What If BFDIA Continued? (Prediction/My Way)

I watched BFDI at the time of BFDIA and the time before IDFB so I am thinking of how the characters would be received back then over now. This is mostly a prediction but also kind of a my way! And I made certain decisions to make the season better!

[@derpydoofus]

I should mention this is a prediction for AS IF IT CONTINUTED IN 2013!!! NOT IF IT WOULDVE CAME BACK TODAY!!!! I think a lot would've changed and for the most part this order kind of still holds up? And yes I am aware BFDIA has returned I reacted to every single recent BFDIA episode LOL

[@tizianocastroperez153]

And now Gelatin is eliminated. Life is full of surprises...

[@Anforkguy]

​@tiziaimnocastroperez153 i. Sad he got elominated because he is my favourite character

[@Jelly_OSC_1]

Gelatin was eliminated but I think he can rejoin!

[@Jelly_OSC_1]

@@Anforkguyhe’s my favorite too

[@letybetancourt1931]

2012-2014 bfdia

[@aBowlWhoAnimates]

Not sure if Needle would've been out over Nickel in her elimination... Also this is the best BFDIA prediction out of all of the ones I've seen out there

[@derpydoofus]

Honestly I agree, nickel probably would’ve got out at that time bc needle was well liked, especially bc of her early exit in bfdi, but I feel like inanimate insanity fans would target needle to save nickel

[@Neonical_Roblox]

Wait, did Inanimate Insanity exist during BFDIA? I'm not sure, I just finished watching all II Episodes in Season 1 and I still haven't watched the rest, so I'm not sure about anything.

[@aBowlWhoAnimates]

@@Neonical_Roblox yes it did ii started in 2011 and bfdia started in 2012

[@Laughabilityiscool]

@@Neonical_Roblox it did

[@IggyGeCaton]

This is a good one, but it lacks in commentary and a bit of reasoning. For example Super Fun Time’s prediction takes more than just the personalities of the characters into cosideration. This still was a good video nonetheless!

[@loganharris4893]

Here after BFDIA 6 dropped:

[@Acegan]

Wow this aged incredibly well

[@ksawerx9277]

Freesmart (mostly pencil and book) felt like the main characters in this season, i feel like this is what i woud haemve wanted to happen. Either: - Right before the elimination pencil would apologize to book and they would make up, then pencil would be eliminated and book would win in the end because of that scene. Or - Pencil and book make up in the episode when pencil gets up for elimination and people end up not voting for pencil as much meaning tennis ball gets out and the fanalie is a rundown of all the challenges where at some point pencil gives up her chance to win to help book forward and eventually book would win. I know popel adore gelatin but book wining would make a lot of sense for this season, especially since book was kinda the firey of bfdia.

[@VectorJW9260]

Yeah. Especially as well with how much IDFB focuses on FreeSmart.

[@amazonbox181]

Its gonna be kinda confusing now that they have to comprehend both seasons at once, and add back their original personalities since BFDIA 6 just realeased after a whole damn 10 year anniversery. Now that they're CONTINUING BFDIA after BFB the 4TH SEASON which was 2 seasons after bfdia, they can't add their new personalities, yet somehow the viewers are gonna vote them based on their current TPOT personalities, so it's really just fucked up to this point. The writiers will have to *maintain* their old personalities but when voting, most viewers aren't gonna vote them based on their old self, but by their newer versions of them

[@MellohiYT]

looking back now i think this worry was a worry for a lot of us but didn't really end up happening

[@jdh9419]

9:48 This is EXACTLY why I find Flower’s win in bfb unfair. Not because of any viewer voting stuff. Because Gelatin got robbed by the season being cancelled and thus deserved the dub he lost out on! On the bright side, at so Flower shared the prize

[@user-kn5rw1gs8r]

TD should have won imo

[@cubefromblender]

​@@user-kn5rw1gs8r Agreed

[@ChocoDonut905]

@@user-kn5rw1gs8rbut flower got the most development than anyone else in all of BFDI

[@amazonbox181]

Exactly my point

[@Stickboy321Go]

TD is kind of overrated and overhated in now.

