Vocal Coach Reacts to Park Hyo Shin「Wild Flowers」박효신 - 야생화｜國外聲樂老師點評 朴孝信《野花》パク・ヒョシン

Join this channel to get access to perks｜加入會員提前解鎖完整版影片:
/ @clubzeromedia
*Performance videos and instrumentals may have been censored due to copyright concerns. Please visit our Bilibili for full-versions of the reaction: space.bilibili...
Stayed tuned for more professional vocal coach reaction videos!
Follow Rozette on KZbin: @RozetteSaaangs
Follow Rozette on TikTok: / rozettesaaangs
Artist Booking: clubzeromedia....
#reaction #vocalcoach #reactionvideo #parkhyoshin #朴孝信 #해외감동사연 #해외반응 #해외네티즌반응 #해외댓글반응 #외국인반응 #한국해외반응 #해외감동사연 #중국반응 #박효신

[@emilychung9216]

There's a painful experience behind this song. Park always cries when he sings this song, and that's why there are pauses (emo😢) towards the end. I recommend to check out the MV of this song and you guys will know the differences.

[@almanini009]

@@emilychung9216 podrías compartirnos el link para ayudar a accesar a esa experiencia tan bella

[@emeychong7035]

one of best ballad singer in Korea,and this song written by himself and there are alot of hardship in his life before,that is why he is so emotional while performing this song🥹 love him and thank you

[@juneseghni]

You're missing so much here without knowing the artist and the backstory. Everyone in that audience will know the hard times he went through prior to this. He is South Korean musical royalty.

[@nunnie3995]

Omg Park Hyo Shin my forever vocal king 🎉❤

[@natsuplay8808]

We call him the captain ❤for a reason he is 44 years old now looking as beautiful as ever His voice technique are top tier

[@goldenlady1108]

W

[@goldenlady1108]

Please educate me with the "captain" reference of this incredible talent? TY

[@rjs722]

Park Hyo Shin is one of the best and most well known ballad singers in South Korea. The MV for this is very good. Brilliant songwriter. His is a very personal song. He wrote this while serving mandatory military service and after fighting with his record label who would blocked his music. Very emotional song for him.

[@juneseghni]

the pianist, Jung Jae Il, is his good friend and co composer of the song. They met in the military. Jung Jae Il also composed the film scores for Parasite, and Okja, and the TV drama Squid Game.

[@국민-bmw]

번역되어 보실지 모르겠지만 한국 가수인 박효신은 군ㆍ병역 생활중 소중했던 친구가 하늘나라로 간 소식을 듣고 깊은 슬픔을 겪고 이곡"야생화"에 그 마음을 담았습니다. 지금도 이곡을 부르는 공연을 할때면 그슬픔에 몰입되어 눈물을 흘리곤 한답니다. 공연에대한 열정과 만족감에 눈물을 흘리는것이 아님을 알아주셨으면 합니다. 그리고 공연장에 참여한 분들 역시 그 마음이 전달되어 함께 마음의 격정을 느끼고 눈물을 흘리는 것임을 아셔야 할것입니다.. 영상 올리신 분에게 필요한 것은 아무래도 올리신분 입장에서는 외국곡 이다보니 가사전달에 부족함이 있어 곡에 대한 이해가 부족했던 것이 아닐까합니다.. 후반부에 가수의 눈물과 관객의 눈물에 대한 해설을 듣고 너무 기술적인 접근에 취우친 영상이 아니었나 싶어 적었습니다.. 영상 잘보았습니다^^

[@Rex-pn1db]

야생화는 황량하고 척박한 환경 속에서도 아름다운 꽃을 피워내는 강인한 생명력을 상징하며 고난과 역경을 이겨내고 다시 일어서겠다는 의지를 빗대어 박효신 인생이 담긴 자작곡입니다. 알고 계신 정보는 잘못된 정보입니다.

[@raylin1153]

哇靠！終於來個韓國實力派 超愛朴孝信❤️

[@wongkokheng9453]

Wow, Park Hyo Shin, whose voice solo singing on stage live, was absolutely unique, amazing and emotional .....melody love sad songs.....he got such an impressive voice that expressed his sad vibes singing on stage live and the pianist playing together was an incredible with the songs lyrics ( playing) respectively.... Given Park Hyo Shin a massive applause! He was one of the greatest and the best vocalist singer in Seoul Korea long long time.👍👍👍👏👏👏💪💪💪🎊🎊🎊🎉🎉🎉🌟🌟🌟🙏🙏🙏♥️💖💝💕

[@yingsu0922]

He may have an idol’s face, but he is NOT a pop singer. He didn’t intend to be anyone else, he is himself.

[@emilychung9216]

Wow....my top notch Korean male vocalist ❤Thanks

[@HAHA-j5j]

a wonderful voice

[@Lizzied1301]

You are definitely missing a lot. He is also a musical artist. The lyrics, his technique, his vibrato, his tone..couldn't be better than this.

[@silverfang3072]

Looking foward to this one.

[@vygengoh6471]

You guys MUST listen to the original MV version of this song, it's said to be only made by performing acoustic piano and vocal sounds in a single long take. And it emphasize more of his technic and how great his is controlling his voice.😉

[@rytova_ar]

His song "Yearning" is another amazing one!

[@yuyu246]

Just some background, Park Hyoshin is a legendary vocalist in Korea, considered one of the best if not the best vocalist in the scene. This song is a vulnerable piece as it relates to some low points in his life and career when he went into lawsuit with his company. The "Wildflower" is essentially describing himself as he starts anew.

[@ssm0225]

한국인으로서 이 노래는 더 사랑받아야 마땅하다

[@sherrywang4591]

Many many thanks to this video! Park Hyo Shin is the best male singer in Korea❤❤❤

[@annmcconnell2099]

@@sherrywang4591 just Korea??? 😁 I think the best anywhere.

