West's Final Attempt at Metaphysics - Martin Heidegger Introductory Discussion (Urdu/Hindi)

[@berkantjan9664]

The only KZbin channel that I can watch for an hour tirelessly without being bored... so interesting and engaging...

[@3rd_POV]

Thanks!

[@Abdull3h_vfx]

TRUE SAME

[@Zafarfarooqi-d7q]

Criminally underrated channel great to see 👍

[@3rd_POV]

Please forward in your groups

[@gurditsingh3301]

I am an Indian and I find your videos very interesting....Good to see you after long time..👍👍

[@RadhaFrequency]

❤❤❤

[@moneyheist-hv8ly]

what a sentence, "I am an Indian" and "I find your videos very interesting".

[@Doshanbe]

What is special being Indian A question from a Khalistani

[@narendradani9548]

Excellent Professor Ali Hassan saheb.

[@3rd_POV]

Thx

[@mohdshanu8174]

इस बंदे का अंदाज़ अलग ही है पढ़ाने का । ऐसा teacher भी नहीं देखा yaaar

[@Amankhan-b9j]

Mentor not a teacher

[@mohdshanu8174]

@Amankhan-b9j What does Teacher mean ?

[@Amankhan-b9j]

@@mohdshanu8174 it means mohd shanu.

[@mohdshanu8174]

@@Amankhan-b9j 🆗 😊

[@sachchidev]

Is baar bahot lamba wait karvaya aapne😊😊

[@mayankkumar-si7iz]

मैं आपका प्रशंसक बन गया हूं, मज़ा आता है, आपकों सुनकर, आपने दर्शनशास्त्र जैसे नीरस विषय को रुचिकर बना दिया है,आप एक सुपर स्टार टीचर है। हिंदुस्तान से प्यारभरा सलाम है।❤

[@sheebaaslam]

Kya aap devnagri hindi script padh sakte hain?

[@ravikantmeena1906]

​@@sheebaaslamunhone jo comment kiya h Wo devnagri hindi script me hi kiya h 😂😂

[@wajeehhasan4860]

Always waiting for your videos❤

[@3rd_POV]

Glad you like them!

[@exincident]

​@@3rd_POVanother fan Sir 🙏

[@3rd_POV]

@ thx

[@afaqahmadchadhar33]

Apki videos ka intezar rehta hai very knowledgeable for us. Love from Dubai 🇦🇪

[@3rd_POV]

Thanks

[@ayoos5168]

Poetry to me is not just words that needs to be understood, It is the truest and most important use of language that most often does not become irrelevant after written, like many writings and ideas of people do. It's not even an idea that the poet thinks is smart or witty, it is the purest form of emotion and most often it is truer than any idea. Fiction reigns supreme but just for the right "Dasein".

[@3rd_POV]

Wow totally agreed

[@ayoos5168]

Heidegger's thoughts on anxiety really gave me a new perspective towards it, amazing work.

[@gullibullicartoon6679]

Sir Eastern Philosophy pr b videos bnain buddhism taoism pr

[@obeidshariff4307]

Assalamualaikum, ye lectures itni qeemti hai upr se urdu aur shayrana andaaz me itni aasani se samajh aajati hai prof. Saha aapka bhot shukriya is sadqa e jariya ke liye

[@3rd_POV]

Thanks

[@razzrazz925]

Sir please continue giving lectures on Beyond Good and Evil of F. Nietzche.

[@3rd_POV]

I will for sure, after a few videos

[@AdvDheerajChaudhary]

Sir Nice Effort To Explain Heidegger..Apka Ek Ek Kar Ke Sare Post-Modernist Ko Samjhana Is Good Because Even Experts Know Little About Post Modernism...Thankyou😊

[@ArhamAhmed-u7u]

Shukirya Ustaad ji ❤

[@MuhammadAnis-jz2qn]

Mubarak ho !!! buhat wait karwaya sari video 3 times dekh li hain

[@3rd_POV]

Hahaha

[@samibabar9543]

Heidegger is a complex philosopher, controversial too. But the way you lead the whole conversation around Heidegger by making insightful segways and multidimensional interjections - make you one of the most unique commentator in my view. Sir I'm indebted!

[@3rd_POV]

Thanks

[@IAzizIAziz]

You’re an incredible teacher who’ve made these difficult subjects interesting and fun. I’ve only just been introduced to your channel by KZbin and I’m addicted ! I really enjoy learning about the evolution of human thought, and philosophy is a great instrument for that. I really enjoy your method of delivery which is casual and easier to follow and love it when you add poetry of Iqbal and Gharib :) This video on Heidegger is fascinating to learn he was the last of the great European philosophers and your explanation of why he was the last on the subject of metaphysics makes perfect sense. I’m excited to learn and will read more on his investigation into ‘being’ that you so eloquently explained. Thank you :)

[@3rd_POV]

Hi- thanks for such great feedback-

[@AgentBrains]

23:35 वस्तु (object)(presence at hand) - विषय (जिस वस्तु से मेरा identification h, कुछ लेना देना है)(ready to hand)

[@sah6373]

Hazoor, you’re doing a great service with these podcasts. I’m a fan! Appreciate you! Jazakomullah!

