Vocal Coach & Songwriter React to Geoff Castellucci (VoicePlay) - The Hobbit | Reaction & Analysis

☕ Buy Us A Coffee: buymeacoffee.com/throga
🎬 Join The Reaction: throga.com/react
🎙 FREE Vocal Profile: throga.com/vocalgym
▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬
DESCRIPTION
Watch first-time reactions and expert analysis with Guinness World Record-breaking vocal coach, Richard Fink IV, and Billboard #1 songwriter, Johnny Cummings.
TIMESTAMPS
00:00 Introduction
02:12 Six Degrees of Geoff Castellucci
04:05 First time hearing Far Over The Misty Mountains Cold
07:19 Explaining Geoff Castellucci’s bass notes
09:43 Geoff Castellucci’s vocal technique
13:03 First time hearing I See Fire
15:55 Chord progression to I See Fire
19:30 Geoff Castellucci's vocal range
21:05 Reaction to Geoff Castellucci's voice
22:57 Shout out and challenge to Geoff Castellucci
23:47 “Prove me wrong”
SONG CREDITS
“Far Over The Misty Mountains Cold" was written by J.R.R Tolkien
• FAR OVER THE MISTY MOU...
"I See Fire" was written by Ed Sheeran
• I SEE FIRE - The Hobbi...
#geoffcastellucci #voiceplay #thehobbit #bass #reaction #vocalcoach #songwriter #thevocalgym

[@Throga]

THANK YOU for all of the comments and info on Geoff - especially those of you who made it to the end! LOL You are amazing!! We had a lot of fun reacting to this and we look forward to checking out more of VoicePlay and Geoff's music and fingers-crossed that we get to chat with Geoff directly one day :)

[@danielbrosky]

As it's October, you guys really should check out Geoff's GREAT Halloween-related videos : "Monster Mash" will leave you in stitches on the floor! (His wife's appearance and performance, too, is hysterical! - subtle, too, when he hits his lowest note!) , and "The Headless Horseman" is also great. He's done videos with VoicePlay on the classics from "The Nightmare Before Christmas", too! Made it to the end! PROVE ME WRONG

[@lifethoughtsdaily4402]

I don't know if you've heard the TNT BOYS when they are still young but can you please check their LISTEN on THE WORLDS BESTS or their performances on YOUR FACE SOUNDS FAMILIAR

[@Yukiko-Sun]

When will you again react to another performance of Dimash? I enjoyed very much your 1st reaction for SOS and wait eagerly for the next one! Thanks and best regards from Germany

[@lordqwertythepyromancer3458]

We need more!

[@leechowning2712]

Voiceplay just released their new halloween song and his will drop into yt over the weekend... and both are Geoff heavy. I actually gave in and got Patreon on both of their channels. It is well worth checking out.

[@kandacek63]

I can’t get enough of Geoff and Voiceplay, so when I find reactors that have never seen him or his solo work, I jump for Joy.

[@Gael4ce]

I love it when a new reactor first hears Geoff in his middle range and is like “ooooh he’s low!”. And I’ll be sitting there thinking “buckle up buttercup….”

[@DravenGal]

It gives me goosebumps when someone watches them for the first time!

[@thebullet7874]

Ditto. I agree !00%. It’s so much fun to watch their reactions

[@DravenGal]

@@thebullet7874And their jaws dropping!

[@stealthelf6439]

me too!

[@Backtotheviews]

In Voiceplay's "OOGIE BOOGIE MAN" Geoff throws the biggest vocal flex ever. Even if you guy's don't do a video on it. You both absolutely have to watch that video. 11 million people can't be wrong can they?

[@janetdw]

I also love that slide he does as Ursula in the little mermaid medley.

[@Backtotheviews]

"This poor unfortunate, Soooulllllll" Good call. I mean its incredible. These are octave slides. "Ain't no sunshine" Bass singer cover by Geoff Castellucci. Some wild slides in there too. @@janetdw

[@theanyktos]

I'm just gonna second the call for Oogie Boogie and Little Mermaid

[@joeb4142]

Nope.

[@draclaudiasilva4323]

Oogie boogie …pleaseeeeeee❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@PappaJon2009]

In his version of the Oogie Boogie song, He does a full 5 octaves in dropping steps at the end, it's seriously impressive

[@huldradraco]

nah, "only" 3.5 octaves in that drop. he has no single song where he displays his entire range like that.

[@Fyrebird721]

@@huldradraco ...little mermaid's slide from sky into the core?

[@huldradraco]

@@Fyrebird721 that's a D5 to D1 sub slide, and I think that D1 may have been layered in. So a 4 octave slide at best, but more likely a 3 octave slide with a layer. Still not a 5 octave slide, which I think would be pretty impossible anyway, as the strain of hitting the top notes would ruin any attempt of being relaxed enough for the struggle of hitting the bottom notes.