[@sherrywang4591]

@@annmcconnell2099 I haven't heard everywhere's male singers' voice, so I can't say that. But in South Korea, he is the best^^ No one like he can express so much deeply emotion and beautiful voice to this song. Rozette's reaction video maybe interrupt too many times, welcome everyone enjoy this complete one: kzbin.info/www/bejne/hanKmpyvgdVops0

[@JCear]

He is one of my favorite Korean artists. You are right; at that time, he had just finished his Korean Broadway show. Actually, he is not K-pop but a Solo Korean Artist. Korea has a lot of talented vocalists/solo artists outside K-pop, for example, IU, Sohyang, Lyn, Davichi, Baek Ji Young, Urban Zakapa, 4Men… I recommend Arirang by Sohyang

[@rafa.subeldia]

She already reviewed SoHyang kzbin.info/www/bejne/raireGSroNV-hpo

[@iamtd298]

I love this song. made me cry for days when I first encountered it years ago. Korean ballads tend to be melancholic.. it mostly about the lyrics... and the vulnerability. Korean ballads have a certain sound to them that kind of "requires" this style of singing haha :) it's what's expected - you guys are right. I think since you hear that he's such a capable singer that you start to want to expect him to go to a direction that's going to appeal to y'all? this song was most likely recommended bcoz of those pauses and the control he had even if he was really feeling very emotional already.. probably the fan that requested this wanted to see your take on a powerful singer that was willing to be so vulnerable (and brave) on stage. which y'all caught

[@queenaliao1027]

居然能看到評朴孝信的，太感動了，他真的是韓國歌壇頂流的歌手

[@kazenooinori]

他們評的是後製過的嗎？？？我不理解他們聽了這首歌不got touched 😂😂😂

[@queenaliao1027]

⁠@@kazenooinori可能是…沒有能夠去了解歌手背景的狀況下，他們又太專注在點評了，和一般觀眾的角度不太一樣吧，但即便如此，還是給予了朴孝信很高的評價了

[@jacobyang9858]

@@queenaliao1027 对的，是看的角度不一样，如果知道这首歌的创作背景可能就完全笑不出来了😂然后他们说的太拖的这个情况对于第一次听这首歌和这个版本的人确实可以理解，比原版还要慢，在还没接收到这首歌的情感的时候可能会进不去。但是真希望老师可以给一些除了风格以外的评价，让我们对朴孝信能有更多不同的理解~

[@christina76454]

Absolutely my favorite Korean artist, not sure if he count in Kpop, but he is so talented

[@MonicaLopez-sj5eo]

🥰🥰🥰 to Park Hyo Shin

[@epikh1gh536]

This song is about his hardship and struggles and also the death of his best friend getting to where he is now.

[@mjaquino1045]

My favorite song of all time. And im filipino' so the song is very foreign.

[@annmcconnell2099]

Listen with the music, he and the pianist play against each other

[@chow457]

Finally you guys made it

[@dragon.slayer..]

wow,这个好强

[@vbwiv]

yayyy thanks for reviewing park hyo shin haha yeah he does theatre work too. he might've gotten that vibrato from his trot singing habit (wikipedia says he sang the genre when young). trot always cracks me up - it's so entertaining you guys gotta hear it. perhaps check out bigbang's daesung's trot numbers someday😹

[@lapisstories]

Keep going. My favorite male vocalist

[@谭振宇]

re这首竟然反应这么平淡 这不比大陆那一票歌手强么

[@ihlee7982]

한국의 발라드는 한국인의 감수성과 정서를 이해 못한다면 다소 지루할수 있습니다 과거의 아픈기억에 저곡만 부르면 눈물을 보이곤 합니다

[@dxmas1127]

神来了啊啊啊啊

[@henry-kb1yj]

Many many thanks to this video! Park Hyo Shin is the best male singer in Korea

[@annmcconnell2099]

He has spasmodic dysphonia from overworked voice when he was young. His company overworked him. He's had to make accomodations to his singing.

[@trockwrites]

I wish she had heard Goodbye instead. His voice on that song is heartbreaking and beautiful.

[@cyanmin8270]

저는 한국인입니다. 이노래를 천번 이상 들었습니다. 멋진 영상을 보게되어 기쁘네요. 이 아름다운 노래를 모든이들이 들어보시길 바래봅니다. 😊

[@Cpsyg]

要澄清的是，他在高音下行部分的runs, 並不是混亂，而是一個arpeggio 的轉音，我曾經也誤以為他出了技術問題，而後我五體拜服

[@jacobyang9858]

这种叫arpeggio的转音和普通的转音有什么不同吗，网上给的解释是把一个和弦分开唱。我属于是每个字都看得懂但和在一起就不理解了😅

[@Cpsyg]

@jacobyang9858 如果平常歌手唱，會做BABAG的轉音，而他則B Bb A G# G

[@raylin1153]

再多一點朴孝信吧！！！！

[@방랑자-n5s]

한국의 평범한 관객들도 음악에 대해 본인들보다 딱히 수준이 낮지 않을듯 딱히 악기없이 목소리로만 감동시키는 가수가 지금 당신들 나라에 얼마나 있는지 궁금하다 그리고 bts가 없었다면 애초에 니네들은 이런 영상조차 보지 않았겠지 이게 너희들이 얼마나 문화적 착각에 빠져있는줄 알수 있다

[@normapuente1097]

Bravo!!!! Reaccionaste a uno de los mejores cantantes de Corea del Sur que yo conozca hasta hoy!!! Y bien dijiste: aprendió una buena técnica de cantar. Sabes, me recordó a dos excelentes cantantes (como él) de México: al señor Javier Solis, reacciona Granada, o la que gustes. Y al señor José José cantando en vivo en 1970 la canción El Triste. Ellos también tenían una técnica parecida a la del señor Park Hyo Shin. Te sugiero escuches cantar a Javier Solis en vivo con el micrófono arriba, no en su boca para que te des una idea de su maravillosa voz. Excelentes cantantes los tres, creo que la naturaleza los dotó con 4 pulmones, algo así.

[@arieskiz8481]

I think I recommended this singer and song before, but I just can't find the comment anymore.

[@chow457]

Maybe try this group Forestella nextime.

