《全民造星》EP 38 - 30強變20強

A3組及B3組完成表演，賽果塵埃落定。一眾導師苦被賽制所困，向製作組反建議增加入圍名額及交換方式，劉美君忍無可忍向製作組開火。最後淘汰名單邊緣人士公開，全場為之惋惜。
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
網絡平台 : viu.tv
IG: viutv
KZbin: bit.ly/2a8lbLu
App:
IOS-apple.co/2NJo9Iw
Andriod - bit.ly/2LCVG9U

[@kaaa13]

講真 B組嘅人才能多好多 偏偏要走10個😧🤯

[@holzerland]

In the memory of Ellen 一part 好感動，人生真的是個比賽，有跑得快有跑得慢，剛看過Mirror 2021年演唱會發現好多mirror 的成員在這個時候被foul 但真的如導師所說不等於他們不會在以後變得更成功站在大舞台上，相信到今天他們可以肯定這是可以發生的事實❤️希望姜B說香港的Mirror要衝出亞洲會好快實現！香港加油💪

[@MGWLUV]

我以前無睇過呢個節目唔明點解D人鍾意Lokman，睇咗幾集之後明白唒，佢真係好charm，有感染力❤️

[@creamcolouredponies]

Me too, only properly discovering Lokman now and understood why he's the captain of Mirror.

[@samanthatenkong994]

我終於明白，點解鏡仔錯仔，會時時刻刻咁感激花姐及Viu Tv全部工作人員。 多謝ViuTV製造左一班明星出黎。真係好好睇。

[@wendykw1336]

睇到呢度更加珍惜mirror 好多成員都喺30強被淘汰 也證明機會係留比有準備嘅人 所以今日佢地先可以發光發亮✨

[@creamcolouredponies]

Well said

[@carolinehall17]

唔明白劉美君有乜好抱怨對A組唔睇好就係唔公平，事實上B組係多啲有talent嘅隊員。而且A組嘅隊員都係導師自己揀嘅，又有乜好怨？

[@eggsplash]

佢抱怨team b輸打贏要，如果掉返轉要求就冇人會理team a

[@MikTes111]

真係接受吾到B組輸，同埋吾明點解狗毛會入，成組最吾鐘意係佢大把人好過佢。

[@blackldc0124]

啱呀,點解要畀狗毛入🙄

[@rinkeiji869]

私心覺得Dee gor/Anson Lo/Tiger 魅力大過狗毛囉～我想佢地三個任何一人留都好過狗毛😕不過唔知係咪d導師想留個音樂人呢🤔～～（但係嚴祺都唔差囉～～～起碼nice過狗毛）

[@mamasuju172]

所以狗毛冇得入Mirror囉，花姐識睇人品嘅..狗毛性格唔得

[@mamasuju172]

@@rinkeiji869 嚴祺係唱得好，但比較TVB feel嗰種，同外型較成熟，不過應該收歸入VIU成為正式歌手

[@kitwong55]

Anson Lo 同阿Dee 好過佢好多

[@crosstam2262]

得罪講句AL bb係少數跳得唱得又有魅力嘅人，點揀都佢先唔係狗毛啦⋯

[@mamasuju172]

揀狗毛都唔揀AL我都O哂咀，我唔係鏡粉，以賽論賽，AL絕對係5強人選。 所以片尾見到花姐攬住AL同而家咁捧佢，相信係為了補償呢個賽果.. By the way..睇完呢集，知道Ellen本身情緒有事，加上呢集佢嘅決定同comment令到B組輸同咁多大熱淘汰，佢可能更承受不少壓力，大會係咪應該暫時唔好搵佢做評審呢? 如果係可以時光倒流，她的結局可能會不一樣...好可惜

[@elizakwong169]

Totally agree

[@biglazyworm4841]

Still don't understand why ANSON LO is not in the list he DESERVES to be in TOP 20! Very angry about this.

[@SC-fv6tl]

Anson and ah Dee deserve it way more

[@holzerland]

That’s why Anson Lo is in Mirror now!

