Is Aaron Rodgers a Realistic Option for the Giants?

[@rawbrob1079]

It would be the dumbest move in Giant's history. Fuck no.

[@flannelguydiy6458]

Stop. Just stop with the rodgers bullshit. The guy took the jets from the toilet to the sewer system below the street. He tore apart their locker room too.

[@cmack7281]

🤣🤣🤣

[@blazinrounds230]

Except. He didn’t.

[@connieq2811]

People keep saying “all the things Aaron brings” lol. All the things are one hour a week on Tuesdays. What other drama does this man bring?

[@moveezy5591]

He tore up the Jets locker room and blamed everyone but himself for what happened in the games

[@connieq2811]

@ he blamed himself after every last loss. Have you ever been in the locker room? Do you know any of the players or coaches personally and they’ve told you this? Or are you just lying thru your teeth

[@ryanMcknight27]

@@moveezy5591jets locker room was done before he got there 🤣

[@tmac848]

Adding Aaron Rodgers, Jaxson dart, Travis Hunter helps the giants more than over drafting Sanders or Ward at 3rd. As long as the giants don’t bow down to Rodgers like the jets did it’s a great plan

[@arcadeslum5882]

Brandon Jacob’s made a good point. Trade back multiple times, take as many swings as you can. See what shows up at camp. We should cut DeCutleto and draft TWO rookie QBs and sign Rodgers and Adam’s ASAP!

[@moveezy5591]

​@arcadeslum5882 Rodgers is washed and his ego is huge he can do no wrong everything is everyone else's fault he will destroy the young locker room

[@blazinrounds230]

@@moveezy5591he’s washed? 3/4 of the leagues starting QBs WISH they had the season Rodgers just had.

[@lucasmartinez5703]

I don't know if he's washed, but he's definitely a distraction that the Giants don't need and aren't good enough to deal with.

[@Twiist585]

Travis hunter wont be there at 3

[@FUTavgDUDE]

As for draft Mason Graham next to Lawrence. Sign a vet qb

[@tyleraguilar2474]

I’m not gonna lie. 2 years removed for the injury. And have Ward or Sanders sit. Devante Adams is gonna be your WR2 and let Slayton walk. And build the O line you could have some level of success

[@555crooked]

He is 42 years old… why ruin your future for an old man

[@tyleraguilar2474]

@ but you don’t because you can cut him loose 🤷🏽‍♂️. The only really valid point is alienating Malik Nabers. Nabers isn’t Wilson. He needs the ball and rightfully so. That’s if you bring in Devante of course

[@TommyRibs]

This is a good idea, and I actually want to do this, and I think Rodgers would do it, because he is already in New Jersey. He and Daboll would do well together. The GIANTS would also HAVE to get a QB in round one or round two in the 2025 draft. If ward is gone, grab Dart, or Will Howard or another College QB that they like.

[@MrFlyhigh86]

Absolutely not ,Aron Rogers is an old man ,the game has changed ,we need a Lamar Jackson,Josh Allen ,Jayden Daniels,burrow types of players

[@TL2354]

Aaron Rodgers

[@blazinrounds230]

You clearly don’t understand the idea of a bridge QB

[@powerboon2k]

There aren't "Burrows types" knocking around dude. He is a generational talent.

[@Petar1908]

Lol stop it

[@markb3786]

Watching AR destroy the chain of command in the Jets' front office and coaching staff has been comedy gold! If he could also do this to the Giants, I would watch!

[@JasonMcDaniel-n2l]

Me too....they already got lucky they didn't get fired, Rodgers a get um fired!

[@azikkii]

That's a good point. It's the perfect way to get rid of daboll and schoen and the rest of the coaching staff

[@soggy79]

Rodgers wants to remake himself. Instead of being known as a dissapointment for ruining the Jets, he wants to be known as the conqueror who destoryed all of NY.

[@connieq2811]

Ruined the jets? Wtf

[@Mr.Brightside8810]

Please, god, don't let the Giants bring in Aaron Rogers. If he's still in NY he's right where he belongs. He's not even a viable bridge QB at this point.

[@blazinrounds230]

Except, he is.

