and is seeking the truth in these dark times. There are two related issues… The validity of the election of Pope Francis (PF) and the validity of the excommunication of Abp Viganò (AV). Regarding the first, I think there is no convincing argument in the public sphere that can deny the validity of the election of PF. The argument clarifying this is the teaching that the universal acceptance of the cardinals together with the universal acceptance of the church throughout the world includes a kind of “sanatio in radice” of any improprieties that may have taken place in the conclave or even before. Jorge Bergoglio was never accused (let alone convicted) by bishops or cardinals of being a public heretic. And no one can get into his mind to know exactly what was the character of his consent when he accepted the keys. Even his later actions are no clear proof of what he intended at the beginning. In the depths of his conscience however, AV is free to believe what he wants to believe… and make whatever arguments he can to defend himself. But his arguments cannot transcend his own self-justification and cannot extend to any moral demands on others. On the other hand, I think there are worthy arguments to be made showing the defect in the excommunication of AV… some related to the Davies arguments…. I believe that a mitigating factor is that a subject cannot be sanctioned if he does not follow the law of one whose authority he questions or cannot accept. These arguments need to be developed more and I believe that they will be, perhaps in a future pontificate. The church is in a terrible way. We seem to be in a unique historical situation in which the church finds itself in a problem for which there is no historical or canonical resolution. As you (and Fr Murr) have said, it will lead to church the clarify these matters in the future, but in the meantime, we must pray, study, do penance and trust in the ultimate victory of Christ.

[@donaldlippert6374]

Sorry… Dr Moynihan. Autocorrect can be frustrating!

[@sophiachavez3377]

“He can’t run amuck….” But isn’t that exactly what Bergoglio has done? Why is it all of you video guys refuse to state the obvious that Bergoglio believes himself to be God? Anyone familiar with the hispanic character would have recognized this a long time ago.

[@Vexx_Line_]

He did loudly proclaim "LET'S MAKE A MESS" shortly after his election. Big red flag.

[@rosalindaarquiza4028]

as a flock, do we still follow even if pope's teaching is different from Christ