Vincenzo Bellini, Casta Diva (Carmen Giannattasio)

Teatro La Fenice - Bellini, Casta Diva (capodanno 2014)
Teatro La Fenice - Concerto di Capodanno 2014
VINCENZO BELLINI
Norma, Casta diva
Orchestra e Coro del Teatro La Fenice
Direttore - Diego Matheuz
Maestro del Coro - Claudio Marino Moretti
soprano
Carmen Giannattasio
tenore
Lawrence Brownlee
La pubblicazione di questo video non intende violare nessun copyright e/o di essere usato a scopo di lucro. In caso contrario siamo a disposizione per l'eventuale rimozione
The publication of this video does not intend to violate any copyrights, or to be exploited for profit. Otherwise the undersigned is available for the eventual removal

[@carmelazilioli4382]

Bravissima, mi hai fatto piangere. Come la Callas.

[@Mr44Alfonso]

Una grande prestazione vocale sorretta da una tecnica ineccepibile e da un cuore liberato dalla necessità : la padronanza tecnica libera la sensibilità del cuore che torna ad esprimersi sovrana! E' la bellezza che si libera dalle difficoltà della materia come nella scultura i prigioni e le pietà del Michelangelo . Talento,impegno,gran cuore. Bravissima Carmen !

[@jaroslawrytel-andrjanik1410]

Voi italiani siete fortunati con tali campioni, vi invidio. :)

[@osvaldoscilingo5164]

Italia siempre la Italia !!!

[@user-dolina28]

Это сарказм😃

[@JamesAHollandMusic]

Wow! She gorgeous and possessing of a wonderful dramatic soprano voice. What a combination!

[@musicaeviaggio9698]

Very beautiful !!!

[@donantonioventulli4811]

Meravigliosa!!!!

[@user-hi5gi2gt8b]

Прекрасное исполнение!

[@annabelsearch]

Meraviglioso! Favoloso. Such vocal control, such grace

[@mariacasemyr]

Stunning voice ❤️

[@annacucciniello2910]

Eccezionale,super brava

[@oscarmyers7468]

Bravo 👏

[@user-sw5cm4nz3c]

素晴らしい表現力と声に魅了されます。後オーケストラが大好きです。

[@ryszardkulesza6912]

Dzięki za taką pieśń i WSPANIAŁE WYKONANIE dla ŚWIATA to jest bardzo wskazane i mądre aby móc komentować oceniać się cieszę i gratuluję KOMPOZYTOROWI o czym świadczą te wszystkie wpisy ale i zachowanie LUDZI ROSJI Dziękuję BardzoSpasiba bolszszaja Spasiba WAM od Ryszarda z Polski POLAKA w interesie Polski i Europy spasiba spasiba dla ludzi którzy są zainteresowani współpracą z nami w interesie Polski i Europy spasiba spasiba

[@rafaelkafka]

Casta Diva, che inargenti queste sacre antiche piante, a noi volgi il bel sembiante senza nube e senza vel... Tempra, o Diva, tempra tu de cori ardenti tempra ancora lo zelo audace, spargi in terra quella pace che regnar tu fai nel ciel...

[@Dylonely42]

Beautiful

[@sergioira627]

Maravilhosa! Wonderful! Fantastique! Wunderbar! Yπέροχο!

[@alfonsodauria7368]

Una meraviglia !

[@bingo1232]

Carmen Giannattasio -- you got my vote hon!

[@janethu9169]

Norma. Beautiful.

[@udospickermann9518]

Welch eine Stimme ! Einfach wunderbar !!!

[@rfu558]

全场境的显示， 好听又好看， Bravo!

[@jackyherrgott9284]

Quel bonheur !!

[@user-fy1ek5pt1y]

Stupendo.🌷🌹💘💘💘💘

[@versitost]

Bravo, Diego Matheuz!

[@antoniovisioli4460]

FANTASTICO!!!!!

