We Tried EVERY Flavor Of Peeps

Today, we're eating way too many Peeps! GMM # 2574
Subscribe to GMM: kzbin.info...
We’re going on tour!! Visit goodmythicaltour.com for info & tickets!
Watch today's GMMORE: • Playing TikTok Easter ...
Click the bell icon so you'll know when we add a new episode!
Want more GMM? Check out these playlists:
Season 23 - • Season 23 | Good Mythi...
Good Mythical Summer 2023 - • Good Mythical Summer 2...
Will It? - • Will It? | Good Mythic...
Taste Tests! - • Taste Tests! | Good My...
Check out Mythical's new cereal! - eatmishmash.com
Check out Sporked, Mythical's website dedicated to helping you find the best food on the shelves! - www.sporked.com
Get a copy of our novel, The Lost Causes of Bleak Creek @ www.bleakcreek.com
Pick up official GMM and Mythical merch at mythical.com
and www.amazon.com/mythical
Don’t miss our weekly podcast, Ear Biscuits: applepodcasts.com/earbiscuits
Join the Mythical Society: www.mythicalsociety.com
Follow Mythical:
Instagram: / mythical
Facebook: / mythical
Twitter: / mythical
TikTok: / mythical
Website: mythical.com
Check Out Our Other Mythical Channels:
Mythical Kitchen: / mythicalkitchen
Rhett & Link: / rhettandlink
Good Mythical MORE: / goodmythicalmore
Want to send us something? mythical.com/contact
Submit your Wheel of Mythicality video here: bit.ly/GMMWheelIntroSUBMISSIONS
Intro Motion Graphics by Fantoons www.fantoons.shop/
Intro & Outro Music by Rhett & Link
In the spirit of minimizing food waste associated with the filming of this series, Mythical is donating to the Hollywood Food Coalition ( hofoco.org ) who provide daily, nourishing meals to underserved communities in the Los Angeles area.
Get the GMM Set Gear!
(As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases from paid links below)
* Apple AirPort Extreme: amzn.to/2NnIvvk
* Apple iPad Pro (12.9-inch, Wi-Fi, 64GB) - Space Gray (Latest Model) - MTEL2LL/A: amzn.to/2NnKXlw
* Guardian Industrial Products DH-CP-4 3 Channel Rubber Cable Ramp (Straight): amzn.to/2NdshoR
* Cartoni Focus HD Fluid Head with 3 Tube Ultra-Light Tripod, Mid-Level Spreader and Soft Case - Black: amzn.to/2X4i7X8
* ARRI SkyPanel S60-C LED Softlight (Blue/Silver, Edison): amzn.to/2YgM3km
* Chef-Master 90050 Professional Heat Lamp, Silver: amzn.to/2Xa1Wwr
* Samsung UN40H5003 40-Inch 1080p LED TV (2014 Model): amzn.to/2NdMU4e
* Sony LMDA170 17" Production Video LCD Monitor, 16:9 Native Aspect Ratio, 1080p Resolution: amzn.to/2YlB9tH
* Behringer Xenyx 1002 Premium 10-Input 2-Bus Mixer with XENYX Mic Preamps and British Eqs: amzn.to/2Yeeqzl
* Elgato Game Capture Card HD60 S - Stream and Record in 1080p60, for PlayStation 4, Xbox One & Xbox 360 (Renewed): amzn.to/2NdOBP6
* Pyle Universal Speaker Stand Mount Holder - Heavy Duty Tripod w/ Adjustable Height from 40” to 71” and 35mm Compatible Insert - Easy Mobility Safety PIN and Knob Tension Locking for Stability PSTND2: amzn.to/2JcCpce
* JBL EON612 Portable 12" 2-Way Multipurpose Self-Powered Sound Reinforcement: amzn.to/2Ndluvm
* Bolt 500 XT 3G-SDI/HDMI Wireless TX/RX: amzn.to/2J1OeSk
* Voigtlaender 17,5/0,95 Nokton 17.5 mm-17.5 mm Lens: amzn.to/2JjUCEP
* Blackmagic Design Micro Converter SDI to HDMI (with Power Supply) BMD-CONVCMIC/SH/WPSU: amzn.to/2J6iw6y
* Panasonic H-HSA35100 F2.8 II ASPH 35-100mm Mirrorless Micro Four Thirds Mount POWER Optical I.S. LUMIX G X VARIO Professional Lens: amzn.to/2RAhIul
* PANASONIC LUMIX Professional 12-35mm Camera Lens G X VARIO II, F2.8 ASPH, Dual I.S. 2.0 with Power O.I.S., Mirrorless Micro Four Thirds, H-HSA12035 (2017 Model, Black): amzn.to/2J9WH5S
* Decimator Design DMON-12S | 12 Channel Multi Viewer with HDMI SDI Outputs: amzn.to/2J9Xkwg
* Decimator MD-HX HDMI and SDI Cross Converter with Scaling & Frame Rate Conversion: amzn.to/2Ymj52c
* PANASONIC LUMIX GH4 Body 4K Mirrorless Camera, 16 Megapixels, 3 Inch Touch LCD, DMC-GH4KBODY (USA Black): amzn.to/2WZjlD6
* Blue Microphones Mouse Microphone Kc: amzn.to/2Ybu12I

