We Ranked Every Assassin's Creed from WORST to BEST

[@PerkaSet]

I love how every single comment is a different opinion. Really makes for an interesting read. Keep them coming!! Thanks guys :) - Jason

[@IgorBozoki1989]

1. Assassin's Creed 2 2. Assassin's Creed Brotherhood 3. Assassin's Creed Revelations 4. Assassin's Creed 1 5. Assassin's Creed 3 6. Assassin's Creed 4 Black Flag 7. Assassin's Creed Rogue 8. Assassin's Creed Liberation 9. Assassin's Creed Unity 10. Assassin's Creed Syndicate 11. Assassin's Creed Origins 12. Assassin's Creed Odyssey 13. Assassin's Creed Valhalla This is my list and Ezio Trilogy must be on top of the list. I really don't like rpg AC games and i put them on the last. I know a lot of people did not like AC 1 and 3 but i enjoy them much more than AC 4 Black Flag.

[@jax_wildguess]

Origins aged so much better than Odyssey! Forget the fact that Odyssey is not an AC game, the story is bad, gameplay is repetitive, the grind makes it more like a job than a game, map is big and empty.. ppl only liked it because it was set in Greece!

[@PerkaSet]

Origins aged so nicely ngl - Jason

[@francivaliosi6550]

I don't agree with your opinion. Ac Odyssey had all that ac origins had only better if you were really invested in the story and world.Anyways still respect your opinion

[@the_CosmicSkyheart]

@@francivaliosi6550 Odyssey was a decent game sure but in no way was it better than Origins. Origins had the more emotional story with Bayeks son and the formation of the creed and how the creed itself started. Bayek and Aya sacrifice a lot and even separate after the events of the game so they can focus on the brotherhood in different areas and insure they brotherhood thrives after they’re gone. Odyssey your fighting mythical monsters and fucking old man’s wives running around as a Spartan demigod. None of that is AC you don’t even have a hidden blade the signature weapon of the hidden ones. Odyssey by itself is ok as a game but it doesn’t belong in the AC family

[@fairoboilawrence5287]

Lol. Odyssey was an Assassin's creed fame thru and thru and if you cant that then you obviously dont understand Assassin's creed what so ever. Lol

[@the_CosmicSkyheart]

@@fairoboilawrence5287 right I forgot Kassandra taking the oath and sacrificing her finger to wear the blade. Also the presence of the hidden ones can’t believe I forgot they were in the game😂….wait nope I’m thinking of Origins and every other AC game kassandra fought mythical monsters and fought gods wtf are you talking about? Maybe you haven’t played the other AC games but they didn’t have demigods and crap like that bc it was mostly grounded with some fantasy elements in there. Odyssey was 400 years or so before the formation of the brotherhood that alone along with my other points says Odyssey isn’t an AC game

[@dimtoso677]

Am I the only one that likes the real life story line...

[@msizzling]

Valhalla was not that bad. It’s just way too long. The story was great and the rpg movement for AC is making it better. You find out a lot about the Isu and the inception of the Templars. A great prelude into the better stories of Altair and Ezio.

[@natchu96]

having played a good chunk of it again recently, at least on a mechanical level it certainly isn't garbage. Kind of misses a lot of what makes RPGs RPGs, at least compared to Odyssey, but looking past the slight jankiness every AC title obligatorily has there are far worse games out there. It just kind of feels like it doesn't know whether to go all-in on RPG or pander to classic AC elements sometimes and ends up somewhere in the awkward middle-ground. The whole game basically feels mid in execution, and while that would be fine in a short game this is easily a 60-100 hour title with DLC holding up huge price tags. If it weren't a single player game it'd almost be the archetypal live service title, I'd basically call it the junk food game of the franchise now that it's all done.

[@gordonramsay6210]

The Valhalla story just felt like a bunch of side quests stitched together.

