Vocal Steam Inhaler Vs Nebulizer For Speaker and Singers

[@healthyvoicetips]

Thank you for watching! Do you use a steamer or a nebulizer for your voice? Let me know in the comments.

[@SamuelNovota]

Katarina H. Thank you very much for remembering my request :).

[@healthyvoicetips]

Hi @Samuel Novota, no problem. It is an interesting topic so I was curious myself. Have you been using steamer or nebulizer?

[@BOSSSMEDIATVLIBERIA]

Very informative. I just bought the Nebulizer and I also ordered for physiodose is it safe to use it with it? Also can i use just a plain water ?

[@louiserothman6566]

Do we need sterile saline water for steam inhalation?

[@TheOmega3Zone]

Never thought about the tools singers use to help their voice. Interesting topic. Thanks for sharing.

[@healthyvoicetips]

Thank you for stopping by!

[@TheOmega3Zone]

@@healthyvoicetips You're welcome.

[@jmttc2489]

@@healthyvoicetips is there any more tools singers use to get the most out of their voice?

[@tristan_840]

​@@jmttc2489 checkout singing straws

[@BerniceTaylorFitness]

Thank you for always sharing your great knowledge on taking care of your voice!

[@healthyvoicetips]

Thank you for stopping by!

[@ChangedWayz]

thinking of getting one of these!! have a good life!!

[@healthyvoicetips]

👍

[@TheFrostDuo]

Can we use bottled alkaline water? I tried mine for the first time today and I felt like I started having spasms

[@healthyvoicetips]

Alkaline water should be just fine. If you are worried when using the steamer, don't use it. If you want to try it again, think about it positively. Relax your body and muscles around the neck. Just the thought of spasms can create tension.

[@KishaWynter]

I am actually going to look into this more for my respiratory system in the winter here, to keep it from getting too dry!! Great video though, I need to use it for my voice as well for speaking engagements sometimes my throat gets very dry on stage

[@healthyvoicetips]

I definitely recommend steaming your voice during winter season. It's a drying season and your voice likes moist air. It does not matter if you do it the old fashioned way - steaming over a pot of boiling water, in the shower, steam room or with a personal steamer. They all work well.

[@defaultHandle1110]

Put in fresh colloidal silver and it cures COVID-19 (def not in a steamer though!)

[@treble473]

Your videos are always so informative. Thank you!

[@healthyvoicetips]

You are so welcome! Thank you for your kind words.

[@annalyvang8502]

I use steamer face then I out my mouth and face my lip dry to its works but I bought the nebulizer for travel to hand carry .Thank u

[@healthyvoicetips]

Good to hear. Do you like your nebulizer?

[@Sarah-sv5hh]

Love you Katarina, great video!!!

[@healthyvoicetips]

That is so sweet, Sarah!

[@DRCHRISTINANGUYEN_US]

This is a great video! Keep up the good work!

[@healthyvoicetips]

Thank you for your kind words!

[@dorotkaz1987]

I really like you, and how you talk about inhalars :) great video

[@healthyvoicetips]

Thank you!

[@jesusismysaviorjanet.8568]

Thank you so much for your information. I just bought one,and I wasn’t sure if is going to work. I’m happy it will,I get it for so low price..🙏🏻

[@healthyvoicetips]

How do you find it?

[@jesusismysaviorjanet.8568]

My voice coach recommended me one,but it was really expensive for me. And I found one in a thrift store for $4 American dollars,but it is different at the one my coach recommended me,but I bought it anyways,$4 dlrs.?? Is not much to loose in case works or not,compare with the original price. And I start to look for videos to see if is Going to work or not,and I found your video. 😊🙏🏻

[@MaxMiniTV]

Always so informative! Thanks!

[@healthyvoicetips]

Thank you for watching!

[@nalamusic7618]

Ji! thank you very much for touching this topic, so glad I could find information about it! I would like to use it on the go for gigs and traveling but from what it looks I'm looking for a steam inhaler that is small and cordless... like the best of both worlds, do you have some suggestions?

[@healthyvoicetips]

If you want a steamer, then Mypurmist has a cordless version too. If you are looking for a nebulizer, which is even more portable, then try VocalMist.

[@storytellernarrations4278]

I purchased the VocalMist nebulizer, and I've used it 4 times so far. And after EVERY use, my throat becomes a bit scratchy and then a bit sore, and my voice becomes more strained. I also use the MyPurMist personal steamer and get much more benefit from that. So, I guess the cool mist isn't good for me?