[@dannymccook]

“There’s no place for this in my life.” is such a funny line to say after tasting something for 0.005 seconds

[@JoeyKlu]

It's one of those golden moments from this show that's now going to live in my mind forever 😂

[@DaxianPreston]

When you know you know

[@coolnout3765]

Profound for morons.

[@fantaoramge]

Lmao I read this comment right as link said it 😂😂

[@Inferdesu]

@@fantaoramgesame idk why it just keeps happening

[@coyotelong4349]

Gotta love the concept of Cotton Candy Peeps. They’re flavored like sugar, as opposed to the usual Peeps flavor of sugar

[@Ssrijon]

this made me giggle

[@markekar6021]

are you saying you dont know what cotton candy flavored things taste like?

[@justinb864]

@@markekar6021Are you lying to yourself that cotton candy flavor taste like anything other than pure sugar?

[@MariaKiran1]

😂

[@louiecosmi3611]

@@justinb864cotton candy is absolutely a unique flavor. I’m a big fan of cotton candy flavored yogurt, which is certainly not just sugar flavored yogurt

[@GreatKaiit]

I think every gut check Rhett scores comparing the flavors to each other and Link scores comparing to all other foods that exist

[@alainnnah]

this makes so so much sense 😭

[@grantzolldan]

Nah, Rhett has acknowledged before that rating something below 50 means that he does not like it

[@JaySay]

Rhett has said it pretty early on that he really scores based on how much he likes it and would eat it again (as people should.) That being said, Rhett is a _big fan_ of most foods, a pretty good antithesis to Link's _hatred_ of most foods, so his score is fairly skewed as well as Link's. It's just that Link uses a wider range of his scores, buuuuuut he frequently forgets how he scored things, so he can score something he likes a 70, and something he's just okay with a 75.🤷‍♂️

[@urpotato5005]

The 62s and 28s at the start felt like a fever dream

[@mikeoxmaul4685]

8:12 As soon as Link heard "cotton candy" he looked around nervously lol

[@amandaburnett2453]

Cotton Candy Randy hiding in the back.....

[@peachhazel7865]

😂😂😂😂😂

[@Dctctx]

Happy cotton candy day daddies

[@EmmaGraham-if7od]

They should've had Cotton Candy Randy feed them the peeps

[@jryangutierrez]

Im woth Rhett when it comes to peeps. I dont mind em. Ill eat like one or maybe 2 a year

[@parad0xicalenigma]

The start of this episode felt like it was going to be the April Fools episode, just giving 62s and 28s for everything

[@MerisaThePotato]

I literally had to check the date

[@Suckitfromthaackbays]

I had to double check I thought they got me again 😂😂

[@theslotwhisperer5513]

@@MerisaThePotato lol same

[@mangekyourinnegan6537]

I think it is. They're literally eating peeps, they're all the same flavors. Don't let their lie fool you! On april first, they'll announce that this was the april fools day video and that they got everyone.