[@revenahja8676]

Valhalla is actually fire tho. Miles better than origins and odyssey. Even better than unity and syndicate tbh

[@smallthousand]

U guys really deserve so much than 100 subs, so u got yourself a subscriber

[@PerkaSet]

We're glad to hear it. Thank you for taking the time to watch -Ethan

[@sussywales]

This guy deserves more subscribers

[@PerkaSet]

Thanks for the feedback. We believe we do too 🤣

[@Aryaveer69]

@@PerkaSet when is the new video coming

[@TheGrooovyDude]

With you on origins being my favorite. Close second would be brotherhood. If we could get something thats a mix of the old school AC and new school id buy that

[@exelierxe.e]

_19:25__ What is this location, Anyone knows?_ anyway AC3 right now, Shows people were wrong, *We dont need Ezio always and always* Connor has his own humor as well

[@alexbastos6960]

Try telling that the vast legion of whiny Ezio fanboys. 😅 But yeah, I couldn't agree more. 👍🏻

[@rockjoggers975]

Black flag was my number 1. Remember my cousin trying to get me into ezio but the game felt hard, my first AC was black flag and it was easy enough to understand and Edward was just a character with so much passion and a really good reasons to why he ended up falling along the assasins path. I would’ve liked Rogue just yhe same but every copy I got had game breaking bugs that would mess up the options objectives. Got spotted in a tree by an enemy in front of me looking the opposite way and I just started comparing from there. Edward even had more passion when yelling orders to his crew. Both stories were stellar though but the bugs in rogue made me sad. Was dope that they tied together though with Edward Haythem and connor and how it linked with AC3 and I live how you could capture territory on rogue and how the cities felt as good as 3

[@AlqhemyA]

AC4 is goated

[@AMB477]

These are some of the opinions of all time

[@jujuthethird4602]

My whole problem with the assasins creed franchise is when they went the rpg route i really don't like it i prefer the original style of the games. I tried playing assasins creed origins and odyssey and couldn't finish them because I did not enjoy it at all i recently purchased assasins creed 2 and loving it again as when i first played it

[@alexbastos6960]

Um... why were we watching some AC2 footage while Jason was talking about Revelations?! 😅

[@robmc-bob2726]

Ive always felt brotherhood is a bit overated though still a fantastic game

[@dashfriday974]

Dang, I’ll have to go back and finish Orgins

[@kurtvanderweg9147]

You know what they say about opinions.

[@CA_Hariharaniyer2023]

I personally hated Assassin's creed Odyssey the most. Syndicate comes after that. The reason is that AC Syndicate is designed to play predominantly in stealth. Thus, Syndicate clearly discourages combat which means that you have to play like an Actual Assassin. AC Odyssey is the exact opposite of everything being an Assassin. It's just an RPG game and not an AC game. AC Valhalla is honestly way better than AC Odyssey provided you play the game for atleast 10 hours. Even I thought to drop out Valhalla after playing like one hour. AC Valhalla is extremely long and slow paced. It takes atleast 60-70 hours to finish just the main story (and the story sucks). But the gameplay is much better than AC Odyssey. I have completed each and every AC game so I believe I am competent enough to provide an opinion.

[@dashfriday974]

So which one is your favorite?

[@CA_Hariharaniyer2023]

@@dashfriday974 out of all the Assassin's creed games, i personally liked AC Revelations and AC3 the most

[@dennythesavage]

I’m going to be honest, I completely lost interest after they killed off Desmond, but the last I played was Black Flag. I keep hearing how great it was after Black Flag though, at least for a bit, but now all I hear now is how bad it has become.

[@Borko781]

Origins is amazing, Valhalla and Odyssey are meh, Syndicate is also meh, Unity is kinda fun tho.

[@KaryonTheirStory]

Black flag by far was the most fun

[@M1seryK1lls]

The biggest L’s in this video are the unity placements

[@The-Like-Button]

Syndicate is so much better than odyssey, because odyssey is the single worst Assassins creed, followed by Valhalla and origins, I hate the RPG era, unity and black flag are the best, followed 3 and then 2 and brotherhood, they are my personal favourites, and unity is number 1 If I had to do my own list it would be 1:AC Unity 2:AC Black flag 3: AC 3 4:AC 2 5: AC brotherhood 6:AC Syndicate 7:AC revelations 8:AC Rouge 9: Assassin's Creed 10:AC Origins 11:AC Valhalla 12:AC Odyssey That's my opinion.