[@markusEuro]

I love it. warm Italian pitch

[@alastisalastis7515]

Как же здорово

[@NickPis83]

senza parole!!!!!!!!!

[@user-eb5mc7tf1q]

ВЕЛИКОЛЕПНО!!!!!!!!!!!!!🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹

[@rediscozia6251]

Carmen giannattasio è una delle più grandi Artiste dei giorni d'oggi

[@bodiloto]

Re Di Scozia povera arte lirica ''moderna'' ... qua sentiamo una vocalità poco adatta à questa musica Meravigliosa. questa e' la vocina di Lauretta non di Norma, e' un fatto.

[@giorgiogiorgini4458]

Vedo, vedo anzi, sento sento! Che portento!

[@gidi3341]

dio mio sembra di vedere Mae West i suoi fulgori con una perfetta voce da soprano...è bellissima, una voce da brividi...ed un abito sicuramente Capucci

[@7373giuseppe]

L'abito è di Antonio Riva

[@violetta47]

Wonderful performance..

[@janp5780]

Super❤️

[@realser9]

*Guten Morgen* 🙌 📚 💖

[@ppRonnie]

She's wonderful, and so is Kimmy Skota, both equally good....

[@teresaweronska5913]

Moja ulubiona aria i kompozytor i ten spektakl -

[@ossydave]

One of the better voices for this aria. Many of the others are too strident or too vibrato.

[@alejoeisabel]

Bravo Maestro Diego Matheuz! You have put this together masterfully.

[@0.68_11]

CHRISTINA AGUILERA in Casta Diva.....

[@Bachateroitaliano]

mail4matt2000 😂😂😂

[@MrLuis85698]

oh lord..lol

[@mariafernandamaldonado6324]

Totalmente !!! Jaaaa y muy mediocre la mina

[@paolostaderini4455]

oltre il coro non si può andare

[@karlhagen7991]

Pas facile!

[@eliocardillo2110]

Mammamia! Grande voce per valorizzare l'immenso Bellini.

[@bodiloto]

''Grande voce''?!... vocalità poco adatta à questo capolavoro .

[@babbonatale9362]

Sulla vocalità effettiva richiesta dal ruolo c'è un acceso dibattito. Non mi risulta che il soprano belliniano fosse un drammatico d'agilità come lo intendiamo noi oggi

[@gerardmignon700]

la robe est intéressante...

[@aquarianja1620]

Estou aqui por causa do conto de Machado de Assis

[@niominiomi3334]

This one is not the same one as Maria Calles

[@user-jt4js7ed3e]

Хорошая.

[@cliffgaither]

Whatever her issues w / this aria, I didn't see a microphone anywhere near her.

[@celibidache1000]

If there weren't a microphone near her, how do you suggest the audio for the video was picked up..? 🤔

[@cliffgaither]

@@celibidache1000 :: Opera singers today are heavily microphoned. There are some singers who can't be heard without them. Granted, mics are needed for the audio, but this singer has no visible sound-enhancement ; maybe just discreetly placed. Famous singers can't be heard in famous houses. JDF stated clearly, to a student, "If they can't hear you, it's their problem !" If singers can't be heard, it's definitely the audience's problem --- they paid money to hear the performance. Great voices are kinda rare today & management & some singers are cheating with amplification. You can sometimes "see" the microphones "hidden" on their costumes during staged operas. Whether or not mics are needed for audio, you can't see them with this singer. Why is that ... ?

[@celibidache1000]

@@cliffgaither We're on the same side in this. ☺️ Opera is microphoned today since nobody can sing, and it's a disgrace.

[@cliffgaither]

@@celibidache1000 :: Yeah ! It's a disgrace, but we've been spoiled & there's no going backwards.

[@shodanart]

Maybe without microphones opera sopranos and tenors are less at risk for ruining their voices early on. I think the insistence on no mics is irrelevant to the beauty of voices and enjoying their arias. Everyone is not Sutherland and perhaps even Callas would have not ruined her voice too early with the dramatic challenges of some huge halls.