[@AspenSauce]

sporked has to be the one playing a joke, they're all the same flavour 😂

[@xeno9505]

Link: “that’s a good flavor” Also Link: “33”

[@IslandpferdeHaukagil]

Like he sais later: it is still just a Peep 😅

[@CloudedRain84]

As soon as Josh came in he was just like, "I'm gonna quietly eat as much of all of these as possibl- Oh Stevie! Yes there is something else to do!"

[@tylerprince6371]

0:55 for a second, I thought Link was going to say "I love when Easter falls on a Sunday" and I wouldn't put it past him either

[@knife126]

lol, same! 😅

[@arg09_20]

I thought he was gonna say that too 😂

[@messibessi11]

Same!

[@mnfenstermaker10]

i love how Link is taking itty bitty bites to limit the sweetness, but Rhett (in true Rhett fashion) is going all in every single round

[@romulofigueroadiaz480]

And even then link is the one that ended up eating more bread 💀

[@jennstrauss5065]

​@@romulofigueroadiaz480oh yeah man HAHAHA HAHAHA HAHAHA HAHAHA HAHAHA HAHAHA HAHAHA HAHAHA HAHAHA HAHAHA HAHAHA HAHAHA HAHAHA HAHAHA HAHAHA HAHAHA HAHAHA HAHAHA HAHAHA HAHAHA HAHAHA HAHAHA HAHAHA HAHAHA HAHAHA HAHAHA HAHAHA HAHAHA HAHAHA HAHAHA HAHAHA HAHAHA HAHAHA HAHAHA

[@jennstrauss5065]

​@@romulofigueroadiaz480OH YEAH

[@sidleidol03]

I just made the same comment! Rhett was going for it as he always does because he just wants to eat and Link is totally donkey lipping them. It’s like the squidward bite!!

[@michaelortiz7737]

I loved Josh's reaction to the Strawberry. His excitement was so genuine. "Try it?!?! I've had hundreds of these!"

[@rebeccas265]

I'm shocked Josh didn't mention the glory of roasting stale Peeps. It refreshes the flavor of the Peep and gives a warm gooey marshmallow in a candy coating. DON'T BURN YOURSELF! You have to let the melted exterior sugar melt and then cool again a little bit to get the candy shell.

[@Serenity_Dee]

I get queasy at the thought of having that many Peeps but I appreciate Josh's enthusiasm.

[@rachelh1720]

The way he just sat there scarfing them while Rhett and link debated was so amusing and on point for himm

[@RUnuts94]

Link looking around for Randy when that cotton candy Peep pulled up 👀

[@mind-of-neo]

Peeps are something you wanna eat like 1 or 2 of a year just to appreciate that they're iconic. They're not actually very good and that marshmallow texture gets really sickening after a few.

[@Roy-G-Biv]

for sure

[@dearoldmold]

Man, I love the texture. The crunch of the sugar on the outside, and I love when they start to get a little stale and chewy loll.

[@EStramel09]

I’m one of the few people who absolutely love peeps. I love the texture and the marshmallowness of it all.

[@anniplaze8050]

They do make a bomb smores

[@Duke-pn4ex]

I’m not a marshmallow person at all, but I love peeps!

[@Lord_Malkior]

12:42 Rhett effortlessly engaging proper, married-man-mode. 😂

[@pnutty5139]

Josh's passion for peeps is so dang adorable

[@internetonsetadd]

This is what Easter is all about. Three guys sitting around eating Peeps.

[@amateurwitchvibes]

I love that they brought Josh in to make things easier but he just went "nah, I'm just gonna complicate everything" 😂👏

[@Tigers_and_Tarot]

"There's no place for this in my life." Honest words to live by. Lol

[@jimmyispromo]

"My tongue went between the ears" "the week aint over yet" 😂😂😂😂

[@SpydurPoet]

Josh getting slightly rage-y with the gingerbread peeps package was slightly scary but also hilarious and awesome.