[@karenponchak5304]

​@@Fyrebird721Little Mermaid slide is three octaves (D5-D2) with a D1 sub layered on the end.

[@sianne79]

.....I will unashamedly admit that I used to be quite proud of my very aggressively contralto register and relished any opportunity I got to freak people out by slipping an A2 or G2 into whatever we were singing if there was even the slightest opportunity to do so....but I voluntarily hung up my hat the first time I heard Geoff covering this song. I can't even be jealous of it, either. This is the aural equivalent of 'if you've got it, flaunt it' and very many kudos.

[@Badger77722]

I've never seen a reaction channel do both Misty Mountains and I See Fire in the same video - that was really interesting! As for Geoff's high range - I think right now the highest note he's hit in a video is a Bb5 in one of VoicePlay's shorts (Peaches), where he's really taking a run at Eli's rock-tenor status. Geoff has said that when he was young, he really wanted to be a rock tenor, and (guessing here) then puberty hit. But he can still hit amazing high notes for someone with as naturally deep a voice as he has. Something that kind of gets overlooked a lot is Geoff's skill at arranging music. He did both of these pieces (he does all of the pieces on his solo channel), and he does about 1/2 of the arrangements for VoicePlay (Layne Stein, the beatboxer, does almost all of the others). That's one of the things I especially like about I See Fire, the arrangement is just so good, gradually adding instruments until the climax is reached. That high solo piano during the 2nd chorus is especially effective on me! Since you guys know Cesar, it's not impossible that Geoff might be willing to come on your channel. He's done interviews with Elizabeth Zharoff (The Charismatic Voice) and Peter Barber, so it's not completely out of the question. Geoff - Prove Me Wrong!

[@JohnGunn]

I feel like, not only does Geoff have a natural gift and crazy amounts of training...but the song choices he makes are so smart and work so well for him every time. It's just so good to listen to.

[@DTA-Music]

Prove me wrong! 1. VoicePlay did a cover of Baby, It's Cold Outside five years ago. I think that cuts a degree or two? 2. The Geoff "clones" are named Goff, Jeoph, and Jeff. Their fourth brother, Daryl, does not appear in this video, but is in some of his others. 3. Check out VP's cover of Oogie Boogie's song to be further amazed by Geoff's abilities!

[@kathrynmenzel2615]

Geoff says that he wanted to be a rock tenor but ended up a base. I think that is why he has retained access to high notes even while continually expanding his unearthly lower range. He is such a great example of practice makes perfect.

[@johndeeregreen4592]

Sort of. But his upper chest voice extends to B4 (one note from tenor high C5). This is purely genetic and very rare for a bass.

[@Backtotheviews]

He did say he wanted to be like Eli and be able to belt those gritty rock tenor belts. What's funny. Geoff doesn't believe he's a true bass and apparently Laine doesn't either. Geoff's words not mine.

[@johndeeregreen4592]

@@Backtotheviews, Geoff's resonance at E2 definitely says he's a true bass. Yes, many baritones can get to an E2, but it's weak and often barely suitable for a choir. No, Geoff is not a true LOW bass, basso, or anything like that. But in the real world of voice classification, he is definitely a true bass.

[@Backtotheviews]

Watch his interview with Peter Barber on KZbin. Geoff discussed that he thinks he's a low tenor. It's funny because the video is basically Peter trying to convince Geoff he's a bass. I thought he was joking but, Geoff seems very sincere in his answers.

[@johndeeregreen4592]

@@Backtotheviews, oh, I seen it. I think Geoff needs to talk to a music professor on the subject. I have a minor in music, I am a trained basso, have taught voice for over 25 years, so I know a thing or two about vocal range and voice classification. Geoff's baritone range is strong like a Hoher bass, but able to go deeper than one. Even a strong baritone doesn't have a G2 with Geoff's power. On no planet is Geoff a tenor of any sort. Even his 1st and 2nd passaggio belie that; you can clearly hear the changes in his voice.

[@johndeeregreen4592]

Geoff is definitely unique for a bass, in his ability to maintain chest voice up to B4, rise into a mixed voice above many tenors, while riding a riff back down into his chest voice above where most baritones sit in the top of their chest voice. Crazy flexibility.

[@carvingsnowdogs]

Prove me wrong! I'd love to see more of you reacting to Geoff, but also to Voiceplay. Because Eli when he can go full rock tenor is just music to my ears.

[@iamsquatty]

Geoff is a freak of nature in all the best ways possible 😂💜

[@sarinarice9800]

Geof did a cover of "Man of Constant Sorrow" which is from the movie "OH brother were aren't thou" so your "six degrees" could have been a lot simpler

[@Denalicat]

and Baby It's Cold Outside with VP

[@jacquelinejeffery3015]

also Home Free did Man of Constant Sorrow, and Geoff has helped Home Free with arrangements as they are friends from when they were both on The Sing Off.