[@3rd_POV]

Thanks - please spread the word

[@DEEPAKPATEL-ez6ho]

Sir, U r a very profound thinker, ur work is highly commendable. 1 request kindly make a vdo on Osho's philosophy too. Love nd Respect from India.

[@zahidmaqsood4531]

Zabardust ❤❤❤❤

[@nidhibhatia3835]

I enjoi and from your sessions. Never knew I will be so interested in philosophy. Thanks!

[@playingwithmk7565]

Super Explaind , lajawab samjhani,thanks dear

[@ravikantmeena1906]

Logic is for understanding material things and poetry is for understanding the ultimate.... Matter cannot be understood through poetry and the ultimate truth cannot be understood through logic....bahut din baad aapne video daala😊

[@urgenlama1337]

Perhaps

[@Amrish_Kumar.]

Aapka bohot bohot shukriya sir jo aapne itni jaldi ek new video upload ki🙏

[@AgentBrains]

29:35 hum apne finite se agree kre, mtlb jaane Par koi finite hoke finite nhi jaan skta, Jo finite ko finite dekh le, vo finite se beyond hi hoga Means infinite Sarir, man finite h Lekin vo jo जानना h, knowing h Vo infinite (beyond finite) hogi (Ye ek philosophy h)

[@sakhanimagsi1725]

Finally done watching all your videos....thanks for your efforts ❤

[@Rakesh_sharma-u6t]

good to see you are back, keep making videos

[@MohsinHasan-xl9el]

your unexpected poetry makes the environment SIR 🤓🤓

[@musalone1405]

Intezaar Khtam❤❤❤🎉

[@ghinasaleem4856]

your lectures are excellent. a lot better than many of them available on youtube. Please make a video on Descartes's epistemology too.

[@mubashirhassan653]

V informative and great plateform good to see u with another great phelosoph theory discus and explained In great enthusiasm ❤

[@123shahnaz123]

Really enjoy the way you explain .Appreciate you effort.

[@ashfaqjatoi8403]

Sir ur Channel is one of the best philosophy Channel on KZbin ❤

[@muhammadgulsherkhan304]

Thank you for such a detailed explanation. It's because of your explanations, understanding complex concepts is possible for me, personally.

[@3rd_POV]

Glad it was helpful!

[@urgenlama1337]

Sir, thankyou for the beautiful content on Heidegger and it is refreshing. Once I was impressed with his concept of dreadfullness, the possibility of impossibility and being in time i.e. in past present an future. It would be wonderful if series on Being and time is made if possible and time permits. Thanks once again.

[@YaseenKhan-qr6xe]

Enthusiastically waiting for other lectures on continental philosophers.

[@prashantkumarsingh5224]

Such a knowledgeable lecture sir..nice information❣️❣️

[@Honey-cq1er]

As usual Great video . Sir , Keep it bringing .

[@UmerSami28]

Great brother! Glad to see channel growing!!😍🤩

[@3rd_POV]

Thanks brother

[@ashfaqjatoi8403]

It was my wish to learn about Heidegger from you. Thank you for this video

[@xoloxgaming]

Yar boht behtreeen !

[@RohitPB35]

Ye lecture sir ka best lecture lga mujhey abhi tak

[@AliRehmanrozikhan]

har ek lacture la jawab ha bahi jan..

[@guppidhandli5054]

app bhut vdia kam kar rahe ho ji please keep uploading love u

[@karanvasudeva5424]

Heidegger: meri maut koi aur nahin mar saktaa Ali saahab: waise to meri khaansi bhi koi aur nahin khaans saktaa 😅 love this channel, thanks for this great content!

[@nowshadk07]

Just yesterday I was waiting for your video. And yep another one!! This time with Ghalib on Thumbnail as well. Already excited 😊😊!!

[@GuruShiya11]

I accidentally come to your videos, i like your way of understanding the things ❤

[@hayatselachi9212]

Thank you sir for ending our wait with such a beauty!