[@singerAR0406]

Interesting! I just used Vocalmist for the first time and my nose is BURNING!! I liked using the mouthpiece better. I still think I really love my old school warm steamer. I'm kinda bummed because I love the convenience of the Vocalmist. Sigh.....

[@healthyvoicetips]

Use what works for you. We are all different.

[@coloraturaMusic]

I was very disappointed at the VocalMist ... it gives you such a "miracle" vibe from the advertisement and it kinda made sense that it would probably be fantastic and it did nothing for me. Plus it was expensive! I'm gonna look for a steaner. MypurMist has a cordless one now.

[@thechristianmompreneur]

I've only used a nebuliser for my asthma as a child. Never thought of this or steaming for vocals! Very interesting

[@healthyvoicetips]

Using a nebulizer for your voice is a relatively new idea. Some voice users love it.

[@ryantheguitarist3678]

Have you ever heard of the brand Vocal Mist? I’m debating on testing them out, but I want to do more research first. They sell a portable nebulizer and their own formula that is a isotonic saline solution. From what I’ve read, isotonic saline is the best for vocals.

[@healthyvoicetips]

Yes, I know Vocal Mist. Well known brand. I don't think they have a saline solution that is different from any other saline solution. For nebulizers, only isotonic saline solutions are recommended. It does not matter what brand you are using.

[@coloraturaMusic]

Got the VocalMist, was expecting their miracle hydration and it did absolutely nothing. Very disappointed.

[@Zoesstuff]

Very informative video - thank you!

[@healthyvoicetips]

I am glad you found it informative. Do you use steamer or nebulizer?

[@Zoesstuff]

Katarina H. I use steam in a pot so no tech and very little cost! Those blue pots from amazon that have the face funnel thing on lol! Was looking for more info on a nebuliser and I think I would use both eventually as you say.

[@GilGaidola]

I'd like to try the steamer

[@CoachRonLyons]

Great video Katarina!

[@healthyvoicetips]

Thank you Ron!

[@craigmcgill7705]

Is the saline solution with sodium chloride?

[@healthyvoicetips]

Yes.

[@VictoriaAjadi]

I’ve used steaming a couple of times. Thanks for this

[@healthyvoicetips]

Great. How did you like it?

[@jackmacmusic]

Which one is better for healing vocal nodules?

[@healthyvoicetips]

Steamers and nebulizers help with hydration, they do not heal vocal nodules. I suggest you do some voice exercises and change vocal habits to heal them.

[@a.mejia24]

Miss Mabis is back on the U.S. Amazon store!

[@healthyvoicetips]

Glad to hear!

[@angweirdo7604]

Thank you so much 😊 I really need this.. Voice is tired of singing every night

[@healthyvoicetips]

😉

[@suryakaroshi9178]

Mem i learn singing And I have lunghs problem When I started the vaporiser steam I felt relax and comfortable with my voice and lungs So nebuliser is good for lungs Should I buy it 🙏

[@healthyvoicetips]

Everything that makes you feel more comfortable would be nice :)

[@alinowak2619]

Good information. Good to know.

[@healthyvoicetips]

I am glad to hear that!

[@DF13939]

I use them both, is it safe to use distilled water in my steamer?

[@healthyvoicetips]

It does not really matter if you use distilled or tap water for your steamer. For a nebulizer, you need the cleanest water possible (sterile).

[@RVersity]

I've always wondered about using these inhalers. More for a cold than singing :)

[@healthyvoicetips]

Yes, people use them to fight colds and infections of the respiratory system.

[@DeeBee2013]

Amazing review :-)

[@healthyvoicetips]

Thank you Dee, that is very kind of you!

[@maximus2275]

What if you put warm water? I mean.... we have been doing the regular water steam breathing for quite a long time, if you think of the typical pot with hot water and a towel over the head my grandma use to do for me... I think just addding warm water to the nebulizer will do the job just fine

[@healthyvoicetips]

I would follow the instructions of the specific nebulizer. If they say to use cold water, then use cold water. But breathing steam from a pot of boiled water will do too.

[@AC-pu2eh]

Which brand nebulizer to buy for singers ?

[@healthyvoicetips]

I don't think there is a specific one just for singers, but I recommend VocalMist because I have good experience with it.

[@AC-pu2eh]

@@healthyvoicetips is it normal to get a sore neck and throat after the first couple days of use? I used sterile saline solution with it and after 2 days my throat and neck are tender and seem a little swollen

[@ACLuz]

which saline should i use to warm my voice and where can i buy?