[@amandabridget8706]

Prove me wrong. His version of 16 Tons is my all time favorite. He really owns those old classic story songs. Such a perfect tone for it. 💯

[@johnwatson2887]

My favorite Castellucci solo piece is Blackbird, which also shows of his range.

[@SlightlySusan]

I made it to the end. Geoff is amazing. He's also a pianist. His arrangements are fantastic. The other thing I love is the way Voice Play uses humor, which -- duh! -- must be why they call their group voice play.

[@ashcgincog5016]

This was so cool. Really glad you finally got round to reacting to Geoff solo. Loved the song choices. Hopefully you can get him on for a chat. I know he has with other reactors and sorry Johnny but he really does seem to be a super lovely & humble, likeable guy.

[@Throga]

haha we have heard nothing but great things about Geoff!! Fingers crossed we get to chat :)

[@ronsbrat525]

He is. He and Voiceplay are the type of guys you want to hang out with. All big goofballs. I'm on both their Patreons and the behind the scenes videos are hilarious.

[@valeriebottles1584]

Prove me wrong!! I'm thrilled to watch someone else simply appreciate this man's talent. If you watch others react, the thing that amazes me is how everyone is surprised by the joy of having heard Geoff sing. The smiles and delight on the reactors faces is as much fun to watch as listening to Geoff. This was by far, my favorite explaining video, although I love to watch Peter Barber 'splaing Geoff, he is enamored. Thanks for giving me a great channel to watch!

[@Broomrider1492]

I'm waiting to see if he does a song from the third movie. He's kept all the costumes. Fell down the Geoff Castellucci & VoicePlay rabbit hole a few years ago. Haven't been disappointed once with anything they have done. Still amazed that they do 98% of everything themselves. Arranging, filming, editing, lighting, costumes, building sets, or finding locations. Prove Me Wrong!

[@janeteitsworth8824]

If you want to see Geoff sing even higher watch voiceplay live Elvira. Great Reaction

[@00Jess_M]

Yes, that's a great one. And Toxic Audio performing "Grace Kelly" at LHP. Had to watch it twice to check if it's actually Geoff.

[@bjspeck4337]

Loved your reaction/analysis especially the spider web. Please do more Geoff/VoicePlay! When he worked at Disney and Universal he was usually pegged as a tenor, and back when he was in school he was certain he would be a tenor. In Enemy, he hit a A0 growl, in Halo a couple of B0s sub and in Valhalla Calling extended B0s again subs one for 14 seconds. His full chest is usually F#1 but I'm pretty sure he's done F1. His falsetto got extended to Bb5 in Peaches (SuperMario). What I love about his voice is the resonance and clarity, nothing muddy about him. He did an interview with Peter Barber and tried to convince him that he was really a baritone with some lower reach. Peter argued with him saying that just because he wasn't Glenn Miller didn't mean he wasn't a bass. That man was 1 in a billion. I would love to hear both of you interview him. I really enjoyed his most recent solo - Folsom Prison Blues. He doesn't have a bad one, really. Nor does VoicePlay. Both seem to be at the top of their game. Another you might enjoy picking apart is the Bass Gang who are in the middle of a 4 song drop - they just did Arabian Nights. Peter Barber, Tomi P and Bobby Bass (3 of the 4) had traveled to the Czech Republic and the 4th, Marwan lives in Egypt and was going to join them for Arabian Nights but couldn't get clearance on his visa so had to find a location for his part, camera crew, dancer, and set up communications with the group. He's 19 and I can't wait to see how he does as his voice matures. They also did the 2nd song, Be Prepared, done in a cave. They will be a force to be reckoned with.

[@musiclovingnurse2802]

If you haven’t seen Peter Hollens and Tim Faust from Home Free do this song, you should. Peter is a MASTER at layering his own voice in songs and really has a wonderful range!!

[@klevesmith]

I can't believe they haven't done any Home Free yet. They're every bit equal to PTX and Voiceplay in the acapella genre.

[@XerooM]

Thank you! I love acapella music. Now I have 2 subscriptions more! :)

[@simmerplayer2747]

I have been really enjoying your reactions to Voiceplay and Geoff Castellucci's solo music. I really enjoy reaction videos that teach me more about music and singing, i also enjoy how clearly you enjoy each others company and your joking together. Prove me wrong!

[@Throga]

Glad you like them!

[@Raven-ds5ow]

You should react to Oogie Boogie's Song by Voiceplay, it is great and mainly features geoffs range really well both his really high and really low range.