[@viviankuong6963]

賽制有問題 但花姐眼光沒毛病 仲好勁添 今時今日贏曬

[@Doraemonhandle]

賽制係要節目好睇為目標⋯⋯安順序foul可能令節目冇咁好睇

[@MsParklover]

還我Anson Lo，仲有Dee哥。好在教主今時今日已經赢返晒

[@carylee9101]

劉美君講得好好，導師嘅作用就係幫佢參賽者包好佢哋嘅短處而放大佢哋嘅長處。如果下下參賽者自己做，甘駛咩要你哋班導師。

[@Doraemonhandle]

火火同劉美君好厲害

[@VITTO54709]

The comments and attitude of these two instructors are incredibly bitter, condescending and mean.

[@theatog]

@@Doraemonhandle i love both of them so much. probably even more than most of the contestants lol.

[@mamasuju172]

揀狗毛都唔揀AL我都O哂咀，我唔係鏡粉，以賽論賽，AL絕對係5強人選。 所以片尾見到花姐攬住AL同而家咁捧佢，相信係為了補償呢個賽果.. By the way..睇完呢集，知道Ellen本身情緒有事，加上呢集佢嘅決定同comment令到B組輸同咁多大熱淘汰，佢可能更承受不少壓力。 如果係可以時光倒流，大會係咪應該暫時唔好搵佢做評審呢? 相信她的結局可能會不一樣...好可惜

[@SC-fv6tl]

如果肥仔同阿Dee我會覺得阿Dee更好，論唱功兩個差唔多一般，跳舞肥仔好勁但係阿Dee都勁，但係我覺得阿Dee更懂戲劇，有橋。然之後真心唔明點解狗毛會入，Anson Lo好好多囉，論Dancer唱功，兩個Anson係最高嘅，阿Dee又talented。講真，狗毛呢啲所謂出咗道咁耐都寂寂無聞，除咗可能冇資源冇平台冇人捧，自身原因都係好大因素，態度一般性格一般，作為出道歌手唱功都好一般，又唔合群，點解呀！！！Anson Lo 阿Dee deserve it way more！講真A組嘅勝利真係教出來噶，A組啱開始畀人感覺的確好雜牌軍，相比起B組有好多明星隊員，可惜。今次啲評判都唔錯，好過上次班蛋散。

[@romanma2556]

肥仔B隊隊內戰嗰時佢教舞好勁 雖則嗰時佢同dee都係carry，但肥仔佢係可以好明顯地transform到佢啲隊員，而dee只係arrange咗各人嘅長處一齊 如果我做導師我會好睇重呢點

[@mamasuju172]

講起上一批評判真係垃垃圾圾，特別係嗰隻爆炸龜導演同嗰隻TVB二打六咩趙乜洪，九唔搭八，Viu邊個諗請呢班人番嚟㗎?

[@ms818]

唱功真係肥仔好過dee哥。不過我全隊error, 我最鍾意dee哥。

[@ms818]

美君話Jer唔係好有drama? 佢之後提名香港電影金像獎最佳新人。

[@rosekwong1186]

不太滿意Eric commented on 姜濤只係靠 椽，不敢認同。睇第二次了，佢嘅努力，今天大家都有目共睹!

[@bbitsme7971]

最錯係俾狗毛入 20 強，係咪黐線？！😩😩😩

[@evadrummond8730]

I do agree! That’s mean he is not a professional! I after watched this show I hate hate hate him😡

[@evadrummond8730]

I do agree with you! Erik just say nonsense! He is not honest person, just in my point of view!

[@lumchung]

而家睇返都覺得好好睇！另一種感覺，Mirror你哋要加油，大家會為你哋集氣。

[@bonbonng7340]

The best is yet to come😭😭

[@evadrummond8730]

Why they keep Jayson instead of Anson Lou! They need glasses

[@user-mm9vg6zk1z]

其實劉美君講得好好

[@hinchunglee6154]

我是2021年8月才開始看「全民造星」，莫名其妙的比賽方法。

[@MsParklover]

超級唔公平嘅賽制，嬲到唔想睇下集。A组有好多唔值得留得，B组有好多完全唔應該走

[@bbitsme7971]

真係睇到眼火爆！😡😡😡 狗毛：何德何能？又唔合群！成個 team B，亞 Dee，Anson Lo，Alton，小評，Frankie ，Tiger ，連阿神都好過佢！班導師，尤其係 Eric Kwok，係咪傻㗎？😡😡😡

[@evadrummond8730]

For sure, Erik Kuok… he just say nonsense n really mean, he thinks he is the best. Tiger is.. Wauuuuuu!🤓🤩🥳

[@Fitfit1946]

姜濤真係唔係淨係靠樣！唱得又跳得！

[@karenng206]