[@SaeedBaloney]

I really miss their Smelling Bee episodes! Hope y’all do another one soon 🙈💛

[@oofmydude8173]

Frrr thooo

[@risaalshaan]

Also CTFWG

[@amandarocha_]

what does ctfwg means?@@risaalshaan

[@runawayfaeIX]

Yes, please!

[@Savyflores]

Very random, but I also agree!! I miss those videos so much. B E A N S will live on in my head forever

[@Justfillintheblank]

Anytime I see Peeps, I'm immediately reminded of this quote: "To me, the candy quack is natures perfect food, and I could eat 100 of them" - Francis Wilkerson.

[@jacobf2833]

As a fellow peep lover, so happy they had Josh in and making the final decision to truly represent us.

[@chargersgirlyfan]

YES! 👏👏👏 So glad someone was there to be a true representative!

[@baev123]

5:10 Rhett was so happy to see a purple bunny

[@builttoscalevideos]

in that chicks and bunnies section I genuinely thought the April Fools episode came early this year lol

[@alexandersizemore6851]

Anyone else feel like this is an april fools episode

[@colespinjetsumaster]

whenever josh is on a gmm episode its always a treat xD

[@abslol1]

If your birthdays on easter its not ALWAYS on easter so I think you're in the clear

[@runawayfaeIX]

I was thinking the same thing... Same goes for Thanksgiving!

[@amyehlers3825]

I'm a once in a while Easter birthday person. It's fun!

[@stephaniemcclarren3615]

Lol. Mine lands on Easter every 8-12 years lol. Though I have the luck of it being my sisters first Easter the first time. Then my nieces first Easter the second time lol

[@kaismith5805]

​@@runawayfaeIX my birthday falls on Thanksgiving every 6-11 years I think. I thought it was just gonna be 6, cause that's how it was for most of my life, but this year was gonna be 6 but it's a leap year so my birthday is on a Friday. So I have to wait til 2029 now 😂

[@SwimmerChick1821]

Having a birthday that's always around Thanksgiving is almost as bad as Christmas, I think. People are too busy with families to celebrate (which is hard as a kid) and people tend to forget your birthday and still group presents with Christmas.

[@misskanders]

At first I thought this was a April Fools day episode 😂

[@justinb864]

Right? I didn’t even know peeps had flavors

[@leoadimanea7826]

@@justinb864 I forgot peeps even existed.

[@sammiluvsuuu]

no frl and they kept scoring the same in the beginning 😭

[@elijahblack1464]

Peeps really aren't that bad.

[@SoulfullyYoursCJ]

Bless y’all’s hearts because Peeps is the nastiest candy ever made! 😅🤢

[@Ichigo1817]

Idk how Link is tasting any of the flavors with these lil bites he be taking lol 😂

[@stefanoraz27]

Josh looks like a 90s heartthrob in this one

[@MayimHastings]

Happy Easter, and Ramadan Mubarak to those celebrating! 🤍🙏🕊

[@anthonykypreos3566]

Happy Easter, hope y'all have a blessed Good Friday

[@SunshineGator]

My birthday IS on Easter this year 😂 you gotta remember that Easter isn’t on the same day every year! It usually meant I got an Easter egg hunt for my birthday so that was cool

[@pedrocosta6289]

Good mythical morning everyone ❤️

[@TheUnfairGambler1]

gmm

[@162111robinson]

Goooooood mythical morninggggg

[@nashin0ki927]

gmm, hope everyone is doing ok :)

[@josephferrel3413]

Good mythical morning ❤

[@CookiesDC]

Good mythical Morning! 🐓🌞

[@MegaAwsometurtle]

Stevie made sure her scoring aid got seen 😂

[@sarahjndonovan]

I love how seriously Josh took the final Peeps judgement, and his passionate defense of Peeps! 😂

[@killuhKD]

criminal lack of Chaseter Bunny in this episode

[@randypowers3904]

I'm so glad someone else loves real Marshmallows as much as I do. Thanks, Mythical Chef Josh.