[@PerkaSet]

The great thing is that there is no right or wrong answer you know? Everyone always prefers something over something else and it's great seeing the variety -Ethan

[@dblevins343]

Yep you lost me immediately. Syndicate is not 12th.

[@lazygamer4746]

I fell off AC when they screwed up the modern day story. The conspiracy sci fi stuff was the best part, and around AC4 when they stopped focusing on it, I kind of lost interest, but I heard Valhalla gets back into it a bit, so I'm excited.

[@hunterstrickland4083]

I love OC Odyssey and it’s one of my favorite but it’s also not a true AC game and I get that

[@senister14]

Brotherhood was my favorite game to, just because of how well it was done.

[@PerkaSet]

The only aspect I wish it had was defending the bases like revelations. But other than that I 100% agree. Brotherhood was a masterpiece-Ethan

[@senister14]

@@PerkaSet yeah that would have been cool, for me I would have changed the story a little, just because the last guy was the only one I enjoyed beating, you never really know who the other guys are, if it was like assassin's creed 3 where you got to really flesh out the other members, that would have been great. Yep, even though I've seen all the games and only played up until black flag, I will never stop loving brotherhood. A master piece that is timeless.

[@arc7653]

How is valhalla more assassins creedy than AC Syndicate... You're comparing a vikingr to an actual assassin in london... Like they in England but how...

[@PerkaSet]

Because the game was absolute dogshit -Ethan

[@AlwaysNoob196]

Pretty good video , keep the good work ! Imo Black flag takes the 1# place, just saying ✌

[@PerkaSet]

Really good choice :) - Jason

[@jakemccallum1695]

How u gonna disrespect unity like Dat;-;

[@aradhyasakpal8083]

Jason still has some pretty accurate rankings. But upon all the reviews and my personal favs from playing all games...here's the definitive list to represent majority of the community: - 1. Assassin's Creed II 2. Assassin's Creed: Brotherhood 3. Assassin's Creed: Origins 4. Assassin's Creed IV: Black Flag 5. Assassin's Creed: Revelations 6. Assassin's Creed: Unity 7. Assassin's Creed: Syndicate 8. Assassin's Creed 9. Assassin's Creed III 10. Assassin's Creed: Rogue 11. Assassin's Creed: Odyssey 12. Assassin's Creed: Valhalla

[@PerkaSet]

Yeah, I think the most populous number 1 choice is AC2 tbh - Jason

[@aradhyasakpal8083]

@@PerkaSet true. Given to the fact...some may consider that game to be be the literal beginning of AC.

[@shinobimsh5687]

I put ac1 and 3 above syndicate

[@aradhyasakpal8083]

@@shinobimsh5687 but syndicate was really good. and i say bein an original fan. the plot was great, soundtrack was meh but the open-world looked fascinating historical accuracy was jaw-dropping and obviously he gameplay was much better. i mean it sour ranking and i respect that but tell me why you felt syndicate was so shit in brief. i watched your vid and understood you point of reason but in brief?

[@elementalcatplays6463]

I think I pretty much agree with your ranking I’d probably swap minor places within the top 6 depending on what I’m feeling and I’d probably put rogue above 3 only because I didn’t click with 3

[@ironicly__iconic]

The newer ones are the better ones IMO 🤷🏼‍♂️

[@Bent_Dent]

The fact that y’all ranked odyssey over Valhalla is insane to me😆, but I get your point of view lol

[@Fck_the_atf]

Yeah Valhalla, odyssey and origins are all literally just the same exact game. And thats a horrible game.

[@Bent_Dent]

@@Fck_the_atf I disagree, but you do you

[@Fck_the_atf]

@@Bent_Dent i mean i love the story and aesthetic of all three games. But its just the gameplay that does it for me.