[@rociogarcia534]

Teardrops elimination was kind of rude because there was this person that wanted coiny to not get eliminated because he had the most disliked so the time so he asked people to dislike teardrops video but the people he told him to do it they didn't know what BFDI was but they still disliked on teardrops video

[@themisfunniesandstupid138]

That was adam kads's female cousin

[@Chickenuggy2501]

Man teardrop got robbed

[@Total_Color_Animations]

Even if Teardrop did stay, that would mean Coiny would’ve gotten eliminated, which in my eyes would’ve been far worse than losing someone who didn’t even do anything in the season to begin with

[@Apples2024]

It’s sad that it happened to Teardrop especially as she’s always been a favourite character of mine, I would’ve been way happier if that never happened and Coiny was eliminated perhaps cuz he sucked in BFDI and was even more worse in BFDIA.

[@Toffiskindamidtbh]

@@Apples2024 same she’s even in my profile picture

[@derpydoofus]

This is mostly a prediction, but I made a few writing decisions on how things would happen to make the seasons better and more interesting! I watched the show during the BFDIA days (Although I was like 5/6 LOL) and I also remember the days before IDFB and I am basing how the viewers would vote based on the people's views back then. I didn't have any debut or any rejects join in, but I do think one would've happened, and I also think the rejects could've been voted on each rejoin but I didn't include that. SUBSCRIBE PLEASE!! I am on the grind and it would be very much appreciated!🙏

[@By_The_Way2664]

Also outdated

[@lexi_may2023]

Rocky was out in media 7

[@justthinkingaboutthearmyofbees]

Now we get to see how accurate it is

[@letybetancourt1931]

Song?

[@yanaromusic]

gelatin got out in bfdia 8 so this is already inaccurate

[@bluy3llow9787]

This is honestly really great

[@7473R]

There should have been a debut, I heard the winner of BAGUETTE could pick someone to join the show

[@sethyboi9702]

I can actually see this being a good prediction! Good job!

[@MasterStartist5]

“I think if BFDIA would’ve continued Gelatin would’ve won” BFDIA 10: “Are you sure about that?” I know this video is outdated but somebody had to say it. Plus I think most people could agree that before it came back the most likely Final 3 would be Tennis Ball, Ruby and Coiny

[@Dub0rN0th1ng]

Bro actually predicated W.O.A.H. bunch being up for elimination for BFDIA 6 and Puffball and Golfball being the last two before they showed who’s eliminated

[@Ai3r]

Pb and gb bottom two was shown in idfb 1

[@empirebeach]

funny how this randomly popped up in my feed after the release of bfdia 6 and Cary confirming it will keep going

[@0d0iz]

did my favorite character just win bfdia-

[@Pia_dabaddest]

I also love gelatin

[@IDFB-o7i]

My fav character won too

[@ww08]

This is a pretty legit prediction/my way for bfdia. I could really see this actually happening

[@infinity_74577]

Well this aged well.

[@Blocbacon14]

Rocky was eliminated in BFDIA 7

[@tpof-bfla]

love the ending of gelatin winning the season hes one of my fav characters

[@Neonical_Roblox]

I mean I agree with him putting gelatin at #1 then I would put Coiny at 2nd, Teardrop at 3rd, Ruby at 4th and Pin at 5th.

[@NotaSonicExeRipOff]

Thanks for spoiling it

[@denizcaml9306]

@@Neonical_RobloxIm not sure ruby would get that far because just like the video says, people just start to get tired of characters

[@yellowdoesstuff2258]

Yea we are very glad you spoiled it :D

[@GolfyTheGolfball]

If this was true in bfb 4 He would've got eliminated over braclety

[@Over0w0MeAmTheHotel]

Omg BFDIA 6 just created a whole alternate reality show

[@DraydenAndSylvester]

pencil after being on her own team: 😤😤😡😡🙍‍♂🙍‍♂😢😢😭😭😢😢😢😢😠😠😢😢😡😡😤😤😢😢🙍‍♂🙍‍♂😖😖😖😖

[@sallyparty1978]