[@danalove3543]

Marshmallows are one food I can buy and not worry my hubs will eat them before I get to. Marshmallows and bananas are his kryptonite. lol. All the more for me!

[@koloblican11763]

Officially the most consistent that Link has ever been on a gut check.

[@rommieyay4444]

He caught himself at 10:17 lol he knew that’s usually the time when he just copies what Rhett says.

[@AliFrankTheTank]

Josh came in like the Tom Brady of peeps😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@brandonfallon4456]

I love that as soon as cotton candy was said, Link instinctively/ panickedly glanced around for Randy 😂

[@firephly8384]

The ratio of mallow and sugar is best at the ears. Also a slightly stale peep is ideal

[@thaismatsumoto]

Yeah.RHETT saying they were gross actually isn't true for a lot of us. I prefer them that way.

[@dearoldmold]

YES!

[@Emma_ilikecheese]

Good mythical night,8:03pm in the sunny coast AUS.

[@user82938]

Rhett and Link have become immune to the party popper attack, but Josh still got got.

[@matthewlongmire7656]

I really wish Link had just given every single one a 28 😂

[@elllizz]

Celibacy week is over? We in this for LIFE

[@246kisses]

Honey I feel that. It’s been celibacy year now

[@rileygabriel6700]

Josh seemed so happy to just come and eat peeps ❤

[@SChck212]

Josh is channeling the 90s HARD 😂♥

[@mango.lightshows]

Remember that Monday’s Episode is likely gonna be an April Fools Day episode

[@carto17518]

As a European, I feel like peeps are iconic Americacore in the same league as Twinkies.

[@RinostarGames]

Yes, in that they're both disgusting.

[@imnotgoodwithnames4101]

The term "Americacore" hurts me

[@lalahreno3121]

America core is the best word for it😭

[@mperry0913]

After seeing the bingo tumbler, an idea popped up. The next time they do this, have Rhett and Link do their normal scoring as usual, but for the sake of science, have one of them (In my mind I see Rhett doing this) roll two 10-sided dice (DnD Percentile Dice) and roll a random number to see what the Mythical Universe has decided for each one. In the end, Rhett and Link will still have their top 4 to choose from, but include a 5th that was the top rated one, chosen randomly by the fate of the Mythical Universe per the dice. Then have them rate them as normal. Just an idea for what I'd think would be a really fun episode.

[@tsukig.p.7848]

Petition for Mythical to make a DnD dice set and use your idea to debut it! ❤

[@tsukig.p.7848]

Petition to have Mythical make a DnD dice set and use your idea to debut them! ❤

[@ixsneakiv9950]

14:57 Rhett: really?! oh my gosh I didn’t know about you” 😂

[@andrewbills1084]

Happy Easter Rhett & Link as well as all my fellow mythical beasts stay safe and stay awesome much love and respect 🤘🤟

[@HayTatsuko]

Good Mythical Friday~ And good riddance to Celibacy Week!!

[@maxdorner2901]

Remember to practice through the weekend

[@masquinongy4652]

@@maxdorner2901no

[@morganstace]

whats the whole celibacy week thing for?

[@cheyennestone74]

I have theories, but honestly I am not sure. I feel like I've missed the explanation.​@morganstace

[@timthelittlemusicfox]

lmao i thought the april's fools episode had come early in the beginning

[@BlakeTheGamblingHero]

my eyes rolled when link rated the dr.pepper peeps low, especialyl since i was just eating them at the moment it happened.

[@irisamelia9787]

I just realized that I'm watching two grown men eating marshmallows and it's wildly entertaining.

[@ActuallyNeptune]

Rhett & link never fails to post on time for iftar lol

[@vegasins7728]

Good mythical night to all my Australians

[@eeriedolly]

this is one of the best gmm episodes in awhile

[@alexho2620]

Love what you guys are doing; i recently watched your podcast aboutyour experience with relgion and recently left my own myself. You’ve brought alot of insight and perspective that aligns with what i went through and for that I appreciate you guys. Keep doing whatcha creative minds and hard work can do! Love ya

[@SpritePix]

Good mythical morning guys!