[@Bent_Dent]

@@Fck_the_atf I get you, the older games had better gameplay but I still like the newer ones

[@Thegbrownman]

The only L in both of ur top 5s is not putting in black flag that is a literal crime also rogue is so underrated I love it and the only other L is both of ur guys Unity placement I loved everything about that game the stealth the parkour the multiplayer the scenery idk how ppl hate on that game, nice video

[@ronintair]

Rogue is a worse black flag, not that underrated

[@ljsgaming5943]

Rouge was literally just DLC

[@circadianflows]

rouge was honestly just bland and unity is a mess the story in both of those games were mid.

[@Igneeka]

I feel the exact opposite with Rogue Everyone calls it underrated but playing it I was so disappointed, it's pretty much smoll Black Flag, barely does anything with its concept (you play as a Templar, a rogue Assassin and the coolest idea they had is sometimes there's an assassin hidden in a bush or on a rooftop that's try to kill you ?), they turned the Assassins into assholes and the Templars into good guys (it kinda makes sense since the Brotherhood was getting really powerful in the west but it's lame when you're here to play as the bad guy) and the story is pretty bad...I mean the way it links with ACIII and Unity is cool but they tried to make it a tragedy to have Shay kill his old friends when they barely had any screentime or a personality at all, Stede Bonnet in Black Flag was more of a character than anyone in Rogue's brotherhood

[@alexbastos6960]

21:16 *"They really put you in the real world and you... like they know you don't wanna do that sh*t."* *THANK YOU!* I literally couldn't agree more. I'll never understand how there are some people who actually try to convince themselves that the modern day segments were ever any good. I mean, don't get me wrong. I do understand how "relevant" it may be, like lore-wise. *But damn, it's SO BORING!!!*

[@PerkaSet]

Yeah you mainly just walked around. Like I wanna be assassinating not just wandering -Ethan

[@nadesun7075]

Tragic new patek💀

[@zawzawcuddly]

jason needs to wake upAC REVELATIONS IS 8 WTH MAN

[@PerkaSet]

I know right. Very uncultured -Ethan

[@PerkaSet]

😂 broooo Revelations wasn't that good 🤧- Jason

[@ionlytalkboxing3648]

Respect your list but having odyssey above revelations was bad take imo. The worst take was ac 2 being six. That's arguably the best game in the franchise. It's the consensus of ac fans

[@powersource7653]

I disagree 😎

[@96ma]

L list. Origins, Odyssey, and Valhalla, were all trash 1. 4BF 2. 3 3. BH 4. Unity 5. Rogue 6. Syindicate 7. Revelations 8. 2 9. 1 Good, but can not be ranked is 3 Liberation HD/Remastered

[@-slice-6103]

Origins was not an L

[@PerkaSet]

Facts - Jason

[@alexbastos6960]

*Origins is a frickin' MASTERPIECE.* ❤️

[@alexbastos6960]

Gotta respect you for ranking AC2 so low, though. That takes courage!

[@Musou_Black]

You put 2 at 9th place you are insane

[@zohebkhan6834]

Bro where is the thumbnails list don’t wanna watch the whole video

[@jayjohnson7140]

why did you search for a video rather than a Reddit list then, your problem not theirs, good video

[@abibas9415]

bad takes ngl

[@KeijiAkuma]

HOW DARE YOU put AC Syndicate to the lowest lvl!! -.- AC1 is the worst of ALL!

[@PerkaSet]

I sadly have to disagree. Syndicate was a sad excuse for an assasins creed -Both of us

[@jax_wildguess]

Are u ok?!

[@raydafuq3570]

No, AC1 is one of the best AC games together with the Ezio Trilogy. No AC game after it came close. So it goes AC1 + Ezio -> Kenway Saga -> Unity (while Unity often get's praised after the patches as one of the best so it can be swapped with Kenway Saga) -> Syndicate -> RPG Games. This is the most accurate depiction of people who actually played all of them and weren't too dumb for it. After watching almost every Tier List video this is the average rating.

[@KeijiAkuma]

@@raydafuq3570 HELL NO

[@natchu96]

I would honestly disagree with either of those being the lowest. Syndicate had alright black boxes and AC1's only real flaw was honestly being too by the book and repetitive.

[@dashfriday974]

I remember the trailer to Brotherhood being so badass.