[@hwyla4416]

I'm going to ask you to also 'prove us wrong'. This particular video of Geoff's does have a bit of an ending that you guys didn't stay for. However, it is not really necessary for this song. You might want to keep listening yourselves all the while until the Patreon list comes up, as both Geoff & VoicePlay have been known to add interesting stuff then. When you get around to "Halo" and "Drunken Sailor" be positive to wait for the list. Just FYI, also - Geoff is the one playing the piano on his songs - as well as any plug-ins (like the guitar on "Folsom Prison Blues") Eli from VoicePlay (tenor) did the lighting for this video. He programs it and leaves it for Kathy (Geoff's wife & VP's production manager) to put in action. She also sometimes is the camera operator, but sometimes it is Layne (VP's beatboxer). And the first video ya'll did today was filmed at Layne's production studio, PattyCake. A great many of VP's & Geoff's videos are done there. Layne co-owns it with Tony Wakim, who was once VP's baritone. He left because he really preferred to be behind the scenes. That 'castle-look' is PattyCake's set for their own videos of "Villains' Lair". A bunch of Disney Villains all working together.

[@Throga]

hahaha Good to know!! We will watch past the Patrons next time for sure :) And thank you for the insight on the production as well.

[@sharonh.5768]

@@Throga Prove me wrong - BOTH videos were filmed at PattyCake Productions studio! Great reaction, guys! Hopefully you’ll get that interview with Geoff soon. I have three videos to suggest: 1. VoicePlay’s “Just Sing”, done during the pandemic. MUST WATCH WITH CAPTIONS ON! It features other singers they know, have worked with or would like to collaborate with (including Tim Foust from Home Free). The captions explain who everyone is, along with some fun details. 2. Geoff’s cover of “Way Down”, on his solo channel. It was also filmed at PattyCake, and shows Geoff’s mad talent and his sense of humor. Watch the outro - he also names his clones in this one using the most common mispronunciations and/or misspellings of his name. 3. Also on Geoff’s channel, “Hearing Loss - A True Story” about his wife Kathy. They wanted to raise awareness as well as let people know a few of the issues they ran into and some options that are available. Thanks again!

[@ilonadever8249]

I always watch to the end if I am being educated or entertained. Prove me wrong! Geoff has done interviews with the Charismatic Voice and Peter Barber, so maybe you can get him to come on. His vocal skills are obviously amazing, but his arrangements are phenomenal.

[@Throga]

Agreed!! Thank you for sticking with us!

[@ronsbrat525]

Yes. Since the beginning of this year he has added little thank you speeches. Usually with a little comedy. Also. At the end of his and Voiceplay videos they do a running list of their Patreons as a thank you to them. I'm not high enough to make it on the list but I'm very happy where I am. Because Voiceplay is independent they fund all their videos and accessories for the videos from the Patreons.

[@janetdw]

@@ronsbrat525 and we always remind reactors to wait until that list starts to roll before they shut off. Too many people miss all the little tidbits after they stop singing.

[@ronsbrat525]

@@janetdw Exactly. Wanted to put that but forgot after I wrote everything else 😂. My bad 😔.

[@janetdw]

@@ronsbrat525 When we are talking VoicePlay or Geoff, there is so much to say that it’s hard to remember or to type everything! 😆

[@joshuaebel7096]

If I am not mistaken the highest note that we have heard Geoff hit was in one of their shorts where they covered Peaches by Jack Black, and there Geoff hit an A5 which would put his range at B0-A5 if I am not mistaken

[@melissag1976]

It was an A#5/Bb5 (same note). His highest note used to be an A5. He also did an A0 growl in Enemy at the end. Don’t know if that counts though.

[@joshuaebel7096]

@@melissag1976 yess! that was what it was... It can be hard to remember all of the specifics lmao

[@Stan_S_Stanman]

probably doesn't count@@melissag1976 He briefly hits a Bb0 in subharmonics in his live snippet of Way Down on tiktok. I'd say that's slightly more countable than the A0 growl.

[@DougRayPhillips]

You could've gone less than 6 degrees. The Soggy Bottom Boys in "O Brother, Where Art Thou?" sang "Man of Constant Sorrow." And Geoff recorded it, too.

[@ronsbrat525]

Great reaction guys. Geoff has a 5+ octave range. He's been singing since the mid 90s when he was in the high school choir. He, Layne Stein (beatboxer, baritone) and 3 others founded Voiceplay in 1997 under the name <a href="#" class="seekto" data-time="242">4:2</a>: Five. They changed the name in 2012 to Voiceplay. Voiceplay is my favorite group and Geoff is my favorite singer. They all have amazing voices. Cesar has been with them for 2: years. I fell in love with him from the first video I saw him in.... Dragonborn Comes Skyrim. Both Geoff and Voiceplay released their Halloween videos on their Patreons Saturday. Both are fantastic. Both are Disney movie Villain songs. They should be released to KZbin in a week or two. The last videos they released.... Geoff.... Folsom Prison Blues. Voiceplay.... Drunken Sailor. Both have a bunch of Halloween videos to choose from. All are amazing.