🤣

[@foxeh9238]

I could see book and icy leaving pencil but ruby remained very loyal to pencil even after her elimination

[@solidfire2923]

i always notice when people comtinue BFDIA, rhey juwt foeget about the team switching mechanic, and its super cool to aee you at least do somwthing with it. And i think we alwaus foeget that befoe BFDI used to switch rules a ton. Its super fun to tru to come up with new game rulesets for these videos, and not juat "straight to merge" goos video tho, love how you explained mowt eliminations with the mindset of back then.

[@DashermanUK]

were you drunk when you wrote this

[@solidfire2923]

@@DashermanUK lmao, perhapssss IDK what i was down with lol

[@novacommander4297]

Boy, have I got news for you guys!!

[@CloudyTpotReal]

0:52 The reason why Teardrop got out is because someone made a video to make people vote Teardrop out to save coiny and also most of the viewers don’t know bfdi is

[@user-kn5rw1gs8r]

For TD, I think her getting out was the best outcome. Because then Team8’s wouldn’t exist.

[@SillySausage543]

Bro not even a month after this video it continued

[@Minigameskid12]

Actually, one teardrop was eliminated. The next person to leave was supposed to be puffball.

[@WirelessPlayToad6831]

No it was match

[@Stuffy2763]

I feel like if this happened then bfb would be changed a lot since gelatin got second so he would probally get out earlier

[@JackJerome-rd9tz]

Now let's see if he's right... BFDIA 6: Yep, Woah Bunch is UFE but I think Rocky's (Unfortunately) Getting out, which pains me :(

[@sharkwalfle6453]

I feel like Firey could of made it farther to 10 or top 5 at the most

[@thecorruptedone1yt]

True

[@Sageytheaxoloti]

Aged so well

[@jasyak2]

Oh hey! You predicted the solo-team thing Fries did, but with Pencil instead.

[@RapidzCharacterVoting]

IOP: Coiny places first due to having much more character development this season 2nd place gelatin he was a big fan favourite but he was a newcomer and I fell like that’s a disadvantage so I guess “there wasn’t enough room” on the first place podium for him. And 3rd would go to Rocky, there’s not much explaining here except he was a fan favourite

[@vitlazdrip494]

9:47 well... about that...

[@Forgotten_foreverbye]

3:11 why did book ice cube and ruby Ditch pencil?

[@benjitaball5893]

BFDIA My Way: 22nd Donut 21st Dora 20th Coiny (Teardrop replaces Coiny) 19th Match 18th Puffball • This point is from video section 17th Yellow Face PUFFBALL REJOIN! (Puffball replaces Teardrop) 16th Firey (Golf Ball replaces Firey) 16th Needle (Bomby replaces Needle) 15th Ice Cube 14th Golf Ball (Fries replaces Firey) 13th Fries 12th Pencil FIREY REJOIN! (FIREY REPLACES GB) MERGE! 12th Nickel (Bomby Replaces Needle 11th Spongy (Rocky Replaces Spongy) 10th Bomby 9th Firey (Rocky replaces Golf Ball) 8th Gelatin (Ruby replaces Gelatin) 7th Puffball Gelatin Rejoin! (Gelatin replaces Pencil 7th Book (Teardrop replaces Book 6th Pin (Rocky replaces Pin)) 5th Teardrop (Rocky replaces Book) 4th Gelatin FINALE! - Rocky as Book, Tennis Ball as Tennis Ball, Ruby as Gelatin 3rd Rocky 2nd Tennis Ball 1st Ruby!!!!

[@jaycic13]

JELLY BOI TO THE WIN!

[@AshFur_Alt]

Her votes her rigged is something I'll say when I talk about teardrops elimination in bfdia

[@Sandwich-C1]

When watching this after BFDIA 12 came Fries shall win

[@chazzurrrrrrr]

this aged well

[@coinygaming2763]

9:47 well this aged well

[@KingBobo936]

Well it happened!