[@Cpsyg]

跪謝老師

[@uamysunshine6252]

TMI. . . The pianist of that song is pianist Jeong Jae-il, the music director of Squid Game and Parasite.

[@Pikaxsu]

I'm not sure if the pauses are counted or if he just needs a moment to collect himself from the overwhelming emotion.. He can't sing this song eyes open because he'll start crying too early to finnish the song. He absolutely wrote the song for his best friend whose life was cut too short.

[@jamesrawlins735]

He also wrote the song for himself - he was treated absolutely abysmally by his record company - they worked him so much that he was exhausted and felt that didn't actually value him.

[@JerisEve]

Where did the sound from piano go? This song is a duet between singer and piano.

[@黄世豪-k7n]

thank you

[@familyfriend7]

Here is a Korean girl group, Oh My Girl(OMG). They are amazing and their songs are very addictive and overwhelming. Once you hear their songs, they won't leave your head. They won the 2nd prize in Queendom, the Korean survival contest in 2019.(creative and solid vocalists) They are a girl group whom girl groups hope to resemble, and called a master of remakes and monsters of dance line formation. They are 6 members.[8(2015~), 7(2017~), 6(2022~)] - Hyojung : Leader, Lead Vocal, Belter - Seunghee: Lead Vocal, Belter, adlib, Delicate voice, D#7 - YooA : Vocal, Main Dancer, Unique voice, 3 solo albums - Yubin(old name is Binnie): Vocal, Soulful voice - Mimi : Rapper, Main Dancer - Arin : Vocal, Breathy voice * JinE left on October 30, 2017 for health reason, and JiHo left on May 9, 2022 with the termination of the contract. < 1.MV 2.Live 3.YooA's Dance 4.Etc > 0. Killing Voice (Hit song medley Live show_2024) kzbin.info/www/bejne/l16yYWWAr6lmq9Usi=35xbTGwEgur2RnA2 < 1. Oh My Girl's Music Video > 1) Secret Garden (2018) (Thanks to No.1 ranking of this song, they escaped disband.) kzbin.info/www/bejne/gqvRqWh3bMuBqtEsi=ZcK9yLJnnK8Ycoz2 2) Closer (Composed in CCM but bought by the company. Many foreign fans say this song is the best K-pop of K-pops. Constellation Choreography_refer to 4.Etc) kzbin.info/www/bejne/n6S4ppeKap2LnM0si=EFclp0glFmQPWnNw 3) Dun Dun Dance kzbin.info/www/bejne/fquym6qCbK6DldEsi=zMkLtCb2KQJIbda- 4) Nonstop kzbin.info/www/bejne/mXnNo59mf7uFn80si=wsXHLG3djGi5PYkR 5) Classified kzbin.info/www/bejne/jIHKXnuqdrqYiLMsi=zHu_0-PcBCt8CDM3 6) The Fifth Season kzbin.info/www/bejne/q5WqqJaXZq11g5Ysi=WCP80fl_pIQI1WsV 7) Remember Me(불꽃놀이) kzbin.info/www/bejne/iKPZlZ2vfrFjnKMsi=I7awgacNWeyqRWrT 8) Windy Day kzbin.info/www/bejne/d3vUmX6NpJ1sfLMsi=wu8co11ZrmVZ0MrS 9) Real Love kzbin.info/www/bejne/eIiuZ2iKi7-Sqq8si=89vzj8APPPqwKVMj 10) Summer Comes(여름이 들려) kzbin.info/www/bejne/nH_EfIarbJiqbJIsi=vUjwZR4EKeMStKRW 11) Dolphin kzbin.info/www/bejne/pZK1hYCggcmcetksi=tYBVua3lAwBwCL7u 12) Bungee(Fall in Love) kzbin.info/www/bejne/h4WnkKyimqh-b7ssi=f7J2MfzA8LPlG4ZJ 13) Cupid (Debut song in 2015) kzbin.info/www/bejne/nHTVdIisa9eEbassi=-ARFehwe2gMHEGaM 14) Liar Liar kzbin.info/www/bejne/gn-9fKSejaipa8Usi=f_ItSD-CN37J_f8V 15) Listen to My Word (A-ing) kzbin.info/www/bejne/lYiXlX9odttpgqcsi=a5hPh6r39enLJbfe 16) Coloring Book kzbin.info/www/bejne/bZTNi3mgjKeNf5Isi=0uQiaB2ctVCArjSu 17) Banhana-Banana Alergy Monkey kzbin.info/www/bejne/qIico5Jnrthlm8Usi=HGEi0VzPCAtiShHw 18) YooA-Bon Voyage(숲의 아이) kzbin.info/www/bejne/d3KygH6YoJKepK8si=KCgTgFzPWQIFiF2S 19) YooA-Selfish kzbin.info/www/bejne/f5nQhJSNg9Kffc0si=Enw69d_h8vjBX_nu 20) YooA-Rooftop kzbin.info/www/bejne/aoWVipSvatxro6csi=OSeAVn2jpiMAooPY < 2. Live > 1) Oh My Girl- Step by Step(2018) kzbin.info/www/bejne/Z5_PoIptebqcmK8si=DNlMN62YI9RIauke 2) Oh My Girl-Summer Comes(it's Live. 2023) kzbin.info/www/bejne/gZaUm2htp96Wesksi=hBqTc5anrscZCz4Z 3) Mimi x YooA-Checkmate(Good girl, survivor competition_2020) kzbin.info/www/bejne/qqW4i4ilar2Mm6Msi=TZHPppW51jx9CyXj 4) Oh My Girl-Time of Our Life (DAY6_한 페이지가 될 수 있게_vertical screen) kzbin.info/www/bejne/eKe3dpmPfd58gbcsi=iXoT5xwsZvQ98n7m 5) King of Masked Singer