[@murphypaschal]

So many so-called "experts" who never really appreciate music, especially opera music, but just critique the singers. This was a beautiful performance. Just leave it at that and get a life and put on your Callas et al recordings every now and again and appreciate them. But give it a rest with your amateurish criticisms. Undignified.

[@0.68_11]

Chtistina Aguilera should try this...

[@karlhagen7991]

Comparez avec Anita Cerquetti et vous comprendrez.

[@numetutelare]

beh siano nell'Olimpo subito dopo la Callas...

[@user-hi5gi2gt8b]

1':37" - начало пения певицы после оркестрового вступления!..

[@raynardi7243]

rispetto l'artista...ma dov'è Norma?🤔

[@cguzmmang]

Un error quererse comparar con otras artistas, un error cantar algo que no dominas y peor aún, que no comprendes, maravillosa voz, pero sus impetus por momentos superan su sentido musical...

[@and1040]

It,s good, but why vibrato??

[@carmelazilioli4382]

PERCHE' LA STRADA SI IMPARA FACENDO.

[@ESilva-qv1uv]

Good rendition for today's standards. Impossible to compare with the great Normas of the past. The conductor is very cute, though.

[@henrifischer1119]

LOL

[@numetutelare]

Questa è una saggia critica... va bene oggi, ma nel passato avrebbe avuto parecchi problemi...

[@KZBPCCAIIK]

Где взяли этого "дирижера"? При таком исполнении - оно смотрится как школьник-мажор (сынок директора школы) ... А не дирижёр.

[@olexandrkostuchenko7112]

Что было из того и слепили, но я больше слушал чем смотрел и мне понравилось ,хотя лучше всего смотреть и слушать живьем .

[@olexandrkostuchenko7112]

Не сотвори себе кумира, я так себя на место ставлю, в общем по моей подготовке неплохо, но почему-то кажется что у Гаранчи все это получается лучше и голос и глубина звучания и артистизм.

[@user-vs9nc2xi6d]

Конкурентов у Монтсеррат Кабалье просто нет! Даже Каллас, по моему мнению не достигает уровня Кабалье.

[@olexandrkostuchenko7112]

@@user-vs9nc2xi6d так у Монсаррат " масса", объём", она , как ДУХОВОЙ ОРКЕСТР!!! Не спорю- она несравненна

[@operabilia]

Casta diva forse ..., Norma certamente no.

[@80Mrmirko]

Mamma mia quanto siamo caduti in basso, se questo rappresenta il top di quello che c’è in giro. Senza bisogno di scomodare paragoni con la Callas. Questa Toscanini non l’avrebbe presa neanche nel coro

[@nektoz5139]

кто исполнительница?

[@user-fy1ek5pt1y]

Кармен Джиннатазио.

[@flyingstar4316]

так петь нельзя .........

[@dmitrynikolenko5410]

Отчего же? Типа в каноны не вписывается?

[@user-ot3zc2ug7e]

Flying Star почему Вы так считаете?

[@user-ex3fq5mx8f]

Потому что все "великие критик",короче "языком молоть,не мешки ворочать"

[@VeronicaBellSoprano]