[@Charles-jg8dz]

I'm praying along with you that Aaron Rodgers is not considered. The Giants need to trade #3 for other picks. The 25' schedule looks rather discouraging so best to focus on the Offensive line with another big Runner and a similar " Malik Nabors" in later rounds.

[@azikkii]

@@Charles-jg8dz schoen is not going to make a trade for more picks when he is being forced to be competitive or be fired. Drafting more players doesn't make them immediately better in 2025. Most players have to take time to develop and schoen doesn't have the time for that development to happen. They won't trade down.

[@Longliveduhhkiid]

Plan makes perfect sense honestly. Folks keep bringing up the jets but u gotta remember they literally signed Rodger’s with no plan at all. If we sign him and have a “plan” for him to just do what he does for a year set the team up structure wise and lead the youngins we could be good

[@cmanayf4354]

I would so enjoy seeing this happen.

[@nndsts8648]

The O line???

[@bankslvrd6978]

The O line is better with AT playing you saw that as soon as he went down it got worse.

[@azikkii]

Easy: AT, Tre Smith, Jermaine Eluemenor, Runyan, JMS

[@mapimages]

I’ve been saying this for a week. Rodgers for a year or 2. Hunter at 3, Dart 2nd round pick. We are back.

[@Gnog22]

I ❤ it

[@stephent3963]

2 rd pick for Joe milton

[@Amber-ed3vd]

If Aaron was that good. Why isn't Jets winning

[@JohnnyLightningV10]

Back to winning 3 games a year constantly and getting top 1st round pics 😂

[@JohnnyLightningV10]

​@@Amber-ed3vdHe is washed and has better weapons on Jets.

[@Muricans1776]

Yes do it . Would be a great reason to watch Giants games. A_Aron + Malik + Travis… hopefully they draft or sign OL.

[@whoisjoshjacobs]

I would get Travis and Daxson imo

[@michaelp6794]

Have to find out if Aaron’s performance was impacted by Achilles. My guess is he’ll be better next year because it takes a long time at his age to recover from such an injury. He probably couldn’t push off properly and move well.

[@FlowFinderUSA]

I like Jaxson Dart. Guy has an arm and an attitude. Could be the steal of the draft in the 2nd round.

[@eincan1313]

Agreed. Drew Allar if he comes out is another one late 1st or early 2nd. I don’t think Sanders or Ward are worthy of a top 3 pick.

[@mickpratt8327]

At this point, it would be a typical Giants move. We've been a trainwreck since Eli retired. How many games are the Giants winning playing Dallasx2, Phillyx2, Washingtonx2. Chiefs, Chargers, Broncos, Vikings, Lions, Packers, and a healthy 49ers? Giants aren't winning more than 6 games next year with or without Rodgers.

[@rubencasanova6144]

Yup imagine we got him with Barkley 😅mg lol Realistically yea that’s the guy we need Get him!

[@Ramonez02]

We should go after the guy no one is talking about. 3,897 yards. 28 TD's. 11 INT's.

[@gr3ml8n]

who’s that

[@AbstractLloyd]

Nice thought for a moment until you have visions of what Micah Parsons, Eagles DLine will do to him. If no Ward or Sanders. Joe Milton, Justin Fields, Jalen Milroe gives us the big arms and speed we need to compete and will not cost us the farm. Go Giants!

[@mattvega6951]

As a Jets fan I was hoping Daboll would’ve gotten fired just so the Jets can hire him

[@Thekidyusuke]

Draft Travis Hunter . Sign Rodgers and draft Dart in the 2nd. That would be beautiful actually

[@MoMoMyPup10]

'Let's see, what idea can we think up that will get people to click on in a lost NY football season?' That's how we got this video.

[@Soupkid91]

Tom Sawyer REALLY doesn't want to white wash that fence. Jets trying to pawn of Rogers 😂

[@randalhanning4058]

Offensive Line has to improve no matter who you get. Every qb mentioned is going to fail without a really good OL. Way too focused on the qb….

[@louisrodriguez5085]

I would 1000% take Rodgers and Adams

[@usachristmas5433]

The Giants will be lucky to win three maybe four games next year with their schedule coming up. There’s no way Rogers signs up for that.