[@dorisg.3]

definitely listen to 'Blackbird' by him, so wonderful!!! He's incredible, you just have to like him!! And of course voiceplay as well...good job guys 👍👍👍👍🫶🫶🫶❤

[@Stephanie-kh6nx]

I love how they are trying so hard to pin down Geoff's notes 😂. Just awesome! I ❤ it!! 🎵 They need to check out Geoff's Headless Horseman song and Voiceplay's Little Mermaid Medley where he sing's Poor Unfortunate Souls 😊

[@DKingXJ]

The thing I love and admire about Geoff is how he is able to hit those low notes while retaining the nimbleness and lightness of articulation and enunciation. So many times (myself included) when reaching for those lower notes, you may hit the note but you can't sing those notes if that makes sense. There is one bass singer on YT that hits stupid low notes but he has to sing so slowly that the song just sounds boring and lame. New subscriber here and really enjoying your videos! PS....Prove me wrong!

[@loritempleman2951]

This was a really informative reaction! Combining the two Hobbit videos in one reaction was a great choice. I do hope you get to chat with Geoff, particularly about his arranging. He also has written several new bridges for songs covered by Voiceplay, and at least one for his solo work that I can think of.

[@Throga]

Thank you so much!

[@TXDancingBuffalo]

Prove me wrong... Geoff Castellucci (and Voiceplay) are the bomb diggity. I'm glad you guys took the time to do a deep dive on these. They are impressive, as is Geoff's range.

[@tompeavy8254]

Oh I made it through the end and I bet Geoff on a video with you guys would be amazing. His videos with Charismatic Voice and Peter Barber were incredible.

[@shirleykarr560]

Prove me wrong. Simplify the six degrees... Eriq was in ER with George Clooney. George pretended to sing Man of Constant Sorrow in O Brother Where Art Thou. Geoff recently did a cover of MoCS. Geoff was blessed with a talent for sure, and has worked hard to develop it into something amazing. He's been singing professionally since he was 17, and friends with Layne, the heatboxer and co-founder with Geoff of VoicePlay, since middle school. And sometimes they still act like adolescent boys (says the mom of a 16-,year-old). Incredibly talented boys.

[@karingreen396]

I’m always so impressed with his range. Thanks for breaking it down

[@Throga]

You're very welcome!

[@DavideBaroni]

I stayed to the end, yet I had to pause it because of a phone call... But I resumed it as soon as the call ended and watched it to the end 🙂 Very interesting analysis. You should check Voiceplay's LIVE version of "Elvira", where Geoff hits his "falsetto" right at the end. . Anyway, again, I loved your analysis and sure enough I learned a lot (duh...). 🙂 See you next time!

[@Throga]

Thanks David!!

[@ashcgincog5016]

Agreed their live version of Elvira is definitely worth a reaction. Also, have you seen Voiceplays version of Peaches from the Mario movie. That really shows off Geoff’s higher range.

[@dianeschluter9995]

​@ashcgincog5016 yeah Geoff has an A5 in peaches. He asked Layne to have someone else do that note and Layne just said no.

[@dravaydesign]

@@dianeschluter9995 Sorry to correct you, but it's not A5, it's Bb5

[@EmileLN]

That piano part of "I see fire" sounded like that of "listen to your heart" by Rosette Who else noticed?😂

[@mikkifullerton]

Thanks for some good analysis portions of the video, always appreciate those! Geoff does have a couple of vocal tutorial videos he made a few years back in which he demonstrates some things like his range and some of the vocal techniques he uses. Perhaps you would enjoy those, or prove me wrong! 😉

[@Throga]

Thank you!

[@ilonadever8249]

Geoff has done a few shorts. Five of them are songs that he has not done as full covers. Some of them are goofy family things, pickle sandwiches, worms for the garden and makeing pizza. A couple of them were made as teasers, and the rest are live, no effects, just showing how he did those lines. Geoff does play the piano, he's done it in a few covers including the one that comes out on Saturday. You will love it, trust me!!

[@thewrenchreviews9986]

Geoff has a hobbtt follow up to this one with his cover of Ed Sheeran's "I see fire" from the second hobbit movie "The Desolation of Smaug" You gotta! And there are 7 Geoffs in his cover of Johnny Cash's "Folsom Prison Blues". Geoff has a 5 octave range, not including his sub harmonics.

[@chelliespider]

Prove me wrong, lol. For a great example of Geoff's head voice, I recommend "Headless Horseman," pun definitely intended. Great high notes, and it's perfect for spooky season.

[@philipmallonee5076]

For this time of year try him in Monster Mash or Headless Horseman (a Thrul Ravenscroft cover). For him in Voiceplay there's really a ton of stuff, but my favorite Geoff show piece is Oogie Boogie Song. Not only does he show astounding range and control in that but he sneaks in a background run that's pretty amazing as well.

