文法懶人包：Relative clause加唔加comma？Which同that係咪一樣？幾時that唔可以用？

[@璃泫喵醬Aila]

多謝你，我小學六年級的，清楚了，期望能做一些練習。😊

[@vuke500]

芬尼你好！實在感激萬分！從此明白了介定與非介定子句的分別了，從前讀書時都不太明白兩者分別，尤其是有逗號與沒逗號來說明當中的含意是有分別的，故把介定子句理解為非介定子句；又把非介定子句理解為介定子句，簡直弄得一塌糊塗。到現才明白，原來最重要是要明白甚麼為介定和非介定的觀念是甚麼，即使以中文來理解都無礙的，不然在無法理解之下，再進一步去學「只有或大多數之中那唯有」的英文文法學習都是無濟於事.....雖然現在明白了，但已過了幾十個年頭了，可忍孰不可忍！無論如何十分感謝芬尼老師你啊！🙏🙏🙏

[@vuke500]

好正！👍👏

[@yukshuitin3400]

聽日考英文 但係我都係分唔清楚 relative clause 嘅comma 要加係邊度 同埋唔知道relative pronoun要加喺邊度 結果有人問出咗我嘅心聲！！

[@天朗高]

请问可不可以理解成，特指某一位的，就是non defining，谢谢

[@i_see1997]

解釋不盡理想，加油。

[@天朗高]

我买了一个杯，而那个杯是在巴黎买的 那个就是我在巴黎买的杯 我觉得没区别啊。。。

[@天朗高]

果个咪就系我系巴黎买噶杯 那个杯，“而”我系巴黎买噶 我觉得没什么区别…所以“而”我觉得很难作为判断标准，希望有更好的解决方法，谢谢您

[@haharay2010]

我覺得譯番做中文去判斷有冇defining feature唔係一個好方法, 有冇英語上點define佢係defining feature? 唔該🙏🙏

[@TiffanyTeachesEnglish]

係咁樣判斷㗎喇，你唔可以就咁睇一啲英文keyword就判斷一句係defining定non defining㗎，一定要用邏輯判斷一句句子嘅意思，唔係用中文，係用邏輯呀

[@天朗高]

我觉得 “而”，很难去解释defining或者non defining，有没有更好的办法呢，谢谢

[@lamphyllis6431]

Thanks a million !😘

[@manhongleong5895]

學了 超過十年 還未很懂，原來 是這樣。

[@XerxesAudio]

"Mr Chan, her neighbour, is very friendly.", written as apositive, flows better.

[@TiffanyTeachesEnglish]

Yes, but obviously, appositives can complicate what is the focus of the lesson here.

[@kwokl86741010]

@@TiffanyTeachesEnglish Shouldn't it be "what the focus of the lesson is here"? Just curious.

[@TiffanyTeachesEnglish]

@@kwokl86741010 Both can be acceptable in modern English, especially in informal contexts :)

[@kwokl86741010]

@@TiffanyTeachesEnglish I see. Thanks!

[@XerxesAudio]

@@kwokl86741010 "Apositives can complicated the focus of the lesson here."

[@chanzeno9119]

啲中文譯法係好夾硬，其實有d用法亦冇交代得清楚

[@TiffanyTeachesEnglish]

唔清楚喺邊度？

[@anniesiu]

咁用a有無分別? 如果都係想表示得一個細佬就: I have a brother, who lives in Toronto. 如果有好多細佬，但講其中一個就用: I have a brother who lives in Toronto.