Compilation : Hyojung-HeeJae, Seunghee-Did you ever..., YooA-Rhinoceros, Yubin-Dip a face in tears kzbin.info/www/bejne/sJ28fHenhqtpasksi=Wyof02j-vgO4GFDB 6) Hyojung-Space(너는 내 세상이었어. Bol4) kzbin.info/www/bejne/gJzZpZp-adioY9Usi=Y2SKmbG-hvC6hUzH 7) Seunghee & Ko Yeong-yeol-Love Song kzbin.info/www/bejne/nIivc2B4e6ehiKcsi=wHCFJ_XH1kWVMe8R 8) Seunghee & Ko Yeong-yeol-Train to Chuncheon kzbin.info/www/bejne/oKW5eJZsiLyhhacsi=_IIj2fzHHnKXfRzu 9) YooA's dance-traffic O.T Genasis (Practice ver.) kzbin.info/www/bejne/ppLVgJmcfNCcfcUsi=pux-kfj0dsiifRii 10) Seunghee's LeeMuJin service (2023)-Summer Comes, Feeling Good(Michael Buble), Love me or Leave me(Day6), 200%(AKMU). kzbin.info/www/bejne/oHWnnX-Eptaan8Usi=sJmogxP213sLva8U 11) Yooa's LeeMuJin service (2022)-Selfish, Hype Boy(NewJeans), Better(BoA), Strawberry Moon(IU). kzbin.info/www/bejne/lWW6ZX6qfNGLecksi=h-wRPXKip0mNcooX 12) Mimi-A Purple Night kzbin.info/www/bejne/noSTcoKXir-Wj7ssi=f2CrVATxjgkeFT9a 13) Seunghee's 'Girl Spirit', a survival competition in 2016_[Dream Girl, A Goose's Dream, I don't know yet what love is, Love Rain, A Daring Woman, Cheer up, Michael Jackson Medley(I Want You Back, Billie Jean, Man in the Mirror), Acoustic medley(If you come into my heart, 첫 사랑니(Rum Pum Pum Pum), Abracadabra, Happiness, Russian Roulette)] kzbin.info/www/bejne/gmqkfXdnr7-CqMksi=CDFvnf7kSnk_w1Mk 14) (Fan cam)Oh My Girl-Liar Liar, Step by Step, Cupid, Closer(2016) kzbin.info/www/bejne/i3zScnSghbmcj5Ysi=IRVUrqcJe6sv1BFG 15) (Fan cam)Oh My Girl-Coloring Book, Step by Step(2017) kzbin.info/www/bejne/e57Vc5arZs-ZmJIsi=Mt9346xu1plwCsGm 16) Seunghee & Son Dongwoon-When would it be kzbin.info/www/bejne/gpCqoXqFepmbq68si=hEJA81ZiINdbZ31R 17) Seunghee & Sandeul(B1A4)-Companion(2016) (A sobbing girl is Seunghee's elder sister.) kzbin.info/www/bejne/iKHInpyLidinjc0si=LFE-hhyFcwR8V7sZ 18) Hyojung-Every Moment of You(song: 12:39~) kzbin.info/www/bejne/iGPXloije9aMfM0si=KAfJeU88t3_CHFrZ 19) Seunghee-All of me(John Legend) kzbin.info/www/bejne/iobaaZ6BeLxsjLssi=P8eoMrpy7fLIbT0O 20) Oh my girl's stage compilation (Time of Our Life, Let's Say Goodbye, Summer Comes, Traffic Light, Real love, Dolphin+Dun Dun Dance, Balloon, You're smiling like a doll but..., Sweet Eighteen) kzbin.info/www/bejne/eZnbZn2GhtKZrqMsi=8Mx_-Yxm8ANyFI8F 21) All about you(그대라는 시.Taeyeon) (Seunghee, YooA) kzbin.info/www/bejne/pnepgIOlaayHgZYsi=YhrH0fSsZpyobxxq (Hyojung) kzbin.info/www/bejne/iZy8qX6VbZ2hjZosi=EXpW9eWi-VYghEwL 22) Seunghee-Slow Motion (Karina) kzbin.info/www/bejne/qKiaeGWPasiegbcsi=L7ewHGluATdwFPfl 23) Ginkgo leaf vs Television(Seunghee)-Star(King of Masked Singer_2015) kzbin.info/www/bejne/iWWmp3VvbMuZjrMsi=A7KH7SrCYcwwmTmo 24) Aquarium & Zoo(Seunghee)-Early Bird Discount Theater Dating_2019 kzbin.info/www/bejne/epbVqKCjmdamoJosi=L-PjDzuZlBbDXY_5 25) Moon(Hyojung) vs Gold star-Decalcomania_2017 kzbin.info/www/bejne/pJ3IgWChqd51g9ksi=BgytZp6VJ_KRL17m 26) Seunghee, Hyojung-Village(Kim Hyunchul) kzbin.info/www/bejne/Z5PMY3iBaJlsmLcsi=s5JSEB3oSE4_HhQa 27) Seunghee & Han Heejun-I'll be free(Wouter Hamel) kzbin.info/www/bejne/hmiyl4Vtp5t7jJIsi=AIDX0uJqcdOgm_6z 28) Lee Juhyuk, Hyojung-Miracle(보통날의 기적.Stella Jang) kzbin.info/www/bejne/eqikeoeJepJ9hK8si=_rJ9dRu154YJbdXR 29) Hyojung, Yubin-Doll kzbin.info/www/bejne/pWa1fHewhdGjhtksi=5arFlYpn1m46IRvp 30) Hyojung's Begin Again Compilation-Love ing(열애중), Dolphin, Secret Garden, Even if I say I love you, Space(너는 내 세상이었어) kzbin.info/www/bejne/pXrHo4GVbM-Vp7ssi=jcxkXSuosjISvj5h 31) Seunghee-The Lonely Bloom Stands Alone. 시든 꽃에 물을 주듯(HYNN박혜원. Improvised cover) kzbin.info/www/bejne/g5vCkpeNZrJ5idksi=wI1F2UZfEueixohO 32) Hyojung-Only Then(그때 헤어지면 돼.Roy Kim) kzbin.info/www/bejne/a3PGhKunp9GIgrssi=3WrSc2nKTyLjcFZ6 33) Hyojung-Yeonan Pier kzbin.info/www/bejne/j3u7e5WOpNyJqbcsi=JLk5MJHT-NQX6q98 34) Hyojung, YooA, Seunghee-Hold My Hand(IU) kzbin.info/www/bejne/mHrCmoCLht-ans0si=NpO9cVCnjZ5eWCsJ - Hyojung-Hold My Hand kzbin.info/www/bejne/r36sm3yrlLGjZ7Msi=j2hB4H0uluI5G_GM

