Watching *Gilmore Girls'* Most Settled Episode

My Patreon: patreon.com/us...
Hire me for Voice over work: voices.com/profile/all-purpose
upwork.com/freelancers/~01b2f87f04c1302113?mp_source=share
Gilmore Girls Playlist: • Gilmore Girls
Thanks for watching.
#commentary #reaction #gilmoregirls

[@radhiadeedou8286]

Luke was insufferable in this episode

[@FirstNameLastName-wt5to]

Everyone is their worst self in this episode.

[@beautiful_black2007]

@@FirstNameLastName-wt5toLogan and Rory were not that bad, they were quite nice actually

[@gabzi27]

Just based on your comment I knew exactly what episode this was going to be before he said the title 😂

[@FirstNameLastName-wt5to]

@@beautiful_black2007 Rory with Logan is the worst Rory. Logan is a narcissist and they are often very charming people. It’s not what they do specifically here but the representation of who they are in general.

[@shelldie8523]

Unlike Lori who was insufferable stringing him along the whole show and abusing his kindness. And when she gets with him gets married decades later and never has a kid. Poor fking luke

[@RainingPouringSnoring]

Interestingly, the "kept" woman life actually suits Rory... the DAR, hosting, the bougie living.

[@Starbits7]

Lorelai's outburst didn't come out of nowhere. After months of Luke ignoring Lorelei & not including her in his life (with April) then calling off the wedding, Lorelei was upset. Plus, Luke at this point still never even introduced her to April. All he does for the first 2/3 of this episode is whine & tear down Logan who is actually trying to connect with him. Then after saying he's committed to Lorelei he can't even commit to a proper wedding or even tries to introduce her to his daughter. It's messed up.

[@shelldie8523]

How is this fair? When she asked for things to be right between her and Rory Luke waited. Patiently. When he asked for time with April lor give him ultimatums... How's about a little equality here?

[@cassie1560]

​​@@shelldie8523 you don't act like that in a partnership. NONE of that is okay and it is not how adults behave. Asking for a little time does not mean months and especially if she is supposed to become April's stepmother. Lorelai did nothing wrong here at all. She did other things wrong in lying and bad communication overall, but this is on Luke entirely.

[@plumdutchess]

​​@@cassie1560 I mean, shelldie8523 has a point. I always hated how Luke handled the April/Lorelai thing. But, he had to endure a lot from Lorelai. She has been back and forth and he waited. Luke is someone who is used to order and the April thing knocked him off his hinges. I'ts not out of character for him to act like this and want to deal with it for himself until he's used to it. Bad in a relationship? Sure. But that is how he is. If she can't handle it, they're not compatible. Saying "this is not how adults should act" presumes that every person is the same and is able to hanle things similarly. That's just not how life works.

[@m3ntyb]

Luke has already met Rory. It makes it seem more like he doesn't want April to get attached to someone who might not be there, in his case. The reasoning he does finally give makes a lot of sense though. ​@@shelldie8523

[@cassie1560]

@@plumdutchess "endure" ?? He needed over a decade to tell her how he felt and even then he could barely do it. I get the point, I just don' agree with it at all. And NO, it doesn't mean that everyone is the same, but Luke is not a teenager, he is an adult and he handled things wrong. All the way. From lying and not talking for MONTHS about his daughter, even though he was engaged and planned to spend the rest of his life with her, to just go and buy a house without telling her. You can simply not marry a person who doesn't communicate the most important things to you is what I am saying. There was no back and forth with Lorelai. He knew what he was in for, it just took him forever to come around and then he chickened out comletely and there is no excuse for it.

[@TheFeminineLinguist]

his pronunciation of vineyard is actually taking me out

[@lucileg.2935]

Love your predictions for the episode... "grandma fell off the stairs, good way to cap off the night" had me tearing up

[@radhiadeedou8286]

This might be an unpopular opinion but i feel like Rory becomes her own person with Logan, she's not Lorelei's mini me anymore

[@2029-jo]

But Lorelai never accepts that! She can't let Rory be her own person, look at how Lorelai mocked her for cooking, for example.

[@FirstNameLastName-wt5to]

Are you kidding? She’s just becoming Lorelei at a younger age. She’s repeating the exact same pattern. Logan is her Christopher.