[@Almania.and.the.pack.]

3:02 *throws up rainbow like puffball in bomby is my favorite*

[@FlagsAndCountrys]

My favorite character actually won yayyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy

[@CharlesTunney]

This aged well

[@maryjanedeguzman1973]

You forgot a few things, Firey eliminated in BFDIA 8, Bubble and Woody could debut due to IDFB, TLC/LOL moved to Yoyleland and others, So I doubt Teardrop, Donut, Dora and Puffball and Match would rejoin. But your prediction is great tho

[@Asteroid1324]

I wish it continued

[@RiceCookerMoai]

It’s continuing bro you never saw bfdia 12

[@Asteroid1324]

I was being sarcastic

[@Mintymenty]

STOP WHY DID FREESMART SPLIT

[@adellagiustina686]

The fact that in the same year of this video BFDIA came back lol

[@sunnymiller4605]

Bro just predicted the future 💀

[@fernandocarrodeguas6204]

9:16 again the third place is for the most liked before the final

[@Saws.numb.1.fan.]

If gelatin win bfdia he wouldn’t get second place in BFB

[@Saws.numb.1.fan.]

Won*

[@PlushBattleSeries]

POV: september 1st, 2023. BFDIA 6 comes out unexpectedly and BFDIA is continuing

[@jdh9419]

Tetris music

[@jdh9419]

For a time anyway

[@Nthemurderdronee]

no way it’s almost like the show actually continued like 2 months ago no way

[@notdaphantom]

But wouldn't that mean Gelatin makes it to the finale twice, unless in BFB he gets eliminated before the final

[@AzureSun]

no this would completely change bfb too probably causing gelatin to miss out on final 2

[@Herxinty]

That is not how rejoins work rejoins involves everybody that didn’t get to make it in BFDIA

[@FlameYEEPS]

WTH

[@user-ug4dk6tk2f]

No people who didn't make it into bfdia are debutants

[@RandomuserwhoplaysSONIC]

@@user-ug4dk6tk2f thats rc rejoins

[@Just_abfdi_fan]

0:20 if pin and coiny are on the same team, it will be kinda awkward for them

[@mathguy37]

1:48 update: Rocky switched teams and is probably eliminated

[@jakubzagraniczny733]

SPOILER: Rocky is eliminated.

[@mathguy37]

@@jakubzagraniczny733 voting ends on the 4th it’s the 3rd

[@Wattson-ston]

​@@mathguy37 People calculate vote results before a video is out

[@plasmapea9822]

​@@mathguy37Rocky is currently on 12k dislikes and 15k likes Yikes

[@plasmapea9822]

​@@Wattson-stonRocky is on 12k dislikes being the most disliked by far

[@ReallyK9brother]

3rd place is my favorite character

[@CommonAmmo]

pencil would 100% sneak match back in with him if he rejoined

[@goddaluvtom]

Pencil is a girl but she would probably do that

[@Egg_VR69420]

lol image if it continued 💀💀💀 FORRSHADOWING

[@animatic573]

the funny thing is that it actually continued-

[@MexicanFoxy]

In Real BFDIA Rocky , Firey and Yellow Face got out

[@blixxy537]

7:07 bro ice cube would be top 8 at least

[@user-zt6ib3rj7r]

Gelatin got eliminated in the latest BFDIA video (BFDIA 10)

[@carmenmiera4805]

Imagine if the votes to get a prize were still in tpot

[@harumokkapatitime3940]

🙂:Hmm hmm. IT SURE DID

[@sallyparty1978]

I'm seeing a pattern in these predictions that TB is at final 5 or 3

[@sallyparty1978]

@Giancarlo Villanueva ah alr.

[@foxeh9238]

I made a bfdia continued and I said gelatin wins glad to see people agree

there was a typo when firey was eliminated

[@cylinderistic]

the fact that BFDIA continued a month ago

[@Awesomeboitheanimator_4879]

Your wish has come true.