[@familyfriend7]

35) Hyojung-Love Always Run away kzbin.info/www/bejne/qZnSaWx3rpyWqacsi=A3r8vgUQdh7evcON 36) YooA-Mini Concert (it's Live.2022) (Blood Moon,Lay Low,Melody,Selfish,Bon Voage,Special Selfish) kzbin.info/www/bejne/apPXmHqkp7yAhK8si=Sjl6IURU0PxsnZFs 37) Hyojung-Lost Child(IU) kzbin.info/www/bejne/iZCxY554rL2Xq5Isi=i5Tknt2Z_LXK9Fhn 38) Hyojung-Shiny Star(밤하늘의 별을.KyoungSeo) kzbin.info/www/bejne/h3eQd5R_otSfrrcsi=mbvlyvtjh33M2hQU 39) YooA-Rocket to the Moon(Netflix animation 'Over the Moon' OST) kzbin.info/www/bejne/bZTXgnupoZJ4eNEsi=ZDqsyDJ5LCT3iHub 40) Hyojung-Always Behind You(바라만 본다remastered) kzbin.info/www/bejne/eaewYWNoqKeprbssi=yKevvTMbIUymxmWZ 41) Hyojung, Seunghee, YooA-halo(Beyonce_2015) (1) kzbin.info/www/bejne/g6CxlqWgobp-bNUsi=8NT124tWgBrd0Sd5 (2) kzbin.info/www/bejne/oGevi2yggMd8grssi=wQITbHY9lJkJwh-h 42) Yubin-On Rainy Days(feat. Mimi) kzbin.info/www/bejne/kKK4o5-YgtuJosUsi=0vET8LuEO7slakyI 43) Oh My Girl-Weekend (Taeyeon_2022) kzbin.info/www/bejne/n6LYmpp_nqerfpIsi=7lsvC2JSymmdzxC4 44) YooA-Eight(IU) kzbin.info/www/bejne/hJvUgXiEqdR5naMsi=Q219ayawzJiQTigA 45) Oh My Girl-Love Song(7 Princess) kzbin.info/www/bejne/m5eQY5d7iKeGpbssi=OzHbcar4gxuqd4vj 46) Yubin-Tears(내 눈물 모아) kzbin.info/www/bejne/n5K5eKFsppWqhbcsi=8sW2r9Ct4ktsphGD 47) YooA-Talk You Down(Charlotte Lawrence) kzbin.info/www/bejne/Z4bHeH-QbZx4oZosi=7AcJCk2RbZ9GxfxH 48) YooA-Just Friends(Audrey Mika) kzbin.info/www/bejne/eHaWZpdoe7iKjacsi=f8WwkFiTrHjOdAoQ 49) Hyojung & Wooseok-Aloha(Cho JungSeok) kzbin.info/www/bejne/eXzMfKGAhNVkmLMsi=3FiCWsScvtm76WBY 50) Mimi, YooA-Black Happiness(Yoon Mirae) kzbin.info/www/bejne/aIfWhJSLgs-MhJosi=mJI4x3i9j3JNr0zP 51) YooA(feat.Mimi)-Senorita kzbin.info/www/bejne/p2q0m3maqb5jia8si=6j5yFZBSAmYuBr_v 52) YooA-Rose(Lee Hi)_it's Live(2020) kzbin.info/www/bejne/Y2W7g52jZsl5f6ssi=k9yxcA0gNOPt1bSp 53) Hyojung-Secret Garden(Defensive match against a Song Stealer) kzbin.info/www/bejne/el6unIhvpcyKfdEsi=bXUl2iSp-0JAdZI5 54) Yoo Jaehwan, Hyojung-Like it(좋니 좋아) kzbin.info/www/bejne/mJ_bo36ri5qMY5osi=Wt3cQlXnKXGSX_6k 55) Yubin, Seunghee, Hyojung-Love Rain kzbin.info/www/bejne/rYnPd6p5rcqGf9Esi=AeUiV0YiRuLYSoVg 56) Seunghee, Hyojung-Father kzbin.info/www/bejne/jZiYhnVmaZmKbacsi=i59hUd9Zyr-zIUcZ 57) Hyojung, Seunghee-8282 kzbin.info/www/bejne/goGbpn-Kq6maoJosi=62raKF8UhSksuv8N 58) Hyojung-Distant Memories of You kzbin.info/www/bejne/fpPEgWOvfM52rNUsi=b5IC3eaPlEfl2kkj 59) Seunghee, YooA-The Moon of Seoul kzbin.info/www/bejne/mJSXcqiGaMh8baMsi=qzd73WaB28U-qSA5 60) Hyojung-Stupid Love(Kwon Jin Ah) kzbin.info/www/bejne/gH21cqZoZ6qjrs0si=y4d3REBjpHJ6ymy1 61) YooA-Price Tag(Jessie J) kzbin.info/www/bejne/eWPXmnecjsiioassi=D426CAwrYFmcV8u2 62) Hyojung-Beyond My Dream(Sunwoo Jung-A) kzbin.info/www/bejne/Z53XhoSLbMumlassi=X7L2gwIP4tsxXr0K 63) Hyojung-Drama(IU) kzbin.info/www/bejne/pJvQoIWafralgtksi=SFuYp2jD_L1c86P1 64) Hyojung-Good Bye(Wendy)+길(Lead the Way)(from "Raya and the Last Dragon" OST) kzbin.info/www/bejne/apzPe6B5nq-jjbcsi=t7kk_PQ6zgR-Pg3W 65) Hyojung-Christmas medley[All I Want for Christmas is You, First Snow, Mery Chri(メリクリ), Underneath the Tree] kzbin.info/www/bejne/oIjWcqOFi897j6ssi=5KOaFdUmQ_m-DDgA 66) Hyojung-If I have you only(Nerd connection) kzbin.info/www/bejne/e5uUpYefnshggNUsi=8rg1R8-XVTY4X7UN 67) UP+Seunghee, Mimi-Ppuyo ppuyo kzbin.info/www/bejne/pZqrfJ-Ka9imlZIsi=O_OSO0OfU_NSY_cN 68) UP+Seunghee, Mimi-Sea kzbin.info/www/bejne/jpLUooSpf8tlmNEsi=c43OUlsLY0tjvNEb 69) Seunghee-You Are(Drama 'Love Temperature' OST) kzbin.info/www/bejne/mYqZZXmtg9hgrZYsi=KAMJ3HMfez-4M_NV 