[@Scottsgamerlounge]

Happy Easter mythical beasts to those who celebrate

[@AdamTheRaptor]

8:14 "Cotton Candy..." Link terrifyingly looks over his shoulder for Cotton Candy Randy.... 😂😂😂

[@Wowfactorsgotemcrazy]

The synchronized "umnm" at 10:14 was pure gold.

[@zachbrown90]

Forever celibacy week 🤌

[@brycevining4500]

Celibacy Week is really easy when I have experience with celibacy.

[@jmurphy0684]

Same lol

[@weregretohio7728]

EZ mode

[@mage1439]

I love the only distinguishing feature being purple.

[@dallasmed65]

I don't think Link realizes there's a whole 70 numbers above 30

[@Dejones95]

I would just like to wish Rhett and Link and all the good mythical crew a very Happy Easter and I hope you all have a amazing Easter because Easter rules.

[@HellsigTheRed]

The only thing that would make the Mythical cookbook better would be if we had the recipe for that Popcorn ice-cream cake. I need it in my life guys

[@lowendgamerleg1227]

18:24 really cracked me up! 🤣🤣🤣

[@rachelthompson1145]

This is the episode I've been waiting for for 10 years

[@Not_dead777]

Happy Easter everyone

[@MonsterBurn74]

Best peeps ever are the seasonal chocolate covered peeps!

[@nicowallace6409]

Good mythical night🌙☺️

[@josephleon_The_GOAT_of_COD]

1.2M views in 1 week is insane! 😳🤯

[@Trunks1200]

I was genuinely starting to believe this was an early April fools episode at first lmao

[@MonsterBurn74]

Good Mythical Morning Beasts Happy FRIDAY yall! :D Have a awesome Beastly weekend!

[@MegaAwsometurtle]

Good mythical morning ❤️

[@reco7234]

This show has been so unhinged lately, there were a few episodes that i had to check if it was april fools this last month, i'm loving it

[@FlowerFellBlizz]

i haven’t watch good mythical morning in YEARS, so hearing celibacy week gave me SO much whiplash 😭😭😭

[@brianalexander4372]

I was convinced this was the April Fool's episode at the onset.

[@lampshade6579]

Honestly watching Link feed himself on a "We tried" episode was shocking. Like I had cold sweats after.

[@happytrails2you]

Happy Good Friday! Thank you for another GMM Today

[@joebluhm]

I love the chaos of this ep. SO FUN.

[@AmericanNitr0us]

Was 100% convinced Stevie single-handedly pranked Rhett, Link, and every mythical beast for April fools, 2 days early so she wouldn't be caught 😂

[@randypowers3904]

I have cotton candy peeps at work - the only peep worth eating in my opinion.

[@pilotdog68]

have you not tried the Dr Pepper ones?

[@nickmullins3451]

Watching this on Easter and I want to eat all of these Peeps right now. I also just love Josh and his passion for food.

[@ethanstamm8134]

Link hearing “cotton candy chicks” then immediately checking for Randy was hilarious! 😂

[@chaleebb]

I dare Stevie to say “alright Simon and Garfunkel” when introducing Rhett & Link 😂

[@temp6670]

good mythical morning people

[@jimmyispromo]

Josh has that 90s kid haircut

[@spoonfulofsalt]

It felt fitting that I was cuddling with my big stuffed rainbow peeps bunny while watching this. Also happy that one of my all-time favorites finally won!!

[@cmichaud04]

I know you said no holiday peeps but excluding the cocoa flavored Halloween bats is a travesty

[@SimonMetin]

i genuinely thought this was going to be an early April Fools episode where all the Peeps were the same flavor and they rated them differently

[@vishalkalicharan7710]

Happy Easter, GMM!!

[@billduggan1334]

I imagine having a birthday around Halloween would be awesome for parties. So you need to have a "Go Wild" week the last week of January.