[@loveibi1]

Thank U, Ali Bhai, once again. I watched this video twice. Heidegger's view of poetry as a unique means of "unconcealing" truth is undeniably powerful, emphasizing the existential and revealing power of art. It drew my mind instantly to Josh Sahib. I hope and wish and humbly request if you could do a through video of Josh Sahib. His works has so much relevance to your larger endeavor. For instance: Josh Malihabadi’s poetic approach does resonate with Martin Heidegger’s philosophy, particularly in the way both thinkers view the role of art, nature, and perception in uncovering truths. Heidegger argued that poetry could "unconceal" or reveal layers of being that logic and scientific reasoning might overlook. Through poetry, he believed, humans could reconnect with the world in a more profound, intuitive way that goes beyond rationality alone. Josh’s verse, "Hum aise ahl-e-nazar ko saboot-e-haq ke liye, agar rasool na hote to subah kaafi thi," aligns with Heidegger’s notion of "unconcealment" through poetic insight. In this line, Josh suggests that for someone with a discerning eye, nature (symbolized by the dawn) itself serves as a testament to truth. This echoes Heidegger’s idea that poetry doesn’t simply describe reality; it brings aspects of existence into the light, allowing us to perceive truths that are often obscured in everyday, rational thought. Additionally, Josh’s rationalism has a unique mystical quality-he trusts human perception to reveal divine or existential truths, even without intermediaries like prophets. This self-reliant and direct approach to truth can be seen as mirroring Heidegger’s focus on "Being" and his emphasis on understanding existence without relying solely on external validation. Heidegger saw language, especially poetic language, as a primary way to connect with being authentically, and Josh’s reliance on the natural world as a source of revelation for ahl-e-nazar (the insightful) closely reflects this idea.

[@3rd_POV]

What a great write up brother- I have not read Josh sahib in detail but will do.

[@deanduniya8128]

سر اگلی ویڈیو کا شدت سے انتظار ہے

[@magrayfayaz1478]

Love you sir ,, From kashmir India,, Your great videos I watch always and learn more and more

[@Farazali_i]

"Aapki videos bohat achi hoti hain! Agar Stoicism par bhi ek video banayein (Marcus Aurelius, Seneca, Epictetus), to bohat madad milegi.

[@fareedahmedbazai5485]

السلام علیکم علی بھائی. اتفاقی طور پر آپکی ایک ویڈیو دیکھی، بہترین انداز میں آپ نے فلسفے کو ایک عام آدمی کی توجہ کا مرکز بنایا. یقین مانیے کہ جتنی خوشی مجھے آپکو سننے میں ہوی شاید ہی کسی اور چیز سے ہوئی ہو. میں نے آپکی بہت سی ویڈیوز دیکھ لیں ہیں. سب کی سب لاجواب ہیں. ایک درخواست ہے کہ آپ کبھی Realism, post Realism, Feminism وغیرہ پر بھی ویڈیوز مرتب کریں تاکہ آپکی بدولت ہم جیسے کتاب سے دور لوگوں کو بھی علم سے مستفید ہونے کا موقع مل سکے. میں اور میرے دوست آپکی علم دوستی اور اس کاوش کو دل کی گہرائیوں سے سراہتے ہیں. خوش رہیں آباد رہیں.

[@3rd_POV]

Bohat shukriya bhai apkay message nay khush kar dia- salamat rahain

[@livewithamirhussain9202]

Great work indeed Please make more vlogs ...you are the most impressive being ..

[@Smilemorefreely975]

I'm always waiting for it

[@peace8243]

Waiting for the next episode of "Beyond good and evil" of Nietzsche. I'm aligning my read with your videos so would help if we get one video each week.

[@GulsherKhan-sz6ku]

Your lectures are really interesting. Love u sir ❤

[@AliRehmanrozikhan]

Thank you, sir, what a lecture mind opener I would say..

[@therandomguy165]

As always, full of knowledge, excitement and motivation. Please do share what is your philosophy of life and your journey

[@pryrkk157]

One more greatest work Authentic 👍

[@3rd_POV]

Thx

[@haiderraza2625]

Maza agaya sir ji 👍👍🙏

[@MuhammadRashid-fe1br]

What a mind-nurturing lecture

[@3rd_POV]

Thx

[@AnkitSharma-qg2dc]

Finally video aa gyi, ab podcast ki tarah sunaenge 🙏😊

[@3rd_POV]

Thx

[@sumitshakya7085]

Beautifully articulated...

[@3rd_POV]

Thanks

[@santoshkumarmarko5621]

Aapko sun ke dil ko sukoon milta hai❤❤

[@3rd_POV]

Thanks!