Уважаемый арт, Flying Star так считает по следующим причинам. во-первых, Casta Diva - это молитва. здесь все начинается очень хорошо, но к середине первой части певица начинает покрикивать, а во втором "куплете" вообще все очень громко. во-вторых, поет она широко и выбивается из дыхания слишком быстро, и голос из-за этого уже начинает качаться, хотя она молодая женщина. у певиц такое обычно начинается к 50-60 годам, да и то далеко не всегда. в-третьих, в колоратурах в конце первой части (в нисходящем пассаже) должны быть полутона, а она их не делает и спускается сразу на тон и потом добавляет ноту снизу. в-четверных, в конце арии она длинный пассаж пробегает, как будто спешит закончить арию, от чего остается много не пропетых нот. в общем создается впечатление неаккуратности. и дело здесь совсем не в том, что другие интерпретации таких великих, как Каллас, Кабалье или Сазерлэнд недопустимы, совсем нет. многие современные певицы поют Норму и делают это прекрасно и по-своему. Дело здесь в том, что у бельканте есть свои правила и свои стандарты, и когда к ним относятся без уважение, это режет слух. Кстати, все эти неприятные детали эта певица могла бы устранить, и я надеюсь она это сделает, поскольку голос у нее шикарный. и последнее: если с моим комментарием кто-то не согласится, пожалуйста не утруждайте себя руганью и оскорблениями в мой адрес; они меня абсолютно не волнуют, и я на них никогда не отвечаю, поскольку комментирую только тогда, когда знаю, о чем говорю. если у кого-то есть противоположное мнение, я с удовольствием поддержу деловую дискуссию в уважительном тоне. спасибо.

[@user-vv7qe3lq5q]

@@VeronicaBellSoprano Я делитант в этом но слушаю КАЛЛАС и мороз по затылку пробирает .. а в этом исполнении ничего не трогает... очень завидую по белому людям которые в подобных вещах разбираются и имеют безвпречный вкус и слух , а ведь сопрано , на мой , взгляд очень недурно., но не трогает.... Добра!

[@user-mn9ye3xj5z]

Повезло ей: у нее молодой дирижёр и ещё симпатичный..

[@carmelazilioli4382]

Sara' anche fortun se vuoi, ma la bravura nell'espressione vocale e' sua e pure i gorgheggi.

[@celibidache1000]

Depressed larynx and very wide vibrato combined with a jaw full of tensions.

[@dracopticon7788]

Well put!

[@dudeforcaster8630]

Oh goody, we have Netrebko impersonators now. Please stop the ride, I want to get off.

[@celibidache1000]

@@dudeforcaster8630 if only she had put as much focus on her singing technique as she seems to have put on her dress, makeup and hair...

[@dudeforcaster8630]

@@celibidache1000 Not very likely, although I can smell a new you tube genre, opera singer doing make up tutorials ...fierce...yasssss queen!

[@celibidache1000]

@@dudeforcaster8630 I'd probably watch that. Sounds fab. As long as they don't sing. 😎

[@bellini7verdi]

no esta mal...............pero le sigue faltando el dominio del poder para saber enfocarlo en cada nota.....................pero no esta mal........................

[@carlasecchi1093]

... Il cigolio di un carretto!

[@ransomcoates546]

Totally lacking in grace.

[@elenamahno6683]

Совсем не впечатлило, очень напряжённо.

[@giovannivacca984]

mai e poi mai paragonabile alla Casta Diva di Maria Callas 1958

[@babbonatale9362]

Cerchiamo di evitare il solito commento scontato. Eddai. Lo sappiamo tutti che la Callas era la Callas. Andiamo oltre su...

[@annascarpata7872]

Sempre il solito paragone con la Callas, sempre il solito commento.

[@eugeniogentili1048]

Sempre la Callas, dove le mettiamo la Tebaldi la Carteri, Boninsegna, Stella, Moffo, Rina Gigli, Flagstad, Caniglia, Lina Bruna Rasa, Scuderi, Steber, Zeani, Gencer.

[@user-ln9pk1bz5z]

D'une part, manque de la beauté mélodique, par rapport à Renée Flemming. D'autre part, manque de la profondeur par rapport à Sondra Radvanovsky. Bien entendu, elle pouvait chanter les autres répertoires manifiquement, mais en ce qui concerne L'interprétation de 'Casta Diva', depuis Maria Callas nous ne pouvons rencontré que quelques peu de chanteuses comme Fleming et Radvanovsky(malgré sa voix soit sombre) en tant qu'un vrai interprétateur de 'Casts Diva'. L'interprétation de Caballet n'est pas appropriée et celle de Sutherland non plus, etc. etc..... De nos jours c'est un vrai miracle de pouvoir entendre la belle interprétation de Renée Flemming !