係，點會淨係得個樣，佢明明唱得好好

[@CanCan-2023]

其實只睇姜濤一個，other peoples don’t care

[@evadrummond8730]

But Erik Kuok said is only his appearance! WTF… Erik go home lah …😡😡😡🤬🤬🤬🤬

[@TiggerCL]

Stanley個組原本係A1，30強個陣先變做A3，會唔會係A組導師既策略黎架？如果B3個陣都變做B1，話唔定會有唔同既結果:(

[@horlo977]

B組哩兩場失誤最多既薑b同唱唔準音既肥仔 真係希望佢哋唔會忘記哩一日

[@tracyhuang9847]

AL的才艺一流，为何舍弃，伤心伤心.

[@venuslau3156]

Team B 一手好牌，造星頭4名都在Team B!! 點解會落敗？我覺得Team B導師Eric Kwok 側田要負最大責任！！因為Team B最大失分位都在唱歌部份！Team B 導師只著重眼神，動作要整齊，反而忽略最重要的唱功，大部分唱功麻麻的隊員們一開聲，嘩！好似無train過咁嘅，Eric Kwok同側田train咗d咩，就係眼神，手勢同"電"d評判？！哼！真是不吐不快！反而，Team A 劉美君真係每個囝囝捉住不停train同練習佢哋每人唱個一兩句，每粒音都不會放過！出到嚟，全部隊員就算唱功麻麻的也没有任何錯誤，走音，感覺Team A全部唱功升喱咁！雖然Team B輸左我都好心痛，但隊員們已經好努力，努力也有回報！Support Mirror! Error!!

[@wd8740]

instead of 執唱功, 嘥時間去酒樓, 無training 去busking 幫Justin plug 新歌, 去train 問答, 編排唱得唔好的例如肥仔唱第一句, 跳舞唔叻的嚴祺一個 moonwalk etc. 應該反省的係 Tears B 的導師們, 成個 show 都對隊員無幫助

[@avleong6460]

劉美君老師，火火！

[@karenng206]

明明係B組既人好有talent .......都唔知點投票架........

[@romanma2556]

A1 B1 我睇就五十五十 A2 B2 真係創意carry咗，五個無咁勁都靠idea推赢咗，變相淨talent人數計B2係net -4地赢咗 (諗idea我個人睇係龍志權carry咗，但唔似之前肥仔carry成隊質素上升咁明顯同震憾) A3 B3 就唔洗講

[@pcKouji]

你睇返比賽結果，頭4都係B組嘅，就知30變20呢下出晒事

[@theatog]

投票 好難做. 但係format 唔make sense 囉. 10 個foul 哂落B 組 係錯既 決定. A 組唔少 廢人.

[@isabellashum9170]

依家聽火火講個句真係毛管戙 唔駛十年，五年都唔駛 呢度foul咗入面真係有4個上咗紅館做主角 而留低嘅依家已經唔知係邊 But then again再俾多十年都唔知會點了 大家都要加油

[@szeman0121]

prudence真係好好

[@evadrummond8730]

It’s true, but Erik Kuok, you WTF… go to Hell n get lost… ! Ok?! This is only means that you are not a professional but Justin is.

[@MGWLUV]

其實賽制可以係由蠃嗰組可以去搶另一組勁嗰D學員，咁唔係仲好睇咩？

[@Anthonysiu1]

其實成個節目由宣傳、剪接到最後播出已經有好明顯鋪路比b組嘅人去比大家認識，所以我覺得劉美君所講嘅偏心係真有其事，了解好多人都好鐘意呢一刻嘅Mirror，但係唔係你地嘅一個喜好就足以矇騙事實？

[@wingwinglau1157]

真係冇咗個比賽壓力，最後果十個人係最能enjoy 個表演過程，enjoy the show。 Lokman 比唔倒好深印象我係因為佢個身形，演唱，性格同氣質都catch唔倒我呀。我只係知佢跳舞勁，但跳舞勁嘅人真係不只Lokman一個。近li幾廿年香港仲有冇一個星好似郭富城咁吖？？？

[@creamcolouredponies]

Anson Lo is Aaron Kwok 2.0

[@horlo977]

劉美君講得好

[@bbitsme7971]

再講，Team A 導師覺得亞 Jer emotion平淡，缺 drama，見到宜家既「狂人 Jer」，係咪跌曬眼鏡？😂😂😂

[@ms818]