[@healthyvoicetips]

For the nebulizer, I would recommend sterile 0.9% isotonic saline water. Ask in your pharmacy or a drug store.

[@cathygracecatubay3207]

Hi mam is this steaming can help to cure the vocal nodules?

[@healthyvoicetips]

Steaming can help but will not heal it. Vocal nodules are a result of vocal trauma - overuse or misuse of your voice. You should focus on eliminating the cause of vocal nodules. Steaming will improve your overall vocal hygiene.

[@cathygracecatubay3207]

Katarina H. Thank you so much mam❤️❤️❤️

[@cathygracecatubay3207]

Katarina H. Mam further question I think I had an vocal nodules because everytime I use my falsetto registered in a vowel ah...I cant do IT mam that why ill take a break with my Daily exercise vocal warm UP...now my question mam is this Ginger can help the to cure the vocal nodules?

[@sharadsharma5692]

Steamer is the best👍

[@healthyvoicetips]

Agree!

[@zeldathomas5196]

Can you put the 0.9 isotonic solution in your steamer

[@healthyvoicetips]

Yes, you can but it's not necessary.

[@stephenhogg6154]

Katarina’s answer here is a little confusing, as she recommends using saline solution in the vid. If you put saline solution in your steamer, remember to put in in the front compartment (the one for essential oils, and the like).

[@buckets212]

In 2024, ithe Mabis machine is available on the US Amazon website at a price $39.99.

[@user-13Bps]

OK so what type of water do I need for the mabis ?

[@healthyvoicetips]

Tap water, nothing special.

[@CarolinaSeville]

Hmmmm I wonder will that work for my asthma too lol I didn’t realize this went into singing too!

[@healthyvoicetips]

Yes, the original use of nebulizers is for respiratory conditions like asthma. Talk to your doctor if you have asthma. But lately, nebulizers caught the attention of singers and voice users.

[@CarolinaSeville]

@@healthyvoicetips Good to know! I was told I had asthma in my early 20s so it wasn't something I've always had to deal with so still learning

[@nillopillo117]

steam can be use for carona .??

[@healthyvoicetips]

Steam will help with hydration but will not cure COVID-19.

[@stephenhogg6154]

The steam inhaler uses distilled water, whereas the nebuliser uses saline solution. This creates a dilemma.

[@healthyvoicetips]

What is your dilemma?

[@stephenhogg6154]

@@healthyvoicetips you identified it. Saline is preferable. As is heat. But the two don’t come together.

[@stephenhogg6154]

The Beurer SI40 Steam Inhaler information on Amazon is now recommending its use with saline. So, we can have heat and saline, the best of both worlds.

[@rebekahlovitt9540]

I have a nebulizer already and wanted to try it for this reason. I noticed that when I tried using it with distilled water, it made me feel like I was swallowing the wrong way every time I breathed in. Is this normal? Is there something I could do differently to get a better result?

[@healthyvoicetips]

I am not sure, Rebekah. I am wondering why you feel the need to swallow. Breathe in and out in a relaxed way, without swallowing. Can you do that?

[@rebekahlovitt9540]

Katarina H. I’m not swallowing. I’m just breathing. I just said that when I breath in, it feels like I’m inhaling water like when you swallow the wrong way. It made me cough.

[@BrunoRodrigues-ny4xm]

Hi, use of distiled water with a nebuliser is not advisable. Regards

[@rebekahlovitt9540]

Bruno Rodrigues what should I use, just plain water?

[@GedCartwright]

@@rebekahlovitt9540 Isotonic Saline 0.9%

[@olimdeasis2951]

Just personaly not for sure, i've found my voice singing on a good condition when on after my sauna or after using nebulizer on my medication.. Until i accidentally found this video😁

[@healthyvoicetips]

Yes, sauna is a great substitution for a nebulizer or steamer.

[@shawno66]

quality nebulizers are over $100 now in 2024

[@healthyvoicetips]

Yes, they are not cheap.

[@m.ritadjesus3317]

💐

[@healthyvoicetips]

🙏

[@angweirdo7604]

Thank you so much 😊 I really need this.. Voice is tired of singing every night

[@healthyvoicetips]

Steaming is a very effective way to reset your voice. Have you tried a laryngeal massage? Some singers love it too.

[@singerAR0406]

@@healthyvoicetips do you have more info on this?