[@valarielopez1055]

@@FirstNameLastName-wt5toLogan is not her Christopher

[@radhiadeedou8286]

@@FirstNameLastName-wt5to wrong, young Lorelei wanted to get away from the Gilmore world, she hated it. Rory loves it, she wants to be part of it and the only thing holding her back is Lorelei

[@CDG1228]

@@2029-jo It was teasing, not mocking. Like when Rory got arrested, Lorelei posted her mugshot, had their "prison" phone call, served her bread & water, etc. This is Lorelei's sense of humor. Has nothing to do with her not wanting Rory to be her own person. Rory is the one who couldn't handle being her own person. The first time she received REAL criticism she dropped out of college & dropped the career she's dreamed of for years. Being her own person would have been her working that much harder to prove his a** wrong. Dropping out just proved he was RIGHT.

[@TheFeminineLinguist]

"losing to a baby is crazy" is crazy 💀💀💀

[@Mr.Nyongo]

No no no no no. One of the most, if not the most HATED episode for a good reason. Luke should have fell off a cliff. He was terrible this episode.

[@TheFeminineLinguist]

"Luke should have fell off a cliff" is wild but also completely accurate

[@Mr.Nyongo]

@@TheFeminineLinguistHe was acting out after Lorlai found out about April and Luke basically called off the wedding. I was DONE.

[@karinatais]

The annoying thing is I LOVE Logan and Rory as a couple in this episode but Luke ruins the whole thing by being the absolute worst!

[@talesyuki]

Oooof, I forgot about that ending. Dayum. Poor Lorelai, this really wasn't her season xD

[@Justwatchingyoutubeforfun]

The chemistry between Luke and Lorelei in the beginning was so sweet and I was definitely rooting for them. I knew the show would take their time to put them together, but they took waaay too long that by the time they did get together I was kind of over it. Also, their relationship before they got together was soooo much better then when they did. It ruined it for me.

[@TeaWithMellow]

Request for Gilmore Girls episode "Happy Birthday, Baby" from season 3. Also, Blind watch request for the show "The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel" It's by the same creator, Amy Sherman Palladino, and it would be such a fun show to watch a blind watch of, lol.

[@TheFeminineLinguist]

I thought he did happy birthday baby. If not that definitely should be on the list!

[@dyskelia]

‘I’m not try a deal with that guy.’ So stressful even just watching that fight

[@buffysummers7887]

(Also her outburst did not come out of nowhere. Lorelai is walking on cutesey-keep-Luke-calm eggshells the entire episode before she snapped)

[@andreachaparro3742]

This episode is another proof that Logan is the perfect boyfriend for Rory. Adult Rory not Teen Rory

[@FirstNameLastName-wt5to]

I guess you didn’t watch the latest season.

[@andreachaparro3742]

@@FirstNameLastName-wt5to actually I did. And I still stand with what I said. If she had accepted his proposal they would still be together and happy IMHO

[@FirstNameLastName-wt5to]

@@andreachaparro3742 Logan is her Christopher. He’s selfish and manipulative. It’s a controlling relationship. She has daddy and abandonment issues. That’s why she stays with him.

[@andreachaparro3742]

@@FirstNameLastName-wt5to I don't see it that way. I see that he calls her on her bs and doesn't idolize her like her other bfs- at least until they ruin him in the special last season

[@FirstNameLastName-wt5to]

@@andreachaparro3742 He was always that way. You just fell for the narcissist’s tricks.

[@maegangibbons792]

Please never stop making these! ❤

[@notthemovie]

I'll try.

[@Bones1220]

I absolutely love watching these with you! 🦞🦞🦞

[@notthemovie]

I'm glad.

[@tracim3080]

Logan was really good in this episode but Luke was just a jerk He wasn’t even going to get his fiancé a Valentine’s Day gift

[@shelldie8523]

Yea, hes the guy who got Rory in trouble and landed her in jail as per what he knows. And luke warms up to Logan, when he gets to know him this episode.

[@cassie1560]

Luke would have probably done something romantic for her, he is not a good gift giver in monetary things, but he listens.

[@plumdutchess]

Not everyone does the "Valentine's" thing. She didn't expect anything, cause that's not how Luke is. He's a considering guy most of the time, which is more important than a gift one day out of the year.

[@ennuiblue4295]

do people say 'the house has kinks'? I thought they say it has it's 'quirks' 😂

[@jydakota95]

I suppose that depends what they mean when they say it. Id say that typically quirks are oddities but not necessarily problems where as Kinks are usually viewed as something that needs to be fixed hence the phrase “some kinks to work out”. Logan saying it’s a grandma so it has some kinks, to me, means that things in the house aren’t as intended anymore because of age, they’re broken or not functioning properly like the example of the hard wood buckling, that’s something they could and probably will at some point repair. Rory say’s peculiarities which is closer to a quirk in my opinion and perfectly describes the raccoon situation it’s a funny little oddity specific to this house but not necessarily something broken. Logan definitely says kink and it’s odd phrasing but still makes sense.