70) Seunghee's Live Compilation(Just Short Introduction) kzbin.info/www/bejne/eWSxqYGMbZWbY5osi=R4m1IqddHSh7bLoK 71) Queendom(Survival contest_2019) (After this contest, they gained a lot of popularity.) (1) Secret Garden kzbin.info/www/bejne/bIm8qqRufrp-sJosi=BDGOSc3E53KUGM7R (2) Destiny(Lovelyz) kzbin.info/www/bejne/g3KlaoyOdrNrraMsi=5DI4BPPEoH3K_2KJ kzbin.info/www/bejne/pobOqaWLrKqKn5Isi=wWLn41R3F229qCjl (3) Twilight kzbin.info/www/bejne/ZqabZGptjtiFjpYsi=lYp5Sx5gu6y7lPDf kzbin.info/www/bejne/e6ispZRorL11oJYsi=XBxurURsDY9fsQNH (4) YooA's dance-Six Puzzle, Smooth Criminal kzbin.info/www/bejne/e2rOmal6m76Errssi=ZR3GKMSTH6FmFYXK kzbin.info/www/bejne/nWO9pp1rZcqFr6ssi=3c1Er3F1uxKfZqQz (5) Guerilla kzbin.info/www/bejne/rYewloGiabqZf6csi=78KtLHpG3RU_otw0 kzbin.info/www/bejne/g2m2qJKud752gq8si=UIBiQOvewqm1-Yiu (6) They were moved to tears in Queendom. kzbin.info/www/bejne/pqDFgnuDmM2IbMksi=5nkrJY1XuCG4qic6 < 3.YooA's Dance > 1) Lights Up(Harry Style) kzbin.info/www/bejne/l4uti3Wof5upZ5osi=YOl5ZUf8Op3ijkBw kzbin.info/www/bejne/ZoWzqXSeabWloLssi=avyEGGuFzobZFK8d 2) Sucker(Jonas Brothers) kzbin.info/www/bejne/Y5W4fqCkdtt7jZIsi=UiBso-e6rzmNtdDs 3) Michael Jackson's dance(Running man 2019) kzbin.info/www/bejne/ZmLdp4VsqtyjfZYsi=LKig9jOyS_nNospx 4) Traffic(O.T Genasis) kzbin.info/www/bejne/pZ3bZZaOq5ZjiKcsi=l_bb8GrRAaEPkYEo 5) Junsun Yoo&YooA-Keeping your head up kzbin.info/www/bejne/hJ6ro6Khja5of9Esi=mm3k_kJV9jeQFTEz kzbin.info/www/bejne/j4TOhIh3lKqEpJIsi=YDgdDGRNtefSiuHL 6) Abracadabra(Lucid dream자각몽_Black performance video) kzbin.info/www/bejne/eJ-womOuhpV6pbssi=DPFL_GUL0w4fEPW5 7) U-Kwon(dog) x YooA(cat)-Secret Day in Hit the Stage(2016) kzbin.info/www/bejne/sGSlgJmrhM6KmpIsi=gZPJnUUAzECkgT3F 8) YooA's dance compilation 1 kzbin.info/www/bejne/fWGZeGx8oNxgqassi=Et38wK64LwkBJYcU 9) YooA's dance compilation 2 kzbin.info/www/bejne/jpC3hJ-KarWfZrssi=8berTmIsmAWhD7_U 10) Shindong x YooA DancingIdol(2020) kzbin.info/www/bejne/jJ_QZqR_mpKmmtksi=rNQC2bPwY-Hexorw 11) YooA-Boy with Luv kzbin.info/www/bejne/Z3S7YX-bitR6h7csi=uGd7drpb_7RutMJ0 12) Running man dance compilation_3 (2019_feat.YooA, Jennie, Bora and Hyuna) kzbin.info/www/bejne/pYPXiKOara6pgtksi=wXbFBqYTVPKw3Yc2 < 4.Etc > 1) Here is Seunghee's whistle match in Knowing Brothers, a comic variety show. She even made ultrasonic sounds(D#7) beyond expectations. :*) She is very versatile. (1) kzbin.info/www/bejne/ip7LnJljdtSAasksi=t1cZguhPYYHh6nNq (2) kzbin.info/www/bejne/gqbYkqh6q7etarssi=0XyLGP8weyTRkVdn (3) kzbin.info/www/bejne/q4e7aapnr91saNEsi=l57GABEjbq1QufA9 2) Oh My Girl's "Closer" constellation choreography. (1) kzbin.info/www/bejne/faa1l2Oeraifo5Isi=deNlsA1xZJq-UikM (2) kzbin.info/www/bejne/sGjPq6dqr8l4hJIsi=BQ1sSsPTQDPLTucL (3) Closer choreography Top ver. kzbin.info/www/bejne/Y3zXo5aKd7J-p80si=q2QF6IAUXZqevKGs (4) The hidden meaning of Closer choreography. (Korean sub) kzbin.info/www/bejne/hWGmgnqerM6fqdUsi=AiAoLLMBqOMKWfr3 E.g. there is symmetry between YooA and Yubin. YooA is the only survivor. Yubin is a guide. Yubin can see YooA. But YooA can never see Yubin. Seunghee and Hyojung act as messengers between the two. Finally, YooA sees Yubin and meets the souls. 3) Oh My Girl-Heavenly(the 10th mini album ) kzbin.info/www/bejne/maiZnX1vmtmnobssi=NGeJCPvOQ9UztRhL 4) Idol Star Championship_400m Relay Final (2016) kzbin.info/www/bejne/rGqTn5KwaJ16mc0si=5TXVQ-odQHUf3H9b (2018) kzbin.info/www/bejne/ommpnmqZesmSr7ssi=qC0a1F8OUDFQU_Xc 5)(Comic) Ice Princess(Seunghee)+Olaf-In to the unknown kzbin.info/www/bejne/aqqmqZ2Iqtt1jM0si=Pw8bNl6VQHwcRTBv - The End -