[@numetutelare]

Bravo a vous...

[@alexgomez2]

Domanda: Chi é questa soprano?

[@Fede842]

+alexgomez2 è scritto nella descrizione

[@nicolehourcade]

alexgomez2 carmen giannastazio

[@carmelazilioli4382]

LA NUOVA MARIA CALLAS, SENZA PARAGONI.

[@eugeniogentili1048]

La nuova Callas... campa cavallo.

[@numetutelare]

@@carmelazilioli4382 Ma non dica sciocchezze... la prego

[@joannilson2900]

Carmen era una studentessa della grande Leyla Gencer- che era una Norma

[@joannilson2900]

Cioe una Norma squisita.

[@enzomodica]

CHE DELIZIA ASCOLTARLA

[@cliffgaither]

Man ! Opera is so tremendously expensive ! White-Tie & Tails ( chorus members / orchestra members. Evening Gowns ( chorus members / orchestra members. Conductor / Soloist. & they all have fees. & this is just a concert. It almost verges on the cheap & vulgar to be critical of their performance.

[@Lorenzo-be1nm]

This is La Fenice... can you imagine....

[@gustavmonger]

Nice voice but the Jean Harlow hair do lessens the dramatic impact.

[@canadianloon6433]

Medona

[@caninbar]

Sembra Christina Aguilera! LOL!

[@clearskye4381]

Out of place your moment".

[@fabiocasadeiturroni]

Ma è un mezzosoprano?

[@LaDivinaLover]

Lmfao she reminds me of Marlene Dietrich.

[@LaSopRAWna]

i don't care much for this.

[@gimmelmom]

She's flat a lot.

[@yoshiyyachben-moshe6890]

Joan Sutherland와 외모가 닮았는데... 키가 좀 작은 편이나 스핀토 소프라노 음색은 마리아 칼라스를 많이 닮은 것 같고... 어쨌든 전도가 유망한 성악가임은 틀림이 없다 하겠다.

[@artdanks]

Unimpressed. That's all I can say, without being rude.

[@steveegallo3384]

So what DOES "impress" you....aside from snorting jaio-jaio off the hips of Ukrainian strippers? I'm just sayin....

[@majzikviktor]

and you had to say...

[@celibidache1000]

@@steveegallo3384 I would be impressed if she had clear vowels, and a developed chest voice. I would be impressed if she didnt have tensions in her jaw, neck and shoulders. I would be impressed if her low notes weren't woofy and her high notes weren't pushed and shrill. I would be impressed if she could sing with a dark quality without depressing her larynx. I would be impressed if she had sung with great legato. Why are you impressed with her singing?

[@steveegallo3384]

@@celibidache1000 -- I discern your problem: You have deep knowledge, perhaps even understanding, of this kind of music, causing you to set the bar Too High. I, on the other hand, possess no such insight and therefor set the bar as low as my amateur standing allows. But if we were to discuss Rakhmaninov's 2nd Concerto, I could then hold forth with magisterial erudition and Periclean eloquence. [Greetings from San Agustinillo, Oaxaca]

[@celibidache1000]

@@steveegallo3384 Expecting an opera singer to be able to sing opera is the lowest possible setting of the bar. And in this I might possess more knowledge. But I'm sure you have more knowledge of Rachmsninov than I, and of so, I would not ever expect you to lower the bar, but I would expect myself to respect your knowledge and aspire to learn more from you.

[@rooitenen]

La voix est belle, mais l'interprètation est figée et pas sentie d'après moi.

[@benjaminespinosa9215]

Mamon

[@silviahildacanini8003]

Ma perché muove così la bocca? mah

[@arpeggio7240]

Sei scema? È una cantante lirica come dovrebbe muoverla?

[@bodiloto]

Arpeggio l'unico scemo vero qua sei tu visto come parli à questa Signora...

[@nektoz5139]

озвучьте исполнительницу

[@panikrystyna1]

płaczę.