[@willtrifirst9957]

Whoa with the unexpected Christopher Cross tribute.

[@sylviefreeze]

Haha, right? Spontaneous yacht rock⛵

[@melinewaller1129]

This is hands down my least favorite episode, at least for the first 6 seasons. Season 7 least favorite is the Loralei and Christopher in Paris episode

[@TheFeminineLinguist]

Luke is a master projector and I hate him. This episode has me seething start to finish.

[@MusicIsMyAeroplane09]

Hey commenters, lets make a long list of everything that sucks about this episode, I'll start - - Luke, absolutely everything about him here - the insanely inaccurate weather portrayl of Martha's vineyard in Feb. - The cringey basketball game - Rory calling herself 'mama' and her insensitive cringe response to Bill

[@cassie1560]

- Mitchum Huntzberger's face, voice, behaviour, anything Mitchum - Rory acting partially like her grandmother, little entitled - Lorelai and Luke not getting married right there - The cringe massage at the gym

[@MusicIsMyAeroplane09]

@@cassie1560 ope I'm not gonna lie the Mitchum scene is the only scene I like in this ep 😬 I think they cast Logan's dad really well, I love the two of them yelling over each other, and idk, Mitchum doesn't actually seem like a villain here, Logan blew off his business plans and silenced his phone, his dad wanted him to grow tf up.

[@cassie1560]

​@@MusicIsMyAeroplane09it was cringe and terrible. It makes my list, but good for you to like it

[@karacatkara]

all the arguably homophobic jokes in that one scene. Luke never having had lobster (and like you said everything he's got going on in this one). The boredom of this episode and lack of side plots.

[@MusicIsMyAeroplane09]

@@karacatkara I almost listed all those things too! Have you listened to the podcast Gilmore Guys lol

[@stephylynnpatch]

Lorelei's burst did not come out of nowhere or came from Luke's nasty attitude

[@alvafairchild13]

No tap water no fireplace My man calm down city boy

[@jdp486]

Worst episode ever. Did a good job of showing how different Luke/Lorelai are from Rory/Logan, though.

[@Harrison_J_T]

Oh God I HATE this episode. Only episode I skip on rewatches, I just can't do it.

[@karamelfan]

I only watch the Rory's and Logan's scenes

[@plumdutchess]

Really? You watch the episode where Jess and Rory get into an accident and Lorelai acts like Jess single handedly strangled, delimbed and beheaded her precious little girl? Interesting.

[@Harrison_J_T]

@@plumdutchess not sure why you've taken offence to this or why you seem to think me watching the episode with the crash say sonething about me. I hate hiw she behaves in that moment too and how she speaks to Luke but not so much that I can't watch the episode. And Luke being shitty here bothers me a lot but I could stand it if that weren't the whole episode (or he had some actual motivation to be such a dick) but it more or less is (the few bits of Logan and Rory playing house is not enough to save this for me) The episode where the car crashes is not solely Lorelai freaking out and being shitty to Luke, that's one scene. Also, she has motivation and it's relevant to plot. Vineyard Valentine is about Luke being shitty because the writers needed to have him be shitty

[@cassie1560]

Yay, a new one already ❤❤❤ The suffering with this one though... 😅

[@cassie1560]

Only the entire 7 season Was worse

[@yennypoo]

please watch season 5 ep 18 🙏 paris, rory, and lane all have a good friendship episode it’s really interesting

[@HuntingViolets]

Why wouldn't you drink orange juice in the morning? A breakfast staple.

[@karacatkara]

Rory not drinking coffee with her breakfast is pretty weird though. par for the course for this weird episode I guess.

[@plumdutchess]

For who? I don't know anyone who drinks it.

[@user-hb2bw5hy7m]

I love this episode. Especially logan in this episode

[@Freebird805]

I always fast forward past the scene where Lorelei yells at Michel 😢 He’s sassy but that was too much

[@bellsduarte3707]

this episode is painful. I think 2 really good ones are "3x17 a tale of poes and fire", it shows a little bit of cycles ending for both Lorelai and Rory's, also lots of the town's people. Also, episode "4x14 the incredible sinking lorelais" has a different energy from most episodes that makes them feel a bit more grounded.