[@thisismetoday7423]

Prove me wrong…. Coming to America is one of my favorite movies! And Geoff is one of my favorite singers! ❤

[@johnwatson2887]

I tend to avoid reaction channels with two reactors because often they seem to be competing with each other, or one putting the other down, or mindlessly agreeing with one another, etc. But you two work really well together AND have real expertise to contribute beyond just ”Oh wow, he's so great!” Thanks!

[@christineschutten248]

Geoff also sang the Christmas song Baby, It's Cold Outside with his group VoicePlay and guest Shoshana Bean.😊 I watched to the very end, which is something you have to do on Geoff and VoicePlay videos because sometimes they just throw something extra at the end! Geoff also did Man of Constant Sorrow from Oh Brother Where Art Thou. He even added his own bridge, at leat that's what i think it's called.😅

[@sheilatabone8186]

Prove me wrong. Jeff sings so beautifully.

[@martymiller9802]

I am most impressed by his arrangement abilities.

[@nedawilmhoff3599]

I love seeing voice professionals being just jaw dropped when listening to Geoff.

[@par500dragon7]

To see Geoff's real range, check out High and Dry and Blackbird. They were done early in the pandemic, so some of his first solos.

[@letheardaw]

Prove me wrong - Voiceplay has us trained to watch to the end! They sometimes include extra humorous / snarky bits / behind the scenes. Love you guys, that was great.

[@bjspeck4337]

Proved wrong. I'm still here. Another of Geoff's you might enjoy is Way Down (Elvis).

[@hwyla4416]

It really shows his sense of humor well! Be sure to wait till the VERY end on that one. Otherwise you'll miss a good joke.

[@jammiegirl74]

"Prove me wrong" lol. Great reaction guys! Hope Geoff comes on to chat. That would be epic! We love when he does interviews, which are too rare. 😊

[@klevesmith]

Great reaction guys. Geoff is truly amazing. There's another bass voice you guys need to check out. Tim Foust of Home Free, another acapella group. Tim and Geoff are good friends as well as all three groups (Voiceplay, PTX, and Home Free are.) Geoff has done an arrangement for Home Free (the 1 I know of is Home Free and the Oak Ridge Boys collaboration of "Elvira".). Avi Kaplan has performed with Home Free on Johnny Cash's "Ring of Fire". Prove me wrong.

[@vallynmar]

For really great/unusual arrangements by Geoff check out his versions of God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen and Man of Constant Sorrow (which lowers your 6 degrees of Geoff to two).

[@FLNatureGuy]

Prove me wrong! First time viewer. Great reaction with loads of information. Huge Geoff and Voiceplay fan. Looking forward to more Geoff and Throga. Loved Jack's Lament and Headless Horseman from Geoff.

[@Throga]

Welcome aboard!

[@rmdewberry2482]

Geoff's listenability is ridiculous! I never tire of his voice. A lot of people say listen to Blackbird or High and Dry, if you want to experience the most range-y covers (and I love those covers), but I think his voice is even better now than in those early days of his channel. I think Monster Mash and The Headless Horseman showcase some of his best high harmonies and would be a fun double feature for October. Hoist the Colors and Little Mermaid with VoicePlay have the best multiple octave slides. Oogie Boogie's final walk-down is, of course, a must. Can't wait to see where y'all end up next!

[@patriciaschuman4205]

Hey, of course I made it to the end. I stumbled upon VoicePlay almost two years ago when I came across a recommendation for their version of 'Eleanor Rigby' because I was exploring different arrangements for that song. And they just blew me away, even without Geoff going way down into the depths of his bass on that one. Never had any desire to join anyone's Patreon before, but I quickly became a member of VoicePlay's, Geoff's and PattyCake Productions' (run by VP beatboxer Layne Stein and former VP member Tony Wakim), and I have never regretted that for a second. I'll try to give a shout-out to you on this month's group chat with Geoff to see if he has heard or would like to consider your offer for an interview.

[@suzanneedwards5667]

Prove me Wrong.... 😉 Love your reactions and analysis.... your surprise and admiration for his talents is so genuine...The heck with misty mountains...I've got misty eyes .... (for me, he does that in nearly every performance!!!) Blessings to you both!

[@kaypease2260]

Prove me wrong! Great video- I love Geoff’s solo stuff as well as his voice play work. Amazing. :)

[@rameusvenin1984]

"Prove me wrong." Great reaction guys. Thank you.

[@lynnperdue1571]

I just recently discovered Geoff and can't get enough.

[@bjspeck4337]

When VoicePlay was doing the Super Mario Bros Peaches he hit Ab5 and in Enemy he hit a fairly quick A0 growl instead of his usual subharmonic. His B0s are extended for 14 seconds at the start and later ones are also extended. His full chest voice starts at F1. I have also heard that he is actually a big cat that curls up purring inside a cello! His version of Jack's Lament (Nightmare Before Christmas) is simply stunning. Love your diagram! Have you checked out Sound of Silence? In high school he wanted to be a high tenor, at Disney he did get to do some tenor work. All of VoicePlay members have worked at the Orlando theme parks. I have stayed. Geoff has chatted/interviewed with the Charismatic Voice and also Peter Barber.