[@Ststephennj68]

Wow we have absolutely nothing to talk about

[@CynthiaGeorgette]

No way…the Giants organization will not bow down to Rodgers. And you won’t be able to take away the controversies which will be a distraction when the focus needs to improve this team and with coaches’ jobs on the line.

[@Phennom]

Please gimme Rodgers 2 year deal get Travis Hunter and if it doesn't work tank for Manning

[@Laughing2daBank]

Last thing we need is aaron Rodgers we don't have the culture in place to have that type of energy we need a leader and positive energy

[@rickrossa]

Why would Rodgers want to play for the Giants? At best, they go 500 and miss the playoffs and he will get crushed with this line. He won't come here.

[@markb3786]

Ok, but its going to have to be a really desperate team with a wackadoodle owner or GM

[@JohnSmith-ds1fm]

What about the Steelers?

[@shakycameratheater]

Who you got on the bench? If you keep Jones, ok maybe but then the Giants appear ready to recycle the QB position again. If you need a QB, does anyone see a veteran quarterback in a Giants uniform longer than two years? There has to be a good QB in the first three picks.

[@robbiegarnz7732]

So now I know where Evan gets his info from…drunks at the bar! Lol!🎉😂

[@EasyGoer-e3z]

Aaron Been to "1" SB in Entire Career Like 15 Years ago and at age 42 and 2 Years Removed From Season Ending Achilles Injury You Expect a SB Appearance?

[@otisdavis6737]

So Joe Flacco isn't a Free Agent

[@FlowFinderUSA]

You mean the common sense, logic, and rational thinking that Rodgers speaks on McAffee,Tiki? Not a thing!

[@wwa9925]

We should’ve kept Tyrod Taylor

[@baxatakbaxatak2014]

So he could get injured after 2 games 😂

[@jonathanvanelli]

Shh Tiki, keep it down about Jersey being great!

[@justwait9822]

As an eagles fan...please do this😂

[@stephencapriglione4238]

I like it!

[@macattack144]

giants need to just tank another year and have a top pick next year so ya, let's sign rodgers

[@swervo990]

at first i was laughing like tiki. now it makes too much sense

[@chirocket4791]

Goofy Wednesday? Really?

[@johnlydon22]

Giants should trade the 3rd pick to the Vikings for JJ McCarthy, that’s THE QB move. If McCarthy was in this draft class he would easily be the top prospect!!

[@azikkii]

They won't do that because with a 1st round pick comes that 5th year team option, which McCarthy no longer has. It would have to be a second without the 5 year contract.

[@justanaverageguytoday]

If the jets dump him I hope he does. It would be so good for him to embarrass woody.

[@redruger3748]

No I rather start fresh and build around our newwwwwww quarter back

[@TL2354]

Their

[@user-cx3wu6gg7x]

Jets can release Rodgers and have him sign with SF.. Yes Purdy is there but have him sit behind Rodgers for a year or 2 and get better

[@markb3786]

🤣🤣🤣AR only runs his ancient Hackett offense. Shahan offense is too complex for AR. AR wouldn't change in Green Bay. This is why he had to have all of the old Packers with the Jets because they know all his secret hand signal audibles!

[@blazinrounds230]

@@markb3786ancient? He was the league mvp 4 years ago

[@kevinburke6055]

Draft Qb first or second round give me Kirk Cousins as the bridge cause if you bench him it’s not a big deal. we don’t need any more of the circus giants are already a circus

[@vincentbrancato5146]

God damn it I can't believe I'm saying this. But Rodgers gives us the best Plan A right now. This talk about drafting hunter tho? Just stop. He isn't the best cover corner in the draft and that's going to be his pro position. Is Hunter worth an extra 1st round pick and change? Because that's what your opportunity cost is for taking hunter. Sign Rodgers, trade the pick for a kings ransom, fill holes and have draft capital for next yrs draft. If you see a QB in rd 2 or 3 take a chance but do not draft Sanders, Ward or Hunter. It's short sighted and desperate. You can get some phenomenal players at 6-10 in this yrs draft. It's worth the trade to do so. Again, opportunity cost for Hunter is just fkn stupid. He isn't worth the true value of the pick.

[@denniskinzler5890]

Who would be better ???…….. if I was Rodgers, I’d pass, too unsafe with that offensive line….