[@rafa.subeldia]

heck yess

[@sammichung8498]

终于等到老师点评队长了❤

[@Dobby-o9u]

希望可以reaction太妍的歌曲

[@mackiesa3385]

Park hyo shin ❤ I hope u react jung dong ha - i miss you

[@starseven8680]

find park hyo shin sing live goodbye... it`s good......find...

[@pakkson]

You all don’t get it! He has an amazing voice!! Too critical

[@Rosannasfriend]

Love this reaction. Especially when you realized you were being “shitty”.

[@yingsu0922]

It is unfortunate that you used a version without music to do the reaction. The pianist is NOT of nobody, and the music is an integral part of the song or the story. I hope you could have done a bit research before recording your reaction. I agree with you that it was a shady reaction.

[@콜라-x4e]

They only removed the background music afterwards to avoid youtube copyright issues, if you checked their version uploaded on biliblili, you'll see. I don't think you can find a version without music on the internet.

[@Cpsyg]

技術性上，我認為祂勝林俊傑一籌

[@chunkitlee7364]

不只一籌吧?

[@lydiaapostol7890]

Pls let her see Winter ahead by V and Park hyo shin. Ty.

[@user-weiting-16]

希望有機會可以讓老師評論這兩位歌手的歌 Sam Kim-make up kzbin.info/www/bejne/d2Hcn6eNat-FnZosi=UjehzWAymw-9DoYc Kim bum soo-I miss you kzbin.info/www/bejne/jJ3bhYqepLV7nrssi=C_l2UMQ_OXpzddnE

[@鄭熙熙]

很喜歡他!這首歌的故事和歌手的經歷也非常讓人感動 不知道合不合頻道規矩想推薦另兩位韓國女歌手BEN和HYNN在killling voice的表現，想聽聽老師會如何分析她們聲音特質和發聲

[@Yuniverse7]

First of all thank you for the reaction. By the way, is it just me or I can’t hear the piano

[@miorandmior]

Funny how you say his voice is theatrical. After a very long hiatus , he returned to just do musical/theatre performances.

[@환희희열]

개인취향 차이겠지만 지루하고 별로다 표현보고 어이상실

[@pjqi48k3ei]

Every time I watch, both staff invisible here consistently prove how musically ordinary or ignorant they are. It's a relief that the host at least seems somewhat professional, a bit pretentious though. That singer is a top-tier male vocalist in Korea, and there are a few more singers like him. With their level of talent, they would undoubtedly be top-tier even in the global market. Just look at his breath control, vocal range, and emotional delivery, you poor amateurs.

[@jinayoung3008]

Is CZ Media China company?

[@carolechacha]

Thanks for picking up my comments and react to this song❤

[@낚시조아-j9f]

당신의 해석은 너무 잦은 멈춤과 리액션이 오히려 본인 자신과 우리도 그의 노래에 관한 감정과 몰입을 방해해 집중이 안되고 좋은 노래도 늘 구독또는 시청자로 하여금 그저 그런 노래로 들리게 만들어 버립니다.

[@maytay4702]

You have to listen to Hyoshin singing Winter Ahead (full Eng song) with V of BTS. He sounds very different and his vocals and V’s blend so well together. I would like to hear your comments. He has less vibrato in that song. Winter Ahead is jazz so it is less theatrical.

[@pagma3276]

가사를 안다면.. 그 지루함이 얼마나 잔잔한 핵폭탄을 가지고 지나가는 호흡인지 알텐데요...아깝네요. 한국어가 세계로 뻗어가는 일은 없을거에요.그 시적인 단어의 어감들...

[@edmondyung5231]

能出一集林宥嘉嗎？等了好久好久了😢😢😢😢

[@LEE_TAESICK]

뭔 듣보잡이 박효신 평가를 하고있네 ㅋㅋ

[@GeminiRan]

I love that you acknowledged you probably had a shitty reaction lol. I didn't look through the comments so I don't know but it could have been seen as offensive to some. It's all fair though, you don't know him, you don't know the song and it can't be expected for you to have the same emotional reaction.

[@라이오아즈]

솔직한 평가들이 감사하고 너무 흥미로워요, 음악의 스펙트럼은 다양하기 때문에 저또한 제가 자라온배경에서 들어온 음악이 아니라면 어색할 수 있을거같아요. 음악을 전공하는 사람으로서 다양한 음악을 듣고 시각을 넓혀 틀을깨려 노력하고 있습니다

[@Jadeee94]

More Korean singers please!

[@cyjune796]

竟然react了我的朴孝信！！！！！！！

[@athomenotavailable]

It's a song designed or arranged for flexing above everything else

[@jamesrawlins735]

No wonder So Hyang is one of the few singers that did justice when covering this song.

[@skyandghost]

@@jamesrawlins735 Hynn, Kyuhyun, Shin Yongjae and Kim Yeonji as well.

[@shinyiyang7858]

推一個韓國二代團的FT、CNblue～～希望有機會可以聽到這兩團的講評～～都是很有實力的韓國團體

[@paulinift]

still can’t understand that why u guys listen to someone singing without background music😅

[@deelee8003]

Am I the only one who can’t hear piano? Or is this how she listens to music? Weird just hearing his voice. It’s so much better with piano

[@BridgetClark-p7o]

Well, she’s obviously on my shit list.