[@audreybasaldua579]

Prove me wrong. I watched because you were reacting to Geoff, but I enjoyed your take on his mind-blowing vocal talent.

[@Stan_S_Stanman]

He has posted short live and unedited snippets of the first section of both of these songs on his social media His chest range ends at F#1, with morning voice. He has to switch into at subharmonics starting at F1.

[@johndeeregreen4592]

There is a lot of confusion among a lot of people who have seen Geoff using one technique but not the other at his lower chest voice. Because he does use subharmonics at G1 down sometimes... even though he has shown an F1 in full chest voice (normally an F#1 is his limit). Subharmonics are awesome for doing a quick octave drop within what is normally within chest range.

[@SunnyOutlook]

Love your reactions! I usually watch to the very end - prove me wrong.

[@lauriebarrett5683]

Need to watch all of Voiceplay videos and Geoff's videos. They are absolutely truly FANTASTIC! The production is done by Geoff he does just about everything on set. Drunken Sailor is sooooo good. Warriors is also good too! All of Geoff's music is AWESOME TOO!

[@EtherealForever]

Prove me wrong 😉. Hope you get Geoff on. I love Voiceplay's rock stuff - Seven Nation Army (White Stripes), Nothing Else Matters (Metallica) and In The Air Tonight (Phil Collins). I think someone else also mentioned this but the highest I've ever heard him sing is in the Peaches mini (Jack Black/Mario).

[@mythosmyths5670]

I came here because of Geoff analysis that I thoroughly enjoyed. I will return because of your intelligently entertaining way of approaching your topic.

[@akakscase]

Geoff has several videos explaining his techniques and exercises on his channel that you might find very interesting. He also did an interview with Elizabeth from Charismatic Voice where he demonstrates some of his subharmonic techniques to her. The crazy thing is as he has continued to sing low bass his chest voice range has expanded to where many of his previously exclusive subharmonic notes are now more chest voice/growls than true subharmonic technique. I think if he truly put his mind to it he could potentially reach into the negatives using a combination of all the techniques he has worked on over the last couple of decades. BTW: Geoff has blown subwoofers with his low notes during live performances.

[@joeysmith5086]

First time listener to your reaction. Your channel is super fun and very educational. As a long time follower of Geoff and Voiceplay, I really enjoyed watching the happy surprises of his exceptional range and where you give comparative analyses. The way you guys transition between movies and music sounds so much like me and my brother 😂. For your diagram, that was the coolest thing I've seen for vocal details and abilities. I myself, completely agreed with your comment of having a large range doesn't make you a good singer. I'm also the best example of that 😢😂. I can go almost as low as Geoff, but can go higher than him and even have some whistletone but can't control it to save my life. Think my range on your diagram being maxed out and the strength maybe halfway, with the rest nonexistent. Learning how to sing past the confines of my truck would be amazing lol. The vocal fry you mentioned and that vibration of the larynx, I have a lot of in my lower registers (D1-A1). Ultimately, you have a new sub and like and I can't wait to see you guys react to more of his and Voiceplays music! Watching VP reactions have become somewhat of a favorite pastime and am always excited to see people in shock even when they know all the singers and their abilities. "Prove me wrong" Thronelyfans... omfg😂

[@sharonleath1232]

Wonderful analysis of vocal abilities.

[@michaelkreller9149]

Awesome , thanks!!!

[@alexwalker8440]

Well, here it goes: "prove me wrong", aka, I stayed to the end 😊 No matter how many times I listen to Geoff and VoicePlay, it just amazes me more and more!

[@angelaryanrnbsn2764]

Made it to the end. Just discovered Geoff yesterday... and my 1st impression... yes... THAT RANGE! Great review!

[@Cpperk95]

BEST reaction ever and easy for me to understand. VP just release Hellfire today and Geoff shows off his upper range as well as the lower register. Thanks for helping us understand the quality beyond the visual oh and "prove me wrong"

[@DC-tm7ys]

I was watching a video and casually found Voiceplay. Loved their talent. Being a fan of low voices. Started to listen to Geoff. I have gone to music nirvana. Cesar is such a wonderful addition to VP. GOOD job guys.

[@karinwolf9639]

Love, love - LOVE your reactions to Geoff! Looking very much forward to more...very much more!!🎉😂❤ And made it to the end of course... 😊

[@alielebaev4003]

Thank you for reaction 👍🏻

[@reflexxuns767]

Fantastic reaction, guys. Really awesome. Prove me wrong When you listen to many VP videos, make sure YOU stay to the end and then some because often they add something funny or informative. Thank you!