[@YaseenKhan-qr6xe]

As superb as always ❤

[@razzrazz925]

As God is beyond all matter outside and above all the heavens. In the same way God is in the deepest realm which is deeper than thought, emotion, mind, ego and soul. As within so without. As Derrida said we can know reality or secrets of the outer world through poetry. Why did he say it? Is the world outside a reflection of the forms, id, images, thoughts, unconscious realm and ego inside? To know why something appears so and behaves as it does, we need to be conscious of the inner world and its images. Is the outer world a reflection of common images of all the beings.? Does poetry help explore the inner unconscious, soul and images that are reflected outward as the world and its contents. Why do so many great philosophers point towards Poets and poetry to know better reality and truths? Is poetry simply the state of bringing unconscious contents into conscious awareness? Just as changing beliefs changes behavior and changing behavior changes beliefs. In the same way, does changing or improving inner reality change external reality? Does improving external reality change internal reality? Is pain and fear due to nonalignment of external reality and internal reality? Or is it the process of changes in either external or internal reality causes a stir, a pain , a fear in the corresponding part of other reality. And it resolves with time by acceptance and acknowledgment of these changes. When external reality changes, I suffer internally until I accept this change internally. Now suppose if I change some part of my internal reality, the outer reality panics, suffers, protests and resists until it slowly accepts and acknowledges this change. This process essentially aligns internal and external realities in the long run, until a new change occurs in either internal or external reality. Written by me Mushahid Hussain.

[@3rd_POV]

Wow- great

[@naumanmustafa7728]

Mohtaram, the way you engraving philosophy is unmatched, Could you please enlighten us why Heidegger at the end on the fruits of modern thoughts asked the help of God, thank you

[@3rd_POV]

Because he thought we have exhausted all other options- that is the only option left.

[@mdsaad8432]

Thank you so much for your informative video.......

[@SiddharthaKumar-ug3iw]

Listening you always interesting and knowledgefull❤❤❤

[@SarasAtheistAdvaita]

Thank you bhai.. ... for this video

[@kamrangul312]

Finally another video uploaded ❤

[@khokhar251]

Well come sir after long time

[@3rd_POV]

Thx

[@aghyaat2625]

Martin Heidegger! I can't believe it! You have made philosophy so interesting that I have started falling in love again. If possible, please do make a video on Jean Paul Sartre's Being and Nothingness book! It's too costly to buy! 🙏

[@nowshadk07]

Great introduction.. Pehle bhi eek video main Heidegger ki baat huwi thi ki is nia bola tha Shayari wapas aani chahiye. Mujhe us pe Sir Iqbal ka ki eek line line yaad aayi thi "Waqt ast ki bukh-shayam mai-khana-e-Rumi baz" Sir Iqbal ka eek alag intention tha shayad but yes I too think poetry thodi common honi chahiye. Thoda maza ata. Earlier we used to entire Epic and Dastaans written in rhythm and rhym. Thank you For the video Sir ji!! ❤❤❤

[@3rd_POV]

Thx

[@sarimfaruqi186]

Thank you for making these good videos

[@MohsinHasan-xl9el]

Keep it up legend ❤

[@Mentor_Trickson]

You are a great teacher, love you sir

[@sameerupadhyay5704]

Well done champion

[@wazeerhaider8148]

I love you.सर आपकी विडियो नहीं मिलती तो मेरा दिल बैचेन हों जाता है

[@huzaifashaikh107]

Sir you are brilliant kindly give us side notes as well about how to read books😊

[@saifurehmankhaskheli2657]

Wah sir kia bat hy ... yar love you... ❤❤❤ you're my leisure. ❤❤❤

[@3rd_POV]

Thank you so much 😀

[@MachiavelliTalks]

Please Make More Videos As Soon As Possible

[@I6eeikahdu38]

Shayari aur philosophy. ❤

[@AbdulAmad-id5eb]

Great as always.🎉

[@3rd_POV]

Thanks!

[@kuldeepbhati7813]

Could you create a video on The Beginning of Infinity by David Deutsch? I really enjoy your POVs!

[@GulshanKumar-vn1xw]

Wonderful lecture Sir. Can you make a detailed lecture on his "Letter on Humanism" and "The Question Concerning Technology"?

[@sustainabilityaxis]

Excellent

[@sudipthapa0757]

I always watch your videos it's very nice... love from Nepal....

[@wajeehhasan4860]

One for the algorithm. Love it❤

[@AsifKhan-bv3iu]

You are great teacher.

[@3rd_POV]

Thx

[@poetic__maan7308]

BRING more videos on this please sir...

[@awaizkhetran3607]

Thanks for video Sir

[@3rd_POV]

Thx

[@Developwithimran]

Wow sir maza aa gya ❤. Next video kaB aai gi Sir

[@3rd_POV]

Hahaha - next video ka abhi na pocho- aur bhi gham hain zamanay main ....

[@Raindropppppp]

David hume wali video kab publuc hogi Ali bhai

[@3rd_POV]

It is open brother

[@girirajsingh9917]

Nice lecture🎉🎉❤

[@berkantjan9664]

Ali Sab.. please do recommend some basic books of history and philosophy for us... thank you.. may you grow more...

[@3rd_POV]

Story of Civilization by Will Durant

[@rafiqekhan]

Good work

[@3rd_POV]

Thanks