[@letybetancourt1931]

Song name? 3:01

[@Empa913]

Well it was wrong cause Gelatin was just eliminated in BFDIA 10: Taste the Sweetness

[@TottalyNot_BIOB]

tell me you love gelatin wiithout telling me that you love gelatin:

[@TwotheTpot]

I strongly like Gelatin

[@RandomuserwhoplaysSONIC]

name of songs?

[@laneapelite8338]

Technically Rocky was eliminated after Puffball

[@arandomguyscrolling2023]

This aged well.

[@simarsfun2524]

YOOO BFDIA IS ACTUALLY CONTINUING

[@Z01Xy]

wow little did you know

[@user-em3vp1tk5q]

yeah im sure book and gelatin would have made it very far in this season

[@carmenmiera4805]

Ive alaays questioned why they stop doing bfdia to do idfb and then do bfb and then do tpot while bfb was still going on

[@suh223]

well bfdia is back

[@CaseMediaUnofficial]

I think now with it continuing yellow face is going to make it far because he says “I’m in your walls” in the new intro and we are seeing his evil side

[@pillowrain]

9.

[@RandomuserwhoplaysSONIC]

@@pillowrain the way you said 9-

[@User_and_atmohd]

next rocky was out after puffball in the real series

[@Orangejuicydrop]

I think donut would rejoin

[@derpydoofus]

It was a tough call, and tbh you are probably right bc everyone had the idea of the first boot rejoining at the time, but pencil would’ve been more interesting

[@AzureSun]

no donut wasnt as evil as pencil all he did was get mad for 2 episodes

[@sallyparty1978]

@@AzureSun he just needed more development

[@AzureSun]

@@sallyparty1978 no he didnt its clear jnj used him as a scapegoat they were just making a flower but more bland

[@sallyparty1978]

@@AzureSun o

[@ClayPot_real]

You got yellow face out early

[@Prussiaboi.]

YAY BOOK IS SECOND PLACE I’m happy

[@coinygaming2763]

What remix did you use at the beginning of the video

[@ATAAM2763]

5th place is not bad for an idolic tack

[@phoenixreborn32]

This final 3 reminds me of bubble leafy and firey

[@perlaignacio7011]

Can u make a updated one bc BFDIA 6 is out?

[@ashley_14]

Golfball: 16th Bomby: 16th!?!?!?

[@unknowngeography]

Y did Pencil get her own team?

[@snivygreen2216]

What Tetris theme is this?

[@RandomuserwhoplaysSONIC]

spooky something

[@keesdevries23423]

1st Eliminated: Donut - rude 2nd Eliminated: Dora - stupid female stick figure 3rd Eliminated: Teardrop - weak 4th Eliminated: Match - she got the sass 5th Eliminated: Puffball - sabotage team for prize Beachball debuts as chosen by Gelatin 6th Eliminated: Pencil - mean and not chosen by no name 7th Eliminated: Gelatin - freesmart avenged Pencil 8th Eliminated: Spongy - fat and not liked by freesmart 9th Eliminated: Nickel - boring and got out in a close tie between him and yellow face 10th Eliminated: Ice Cube - annoying and not chosen by woah bunch 11th Eliminated: Rocky - useless and not chosen 12th Eliminated: Bomby - explodes too much and not chosen by woah bunch Teardrop rejoins 13th Eliminated: Yellow Face - annoying and stupid with ads 14th Eliminated: Fries - pushy and already in bottom two thrice 15th Eliminated: Firey - already won 16th Eliminated: Golf Ball - bossy and clumsy 17th Eliminated: Beachball - arrogant and a waste 18th Eliminated: Book - keeps bragging about intelligence 19th Eliminated: Ruby - annoying crying girl 20th Eliminated: Bubble - pops too much 21st and 22nd Eliminated: Needle and Teardrop (again) - Needle slaps and Teardrop is silent and rejoiner 23rd Eliminated: Tennis Ball - lost to Pin and Coiny in finale Runner Up: Pin Winner: Coiny

[@theharrbear]

jeez

[@pillowrain]

ae who tf is beachball