[@user-gs4bg1iy1p]

Ужасно...

[@sigmaexperience7876]

Temevo peggio. Con quest'aria, il paragone con le top si impone, ma lei sembra reggere con coraggio, passando sopra alle imperfezioni nei calando ed in qualche acuto.

[@numetutelare]

E qualche slittata nella messa di voce e nella pulizia della linea di canto, ma sì, se la cava onorevolmente

[@bellini7verdi]

esta bien cantada...........pero solo bien............le falta la atmosfera.........vemos en los cuadros de velasquez.....o el sfumato en los de leonardo............a la voz le falta...........esa parte dimensional de la voz.........que se apodera de todo......................es lo que hecho de menos........legado del pasado...............que ya existe......y que parece hoy no se puede reproducir............cantar si se puede......pero....con el alma.........de quien tienen los genes....es algo mas dificil..............

[@raffaeledeangelis3942]

Mi auguro che stiate scherzando con i complimenti lodevoli... Con questa interpretazione possiamo dichiarare Norma morta anzitempo!!! Ma per favore, ascoltate Sutherland, Callas, Cabballe, Cerquetti e risparmiate questi supplizi a teatro!!!

[@rossellasantaniello5589]

Ma che palle

[@bodiloto]

Ma che palle ...

[@vincensmirra7521]

Secondo il tuo ragionamento non dovrebbe cantare più nessuno allora 😂

[@blustella6555]

@@vincensmirra7521 hai ragione certa gente si atteggia ad intenditori ma di.lirica ne sanno pochino .non si può parire sempre dalka callas e altre interpreti .il tempo passa e bisogna saper apprezzare altre voci altrimenti chiudiamo i teatri e tanti saluti .

[@irynafilippova5121]

Слушать ,но не смотреть.На высоких тонах громковато, резковато. Серьги ужасные.Здесь нужно что-то скромно--дорогое,нежное. Каллас пока никто не перепел

[@flyingstar4316]

это не моё

[@exposegel]

2:38 あのイボ痔、あのイボ痔、あぁあぁああ〜

[@mauricio1928]

CERTO

[@user-jw7zf9ye2q]

О ужас!!!

[@gerardmignon700]

Bof, juste passable. Il faut un autre format pour ce répertoire. Elle fait les notes, c'est déjà pas mal.

[@michaelewens6441]

very good but in my opinion this aria belongs to Renee Fleming

[@eduardooliverosanca4138]

For today poor standards, not bad. Well, opera is dead already, so why do I have to feel bad. People already and not only in opera have lost the sense of excellency. Callas, Caballe, Sutherland, Tebaldi. La Norma is a little bit to much for this lady. Sorry but I had to say it.

[@gimmelmom]

Her jaw moves too much, it's forced, and not natural.

[@terrance7220]

Lol

[@morganchan2465]

She have a little bit out of breath in some phrase end ~ Renee Flaming still the best and closest to Callas' perfection

[@mrlopez-pz7pu]

A little out of breath? Her breathing is bad all over, she is off key, and her diction is hilarious. Is Callas or Fleming your only references? Watch Caballé, Orange, 1974. The greatest i have ever seen live or on film. And Callas would agree.

[@zhizhi9138]

Poor

[@user-mc5uz2re6r]

Ну нет , Гарифуллина лучше.На мой взгляд.

[@olexandrkostuchenko7112]

А Гаранча ,хоть и мецо ,еще лучше, ну а Монсерат та вообще Орган ,я инструмент имел ввиду.

[@user-mc5uz2re6r]

@@olexandrkostuchenko7112 , а очень точно подмечено! Про Кабалье - басит .

[@giudiciadanna4550]

Cantare "Casta Diva" conciata da Jean Harlow anzi, da Sumi Jo ossigenata fai ridere i polli.

[@babbonatale9362]

È un abito da concerto... Se non l'avesse compreso

[@GIAMI180]

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