Jer提名電影金像獎最佳新人喎！

[@bbitsme7971]

@@ms818 唔係我放馬後砲，我睇阿 Jer 個「男排」嗰個殊嘜方丈已經知佢掂。最緊要就係佢貪玩冇偶包，扮乜似乜！👌👌👌 「男排」後佢好耐冇演戲等到我頸都長呢！「阿媽」之前我幾驚佢唔再做戲咁就真係嘥料喇！😩😩😩

[@ms818]

@@bbitsme7971 我睇薯嘜方丈覺得牙柳好生硬…… 睇阿媽我先信牙柳d戲真係唔錯！

[@bbitsme7971]

@@ms818 唔好搞錯，我唔係話柳柳喺「男排」嗰時既演技一等一，睇睇哩個訪問兒登頭兩分鐘點講阿 Jer 如何做準備功夫演出。Link 幾次都 link 唔到，你要自己搵：係「男排女將」「娛樂專訪」AL，Jer，Edan，Tiger am730片。 阿 Jer 有嗰份心思去設計角色，佢做啲托眼鏡小動作、小演技未必有人留意到，但作為新演員，係與生俱來既慧根同觸覺嚟既。嗰時佢仲未去上彭秀慧 acting class 呢！所以「阿媽」開頭根本柳柳冇去做 casting，彭導就係教過阿 Jer 諗起佢特別先叫佢去。當時阿 Jer 根本唔想拍戲呢！ 你留意吓佢唱「狂人」live，次次都有新元素加入，阿 Jer其實好努力，不過佢唔會攞出嚟吹咁解咋！佢入行以來啲角色演出次次都有新嘢冇乜重複㗎，留意吓？唔係個個新演員係咁正㗎囉！😁😁😁

[@fishuuuuu]

火火講得好岩～ 輸左都未係最後，若干年後你就係喺紅館開演唱會嗰個

[@ms818]

唔使若干年，開個人演唱會啦～ 唔係紅館，係博覽館呀！大家預備瘋狂搶飛啦！

[@ellyhui8395]

如果B3早d出嚟可能B組會贏

[@pamelakoo4476]

究竟點解要要留咁多B組 醜人多作怪 個節目究竟點睇落去 娛樂圈就係咁㗎啦 睇表演揀星就係睇overall 計埋個樣 唔係點賞心悅目啊 我放工得閒睇門口d大媽跳廣場舞一樣好有娛樂性啊 ViuTV好比多d心機係揀評委到

[@user-0947]

唔明狗毛點解會入 ANSON LO 好過狗毛好多

[@hinchunglee6154]

是否真是20強？

[@diyer1190]

阿dee入唔到？

[@MGWLUV]

好激氣！

[@fontanechu]

Anson Lo 出局令人對餘下集數完全無晒興趣

[@govyiu]

Rip Ellen 人生無常

[@ms818]

唔緊要啦～今日撈撈豬咁受歡迎，回頭一望，小事一樁嗟～ 大家都要預備搶撈撈豬演唱會門票咯！

[@evadrummond8730]

Prudence n 火火 … 🙏👏👏👏👏! Eric just say nonsense… never taught the contestants anything… poor guy!

[@jason38800]

Thats why even though group B had all the talents, they still lost because Eric doesn't teach them anything. Prudence is a true mentor, thats why Jer was crying (I would too).

[@evadrummond8730]

@@jason38800 I totally agree

[@jasminelai9459]

In fact, Anson Lo should be chosen instead of 狗毛

[@MarcusLau0104]

Also Dee and yimk

[@evadrummond8730]

It’s just because the stupid instructor..Erik… the hole show he was feeling sleepy n just attacked the people with talent! He is not a professional…????

[@lefrancaissimplement2433]

靚仔就冇實力咩 我又唔覺得姜濤冇實力 佢好有台型 Anson 都冇。。。

[@evadrummond8730]

I will keep Anson Lo instead of Kao Mou… lol… really I’m so glad Anson Lo is now in Mirror! I don’t understand why Eric said this to KT BB… don’t has talent, really stupid!🤬🤬😡😡

[@adayu1756]

Group B's teacher is not good... like all they care is winning and losing the competition... the real meaning of that show is not like this

[@eggsplash]

「11對11」邊個講㗎？做咩人地贏咗仲要為你班losers cut四個？