[@notthemovie]

I've seen the Incredible Sinking Lorelais episode already. Not sure when it'll move from Patreon to KZbin though.

[@lindseyswift3435]

OMG sing more Christopher Cross!!! I could listen to you sing that song all day ! 😉

[@teaembo3398]

wait i can't believe you haven't watched any episodes with Mitchem yet

[@buffysummers7887]

I can't watch the basketball scene EVER. I've watched the whole series at minimum once a year for who knows how long, and I skip it every time. It's too awkward & painful to watch

[@ericacarreiro9299]

I Love this episode so much.. but I hate how Luke's act. Lorelai was suffering with April's stuff.

[@plumdutchess]

I always hated how Luke handled the April thing. But at the same time, he is a man of order. He likes his predictable and simple life. The April thing knocked him off his hinges and he needed time to adjust. All Luke knows is that Logan was a bad influence on Rory. She got off track as soon as she met him. He got her arrested and let her drop out of Yale. At least, that's the extent of Luke's knowledge. It's fine that he's skeptical.

[@jshie20]

Do Gilmore Girls a Year in the Life Episode 1 pls !!!

[@hhhcubed2802]

The Lorelai Luke breakup was so stupid. Luke acted completely irrational leading up with keeping Lorelai and April apart, and then asks like a dick for no reason

[@Sahnn_bombss]

Can you do season 2 episode 4 “road trip to Harvard) it’s one of my favourite episodes!

[@theboringkaren]

Okay somehow I don't remember this episode and as a Logan hater, I thought he was fine in this ep?? I'm shocked haha.

[@karacatkara]

I know a Logan hater IRL and she's always surprised Logan has his share of episodes being a decent boyfriend lol

[@elliekelly3331]

Little comment for the algorhythm, onto 10k subscribers soon!

[@tbonemalone3407]

This episode is one of Luke’s worst episodes. Season six is probably my least favorite.

[@cutienerdgirl]

13:11 Party rice? Are you West African or Caribbean?

[@notthemovie]

West side

[@MusicIsMyAeroplane09]

Oh nooooo the worst episode (should change your title to that)

[@notthemovie]

Funny, I was just thinking about finding the show's worst episode. I didn't know I already had.

[@Shininglight1984]

I love this episode

[@DoreYaya]

You gotta do another teen wolf episode!!

[@notthemovie]

I cannot, sorry. MTV won't allow it.

[@marlenaeva3813]

Huntzberger is terrible as a father, I'd take his money and leave, too. Ha ha. Imagine growing up with him OMG

[@starcie2.0]

You should react to Dawson creek

[@notthemovie]

I have once.

[@ClaireHookham]

Everyone hates this episode, don’t they? Urgh.

[@elliekelly3331]

Wait, you haven't been to the beach until 13? Is that a US thing?

[@notthemovie]

Never lived near one until then.

[@elliekelly3331]

@@notthemovie Oh no, never thought of that as a spoiled european- we're never far from a beach luckily!

[@Mondeskind]

Funny, i watched this one yesterday. I hate that season, it fells so off..

[@princessbuttercup482]

You're Nigerian?? Hi!! 🤗🫂💕

[@notthemovie]

Yes.

[@theinvisibleme4104]

Why is Luke being such an asshole?

[@Angelscon]

What time are people supposed to drink orange juice?? 😅 Also, “out of nowhere” 🤨?????

[@plumdutchess]

Anytime they want. If they even want to.

[@notthemovie]

Just seemed unlike her, I mean.

[@RoPiDe]

I hate this episode, for me it is THE WORST of the entire show, but is the main example why i hate stupid fake holidays like valentine's day: Luke finds it absurd but is willing to go just to please her girlfriend, she was fine without that nonsense but got pressured by Rory and societal bullshit. He's uncomfortable the whole time and instead of helping her, Lorelai just teases him. And at the end he was kinda proved right, they were in that beach house with some rich insufferable kid who didn't even had permission to be there from the very beginning...

[@jdp486]

It's not about the holiday. He's a man child who just found out he has a child of his own. He's pushing Lorelei away every chance he gets.

[@HuntingViolets]

He agreed to go. He should have not gone if he only wanted to complain about everything every minute.

[@heidihernandez2771]

He's not wrong. It's absolutely not spelled viñurd.

[@HuntingViolets]

He said it like viñurd after the first time, I think. Once he found out it was Martha's.

[@heidihernandez2771]

@@HuntingViolets I was hoping he would keep it. I'm certainly gonna say it like that now, it's too good hahaha