[@markdeming8900]

We have a better o line than the Jets and Daboll can handle Rogers. Yes all in, let's go. NY can handle craziness.

[@TL2354]

They, not we

[@razielthagreat]

These boys really got nothing else to throw at the wall. No, Aaron Rodgers will never be a Giant. Mara will have a riot on his hands if he did

[@JohnSmith-ds1fm]

Do not take a QB in first round!!!!!!!!

[@Ststephennj68]

Ean the same guy to suggest to Giant fan to do whatever it takes to go to Philly for-the 2022 playoff game so yeah he has bad advice

[@MoneyMike718]

Rodger’s is washed that would be a horrible move

[@davemandaro2138]

Hard No on Rodgers / Giants !

[@arcadeslum5882]

I want Rodgers and Adam’s with Nabers, Robinson and Tracy. Daboll would have a field day.

[@GLOKToNe]

Can Roger's take the hits from a crap o line??

[@TL2354]

Rodgers

[@HunchoJesus2877]

Ironic for tiki to be bringing up Rodgers as a locker room problem. Aren’t you the same guy that would leak teammate drama to the Adam schefters of the world while you were a giant? Or maybe shit on your quarterback?

[@edwardcricchio6106]

Sports talk radio. Pre show meeting: What are we going to talk about today to generate 4 hours of phone calls and interest? I know, I'll propose the Giants try to sign Aaron Rodgers for nest season. OK, I'll take the opposite side in that argument. It will rile up the fans who call this radio station and we can get 4 hours out of it. OK let's go, it's almost time to do the show. These fans are so gullible, it's like we are stealing money to do this nonsense.

[@richardrodriguez6689]

You mean a QB that asked for everything and gave nothing but a terrible record. I'll pass

[@jimwerther]

Of course, the terrible record was all his fault 😂

[@markb3786]

@@jimwerther 90% is. Defense was much better when Saleh was still there. AR had Saleh fired because Saleh said in a press conference that AR's phony offense was too complex. NYC media shouted Saleh down, and AR went to Woody or one of the boys crying about it.

[@blazinrounds230]

@@markb3786that never happened.

[@richardrodriguez6689]

@@jimwerther the jet defense was not that bad and Arron made the throws. Tyrod Taylor did more in less than a quarter than Arron did in three. He asked for a receiver and that did nothing. He got the coach fired and that did nothing. Who fault is it then?

[@jimwerther]

@@richardrodriguez6689 He did not get the coach fired. The reason this team is a disaster is WOODY JOHNSON. Joe Douglas messed up the #2 pick in choosing Zack, and also dropped the ball when choosing a Head Coach. Both true. And yet, he otherwise did an absolutely brilliant job building this roster. Mike is 1000% correct that this team could go places if it had a professional coaching staff. If they somehow bring in Bruce Arians, for example, and retain the talent from last year (with minor upgrades)? They would be a threat to win a championship. Rodgers is absolutely capable of that. The notion that Rodgers (28 TDs, 11 INTs on a wreck of a team) is somehow the problem? That couldn't possibly be more off base.

[@thehouseisglass9802]

Why are these guys fixated on washed up QBs This is an embarrassing take and I pity all the people in their lives that are forced to listen to them.

[@Leostunzz]

Please no. Just retire

[@jeffbryant62]

NFW ARodgers might win 5 games,and he 's not a Mentor.

[@beefoneeto]

LOL how stupid .Rodgers should retire.

[@denniskinzler5890]

Giants should trade a #2 to Jacksonville for Trevor Lawrence……. Draft WR & OL with remaining draft picks….

[@pcarlson214]

Rodgers has never been a mentor before...unlikely that he ever will be. That's just not his personality. He won't be "nurturing" any rookie QBs.

[@joellugo5114]

Hellll NOOO

[@generalimlerith8356]

I mean giants have no QB can’t be worse than drew lock right lol

[@airforceups1]

Never!!!!!!!!!

[@Mj-bg2uj]

Hysterical.. Rodgers can’t win with the weapons he has on the Jets, you think he can win with the Giants surrounded by no talent ??? PLEASE .. the Giants are in a free fall and next year will be rock bottom . Those 2 idiots will draft a Qb, have 2-3 wins next year , get fired and we will be stuck with a 2nd year QB forced on a new regime.. Mara is an absolute dope and completely inept and lazy ..last year Evan Neal told Giants fans to go back to flipping burgers and Nabers basically admitted that dabolll was the problem and you think they are gonna lay down the law with Rodgers ??? Giants fans have become delusional and don’t see how disgraceful this organization has become..