[@augustuschao]

I believe Rozette will love to review this song by JJ and David Tao kzbin.info/www/bejne/jXi5dmWYnpmpn6csi=UR4B0k1-qcbEl6ja Also this song 李宗盛《山丘》is worthy to review. 2 live versions to choose kzbin.info/www/bejne/ZoHGYYepi56ihassi=u9Htg6lQDDFmrHRP kzbin.info/www/bejne/rIGzkJdua6x_nrssi=wyEO3qMNLus_DGv0

[@_bgcc]

第一遍主歌还在疑惑为什么声音听起来这么奇怪 原来是消音版 其实这种抒情歌本来伴奏就很少了还需要听消音吗😂听得有点难受

[@xXDaddyLongLegsXx-uk]

Please have a react to Taeyeon , her latest live clip of "Blur" is really amazing

[@nabilens7607]

와우 이렇게 평할 수도 있구나. 잘 봤습니다.

[@zhenli-i5j]

点评期河铉雨吧

[@goldenlady1108]

I understand she's a vocal coach but when you don't understand the audience culture and the way a particular singer sings a song they wrote and intent you can't provide a professional critique of that person's instrument "voice" technique, especially if you're not Korean.

[@xiaoyangwu9270]

为啥不选雪之华？ 活着他唱的怪盗一枝梅的主题曲啊……

[@vbwiv]

下次就是了，預告里有嘿嘿

[@Robert-b1v9b]

Hope can listen the song “still loving you” from 蘇見信 version

[@hildommar]

Yes..read the room!…. Read his demeanour, perhaps listen to the song WITH the accompanying instrumentation first! …then isolate his voice to complete your reaction. I will concede that you at least realised that it was a sh***y reaction. Off the mark in so many places. The piano was an integral part of that performance. He wrote and composed that piece.…that is what he ‘s known as …a solo singer songwriter. . It’s an emotional telling of his own story and he can tell it in whatever way he sees fit. Not according to some formula set by others. Thank God there are artists like these who don’t give a flying fig about what genre they should be sticking to, etc. Not all Korean artists operate in the pop genre….nor do they always aspire to. There are those who are mind-blowingly good at it, and others who are gifted in other areas. There are countless, amazing artists in that part of the world that so many in the west are missing out on, for so many reasons….some of them ridiculous. There are so many other genres that are interesting and captivating as well and the means whereby certain artists with certain abilities can express themselves more effectively. There is a S. Korean group Forestella, not a K-pop boyband…more like multi-genre crossover idols…who paid an amazing homage to Park Hyo Shin’s Wildflower in 2020, rearranging it for 4 different voices…their live performance is in fact how I discovered Park Hyo Shin in the first place. On paper their voices probably should not sound so good across multiple genres and languages…but they are brilliant nonetheless. They refused to be categorised into any one genre because they have an eclectic taste in music and genres and so have produced amazing performances across genres since their inception in 2017. Bohemian Rhapsody introduced them to international audiences, as did Lady Gaga’s Bad Romance in 2022 , their Despacito in 2023 was a party on stage. K-pop group EXO’s Mama 2022, a sample of BTS Fake Love at MAMA 2022 leading into their own SAVE OUR LIVES 2022..complete different genre again, like UTOPIA, 2022. FInd their Time in a Bottle in 2021…see what they did to that Jim Croce song! Or Scarborough Fair, or Queen ‘s Show Must Go On (as a trio because bass singer in military til May ‘25) Legends Never die (League of Legends theme ) and Lazenca Save Us. KOOL is unabashedly K-pop after a promise they made to fans to do a Kpop cover, but released an original instead. I’ve listed rock, rockopera, folk, reggaeton, ballad, popera, and for electro pop …Inner Universe and their heavier Stuck in a Maze. 🎉Do yourselves a favour and discover V and Park Hyo Shin’s collaboration in a song they just released yesterday called Winter Ahead. Not a Christmas song! And not a song you’ll normally expect to find on BillBoard, but so what.…I would not be surprised if it did happen. V does not make music with that in mind. Watch V’s Tiny Desk live performance of songs from his Layover album, before he entered the military last year. Learn to be more open-minded about what the rest of the world is listening to and wanting more of…and why artists some might write off as not having “ popular appeal” thrive and outlast some who bask in brief adoration. Many audiences around the globe don’t always care about how the music industry wants to label an artist or whether their favourite follows the ‘set’ rules of a genre etc or what’s declared as being current or popular…and many certainly don’t regard music, which has elements of being ‘theatrical’ or perhaps even jazzy, with disdain.

[@annmcconnell2099]

@@hildommar I prefer the version of Winter Ahead with V and Hyo Shin sitting at the table together. The other video is too distracting to the music with V's visuals. Love that V and Park Hyo Shin have become friends and I hope to collaborate again. Park Hyo Shin is my favorite vocalist. He's just amazing.

[@tookleleng]

Try to react to Sohyang’s and Min Woohyuk version. It’s amazing as well.

[@嗨大家今天過得好嗎]

Sohyang 素香也有唱過這首歌！！！

[@kenhuang7424]

朴孝信發聲方式在兵役前後有顯著改變，早期唱法常被認為是「韓國張宇」。

[@Js-px9pr]

怎樣時候有依純？

[@JosieDong]

Please react to EXO 'PAPER CUTS' live

[@jeungy706]

와. 이런 리액션 정말 오랜만이네요. 당신들의 솔직함에 감사드립니다. 정말 중요한 것은 그런 것이죠. 이 노래는 저도 지루하게 느껴져요. 사실 감상에 엄청난 에너지가 필요한 노래이고 편안하게 감상할 노래가 아니라서 저는 즐겨 듣지 않아요. 이것은 그의 자전적인 노래이고 그는 많은 시간 동안 고통스러운 삶을 살았어요. 저는 그의 노래 중에서 the dreamer를 추천드립니다. 당신들의 리액션에 대해 감사드립니다.

[@evacheong6390]

Taeyeon pleaseeee

[@조현수-d4k]

이영현 이란 가수를 찾아보시길~~~~