[@kezmet5998]

I watched to the end, and your comment prompted me to recommend you do the same for Geoff and Voiceplays videos - at least until the patreon list! They'll often add an extra treat for us, so don't stop watching too early!

[@hollyryalsgrubb1273]

This analysis is top! thanks for the added information and discussion.

[@Throga]

Much appreciated!

[@NorthPhoenixActivist]

Geoff is a true phenomenon!

[@katthor7311]

Prove me wrong. One of my favorite comments ever is one of Geoff's how to sing low videos on his channel. Someone said that Geoff bought the whole piano, so he's going to use the whole piano. As others have pointed out, you got to Geoff Castellucci in 2 degrees as he has done a cover of Man of Constant Sorrow, but also in Degree 3, Voiceplay have done a cover of Baby, It's Cold Outside featuring Shoshana Bean. Geoff also only does one true subharmonic note in this piece. If you compare the Thorin version of himself to the Killi version, Thorin is using a technique to darken the sound of his voice to get that rumblier sound, but it's not subs. Killi is what Geoff sounds like without that technique to darken his voice. Peter Barber explains it way better than me.

[@draclaudiasilva4323]

Can’t wait for more Voiceplay…❤❤❤❤❤

[@shelleeroe7305]

I bet if you reach out to him he’ll be willing come on and do an interview. He’s done one with Peter Barber, Charismatic Voice, Tara Simon studio and bass singing central. I love that more and more people are finding him and Voiceplay. I found him after searching for a particular song Avi was in for Pentatonix….found Geoff and then through him found Voiceplay. I found them at a time when I was not only struggling creatively, but also suffering from depression, so doing daily tasks has been a real struggle. Music has been a key motivator and I’m finding the will to so much more than I used to….even finished my business logo in two weeks after listening to Voiceplay. I do hope you guys are able to do an interview with him. I’m totally there for that.

[@professorcarlosedmundomart2654]

¡ Gracias, gracias, GRACIAS !

[@hwyla4416]

And Richard - Thanks for your breakdown on the points for singing. That was really interesting and new info to me! I really enjoyed it!

[@Throga]

You're welcome! I'll have to do that more often :)

[@hwyla4416]

@@Throga GOOD! It's something I've never seen before and as a singer (VERY amateur, just for fun) I find it fascinating!

[@chubbyvixen8968]

"Prove me wrong!" cracked me up lol

[@MattPhizzle]

Prove me wrong lol. Love it guys! Would be so awesome to see Geoff on the channel!

[@camilemckitrick8783]

I wouldn't even consider exiting one of your videos early as they are so informative and entertaining. To hear some other amazing things Geoff can do with his lower register, I would suggest his newest release "Wicked Game".

[@craftykori9128]

"Prove me wrong." I did what you asked/said. I enjoyed your video...thank you so much. Geoff & VoicePlay are great singers.

[@Throga]

Thanks for listening!

[@silentbob6158]

LMAO!! You had me with "Soul Glow". 🤣🤣🤣

[@elizabethjennings9316]

Made it to the end!😂

[@rarelycares8416]

In VoicePlay's Pirates of the Caribbean cover "Hoist the Colors" Geoff does I believe a 3 octave one breath run in about 3 seconds, low to high. Very impressive...prove me wrong.

[@chrisfreeman1991]

I'd love to see you two react to Geoff singing High and Dry! It really shows his higher range

[@toddwright3619]

I would love to see you have an interview with Geoff. I am hopping that he will do it.

[@janetdw]

These are two of my favorites. Not only am I a Tolkien geek, but these are such beautiful pieces of music on their own. Add in his amazing range and tone and artistic interpretation and they’re winners. I really enjoyed the spider graph. I have zero musical training and I have a hard time interpreting into words what I’m hearing. now I have something to go back to when I’m trying to explain what I think I’m hearing. When I hear him sing I’m always reminded of the scene in Singing in the Rain. Kathleen Freeman, in her beautiful plummy British accent, is encouraging “round tones Miss Lamont round tones.” it’s such a rich full, and yes round, sound He is releasing his Halloween special this Saturday, October 7 (I’m late in viewing your reaction) and it is my favorite of the songs from Nightmare before Christmas. VoicePlay did four of those songs several years ago and I’m sure everybody will tell you to go check out Oogie boogie because that’s the first time he used a subharmonic in one of the videos. There’s an amazing multi octave slide at the very end. Speaking of the very end, we always tell everyone to watch the video until the Patreon roll starts because they frequently will add little Easter eggs just as you seem to do. So, you gained a new subscriber because you seem to know what you’re doing. 😊 Prove me wrong!

[@mathowle1109]

Vocal range examples for Geoff check out "High and Dry" and " Sound of Silence".

[@RWHansen]

Prove me wrong, lol! Great reaction!😆I hope you get to interview him. I would love to watch that.