[@Enzo575]

Wouldn't wanna give them any draft capital. But they both mediocre so anything goes.

[@samalvarado4962]

Aaron Rodgers is not an option he couldn't do anything with the jets ..y would he do that with the giants..new talent plain and simple!

[@jimwerther]

"he couldn't do anything with the Jets" I guess you didn't watch the games?

[@samalvarado4962]

@jimwerther they finished 5 and 12 I rest my case

[@jimwerther]

@@samalvarado4962 Lol! Brilliant analysis. That team was possibly the worst coached squad in NFL history. Anyone who assumes that the players must all be awful because they finished with a bad record knows _nothing_ about football. Remember when Parcells took Rich Kotite's 1-15 team and went 9-7 the next year? Coaching matters.

[@forman208]

I like this show, but good god, some of the nonsense you have to talk about to fill the time is wild lol, this is genuinely the dumbest topic I've ever seen lol

[@willryan2336]

gmen don't want him

[@rebeccaotero9739]

Noooo!!!

[@jonfarva2052]

Jets fan don’t even want his bum ass anymore they want to ship him to the other NY team to make them look trash

[@mikeoxmaul7723]

Pathetic show opening. Whos this guy on the third mic???

[@sohelhussain2689]

Can you stop

[@davissinclair4945]

Aaron Rodgers? To giants?? Ok you guys really need to lay off the cheap weed or the cheap liquor.

[@RoccoGallo]

i wonder how long it takes them to come up with stupid stuff, ( they must have a Stupid Crap Department) that fees them and Sal/BT show stuff to talk about.

[@tomhman6441]

Of course he is. Bring in JoeFlacco to be his back up and tiny blue has the oldest quarterbacks in history. Tlnkis head shins like a beacon . You could bounce a laser beam off of it and blind everyone in the studio.Oh no another baldino with an opinion. The Tiny blues have a terrible defense and Rogers will get killed. So great idea and tiny blue should jump on it.

[@jv_free]

If Jets are dumb enough to not keep Rodgers, I would love him and Adams to join the Giants. THIS WOULD FLIP ME TO BEING A GIANTS FAN!

[@jeanpepin6497]

Evan just wants him off the jets 😅

[@louvega3723]

I am with you. Let's take him. I'm a giants fan for 40 years. I do not want them to draft a quarterback.This is not the year for that.I do not want them to go all in on sanders or ward.Pick up rogersLet him lead you 24 win season next year.Then you're picking at the top of the draft again, let's do it.

[@Sarconthewolf]

Nabers

[@Sarconthewolf]

Why would Rogers go to the Giants?

[@bigshine36]

drunk ass

[@frankgraham1996]

NO to RODGERS. The Giants are bad but not homeless, or that desperate.

[@JohnSmith-o9t]

Omg

[@JohnnyLightningV10]

Until you fix the line it doesnt matter who you have. Run Lock and pick up supporting cast. He is a Sam Darnold caliber. That team could make playoffs by also drafting Ashton with 3rd pick.

[@Rodxyou]

Aaron Rodgers to the NY Giants? "Hell 🔥 No" ! I rather get Kirk Cousins.

[@baxatakbaxatak2014]

Nobody wants Rodgers. Don’t be stupid.

[@MartialFit50]

What current QB on the Giants is better than the Hall of Famer Rodgers ?

[@Civilis1980]

My Giants may need him 🥲

[@DonteJ-h5s]

lol Aaron Rodgers better stay far away as he can.from that 2025 giants schedule SMH BRUTAL 😳

[@starpowerj]

This deserves to be mocked into infinity. Rodgers is a PR nightmare and he's the last thing the completely dysfunctional Giants need either on the field or in the locker room. "The Giants need to not be a laughingstock and they need to stabilize" the ENTIRE NFL community is laughing at Aaron Rodgers every time he makes an ass of himself on the Pat McAfee Show, Shawn - you absolute clown.